CourtListener 9513649•People v. Calderon CA2/8
Testo completo
Filed 6/7/24 P. v. Calderon CA2/8
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION EIGHT
THE PEOPLE, B322373
Plaintiff and Respondent, (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No. VA156679–01)
v.
MARIO EMERSON CALDERON,
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of
Los Angeles County. John A. Torribio, Judge. Affirmed as
modified.
Katharine E. Greenbaum, under appointment by the Court
of Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Rob Bonta, Attorney General, Lance E. Winters, Chief
Assistant Attorney General, Susan S. Pithey, Assistant Attorney
General, Scott A. Taryle and Rene Judkiewicz, Deputy Attorneys
General, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
_________________________________
INTRODUCTION
Mario Emerson Calderon appeals from his judgment of
conviction of one count of assault with a deadly weapon (Pen.
Code,1 § 245, subd. (a)(1); count 1) and three counts of second
degree robbery (§ 211; counts 2–4). On appeal, Calderon argues
(1) the trial court erred in denying his two pretrial motions for
substitution of counsel under People v. Marsden (1970) 2 Cal.3d
118 (Marsden), and (2) the abstract of judgment incorrectly
identifies the offense in count 2. We conclude the trial court did
not abuse its discretion in denying the Marsden motions because
it conducted an adequate inquiry into Calderon’s claims about his
counsel, and Calderon failed to show inadequate representation
or an irreconcilable conflict. We modify the abstract of judgment
to correct the error in count 2, but otherwise affirm.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
I. Evidence at trial
A. July 28, 2021 assault at Target
On July 28, 2021, Elijah Lloyd was working as a security
guard at a Target store in Pico Rivera. Lloyd observed Calderon
load two canopies into a shopping cart and then attempt to leave
the store without paying for the items. When Lloyd approached
Calderon near the exit, he identified himself as a security guard,
grabbed the cart of canopies, and asked Calderon to leave the
merchandise inside the store. Calderon refused, and repeatedly
told Lloyd to let go of the cart. Calderon reached out his arm,
and stabbed Lloyd in the chest with a sharp metal object that
looked like a box cutter. Calderon then walked out of store while
1 Unless otherwise stated, all further undesignated statutory
references are to the Penal Code.
2
pointing at his own chest near the area where he stabbed Lloyd.
When Lloyd looked down at his chest, he saw that he had a hole
in his shirt and was bleeding. Lloyd sought treatment at a
hospital later that day, and missed work for the next two weeks.
At trial, Lloyd testified about the July 28, 2021 incident,
including the injury that he sustained from Calderon. The jury
saw surveillance video footage of the altercation, along with
photographs that Lloyd took of his injury.
B. August 6, 2021 robbery at Lowe’s
On August 6, 2021, Jonathan Leon was working as a
cashier at a Lowe’s store in Pico Rivera. When Leon saw
Calderon leaving the store with a shopping cart full of canopies,
he approached Calderon and asked to verify his receipt. As
Calderon continued walking away with the cart, he pulled out a
box cutter and threatened to stab Leon. Calderon then loaded
the canopies into a parked car. Fearing for his life, Leon did not
try to stop Calderon from leaving, but he took photographs of the
car and its license plate.
At trial, Leon testified about the August 6, 2021 incident.
The jury saw surveillance video of the theft and the photographs
that Leon took of Calderon’s car. The video showed Leon talking
to Calderon as he left the store with the canopies, but did not
capture Calderon threatening Leon with a weapon.
C. August 16, 2021 robbery at Lowe’s
On August 16, 2021, Angie Campos was working as a
cashier at the same Lowe’s store in Pico Rivera. Campos noticed
Calderon walking out the store with a cart of canopies. Because
she had not seen him pay for the items, Campos asked Calderon
for a receipt. When Calderon did not respond, Campos followed
him outside. After exiting the store, Calderon turned back
3
toward Campos and lifted his shirt, exposing a rectangular-
shaped object that resembled a box cutter holster. Campos was
fearful, and went back inside to report the incident.
At trial, Campos testified about the August 16, 2021
incident, and the jury saw surveillance video of the theft. The
video showed Calderon exiting the store with the cart of canopies,
but did not capture his encounter with Campos outside the store.
D. August 28, 2021 robbery at Lowe’s
On August 28, 2021, both Leon and Campos again saw
Calderon leaving the Lowe’s store in Pico Rivera with a shopping
cart of canopies. When Leon asked for a receipt, Calderon replied
in an aggressive manner, “Do you want to go?” Calderon also
reached his hand toward his waistband, but did not show Leon
any weapon. Calderon then walked to the parking lot and loaded
the canopies into the same car that Leon had seen before. Leon
watched Calderon from the store exit but did not pursue him
because of their prior encounter. While the August 28, 2021
incident was not captured on surveillance video, both Leon and
Campos testified about the incident at trial.
E. Police investigation
The detective investigating the robberies reviewed the
surveillance video footage from the Target and Lowe’s stores, as
well as the photographs that Leon took of the suspect’s car. In
September 2021, the detective observed Calderon entering that
car, which was parked across the street from a residence. When
the detective executed a search warrant on the residence a few
days later, Calderon was present in the home, and the car was
parked nearby. During the search, no canopies or box cutters
were found inside the residence or the car.
4
II. Jury verdict and sentencing
At the conclusion of the trial, the jury found Calderon
guilty as charged of one count of assault with a deadly weapon
and three counts of second degree robbery. The trial court
sentenced Calderon to a total term of four years in state prison.
Calderon filed a timely appeal.
DISCUSSION
I. Denial of the Marsden motions
Calderon contends the trial court prejudicially erred in
denying his two pretrial Marsden motions, because it did not
conduct an adequate inquiry into the reasons why Calderon was
requesting the substitution of appointed counsel. On this record,
we conclude Calderon has failed to establish Marsden error.
A. Marsden proceedings
1. December 8, 2021 motion
On December 8, 2021, six months prior to trial, Calderon’s
appointed counsel, James Neptune, informed the trial court that
Calderon wanted to make a Marsden motion. Outside the
presence of the prosecutor, the court held a Marsden hearing on
Calderon’s request. At the start of the hearing, Calderon told the
court, “I would like my discovery, the medical records of the
alleged injured victim and to see the store videos of all of this
where Mr. Neptune hasn’t provided me. He said he was going to
send me my copies and show me. He hasn’t done anything, in
fact, three months that he’s been representing me. I would like
to postpone my date to another date with a different public
defender, if that’s possible.”
In response, Neptune stated he had “a redacted copy of
[Calderon’s] discovery right here.” After confirming with
Neptune that all necessary redactions to the discovery had been
5
made, the court told Calderon, “That has been done, and he has
just handed it to the deputy to make sure the redactions are in
order, and you’ll receive a copy of it.”
The court then asked Calderon about his second complaint.
Calderon replied he wanted a different attorney because he and
Neptune had “a conflict of interest in [his] case.” The court
inquired what the conflict of interest was, and Calderon
answered that Neptune was “pressuring [him] on something”
that he did not believe was necessary. When asked to elaborate,
Calderon stated that every time he saw his attorney, Neptune
would tell him that he “would get a better deal,” but he never did.
Calderon added, “I don’t think he’s actually doing anything in my
behalf for my case.”
The court explained to Calderon that, because he was
charged with assault with a deadly weapon along with three
counts of robbery, it would be “extremely difficult” for him to
receive a favorable plea offer. The court also noted that, a few
weeks earlier, Calderon rejected the prosecution’s early
disposition offer, which is “generally as good as it gets.”
The court told Calderon, “And when that offer is rejected, they
usually don’t reoffer the same offer. It usually goes up.”
Calderon indicated that he understood.
The court next allowed Neptune to respond to Calderon’s
complaint about a plea deal. As described by Neptune, the
prosecution’s early disposition offer required Calderon to plead to
each count, which was “not a very good offer.” The prosecutor
later proposed a plea deal of five years for one strike or three
years for two strikes. After Calderon rejected both offers, the
case proceeded to a preliminary hearing, and the court held
Calderon to answer on all counts. Calderon told Neptune that he
6
did not believe the prosecutor had sufficient evidence for a
conviction. Although Neptune expressed to Calderon that the
eyewitnesses’ testimony would be sufficient to convict him
regardless of whether each incident was fully captured on video,
Calderon maintained he did not threaten anyone. Neptune
further explained to the court that, earlier that day, he proposed
a plea deal of three years for one strike, but the prosecutor
rejected his offer.
Calderon disagreed about the terms of the prosecution’s
last offer, noting that Neptune told him it was “four years for one
strike.” Calderon then stated, “I really would like to roll my dice
on this and get somebody else.”
After listening to Calderon, the court responded, “So here’s
the thing, what you have said is, basically, he’s not fighting for
you. He hasn’t given you a better deal. So what I heard is there
was, essentially, an offer made for a plea to all counts and your
attorney said, no, that’s ridiculous. That’s not a good deal. Don’t
take it. I’m not going to advise you to take that deal. So you
saying he’s not fighting for you is rejected by the fact he could
have just said, yeah, go ahead. Take, you know, plead to all
counts.”
At that point, Calderon attempted to interrupt the court,
asserting, “The first deal that was offered—.” The court,
however, continued, “Just listen. So your attorney said, that’s
not a great deal. Let’s see what happens at prelim. At prelim,
they made you another offer and you rejected that offer. And
they actually brought in live witnesses and the judge said, you
know what, I think there’s enough there for a jury to decide on
his guilt or innocence and you were held to answer.” The court
told Calderon, “So your attorney is doing his job. Even as of
7
today, he even asked the D.A. for a lower offer, . . . and she said
no.”
The court concluded the hearing, stating, “[Y]our attorney
is doing exactly what he is required to do and that is get in there
and fight for you. That’s exactly what he’s doing. He just turned
over discovery, the redacted portion of the discovery, you now
have. The court is going to deny your request to have
Mr. Neptune relieved.”
2. April 27, 2022 motion
On April 27, 2022, two weeks before trial, Calderon made a
second Marsden motion. In response to Calderon’s request, the
court again held a Marsden hearing outside the presence of the
prosecutor. Calderon told the court, “So far I asked for my
discovery, and Mr. Neptune, all he did was just provide me with
paperwork. . . . [H]e hasn’t gotten for me injury report or any
evidence against me with the box cutter. [¶] Also, he hasn’t
shown me any videos. So . . . I don’t feel like he’s capable of
representing me ’cause he hasn’t shown me no discovery of my
file. He wants me to get convicted of something I did not do.”
The court asked Neptune whether the evidence sought by
Calderon existed. Neptune replied, “Yes, Your Honor. I provided
Mr. Calderon with what discovery I’m able to per the sheriff
department policies. I’m not able to give him audio disks or
D.V.D[s].” Upon further inquiry, Neptune confirmed Calderon
had not seen any video footage, and offered to set up his
computer to show Calderon the videos he obtained in discovery.
The court advised Neptune that, with the bailiff’s assistance, he
could show the videos to Calderon in the courtroom that day.
The court then asked Calderon what else he believed his
attorney had not done. Calderon responded that he had not seen
8
the medical report or photographs of the alleged assault victim.
Neptune confirmed he had the victim’s medical record and
photographs of his injury on disks. The court noted that the
victim’s medical record was private information, but that
Neptune could show Calderon the photographs of the victim’s
injury when he showed him the videos.
After the court advised Calderon that it would make sure
he saw all the discovery that day, Calderon stated that he still
wanted another attorney. Calderon told the court, “In nine
months I don’t feel Mr. Neptune has been working for me.” When
the court asked for more specific information, Calderon answered,
“He’s strong with his tricks. He sees me as a convict. He didn’t
see my innocence. I’m innocent until proven guilty, but this he
just pushes, pushes, pushes me to sign . . . a deal that I know I’m
not guilty of. That’s why I don’t want him to represent me, not
even if I see the videos, I still don’t want him to represent me.
I don’t care if I come back [in] nine months, I don’t mind, but I do
not want him to represent me anymore. Thank you.”
In response, Neptune stated, “Now, I think Mr. Calderon is
under the misapprehension when I conveyed offers to him that
I’m somehow preparing him to take a deal. That is not correct.
If Mr. Calderon . . . does not want to accept the offers, then we do
the trial. That’s how it is. That’s what I do; but the fact that
I convey offers to him, okay, and the fact that I let him know that
I don’t think his chances at trial are very good based on what I’ve
seen of the case, that doesn’t mean that I’m pressuring him to
take a deal. I’m simply being realistic with Mr. Calderon. [¶] So
if he didn’t like my assessment of his case, that’s fine, but that’s
not a reason to remove me from the case.”
9
The court explained to Calderon that his attorney had an
obligation to provide him with an honest assessment of his case
and to convey any plea offers made by the prosecution. The court
also noted that his attorney was “only doing his job” in “telling
[Calderon] those things [that] he must.” The court denied the
second Marsden motion, stating, “So at this point in time it’s
denied subject to the videos being shown . . . . Medical reports
are privileged and only the attorney can see them, not anybody
else . . . . [¶] He can go over them with you and explain them to
you, but you can’t have them in your possession.”
Later that afternoon, in open court, the trial court asked
Neptune whether he was able to show the discovery to Calderon.
Neptune replied that he was able to show Calderon the video of
the Target incident, but he could not access the videos of the
other incidents or the photographs of the victim’s injury due to
network connection issue. Neptune also stated that he would be
reviewing the victim’s medical report with Calderon before he left
court that day, and would print out the photographs for him by
the next court hearing. The prosecutor confirmed that the other
videos showed Calderon leaving the store with the merchandise,
but did not capture him making any threats. Calderon did not
object or raise any other concerns about his counsel with the trial
court.
B. Governing law
Under Marsden and its progeny, when a defendant seeks
substitution of appointed counsel, “ ‘ “the trial court must permit
the defendant to explain the basis of his contention and to relate
specific instances of inadequate performance. A defendant is
entitled to relief if the record clearly shows that the appointed
counsel is not providing adequate representation or that
10
defendant and counsel have become embroiled in such an
irreconcilable conflict that ineffective representation is likely to
result.” ’ ” (People v. Ng (2022) 13 Cal.5th 448, 500.) “ ‘A trial
court should grant a defendant’s Marsden motion only when the
defendant has made “a substantial showing that failure to order
substitution is likely to result in constitutionally inadequate
representation.” ’ ” (People v. Streeter (2012) 54 Cal.4th 205, 230.)
“ ‘Once a defendant is afforded an opportunity to state his
or her reasons for seeking to discharge an appointed attorney, the
decision whether or not to grant a motion for substitution of
counsel lies within the discretion of the trial judge.’ ” (People v.
Myles (2012) 53 Cal.4th 1181, 1207.) We review the denial of a
defendant’s Marsden motion for abuse of discretion. (People v.
Ng, supra, 13 Cal.5th at p. 500.) “ ‘Denial is not an abuse of
discretion “unless the defendant has shown that a failure to
replace counsel would substantially impair the defendant’s right
to assistance of counsel.” ’ ” (Ibid.)
C. The trial court did not abuse its discretion in
denying Calderon’s two Marsden motions
Calderon argues the trial court erred by failing to conduct
an adequate inquiry at each of the Marsden hearings. Calderon
asserts that, at the first hearing, the court did not allow him to
fully explain why he was seeking another attorney, and at the
second hearing, the court did not adequately inquire into why his
attorney had not provided access to the video and photographic
evidence. We conclude Calderon’s claims lack merit.
In Marsden, our Supreme Court held that a trial court that
“denies a motion for substitution of attorneys solely on the basis
of [its] courtroom observations, despite a defendant’s offer to
relate specific instances of misconduct, abuses the exercise of [its]
11
discretion to determine the competency of the attorney.” (People
v. Marsden, supra, 2 Cal.3d at p. 124.) Accordingly, “ ‘[w]hen a
defendant moves for substitution of appointed counsel, the court
must consider any specific examples of counsel’s inadequate
representation that the defendant wishes to enumerate.’ ”
(People v. Hines (1997) 15 Cal.4th 997, 1024.) In this case, the
record reflects that the trial court made a proper inquiry into
Calderon’s two requests for substitution of counsel, and acted
within its broad discretion in denying each request.
At the first Marsden hearing, the trial court gave Calderon
ample opportunity to articulate his reasons for wanting to replace
Neptune. Calderon raised two complaints about his counsel at
that time. He first claimed Neptune had not provided him with
copies of the discovery, including the assault victim’s medical
records and the store surveillance videos. In response to this
claim, Neptune told the court he had a “redacted copy of [the]
discovery right here,” and would give it to Calderon. Because
Calderon would be receiving the redacted copy of his discovery
that same day, the court turned to his second complaint.
Calderon next claimed he had a “conflict of interest” with his
counsel because Neptune had not obtained a “better deal” for
Calderon despite assurances that he would do so. The court
informed Calderon that a more favorable plea deal might not be
possible given the serious charges against him. After Calderon
stated that he understood, the court allowed Neptune to respond
to this complaint. Neptune recounted the plea offers made by the
prosecutor and Calderon’s reasons for rejecting them. Neptune
also noted that he had advised Calderon that the prosecution
likely had sufficient evidence for a conviction based on the
eyewitnesses’ testimony. Neptune added that, while he
12
continued to seek a favorable plea deal, the prosecutor rejected
his most recent offer, and Calderon wanted to proceed with the
trial. As our Supreme Court has observed, “ ‘ “[t]actical
disagreements between the defendant and his attorney do not by
themselves constitute an ‘irreconcilable conflict.’ ” ’ ” (People v.
Myles, supra, 53 Cal.4th at p. 1207.)
Calderon claims that, at the first hearing, the trial court
improperly cut him off when he tried to further explain why he
wanted to replace his attorney. The record, however, does not
support this claim. The court allowed Calderon to fully explain
his reasons for requesting the substitution of counsel, and asked
him to elaborate when he stated that they had a “conflict of
interest” and Neptune was “pressuring [him] on something.”
The court then listened to Calderon’s complaint regarding his
counsel’s failure to obtain a “better deal,” and asked Neptune to
respond to that complaint. After Neptune detailed the specific
plea offers made by the prosecutor and the reasons that a deal
had not been reached, the court informed Calderon why his
complaint did not warrant the substitution of counsel. At one
point, Calderon tried to interrupt the court with a comment about
the “first deal that was offered.” While the court did not allow
that interruption, the record shows it did permit Calderon to
“explain the basis of his contention and to relate specific
instances of inadequate performance.” (People v. Ng, supra,
13 Cal.5th at p. 500.) The court thus conducted an adequate
inquiry at the first Marsden hearing, and reasonably could
conclude that Calderon failed to show either inadequate
representation or an irreconcilable conflict with his counsel.
At the second Marsden hearing, the trial court again
allowed Calderon to explain why he was dissatisfied with his
13
counsel’s performance, and then questioned Neptune about each
claim. Calderon complained that Neptune still had not provided
him with all of the discovery, and identified three items he had
not seen: (1) the store surveillance videos; (2) the photographs of
the assault victim’s injury; and (3) the assault victim’s medical
record. While Neptune confirmed this evidence existed, he
explained that he could not provide it to Calderon “per the sheriff
department policies,” and he had given Calderon the discovery
that was allowed. In an effort to address Calderon’s complaint,
the court instructed Neptune to show Calderon the video and
photographic evidence that same day, and to review the victim’s
medical record with him. The court also made its courtroom
facilities available to Neptune for this purpose. After addressing
the discovery issue, the court inquired whether Calderon had any
other concerns about his counsel. The court listened to
Calderon’s complaint that Neptune was pushing him to “sign a
deal” because he believed Calderon was guilty, and to Neptune’s
response that he was complying with his obligation to convey all
plea offers and to provide an honest assessment of the case.
Neptune denied he ever pressured Calderon to accept a plea, and
explained that he was “simply being realistic” about his chances
at trial. To the extent there was a credibility question between
Calderon and his counsel at the Marsden hearing, the court was
“ ‘ “entitled to accept counsel’s explanation.” ’ ” (People v. Rices
(2017) 4 Cal.5th 49, 69.)
Calderon contends that, at the second hearing, the trial
court committed Marsden error because it never asked Neptune
why he had not shown the video and photographic evidence to
Calderon earlier, or asked Calderon why he wanted to view these
materials. We disagree. At the second hearing, the court took
14
active steps to ensure that Calderon was given access to each
requested item that same day, and stated that it was denying
the Marsden motion subject to counsel showing Calderon such
evidence. Later that day, the court asked Neptune whether he
was able to share the materials with Calderon. Neptune stated
that, due to technical difficulties, he could only show Calderon
the video from the Target assault, and that he would share the
assault victim’s photos and medical report with Calderon by the
next hearing date. Calderon did not object to this proposal, nor
did he raise any other complaints about Neptune’s performance
following the second Marsden hearing. Moreover, in considering
Calderon’s complaints about his lack of access to the discovery,
the question before the trial court was not whether Neptune
could have shared such evidence with Calderon earlier in the
case, but whether the failure to do so demonstrated that counsel’s
performance “was so deficient that constitutionally ineffective
representation was likely to result.” (People v. Wright (2021)
12 Cal.5th 419, 441.) After hearing at length from both Calderon
and Neptune, the court reasonably could find that Calderon
failed to make the requisite showing.
On this record, we conclude the trial court conducted a
proper inquiry into each of Calderon’s requests for substitution of
counsel, and did not abuse its discretion in denying the two
Marsden motions.
II. Abstract of judgment
Calderon contends, and the People concede, that the
abstract of judgment incorrectly states that Calderon was
convicted of first degree robbery in count 2. It is undisputed that,
in count 2, Calderon was charged with and convicted of second
15
degree robbery, not first degree robbery. The abstract of
judgment must be modified accordingly.
DISPOSITION
The judgment is modified to reflect that the conviction in
count 2 is for second degree robbery. As modified, the judgment
is affirmed. The superior court is directed to prepare an amended
abstract of judgment, and to forward a certified copy to the
Department of Corrections.
VIRAMONTES, J.
WE CONCUR:
GRIMES, Acting P. J.
WILEY, J.
16
Ti chiedi come si applica questo testo alla tua situazione?
Consulenza gratuita, senza impegno
Descrivi la tua situazione. Il nostro team ti ricontatterà via e-mail per la tua consulenza.
Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude
Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.