In re J.G. CA2/5

CourtListener 9509074Calctapp30 mag 2024

Testo completo

Filed 5/30/24 In re J.G. CA2/5
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on
opinions not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule
8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication or ordered published for
purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION FIVE

In re J.G., a Person Coming Under
the Juvenile Court Law. B326648

LOS ANGELES COUNTY (Los Angeles County
DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN Super. Ct. No.
AND FAMILY SERVICES, 18CCJP00878C)

Plaintiff and Respondent,

v.

T.D.,

Defendant and Appellant.

APPEAL from orders of the Superior Court of Los Angeles
County, Jean M. Nelson, Judge. Reversed.
Suzanne M. Nicholson, under appointment by the Court of
Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, Kim Nemoy,
Assistant County Counsel, and Veronica Randazzo, Deputy
County Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
T.D. (Mother) appeals the juvenile court’s order assuming
dependency jurisdiction over her infant son, J.G. (Minor). We are
asked to decide whether substantial evidence supports the
jurisdiction finding, which rests on the court’s conclusion that
Minor was at risk from Mother’s methamphetamine abuse that
led to a prior finding of dependency jurisdiction over one of
Minor’s siblings.1

I. BACKGROUND
A. Prior Pertinent Dependency History
In 2018, a juvenile court asserted dependency jurisdiction
over Mother’s daughter, H.R., after sustaining allegations that
Mother had a history of engaging in violent altercations in H.R.’s
presence. During the investigation into those allegations, Mother
admitted to a social worker from the Los Angeles County
Department of Children and Family Services (the Department)
that she had smoked crystal methamphetamine in the past; she,
however, denied drug use at the time. The juvenile court
ultimately terminated dependency jurisdiction over H.R. and
granted her father sole legal and physical custody of the child.
In 2020, the Department filed a dependency petition
concerning Mother’s son, D.D., based (among other things) on
evidence that he tested positive for amphetamines at birth and
that Mother was an abuser of amphetamines and
benzodiazepines who likewise tested positive for those substances
the day D.D. was born. Mother pled no contest to the petition’s
allegations and the juvenile court took jurisdiction over D.D.

1
No findings were sustained as to Minor’s father, B.G.
(Father), and he is not a party to this appeal.

2
Mother was ordered to drug test weekly and to complete a drug
and alcohol program of at least six months’ duration. In April
2022, the juvenile court terminated reunification services for
Mother in D.D.’s case.2

B. These Dependency Proceedings
1. The Department’s initial investigation
In May 2022, a few days after Mother gave birth to Minor,
the Department opened an investigation into his well-being.
Minor was in the NICU being treated with precautionary
antibiotics due to an aspect of Mother’s medical history. Minor
was doing well, and Mother was attentive when she visited.
Mother and Minor tested negative for substances at Minor’s
birth, and there were no concerns based on Mother’s actions at
the hospital. The Department was apparently alerted to Minor’s
birth because Mother told hospital staff she had two children but
discussed only one.
The Department interviewed Mother at the NICU. Mother
did not understand why the Department was present or involved.
She stated she was in compliance with court orders, the baby was
well, and she was not under the influence. Mother also said the
Department could not use her past against her.
Paternal grandmother V.H. (Paternal Grandmother), who
was also at the NICU, reported Mother and Father were living
with Paternal Grandmother and Mother was doing fine.

2
Mother filed a section 388 petition in D.D.’s case in October
2022, alleging changed circumstances. The juvenile court
granted a hearing on the petition, but the record in this appeal
does not reveal how the court ultimately ruled on that petition.

3
Paternal Grandmother also said she drove Mother to her court-
ordered services.
When the Department social worker spoke to Father the
following day, he denied having concerns regarding Minor’s
safety or wellbeing. Father claimed Mother was no longer using
drugs and was attending services.
The social worker assigned to D.D.’s case, however,
reported Mother had not been compliant with services and had
been inconsistent in demonstrating behavioral changes to
address the reasons the Department had an open case regarding
D.D. The social worker reported the biggest concern was Mother
not taking responsibility for her actions and lacking insight both
as to the reasons her children were removed from her custody
and as to how her actions affect their safety and well-being.
Minor was released from the hospital and into Mother and
Father’s care. The same day, the Department social worker
asked them to test for drugs and alcohol. They were not able to
test at the designated site that day, but they tested negative the
next day.
A Department social worker also undertook additional
investigation concerning Mother’s progress with sobriety. Mother
had been enrolled in a drug and alcohol program since November
2021. A representative from the program agreed Mother needed
to increase attendance and participation in services but also
stated Mother had increased her attendance in the prior couple of
months. Paternal Grandmother reported she had not seen
Mother using drugs in her home.
In July, Father reported having some relationship issues
with Mother. He said he wanted Minor to remain in Paternal
Grandmother’s home, but he claimed Mother was disrespecting

4
household rules and threatening to leave with Minor. Around the
same time, Mother asked the Department social worker for
housing resources.

2. The initial petition
Although the Department found Minor was in good health
and recommended he remain in his parents’ care, it nonetheless
deemed him to be at “high” risk of future harm and neglect.
The Department filed a two-count petition in July 2022,
asking the juvenile court to assume jurisdiction over Minor under
Welfare and Institutions Code section 300, subdivisions (b)(1) and
(j).3 The petition alleged in the subdivision (b) count that Minor
was at substantial risk of suffering physical harm due to his
young age and Mother’s history of abusing amphetamines and
benzodiazepines. The subdivision (j) count asserted Minor was at
risk of harm in light of Mother’s inability to care for his half-
sibling, D.D., as a result of her history of substance abuse. At the
detention hearing, the juvenile court released Minor into his
parents’ care under the Department’s supervision and ordered
family preservation services for both parents, including drug
testing.

3. Further investigation
Over the ensuing months, the Department continued to
monitor the family. In September 2022, Mother claimed Father
hit her in the face in April 2021 (before the initial detention
hearing for Minor) and in July 2022 (after). Mother stated she

3
Undesignated statutory references that follow are to the
Welfare and Institutions Code.

5
reported at least one domestic violence incident to the police and
claimed some of the violence had been witnessed by paternal
relatives. Mother also said that, as a result of a recent incident of
abuse, Mother had taken Minor and left Paternal Grandmother’s
home. Mother planned to stay with a friend until the social
worker could help her get into a program for people with
children.
Discussing the drug abuse allegations, Mother asserted she
did not think she should be testing anymore because she had by
then completed her drug and alcohol program. Mother said the
last time she used any drugs was in November 2020, on the day
D.D. was born. Mother stated it was not right that the
Department kept bringing up her prior drug use and asserted the
hospital had given her benzodiazepines for pain.4
The social worker also reviewed Mother’s recent drug test
results and learned Mother tested negative six times and missed
nine tests during the period from May 24, 2022, through August
26, 2022.5 The social worker also verified Mother graduated from
her six-month drug and alcohol program in August 2022 and was
enrolled in domestic violence classes.

4
The detention report from D.D.’s dependency case reflects
that a doctor at the hospital where Mother delivered D.D. told a
Department social worker that benzodiazepines are typically
medications that treat anxiety, such as Ativan or Valium.
5
The negative tests occurred on June 6, June 9, June 15,
July 1, July 14, and August 11, 2022. The missed tests occurred
on May 24, June 2, June 8, July 8, July 21, July 27, August 5,
August 17, and August 26, 2022.

6
The social worker also interviewed other family members.
Father expressed concern about Mother’s substance abuse,
though he had never seen Mother use drugs. Father denied all of
the allegations of domestic violence. Paternal Grandmother said
she had no concerns about Mother using drugs or alcohol but
denied Mother’s allegations that Father had been abusive.
Paternal Grandmother was, however, concerned that Mother did
not know how to parent a baby (giving, as an example, Mother’s
decision to feed Minor applesauce when he was two months old).
S.H. (Paternal Great Aunt) also expressed concern about
Mother’s parenting ability, opining she did not know how to take
care of a baby and did not want to change his diaper. She
claimed Mother had given Minor baby food when he was only a
few days old.
Mother denied giving Minor baby food, but she admitted
she had given him baby cereal. When the social worker asked if
Minor’s doctor had approved of Mother doing so, Mother stated
he was supposed to start at 6 months, but Minor was still hungry
when she gave him bottles so she gave him a little bit of baby
cereal as well.
In October 2022, the Department social worker reviewed
Mother’s drug tests for the period from August 29, 2022, through
October 18, 2022. Mother tested negative four times and missed
five tests.6 Mother told the social worker she missed one test
because she was on her period and missed two other tests
because she was ill.

6
The negative tests occurred on September 8, September 12,
September 28, and October 5, 2022. The missed tests occurred on
August 29, September 9, September 20, October 12, and October
18, 2022.

7
Mother additionally told a social worker that she had not
had any contact with Father since leaving Paternal
Grandmother’s home. Father, on the other hand, said he spoke
to Mother regularly but he had not seen Minor since Mother left
Paternal Grandmother’s home.
Also in October 2022, the Department filed an amended
dependency petition that added a new count, designated b-2,
alleging Minor was at substantial risk of serious physical harm
from Father’s domestic violence against Mother. By December of
that year, Mother and Father had a schedule in place pursuant to
which Mother cared for Minor during the week and Father cared
for him over the weekend. The Department social worker
reported Minor appeared to be developing well.
Mother stated there had been no issues with Father since
she moved out of Paternal Grandmother’s home. Mother
continued to participate in domestic violence classes, and she had
recently contacted her individual therapist to resume services.
The social worker again reviewed Mother’s drug test results.
During the period from October 27, 2022, through November 21,
2022, Mother appeared for, and tested negative at, all five
scheduled tests.7 Though the Department submitted requests to
relevant police departments, it did not receive any police reports
confirming Mother’s assertions of domestic violence.

4. The jurisdiction hearing
The juvenile court held a jurisdiction hearing in December
2022. The court sustained counts b-1 and j-1, regarding Mother’s

7
The negative tests occurred on October 27, November 3,
November 7, November 14, and November 21, 2022.

8
substance abuse and dismissed count b-2, regarding the domestic
violence allegations. The court observed it was “very true” that
Mother had made progress, but the court believed Mother had a
“long history of a number of different problems” including
substance abuse and an “inconsistency in her ability to follow
through on services.” The court opined methamphetamine was “a
type of drug that a parent can avoid for years and then they go
back to it for some reason” and expressed concern that Mother
was not testing consistently until recently. The juvenile court
reiterated Mother was “making progress” but explained “the
period of sobriety I need to see for somebody who’s had her
reunification services terminated in the past . . . needs to be
much more substantial than what we have here, where by
September of this year I’m still worried she is not testing
regularly. This is not to minimize Mother’s progress. It just
means, given the number of risks, her history, what the
Department shows, I need to be very sure she can maintain her
sobriety, and I don’t have that.”
The court released Minor to Mother and Father’s care,
conditioned on Mother and Father not living together. Mother
was ordered to participate in random drug and alcohol testing
and individual counseling.

II. DISCUSSION
Although the substantial evidence standard of review is
deferential (In re R.T. (2017) 3 Cal.5th 622, 633) and section 300,
subdivision (j) provides the broadest grounds for asserting
dependency jurisdiction over a child (In re I.J. (2013) 56 Cal.4th
766, 774), there is still insufficient evidence of a substantial risk
that Minor would be abused or neglected within the meaning of

9
that subdivision.8 There were no concerns with Minor at birth
that initially prompted the Department’s investigation. Then,
over the ensuing six-plus months when Minor remained in
Mother’s (and Father’s) care, Mother repeatedly tested negative
for methamphetamine use, she completed a drug program, the
Paternal Grandmother reported no reason to believe she was
again using drugs, and Minor continued to be in good health and
doing well. The best that can accordingly be said for the juvenile
court’s jurisdiction finding is that Mother had a history of
methamphetamine abuse, had several earlier missed drug tests
and, in the opinion of one social worker assigned to D.D.’s case,
lacked “insight.” (She also fed Minor some solid food apparently
before that was indicated, but that was not an alleged ground for
jurisdiction in the dependency petition and would not alter our
conclusion in any event.) Those facts, in our view, are not
substantial evidence of a risk of neglect or abuse that can support
jurisdiction here.

A. Section 300, Subdivision (j)
Section 300, subdivision (j), authorizes a juvenile court to
assume dependency jurisdiction over a child when the following
two requirements are met: “[t]he child’s sibling has been abused
or neglected, as defined in subdivision [(b)(1) or other

8
Because the basis on which a juvenile court can assert
jurisdiction under section 300, subdivision (j), is broader than
that under section 300, subdivision (b)(1), our analysis of the
sufficiency of the evidence focuses on the subdivision (j) finding
and we need not discuss the juvenile court’s subdivision (b)(1)
finding.

10
subdivisions], and there is a substantial risk that the child will be
abused or neglected, as defined in those subdivisions.” (§ 300,
subd. (j).) Under subdivision (b)(1), a child is a dependent child
when “[t]he child has suffered, or there is a substantial risk that
the child will suffer, serious physical harm or illness, as a result
of . . . [¶] [t]he failure or inability of the child’s parent or
guardian to adequately supervise or protect the child . . . .”
(§ 300, subd. (b)(1)(A).) Our Supreme Court has recently
emphasized that section 300, subdivision (b)(1) “allows for
dependency jurisdiction based on substance abuse only when this
abuse leads to an ‘inability’ on the part of a parent or guardian ‘to
provide regular care for [a] child’ [citation] that causes the child
to suffer, or creates ‘a substantial risk that the child will suffer,
serious physical harm or illness’ [citation] . . . .” (In re N.R.
(2023) 15 Cal.5th 520, 540.) “[E]xcessive use of drugs or alcohol
[that] has other negative manifestations[, on the other
hand,] . . . does not provide a basis for jurisdiction . . . .” (Ibid.)
Our Supreme Court has also explained that, “[u]nlike the
other subdivisions, subdivision (j) includes a list of factors for the
court to consider: ‘The court shall consider the circumstances
surrounding the abuse or neglect of the sibling, the age and
gender of each child, the nature of the abuse or neglect of the
sibling, the mental condition of the parent or guardian, and any
other factors the court considers probative in determining
whether there is a substantial risk to the child.’ (§ 300, subd. (j).)
‘The “nature of the abuse or neglect of the sibling” is only one of
many factors that the court is to consider in assessing whether
the child is at risk of abuse or neglect in the family home.
Subdivision (j) thus allows the court to take into consideration
factors that might not be determinative if the court were

11
adjudicating a petition filed directly under one of those
subdivisions. [¶] The broad language of subdivision (j) clearly
indicates that the trial court is to consider the totality of the
circumstances of the child and his or her sibling in determining
whether the child is at substantial risk of harm, within the
meaning of any of the subdivisions enumerated in subdivision (j).
The provision thus accords the trial court greater latitude to
exercise jurisdiction as to a child whose sibling has been found to
have been abused than the court would have in the absence of
that circumstance.’ [Citation.]” (I.J., supra, 56 Cal.4th at 774.)

B. Substantial Evidence Does Not Support the Juvenile
Court’s Dependency Finding
It is, of course, undisputed D.D. was adjudged a dependent
of the juvenile court due to Mother’s substance abuse and D.D.
and Minor were relatively close in age (D.D. is approximately 18
months older). But that is where the similarities end. Minor,
unlike D.D., was born without drugs in his system and hospital
personnel reported no concerns about his well-being or Mother’s
interaction with him. The Department was called nonetheless,
and during the ensuing dependency proceedings, Mother reported
she was not using methamphetamine, the Paternal Grandmother
(who lived with Mother for a time) advised she had no concerns
Mother was using drugs, Mother tested negative for
methamphetamine use at least once per month (and never tested
positive), and Mother completed a drug and alcohol program. In
addition, during all this time, Minor remained in Mother’s care,
and the Department documented no adverse effect on his health
or well-being (including from Mother’s admitted decision to feed
Minor some baby cereal before that was apparently indicated)—

12
and certainly no harm or risk of harm that would appear to be
attributable to methamphetamine use.
That, of course, leaves the drug tests that Mother did miss,
but considering those missed tests in light of the entirety of her
testing schedule and the other evidence in the record, we are not
persuaded the missed tests provide a sufficient basis for
dependency jurisdiction. Indeed, a contrary holding on this
record would mean dependency jurisdiction would automatically
attach to any subsequent children that are born to a parent who
suffered a previous adverse substance abuse dependency
finding—at least absent a perfect or near-perfect substance abuse
testing record over the course of, perhaps, multiple years.9 We
cannot accept that view, particularly in light of our Supreme
Court’s recent emphasis that the touchstone for a substance
abuse risk-based dependency finding (albeit one predicated on
section 300, subdivision (b)(1) directly) is evidence of an inability
to provide regular care that creates a substantial risk of physical
harm or illness, not mere negative manifestations of drug abuse
or questionable parenting decisions. (N.R., supra, 15 Cal.5th at
540.)
We shall therefore reverse the juvenile court’s finding of
dependency jurisdiction. We caution, however, that the reversal
is based on the state of the appellate record before us. If there
have been significant developments concerning Minor’s welfare or
Mother’s sobriety that post-date the December 2022 jurisdiction

9
As we have already recounted, the juvenile court opined
methamphetamine was a drug that a parent could return to
abusing after “years” of sobriety and stated it needed to be “very
sure [Mother] can maintain her sobriety.”

13
hearing from which this appeal is taken, our disposition will
permit the juvenile court to take those into account.

DISPOSITION
The juvenile court’s jurisdiction order is reversed. The
cause is remanded with directions to hold a new jurisdiction
hearing as soon as possible, consistent with the right of all sides
to prepare their case. If, at the new jurisdiction hearing, there
are no new significant developments (i.e., events or circumstances
that did not exist at the time of the order under review in this
appeal), the juvenile court shall enter a new and different order
dismissing the July 18, 2022, dependency petition. If the court
finds there are new developments that warrant a ruling other
than dismissal of the July 18, 2022, dependency petition, the
court shall make any necessary findings and orders and do so in a
manner sufficient to permit appellate review of that conclusion.

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS

BAKER, Acting P. J.

We concur:

MOOR, J. LEE, J.*

*
Judge of the San Bernardino County Superior Court,
assigned by the Chief Justice pursuant to Article VI, section 6 of
the California Constitution.

14

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.