CourtListener 2803434•Vector Resources, Inc. v. Baker CA4/1
Testo completo
Filed 5/26/15
CERTIFIED FOR PUBLICATION
COURT OF APPEAL, FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION ONE
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
VECTOR RESOURCES, INC., D065224
Plaintiff and Appellant,
v. (Super. Ct. No. 37-2012-00097974-
CU-MC-CTL)
CHRISTINE BAKER, as Director, etc., et al.,
Defendant and Respondent.
APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of San Diego County, Joel R.
Wohlfeil, Judge. Affirmed.
Sheppard, Mullin, Richter & Hampton, Richard M. Freeman and Matthew S.
McConnell for Plaintiff and Appellant.
Christopher Jagard and John J. Korbol for Defendants and Respondents.
This action arises out of a determination by the Department of Industrial Relations
(the Department) that plaintiff Vector Resources, Inc. (Vector) failed to pay the
appropriate prevailing wages to its workers on a public works project for the San Diego
Unified School District. Specifically, the Director of Industrial Relations (the Director)
issued a decision in which she found that Vector underpaid its employees by failing to
1
pay a higher "shift differential" rate for work performed during shifts commencing after
12:00 noon. The director's decision was based on regulatory language in a document
entitled "Important Notice To Awarding Bodies And Other Interested Parties Regarding
Shift Differential Pay In The Director's General Prevailing Wage Determinations" (the
Important Notice), which was posted on the Department's Web site. The Important
Notice addresses shift differential pay for various crafts used on public works projects,
and is augmented by additional regulatory language in a "Note" that the Department
places on the cover page of prevailing wage shift provisions. The parties refer to this
Note as "the Stamp."1
Vector filed a declaratory relief action against the Department, seeking a
declaration that the Important Notice and Stamp are invalid and unenforceable as
"underground regulations" because they were not promulgated in compliance with the
notice and hearing requirements of the Administrative Procedure Act (APA). (Gov.
Code, § 11340 et seq.)2 Vector and the Department filed cross-motions for summary
1 Presumably, the parties refer to this Note as the Stamp because Vector alleged in
its operative second amended complaint that "since approximately 2006, the
[Department] has 'stamped' [the] 'Note' on the cover page of shift provisions . . . ."
2 "The APA establishes the procedures by which state agencies may adopt
regulations. The agency must give the public notice of its proposed regulatory action
(Gov. Code, §§ 11346.4, 11346.5); issue a complete text of the proposed regulation with
a statement of the reasons for it (Gov. Code, § 11346.2, subds. (a), (b)); give interested
parties an opportunity to comment on the proposed regulation (Gov. Code, § 11346.8);
respond in writing to public comments (Gov. Code, §§ 11346.8, subd. (a), 11346.9); and
forward a file of all materials on which the agency relied in the regulatory process to the
Office of Administrative Law (Gov. Code, § 11347.3, subd. (b)), which reviews the
2
judgment, based largely on stipulated facts. The court granted the Department's motion
on the ground that under Government Code section 11340.9, subdivision (g), the
Important Notice and the Stamp are exempt from the notice and hearing requirements of
the APA because they are part of an overall prevailing wage determination process that
constitutes "rate setting."
Vector contends the summary judgment in favor of the Department must be
reversed because (1) the Department admitted that the shift premium rule is a regulation,
(2) the Department admitted that that regulation was not adopted in compliance with the
APA, (3) the Department failed to prove that the shift premium regulation establishes or
fixes rates within the meaning of Government Code section 11340.9, subdivision (g), (4)
the court erred in failing to specifically cite the evidence it relied on to grant summary
judgment, (5) the court's written order ignored the law and the admissible evidence, and
(6) the Department's motion relied upon inadmissible evidence. We affirm.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
A. Factual Background
The factual background is largely based on facts to which the parties stipulated in
support of their cross-motions for summary judgment.
Workers employed on public works projects in California are entitled to be paid
prevailing wages. The Department determines the prevailing rate of per diem wages.
Prevailing wages are specific to the county where the work is to be performed and the
regulation for consistency with the law, clarity, and necessity (Gov. Code, §§ 11349.1,
11349.3)." (Tidewater Marine Western, Inc. v. Bradshaw (1996) 14 Cal.4th 557, 568.)
3
particular craft, classification, and type of work involved. Contractors must use the
prevailing wage determinations in effect on the bid advertisement date of the public
works project.
When the Department determines that the regular straight-time hourly rate within
a collective bargaining agreement is prevailing for a craft, classification, and locality, the
Department may adopt the collective bargaining agreement by reference. Over 90
percent of the Department's prevailing wage determinations are based on collective
bargaining agreements.
The Department regularly issues prevailing wage determinations for shift work
applicable to a craft, classification, or type of work, in connection with the general
prevailing wage determinations. In 2002, the Director issued an Important Notice
regarding shift differential pay. The Important Notice states:
"The Director's General Prevailing Wage Determinations includes
shift differential pay for various crafts used on public works projects.
This notice is to clarify the worker's eligibility to receive the shift
differential pay when working on a public works project. Please
note that not all crafts have shift differential pay published in the
Director's General Prevailing Wage Determinations. [¶] When a
worker is required to work a regular shift, he/she must be paid the
applicable craft rate from the Director's General Prevailing Wage
Determinations for the construction activity he/she is performing.
However, when a worker is required to work a shift outside of
normal working hours, he/she must be paid the shift differential pay
according to the shift he/she is working. For example if only one
shift is utilized for the day, and the work being performed is during
the hours typically considered to be swing (second) shift or graveyard
(third) shift, the worker employed during the hours typically
considered to be a swing shift or graveyard shift must be paid the shift
differential pay for the shift he/she is working. If multiple shifts are
used for the day, the worker working on the second or third shift must
be paid according to the shift he/she is working." (Italics added.)
4
In 2006 the Director began to place the Stamp on the cover page of prevailing
wage shift provisions. The Stamp states:
"Note: The shift provisions provided in the following pages provide
guidance on the work hours that are applicable to each shift. Shift
differential pay is required and will be enforced during each
applicable shift where shift differential pay is in the determinations.
Any shift provisions restricting the work hours for a particular shift
for a type of work will not be enforced on public works. However,
if work is performed during hours typically associated with a 2nd or
3rd shift the appropriate shift rate of pay is required. Shift
differential pay shall not apply to work during traditional shift hour
(swing or grave) if the determination includes a footnote that
indicates that the non-shift rate may be paid for a special single shift.
Please note the exemptions in California Code of Regulations
Section 16200 (a)(3)(F) do not waive the shift differential pay.
These regulatory exemptions only apply to overtime pay. Overtime
pay shall be required in accordance with the determination and
Labor Code Section 1810 through 1815." (Italics added.)
The Department issued the Important Notice and the Stamp without publishing a
notice of intent to engage in rule making, inviting public comment, or holding a public
hearing as the APA requires before the adoption of an administrative regulation, unless
an exemption under Government Code section 11340.9 applies.
The Department maintains a Web site where the current prevailing wage
determinations are available to the public. Public works contractors look to the Web site
for the particular prevailing wage rates in effect at the time of the bid advertisement date
for a public works project. For nearly all of the prevailing wage determinations posted
on the Department's Web site, the Department also posts specific provisions of the
applicable collective bargaining agreements regarding holidays, scope of work, and travel
5
and subsistence. Some, but not all, prevailing wage determinations also include shift
rates. For those determinations, the Department also posts "associated" shift provisions.
The Important Notice is posted on the Department's Web site as one of at least 112
other "important notices" that clarify, explain, and provide guidance to the public
regarding various aspects of prevailing wage determinations. The language of the Stamp
appearing on the cover page of prevailing shift provisions is also posted on the
Department's Web site.
B. Procedural Background
This case arises out of a prevailing wage enforcement action that the San Diego
Unified School District brought against Vector. In that proceeding, the Director
determined that Vector underpaid its employees on a public works project, by failing to pay
the workers at a higher shift differential rate for work performed during a shift that began
after 12:00 noon. Vector sought judicial review of the Director's decision by filing a
petition for writ of mandate in superior court and the present action for declaratory relief.
In the present action, Vector filed a second amended complaint for declaratory
relief against the Director and the Department (defendants) seeking a declaration that "(a)
the [Department] impermissibly failed to comply with the APA, Labor Code section 1773,
and the supporting regulations, when issuing the rules established by the [Important]
Notice and the Stamp[;] (b) the [Important] Notice and the Stamp constitute invalid
underground regulations[;] and (c) the [Important] Notice and the Stamp are not
procedures that comply with the requirements of Labor Code [section] 1773."
6
The parties filed a stipulation to file cross-motions for summary judgment, stating
they agreed "that the Court may be able to dispose of the issues in this case via summary
judgment."3 In its summary judgment motion, Vector argued that the rule requiring the
payment of shift premiums set forth in the Important Notice and the Stamp was a
regulation that must comply with the notice and hearing requirements of the APA.
Because these requirements were not met, Vector asserted that the Important Notice and
Stamp were invalid "underground regulations."
The Department conceded that the shift premium rule was a regulation and that the
notice and hearing requirements of the APA were not met. However, the Department
argued that the shift premium regulations were exempt from the APA as a "regulation that
establishes or fixes rates, prices, or tariffs," under Government Code section 11340.9,
subdivision (g).
The court granted summary judgment in favor of the Director and against Vector.
The court decided the challenged regulations constituted rate-setting that was exempt
from the APA's rulemaking requirements under Government Code section 11340.9,
subdivision (g), stating:
"[T]he APA contains an exception for a regulation that 'establishes
or fixes rates, prices, or tariffs.' [Citation.] Wage determinations set
'rates' such that these determinations are exempt from the notice and
hearing provisions of the APA. [Citation.] Moreover, the
[Department] exercises delegated quasi-legislative power such that
there is no constitutional requirement that it hold hearings or give
3 The parties stipulated that the defendants' opposition to Vector's summary
judgment motion would serve as their moving papers for their cross-motion.
7
notice before making wage determinations. [Citation.] As the wage
determination process is exempted from the hearing requirements of
the APA, a coverage determination, as an integral part of that
process, is also exempted. [Citation.] There is no conflict in the
evidence to create a [triable] issue of material fact to warrant any
conclusion [other] than that (a) Defendants did not impermissibly
fail to comply with the APA, Labor Code section 1773, and the
supporting regulations when, when issuing the rules established by
the 2002 [Important] Notice and the Stamp[;] and (b) [t]he 2002
[Important] Notice and the Stamp do not constitute invalid,
underground regulations."
DISCUSSION
I. STANDARD OF REVIEW
A motion for summary judgment or adjudication must be granted when there is no
triable issue of material fact and the moving party is entitled to judgment as a matter of
law. (Code Civ. Proc., § 437c, subd. (c).) Summary judgment is appropriate in a
declaratory relief action when only legal issues are presented for the court's
determination. (Gafcon, Inc. v. Ponsor & Associates (2002) 98 Cal.App.4th 1388, 1401-
1402.) The defendant's burden in a declaratory relief action "is to establish the plaintiff is
not entitled to a declaration in its favor. It may do this by establishing (1) the sought-
after declaration is legally incorrect; (2) undisputed facts do not support the premise for
the sought-after declaration; or (3) the issue is otherwise not one that is appropriate for
declaratory relief." (Id. at p. 1402.)
"We review a summary judgment or summary adjudication ruling de novo to
determine whether there is a triable issue as to any material fact and whether the moving
party is entitled to judgment as a matter of law. [Citation.] 'In practical effect, we
assume the role of a trial court and apply the same rules and standards which govern a
8
trial court's determination of a motion for summary judgment.' " (Mills v. U.S. Bank
(2008) 166 Cal.App.4th 871, 895.)
II. ANALYSIS
A. Applicable Authority
"The California Prevailing Wage Law is a comprehensive statutory scheme
designed to enforce minimum wage standards on construction projects funded in whole
or in part with public funds. [Citations.] [¶] Under the prevailing wage law, all workers
employed on public works costing more than $1,000 must be paid not less than the
general prevailing rate of per diem wages as determined by the Director . . . for work of a
similar character and not less than the general prevailing per diem wage for holiday and
overtime work." (Road Sprinkler Fitters Local Union No. 669 v. G & G Fire Sprinklers,
Inc. (2002) 102 Cal.App.4th 765, 776; Lab. Code, § 1771.) "The central purpose of the
prevailing wage law is to protect and benefit employees on public works projects." (Ibid.;
Lusardi Construction Co. v. Aubry (1992) 1 Cal.4th 976, 985.) "The Department's
authority pertaining to prevailing wage determinations is quasi-legislative and it has
legislative discretion with respect to such decisions." (California Slurry Seal Assn. v.
Department of Industrial Relations (2002) 98 Cal.App.4th 651, 662.)
B. The Important Notice and Stamp Are Exempt from the Notice and Hearing
Requirements of the APA
A prevailing wage determination is exempt from the notice and hearing
requirements of the APA if it is "[a] regulation that establishes or fixes rates, prices, or
tariffs." (Gov. Code, § 11340.9, subd. (g).) Vector contends the Department does not fix
9
or set any actual prevailing rates, including shift premium rates; rather, the Department
only determines the prevailing rates. However, the prevailing wage statutes reveal that
the Department or Director's "determining" prevailing rates is semantically equivalent to
"fixing" or "establishing" rates. Labor Code section 1773 provides, in relevant part:
"In determining the rates, the Director of Industrial Relations shall ascertain and
consider the applicable wage rates established by collective bargaining agreements
and the rates that may have been predetermined for federal public works, within
the locality and in the nearest labor market area. Where the rates do not constitute
the rates actually prevailing in the locality, the director shall obtain and consider
further data from the labor organizations and employers or employer associations
concerned, including the recognized collective bargaining representatives for the
particular craft, classification, or type of work involved. The rate fixed for each
craft, classification, or type of work shall be not less than the prevailing rate paid
in the craft, classification, or type of work. [¶] If the director determines that the
rate of prevailing wage for any craft, classification, or type of worker is the rate
established by a collective bargaining agreement, the director may adopt that rate
by reference as provided for in the collective bargaining agreement and that
determination shall be effective for the life of the agreement or until the director
determines that another rate should be adopted." (Italics added.)
The italicized words in Labor Code section 1773 show that the terms "determine" and
"fix" are used interchangeably and have the same meaning in the statute–i.e., the
Director's determination of a prevailing wage rate fixes (i.e., establishes) that rate.
Labor Code section 1773.9 similarly illustrates that there is no semantic difference
between "establishing" a prevailing wage rate and "determining" such a rate. Labor Code
section 1773.9, subdivision (a) states: "The Director of Industrial Relations shall use the
methodology set forth in subdivision (b) to determine the general prevailing rate of per
diem wages in the locality in which the public work is to be performed." (Italics added.)
Labor Code section 1773.9, subdivision (b) states:
10
"The general prevailing rate of per diem wages includes all of the following: [¶]
(1) The basic hourly wage rate being paid to a majority of workers engaged in the
particular craft, classification, or type of work within the locality and in the nearest
labor market area, if a majority of the workers is paid at a single rate. If no single
rate is being paid to a majority of the workers, then the single rate being paid to
the greatest number of workers, or modal rate, is prevailing. If a modal rate
cannot be determined, then the director shall establish an alternative rate,
consistent with the methodology for determining the modal rate, by considering
the appropriate collective bargaining agreements, federal rates, rates in the nearest
labor market area, or other data such as wage survey data. [¶] (2) Other employer
payments included in per diem wages pursuant to [Labor Code] Section 1773.1
and as included as part of the total hourly wage rate from which the basic hourly
wage rate was derived. In the event the total hourly wage rate does not include
any employer payments, the director shall establish a prevailing employer
payment rate by the same procedure set forth in paragraph (1)." (Italics added.)
Based on the Legislature's interchangeable use of the terms "determine," "establish," and
"fix," we conclude that in "determining" prevailing wage rates, the Department
"establishes [and] fixes rates" within the meaning of Government Code section 11340.9,
subdivision (g).
We further conclude that the Important Notice and Stamp both constitute
regulations that "establish" rates within the meaning Government Code section 11340.9,
subdivision (g), notwithstanding the fact that they do not establish or fix a shift
differential rate for a particular craft, classification, or type of work within a specific
locality. The Important Notice states that "[t]he Director's General Prevailing Wage
Determinations includes shift differential pay for various crafts used on public works
projects[,]" and clarifies that "when a worker is required to work a shift outside of normal
working hours, he/she must be paid the shift differential pay according to the shift he/she
is working." (Italics added.) The Stamp similarly provides that "[s]hift differential pay is
required and will be enforced during each applicable shift where shift differential pay is
11
in the determinations." (Italics added.) Thus, the Important Notice and Stamp establish
prevailing wage rates for shifts outside of normal working hours–i.e., they establish that
workers must be paid the applicable shift differential pay for the shift he or she is working.
As integral parts of the prevailing wage determination process, the Important Notice and
Stamp are exempt from the notice and hearing requirements of the APA. (Winzler &
Kelly v. Department of Industrial Relations (1981) 121 Cal.App.3d 120, 128 [the overall
wage determination process and integral parts of that process are exempt from the prior
hearing requirements of the APA].)
Vector relies heavily on this court's opinion in Division of Labor Standards
Enforcement v. Ericsson Information Systems, Inc. (1990) 221 Cal.App.3d 114 (Ericsson)
in arguing that the Important Notice and Stamp do not fall within the rate setting
exemption of Government Code section 11340.9. In Ericsson, a contract between the
University of California of San Diego and a contractor for installation of a telephone
system required the contractor to pay prevailing wages. (Ericsson, supra, 221
Cal.App.3d at p. 120.) However, because no prevailing wage rate had been determined
for communications technicians who worked on the project, the Division of Labor
Standards Enforcement (DLSE) applied the rate that had been determined for "inside
wiremen," the classification that DLSE deemed to be the most similar to communications
technicians. (Id. at p. 121.) The contractor contended the DLSE's policy of applying a
similar classification to workers who were not covered by a published classification
constituted a rule subject to the notice and hearing requirements of the APA. (Id. at p.
127.)
12
The Ericsson court agreed that the DLSE's policy was a rule that "should be
promulgated under the APA." (Ericsson, supra, 221 Cal.App.3d at p. 128.) The court
concluded the DLSE's policy was not "a step in the process of prevailing rate
determinations so as to be exempt from the APA . . . ." (Ibid.) Rather, the Ericsson court
decided that the policy created "a standard for the application of already established rates,
to cover a situation not addressed in the statute or regulations . . . ." (Ibid.) Vector
contends that like the policy at issue in Ericsson, the Important Notice and Stamp are
subject to the notice and hearing requirements of the APA because they create a general
standard or rule as to when and under what circumstances already existing shift premium
rates must be paid.
We conclude Ericsson is inapposite. The DLSE's policy at issue in Ericsson
applied established prevailing wage rates for a particular class of workers to a different
class of workers for whom no prevailing wage determination had been made–i.e., the
"already-established" rates had not been established for the workers to whom the DLSE
applied them. The DLSE's policy was not part of the overall rate determination process
because no such process had been implemented for those workers. In contrast, the
Important Notice and Stamp apply already-established shift differential rates to the
workers for whom those rates were established, clarifying the circumstances under which
those rates are to be applied. As part of the prevailing wage determination process for
those workers, the Important Notice and Stamp are exempt from the notice and hearing
requirements of the APA. (Winzler & Kelly v. Department of Industrial Relations, supra,
121 Cal.App.3d at p. 128.)
13
Even if the Important Notice and Stamp did not "fix" or "establish" rates within
the meaning of Government Code section 11340.9, subdivision (g), they are exempt from
the notice and hearing requirements of the APA under Labor Code section 1773.5,
subdivision (d), which became effective January 1, 2014 as part of the 2013 amendment
of Labor Code section 1773.5. (Stats. 2013, ch. 780 (S.B.377), § 3.)4 Labor Code
section 1773.5, subdivision (d) provides: "The director shall have quasi-legislative
authority to determine coverage of projects or types of work under the prevailing wage
laws of this chapter. A final determination on any administrative appeal is subject to
judicial review pursuant to Section 1085 of the Code of Civil Procedure. These
determinations and any determinations relating to the general prevailing rate of per diem
wages and the general prevailing rate for holiday, shift rate, and overtime work, shall be
exempt from the Administrative Procedure Act . . . ." (Italics added.)
We construe the term "shift rate" in the italicized statutory language as a reference
to the pay rate for shifts outside of normal working hours. Thus, Labor Code section
1773.5, subdivision (d) broadly exempts from the APA any determination relating to the
general prevailing rate for shifts outside of normal working hours. The Important Notice
and Stamp clearly are determinations by the Director that, at minimum, relate to, if not
establish or fix, shift differential pay rate (i.e., the rates for shifts outside of normal
4 Because declaratory relief operates prospectively to declare future rights (County
of San Diego v. State of California (2008) 164 Cal.App.4th 580, 607), "we apply the law
in effect at the time of review because that is the law under which the judicial declaration
will have effect." (City of Watsonville v. State Dept. of Health Services (2005) 133
Cal.App.4th 875, 885.)
14
working hours). Accordingly, the Important Notice and Stamp are exempt from the
notice and hearing requirements of the APA under Labor Code section 1773.5,
subdivision (d).5
DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed. The Department is awarded its costs on appeal.
NARES, Acting P. J.
WE CONCUR:
O'ROURKE, J.
IRION, J.
5 In light of our legal conclusion that the Important Notice and Stamp are exempt
from the notice and hearing requirements of the APA, we need not address Vector's
contentions that the court erred in failing to specifically cite the evidence it relied on to
grant summary judgment, the court's written order ignored admissible evidence, and the
Department's motion relied upon inadmissible evidence.
15
Ti chiedi come si applica questo testo alla tua situazione?
Consulenza gratuita, senza impegno
Descrivi la tua situazione. Il nostro team ti ricontatterà via e-mail per la tua consulenza.
Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude
Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.