People v. West CA1/5

CourtListener 9502502Calctapp15 mag 2024

Testo completo

Filed 5/15/24 P. v. West CA1/5

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on
opinions not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule
8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication or ordered published for pur-
poses of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

FIRST APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION FIVE

THE PEOPLE,
Plaintiff and Respondent, A164873
v.
SANTANA DUANE WEST, (San Francisco City & County
Defendant and Appellant. Super. Ct. Nos. SCN226436, CRI-
14031086)

Santana Duane West1 appeals after a jury convicted him of
forcible rape (Pen. Code, § 261, subd. (a)(2); count one),2 sexual
battery by restraint (§ 243.4, subd. (a); count six), two counts of
assault with force likely to cause great bodily injury (§ 245, subd.
(a)(4); counts eight-nine), false imprisonment (§ 236; count 11),
and assault with intent to commit rape (§ 220, subd. (a)(1); a
lesser included offense of count five). The jury also found true a
prior conviction allegation, which was alleged as a qualifying
prior under the one strike law (§ 667.61, subds. (a), (c)(1), (d)(1))
and the habitual sexual offender law (§ 667.71, subds. (a), (c)(1)).
That conviction (along with two others) were also alleged as

The parties stipulated below that appellant’s birth name
1

is Elon Collins, but he was charged as Santana Duane West and
is therefore referred to as West throughout this opinion.
2 Undesignated statutory references are to the Penal Code.

1
qualifying prior strikes under the three strikes law (§§ 667,
subds. (d)-(e), 1170.12, subds. (b)-(c)).

After a bifurcated court trial, at which the trial court found
all three prior strike allegations true, West was sentenced to a
prison term of 75 years to life. On appeal, West asserts claims of
evidentiary, prosecutorial, and sentencing error. We find no
prejudicial error and affirm.

BACKGROUND

A.

At around noon on December 2, 2014, Catherine S. went
out to buy crack in the Tenderloin neighborhood of San Francisco.
Although she had smoked crack earlier in the day, she was no
longer feeling its effects. She met West, who said he had drugs
and asked Catherine if she wanted to get high. Catherine agreed
and invited West to her apartment to smoke. Catherine testified
that she and West did not discuss exchanging sex for crack.

On their walk to Catherine’s apartment, West was drinking
liquor. Catherine did not drink any alcohol with him, but she
had consumed some earlier in the day. They entered her
apartment, Catherine gave West a pipe, and he “took a hit.”

Immediately thereafter, and within five minutes of
entering the apartment, West punched Catherine in the face,
knocking her onto the bed. He said, “[t]ake off your clothes,
bitch,” and punched her again. Catherine was a cancer survivor
and had not had sex in years. Catherine told him this and that
she “can’t do nothing.” West responded that she was lying and
claimed he had a nine-millimeter gun. Although Catherine never
saw a gun, West said several times that he would “kill” or “shoot”
her if she did not comply.

As Catherine struggled on the bed with West, she tried to
bang on the wall (adjacent to an exterior hallway) to get

2
someone’s attention. But West then held her hands and pressed
a pillow down over her face. Catherine testified that she thought
she was “going to die.” When he removed the pillow, Catherine
said, “[O]kay man I quit. I quit. I quit.” West then penetrated
Catherine’s vagina with his penis.

Eventually, West stopped and went into Catherine’s
kitchen in search of food. Catherine testified that he then hit her
several more times, threatened to kill her, and forcibly had
sexual intercourse with her two or three more times. Over the
course of the entire attack, which lasted between five and six
hours, West pushed the pillow over her face three or four times.
He also used his hands to cover her mouth and nose, and he
strangled her—using both of his hands around her neck to hold
her down. After a final act of forced intercourse, West fell asleep
in Catherine’s bed. Catherine then ran to her neighbor’s
apartment and called the police to report being raped.

B.

Catherine’s neighbor (and friend) testified that, on the
evening of December 2, 2014, Catherine knocked on his door and
said she had been “violated.” Catherine’s eyes were puffy, and
she appeared “shaken up.”

San Francisco Police Department Officer Irving Garcia, Jr.
responded to Catherine’s apartment building that night. When
Officer Garcia met Catherine in the hallway, she was wearing
only a jacket, with nothing on underneath. Catherine—who did
not appear to be under the influence of cocaine—initially told
Garcia, “he beat me up” and that her assailant was still in her
apartment. She appeared frightened, agitated, and disheveled
and had observable injuries to her face (including eyes, chin, lip,
and jaw), as well as to her neck, shoulder, and arm.

When Officer Garcia entered Catherine’s apartment, he
found West asleep, in her bed, wearing a white shirt but nothing

3
else. Spots of blood were on West’s shirt. When asked about it,
West said he thought he had a cut on his finger. While Officer
Garcia remained with West, a transmission on the police radio
referenced an ambulance for “a possible 261 victim.” West
immediately stated, “ ‘I did not have sexual relations with this
woman. I know what 261 means.’ ”

Officer Garcia returned to the hallway to interview
Catherine. Catherine told him that, when she first met West
around noon, West offered her crack, and they went back to her
apartment to get high. Catherine said that she never actually
ingested any drugs because, once they arrived at her apartment,
West beat her, raped her three or four times, and she only
escaped when West fell asleep.

Crime scene investigators did not find a gun in Catherine’s
apartment, but they collected a bra, which had an apparent blood
stain on it. Her mattress and nearby wall also showed what
appeared to be blood.

C.

Catherine was examined by a nurse practitioner at San
Francisco General Hospital. The nurse practitioner testified as
an expert in conducting forensic sexual assault examinations and
in the identification of symptoms of strangulation.

When Catherine was examined, she was crying but did not
appear to be intoxicated. She had a bruise on her left shoulder,
scratches on both arms and her face, swelling around her eyes,
and bruising around her eyelids, forehead, and lips. Both of
Catherine’s eyes showed recent subconjunctival hemorrhages and
her voice was hoarse. The nurse practitioner opined that these
injuries were consistent with manual strangulation and were
likely suffered in the last 24 hours. A sexual assault exam also
revealed that Catherine had suffered recent injuries to her

4
genitalia consistent with sexual trauma—including tears,
bruising, and petechia (ruptured blood vessels).

When interviewed (at the hospital) by San Francisco Police
Department Sergeant Andrea Creed, Catherine stated that West
had strangled her during the assault. Sergeant Creed also
interviewed West a few hours after his arrest. Portions of the
interview recording were played for the jury. After he waived his
rights under Miranda v. Arizona (1966) 384 U.S. 436, West told
Creed that he had consensual sex with Catherine (two or three
times) but denied hitting (or otherwise injuring) her.

When West was photographed, he had a bandage on his
neck and an abrasion on his shoulder. With respect to the
apparent bloodstains on his shirt, West repeated the explanation
about a cut to his hand. But no fresh wounds were seen on his
hands.

Pursuant to Evidence Code section 1108, the trial court
admitted a certified copy of West’s 2003 conviction for forcible
rape (Pen. Code, § 261, subd. (a)(2)).

D.

West testified, in his own defense, that he offered
Catherine crack in exchange for sex. She agreed and invited him
to her apartment. When he entered the apartment, he did not
intend to assault Catherine. They both smoked crack, then West
initiated sex, and Catherine agreed. West consensually
penetrated Catherine twice but could not maintain an erection.

West testified that Catherine made fun of his inability to
maintain an erection, they both smoked some more, and he drank
some alcohol. At some point, Catherine demanded more drugs.
Catherine told him that she was “ ‘going to hurt [him]’ ” and
started to reach under the bed. West, who is a Vietnam combat
veteran and has combat-related posttraumatic stress disorder,
was in fear because he did not know what she was reaching for.
5
He “reacted” to the perceived threat by grabbing her hand. Then
a “fight” ensued. West testified that Catherine was trying to
scratch and bite him, and despite being in fear for his life, he was
merely trying to restrain her. Although West admitted slapping
Catherine two or three times, he testified that he never punched
or strangled her. West eventually fell asleep and woke up when
officers entered the apartment.

In rebuttal, additional portions of West’s interview with
Sergeant Creed were played for the jury. During that interview,
West never mentioned having problems maintaining an erection,
Catherine commenting about such dysfunction, Catherine
reaching for something that made him fear for his safety, or that
he had restrained Catherine in self-defense. West also made no
attempt to explain his earlier statement (to Officer Garcia) that
he and Catherine did not have sex.

E.

The jury convicted West of one count each of forcible rape,
sexual battery by restraint, and false imprisonment; two counts
of assault with force likely to cause great bodily injury; and
assault with intent to commit rape as a lesser included offense to
count five—which was originally charged as assault with intent
to commit sexual assault during a burglary (§§ 220, subd. (b),
460, subd. (a)). The jury also found true an allegation that West
had been previously convicted of forcible rape, which made him
eligible for punishment under the one strike law (§ 667.61, subds.
(a), (c)(1), (d)(1)), as well as under the habitual sex offender law
(§ 667.71, subds. (a), (c)(1)).

West was acquitted of the other charged offenses, including
two additional counts of forcible rape (counts two and three),3

3An additional count of forcible rape (count four) was
dismissed by the court, pursuant to section 1118.1, before
deliberations.
6
making criminal threats (§ 422; count 10), and burglary (§ 459;
count 16).

The trial court found true allegations that West had
suffered three prior felony convictions—second degree robbery
(§ 211) in 1987, first degree robbery (§ 212.5, subd. (a)) in 2003,
and forcible rape in 2003. All three qualified as strikes under the
three strikes law (§§ 667, subds. (d)-(e), 1170.12, subds. (b)-(c)).
West was sentenced, on count one, to a prison term of 25 years to
life pursuant to the habitual sex offender law (§ 667.71, subd.
(b)), which was tripled to 75 years to life under the three strikes
law (§§ 667, subd. (e)(2)(A)(i), 1170.12, subd. (c)(2)(A)(i)).

DISCUSSION

A.

West contends the trial court abused its discretion under
Evidence Code section 352 by admitting evidence of his prior rape
conviction under Evidence Code section 1108. He is wrong.

1.

Although evidence of prior criminal acts is ordinarily
inadmissible to show a defendant’s disposition to commit such
acts (Evid. Code, § 1101), the Legislature has created an
exception to this rule in cases involving sexual offenses. (Id.,
§ 1108; People v. Reyes (2008) 160 Cal.App.4th 246, 251.) When
accused of a sex offense, Evidence Code section 1108 allows
admission of evidence of the defendant’s commission of other sex
crimes to demonstrate the defendant’s disposition to commit
similar crimes. (People v. Avila (2014) 59 Cal.4th 496, 514–515.)
The court has discretion, under Evidence Code section 352, to
exclude the evidence if its probative value is substantially
outweighed by the probability that it will consume an undue
amount of time or create a substantial danger of undue prejudice,
confusion of issues, or misleading the jury. (Evid. Code, § 352;
Avila, supra, at p. 515.) However, Evidence Code section 1108
7
evidence is presumed admissible. (People v. Loy (2011) 52
Cal.4th 46, 62 (Loy).)

Like any ruling under Evidence Code section 352, the trial
court’s admission of uncharged sex offense evidence is reviewed
for abuse of discretion. (People v. Cordova (2015) 62 Cal.4th 104,
132.)

2.

Before trial, defense counsel moved to exclude evidence of
West’s 2003 conviction for rape. West argued the evidence was
inadmissible testimonial hearsay because the previous
complaining witness had since died and never been cross-
examined. West also asserted any evidence was neither
admissible under Evidence Code section 1101, subdivision (b), nor
under Evidence Code section 1108, because the 2003 rape was
remote and dissimilar, and because admitting the evidence would
lead to undue consumption of time and jury confusion. The
prosecutor filed a competing motion to admit the evidence under
Evidence Code sections 1101, subdivision (b), and 1108.

After lengthy pretrial arguments and an Evidence Code
section 402 hearing, the trial court admitted the fact of West’s
prior rape conviction, pursuant to Evidence Code section 1108,
but only in sanitized form (the certified record of conviction). The
court excluded all evidence of the underlying conduct. The People
filed a motion to reconsider the latter ruling, which the trial court
denied.

3.

The trial court did not abuse its discretion in admitting the
fact of West’s 2003 rape conviction.

West first contends that his prior conviction was wholly
irrelevant because it was undisputed that he and Catherine had
sex. The argument is specious. It was the fact that West claimed

8
they had sex consensually, and denied using force (or threats of
force) to overcome Catherine’s will, that made the probative value
of his prior conviction so high. (See Loy, supra, 52 Cal.4th at p.
61 [“ ‘[s]ection 1108 assists the jury’s task by allowing the
accused’s sexual misconduct history to be considered for whatever
light it might shed on [whether the conduct took place as the
victim described it]’ ”].)

Similarity between sex crimes increases the probative
value of uncharged sexual offense evidence. (People v. Lewis
(2009) 46 Cal.4th 1255, 1287.) However, unlike Evidence Code
section 1101, subdivision (b), admissibility under Evidence Code
section 1108 does not require a significant degree of similarity
between charged and uncharged offenses. (People v. Merriman
(2014) 60 Cal.4th 1, 41.) It is enough that both the charged and
uncharged offenses are sex offenses as defined by Evidence Code
section 1108. (People v. Jones (2012) 54 Cal.4th 1, 50; Loy, supra,
52 Cal.4th at p. 63.) Here, both the prior and current offenses
involved forcible rape (Pen. Code, § 261, subd. (a)(2)), which
means that they are sufficiently similar. (See Evid. Code, § 1108,
subd. (d)(1)(A); Jones, supra, at p. 50.) Accordingly, the trial
court properly presumed that the evidence was admissible.
(People v. Cordova, supra, 62 Cal.4th at p. 132.)

Nor did the trial court abuse its discretion by declining to
exclude the evidence under Evidence Code section 352. “In
deciding whether to exclude evidence of another sexual offense
under [Evidence Code] section 1108, ‘trial judges must consider
such factors as its nature, relevance, and possible remoteness,
the degree of certainty of its commission and the likelihood of
confusing, misleading, or distracting the jurors from their main
inquiry, its similarity to the charged offense, its likely prejudicial
impact on the jurors, the burden on the defendant in defending
against the uncharged offense, and the availability of less
prejudicial alternatives to its outright admission, such as

9
admitting some but not all of the defendant’s other sex offenses,
or excluding irrelevant though inflammatory details surrounding
the offense.’ ” (People v. Story (2009) 45 Cal.4th 1282, 1295.)

West fails to point to any circumstances that required the
trial court to find the presumption in favor of admissibility had
been overcome. It was appropriate for the trial court to admit the
fact of West’s prior conviction, under Evidence Code section 1108,
without testimony about the underlying circumstances. (See
People v. Wesson (2006) 138 Cal.App.4th 959, 968-969.) This did
not make the uncharged offense wholly dissimilar or reduce its
probative value to nil. (Id. at p. 969.) If West wished to
emphasize the dissimilarity of his prior offense, he could have
presented evidence on that issue. (See ibid.)

The prior rape was not too remote to demonstrate
propensity simply because it occurred more than 10 years before
the charged offense. (People v. Branch (2001) 91 Cal.App.4th
274, 284-285.) As the trial court noted, West was incarcerated
during a significant part of the 11-year gap between the charged
offenses and his conviction on the uncharged rape. This
circumstance mitigates any potential remoteness. (See People v.
Dejourney (2011) 192 Cal.App.4th 1091, 1106.)

“Evidence of previous criminal history inevitably has some
prejudicial effect. But under [Evidence Code] section 1108, this
circumstance alone is no reason to exclude it.” (Loy, supra, 52
Cal.4th at p. 62.) Here, the evidence was presented in an
efficient fashion and without any inflammatory detail. In fact,
the circumstance that West had been convicted of the 2003
rape—having pled guilty to the charge—“strongly supports” its
admission. (Loy, supra, at p. 61.) “His commission of those
crimes had already been established and was thus certain, and
[West] bore no new burden of defending against the charges. The
jury would not be tempted to convict him of the charged crime to
punish him for the earlier crimes.” (Ibid.)

10
The record shows that the court carefully considered the
evidence, appropriately found that the fact of West’s prior rape
conviction had significant probative value and took steps to
minimize any confusion by excluding the conduct underlying his
conviction. West fails to demonstrate the trial court abused its
considerable discretion in admitting the evidence.

B.

West also argues that the prosecutor committed numerous
instances of misconduct, and that such misconduct in
combination with the purported evidentiary error was
prejudicial. We have rejected the notion that the trial court
abused its discretion in admitting West’s prior rape conviction.
We deem any prosecutorial error harmless.

1.

The United States Constitution is violated when a
prosecutor’s conduct is so egregious that it infects the trial with
such unfairness as to make the resulting conviction a denial of
due process. (People v. Flores (2020) 9 Cal.5th 371, 403.) A
prosecutor’s lesser misconduct will violate state law “ ‘ “if it
involves the use of deceptive or reprehensible methods to
persuade the . . . jury.” ’ ” (Ibid.)

2.

In addition to excluding all evidence of the underlying
conduct of West’s 2003 rape conviction, the trial court also ruled
that, if West testified, the prosecutor could impeach him with
three of his prior felony convictions, but that the convictions were
to be sanitized and referred to only as “felony [convictions] of
moral turpitude.”

Despite these rulings, the prosecutor stated (in the People’s
opening statement): “[Y]ou are also allowed to consider prior
sexual misconduct in this case. [¶] And you will hear that in 2003

11
Mr. West did suffer convictions for forcible rape, which is what
he’s charged with here, as well as first-degree robbery. I will not
ask you to convict him on that alone, but I will ask you to
consider that as a factor when it’s time.” (Italics added.)

At the conclusion of the prosecutor’s statement and outside
the presence of the jury, defense counsel objected, arguing that
the prosecutor’s reference to West’s 2003 robbery conviction—
both orally and in a Power Point slide shown to the jury—was in
violation of the court’s rulings. The trial court agreed. Although
the trial court denied defense counsel’s motion for a mistrial, it
admonished the jury to disregard the prosecutor’s reference to a
2003 robbery conviction. Specifically, the trial court instructed
the jury (as defense counsel requested): “[Y]esterday during
opening statements you heard the [prosecutor] . . . mention that
the defendant had a conviction for a violation of a fi[r]st degree
robbery. This was in violation of a previous Court order. [¶] You
are not to consider for any reason the first degree robbery. Do
not consider it for any reason whatsoever.”

Later, while presenting the People’s case in rebuttal, the
Prosecutor played an unredacted portion of Sergeant Creed’s
interview with West that referenced him having been previously
arrested and convicted. Although the record before us does not
include defense counsel’s apparent objection or request for
admonition, the trial court later admonished the jury: “[D]uring
a portion of the playing of the audio, a portion of the audio was
inadvertently played, which indicated, along the lines of the
inspector saying, and the truth is that you have been arrested
and convicted. That portion of the audio was inadvertently
played. However, that portion of the audio relates to evidence
that you have already been presented in this case. You are not to
speculate to it being anything beyond that. So I’m instructing
you to not use that portion . . . for anything in any portion of your
deliberation.”

12
3.

West contends that, in the above instances, the prosecutor
committed prejudicial misconduct by exposing the jury to prior
conviction information that they otherwise would not have
learned.

We agree that—by referring to West’s 2003 robbery
conviction—the prosecutor violated the trial court’s pretrial
evidentiary ruling, and thereby committed misconduct,
regardless of whether the violation was intentional. (People v.
Friend (2009) 47 Cal.4th 1, 33; People v. Crew (2003) 31 Cal.4th
822, 839.)

In the second instance of purported misconduct, the record
is insufficient to demonstrate that West preserved his argument
by raising a specific objection and requesting admonition. (See
People v. Dykes (2009) 46 Cal.4th 731, 760 (Dykes) [“ ‘ “a
defendant may not complain on appeal of prosecutorial
misconduct unless in a timely fashion—and on the same
ground—the defendant made an assignment of misconduct and
requested that the jury be admonished to disregard the
impropriety” ’ ” (italics added)].) Nor does West demonstrate that
objection may be excused because it would have been futile, or
admonition would not have cured the harm. (Ibid.)

In any event, any error is harmless (whether considered
individually or cumulatively) on the record before us. A
defendant’s conviction will be reversed for prosecutorial
misconduct if “it is reasonably probable that a result more
favorable to the defendant would have been reached without the
misconduct.” (People v. Crew, supra, 31 Cal.4th at p. 839.)

First, in both instances, the trial court quickly gave
admonitions that explicitly instructed the jury to disregard the
prosecutor’s references to any prior conviction other than the
2003 rape conviction. With respect to the prosecutor’s opening

13
statement, the trial court also repeatedly instructed the jury that
“what the attorneys say is not evidence.” We must presume that
the jury followed these instructions “even where supposedly
‘improper inflammatory attacks’ are at issue.” (People v.
Daveggio and Michaud (2018) 4 Cal.5th 790, 857, 861; People v.
Avila (2006) 38 Cal.4th 491, 571-574.)

Second, the evidence against West was, if not
overwhelming, very strong. “ ‘ “Improper evidence of prior
offense results in reversal only where the appellate court’s review
of the trial record reveals a closely balanced state of the
evidence.” ’ ” (In re James B. (2003) 109 Cal.App.4th 862, 875.)
Even though the jury apparently did not believe the prosecution
had proved West guilty (beyond a reasonable doubt) of burglary,
making criminal threats, or of multiple counts of rape, this is not
such a case.

Catherine’s testimony (regarding the counts on which West
was convicted) was corroborated by the accounts she gave to her
neighbor, the 911 dispatcher, Officer Garcia, and Sergeant
Creed.4 Catherine’s account was also corroborated by West’s
prior rape conviction and the physical evidence. On the other
hand, West’s testimony—that he and Catherine had consensual
sex, that he was unable to maintain an erection, and that he
thereafter only slapped Catherine and restrained her hand—is in
conflict not only with the physical evidence but also with his own
initial prior statements to police.

Third, neither fleeting reference to West’s criminal history
is particularly prejudicial when compared to the Evidence Code
section 1108 evidence, which was properly admitted to show

4Catherine was impeached with her prior arrest, in
December 2013, for falsely identifying herself to a police officer.
She also admitted her own history of violent behavior, including a
conviction for misdemeanor domestic violence and an arrest for
allegedly pulling a knife on a stranger on a bus.
14
West’s disposition to commit sex offenses. Indeed, in his own
appellate briefs, West maintains that the prosecutor’s misconduct
was prejudicial only in conjunction with the purported
evidentiary error. Having already concluded that West’s prior
rape conviction was not admitted in error, we also decide that the
impact of the prosecutor’s brief reference to West’s 2003 robbery
conviction was negligible.

On this record, it is not reasonably probable the jury would
have reached a more favorable result absent the prosecutorial
error. For the same reasons, the trial court did not abuse its
discretion in denying West’s motion for a mistrial. (People v.
Ayala (2000) 23 Cal.4th 225, 283 [standard of review].) West’s
chances of receiving a fair trial were not irreparably damaged.
(Ibid.)

4.

West complains of other instances of purported
prosecutorial misconduct, which we need not address in detail.
We have reviewed the record surrounding each instance and
conclude that, by failing to raise prosecutorial misconduct
objections and request corresponding admonitions below, West
forfeited these claims on appeal. (Dykes, supra, 46 Cal.4th at pp.
763, 766.) Furthermore, any misconduct was harmless (either
considered alone or cumulatively) for the reasons stated above
and because the trial court sustained other objections, gave
requested admonishments, and/or granted motions to strike in
every complained of instance. “A party generally is not
prejudiced by a question to which an objection has been
sustained.” (People v. Johnson (2003) 109 Cal.App.4th 1230,
1236; accord, Dykes, at p. 763.)

C.

Next, West insists the trial court erred in denying his
motion to continue sentencing so that he could prepare a motion

15
for discovery under the California Racial Justice Act of 2020
(Racial Justice Act; §§ 745, 1473, subd. (f), 1473.7, subd. (a)(3)).
We disagree.

1.

Effective January 1, 2021, the Racial Justice Act permits a
criminal defendant to challenge a conviction or sentence on the
ground that it was obtained “on the basis of race, ethnicity, or
national origin.” (§ 745, subd. (a); Stats. 2020, ch. 317, § 3.5.)
“The Act sets forth four categories of conduct, any of which, if
proved, is enough to ‘establish’ a violation of section 745,
subdivision (a).” (Young v. Superior Court (2022) 79 Cal.App.5th
138, 147 (Young).) A defendant may establish a violation by
proving, by a preponderance of the evidence, that “[a] longer or
more severe sentence was imposed on the defendant than was
imposed on other similarly situated individuals convicted of the
same offense, and longer or more severe sentences were more
frequently imposed for that offense on people that share the
defendant’s race, . . . than on defendants of other races, . . . in the
county where the sentence was imposed.” (§ 745, subd. (a)(4)(A).)

The statute also provides a discovery mechanism: “A
defendant may file a motion requesting disclosure to the defense
of all evidence relevant to a potential violation of subdivision (a)
in the possession or control of the state. A motion filed under this
section shall describe the type of records or information the
defendant seeks. Upon a showing of good cause, the court shall
order the records to be released.” (§ 745, subd. (d).) “[I]n order to
establish good cause for discovery under the Racial Justice Act, a
defendant is required only to advance a plausible factual
foundation, based on specific facts, that a violation of the Racial
Justice Act ‘could or might have occurred’ in his case.” (Young,
supra, 79 Cal.App.5th at p. 159.)

“[A]lthough the plausible justification standard is
‘minimal,’ it must still be ‘based on specific facts.’ [Citation.]
16
Thus, preparing a discovery motion under the [Act] necessarily
entails a fairly thorough review of the trial record for any
remarks or conduct by the trial judge, attorneys, experts, jurors,
and law enforcement officers that may plausibly support the
conclusion that a . . . violation ‘ “could or might have occurred” in
[the] case.’ ” (People v. Garcia (2022) 85 Cal.App.5th 290, 297
(Garcia).)

Continuances of any criminal hearing “shall be granted
only upon a showing of good cause.” (§ 1050, subd. (e).) “Whether
good cause exists is a question for the trial court’s discretion but
requires at a minimum that the party seeking continuance
demonstrate it has prepared for the hearing with due diligence.”
(People v. Johnson (2013) 218 Cal.App.4th 938, 942, italics
added.) The party challenging the trial court’s continuance
ruling bears the heavy burden of establishing an abuse of
discretion. (People v. Beames (2007) 40 Cal.4th 907, 920.)

2.

The jury returned its verdicts on August 30, 2021. About
five weeks later, on October 5, 2021, the trial court found West’s
prior conviction allegations true, and set West’s sentencing
hearing for December 10, 2021—over the People’s objection that
delaying sentencing was unfair to Catherine. In doing so, the
trial court cautioned West: “I have agreed . . . to give you a little
additional time, based on [defense counsel’s] concerns [about your
age and COVID-19 conditions at San Quentin], and . . . based on
the amount of research and information that will be necessary to
provide a thorough sentencing memorandum. . . . I need you to
understand that [December 10] is the date for sentencing. [¶] . . .
[¶] . . . [I]f you do not appear on that date, I will proceed with the
sentencing without you being present.”

In its presentencing report (received on October 27, 2021),
the probation department recommended West be sentenced to an
aggregate term of 176 years and four months to life. Sentencing
17
was continued, on West’s request, to January 28, 2022, and then
to February 10, 2022. In the interim, the People filed their
sentencing memorandum, on January 19, 2022, which requested
imposition of an aggregate sentence of 76 years and four months
to life.

In his sentencing brief, West asked the trial court to
dismiss or strike all three of his prior strikes, pursuant to section
1385 and People v. Superior Court (Romero) (1996) 13 Cal.4th 497
(Romero). West also argued that imposition of the life sentence
mandated by either the one strike law or the habitual sex
offender law—or any sentence that totaled more than 20 years—
would constitute cruel and unusual punishment given his age
(68) at that time.

Two days before the date then set for sentencing, the trial
court issued its tentative ruling—indicating the court’s intent to
sentence West to an aggregate term of 75 years to life. On
February 10, 2022, West refused to appear at the sentencing
hearing. Sentencing was once again continued to March 3, 2022.
West was again ordered present, and counsel was ordered to
notify him that sentencing would proceed in his absence if he did
not voluntarily appear on that date.

A little more than a week before the sentencing hearing,
defense counsel filed a motion for continuance, in which West—
who is African American—requested six weeks to “investigate . . .
[racially] disparate sentences.” The People opposed the
continuance request, noting that sentencing had now been set
and continued several times—at great emotional cost to
Catherine. The prosecutor also maintained that defense counsel
had over five months to file a motion for discovery and did not
present a reasonable excuse for delaying the filing.

The trial court denied West’s motion to continue
sentencing—on the grounds that it was untimely and
unsupported by good cause. Sentencing went forward as
18
calendared, on March 3, 2022, after West waived his personal
presence (§§ 977, subd. (b), 1043, subd. (d)).

At sentencing, the trial court partially granted West’s
Romero motion and dismissed the strike for the 2003 robbery, but
otherwise denied the motion. Because West had been previously
convicted of forcible rape in 2003, the trial court determined that
his sentence on count one was 25 years to life, under the habitual
sexual offender law (§ 667.71, subds. (a), (b), (c)(1)) and stayed his
sentence under the one strike law (and remaining counts). (See
People v. McQueen (2008) 160 Cal.App.4th 27, 38.) The trial
court tripled the 25-years-to-life term under the three strikes law
(§§ 667, subds. (d)-(e), 1170.12, subd. (c)(2)(A)(i)) due to its
previous findings that he had suffered two prior strikes.

3.

The trial court did not abuse its discretion by denying
West’s request for a continuance.

Defense counsel did not present a reasonable excuse for
delaying the filing of a motion for discovery approximately five
months after entry of the jury’s verdicts. In her declaration,
defense counsel stated that she began looking into a claim under
the Racial Justice Act after receiving the trial court’s indicated
sentence, on February 8, 2022. Defense counsel stated that,
although it already had information suggesting a racially
disparate pattern of arrests and charging for sex crimes in San
Francisco, the defense needed more time to investigate racial
disparity in sentencing.

This was not sufficient to establish due diligence. After all,
the Racial Justice Act had been enacted more than a year earlier.
(Stats. 2020, ch. 317, § 3.5.) And defense counsel had known of
West’s vulnerability to an extremely long three strikes sentence
for approximately five months. The trial court’s sentencing
discretion was limited. (See §§ 667.61, subds. (a), (g), 667.71,

19
subds. (b), (d); People v. Vargas (2014) 59 Cal.4th 635, 641; People
v. Hammer (2003) 30 Cal.4th 756, 761; People v. Murphy (2001)
25 Cal.4th 136, 159–160; People v. Snow (2003) 105 Cal.App.4th
271, 281, 283.) Despite all this, defense counsel chose not to
pursue discovery under the Racial Justice Act until immediately
before the sentencing hearing, after the hearing had already been
repeatedly delayed.

Additionally, in California, victims have a right to a prompt
conclusion of the case. (Cal. Const., art. I, § 28, subd. (b)(9);
§ 679.02, subd. (a)(10).) By the time of the continued sentencing
hearing, more than seven years had elapsed since the commission
of the charged offenses. On this record, the trial court acted well
within its discretion in denying West’s motion for a continuance.
(See People v. Alexander (2010) 49 Cal.4th 846, 935.)

West’s reliance on Garcia, supra, 85 Cal.App.5th 290 is
misplaced. In Garcia, our colleagues in division three reversed a
trial court order denying a continuance of sentencing that was
requested, in part, for investigation of a Racial Justice Act claim.
(Id. at pp. 294, 297.) In that case, new counsel was appointed for
the defendant on remand for resentencing. And counsel had less
than a week after her appointment “to familiarize herself with
the case, prepare the sentencing brief, and marshal facts for and
prepare a motion for discovery under the [Racial Justice Act].”
(Id. at p. 297.) The Garcia court concluded that the one-week
period was insufficient and that the “defendant should have been
given a reasonable opportunity to review the trial record and
gather relevant information to prepare a motion for discovery.”
(Ibid.)

Here, in contrast, defense counsel was not new to the case
and had approximately five months to prepare and file a motion
for discovery, or to otherwise advance the requisite “plausible
factual foundation” for a claim under the Racial Justice Act.
(Young, supra, 79 Cal.App.5th at p. 159.)

20
D.

West also maintains that the trial court abused its
purported discretion, under recent amendments to section 1385,
by tripling his 25-years-to-life term on count one. He is wrong.

1.

Effective January 1, 2022, Senate Bill No. 81 (2021–2022
Reg. Sess.) amended section 1385 to add subdivision (c). (Stats.
2021, ch. 721, § 1; People v. Olay (2023) 98 Cal.App.5th 60, 64.)
Section 1385, subdivision (c)(1) provides: “Notwithstanding any
other law, the court shall dismiss an enhancement if it is in the
furtherance of justice to do so, except if dismissal of that
enhancement is prohibited by any initiative statute.” (Italics
added.) Section 1385, subdivision (c)(2) provides that, in
determining whether to dismiss an enhancement “under this
subdivision,” the court must “consider and afford great weight to”
nine listed mitigating circumstances if proven by the defendant
(id., subds. (c)(2)(A)–(I)), “unless the court finds that dismissal of
the enhancement would endanger public safety.” (Id., subd. (c)(2),
italics added.) One of the mitigating circumstances is: “The
application of an enhancement could result in a sentence of over
20 years. In this instance, the enhancement shall be dismissed.”
(Id., subd. (c)(2)(C), italics added.)

West argued, in his sentencing brief, that dismissal of all
three of his strikes was required under section 1385, subdivision
(c)(2)(C). The People disagreed.

2.

Although West concedes that the trial court exercised its
preexisting Romero, supra, 13 Cal.4th 497 discretion to dismiss
one of his strikes (for the 2003 robbery conviction), West argues
(as he did in his sentencing brief below) that—absent a showing
that it would endanger public safety—dismissal of all three of his
strikes was required under section 1385, subdivision (c)(2)(C). In
21
other words, he insists that the trial court necessarily abused its
discretion by declining to dismiss the remaining prior strike
allegations under section 1385, subdivision (c)(2)(C). The People
have the better argument.

This division recently held, after extensive review of Senate
Bill No. 81’s legislative history, that section 1385, subdivision (c),
does not apply to this situation because the three strikes law is
an alternative sentencing scheme, not an enhancement. (People
v. Olay, supra, 98 Cal.App.5th at pp. 67, 69; accord, People v.
Burke (2023) 89 Cal.App.5th 237, 242-244 [“plain language of
subdivision (c) of section 1385 applies only to an ‘enhancement,’
and the Three Strikes law is not an enhancement”].) West
presents no reason for us to reconsider that ruling. Accordingly,
West fails to show any abuse of discretion.

DISPOSITION

The judgment is affirmed.

BURNS, J.
WE CONCUR:

JACKSON, P. J.
CHOU, J.

People v. West (A164873)

22

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.