CourtListener 9771354•People v. Snow CA4/1
Testo completo
Filed 6/24/24 P. v. Snow CA4/1
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
COURT OF APPEAL, FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION ONE
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
THE PEOPLE, D081968
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v. (Super. Ct. No. SCE414069)
AARON JOSEPH SNOW,
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of San Diego County,
John M. Thompson, Judge. Affirmed.
Robert V. Vallandigham, Jr., under appointment by the Court of
Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Rob Bonta, Attorney General, Lance E. Winters, Chief Assistant
Attorney General, Charles C. Ragland, Assistant Attorney General,
A. Natasha Cortina and Melissa Mandel, Deputy Attorneys General, for
Plaintiff and Respondent.
A jury convicted Aaron Snow of felony false imprisonment by violence
or menace (Pen. Code, §§ 236, 237, subd. (a))1 and misdemeanor battery
(§ 242) after an incident on the trolley in San Diego. Snow witnessed an
autistic teenager, William M., board the trolley with his mother (Y.M.) and
sister (P.M.). At William’s request, his hands were tied loosely behind his
back with a t-shirt because it made him feel more secure. Snow believed the
child was in danger and needed to be rescued. He punched William’s mother
and grabbed William, forcibly separating him from his mother for
approximately 10 minutes. Snow did not release William even after his
mother and sister identified themselves as such. Police eventually arrived
and arrested Snow.
Snow contends that the judgment in this case must be reversed because
the evidence was insufficient to support his conviction for false
imprisonment. According to Snow, where the victim is a minor or otherwise
lacks the capacity to consent to the charged conduct, a false imprisonment
conviction requires proof that the defendant had an illegal purpose or illegal
intent. Snow argues that the People failed to present any evidence to
establish this illegal purpose or intent element, and his conviction must
therefore be overturned. The People respond that there is no such
requirement under the law, and that even if there were, the victim here did
not lack the capacity to consent.
We conclude that sufficient evidence was presented from which the jury
could have concluded that William was capable of giving consent. Thus, even
assuming the crime of felony false imprisonment requires an illegal purpose
or intent where the victim is incapable of consenting, there was substantial
evidence to establish that this additional element did not apply on the facts of
1 Undesignated statutory references are to the Penal Code.
2
this case. We further conclude that there was sufficient evidence of the other
applicable elements of felony false imprisonment, and we therefore affirm the
judgment.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
A. The Prosecution’s Case
Y.M. has three children, including daughter P.M. and son William, who
at the time of trial were 20 years old and 13 years old, respectively. William
has medical issues and special needs, including severe autism. He is mostly
nonverbal and sometimes engages in self-harm, including punching himself.
William can communicate with his family, though, and ask for things he
wants by making gestures.
When Y.M. takes William in public, she needs to do a lot to prepare
him in advance. For example, Y.M. only takes William to the grocery store in
the early morning or in the evening just before closing, because the noise and
lighting will startle and rattle him. Sometimes, when William is feeling
uncomfortable in public, he communicates that he would like his hands to be
bound so he feels more secure. His mother spoke about this request with
William’s pediatrician, and they discussed using William’s old t-shirts to
wrap his hands. Once his hands are tied, William “is instantly happy.” The
t-shirt is “not wrapped tight at all”—“[i]t’s just there because that’s what he’s
asked for, and he’s just fine.” Y.M. has had people ask her about William,
and she is “happy to answer any questions they have because everybody is
not used to an autistic child.” She always tells anyone who asks her
questions, “if you have a problem with what you see or what I’m doing, I
invite you to call the cops. My son is registered with the police department[.]”
On the day of the incident, Y.M. was with her daughter and son on the
trolley. Before they boarded the trolley, William requested that his mother
3
put his t-shirt around his hands, so she did. She explained what happened
next while narrating the security video footage taken from the trolley that
was played for the jury.
After boarding the trolley, Y.M. noticed Snow staring at her and her
children. Snow then walked over to Y.M. and punched her in the face. He
took William out of her hands “very forcefully,” in a “violent” manner that
made William’s sister P.M. fear for his safety as well as her own. After Snow
grabbed William and pulled him away from his family, Snow put his
backpack on top of William, and then he sat on him to keep him in the seat.
Y.M. and P.M. pressed the call box button to tell the conductor there
was an emergency. Y.M. “let the conductor know that [she] had been
attacked on the train” and asked the conductor to call the police. At first,
Y.M. attempted to get her son back, but she realized she had already been
punched and did not want to make a bad situation worse, so she needed to
get help.
P.M. was very nervous, scared, and shook up throughout the incident,
and she was worried about her brother. She tried to get her brother back, but
Snow pushed her and stood in the way to prevent her from reaching William.
P.M. then stood in front of the door to keep Snow from taking her brother off
the trolley until they could get help.
At a certain point, Snow tried to get off the trolley. After two men
questioned why he was running if he had just been trying to help, Snow got
back on the trolley. It was during this time that Y.M. was able to get William
back. Y.M. said she thought “a good 10 to 15 minutes” elapsed between when
Snow took William and when she got him back.
William appeared to be in shock during the incident, and he was not
able to get up and go back to his family. Y.M. was also in shock and felt
4
helpless during the incident. She is a cancer patient and did not have her
normal body strength at the time, so she knew she could not overpower Snow
to get her son back. She knew, however, that she would not let Snow get off
the trolley with William even if she had to give her life.
Since the incident, William has not been sleeping or eating much. He
is “really jittery” and has been scratching his family, which he used to do
when he was younger when he got upset. William has always loved the train,
but now sometimes he “gets really freaked out” near trolley stations or on the
trolley.
B. The Defense Case
Snow testified on his own behalf. He saw that William was tied up and
thought he could have been a missing child who was being trafficked and
possibly taken to the Mexican border. Snow did not think it was normal or
acceptable to tie up a child, so he felt he needed to act. He further believed
that to ignore a crime taking place is itself a crime. Snow’s intent was to
protect William because he perceived William was being abused. He thought
he had to act quickly because there was a risk that William might disappear.
Snow acted the way he did to separate and untie William in the hopes
that he could then “restrain that child enough to control the situation in
order that the police would then arrive.” He felt what he did was necessary
to keep William safe and believed he had the right to make a citizen’s arrest.
Snow did not sit on William but rather squatted over him without putting
any weight on him or making physical contact. Snow placed his backpack on
William because he wanted him to hold it to distract him. He tried to be very
careful with William because he appeared malnourished and frail.
5
Snow got off the trolley momentarily because he was afraid of being
arrested, but he returned because he realized it was his responsibility to see
this through and that he should not leave his post.
Snow acknowledged that he punched Y.M. but said he did not
repeatedly attack her. He was not trying to injure her but instead used a
“quick stun maneuver” to disorient her to get William and “maintain the
safety of the child.” He then told others on the trolley to call the police. Snow
admitted he did not let William go even after his mother and sister identified
themselves as such.
C. Relevant Jury Instructions and Verdict
The trial court instructed the jury on felony false imprisonment using
CALCRIM No. 1240, which provides as follows: “To prove that the defendant
is guilty of this crime, the People must prove that: [¶] 1. The defendant
intentionally and unlawfully restrained, confined, or detained someone by
violence or menace; [¶] AND [¶] 2. The defendant made the other person stay
or go somewhere against that person’s will. [¶] Violence means using
physical force that is greater than the force reasonably necessary to restrain
someone. [¶] Menace means a verbal or physical threat of harm. The threat
of harm may be express or implied. [¶] An act is done against a person’s will
if that person does not consent to the act. In order to consent, a person must
act freely and voluntarily and know the nature of the act. [¶] False
imprisonment does not require that the person restrained be confined in jail
or prison.”
6
After deliberating, the jurors found Snow guilty of felony false
imprisonment and misdemeanor battery. They found him not guilty of felony
child abuse and not guilty of making a criminal threat. The court sentenced
Snow to two years in state prison.
Snow appeals only the felony false imprisonment conviction.
DISCUSSION
Standard of Review
Our review of a claim of insufficiency of the evidence is limited. We
review the entire record in the light most favorable to the prosecution to
determine whether it contains evidence that is reasonable, credible, and of
solid value, from which any rational trier of fact could find the defendant
guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. (People v. Whitmore (2022) 80 Cal.App.5th
116, 129 (Whitmore).) Given this court’s limited role on appeal, Snow “ ‘bears
an enormous burden in claiming there was insufficient evidence to sustain
his conviction . . . . If the verdict is supported by substantial evidence, we are
bound to give due deference to the trier of fact and not retry the case
ourselves.’ ” (Id. at p. 130.)
Analysis
False imprisonment is the unlawful violation of the personal liberty of
another, and it is a felony when effected by violence, menace, fraud, or deceit.
(Whitmore, supra, 80 Cal.App.5th at p. 130; §§ 236, 237.) “Violence” in this
context means the use of physical force beyond what is reasonably necessary
to restrain the person. (People v. Matian (1995) 35 Cal.App.4th 480, 484.)
The additional force required to elevate misdemeanor false imprisonment to a
felony may come in the form “ ‘of simply pulling a victim toward a location
when the victim’s liberty has already been violated.’ ” (Whitmore, at p. 130.)
“Menace” means the threat of harm, whether express or implied, through
7
words or acts. (Ibid.) As the jury was instructed here, the act must be done
against a person’s will, meaning that the person did not consent to it.
(CALCRIM No. 1240; see also People v. Rios (1986) 177 Cal.App.3d 445, 453
(Rios).)
Snow concedes there was sufficient evidence of each element of false
imprisonment by violence or menace with the exception of consent. According
to Snow, there was insufficient evidence to support his false imprisonment
conviction because the People failed to demonstrate that he had an illegal
intent or purpose, which is a required additional element where the victim
lacks the capacity to consent.2 Snow’s argument assumes that the victim
here, William, was unable to consent to Snow’s conduct.
The People argue that Snow’s argument fails for three reasons:
(1) William did not lack the capacity to consent; (2) even if he did, the People
were not required to show that Snow had an illegal purpose or intent,
because that is not an element of false imprisonment of a victim unable to
consent; and (3) in any event, substantial evidence established that Snow did
act with an illegal purpose or intent. Because we conclude that there was
2 Notably, Snow only raises a sufficiency of evidence claim. He does not
contend that the jury instructions erroneously omitted this alleged element of
false imprisonment. In civil cases, “[w]e review the sufficiency of evidence to
support a verdict under the law stated in the instructions given, rather than
under some other law on which the jury was not instructed.” (Bullock v.
Philip Morris USA, Inc. (2008) 159 Cal.App.4th 655, 674–675, citing Null v.
City of Los Angeles (1988) 206 Cal.App.3d 1528, 1535.) We do not apply this
rule here, however, and we express no opinion whether it is applicable to
criminal cases. We instead analyze the sufficiency of evidence issue as if the
jury had been instructed on the principle of law Snow invokes—that illegal
intent or purpose is an element of false imprisonment when the victim lacks
the capacity to consent.
8
sufficient evidence from which the jury could have determined William was
capable of giving consent, we need not reach the People’s other arguments.3
Snow relies on four cases to support his contention that the People
were required to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that he had an illegal
purpose or intent in falsely imprisoning a victim without the capacity to
consent. But these cases do not compel the conclusion that William lacked
the capacity to consent here. Each of the cases Snow cites involved a child
under the age of three who was moved without physical violence under
circumstances where they were seemingly unaware of what was happening to
them. (See People v. Hill (2000) 23 Cal.4th 853, 856–861 [carjacking and
kidnapping of a seven-month-old]; People v. Oliver (1961) 55 Cal.2d 761, 763
(Oliver) [kidnapping of a two-year-old]; In re Michele D., supra, 29 Cal.4th at
pp. 603–605 [kidnapping of a 12-month-old]; Rios, supra, 177 Cal.App.3d at
pp. 448–449 [false imprisonment of a 13-month-old].) William, by contrast,
was 13 years old at the time of the incident and there is no evidence that he
was unaware of what was happening.
Snow relies on Oliver to argue that the People were still required to
show he had an illegal purpose or intent due to William’s “diminished mental
state.” In Oliver, the Supreme Court held that, to avoid the possibility of an
3 With regard to the People’s second argument, however, we note that at
least one appellate court has concluded that where the victim of false
imprisonment is an infant or small child, evidence of the defendant’s illegal
purpose or intent is required. (People v. Dominguez (2010) 180 Cal.App.4th
1351, 1358 (Dominguez) [“We assume the discussion of force in the context of
a kidnapping prosecution in [In re] Michele D. [(2002) 29 Cal.4th 600] applies
equally to the force requirement of false imprisonment. This assumption
appears beyond reasonable dispute, as Rios, a false imprisonment case, was
cited with approval in [In re] Michele D. . . . .”].)
9
unjust result in kidnapping cases involving an unresisting infant4 incapable
of giving consent, the kidnapping statute should be given a “ ‘sensible
construction,’ ” and the element of force in kidnapping cases involving those
who lack the ability to consent is thus established only “ ‘if the taking and
carrying away is done for an illegal purpose or with an illegal intent.’ ”
(Dominguez, supra, 180 Cal.App.4th at pp. 1357–1358, quoting Oliver, supra,
55 Cal.2d at p. 768.) The Oliver court stated that the rule applied to people
incapable of giving consent “because of infancy or mental condition.” (Oliver,
at p. 766, italics added.) In a more recent case involving the rape and
kidnapping of an intoxicated victim, the Supreme Court concluded that
“[w]hile children and mentally impaired adults may not be similar in all
respects, they are similarly vulnerable to kidnapping and equally unable to
consent to being moved, so the relaxed force requirement applies to each.”
(People v. Lewis (2023) 14 Cal.5th 876, 895 (Lewis), italics added.) The Lewis
court explained that the law protects a victim who may go willingly with the
defendant because they are “unable to appreciate the defendant’s illegal
intent.” (Id. at p. 896.)
But these legal principles do not help Snow. The key factor is not the
fact of the victim’s age or mental capacity itself, but whether the victim’s age
and/or mental capacity renders them “legally unable to consent.” (Lewis,
supra, 14 Cal.5th at p. 897.) Although William is autistic and generally
nonverbal, his mother testified that he “talks just a little bit” and
“communicates with [his family] well.” She described William as “a
4 We acknowledge that courts’ use of terminology to refer to victims in
this context is imprecise; the terms “infant,” “child,” “small child,” “child of
tender years,” “minor,” and “youth” are rarely defined and often used
interchangeably.
10
requester” who “makes gestures to get things he wants.” Sometimes when
William is uncomfortable, he asks for his hands to be bound, as he did the
day of the incident. William also pushed Snow’s backpack off of his lap and
held his arms up, which the jury could reasonably find indicated he did not
consent to Snow’s acts. This evidence is sufficient to support a conclusion
that William did not lack the capacity to consent.
As noted, Snow’s sufficiency of evidence argument depends entirely on
the factual assumption that Williams lacked the capacity to consent. Snow
does not contest that if William had the capacity to consent, the People were
not required to prove that he acted with an illegal purpose or intent. Because
the evidence supports a finding that William had the capacity to consent, the
factual predicate of Snow’s sufficiency of evidence argument is absent. We
need not decide whether there was sufficient evidence that Snow acted with
an illegal purpose or intent because, on this record, this is not a required
element of the crime when viewing the evidence in the light most favorable to
the judgment.
The evidence was otherwise sufficient to establish all the traditional
elements of felony false imprisonment. Snow forcibly grabbed William—first
by the neck and arm, and then by wrapping his arms around William’s
body—to physically separate him from his mother. He then moved William
several feet away, where he continued to physically restrain William by
holding him back, with Snow’s arms fully around William’s body. Snow then
untied William’s hands, pushed him into a seat, and placed a backpack on top
of him. William pushed the backpack off of his lap, and Snow then crouched
over or sat on William to continue preventing his movement. This was
substantial evidence that Snow intentionally restrained, confined, or
detained William against his will by violence or menace. Accordingly, we
11
conclude that sufficient evidence supports the conviction for felony false
imprisonment.
DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed.
BUCHANAN, J.
WE CONCUR:
HUFFMAN, Acting P. J.
KELETY, J.
12
Ti chiedi come si applica questo testo alla tua situazione?
Consulenza gratuita, senza impegno
Descrivi la tua situazione. Il nostro team ti ricontatterà via e-mail per la tua consulenza.
Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude
Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.