CourtListener 10848643•Aguilar v. Owens-Brockway Glass Container CA2/2
Aguilar v. Owens-Brockway Glass Container CA2/2
CourtListener 10848643Calctapp27 apr 2026
Testo completo
Filed 4/27/26 Aguilar v. Owens-Brockway Glass Container CA2/2
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION TWO
PRISCILLA AGUILAR et al., B341875
Plaintiffs and Respondents, (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No.
v. 21STCV33017)
OWENS-BROCKWAY GLASS
CONTAINER, INC.,
Defendant;
LUCIO LEMUS, JR.,
Movant and Appellant.
APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of Los
Angeles County, Elaine Lu, Judge. Affirmed.
Matern Law Group, Matthew J. Matern, Mikael H. Stahle,
Debra J. Tauger; Altshuler Berzon and Michael Rubin for Movant
and Appellant.
James Hawkins, James R. Hawkins, Christina M. Lucio,
Mitchell J. Murray and Samantha A. Jones for Plaintiffs and
Respondents.
PRISCILLA AGUILAR et al., B343959
Plaintiffs and Respondents, (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No.
v. 21STCV33017)
OWENS-BROCKWAY GLASS
CONTAINER, INC.,
Defendant and Respondent;
LUCIO LEMUS, JR.,
Movant and Appellant.
APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of Los
Angeles County, Elaine Lu, Judge. Affirmed.
Matern Law Group, Matthew J. Matern, Mikael H. Stahle,
Debra J. Tauger; Altshuler Berzon and Michael Rubin for Movant
and Appellant.
James Hawkins, James R. Hawkins, Christina M. Lucio,
Mitchell J. Murray and Samantha A. Jones for Plaintiffs and
Respondents.
Seyfarth Shaw, Candace Bertoldi, Elizabeth J. MacGregor,
Robin E. Devaux and Brian P. Long for Defendant and
Respondent.
___________________________________
Lucio Lemus, Jr. filed two appeals in this superior court
case. In B341875, he challenges the trial court’s denial of his
motion to intervene. After denying intervention, the court
entered judgment on the parties’ negotiated settlement. In
2
B343959, appellant challenges the denial of his motion to vacate
the judgment. We have consolidated the appeals.
In B341875, we conclude that appellant’s motion to
intervene was properly denied for lack of standing to maintain a
Private Attorneys General Act (PAGA) claim. (Lab. Code, § 2698
et seq.)1 Appellant lacks standing to appeal in B343959 because
he is not an aggrieved party. We affirm the orders.
FACTS AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY
Respondents’ Lawsuit
Respondents Priscilla Aguilar, Julian Haro, Richard
Nunez, and Juan Madera worked for Owens-Brockway Glass
Container, Inc. (Owens).2 In 2021, they sued Owens for labor law
violations. Respondents notified the Labor and Workforce
Development Agency (LWDA) that they sought civil penalties
under PAGA.
Respondents negotiated a settlement with Owens. Owens
denied violating labor laws but settled to avoid further litigation.
The $3.7 million settlement (Settlement) encompassed class and
PAGA claims. The LWDA received $225,000 of the PAGA
penalty; aggrieved employees received $75,000.
Respondents requested court approval of the Settlement.
The court granted preliminary approval in December 2023,
finding the Settlement fair, adequate, and reasonable.
Respondents then notified 1,106 class members, none of whom
objected to the Settlement.
1 We are applying the version of PAGA in effect from
June 27, 2016, until June 30, 2024. (Stats. 2016, ch. 31, § 189.)
2 Owens is a respondent in B343959 but not in B341875.
3
Appellant Moves to Intervene
In July 2024, appellant moved to intervene in respondents’
lawsuit, claiming “an interest in enforcing rights and remedies
under PAGA arising out of conduct that is the subject” of
respondents’ lawsuit. As the basis for his request, appellant
pointed to his own lawsuit, Lemus v. Owens-Brockway Glass
Container, Inc. (Super. Ct. L.A. County (2024) No. 20STCV44110)
(the Lemus Action). He argued that intervention is mandatory
because the Lemus Action “will be materially and adversely
affected” by the Settlement. Alternatively, he sought permissive
intervention because respondents “unilaterally and without
consideration extended the PAGA release period.”
The Lemus Action was filed by Owens employee Lucio
Lemus, Sr. (Lemus Sr.), who alleged labor law violations and a
PAGA claim. Appellant was appointed successor in interest after
his father’s death in 2021. The Lemus Action is currently before
this court on appeal from an order granting Owens’s motion for
summary judgment, Lemus v. Owens-Brockway Glass Container,
Inc. (B341878).3
Respondents opposed intervention. They argued that
appellant’s motion is untimely; he lacks standing because he is
not an “aggrieved employee”; he did not exhaust administrative
remedies; and he has no direct or immediate interest in
respondents’ lawsuit.
Appellant replied that he is entitled to prosecute his
father’s PAGA claim. He clarified that he seeks intervention to
protect Lemus Sr.’s “personal interest in his own, individual,
PAGA claim.” He argued that the motion is timely; respondents
3 We refer to that appeal as B341878.
4
do not adequately represent his interests; and intervention would
not enlarge the issues raised in their suit.
The Trial Court Denies Intervention
The court wrote that appellant seeks intervention “because
the PAGA claim in the Aguilar Action overlaps with the PAGA
claim in the Lemus Action.” Recent case authority holds that a
PAGA plaintiff cannot intervene in a settlement reached by
another PAGA plaintiff. As to appellant’s claim of protecting his
father’s personal interest, the court ruled (1) there is no personal
interest in a PAGA claim, and (2) even if there is a personal
interest, appellant lacks standing—he was not an Owens
employee and cannot pursue his father’s claim. The court denied
his motion. He appealed.
Lemus Challenges Final Approval of the Settlement
In September 2024, the court granted final approval of the
Settlement. Respondents served notice of entry of order and
judgment on September 30, 2024, though notice was not served
on appellant.
On December 11, 2024, appellant gave notice of his motion
to vacate the judgment. He argued that the judgment improperly
extended the PAGA period for five months without new
consideration. Expansion of the PAGA period impaired his
personal interest in recovering 25 percent of the PAGA proceeds.
He is aggrieved by the judgment, which “will directly and
adversely impact his own PAGA case (as successor in interest to
Lemus Sr.) against Defendant,” which covers a longer period.
The judgment in respondents’ case will have a res judicata effect
on the Lemus Action.
In opposition, respondents argued that appellant is not
aggrieved by the judgment. He lacks standing to pursue Lemus
5
Sr.’s PAGA claims; he forfeited his right to object to the
Settlement by opting out of it; his motion to vacate was untimely;
and the court lacked jurisdiction to hear the motion while
appellant appealed the denial of his motion to intervene.
Appellant responded that his motion is timely because no
one served notice of entry of judgment upon him. He is entitled
to pursue his personal interest in Lemus Sr.’s PAGA claim. The
court had jurisdiction because his pending appeal was from the
order denying his motion to intervene, not the judgment. He
asserted that respondents’ case adversely impacted his own
PAGA case, as Lemus Sr.’s successor in interest.
The Court Denies the Motion to Vacate
The court first ruled that it could not entertain the motion.
An automatic stay suspending its jurisdiction was in place during
the pendency of appellant’s appeal of the order denying
intervention.
Assuming it had jurisdiction, the court ruled that appellant
lacked standing to vacate the judgment. Appellant opted out of
the class action portion of the Settlement and is not bound by it.
As to the PAGA portion of the judgment, appellant is not an
aggrieved party. Recent case law forbids multiple people with
PAGA claims against a common employer from seeking to vacate
a settlement by one of them. Appellant has no “personal interest”
in a PAGA claim belonging to the state’s labor law enforcement
agencies. Finally, Lemus Sr.’s PAGA claim did not survive his
death and appellant cannot pursue it. The court denied
appellant’s motion to vacate. He appealed.
6
DISCUSSION
APPEAL NO. B341875
1. Appeal and Review
Appeal may be taken from an order denying intervention
because it “is a final determination of the litigation as to the
party seeking to intervene.” (Bowles v. Superior Court (1955) 44
Cal.2d 574, 582.) The trial court’s ruling was premised on
appellant’s lack of standing to intervene in respondents’ lawsuit.
The parties agree that standing is a purely legal question,
reviewed de novo. (San Luis Rey Racing, Inc. v. California Horse
Racing Bd. (2017) 15 Cal.App.5th 67, 73.)
2. Intervention Rules
A nonparty may seek intervention to claim what is sought
by a complaint. (Code Civ. Proc., § 387, subd. (b).) Intervention
is mandatory if the law confers an unconditional right to
intervene, or if disposition may impair the interests of the
intervener, who is not adequately represented by existing parties.
(Id., subd. (d)(1).) Permissive intervention gives the court
discretion to determine if the person seeking intervention has an
interest in the litigation or the success of the parties. (Id., subd.
(d)(2).)
3. Appellant Lacks Standing to Intervene
Appellant cannot intervene under either a mandatory or
permissive theory because he lacks standing to pursue a PAGA
claim. He argues that respondents relinquished months of PAGA
penalties “without any additional consideration, thereby
stripping [his] right to recover the PAGA civil penalties during
that same period” in the Lemus Action. The problem is that
appellant has no right to maintain a PAGA action.
7
In B341878, this court rejected appellant’s claim of
standing to pursue a PAGA claim. We wrote that appellant, who
never worked for Owens, is not an “aggrieved employee.” An
aggrieved employee is “any person who was employed by the
alleged violator and against whom one or more of the alleged
violations was committed.” (Lab. Code § 2699, former subd. (c).)
A PAGA action is “brought by an aggrieved employee on behalf of
himself or herself and other current or former employees.” (Id.,
former subd. (a), italics added.)
PAGA allows “an enforcement action between the LWDA
and the employer, with the PAGA plaintiff acting on behalf of the
government.” (Kim v. Reins International California, Inc. (2020)
9 Cal.5th 73, 86; Turrieta v. Lyft, Inc. (2024) 16 Cal.5th 664, 681–
682 (Turrieta); ZB, N.A. v. Superior Court (2019) 8 Cal.5th 175,
185 [“All” PAGA claims “are brought on the state’s behalf”].) The
aggrieved employee “is asserting a ‘claim[] belonging to a
government agency.’ ” (Turrieta, at p. 682.)
Because a PAGA claim belongs to the state, appellant did
not inherit it. PAGA “does not create property rights or any
other substantive rights. Nor does it impose any legal
obligations. It is simply a procedural statute allowing an
aggrieved employee to recover civil penalties—for Labor Code
violations—that otherwise would be sought by state labor law
enforcement agencies.” (Amalgamated Transit Union, Local
1765, AFL-CIO v. Superior Court (2009) 46 Cal.4th 993, 1003.)
The employee “does not own” an interest in a PAGA claim. (Ibid.)
“The plaintiff is not even the real party in interest in the action—
the government is.” (Huff v. Securitas Security Services USA,
Inc. (2018) 23 Cal.App.5th 745, 757.)
8
Aggrieved employees’ ability to file a PAGA claim “does not
convert the state’s interest into their own or render them real
parties in interest.” (Turrieta v. Lyft, Inc. (2021) 69 Cal.App.5th
955, 972, affirmed in Turrieta, supra, 16 Cal.5th 664.) The
LWDA shares any civil penalty with employees. (Lab. Code,
§ 2699, former subd. (i) [LWDA receives 75 percent of the
penalty, aggrieved employees receive 25 percent of it].)
Appellant cites laws relating to the survival of a cause of
action for or against a decedent. (Code Civ. Proc., §§ 377.20,
377.34.) Survivorship laws do not apply to rights belonging to
the state government. Accordingly, an aggrieved employee’s
death necessitates dismissal of his or her PAGA claim. (Hargrove
v. Legacy Healthcare, Inc. (2022) 80 Cal.App.5th 782, 789–790.)
Lemus Sr.’s PAGA claim did not survive him.
Appellant cannot intervene in a representative capacity.
(Turrieta, supra, 16 Cal.5th 664.) Nor can he intervene to pursue
his father’s “individual PAGA claim.” (See Viking River Cruises,
Inc. v. Moriana (2022) 596 U.S. 639, 649 [142 S.Ct. 1906, 213
L.Ed.2d 179] [an “ ‘individual PAGA claim’ [refers] to claims
based on code violations suffered by the plaintiff”].) As we
explained in B341878, appellant cannot prove Lemus Sr. suffered
any Labor Code violations. The motion to intervene was properly
denied.
APPEAL NO. B343959
In this appeal, appellant challenges the court’s denial of his
motion to vacate the judgment. “A judgment or decree, when
based upon a decision by the court, or the special verdict of a
jury, may, upon motion of the party aggrieved, be set aside and
vacated” if the decision has an incorrect legal basis or is not
consistent with a special verdict. (Code Civ. Proc., § 663.)
9
Appellant must establish standing to appeal the denial of
his motion. “[O]nly parties of record may appeal; consequently
one who is denied the right to intervene in an action ordinarily
may not appeal from a judgment subsequently entered in the
case. [Citations.] Instead, he may appeal from the order denying
intervention.” (County of Alameda v. Carleson (1971) 5 Cal.3d
730, 736 (Carleson).) Appellant challenged the order denying
intervention. As discussed in B341875, ante, he had no right to
intervene and his motion was properly denied.
“ ‘Any party aggrieved’ ” may appeal a judgment. (Code
Civ. Proc., § 902.) “[O]ne who is legally ‘aggrieved’ by a judgment
may become a party of record and obtain a right to appeal by
moving to vacate the judgment pursuant to Code of Civil
Procedure section 663. [Citations.] One is considered ‘aggrieved’
whose rights or interests are injuriously affected by the
judgment. [Citations.] [The] interest ‘ “must be immediate,
pecuniary, and substantial and not nominal or a remote
consequence of the judgment.’ ” (Carleson, supra, 5 Cal.3d at pp.
736–737.)
Our Supreme Court has determined that when employees
settle a PAGA suit, coworkers with parallel PAGA suits cannot
move to vacate the judgment. Oversight of PAGA actions lies
with the courts and LWDA; nothing suggests the Legislature
intended to allow one aggrieved employee “to move to vacate a
judgment obtained by another aggrieved employee—representing
the same state interest—after a proposed settlement has been
submitted for review to both the trial court and the LWDA, and
the court has determined that the proposed settlement ‘is fair to
those affected.’ ” (Turrieta, supra, 16 Cal.5th at p. 711.) Absent a
10
right to vacate the Settlement, appellant is not aggrieved and has
no standing to appeal the denial of his motion to vacate.
Even if appellant has standing to appeal, his claims cannot
succeed. He writes, “The issue in this appeal is whether a
successor in interest to his deceased father’s claims under
[PAGA] may seek to vacate a judgment in a later-filed,
overlapping PAGA action.” As discussed in B341878 and
B341875, appellant has no personal interest in PAGA penalties
and cannot pursue his father’s claims. His motion to vacate was
properly denied.
11
DISPOSITION
The orders in B341875 and B343959 are affirmed.
Respondents are entitled to recover their costs on appeal.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED.
CHAVEZ, Acting P. J.
We concur:
RICHARDSON, J.
GOORVITCH, J.*
* Judge of the Superior Court of Los Angeles County,
assigned by the Chief Justice pursuant to article VI, section 6 of
the California Constitution.
12
Ti chiedi come si applica questo testo alla tua situazione?
Consulenza gratuita, senza impegno
Descrivi la tua situazione. Il nostro team ti ricontatterà via e-mail per la tua consulenza.
Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude
Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.