CourtListener 10864959•People v. Benson CA3
Testo completo
Filed 5/27/26 P. v. Benson CA3
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
THIRD APPELLATE DISTRICT
(Placer)
THE PEOPLE, C100153
Plaintiff and Respondent,
(Super. Ct. No. 62180971)
v.
DAMON ALLEN BENSON,
Defendant and Appellant.
Defendant Damon Allen Benson punished his girlfriend for cheating on him.
After she drank enough alcohol to endure what he had planned for her, he punched her in
the face, struck her with a paddle, used a stun gun on her body, and cut the shape of a
swastika into her back. He later broke into her partner’s home and killed him. A jury
found defendant guilty of aggravated mayhem and torture, first degree residential
burglary, and first degree murder with malice aforethought. The trial court sentenced
defendant to 25 years to life for murder plus four years for burglary.
Defendant raises two contentions on appeal: (1) the trial court had a sua sponte
duty to instruct the jury on mistaken consent to mayhem and torture; and (2) the
consecutive burglary sentence was unauthorized. The second contention has merit; the
first does not. We remand for resentencing and otherwise affirm. Statutory references
are to the Penal Code.
1
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
I. Torture and Mayhem
A. Girlfriend’s Testimony
Girlfriend began dating defendant in February 2021. While defendant intended to
have a monogamous relationship, girlfriend told defendant she was pansexual and
polyamorous. She also told him she was into “dominance and submission” and would
make an effort to be monogamous.
In early July 2021, girlfriend had sex with Cameron Gabriel, a previous sexual
partner. Defendant broke up with girlfriend for cheating on him, but they started
communicating again about a week later. In those communications, defendant instructed
girlfriend to be ready for him to pick her up so he could punish her. Girlfriend told him
she would be ready but also told him not to hurt her.
On July 16, 2021, defendant took girlfriend to his place. They talked for about an
hour, and girlfriend took her clothes off within the first 30 minutes, which was customary
for her when she would visit defendant. Defendant “forcefully” told her to drink as much
alcohol as she could, and girlfriend had four or five “large pours of limoncello.”
Girlfriend also complied when defendant told her to put out her hands. He bound her
hands suspended her from a hook in the ceiling. Girlfriend was uncomfortable and did
not want to be in this position, but she did what defendant asked because she was scared.
Defendant extinguished a cigarette on her neck and punched her in the face with a
closed fist as she jumped back in pain. Somewhere between 15 and 39 closed-fist strikes
followed. Defendant then struck her with a paddle, pulled hard on the inside of her nose
with pliers, used a stun gun on her ovaries and back, and cut the shape of a swastika into
her back with a machete knife. The events lasted about an hour. Girlfriend constantly
begged and pleaded to be let down. After defendant let her down, she stayed the night
2
with him “against [her] will.” The next day, defendant texted her “‘you’re mine for sure
now,’” and she responded, “‘I’m glad to be.’”
B. Defendant’s Testimony
Defendant testified that girlfriend “liked danger boys” and “having sort of a
dominant male who was jealous.” On their first date, she told defendant she was into
slapping, choking, biting, bondage, and being tied up and was not interested in being the
dominant person. The first night they got together, they practiced choking and defendant
held her down, both of which were girlfriend’s ideas.
Throughout their relationship, girlfriend told defendant he didn’t order her around
enough. She instructed him to make her submit if she did something he did not like. He
used his paddle on her “numerous times” before July 16, 2021, sometimes at her request.
They also used the rope for tying hands or ankles and for hanging her from the ceiling a
few times. During these activities, defendant would stop what he was doing if girlfriend
said the word “mercy” or held her hands up as if she was praying.
After girlfriend admitted cheating on defendant, she told him it was the biggest
regret of her life and hoped they could work things out. Defendant broke up with her but
texted her a few days later to get back together. He told her he wanted to meet with her
again and punish her for cheating on him. Defendant was explicit that he was going to
inflict pain on her. At first, girlfriend said she wasn’t into that, but her attitude changed
after she arrived.
When they went to his bedroom, defendant told her she was going to be in extreme
pain and advised her to drink a lot of alcohol before they got started. Girlfriend agreed.
Defendant did not force her to drink. Defendant also drank to the point where he
considered himself drunk. After girlfriend had drunk enough to be able to endure what
he had planned for her, defendant asked her if she was ready to get started. She jumped
off the bed, said “yes,” and offered her hands for him to tie her up. Defendant claimed
3
girlfriend’s testimony on what happened next was inaccurate in three ways: (1) the
episode lasted 20 to 25 minutes; (2) she did not beg to be let down; and (3) he did not
punch her 40 to 50 times. Girlfriend also never said “mercy” or made the sign she had
used previously. In cutting her back, he was performing a pagan binding ritual that binds
two souls together for eternity. They had previously discussed that the swastika
represents a union between two divinities. And they had consensual sex before they went
to sleep that night. Girlfriend later told him she “would have done anything to be with
[him] again.”
C. Instructions, Closing Arguments, and Verdict
The court instructed the jury on the elements of aggravated mayhem and torture
using CALCRIM Nos. 800 and 810. Defendant did not request an instruction on
mistaken consent. During closing arguments, defense counsel admitted that defendant
inflicted the injuries underlying the mayhem and torture counts, but argued defendant
was not guilty because the injuries were “part of their relationship” and “things that they
experimented in.” He told the jury it had the difficult decision of finding the line
“between the dominance and submission type relationship, and torture/mayhem.” He
also argued that defendant lacked the requisite intent to commit mayhem or torture
because he was intoxicated.
The jury found defendant guilty of aggravated mayhem and torture.
II. Murder and Burglary
During a physical altercation with girlfriend on July 24, 2021, defendant
demanded Gabriel’s address and gathered a baton and a satchel containing a loaded
pistol. After arriving at Gabriel’s house, defendant kicked in the door and found Gabriel
in his bedroom. Defendant struck Gabriel with the baton a few times and then fired the
pistol seven times in his direction. Gabriel died from multiple gunshot wounds.
4
During closing arguments, the prosecution argued that defendant committed
residential burglary because he entered Gabriel’s home intending to commit murder. The
jury found defendant guilty of first degree murder and first degree residential burglary.
The trial court sentenced him to 25 years to life for murder and a consecutive term of four
years for burglary. Defendant timely appeals.
DISCUSSION
I. Sua Sponte Instruction on Mistaken Consent
Relying on People v. Mayberry (1975) 15 Cal.3d 143, 155, defendant contends the
trial court prejudicially erred by breaching its sua sponte duty to instruct the jury on
mistaken consent as a defense to the torture and mayhem counts. We disagree that such a
duty existed.
A trial court has no sua sponte duty to instruct on doctrines of law that have not
been established by authority. (People v. Michaels (2002) 28 Cal.4th 486, 529.) A
Mayberry defense applies to sex offenses that have “as an essential element the absence
of the victim’s consent.” (People v. Andrews (2015) 234 Cal.App.4th 590, 602.)
Defendant cites no authority establishing consent, mistaken or otherwise, as an element
of, or possible defense to, torture or mayhem. (See §§ 205, 206; People v. Burton (2006)
143 Cal.App.4th 447, 451-452 [torture]; People v. Lee (1990) 220 Cal.App.3d 320, 324-
325 [aggravated mayhem].) The authorities we found indicate defendant’s theory is
either unsupported or has not received sufficient elucidation to constitute a general
principle of law triggering a sua sponte duty to instruct. (See People v. Samuels (1967)
250 Cal.App.2d 501, 513-514 (Samuels) [consent not a defense to aggravated assault
charge arising from severe beating inflicted for creation of sadomasochistic film]; People
v. Alfaro (1976) 61 Cal.App.3d 414, 429 [consent not a defense to assault that results in
great bodily injury]; People v. Rivera (1984) 157 Cal.App.3d 736, 742 [touching not
unlawful where reasonable belief in consent present]; People v. Flannel (1979) 25 Cal.3d
5
668, 683 [no duty to instruct on undeveloped rule], superseded by statute on another
ground as stated in In re Christian S. (1994) 7 Cal.4th 768, 776.)
Also, a Mayberry defense has a subjective and an objective component, and a
Mayberry instruction is required only where both components are supported by
substantial evidence. (People v. Williams (1992) 4 Cal.4th 354, 360-362.) As to the first
component, there must be substantial evidence of the victim’s equivocal conduct that
served as the basis for the defendant’s good faith but mistaken belief that the victim
consented. (Id. at pp. 360-361.) As to the second component, the evidence must support
the conclusion that the defendant’s subjective good faith belief was objectively
reasonable under the circumstances. (Id. at p. 361.) “[R]egardless of how strongly a
defendant may subjectively believe a person has consented to [the act], that belief must
be formed under circumstances society will tolerate as reasonable.” (Id. at p. 361.) Here,
although defendant acknowledges both Mayberry components, he does not explain how
the second component was satisfied, specifically how his belief was formed under
circumstances that society will tolerate as reasonable. Defendant does not meet his
burden to show error. (See People v. Garza (2005) 35 Cal.4th 866, 881 [party attacking
judgment has burden of affirmatively demonstrating error].) And we do not see how
defendant could have an objectively reasonable belief that after drinking multiple pours
of alcohol, girlfriend consented to being punched multiple times in the face, and after
being so punched, she then consented to being stunned, struck with a paddle, and branded
with a swastika using a knife. (See Samuels, supra, at 250 Cal.App.2d at pp. 513-514 [“a
normal person in full possession of his mental faculties does not freely consent to the use,
upon himself, of force likely to produce great bodily injury”].)
For these reasons, we find no merit to defendant’s sua sponte contention.
6
II. Unauthorized Sentence
The People concede defendant’s argument the trial court erred under section 654
by imposing consecutive sentences for the murder and burglary convictions. We accept
the People’s concession.
Section 654 precludes multiple punishments for an indivisible course of conduct.
(People v. Centers (1999) 73 Cal.App.4th 84, 98.) For example, when a defendant is
convicted of burglary and the intended felony underlying the burglary, section 654
prohibits punishment for both crimes. (People v. Islas (2012) 210 Cal.App.4th 116, 130.)
A claim of error under section 654 is nonwaivable. (People v. Scott (1994) 9 Cal.4th 331,
354, fn. 17.)
Here, murder was the felony underlying the prosecution’s burglary theory, so the
trial court erred by imposing consecutive sentences for both crimes. Because the trial
court has discretion to decide which sentence should be stayed, remand is required.
(People v. Mani (2022) 74 Cal.App.5th 343, 379.)
7
DISPOSITION
Defendant’s sentence is vacated, and the case is remanded for full resentencing.
(People v. Buycks (2018) 5 Cal.5th 857, 893.) The judgment is otherwise affirmed.
/s/
MESIWALA, J.
We concur:
/s/
ROBIE, Acting P. J.
/s/
KRAUSE, J.
8
Ti chiedi come si applica questo testo alla tua situazione?
Consulenza gratuita, senza impegno
Descrivi la tua situazione. Il nostro team ti ricontatterà via e-mail per la tua consulenza.
Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude
Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.