People v. Saenz CA1/2

CourtListener 10799827Calctapp24 feb 2026

Testo completo

Filed 2/24/26 P. v. Saenz CA1/2
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication or
ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

FIRST APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION TWO

THE PEOPLE,
Plaintiff and Respondent,
A172268
v.
NATHAN SAENZ, (San Bernardino County
Super. Ct. No. FSB24001792)
Defendant and Appellant.

Nathan Saenz1 appeals from a judgment after a jury trial convicting
him of felony criminal threats, felony assault with a deadly weapon, and
misdemeanor disobeying a court order. Nathan contends that the trial court
erred by failing to sua sponte provide a jury instruction on the lesser included
offense of attempted criminal threats because substantial evidence showed
the victim lacked the requisite “sustained fear” and he was prejudiced by this
error. We disagree and affirm.
BACKGROUND
Nathan, Leopoldo, and Jaime Garcia reside on the same property in
San Bernadino. Garcia, who is Leopoldo’s nephew and Nathan’s cousin, lives
in a trailer in the backyard. Nathan, who is Leopoldo’s son, is the subject of

1 We refer to Nathan and his father, Leopoldo Saenz, by their first

names to avoid confusion; we intend no disrespect.

1
two restraining orders2 requiring him to stay at least 100 yards away from
the property and have no contact with Leopoldo and Garcia. However,
Nathan would “break[] the lock” or “break the windows” to get into the house
“when he just didn’t have anywhere to stay,” so Leopoldo would let Nathan
stay in a converted bedroom in the garage. This meant Nathan lived at the
house “practically” every day, “[e]ven though there’s a restraining order.”
On May 15, 2024, Nathan and Leopoldo had an argument at the house.
Around 9:00 or 10:00 a.m., Leopoldo called Garcia for help, but Garcia said he
could not assist until he finished work and told Leopoldo to call the police.
Leopoldo did not call the police and instead waited for Garcia to return
because his “lack of hearing and speech” makes it “always a problem for him
to understand what they’re telling him.”
When Garcia arrived home around 6:00 or 6:30 p.m., Leopoldo was
sitting on the porch. Using “vulgar words,” Leopoldo explained what had
happened; he said he had “kicked out” Nathan, but Nathan refused to leave.
Leopoldo directed Garcia to the garage bedroom “to tell [Nathan] that he was
not supposed to be there.” Garcia first went to his trailer to get something to
drink, after which he returned to the house and entered the garage bedroom.
Garcia found Nathan there with a friend, whom Garcia told to leave. After
the friend left, Garcia sat down on a chair and asked Nathan, who was

2 The first restraining order arose out of a September 2019 incident

during which Nathan was alleged to have stabbed Leopoldo with an ice pick.
A five-year restraining order issued on February 11, 2020, and prohibited
Nathan from contacting Leopoldo and coming within 100 yards of the
property. The second restraining order arose out of an unspecified incident
that resulted in the April 25, 2023, issuance of another five-year restraining
order that protected both Leopoldo and Garcia and repeated the direction to
stay at least 100 yards away from the property. Both restraining orders were
in effect during the May 2024 incident that led to the trial and conviction
that is at issue in this appeal.

2
standing by the bed about four to five feet away, “what was going on.”
Nathan began to get upset. Garcia told Nathan that Leopoldo did not want
him at the house and he was “not allowed to be here.” In response, Nathan
said he had “received a paper stating he owns the house and the house is his
and that if anybody should leave it should be” Garcia and Leopoldo. At that
point, Leopoldo popped his head into the room, and Nathan threatened to kill
him. Leopoldo left; Garcia did not believe Leopoldo heard the threat.
Garcia told Nathan to relax and “waived my hand at him” to “like
relax.” Garcia said, “I need you to leave. You’re causing too much problem,
leave. Your dad doesn’t want you here. I definitely don’t want you here.”
When Nathan refused, Garcia stated, “you’re aware we have a restraining
order against you, you shouldn’t be here.” But Nathan repeated it was “his
house, he can do whatever he wants”; he wanted Garcia and Leopoldo to
leave.
The “situation escalated”; Nathan was getting agitated and louder and
told Garcia to “get the fuck out of the room.” Garcia responded, “we cannot
continue this. This has gone too far.” Nathan was “irate” and told Garcia to
“get the fuck out of my room or else I’m going to kill you.” Garcia was “upset
too” and got “a little mad” and said, “this is not going to happen,” but “that
time [Nathan] got real mad, picked up a screwdriver and he waived it at me,
told me he was going to kill me.”
Garcia rose from the chair. He reflected, “I thought about my kids. . . .
If I don’t attack him, what if he gets the best of me” because he was fearful
for his life. Nathan held the screwdriver—which had a metal portion that
was four to five inches in length—in his right hand, extended it “fully out,”
and took a couple steps around the edge of the bed toward Garcia. Garcia

3
“shot out of the room.” He walked to the backyard, tried to compose himself,
and called 911 “about five minutes” later.
Responding officers were dispatched at 8:25 p.m. and arrived at the
house at 8:30 p.m. They conducted a records check and verified the five-year
criminal protective order issued on April 25, 2023, was still in effect. Officers
also located a screwdriver that matched Garcia’s description; the metal tip
was approximately five inches long, and it had a black and yellow handle.3
When speaking to the officers after the incident, Garcia represented he was
still “fearful” because of Nathan’s “aggressive demeanor.”
Nathan was arrested and ultimately proceeded to jury trial on a
criminal information alleging three counts: felony criminal threats likely to
result in death or great bodily injury (Pen. Code,4 § 422, subd. (a); count 1);
felony assault with a deadly weapon with force likely to produce great bodily
injury (§ 245, subd. (a)(1); count 2); and misdemeanor disobeying a court
order (§ 166, subd. (a)(4); count 3). The information further alleged 18
circumstances in aggravation under the California Rules of Court, rule 4.421.
At trial, Garcia testified Nathan had said, “I’ll kill you” “more than
three times.” Garcia had been “Scared. Fearful. . . . I really can’t iterate
how you feel at that time, you know what I mean, when your life is
threatened. It’s just something weird. That’s a feeling, anxious, get the hell
out of there, and I just bolted out of the room.” Garcia and Nathan had been
approximately three feet apart when Garcia fled. Garcia felt as though if he

3 Garcia described the screwdriver as a Phillips head, but the

photograph of the collected screwdriver that was admitted into evidence at
trial was a flathead. Garcia testified that he did not “recollect” if the
screwdriver in the photograph was the same screwdriver with which Nathan
had threatened him.
4 Further undesignated statutory references are to the Penal Code.

4
did not leave the room, Nathan would have acted on the threat. Garcia
estimated the interaction with Nathan lasted “15 or 20 minutes,” but he was
“not sure the actual time frame of everything that happened exactly within
that duration” including when he arrived home. Garcia said that they
conversed “for a while,” and he became fearful for his life about 10 minutes
into the conversation.
Leopoldo testified that he did not remember the incident and denied
that Nathan had harmed him before but also stated that Nathan breaks locks
and windows to get into the house, and “I can’t get him out. [¶] . . . [¶] He
hits me.” Although Leopoldo said he previously wanted Nathan out of the
house, at trial he explained, “Right now I want him to live in that room.
[¶] . . . [¶] He’s my son. He’s my son. If I were living in a cave I would want
him with me.”5
Pursuant to section 1101, subdivision (b), in order to show motive and
intent, the People also introduced evidence of two prior incidents involving
both Garcia and Leopoldo in 2019 and 2020. The first incident took place on
September 19, 2019, and began with an argument between Leopoldo and
Nathan about washing Leopoldo’s coffee cup. Nathan got upset and at that
point, “a physical altercation happened,” and Nathan put Leopoldo “in a
choke hold” and “stabbed him in the neck.” Leopoldo went to Garcia’s room to
ask for help; he had blood on his neck. Leopoldo “was babbling about Nathan
had attacked him” and brought Garcia to the kitchen, where Nathan was
standing over the stove holding a spatula.

5 Subsequently, the court granted the People’s request to introduce

Leopoldo’s prior statements to law enforcement detailing the different
incidents as “prior inconsistent statements.” These rulings are not
challenged on appeal, so we do not discuss them further.

5
Leopoldo entered the kitchen, swearing and trying to kick [Nathan] out
of the house. [Nathan] turned around answering him, defending himself.
There was a scuffle.” Garcia tried to intervene and “got in the middle of both
of them.” Nathan had an ice pick in his hand. Garcia noticed Leopoldo
“bleeding on his neck as I pulled him away.” Nathan tried to attack Leopoldo
again, and Garcia “pushed him real hard,” but when Nathan “came back at
it,” he poked Leopoldo’s arm with an ice pick. There was blood on Leopoldo’s
arm and neck. Nathan put Leopoldo “into a choke hold,” and Leopoldo fell to
the ground. Garcia helped Leopoldo back up, and Nathan “left to go back to
his room. He was not concerned of anything.” Garcia “rushed to [his] house”
and called the police. Responding police officers saw Leopoldo “had a
laceration to his neck area” and arrested Nathan but did not locate an ice
pick. Garcia testified he later found the ice pick “[o]n the bottom of the
kitchen table.” As a result of this incident, the above-referenced February
2020 restraining order issued prohibited Nathan from contacting Leopoldo
and directed him to stay 100 yards away from the property.
The second incident took place on August 1, 2020, when Garcia’s cousin
“ran to [his] room” and said Nathan was fighting with Leopoldo. Garcia ran
through the back side door into the house to find Nathan “throwing . . .
[s]ome pots and pans”; Leopoldo was “yelling at him to leave, get out of the
house, leave.” Nathan walked towards his garage bedroom, and Leopoldo
was “chasing him,” telling him, “no, you don’t go there, you go outside, get out
of here.” Nathan grabbed something from the dresser; it was a 10-inch knife
with a wooden handle that had gray duct tape on it. Nathan was waving it at
Garcia and Leopoldo, indicating for them to get out of the room. Nathan told
Leopoldo he had “better leave or else he was going to kill him . . . .” Nathan
was “irate,” “furious, mad, yelling, cursing at [them].”

6
Leopoldo left, but Garcia stayed and attempted to defuse the situation.
“[A]t that moment” the knife slipped from Nathan’s hand and landed on the
bed; Garcia grabbed the knife and walked out. Nathan said, “he had a gun at
his friend’s house down the street and that he was going to come back right
now with it,” but Garcia “wasn’t that fearful because I knew that he was
going to leave and I was already calling the police.” When the police arrived,
Nathan was gone. A responding officer testified that the February 2020
restraining order was in effect at the time of the incident.
At the conclusion of evidence, Nathan moved to dismiss counts 1 and 2
(violations of §§ 422 & 245, subd. (a)(1), respectively), pursuant to section
1118, arguing Garcia was “in a position of power and authority . . . and was
not sufficiently in fear of his life” and that “the waiving of a screwdriver” from
that distance “doesn’t rise to the level” of assault with a deadly weapon. In
the alternative, Nathan requested counts 1 and 2 be reduced to
misdemeanors pursuant to section 17, subdivision (b). After hearing counter-
argument from the People, the court denied the motions, concluding, “there is
substantial evidence that does prove beyond a reasonable doubt each of the
elements of those offenses” and noting, “when we look at the history of
conflicts leading to assaults, some of which involved weapons, probation,
protective orders being violated, ongoing course of conduct, I don’t think that
it’s appropriate to reduce[] the matter to a misdemeanor at this time.”
The jury subsequently found Nathan guilty of all three counts.
Following a court trial, the court found four factors in aggravation to be true
and also found several factors in mitigation. The court stated the
aggravating and mitigating factors “balance each other out,” denied
probation, and sentenced Nathan to the three-year middle term on count 2,
assault with a deadly weapon, and a concurrent two-year middle term on

7
count 1, felony criminal threats, for a total term of three years in state prison,
with custody credits of 268 days (134 days actual plus 134 days conduct). The
court denied probation on count 3, misdemeanor violation of a court order,
and gave Nathan credit for the custody time he had already served as a
“terminal disposition.”6 The court issued a new five-year restraining order
protecting Garcia and Leopoldo and directing a 100-yard stay away from the
property.
Nathan timely appeals.
DISCUSSION
Nathan contends that (1) the trial court erred in failing to sua sponte
instruct the jury on attempted criminal threats as a lesser included offense of
criminal threats, and (2) he was prejudiced by this error because the “jury
might have convicted [him] of attempted criminal threats without a finding of
reasonable fear, even absent actual fear,” requiring reversal. We disagree
because the evidence did not support such an instruction, and even if it did,
any error was harmless.
I. No Sua Sponte Instruction Required
“On appeal, we review independently the question whether the trial
court improperly failed to instruct on a lesser included offense.” (People v.
Souza (2012) 54 Cal.4th 90, 113.) “A trial court has a sua sponte duty to
‘instruct on a lesser offense necessarily included in the charged offense if
there is substantial evidence the defendant is guilty only of the lesser.’ ”
(People v. Shockley (2013) 58 Cal.4th 400, 403.) “[T]he ‘substantial’ evidence
required to trigger the duty to instruct on such lesser offenses is not merely

6 The court also terminated Nathan’s misdemeanor probation for

“disobeying a court order” in a different docket as “unsuccessful,” giving
Nathan credit for the time he had already served.

8
‘any evidence . . . no matter how weak’ [citation], but rather ‘ “evidence from
which a jury composed of reasonable [persons] could . . . conclude[ ]” ’ that the
lesser offense, but not the greater, was committed.” (People v. Cruz (2008)
44 Cal.4th 636, 664; see People v. Breverman (1998) 19 Cal.4th 142, 162,
overruled on other grounds by People v. Schuller (2023) 15 Cal.5th 237, 260,
fn. 7 [trial court errs if it fails to sua sponte instruct on a lesser included
offense which finds substantial support in the evidence].)
“In order to prove a violation of section 422 [criminal threats], the
prosecution must establish all of the following: (1) that the defendant
‘willfully threaten[ed] to commit a crime which will result in death or great
bodily injury to another person,’ (2) that the defendant made the threat ‘with
the specific intent that the statement . . . is to be taken as a threat, even if
there is no intent of actually carrying it out,’ (3) that the threat—which may
be ‘made verbally, in writing, or by means of an electronic communication
device’—was ‘on its face and under the circumstances in which it [was]
made, . . . so unequivocal, unconditional, immediate, and specific as to convey
to the person threatened, a gravity of purpose and an immediate prospect of
execution of the threat,’ (4) that the threat actually caused the person
threatened ‘to be in sustained fear for his or her own safety or for his or her
immediate family’s safety,’ and (5) that the threatened person’s fear was
‘reasonabl[e]’ under the circumstances.” (People v. Toledo (2001) 26 Cal.4th
221, 227–228 (Toledo).)
An attempted criminal threat is a lesser included offense of a criminal
threat. (Toledo, supra, 26 Cal.4th at pp. 231–232.) “ ‘[I]f a
defendant . . . acting with the requisite intent, makes a sufficient threat that
is received and understood by the threatened person, but, for whatever
reason, the threat does not actually cause the threatened person to be in

9
sustained fear for his or her safety even though, under the circumstances,
that person reasonably could have been placed in such fear, the defendant
properly may be found to have committed the offense of attempted criminal
threat.’ ” (People v. Chandler (2014) 60 Cal.4th 508, 515.)
“ ‘[S]ustained’ . . . means a period of time that extends beyond what is
momentary, fleeting, or transitory.” (People v. Allen (1995) 33 Cal.App.4th
1149, 1156 (Allen).)
Nathan “does not argue here that there was insufficient evidence to
support the jury’s verdict” on the criminal threats charge alleged in count 1.
Instead, he contends that even if there was substantial evidence to support
the criminal threats verdict, “there was also substantial evidence to support
the lesser-included offense of attempted criminal threats” because the jury
“could have concluded that [Garcia] did not experience sustained fear, despite
his challenged testimony to the contrary, given the prior history between” the
parties. Nathan asserts that at trial he argued that Garcia “did not act like
he was in fear” and, had the court provided the instruction, “then at least one
member of the jury may have had a reasonable doubt” about Garcia’s
sustained fear because it was an “equally plausible” lesser included offense.
Nathan further contends that the court had a sua sponte duty to instruct on
the lesser included attempt “even if any failure to request [it] by the defense
was arguably part of trial tactics.” Nathan argues the jury had “ample
grounds to find that he was not actually in sustained fear” because Garcia
had not been fearful in the prior incidents, “did not leave immediately” after
seeing Nathan with the screwdriver, and instead, “calmly left the garage.” In
fact, if Garcia returned from work around 6:00 or 6:30 p.m. but did not call
the police until approximately 8:25 p.m., Nathan contends that means about
two hours elapsed between the argument and when Garcia called the police,

10
which is a further sign of insufficient fear. Nathan also points to the court’s
“mus[ing]” that it might have reduced the charges to misdemeanors if not for
Nathan’s past incidents to support his argument that substantial evidence
supported a conviction for only a lesser offense. We are not persuaded.
Here, there was ample evidence that Nathan could not be found guilty
of only attempted criminal threats—and therefore no sua sponte jury
instruction for attempt was warranted—because Garcia testified explicitly
and convincingly that during the May 2024 incident, unlike during the prior
disputes, he was fearful for “a sustained period,” which, as Nathan
acknowledges, does not require a specific duration of time. (People v.
Shockley, supra, 58 Cal.4th at p. 403; Toledo, supra, 26 Cal.4th at pp. 227–
228.)
Garcia described Nathan’s increasing anger during the May 2024
incident and how the “situation escalated.” He testified that when Nathan
began “[a]ctually coming at [him],” he was “Scared. Fearful. . . . I really can’t
iterate how you feel at that time, you know what I mean, when your life is
threatened. It’s just something weird. That’s a feeling, anxious, get the hell
out of there, and I just bolted out of the room.” Garcia felt as though Nathan
would have acted on the threat if he did not leave the room; he was afraid
because of the “way [Nathan] came at me, the way he looked at me, his
anger.” Garcia explained, “the guy you see right now is cute and handsome,
[but] at that moment it was something I never saw in him.” Garcia “saw so
much anger in [Nathan’s] face. I saw something that was different that I
never seen. And like I said, you -- you have to experience something like
that, go through it, see it, in order to know what fear really is, and my -- I felt
my life was gone for a moment when I saw him coming at me.” Garcia
represented that he “never had that type of fear in my life. . . . [¶] He’s done

11
it numerous times, but this time it was more intense, more serious. . . . I was
angry, mad, nervous. I wanted to go back in there, but . . . I want to see [my
children and grandchildren] grow up.” “Even when the police got there[,] I
was still nervous” because of Garcia’s “aggressive demeanor” that was
“intense.”
In addition, Garia’s testimony detailing the difference between his
sustained fear in May 2024 and his feelings in September 2019 and August
2020 is supported by the factual differences between the charged incident
and the prior incidents. Most notably, Leopoldo was the target of Nathan’s
anger in the prior incidents, whereas here, Garcia was. Garcia testified there
had been “so many incidents” between Nathan and Leopoldo, including
“scuffles before.” Although Nathan and Garcia had had physical altercations
themselves where “sometimes [Garcia] won and sometimes [Nathan] won,” in
the September 2019 incident, Leopoldo had come to Garcia for help, and in
the August 2020 incident, another cousin sought Garcia for assistance after
Nathan began to fight with Leopoldo. In both prior incidents, Garcia had
acted as a pacifier, intervening and trying to “[de]fuse” the tension. But the
May 2024 incident was different; as Garcia testified, Nathan “came at me,”
and Garcia “saw something that was different that I never seen.” (See, e.g.,
Allen, supra, 33 Cal.App.4th at p. 1156 [a “victim’s knowledge of defendant’s
prior conduct is relevant in establishing that the victim was in a state of
sustained fear”].) Garcia was so shaken, he was “still nervous” after the
police arrived.
Nor does the evidence support Nathan’s claim that Garcia could not
have been afraid because he waited two hours after the incident to call the
police. First, fear does not necessarily end after a threat has passed. (See
People v. Culbert (2013) 218 Cal.App.4th 184, 191 [“Experiencing relief that

12
one has survived is not the same thing . . . as having one’s fear evaporate”];
People v. Melhado (1998) 60 Cal.App.4th 1529, 1537–1538 [calls to the police
are evidence that a victim is in fear of the defendant].) Second, the record
does not support Nathan’s claim of a two-hour delay. Garcia testified he
came back from work around 6:00 or 6:30 p.m. Then, he spoke with Leopoldo
about what had happened. Then, Garcia went to his trailer where he
consumed a can of Diet Coke. Then, Garcia returned to the house and found
Nathan with a friend. Only after the friend left, did Garcia begin his
conversation with Nathan that lasted “a while.” Garcia estimated the
conversation lasted 15 to 20 minutes, but he also stated that he was “not sure
the actual time frame of everything that happened exactly within that
duration,” including when he arrived home. Regardless, part way through
that conversation, Nathan became “irate,” grabbed a screwdriver, waived it
at Garcia, and threatened to kill him. As Nathan made clear, he “does not
argue here that there was insufficient evidence to support the jury’s verdict.”
It was after these threats that Garcia “shot out of the room” and called the
police. Though specific time estimates may be off, there was no mention of
delay. In fact, Garcia testified that he walked to the backyard, tried to
compose himself, and then he called the police “about five minutes later.”
In sum, it is Nathan’s own and different conduct that supports Garcia’s
testimony detailing his different and sustained level of fear in the May 2024
incident. (People v. Cruz, supra, 44 Cal.4th at p. 664; Allen, supra, 33
Cal.App.4th at p. 1156.) As such, the evidence of Garcia’s sustained fear
means that Nathan could not be found guilty of attempted criminal threats,
relieving the court of any potential sua sponte instruction obligation. (Cruz,
at p. 664 [The court must instruct “on lesser included offenses when the
evidence raises a question as to whether all the elements of the charged

13
offense were present, but not when there is no evidence that the offense
committed was less than that charged”].)
II. Any Error Was Harmless
Contrary to Nathan’s claim of prejudice, even if the absence of an
attempted threat jury instruction was error, it is harmless.
“Any error in failing to instruct on a lesser included offense is subject to
the harmless error test set forth in People v. Watson (1956) 46 Cal.2d 818”
(Watson), whereby “reversal is only required if it appears ‘reasonably
probable’ the defendant would have obtained a more favorable outcome had
the jury been properly instructed.” (People v. Perez-Robles (2023) 95
Cal.App.5th 222, 235 (Perez-Robles).) “[T]he Watson test for harmless error
‘focuses not on what a reasonable jury could do, but what such a jury
is likely to have done in the absence of the error under consideration. In
making that evaluation, an appellate court may consider, among other
things, whether the evidence supporting the existing judgment is
so relatively strong, and the evidence supporting a different outcome is
so comparatively weak, that there is no reasonable probability the error of
which the defendant complains affected the result.’ ”7 (People v. Beltran,
supra, 56 Cal.4th at p. 956.)

7 Nathan states, it “remains unresolved whether the erroneous failure

to instruct on a lesser-included offense amounts to a denial of federal
constitutional rights to be evaluated for prejudice on appeal under the more
stringent test set forth in Chapman v. California (1967) 386 U.S. 18, 24”
instead of Watson. However, his cited cases are inapposite as they concern
the narrow area of heat-of-passion instructions to be given in homicide cases.
(See, e.g., People v. Franklin (2018) 21 Cal.App.5th 881, 890–891 [“whether
the absence of instruction on heat of passion amounts to federal
constitutional error” governed by Chapman or constitutes an error of state
law only subject to Watson review remains unsettled]; see also People v.
Wang (2020) 46 Cal.App.5th 1055, 1071.) Our Supreme Court has made clear

14
Nathan cites People v. Racy (2007) 148 Cal.App.4th 1327, 1335, and
Perez-Robles, supra, 95 Cal.App.5th at pages 236–239 for the general
principle that reversal of the conviction for the greater offense is required
“ ‘if, “after an examination of the entire cause, including the evidence”
[citation], it appears “reasonably probable” the defendant would have
obtained a more favorable outcome had the error not occurred.’ ” (Racy, at
p. 1335.) “[I]n assessing prejudice, it does not matter that the jury chose to
convict the defendant of the greater offense over acquittal or that the
defendant was convicted of the greater offense on sufficient evidence.” (Ibid.)
“ ‘When a greater offense must be reversed, but a lesser included offense
could be affirmed,’ the People have the ‘option of retrying the greater offense,
or accepting a reduction to the lesser offense.’ ” (Id. at p. 1336.)
But Nathan’s citations do not further his claims. We do not dispute the
applicable legal standards or that a prosecutor may retry the reversal of a
greater offense or accept the reduction to a lesser offense. But we do disagree
that the cited cases, which involve “wobblers”8 where the trial court neglected
to provide misdemeanor instructions for the felony offenses charged bears
any true analogy to the instant case, which involves a lack of evidentiary
support for the lesser instruction now requested. (Cf., People v. Racy, supra,
148 Cal.App.4th at pp. 1334–1335 [“the evidence supporting the guilty

that Watson applies when a trial court has not sua sponte given instructions
for lesser-included offenses. (People v. Beltran (2013) 56 Cal.4th 935, 955
[“ ‘in a noncapital case, error in failing sua sponte to instruct, or to instruct
fully, on all lesser included offenses and theories thereof which are supported
by the evidence must be reviewed for prejudice exclusively
under . . . [Watson]’ ”].) We therefore apply Watson here.
8 “ ‘ “Wobbler[s]” ’ ” are crimes that “ ‘are chargeable or, in the

discretion of the court, punishable as either a felony or a misdemeanor.’ ”
(People v. Superior Court (Mitchell) (2024) 17 Cal.5th 228, 242.)

15
verdict of felony elder abuse was not so compelling that the jury instead could
have reasonably reached a guilty verdict of misdemeanor elder abuse”];
Perez-Robles, supra, 95 Cal.App.5th at p. 239 [the court agreed that
“ ‘Misdemeanor [sexual] battery was a readily available alternative [to felony
sexual battery] which would have been adopted by this jury’ had it been
properly instructed . . .”].)
Even Nathan recognizes the strength of the evidence that does not
make it “reasonably probable” an additional jury instruction would have
resulted in a different outcome, as he wisely “does not argue here that there
was insufficient evidence to support the jury’s verdict” on the charge of
criminal threats. Where “the evidence supporting the existing judgment is so
relatively strong, and the evidence supporting a different outcome is so
comparatively weak, . . . there is no reasonable probability the error of which
defendant complains affected the result.” (People v. Breverman, supra,
19 Cal.4th at p. 177.)
In sum, because Nathan does not demonstrate that “ ‘it is reasonably
probable a more favorable result would have been obtained absent the error’ ”
had the jury been instructed on the lesser included offense of an attempted
criminal threat, any error was harmless.9 (People v. Beltran, supra,
56 Cal.4th at p. 955.)

9 We also note that the court ordered the two-year sentence imposed on

count 1 to run concurrent with the three-year sentence on count 2, meaning a
reversal of the criminal threats (count 1) conviction would not change the
amount of time to be served in custody. However, we consider Nathan’s
claim of prejudice because we recognize that a conviction can have collateral
consequences that extend beyond the time ordered to be served. (See People
v. DeLong (2002) 101 Cal.App.4th 482, 492 [appeal from criminal conviction
is not moot because “to the extent the conviction continues to exist” defendant
“continues to suffer disadvantageous and prejudicial collateral
consequences”]; see also People v. Moore (1998) 69 Cal.App.4th 626, 630

16
DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed.

[potential “collateral” consequences may include “the possibility of enhanced
punishment in the event of a future conviction,” “the possibility of probation
revocation in another case,” and “limitations on the ability to earn conduct
and work credits while in prison”].)

17
DESAUTELS, J.

We concur:

STEWART, P. J.

RICHMAN, J.

People v. Saenz (A172268)

18

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.