American First Credit Union v. Platinum Properties Investment Network CA4/3

CourtListener 10847277Calctapp23 apr 2026

Testo completo

Filed 4/23/26 American First Credit Union v. Platinum Properties Investment Network CA4/3

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS

California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not
certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been
certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION THREE

AMERICAN FIRST CREDIT
UNION,
G064901
Plaintiff and Respondent,
(Super. Ct. No. 30-2022-
v. 01255653)

PLATINUM PROPERTIES ORDER MODIFYING
INVESTOR NETWORK, INC., et al., OPINION AND DENYING
PETITION FOR REHEARING;
Defendants and Appellants. NO CHANGE IN JUDGMENT

It is ordered that the opinion filed on March 24, 2026, be modified
as follows:
1. On page 16, first incomplete paragraph, after last sentence
that ends in “we do not address the legal merits of its argument,” add the
following footnote:

In a rehearing petition, Platinum Entities
claim that none of the appellate briefs discussed the
theory that they made an “alleged tacit admission of
ROI’s claim.” They contend rehearing is required
under Government Code section 68081, so they can
brief this theory. However, there is no “right under
[Government Code] section 68081 to . . . be granted a
rehearing each time an appellate court relies upon
authority or employs a mode of analysis that was not
briefed by the parties. The parties need only have
been given an opportunity to brief the issue decided
by the court, and the fact that a party does not
address an issue, mode of analysis, or authority that
is raised or fairly included within the issues raised
does not implicate the protections of section 68081.”
(People v. Alice (2007) 41 Cal.4th 668, 679, italics
added.) The theory highlighted by Platinum Entities
was fairly included within the issues raised by their
opening brief. For example, they argued “[Platinum]
LLC was the only party with a present possessory
right to the interpleaded funds at the time this action
was commenced.” (Italics added.) Evaluating this
argument required analyzing whether ROI had a
present claim to the levied funds.
This modification does not change the judgment.
The petition for rehearing is DENIED.

MOORE, J.

WE CONCUR:

MOTOIKE, ACTING P. J.

SANCHEZ, J.

2
Filed 4/1/26 American First Credit Union v. Platinum Properties Investment Network CA4/3

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS

California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION THREE

AMERICAN FIRST CREDIT
UNION,
G064901
Plaintiff and Respondent,
(Super. Ct. No. 30-2022-
v. 01255653)

PLATINUM PROPERTIES ORDER MODIFYING
INVESTOR NETWORK, INC., et al., OPINION; NO CHANGE
IN JUDGMENT
Defendants and Appellants.

It is ordered that the opinion filed on March 24, 2026, be modified
as follows:
1. On page 1, delete “(Super. Ct. No. 30-2022-
01255635)” and replace with “(Super. Ct. No. 30-2022-
01255653)” in its place.
This modification does not change the judgment.

MOORE, J.

WE CONCUR:

MOTOIKE, ACTING P. J.

SANCHEZ, J.

2
Filed 3/24/26 American First Credit Union v. Platinum Properties Investor Network CA4/3
(unmodified opinion)

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS

California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION THREE

AMERICAN FIRST CREDIT
UNION,
G064901
Plaintiff and Respondent,
(Super. Ct. No. 30-2022-
v. 01255635)

PLATINUM PROPERTIES OPINION
INVESTOR NETWORK, INC., et al.,

Defendants and Appellants.

Appeal from orders of the Superior Court of Orange County,
Michael J. Strickroth, Judge. Affirmed.
Diefenbach Law Group and James C. Diefenbach for Defendants
and Appellants.
No appearance for Plaintiff and Respondent.
* * *
This appeal challenges the trial court’s orders (1) finding that
plaintiff credit union had the right to file this interpleader action,
(2) discharging the credit union from this proceeding, and (3) awarding the
credit union attorney fees. It arises from a $233,498.54 judgment that
defendants ROI Property Group Management, LLC and ROI Property Group
2, LLC (collectively, ROI) obtained against defendant Platinum Properties
Investor Network, Inc. (Platinum Inc.), which is a subsidiary of defendant
Platinum Properties Investor Network, LLC (Platinum LLC). Both Platinum
Inc. and Platinum LLC are run by Jason Hartman.
ROI sought to levy one of Platinum Inc.’s bank accounts at
plaintiff American First Credit Union (American First). American First
withdrew $233,498.54 (plus a $40 writ fee) from the account of Platinum LLC
rather than Platinum Inc. Hartman discovered this error and then engaged
in two contradictory actions. He demanded that American First return the
levied funds to Platinum LLC’s account. American First then reached out to
ROI to facilitate return of the levied funds. However, ROI provided American
First with proof that Hartman had told ROI to apply the levied funds to
satisfy the judgment ROI had against Platinum Inc. In other words, Hartman
wanted to have his cake and eat it too: he sought to allow ROI to keep the
levied funds in satisfaction of Platinum Inc.’s judgment debt while
demanding that American First reimburse Platinum LLC for the amounts
taken.
Despite the confusion, American First asked ROI to return the
levied funds, but ROI asserted the levy was proper because Platinum Inc.
was either the alter ego of Platinum LLC or had fraudulently conveyed the
funds to Platinum LLC to avoid paying the judgment. ROI only agreed to
return the levied funds to American First if it filed this interpleader action.

2
American First agreed and filed this action after receiving the funds from
ROI.
In this appeal, Platinum Inc. and Platinum LLC (collectively,
Platinum Entities) primarily argue the trial court incorrectly ruled that
American First was entitled to file this interpleader action. The thrust of
their argument is that the levied funds clearly belonged to Platinum LLC,
and American First should have returned them rather than forcing Platinum
Entities into this litigation. However, this argument overlooks Hartman’s
role in creating confusion over the funds’ ownership by both seeking their
return and having them credited to the judgment against Platinum Inc. As
another court has opined, “in litigation as in life, you can’t have your cake
and eat it too.” (Guess?, Inc. v. Superior Court (2000) 79 Cal.App.4th 553,
555.)
Platinum Entities also contend the trial court erred by denying
them a full evidentiary hearing on American First’s right to interplead.
However, they have not cited any authority showing they were entitled to
such a hearing. Nor have they shown any prejudice from the alleged error.
Finally, Platinum Entities claim that the trial court erred by
discharging American First from this action and awarding it attorney fees.
They claim the relevant statutes do not allow for a plaintiff to be discharged
and awarded fees. We disagree. Existing case law has rejected Platinum
Entities’ argument, and they have failed to adequately explain why this case
law is incorrect.
For these reasons, we affirm the relevant orders.

3
FACTS AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY
I.
LEGAL BACKGROUND
“When a person may be subject to conflicting claims for money or
property, the person [(known as a stakeholder)] may bring an interpleader
action to compel the claimants to litigate their claims among themselves.
[Citation.] Once the person admits liability and deposits the money with the
court, he or she is discharged from liability and freed from the obligation of
participating in the litigation between the claimants.” (City of Morgan Hill v.
Brown (1999) 71 Cal.App.4th 1114, 1122, fn. omitted.) “The effect of such an
order is to preserve the fund, discharge the stakeholder from further liability,
and to keep the fund in the court’s custody until the rights of the potential
claimants of the monies can be adjudicated.” (Dial 800 v. Fesbinder (2004)
118 Cal.App.4th 32, 42–43.)
“The purpose of interpleader is to prevent a multiplicity of suits
and double vexation. [Citation.] ‘The right to the remedy by interpleader is
founded, however, not on the consideration that a [person] may be subjected
to double liability, but on the fact that he is threatened with double vexation
in respect to one liability.’”1 (City of Morgan Hill v. Brown, supra, 71
Cal.App.4th at p. 1122.)
“[T]he interpleader proceeding is traditionally viewed as two
lawsuits in one. The first dispute is between the stakeholder and the
claimants to determine the right to interplead the funds. The second dispute

1 Double vexation means the interpleading plaintiff could face

multiple claims from the defendants over the thing, debt, or duty at issue.
(See Placer Foreclosure, Inc. v. Aflalo (2018) 23 Cal.App.5th 1109, 1115–
1116.)

4
to be resolved is who is to receive the interpleaded funds.” (Dial 800 v.
Fesbinder, supra, 118 Cal.App.4th at p. 43.)
II.
FACTUAL BACKGROUND
A. The Levied Funds
Platinum LLC is a Wyoming limited liability company that
functions as a holding company. One of its subsidiaries is Platinum Inc., a
California corporation that operates a nationwide real estate referral
network. Hartman is the manager of Platinum LLC and the chief executive
officer of Platinum Inc.
American First is a credit union that is authorized to conduct
business in California. Hartman opened separate bank accounts at American
First for Platinum LLC and Platinum Inc.
In December 2021, ROI obtained a $233,498.54 judgment (the
Fuller judgment) against Platinum Inc., in a case entitled Platinum
Properties Investor Network, Inc. v Fuller, et al., case No. 30-2018-00974280
(the Fuller action). The record contains a declaration from ROI’s counsel,
James E. Heffner (the Heffner declaration). The Heffner declaration states
that after entry of the Fuller judgment, Heffner spoke with Platinum Inc.’s
counsel and Hartman directly.2 They both informed Heffner that Platinum
Inc. did not have the funds to pay the Fuller judgment and offered to settle
“for amounts at and around $50,000.”

2 The record contains several direct communications between

Hartman and Heffner. It appears that Platinum Entities’ counsel authorized
Heffner to speak with Hartman directly.

5
ROI obtained a writ of execution on the Fuller judgment, which
identified Platinum Inc. as the judgment debtor. The Orange County Sheriff
(the sheriff) served a notice of levy on American First. However, American
First identified Platinum LLC’s account as the subject of the levy instead of
Platinum Inc.’s account.
On January 20, 2022, American First sent Platinum LLC a letter
stating that it had received a notice of levy from the sheriff and that it would
withdraw $233,498.54 from Platinum LLC’s account on January 28, 2022.3
The letter was sent to an address in Florida that was listed on the account’s
bank statements. American First received no response, so it paid $233,498.54
to the sheriff on January 28 (the levied funds).
B. Dispute over the Levied Funds
Platinum LLC did not receive American First’s letter before the
levy occurred. It learned of the levy on February 4, 2022, when an attempted
transaction was rejected for insufficient funds. Hartman contacted American
First, learned of the withdrawal, and informed American First that the
withdrawal was unauthorized. American First asked Hartman to contact the
sheriff. It is unclear whether Hartman contacted the sheriff, but he continued
to ask American First to restore the funds to Platinum LLC’s account.
The funds were not restored, so Hartman filed a Consumer
Complaint Form with the California Department of Financial Protection and
Innovation on February 9, 2022 (the consumer complaint). Hartman
complained that American First had levied the wrong account. He asked that
American First “return our $233,498.54 + interest/opportunity cost and legal
costs immediately or we will be forced to litigate.”

3 A $40 fee was added for issuing the writ of execution.

6
However, the day after filing the consumer complaint, Hartman
took a markedly different position on the levied funds. In an e-mail to Heffner
(the February 10 e-mail), he claimed the levied funds had satisfied the Fuller
judgment and asked Heffner to file a satisfaction of judgment in the Fuller
action. The February 10 e-mail reads, “Congrats on your collection! . . . Please
file a satisfaction judgement, notify the court [in the Fuller action] and
withdraw your motions. Please email copies to me. Also, I’m curious as to
why the hearing was held last week when you had already been notified that
the levy was collected.” Significantly, Hartman did not state that American
First had levied the wrong bank account.
On February 11, 2022, two days after Hartman filed the
consumer complaint, Platinum Inc.’s counsel informed Heffner that he would
apply ex parte for a satisfaction of the Fuller judgment if ROI did not credit
Platinum Inc. for the levied funds. Heffner replied that he had not yet
received the levied funds and ROI intended to acknowledge their receipt.
Again, Platinum Inc.’s counsel did not tell Heffner that the funds had been
levied from the wrong account.
American First called Heffner on February 14, 2022, and told him
Platinum LLC was claiming that the levied funds had been taken from the
wrong bank account and was threatening litigation if they were not returned.
The Heffner declaration states that “[a]t no time prior to this call from
[American First] did Mr. Hartman or his various counsel inform ROI that the
[levied] funds were taken from the wrong account or that they were
threatening [American First] if the funds were not returned.”
Heffner then e-mailed Platinum Inc.’s counsel. He explained that
the sheriff had not yet delivered the levied funds, but “I am informed that
your client is claiming the sheriff levied on the wrong account. The bank and

7
account were identified because that is where [Platinum Inc.] has deposited
checks written out to it in the past. I am not aware of why Platinum claims
the levied account is incorrect.” Heffner also expressed confusion as to why
Hartman had asked him to file a satisfaction of the Fuller judgment while
insisting that American First return the levied funds. Thus, he asked
whether “Platinum [Inc.] is claiming the funds were improperly levied
upon such that it seeks their return.”
Platinum Inc.’s counsel responded the same day. He stated, “I
have been back and forth with the client on this, so let me clarify this for all.
For purposes of resolving [the Fuller action], we are not protesting the
amount/funds levied here. . . . [W]e are not asking for that money and expect
such amounts to be reflected as we move forward with trying to resolve this.”
(Italics added.)
Heffner replied, “Thank you for . . . confirming [Platinum Inc.] is
not seeking the return of funds levied by the sheriff. I emailed because
[American First] asked for the return of funds today. My office will inform
[American First] that we will not return the funds and that Platinum is not
claiming they must be returned.” With permission of Platinum Inc.’s counsel,
Heffner shared with American First the above e-mail from Platinum Inc.’s
counsel that the levy was not contested. American First then asked Hartman
to withdraw the consumer complaint.
However, the Heffner declaration states that Platinum Inc.’s
counsel informed Heffner on February 16, 2022, “that Platinum LLC
intended to sue [American First] for return of the Levied Funds despite
offering to allow ROI to keep them in full settlement of disputes with ROI.”
Platinum Inc.’s counsel denied Heffner’s request to indemnify ROI from any

8
“claims by [American First] arising from Platinum LLC’s litigation against
it.” Nor would Platinum LLC waive its claims against American First.
On February 17, 2022, American First sent a letter to Heffner
stating it had taken funds from Platinum LLC’s account instead of Platinum
Inc.’s account. It requested that Heffner return the funds to the sheriff to
correct the error. The letter also advised that Hartman was disputing the
levy and intended to take legal action.
Heffner then e-mailed American First’s counsel, Alana Anaya.
Heffner attached the February 10 e-mail, in which Hartman had directed
Heffner to file a satisfaction of the Fuller judgment. Heffner noted that
“Hartman’s attorney” had threatened to file an ex parte motion to credit the
levied funds to the Fuller judgment. He also cited the other statements set
forth above by Hartman and Platinum Inc.’s counsel that ROI could keep the
funds in satisfaction of the Fuller judgment. Heffner explained that he had
directed the sheriff to the levied account because Platinum Inc. had deposited
checks there. Thus, Heffner believed the levied funds belonged to Platinum
Inc. regardless of the named account holder.
Heffner continued to engage in settlement discussions directly
with Hartman regarding the levied funds and other issues between ROI and
Platinum Inc. These settlement discussions included terms allowing ROI to
keep the levied funds, a cessation of enforcement efforts to collect on the
Fuller judgment, and a pause on interest accruing on the Fuller judgment,
among others. These discussions were still ongoing through the beginning of
April 2022.
While these settlement discussions were ongoing, Hartman
continued to demand that American First return the levied funds to Platinum
LLC’s account. For instance, in an e-mail sent on March 3, 2022, Hartman

9
told Anaya that “[w]e are really trying to avoid litigation but we cannot wait
much longer, we need [Platinum LLC’s] account replenished immediately.”
Anaya was also in contact with Heffner, who kept her apprised of the
settlement progress between ROI and Platinum Entities.
On March 16, 2022, Heffner informed Anaya that settlement
discussions between ROI and Hartman were “breaking down because
[Hartman] insists on recouping the money from [American First] while also
agreeing my client can keep it. With [ROI] making a claim on the [levied
funds], what is the process for providing it to [American First] to be
interplead and how can I assure [ROI] the funds will not simply be provided
to Platinum LLC?”
Anaya replied that the levied funds would be placed in a
segregated account and then deposited with the court. She then asked
whether ROI was interested in resolving this issue through an interpleader
action.
On April 6, 2022, Heffner tentatively agreed that an interpleader
action should be filed. However, he sought assurances from American First
that it would file the interpleader action and not return the levied funds to
Platinum LLC’s account. He asked for a statement that American First
understood there was a dispute over the levied funds and would interplead
them.
Two days later, Anaya sent Heffner a letter confirming that
American First “agree[d] to interplead the funds with the Orange County
Superior Court levied from the account held in the name of [Platinum LLC]
related to your firm’s collection of a judgment against debtor [Platinum Inc].”
Heffner informed Hartman of his intent to return the levied
funds to American First so it could file an interpleader action. He explained,

10
“[r]egarding the funds levied upon by the sheriff, I expect to have those filed
with the Court by the end of next week. I believe that is the proper response
to competing claims by Platinum LLC and [ROI].”
Months later, in November 2022, Platinum LLC filed a lawsuit in
Wyoming against American First asserting various tort and contract claims
allegedly arising from the levied funds.4
C. The Interpleader Complaint
American First filed this interpleader action and deposited the
levied funds with the trial court in April 2022.
ROI cross-complained against Hartman, Platinum Entities, and
another entity believed to be controlled by Hartman (the cross-complaint).
Generally, the cross-complaint alleged that Platinum Inc. had fraudulently
transferred funds to Platinum LLC to avoid paying the Fuller judgment. It
also claimed that Platinum LLC and Hartman were the alter egos of
Platinum Inc. and liable for the Fuller judgment.
Shortly after filing the cross-complaint, Heffner sent American
First a demand letter claiming it was the rightful owner of the levied funds
(the demand letter). The demand letter asserted the levy was proper because
the levied funds had been fraudulently conveyed from Platinum Inc. to
Platinum LLC. The letter also noted that ROI had only returned the levied
funds to American First under the express condition that they would not be
given to Platinum LLC absent a court order. Accordingly, “[i]f the Court
returns the Levied Funds to [American First], they must be returned to ROI.
Failure to do so will result in an action by ROI against [American First] for
various claims, including breach of contract.”

4 The current status of this case is unclear from the record.

11
American First filed the operative first amended complaint in
September 2022 (the interpleader complaint), which named ROI and
Platinum Entities as defendants (collectively, Defendants). The interpleader
complaint alleged that Defendants were asserting “multiple, conflicting
claims” on the levied funds that would subject American First “to double
liability and double vexation with this interpleader action.” The interpleader
complaint cited Platinum LLC’s demand for the levied funds, including
Hartman’s consumer complaint. It also attached the February 10 e-mail, in
which Hartman claimed the levied funds satisfied the Fuller judgment and
instructed Heffner to file a satisfaction of judgment. The interpleader
complaint also noted the cross-complaint’s allegations that (1) Hartman had
made fraudulent transfers between Platinum LLC and Platinum Inc., and (2)
the Platinum Entities were alter egos of each other.
The trial court overruled Platinum Entities’ demurrer to the
interpleader complaint.
D. The Interpleader Ruling
A hearing on American First’s right to interplead the levied funds
occurred on October 20, 2023. At the hearing’s outset, Platinum Entities
requested a full evidentiary hearing in which they could examine witnesses.
The court denied this request and limited the hearing to the evidence
included with the parties’ briefs. Based on this evidence, the court held
American First had the right to interplead the levied funds (the interpleader
ruling).
The court found American First was a disinterested stakeholder.
It was undisputed that American First had no claim to the levied funds while
ROI and Platinum LLC had each made competing claims to them.

12
The court also concluded American First had shown it was
subject to double vexation. Platinum LLC had already sued American First in
Wyoming over the levied funds. ROI also had claims against American First
based on (1) its agreement with American First to return the levied funds
only if it filed this interpleader action, and (2) its position that the levied
funds could be used to satisfy the Fuller judgment based on alter ego or
fraudulent conveyance. In support, the court cited the demand letter, in
which ROI had threatened to sue American First if it returned the funds to
Platinum LLC absent a court order.
E. Attorney Fees and Discharge
After the trial court found the interpleader action was
appropriate, American First moved to be discharged from this action and also
moved for $27,949.75 in attorney fees and cost. Platinum LLC opposed both
requests.
While the above motions were pending, it appears that ROI and
Platinum Entities reached a settlement. ROI withdrew its answer to the
interpleader complaint and withdrew its claim to the interpleaded funds. It
also concurrently dismissed the cross-complaint with prejudice.
The trial court granted American First’s request for attorney fees
and discharged it from the action (the discharge order). It later entered an
order disbursing the interpleaded funds (the disbursal order). The disbursal
order noted that given ROI’s notice of withdrawal and dismissal of the cross-
complaint, only Platinum LLC had a claim to the levied funds. Thus, the
court deducted $27,979.75 from the levied funds for American First’s attorney
fees and ordered that the remaining balance be sent to Platinum LLC’s
counsel.

13
Platinum Entities appeal the discharge order and the disbursal
order. They claim the trial court erred by (1) finding American First had the
right to interplead the levied funds, (2) awarding American First attorney
fees, (3) discharging American First from this proceeding, and (4) denying
them a full evidentiary hearing.5
No respondent’s brief was filed.
DISCUSSION
I.
RIGHT TO INTERPLEAD
“The trial court’s ruling is presumed to be correct on appeal, and
the burden is on the appellant to affirmatively show error.” (Starcevic v.
Pentech Financial Services, Inc. (2021) 66 Cal.App.5th 365, 374.) We review
the trial court’s factual findings for substantial evidence and its legal
conclusions de novo. (Fuller v. Tucker (2000) 84 Cal.App.4th 1163, 1169.)
Under the former standard, “we examine the evidence in the light most
favorable to the prevailing party and give that party the benefit of every
reasonable inference.” (In re Marriage of Drake (1997) 53 Cal.App.4th 1139,
1151.)
Platinum Entities make three arguments as to why the
interpleader action was improper. First, Defendants did not seek the same
thing, debt, or duty. Second, American First was not a disinterested

5 Platinum Entities also claim the trial court erred by overruling

their demurrer to the interpleader complaint. But none of their arguments
specifically address the court’s demurrer ruling. Nor does their notice of
appeal include the order overruling the demurrer. Thus, we will not address
the court’s demurrer ruling. (City of Riverside v. Horspool (2014) 223
Cal.App.4th 670, 679, fn.8.)

14
stakeholder. Third, American First was not threatened with double vexation.
These arguments are unpersuasive.
A. Same Thing, Debt, or Duty
To maintain a valid interpleader action, “the claimants [must]
seek the same thing, debt, or duty.” (City of Morgan Hill v. Brown, supra, 71
Cal.App.4th at p. 1123.) “If the claims do not relate to the same thing, debt,
or duty, then interpleader is improper. [Citation.] ‘[T]he very rationale of
interpleader compels the conclusion that [Code of Civil Procedure section
386] does not allow the remedy where each of the claimants asserts the right
to a different debt, claim or duty.’”6 (Ibid.) This standard is met because
Defendants all asserted claims on the levied funds.
However, Platinum Entities contend “[i]t is undisputed that
[Platinum LLC] was the only party with a present possessory right to the
interpleaded funds at the time this action was commenced.” They maintain
ROI had no present right to the levied funds because it had not yet litigated
its alter ego or fraudulent transfer theory. Thus, “ROI’s right to the funds, if
any existed, was a contingent, future interest.”
Platinum Entities’ argument is belied by the record, specifically
the actions of Hartman and Platinum Inc. While Hartman was demanding
that American First return the levied funds to Platinum LLC, he was also
insisting that they satisfied Platinum Inc.’s obligations under the Fuller
judgment. Indeed, over a year after American First filed this interpleader
action, Platinum Inc. filed a motion to compel satisfaction of the Fuller

6 Undesignated statutory references are to the Code of Civil

Procedure.

15
judgment in the Fuller action.7 By attempting to use the levied funds to
satisfy the Fuller judgment, Hartman and Platinum Inc. tacitly admitted
that ROI had a credible, present claim to the levied funds. Thus, when this
action was filed, it was not undisputed that only Platinum LLC had a present
possessory interest in the interpleaded funds. Because Platinum Entities’
argument is premised on an inaccurate factual predicate, we do not address
the legal merits of its argument.
B. Disinterested Stakeholder
Next, Platinum Entities assert American First was not a true
disinterested stakeholder. (Pacific Loan Management Corp. v. Superior Court
(1987) 196 Cal.App.3d 1485, 1489 [“It is the stakeholder’s avowed disinterest
in the interpleaded proceeds which gives him the right to interplead”].)
Rather, they claim American First is “a full-fledged adversary in a lawsuit for
draining [Platinum] LLC’s account of the very proceeds that [American First]
deposited in the interpleader action, scheming with ROI to keep funds from
LLC, and unlawfully disclosing financial details about LLC in the process.”
They further argue that American First filed this “sham interpleader for the
purpose of skirting liability for [its] own wrongdoing.”
Platinum Entities’ argument is based on a gross distortion of the
record. Examining the evidence in the light most favorable to American First,
the record shows Hartman was largely responsible for the conflict at issue.
Hartman demanded that American First return the levied funds to Platinum

7 Platinum Inc.’s motion to compel satisfaction of the Fuller

judgment was denied. The trial court explained, “[Platinum Inc.] urges this
Court to compel ROI to file a satisfaction of judgment even though [Platinum
Inc.] claims the funds paid towards that judgment do not belong to ROI and
were wrongfully levied. This argument defies common sense.”

16
LLC while simultaneously claiming that they satisfied the Fuller judgment
owed to ROI. Due to his actions, American First was reasonably unsure of the
levied funds’ proper owner. Its correspondence with Heffner was not part of a
“scheme.” Rather, we can reasonably infer that American First corresponded
with ROI in an attempt to identify the funds’ proper owner. It eventually
determined that an interpleader action was necessary.
More importantly, Platinum Entities have failed to cite any
evidence showing that American First ever asserted an interest in the levied
funds. The evidence only shows that it sought to transfer the levied funds to
their proper owner. As such, Platinum Entities have failed to show that
American First was not a disinterested stakeholder. (Farmers New World
Life Ins. Co. v. Rees (2013) 219 Cal.App.4th 307, 320 [interpleading plaintiff
that “never claimed in interest in the funds” was a disinterested
stakeholder].)
C. Double Vexation
“The right to the remedy of interpleader is founded on the
consideration that a person is threatened not just with double liability, but
with double vexation in respect to one liability. [Citation.] An interpleader
action, however, may not be maintained ‘upon the mere pretext or suspicion
of double vexation; [the plaintiff] must allege facts showing a reasonable
probability of double vexation’ [citation], or a ‘valid threat of double
vexation.’” (Westamerica Bank v. City of Berkeley (2011) 201 Cal.App.4th 598,
608.) Platinum Entities make several arguments as to why American First
did not face double vexation. None are convincing.
It is undisputed that Platinum LLC had claims against American
First based on the levied funds. While Platinum Entities contend that
Platinum Inc. “ma[de] no claim against the funds,” this is inaccurate. As set

17
forth above, Platinum Inc. claimed the levied funds satisfied its obligations
under the Fuller judgment.
American First also faced viable claims from ROI. ROI claimed
the levied funds had been fraudulently conveyed from Platinum Inc. to
Platinum LLC to avoid payment of the Fuller judgment. It only returned the
levied funds to American First under an agreement that American First
would file this interpleader action so the court could determine their proper
owner. American First faced a potential breach of contract claim from ROI if
it returned the levied funds to Platinum LLC instead of interpleading them.8
In response, Platinum Entities argue that the contract between
American First and ROI lacked consideration because ROI was legally
compelled to return the funds. In support, it cites a portion of the court’s
ruling in the Fuller action denying Platinum Inc.’s motion to compel
satisfaction of the Fuller judgment. In denying the motion, the court
explained, “ROI was legally compelled to return the levied funds as those
funds were improperly taken from [Platinum LLC].”
This argument is unpersuasive. First, Platinum Entities have not
explained why the court’s finding in the Fuller action has any bearing in this
interpleader action. Second, ROI and American First entered into their
contract over a year before the Fuller court’s statement above. At the time, it
was unclear whether ROI was required to return the levied funds. Indeed,
Hartman and Platinum Inc. were claiming that ROI should apply the levied

8 Platinum Entities also appears to argue that it was inequitable

to allow American First to enter into a contract with ROI for return of the
levied funds and then use that contract to establish double vexation. But, as
we explain in the next section, we find no inequity given the circumstances of
this case.

18
funds to satisfy the Fuller judgment. As such, ROI could reasonably believe it
had no legal obligation to return the levied funds when contracting with
American First. Platinum Entities have not explained why there was
insufficient consideration under these facts.
Next, Platinum Entities assert that American First had fully
performed its contract with ROI after filing the interpleader action. Thus, it
faced no viable breach of contract claim after filing this lawsuit. However, the
record indicates that under their contract, American First was obligated to
return the levied funds to ROI if the interpleader action was dismissed and
the funds were returned to American First. Thus, the contract was not fully
complete when American First filed the interpleader action.
D. Unclean Hands
Platinum Entities claim the unclean hands doctrine barred
American First from seeking interpleader relief. Specifically, they claim
American First levied the wrong account and then brought this action to
avoid liability. American First’s actions do not warrant application of this
doctrine.
“‘[I]nterpleader is an equitable proceeding in which the rights of
the parties, as between themselves, are governed by principles of equity.’”
(Shopoff & Cavallo LLP v. Hyon (2008) 167 Cal.App.4th 1489, 1513.) Unclean
hands is a defense “‘available in legal as well as equitable actions.’ [Citation.]
However, ‘the unclean hands doctrine is not a legal or technical defense to be
used as a shield against a particular element of a cause of action. Rather, it is
an equitable rationale for refusing a plaintiff relief where principles of
fairness dictate that the plaintiff should not recover, regardless of the merits
of his claim. It is available to protect the court from having its powers used to
bring about an inequitable result in the litigation before it.’ [Citation.] ‘The

19
doctrine promotes justice by making a plaintiff answer for his own
misconduct in the action. It prevents “a wrongdoer from enjoying the fruits of
his transgression.”’” (Meridian Financial Services, Inc. v. Phan (2021) 67
Cal.App.5th 657, 685.)
Allowing American First to bring an interpleader action does not
create an inequitable result. While American First may have levied the
wrong account, it was Hartman’s actions following the levy that led to this
interpleader action. After Hartman informed American First that it had
levied the wrong account and demanded return of the levied funds, American
First learned that he was also seeking to use the levied funds to satisfy the
Fuller judgment. Based on these contradictory actions, American First was
understandably unsure of the levied funds’ proper owner. Thus, it reasonably
filed this interpleader action to allow the court to make that determination.
II.
AMERICAN FIRST’S DISCHARGE AND ATTORNEY FEES
Platinum Entities contend that under the relevant statute,
section 386, only a defendant can be discharged from an interpleader action.
Likewise, since American First could not be discharged, the court erred by
awarding it attorney fees. (§ 386.6, subd. (a) [the court may award attorney
fees “[i]n ordering the discharge of [a] party”].)
This argument has been rejected by another appellate court. In
Southern California Gas Co. v. Flannery (2014) 232 Cal.App.4th 477, 492, one
of the defendants argued that “the court lacked authority to discharge [the
interpleading plaintiff] from the Interpleader Action because section 386 does
not authorize such a discharge.” The appellate court disagreed. It explained,
“[t]o the contrary, section 386.6, subdivision (a) authorizes the court to
discharge the interpleading party and award attorney fees before a final

20
judgment in the action.” (Ibid., first italics added.) Platinum Entities have
not explained why this holding is incorrect, and we will not make the
argument for them. (City of Riverside v. Horspool, supra, 223 Cal.App.4th at
p. 679, fn.8.)
Platinum Entities also maintain that the trial court abused its
discretion in awarding American First attorney fees because it forced
Platinum LLC to litigate this case instead of returning the levied funds. They
provide no authority stating that an award of fees under such circumstances
is an abuse of discretion. Further, as discussed above, it was reasonable for
American First to file this interpleader action. Thus, we find no abuse of
discretion.
III.
EVIDENTIARY HEARING
Finally, Platinum Entities assert the lower court erred by
denying them a full evidentiary hearing that included witness examination.
But they cite no authority entitling them to such procedures. Platinum
Entities cite Lincoln Nat. Life Ins. Co. v. Mitchell (1974) 41 Cal.App.3d 16,
19–20, which states that “‘[t]he first step is a trial or hearing by the court on
the issue of the plaintiff’s right to interplead. If the proof is sufficient . . . , the
court makes an interlocutory order. This directs the plaintiff stakeholder to
deposit the amount or deliver the property, and requires the defendant
claimants to interplead and litigate their claims among themselves.’” Nothing
in this passage reasonably pertains to the right to call witnesses at a hearing
on a plaintiff’s right to interplead.
Further, even if Platinum Entities were correct that the trial
court erred by denying them a full evidentiary hearing, they have not shown
any prejudice. They have failed to explain how a more favorable result might

21
have resulted had the court allowed them such a hearing. (Jones v. Farmers
Ins. Exchange (2013) 221 Cal.App.4th 986, 999.)
DISPOSITION
The discharge order and the disbursal order are affirmed.
Platinum Entities shall bear their own costs on this appeal.

MOORE, J.

WE CONCUR:

MOTOIKE, ACTING P. J.

SANCHEZ, J.

22

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.