CourtListener 10872143•People v. Romero CA6
Testo completo
Filed 6/8/26 P. v. Romero CA6
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not
certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been
certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SIXTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
THE PEOPLE, H053210
(Monterey County
Plaintiff and Respondent, Super. Ct. No. 19CR000358)
v.
JAIME DEMECIO ROMERO,
Defendant and Appellant.
In re JAIME DEMECIO ROMERO, H053790
(Monterey County
on Habeas Corpus. Super. Ct. No. 19CR000358)
Defendant Jaime Demecio Romero, a life prisoner, was convicted by a jury
of second degree murder. A codefendant, Alberto Sanchez Cortez, was convicted
of first degree murder and assault by a life prisoner.1 The trial court sentenced
Romero to a term of 45 years to life plus 16 years.
1
A different panel of this court affirmed Sanchez Cortez’s convictions.
(People v. Sanchez Cortez (Dec. 11, 2025, H052814) [nonpub. opn.].)
On appeal, Romero argues that his trial counsel was ineffective for failing
to seek to admit a purported suicide note written by Sanchez Cortez as a prior
consistent statement.2 We disagree.
As explained below, we need not address whether trial counsel’s failure to
seek admission of the note as a prior consistent statement was deficient
performance, because Romero cannot show a reasonable probability of a more
favorable outcome had trial counsel sought and obtained its admission. We will
affirm the judgment.
I. FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
A. Procedural background
On February 28, 2024, the Monterey County District Attorney filed an
amended information charging Romero with first degree murder (Pen. Code,3
§ 187, subd. (a); count 1). The amended information further alleged that Romero
personally used a deadly or dangerous weapon (§ 12022, subd. (b)(1)) in
committing the offense charged in count 1 and that Romero had three prior strike
convictions (§§ 667, subd. (a)(1), 1170.12, subd. (c)(2)) as well as three prior
serious felony convictions (§ 667, subd. (a)(1)).
On May 31, 2024, a jury convicted Romero of second degree murder,
finding that he did not act willfully, with premeditation and deliberation. The jury
also found true the allegation that he personally used a deadly weapon in
committing the murder. In a bifurcated proceeding, the court found true the prior
strike and prior serious felony allegations.
2
Romero has filed a petition for writ of habeas corpus (H053790) that this
court ordered considered with the appeal. We have disposed of the habeas petition
by separate order filed this day. (See Cal. Rules of Court, rule 8.387(b)(2)(B).)
3
Unspecified statutory references are to the Penal Code.
2
After denying his motion for a new trial and his Romero4 motion, the trial
court sentenced Romero to a term of 45 years to life (15 years to life, tripled due to
his prior strikes) consecutive to a term of 16 years (one year for the personal use
enhancement plus five years for each of his three prior serious felony convictions).
The court stated that Romero’s sentence was to be “served consecutive to any
other sentence [he] is currently serving.”
Romero timely appealed.
B. Facts
1. Prosecution case
a. Correctional officers’ testimony
On January 12, 2018,5 correctional officer Jose Carmona was working as
the control booth officer at Facility B-4 in Salinas Valley State Prison (SVSP).6 As
the control booth officer, Carmona could unlock the cell doors electronically, but
those doors had to be physically closed by inmates or correctional officers. Once
closed, the doors automatically lock.
At 11:15 a.m., Carmona gave a five-minute warning to the inmates in the
dayroom to return to their cells. Carmona unlocked Cells 101 to 117 for the
inmates assigned to those cells.
At approximately 11:21 a.m., the floor officers called out an alert that there
was a fight in a cell. As directed by Sergeant Mario Barroso, Carmona opened the
door to Cell 112, which was assigned to the victim Alcantar Ortega. According to
Carmona, Alcantar Ortega did not have a cellmate. Carmona went to assist
Barroso and began pulling Alcantar Ortega, who was lying on the floor by the
4
People v. Superior Court (Romero) (1996) 13 Cal.4th 497.
5
Unless otherwise specified, all dates are from 2018.
6
SVSP is designated as a “high security” prison.
3
door, out of the cell.7 Carmona saw Romero and Sanchez Cortez inside Cell 112,
but he had not seen either of them enter that cell.
On January 12, correctional officer Lucio Cuevas was working as a yard
officer at SVSP. At approximately 11:21 a.m., the incident alarm went off in the
yard of B-4. Cuevas responded and, as he scanned the area inside B-4, Cuevas
saw “blood in … Cell 112. … on the floor [coming from under the door] and
smeared in the window of the door.” When Cuevas looked through the cell
window, he saw Alcantar Ortega, who “had visible injuries and blood,” “lying
face up … [on the floor with] his head near the door.” Cuevas also saw Romero
and Sanchez Cortez inside the cell, by Alcantar Ortega’s feet, and both “had
bloodstains [on their clothing.]” On cross-examination, Cuevas said that Romero
and Sanchez Cuevas had “about the same” amount of blood on their clothing.
Once the door to the cell was unlocked, Cuevas dragged Alcantar Ortega,
who was not moving, out of the cell. Cuevas closed the door and waited for
additional staff before he handcuffed and removed Romero from the cell. Cuevas
escorted Romero to the dayroom and guarded him there before turning him over to
staff from the Investigative Services Unit (ISU).
Correctional officer Seth Puckett was working as a floor officer in Facility
B-4 at SVSP on January 12. At approximately 11:21 a.m., Puckett heard a “loud
bang on … one of the doors, and … heard a ‘man down’ come from one of the
cells.” Puckett noticed blood on one of the cell’s windows and blood seeping
under the door, so he alerted his partner there was a possible cell fight and
activated his alarm.
7
On cross-examination, Carmona said he saw Alcantar Ortega get “dragged
out” after which Romero and Sanchez Cortez were removed from the cell.
4
When Puckett reached the door to Cell 112, he could not see inside as it
was dark, and the back window was covered. Puckett used his flashlight and saw
Romero and Sanchez Cortez standing in the middle of the cell looking toward the
door. Puckett knew that Alcantar Ortega was assigned to that cell and Romero
and Sanchez Cortez were not.8 Puckett could not see Alcantar Ortega inside the
cell, but he waited for additional staff to respond before opening the door.
Puckett’s supervisor, Sergeant Barroso, arrived on scene and ordered the
control booth officer to unlock the cell door. When the door opened, Puckett saw
Alcantar Ortega lying on the floor “lifeless” with multiple injuries to his face and
upper body and “a lot of blood.”
Puckett’s partner helped Cuevas pull Alcantar Ortega out of the cell so he
could receive medical attention. Sergeant Barroso ordered Romero and Sanchez
Cortez to face the back of the cell, put their hands behind their backs, and step
backwards out of the cell one at a time. As each inmate exited the cell, they were
handcuffed and placed against a wall for evidence collection.
Lieutenant Barroso9 responded to the report of a fight in Facility B-4 on
January 12. When he arrived on scene, Barroso saw Puckett and another
correctional officer in front of Cell 112. Barroso could see blood seeping
underneath the door to that cell and blood spatter on the window. Through the
window, Barroso saw two inmates standing at the back of the cell, looking toward
the door, and a third inmate lying motionless on the floor. Barroso directed the
control officer to unlock Cell 112 and, after the door was pulled open, he directed
the two inmates standing inside to face the back wall of the cell and put their
8
Puckett, after reviewing his report, testified that Sanchez Cortez was
assigned to Cell 119 and Romero was assigned to Cell 125.
9
Barroso clarified that he was a sergeant at the time of the January 12
incident.
5
hands behind their heads. Barroso also told the other correctional officers to
remove the injured inmate from the cell. After the third inmate was outside
receiving medical attention, Barroso had correctional officers remove the other
two inmates, one by one, from the cell and place them in restraints. Barroso
identified Sanchez Cortez and Romero in court as those two inmates.
According to Barroso, when he first looked into the cell, Sanchez Cortez
had “kind of a just a crazy smile,” whereas Romero was shaking and looked
shocked. Barroso observed that both inmates’ hands were “trembling and
shaking.” He did not see either inmate holding a weapon. The inmates were
covered in blood and, as they stood there, Barroso saw Sanchez Cortez use his
thumb to wipe something off Romero’s head.
In the ensuing investigation, a correctional officer photographed the inside
of the cell after Romero and Sanchez Cortez were removed, documenting the
blood on various objects in the cell, as well as two inmate-manufactured weapons
discovered in the toilet. The weapons were admitted into evidence and exhibited
to the jury.
Another officer photographed Romero and Sanchez Cortez. Sanchez
Cortez had “quite a bit of blood” on his clothing and his person, with blood spatter
on his face, hands, wrists, forearms, stomach, and front lower body. Romero had
blood on his forehead, eye, hands, shoes, and knee. The photographs of Sanchez
Cortez and Romero were exhibited to the jury and admitted into evidence.10 The
officer taking the photographs did not observe any injuries of note on either
Sanchez Cortez or Romero.
10
As depicted in the photographs, Romero had a significant amount of
blood on his hands, including under his fingernails, and the tops of his shoes.
6
After Alcantar Ortega was transported to the hospital, a correctional officer
searched his clothing but found no weapons. Alcantar Ortega was taken off life
support and pronounced dead at 5:52 p.m.
b. Autopsy evidence
Dr. Venus Azar, a forensic pathologist with the Monterey County
Coroner’s office, testified as an expert in forensic pathology. Dr. Azar performed
the autopsy on Alcantar Ortega on January 18 and noted that medical personnel
had placed 220 “staples or sutures” in attempting to treat his injuries.
In all, Alcantar Ortega had more than 70 “sharp force injuries,” which
includes stab wounds and incision wounds. Dr. Azar counted 17 stab wounds on
Alcantar Ortega’s head, one of which “penetrated into the cranial cavity.”11
Alcantar Ortega had 12 stab wounds to his neck, most of which were superficial,
but one “puncture[d] or involve[d]” his jugular vein. Dr. Azar noted 20 stab
wounds and 15 skin incisions or punctures on Alcantar Ortega’s torso. One of the
stab wounds on his torso punctured his left lung, collapsing it. Finally, Alcantar
Ortega had three stab wounds to his right arm or shoulder and nine stab wounds to
his right thigh and leg. The deepest stab wound to his leg was seven inches in
depth.
Dr. Azar determined that the cause of death was multiple stab wounds, and
the manner of death was homicide. Her opinion was based on the fact that
Alcantar Ortega “was bleeding profusely” on his arrival to the hospital, as well as
the injuries to major blood vessels in his head and neck, and the injury to his left
lung.
11
Dr. Azar subsequently testified that two stab wounds “penetrated … into
the cranial cavity[,] … [where] they severed a major blood vessel that supplies the
brain with blood.”
7
2. Defense case
a. Sanchez Cortez’s testimony
Prior to Sanchez Cortez taking the witness stand, the court informed the
jury that the parties stipulated that, at the time of the stabbing, Sanchez Cortez was
serving a life term in prison.
Sanchez Cortez testified that, on January 12, he was returning to his cell
from the dayroom when he encountered Alcantar Ortega who “didn’t want to go
into his cell for whatever reason.” Sanchez Cortez admitted that his cell, Cell 119,
was not on the same side of the tier as Cell 112 and was “about 30 yards away.”
When the floor officers told Alcantar Ortega to go into his cell, he did not comply.
Sanchez Cortez said the floor officers “kind of looked around” and “wanted to go
on with their job” so Sanchez Cortez “voluntarily went [to Alcantar Ortega’s cell]
to assist them.”12
Sanchez Cortez walked over to Alcantar Ortega and told him, “two, three,
four times,” “ ‘Get into your cell.’ ” Alcantar Ortega refused to do so and began
arguing with Sanchez Cortez. Each time Alcantar Ortega refused, he got louder
and “more aggressive.” Sanchez Cortez told Alcantar Ortega that it was “ ‘not up
for argument’ ” and that he needed to get in his cell so “ ‘program can continue.’ ”
Sanchez Cortez testified that if the inmates “hold up program,” the correctional
officers will get them in trouble.
Sanchez Cortez said that the argument “led to an altercation” and he and
Alcantar Ortega began to fight. Sanchez Cortez was “pretty sure” he threw the
first punch. Alcantar Ortega punched Sanchez Cortez in the lip, and Sanchez
Cortez “got pretty mad.”
12
Sanchez Cortez testified that, on January 12, Alcantar Ortega was a
“northerner” like himself and Romero. However, at the time of trial, Romero was
no longer a northerner.
8
Sanchez Cortez had two knives in his pocket, explaining it was “not
unusual for people to carry weapons” given that it was a “Level IV prison.”
Sanchez Cortez pulled out one of his knives and stabbed Alcantar Ortega in the
throat because “he’s bigger than me.” Sanchez Cortez said he “stabbed [Alcantar
Ortega] repeatedly on the tier.” They ended up inside Alcantar Ortega’s cell
“where we were just going at it, just me and him, one on one.” Alcantar Ortega
was “throwing punches back.” Sanchez Cortez “stabbed him again and again and
again and again” inside the cell and stabbed him “everywhere.” Alcantar Ortega
slipped and fell but Sanchez Cortez “let him get back up” and they continued to
fight. Sanchez Cortez “continued to stab him[] [¶] [and] [] didn’t stop.”
Alcantar Ortega fell on the bunk and Sanchez Cortez “jumped on him[]
[a]nd [] stabbed him some more. … maybe in the back of the neck or in the back.”
When Alcantar Ortega ran for the door, which was shut, Sanchez Cortez “stabbed
him [] in the back of the neck” and stabbed him “[m]aybe” more than 15 times.
Alcantar Ortega fell to the floor and Sanchez Cortez “stabbed him a few times
while he was down.” Sanchez Cortez stabbed Alcantar Ortega in “the nape of his
neck and pulled [his knife] upwards.” Sanchez Cortez said that he was not trying
to kill Alcantar Ortega but was trying “to stop him.” Alcantar Ortega got up and
threw “a couple more punches,” fell back to the floor when Sanchez Cortez
punched him again, at which point “everything was just over.”
After “everything kind of [] settled down,” Sanchez Cortez heard a loud
bang which was the cell door closing. Sanchez Cortez denied closing the cell
door. Sanchez Cortez turned and saw Romero, who was yelling at him, “ ‘Stop,
stop, stop.’ ” At that point, Sanchez Cortez “came to” and saw Alcantar Ortega on
the floor. Sanchez Cortez’s adrenaline was still pumping and he and Romero
stood there for “probably 15 minutes, maybe longer.” Romero looked scared, and
9
Sanchez Cortez testified that he may have laughed at him. Sanchez Cortez said
that Romero did not do anything besides “run in there and try to stop the fight.”
Sanchez Cortez told Romero, “ ‘Damn, you got blood on you. Like, my
bad.’ ” He then used his fingers to wipe the blood on Romero’s head. Sanchez
Cortez took his two knives and threw them both in the toilet, but they were too big
to flush.
The correctional officers then showed up, removed them from the cell, and
asked them what happened. Sanchez Cortez said that, once the cell door opened,
Alcantar Ortega crawled out “really fast” on his own.
b. Romero’s testimony
Romero testified that he was heading back to his cell from the dayroom
when he saw Alcantar Ortega and Sanchez Cortez “facing each other” in front of
Cell 112. Romero did not hear what they were discussing but saw them start
fighting and go into Cell 112. He walked over to Cell 112 because he knew that
Sanchez Cortez “gets mad easily.”
Romero got to the cell and saw the two men exchanging blows, but he did
not see a knife in anyone’s hand. He was telling the men to stop fighting but when
he saw “an object” in Sanchez Cortez’s hand, Romero backed away inside the cell.
Romero looked for a way out but saw that the door was closed. Romero did not
close the door and did not see that Alcantar Ortega or Sanchez Cortez closed it.
He tried to stay out of the way until correctional officers arrived and remembered
“[t]here was a lot of blood.” Romero saw Sanchez Cortez stab Alcantar Ortega
multiple times, “all over the body towards the neck, head, back, shoulder.” At
some point, Sanchez Cortez or Alcantar Ortega bumped into Romero, causing him
to lose his balance. Romero put his hands out to break his fall and noticed blood
on the floor.
10
After Alcantar Ortega was on the ground, Romero saw Sanchez Cortez
throw something in the toilet as correctional officers came in. Romero saw
Alcantar Ortega try to crawl out of the cell before he was pulled out by a
correctional officer. Sanchez Cortez came toward him, and Romero froze,
thinking Sanchez Cortez was going to hurt him. Instead, Sanchez Cortez rubbed
at something on his head, saying “ ‘You got blood on you.’ ”
At the time of the stabbing, Romero had a release date and was not serving
a life sentence.
3. Rebuttal
Carmona testified, during recall, floor officers are “observing the inmates
walking toward[] [their cells]” and, once the inmates are inside, the floor officers
“start locking [] the doors.” As the inmates moved from the dayroom, Carmona
was focused on making sure they were walking to their cells since “[a]nything []
might happen.” He did not see Alcantar Ortega and Sanchez Cortez fight nor did
he see floor officers have any issue with Alcantar Ortega refusing to enter his cell.
Based on his experience, there could not have been a fight outside a cell in the
middle of the section without himself or a floor officer observing it. On cross-
examination, Carmona said that he did not see anyone in front of Cell 112, nor did
he see anyone enter that cell, as he was focused on the floor officers “closing
down the cells.”
II. DISCUSSION
Romero argues his trial counsel provided constitutionally ineffective
assistance. Specifically, Romero contends counsel should have argued that a note
written by Sanchez Cortez before trial, in which he took sole responsibility for
Alcantar Ortega’s murder and denied that Romero participated in any way, was
admissible as a prior consistent statement. In Romero’s view, Carmona’s
11
testimony on rebuttal “impliedly attacked [Sanchez] Cortez’s credibility,” thereby
rendering the note admissible under that exception to the hearsay rule.
The Attorney General contends that Romero has failed to demonstrate that
trial counsel was ineffective because the hearsay statements in Sanchez Cortez’s
note did not qualify as prior consistent statements under Evidence Code section
791, subdivision (b). Alternatively, the Attorney General argues that Romero
cannot show he was prejudiced by exclusion of the note.
As explained below, even assuming that trial counsel was ineffective as
Romero argues, we agree with the Attorney General that Romero cannot establish
prejudice.
A. Additional background
“On February 21, 2024, correctional officers began gathering inmates,
including Defendant [Sanchez] Cortez for court. Defendant [Sanchez] Cortez
shouted to the officer that he wasn’t going anywhere and had a sheet drawn across
the cell window, blocking officers’ view and the cell lights were off. Officers
called to him again and he repeated that he wasn’t going. Officers heard
Defendant Sanchez Cortez moaning, and he then stopped responding to officers.
They looked inside and saw blood spatter on the floor of the cell and the sheet.
Officers observed lacerations on his arms which appeared to be self-inflicted and
pools of blood on the mattress. A razor blade used to inflict the injuries and a
handwritten note was found. The note stated: [¶] ‘To my wife N Family I am so
sorry but fuck this life it aint living. I confess to the 2018 187. Creeper didn’t do
nothing.’ ”13 (Sic.)
Before trial, the prosecution moved in limine to exclude the note written by
Sanchez Cortez as inadmissible hearsay. Romero’s counsel moved in limine to
13
This recitation is taken verbatim from the prosecution’s motion in limine.
12
admit the note, arguing that it is not hearsay or, alternatively, that it is admissible
as a statement against penal interest.
At the hearing on motions in limine, the trial court indicated that the note
would only be relevant if Romero was “Creeper” and was being offered for the
truth of the statement that Romero did not participate in the murder.
In her argument, defense counsel contended the note was admissible under
the declaration against penal interest exception to the hearsay rule (Evid. Code,
§ 1230). The prosecution argued that there were no applicable exceptions to the
hearsay rule, and the note was therefore inadmissible.
The trial court concluded that the note was hearsay and that the declaration
against penal interest exception did not apply. Specifically, the court found that
the statement “Creeper didn’t do nothing” was not against Sanchez Cortez’s penal
interest nor were there other indicia of reliability to support admitting it. Sanchez
Cortez’s counsel then inquired whether the court would allow the note to come
into evidence as a prior consistent statement if his client “were to testify and
[Sanchez Cortez] were to take responsibility [for the murder].” The court replied
that it would consider doing so, but it “would want to see the parties [] brief that.”
B. Applicable legal principles
The standard for evaluating claims that counsel provided constitutionally
ineffective assistance is set forth in Strickland v. Washington (1984) 466 U.S. 668,
687–694 (Strickland). This standard provides that: “[t]o secure reversal … upon
the ground of ineffective assistance of counsel under either the state or federal
Constitution, [an appellant] must establish (1) that [] counsel’s performance fell
below an objective standard of reasonableness, i.e., that counsel’s performance did
not meet the standard to be expected of a reasonably competent attorney, and (2)
that there is a reasonable probability that [appellant] would have obtained a more
favorable result absent counsel’s shortcomings. [Citations.]” (People v.
13
Cunningham (2001) 25 Cal.4th 926, 1003, citing Strickland, supra.) “A reviewing
court can begin an ineffective assistance of counsel inquiry with either element
and need not address both elements if one is not satisfied. [Citations.] Indeed, it
is often preferable for a court to dismiss an ineffective assistance of counsel claim
solely for lack of prejudice. [Citations.]” (In re Tellez (2024) 17 Cal.5th 77, 88
(Tellez).) With regard to the prejudice prong of ineffective assistance of counsel,
“ ‘[a] reasonable probability is a probability sufficient to undermine confidence in
the outcome.’ [Citations.]” (In re Marquez (1992) 1 Cal.4th 584, 603 (Marquez).)
“When there has been no showing of prejudice, we need not determine whether
trial counsel’s performance was deficient. [Citations.]” (Id. at p. 602.)
“On direct appeal, a conviction will be reversed for ineffective assistance
only if (1) the record affirmatively discloses counsel had no rational tactical
purpose for the challenged act or omission, (2) counsel was asked for a reason and
failed to provide one, or (3) there simply could be no satisfactory explanation. All
other claims of ineffective assistance are more appropriately resolved in a habeas
corpus proceeding.” (People v. Mai (2013) 57 Cal.4th 986, 1009.)
C. Analysis
1. Trial counsel’s performance
Only relevant evidence is admissible. (Evid. Code, § 350.) Under the
Evidence Code, hearsay is defined as “evidence of a statement that was made
other than by a witness while testifying at the hearing and that is offered to prove
the truth of the matter stated.” (Evid. Code, § 1200, subd. (a), italics added.)
Unless the hearsay evidence falls within an exception to the hearsay rule, an out-
of-court statement is inadmissible for its truth. (Id., subd. (b).) There is no dispute
that the note in question is hearsay.
Under Evidence Code section 1236, “[e]vidence of a statement previously
made by a witness is not made inadmissible by the hearsay rule if the statement is
14
consistent with his testimony at the hearing and is offered in compliance with
Section 791.” Evidence Code section 791, subdivision (b) provides that a prior
consistent statement may be admitted to support the credibility of a testifying
witness if “[a]n express or implied charge has been made that his testimony at the
hearing is recently fabricated or is influenced by bias or other improper motive,
and the statement was made before the bias, motive for fabrication, or other
improper motive is alleged to have arisen.”
As stated earlier, Romero argues that Carmona’s rebuttal testimony
“created an inference [Sanchez] Cortez had fabricated his account of the fight”
which amounted to an implied charge that Sanchez Cortez’s trial testimony was
recently fabricated. We need not decide whether Sanchez Cortez’s note qualifies
as an admission under Evidence Code section 791, subdivision (b). As discussed
below, assuming without deciding deficient performance by trial counsel for
failing to seek admission of the February 2024 note written by Sanchez Cortez as a
prior consistent statement, Romero has not met his burden on direct appeal that
there was a reasonable probability of a more favorable outcome.
2. Romero has not shown prejudice
Our Supreme Court has instructed that, when addressing a claim of
ineffective assistance of counsel, “[a] reviewing court can begin … [that] inquiry
with either element [i.e., counsel’s deficient performance or prejudice] and need
not address both elements if one is not satisfied. [Citations.]” (Tellez, supra, 17
Cal.5th at p. 88.) For the purposes of this discussion, we will assume that trial
counsel requested admission of the suicide note as a prior consistent statement and
the trial court admitted it into evidence. Because Romero has not shown, even
under such a circumstance, “ ‘[a] reasonable probability … sufficient to undermine
confidence in the outcome[,]’ [citations]” (Marquez, supra, 1 Cal.4th at p. 603),
his claim of ineffective assistance of counsel is without merit.
15
As discussed earlier, when correctional officers arrived at Cell 112, the cell
door was closed and locked. It was undisputed that only the inmates themselves
or correctional officers could close and lock the cells once they had been unlocked
by the control officer. Sanchez Cortez and Romero were inside the cell, and
Romero had blood on his forehead, eyes, hands, shoes, and knee.14 Alcantar
Ortega had been stabbed more than 70 times, and two inmate-manufactured
weapons were discovered inside the toilet.
Romero argues that there was no evidence to support the prosecution’s
theory that he participated in the murder, explaining that there was no affirmative
evidence to show who closed the cell door, how he was spattered with blood, or
that he used either of the weapons found in the toilet. We disagree. There was
ample evidence from which the jury could have reasonably found that Romero
participated in the murder. While Romero testified, he became trapped inside
Alcantar Ortega’s cell by happenstance as he sought to stop the fighting between
Sanchez Cortez and Alcantar Ortega, there was considerable circumstantial
evidence which established his active participation in the murder. Correctional
officers discovered two inmate-manufactured weapons in the cell and the jury was
entitled to disbelieve the testimony that Romero did not use either of those
weapons. The sheer number of stab wounds, more than 70, suggests that they
were inflicted by more than one person. The amount of blood on Romero’s
person, especially his hands, including beneath his fingernails, and on the tops of
his shoes, also supports the jury’s conclusion that he was directly engaged in the
repeated stabbing of Alcantar Ortega.
Against the relatively strong evidence of Romero’s culpability described
above was the relatively weak evidence favoring his version of events, which
14
See footnote 11, ante.
16
consisted of: (1) Romero’s testimony that he only ended up in Alcantar Ortega’s
cell because he tried to stop Sanchez Cortez from fighting; and (2) Sanchez
Cortez’s direct testimony that Romero did not participate in the killing. Sanchez
Cortez’s suicide note was cumulative to Sanchez Cortez’s trial testimony and
would have added little to the jury’s evaluation of the evidence. Moreover, we
will not presume that the suicide note—written more than six years after the
murder and after both Sanchez Cortez and Romero had been charged with that
murder—would have been particularly credible to a jury in light of the other
evidence presented.
Consequently, Romero has failed to show “a reasonable probability of a
more favorable outcome in the absence of the assertedly deficient performance.”
(People v. Stewart (2004) 33 Cal.4th 425, 459.)
III. DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed.
17
_________________________________
WILSON, J.
WE CONCUR:
______________________________________
LIE, Acting P. J.
______________________________________
CHUNG, J.
The People v. Romero; In re Jaime Demecio Romero on Habeas Corpus
H053210, H053790
Judge of the Santa Clara County Superior Court, assigned by the Chief Justice
pursuant to article VI, section 6 of the California Constitution.
Ti chiedi come si applica questo testo alla tua situazione?
Consulenza gratuita, senza impegno
Descrivi la tua situazione. Il nostro team ti ricontatterà via e-mail per la tua consulenza.
Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude
Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.