In re Ethan B. CA2/1

CourtListener 10765574Calctapp26 dic 2025

Testo completo

Filed 12/26/25 In re Ethan B. CA2/1
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS

California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION ONE

In re ETHAN B. et al., Persons B345077
Coming Under Juvenile Court
Law. (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No. 24LJJP00305)

LOS ANGELES COUNTY
DEPARTMENT OF
CHILDREN AND FAMILY
SERVICES,

Plaintiff and Appellant,

v.

JOSE B.,

Defendant and
Appellant.

APPEAL from orders of the Superior Court of Los Angeles
County, Debra L. Gonzales, Judge Pro Tempore. Dismissed in
part, affirmed in part.
Janette Freeman Cochran, under appointment by the Court
of Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, Kim Nemoy,
Assistant County Counsel, and Peter Ferrera, Deputy County
Counsel, for Plaintiff and Appellant.

__________________________________

In 2024, plaintiff and appellant Los Angeles Department of
Children and Family Services (DCFS) filed a petition under
Welfare and Institutions Code section 300 on behalf of Aidan M.
and Audrey G. (children of mother Roxana B.) and Ethan B. and
N.B. (children of both Mother and defendant and appellant father
Jose B.).1 Father appeals the juvenile court’s orders: (1) finding
jurisdiction over Aidan, Ethan, and N.B.; (2) removing Ethan and
N.B. from his custody; and (3) ordering his visits with Ethan and
N.B. be monitored. DCFS states that, in the event we agree the
court erred in finding jurisdiction over Ethan and N.B., it cross-
appeals the juvenile court’s order striking Ethan and N.B. from
certain counts in the petition.
After appellate proceedings commenced, the court issued a
subsequent order that Father have unmonitored visits with
Ethan and N.B. Nothing in the record indicates any party
appealed this order. Therefore, Father’s appeal regarding
monitored visitation is moot.
We additionally conclude substantial evidence supports the
court’s orders finding jurisdiction over Aidan, Ethan, and N.B.,
and removing Ethan and N.B. from Father’s custody. Because we

1 Undesignated statutory references are to the Welfare and

Institutions Code. Mother is not a party to this appeal.

2
are affirming the court’s finding of jurisdiction over Ethan and
N.B., we need not consider DCFS’s contention of error.
Therefore, we dismiss as moot DCFS’s cross-appeal and the
portion of Father’s appeal regarding monitored visitation and
otherwise affirm.

FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
Mother has five children: Y.M.,2 Aidan M. (born September
2008), Audrey G. (born July 2010), Ethan B. (born March 2014),
and N.B. (born July 2019). Mario M. is the father of Y.M. and
Aidan, Jaime G. is the father of Audrey, and Jose B. (Father) is
the father of Ethan and N.B. Mother and Father met in 2012
and married in 2016.

A. DCFS Investigates a Referral

1. Initial Investigation
In September 2024, DCFS received a report that Aidan told
Y.M. that Father was sexually abusing Audrey by putting his
penis in her while she was sleeping. When Aidan told Mother,
Father “got mad” and tried to “put hands on” Aidan; Father also
tried to “change things around,” accusing Aidan of going into
Audrey’s room and pushing her. The reporting party stated that
“[r]ight before” Y.M. moved out of the family home in August
2024, Y.M. witnessed Father put his finger in Audrey’s vagina.
Additionally, the reporting party claimed Father committed
domestic violence towards Mother in the children’s presence, and
once hit Mother in the stomach when she was pregnant with N.B.

2 The record does not reveal Y.M.’s birthdate but notes she

was 18 years old in September 2024.

3
(a) Y.M.
A children’s social worker (CSW) called Y.M., who reported
an incident where Father punched a hole in the door to Aidan’s
room, after Ethan complained to Father that Aidan was being
loud. Y.M. heard Aidan say, “You’re dirty[,] you raped my little
sister.” Father then grabbed a phone charger and started hitting
Aidan. Y.M. then jumped on Father and told him to stop.
After this incident, Y.M. witnessed Father stick his fingers
in Audrey’s vagina. The sisters shared a room and one night,
Y.M. saw Father enter the room, go to Audrey’s bed, remove her
pants, and put his fingers inside of her. Y.M. did not know what
to do, so she said, “Audrey get up!” Audrey awoke, and Father
became angry. Although Audrey was very private, she revealed
to Y.M. that Father had “touched [Audrey] everywhere,” and
Y.M. recalled that she had previously heard Audrey “threaten
[Mother] about social workers.”
Y.M. recalled that when she was younger, Father “did that
to me,” disclosing that Father also removed her clothes and put
his fingers in her vagina. He touched “everything” on her body
and put his penis inside her vagina three to four times. Father
told her not to tell Mother, and Y.M. never did. Y.M. stated the
last time it happened, she was in middle school.

(b) Maternal Grandmother
The CSW spoke with the maternal grandmother (MGM),
with whom Y.M. was staying. MGM confirmed Y.M. had told her
the things she told the CSW, and MGM had told Y.M. that, if the
allegations were true, Y.M. needed to report it. MGM claimed
Father was controlling and forbade Mother from talking to
Mother’s sisters. MGM recounted a recent call in which Mother
was crying because Father “was cheating on Mother again” and

4
wanted to leave her. MGM told Mother she deserved better, but
Mother said she would not leave Father “because of economic
support.”

(c) Aidan
The next day, the CSW interviewed Aidan and Audrey at
their school. Aidan confirmed Father hit him twice in the leg
with a cell-phone charger, after Aidan refused Father’s demand
that he vacate the room he shared with Ethan and go sleep in the
living room. Aidan then angrily yelled at Father, “You’re dirty.
You raped my sister.” Aidan said that sometimes at night, when
he could not sleep and Mother was at work, he would hear
“sexual moaning from Audrey’s room,” which was next to his.
Once, when he opened the door, he saw Father sitting on the edge
of the bed, and Audrey facing the wall. Aidan also related that
Audrey had told him while crying that Father “stuck his penis in
her.” Aidan stated the last time he remembered seeing Father in
Audrey’s room was “a couple of weeks ago.” Aidan expressed his
belief that Mother knew of the situation because, the night
Father hit him and he accused Father of raping Audrey, Mother,
Y.M., Audrey, and Father “were arguing,” and Father “left the
house that night.” Father and Mother later told Aidan not to talk
to Y.M. because, if he did, Father “is going to go to jail.”
When asked when he last spoke with his father, Mario,
Aidan responded, “[Father] doesn’t let us talk to him.” When
asked how he was disciplined, Aidan said Father “disciplines him
with a belt, hanger, or charger” and the parents “also yell at
him.” He added Ethan “gets ‘whooped’ with a belt, but his
youngest brother [N.B.] does not.” Aidan claimed Father was
“nicer” to Ethan and N.B. and that Ethan would never say

5
anything bad about Father. Aidan also remembered Father
hitting Mother when she was pregnant with N.B.

(d) Audrey
When the CSW spoke with Audrey and asked if she had
ever seen Father hit Aidan, Audrey immediately said, “[Y.M.] is
making it up. She left the house because she likes going out and
doing her own thing. She’s mad at my parents. They are going
through a divorce but trying to make things work.” When the
CSW asked Audrey about her own observations, she denied
seeing Father hit Aidan, opining Aidan had “anger issues.” She
also stated “my dad [referring to Father] is not home a lot. He
works and then goes to the gym.” She claimed the parents
disciplined her and Aidan through yelling or taking away phones,
sometimes sending Aidan to his room; Ethan and N.B. never got
in trouble. She denied any domestic violence between Mother
and Father and any sexual abuse. She denied ever telling Aidan
Father raped her. When asked why Father went to her room at
night, she responded, “He lies on the bed with us and just goes in
to check on us.” Audrey added that sometimes they talked, and
sometimes Ethan was there, too. When the CSW recounted
Y.M.’s statement that Father “was in the room doing something
to Audrey and” Y.M. woke her up by yelling, Audrey denied it
ever happened.

(e) Mother
Later that day, the CSW was able to speak with Mother at
the family home. Mother explained Aidan “has autism and anger
issues.” Mother recounted that, on the day of the incident
between Father and Aidan, she reminded Aidan to do his chores
after she got home from work. Aidan, who was playing video

6
games, called Mother a “bitch,” and Mother “yelled . . . back.”
Aidan then grabbed Mother’s wrist and pushed her. Mother “got
scared of Aidan because when he is mad, he has no self-control.”
After Father returned home and learned what had happened, he
“got upset with Aidan and told him he had to respect” Mother.
Aidan responded by calling Mother a “puta” and punching his
door. Father called him ungrateful, and Aidan began insulting
Father and called him a rapist. Mother asked Aidan why he was
saying that, and Father said, “If I’m a rapist, here is my phone
and call 911.” Aidan would not call. Aidan said “he just felt like
saying it.” Father then took away Aidan’s laptop charger
“because they had an issue with Aidan staying up until 2am on
the laptop.” Mother denied Father ever hit Aidan. After the
incident, Mother stated she had a conversation with Y.M. and
Audrey about sexual abuse, and they denied Father “had done
anything to them.” Mother believed they would tell her “if
something was wrong because she had talked to them about
sexual abuse in the past.” Mother also denied any domestic
violence.
Mother claimed Y.M. “made up the entire referred
incident.” She said Y.M. “had been saying she was going to leave
since she turned 18” and wanted to live with MGM or Mario. She
explained Y.M. essentially moved out one day without telling her,
and when she called MGM to see if Y.M. was there, MGM began
insulting her, saying Y.M. did not want to live with her anymore,
and to accept it. Mother became upset when she learned Mario
was there, claiming Mario used drugs and hit her when Y.M. and
Aidan were young. Mother admitted MGM told her that Y.M.
claimed Father had raped Y.M., but denied Y.M. had ever told
Mother this information.

7
As for Audrey, Mother stated that when she picked her up
from school that day and learned the CSW had spoken with her,
she told Audrey to “tell the truth” and asked whether Father had
“do[ne] anything” to her; Audrey said he had not. Mother
claimed Father had never given her a reason to believe he “would
do anything to them” and swore she would have called the police
if she knew anything. Mother reported MGM has held a grudge
against Father since an incident in which Father “kicked MGM
out of [Mother and Father’s] home.” Mother claimed MGM had
threatened Father in the past, saying he would “pay” for what he
had done to her.

(f) Ethan and N.B.
The CSW also spoke with Ethan, who denied Father hit
Aidan or anyone else. N.B., who was two years old, was
uninterested in speaking with the CSW.

2. Aidan and Audrey Leave the Home
The CSW explained to Mother that, due to the inconsistent
statements provided by the family, DCFS needed to implement a
safety plan: either Father or Aidan and Audrey needed to leave
the home for seven days while the investigation progressed.
Mother vetoed Father leaving because he watched the children
when she worked. Mother then informed Audrey she would need
to leave the home, and Audrey refused. The CSW advised
Mother to look for friends who could help her; as she was doing
so, the CSW heard a large bang, and Audrey yelling, “Fuck you
bitch! I hate you!” Mother was “nonchalant” and explained
Audrey and Y.M. were now “fighting because of this.” Aidan also
refused to leave.

8
The CSW made suggestions for arranging the children’s
care, but Mother “had an excuse for everything.” After Mother
continued to have trouble arranging care for Audrey and Aidan,
the CSW informed Mother “a plan needed to be developed
forthwith, or the children could be taken into protective custody
due to immediate safety concerns.” The CSW explained part of
the plan would be to allow the children to receive a forensic exam.
Mother then said, “You do know that Audrey is having sex
already?”
When one potential solution for someone to watch Aidan
required a phone call to Mario, the CSW called Y.M. to get
Mario’s number. The CSW noted she was crying and asked why.
Y.M. explained “Audrey was mad at her because they were taking
her away and Audrey would not say the truth.”
Mother found someone to watch Audrey but refused to
permit Aidan to go with MGM or Father, stating she would prefer
DCFS put him into foster care. She eventually found another
friend to care for Aidan. After the children had packed, Mother
searched Aidan’s bag and removed his laptop and all electronics,
stating she did not want him to contact Y.M. or MGM.

3. DCFS Speaks With Father
The next day, a CSW spoke with Father. Regarding the
incident with Aidan, he explained Aidan was angry with Mother
for taking away his laptop and had pushed her and pulled her left
arm. When Father asked what was going on, Aidan tried to fight
him. When Father tried to unplug the laptop charging cord,
Aidan tried to stop him, and Father “possibly hit him with the
cord” on accident. Aidan then “became more defensive trying to
hit him” and Father told him, “If you hit me[,] you won’t be able
to handle me.” Aidan yelled back that Father was a “pervert”

9
and accused him of “go[ing] into the girls’ bedrooms all the time.”
Father responded it was his “duty” to go into the bedroom to
“check things are okay.”3 Father claimed Y.M. was present and
when he asked her whether what Aidan was saying was true, she
said it was not. Mother and Father then told Aidan if he
repeated himself in school, Father could go to jail. Father
claimed Aidan apologized to him later that night, and that he had
no further trouble with Aidan.
Father described Y.M. as “manipulative and unaware of
consequences.” He related an incident in which Y.M. falsely
accused a school bus driver of groping her because she wanted
Mother to drive her to school in a new car the family had
purchased. Father also claimed MGM told Y.M. if she ever
wanted something, “she had to play the role of a sexual abuse
victim.” Father asserted Aidan was easily influenced by Y.M.,
and Y.M. had told him if he moved in with MGM, he would get a
phone. Father said MGM “hates” him because years ago, when
MGM lived with them, she tried to take Y.M. and Aidan to see
Mario without telling them. When Father confronted her, MGM
“became offended” and claimed Father was just looking for an
excuse to kick her out. Father was unapologetic, and MGM
moved out. On her way out, she threatened that “at any
moment,” she could “fuck up [Father’s] life.” Father retorted, she
could only do so by lying, because he was not Mario or Jaime.

4. DCFS Speaks With Y.M. and MGM Again
On the same day the CSW spoke with Father, she received
a call from a sheriff’s deputy who stated the report would be

3 Father later told the CSW he went into the children’s

bedroom at night to go through their phones.

10
closed with “No Crime Suspected.” The deputy said other
deputies had interviewed Aidan, who now denied the allegations.
Mother also played a voicemail for the deputy in which Y.M. told
Father, “If you don’t leave my mom alone, I am going to tell
everyone you raped me.” The deputy opined Y.M. was upset
because Father “has a mistress” and wanted him and Mother to
“break up.”

(a) Y.M.
The CSW spoke with Y.M. at MGM’s home, asking her to
try to remember the sexual abuse incidents involving her. Y.M.
claimed Father began abusing her immediately after they began
living together, probably when she was in kindergarten. She
stated Father implemented a rule when Mother went to the store
that she could take only two kids. Once, when Y.M. was the child
not taken, Father suggested they play “mami y papi.” Y.M.
agreed and shared her dolls, and Father began touching her
vagina. Y.M. stated her memory was “blurred regarding those
events.” Y.M. asserted Father “stuck his penis in her multiple
times while growing up” and she was in middle school when he
stopped raping her. Y.M. said she was afraid to tell Mother, and
she did not learn she was raped until they watched a video about
sex in middle school.
Y.M. also reported that Father once hit Mother in the
stomach when she was pregnant with N.B. Y.M. stated Aidan
pushed Father—the record is unclear if this was part of the same
incident as Father punching Mother—and Father hit Aidan.
Y.M. characterized Father as “very bossy” and “nosey.” Y.M. said
she had told both Aidan and Audrey about Father’s abuse of her.
Regarding the incident with Aidan, Y.M. reported Father
asked Aidan for his computer after Aidan and Ethan were

11
arguing over it. Father then began hitting Aidan with the
charger. Y.M. told Father to stop, and Aidan began yelling
“rapist” and telling Father to leave the house. Y.M. told Father if
he hit them again, she would call the police and tell them what
he did to her. Mother then asked what they were fighting about,
and Y.M. told Aidan not to say anything and refused to tell
Mother both because she was not ready and because she had a
friend sleeping over and did not want the friend to wake up and
“hear the drama.”
Regarding the incident with Audrey, Y.M. claimed she was
awake in the room she shared with Audrey with the lights off
when Father slowly opened the door and “flashed his cellphone
light” at them to see if they were sleeping; Y.M. pretended to be
asleep. Father then walked toward Audrey’s bed and was
“shuffling her shorts.” From the light outside the bedroom door,
Y.M. could see Father “sticking his fingers in her.” Y.M. then
yelled, “Audrey get up!” Audrey woke up and Father ran out of
the room. Y.M. stated this was the first time she saw Father do
anything to Audrey. Y.M. said a few weeks later, she was
walking with Audrey in a park when Audrey told her Father had
“touched me everywhere, but I don’t care anymore and I don’t
want to talk about it.”
On the day Y.M. moved in with MGM and Mother called
looking for her, a maternal aunt who was present told Mother
that Father was a rapist, and she should leave him. Mother
became upset and hung up. The next day, Mother called MGM
crying because Father had a girlfriend. When MGM told her to
leave Father, Mother again hung up. Y.M. called Mother back
and told her the same thing; Mother hung up on Y.M., too. Y.M.
was “furious,” so she left Father a voicemail “telling him to leave

12
her mother alone, get out of the house, and leave or else she
would tell everyone that he raped her.” Mother then called Y.M.
back to tell her to leave Father alone.
Y.M. stated that “the other day,” Aidan called to tell her he
saw Father in bed “doing something” to Audrey; he was unsure
what. Y.M. also called Audrey’s boyfriend and asked whether
Audrey had ever said anything about Father. The boyfriend
related that Audrey claimed to have been touched by “one fat
man” and by Father, but said she did not care.

(b) MGM
MGM stated that, on the day she and Mario picked Y.M. up
from the family home, Y.M. cried and told her Father had been
raping her since she was little, when Mother was not home.
MGM told Y.M. that she needed to report it, that these were
serious accusations, and that, if she was lying, she could go to
jail.
Regarding Audrey, MGM stated she had also spoken with
Audrey’s boyfriend, who told her that Audrey said she had been
raped by “an older fat man with a mustache” and by Father.
MGM claimed the “older fat man” was her brother, Audrey’s
great-uncle. MGM said that, when Audrey was five, Mother
called her and asked, “Can you believe Audrey is saying that Tio
H[.] touched her?” When MGM told Mother to report it to the
police, Mother said, “What if she’s lying. Then this will create a
mess.” MGM also confirmed what Y.M. stated about her
conversations with Mother about leaving Father.

13
5. DCFS Speaks with Maternal Aunt
Veronica
Veronica confirmed being present when Y.M. told MGM
about Father’s sexual abuse. She stated Y.M. also said she had
told Mother about the abuse, and Mother had done nothing.
Veronica reported that when Mother first married Father, he
mistreated Y.M., Aidan, and Audrey, hitting them with a belt and
pulling on their ears. Mother “would never tell him anything.”

6. DCFS Speaks With Mario
Mario confirmed MGM’s account of picking Y.M. up and
hearing Y.M. accuse Father of sexual abuse. Mario added Y.M.
had previously stated she was being abused but had refused to
provide details. He was also present when Mother called MGM
and heard Mother accuse Y.M. of “inventing things.” Mario
offered to take Y.M. to the police, but she did not want to go.

7. Audrey Undergoes Forensic Interview
Audrey denied being abused by Father but based on her
responses, the interviewer suspected “something is happening in
the home.” “Audrey was quick to deny allegations about any
sexual abuse, inappropriate comments, and denied any comments
by [Father] that made her feel uncomfortable before the
interviewer even asked.” Although Audrey denied sexual abuse
by Father, she claimed she was abused by her maternal great-
uncle, something she said she had reported.
The CSW later learned from Nancy T., the family friend
with whom Audrey had been staying, that Audrey confirmed
Father and Aidan “had gotten in several physical altercations.”

14
B. DCFS Files a Petition
On September 24, 2024, the court granted a removal order
for the children. Aidan was released to Mario, Audrey was placed
with MGM, and Ethan and N.B. were placed with a paternal
great-aunt.
The next day, the CSW spoke with Audrey’s ex-boyfriend,
with whom she had broken up with four days ago. The ex-
boyfriend confirmed, two months ago, “Audrey confessed to him
that [Father] had been sexually abusing her since she was a little
kid. He reported that Audrey told him that [Father] touches all
her private areas. She told him that he does it at night when she
is sleeping. He denied knowing about actual penetration. He
reported that Audrey told him that [Y.M.] and Aidan knew
because she told them.” When asked why Audrey told a different
story, the ex-boyfriend reported Audrey also told him she did not
want Father to go to jail or the children to go into foster care.
The ex-boyfriend forwarded the text messages Audrey sent him,
describing the abuse. In the text exchange, Audrey stated she
had told Aidan and Ethan about the abuse but was unsure if they
believed her. According to the text messages, Audrey also told
Mother, but Father denied the accusations, and Mother did not
call the police.
In September 2024, DCFS filed a petition under section
300, subdivisions (a), (b)(1), (d), and (j), on behalf of all the
children. Count a-1 alleged Father physically abused Aidan,
striking him with a belt, hanger, and cell-phone charger. Count
a-2 alleged Mother and Father engaged in a “violent[,] physical
altercation” in Aidan’s presence, and Father struck Mother while
she was pregnant with N.B. Both counts alleged Father’s acts
placed the other children at risk of physical harm, too.

15
Counts b-1, d-1, and j-1 alleged Father sexually abused
Audrey—as well as the children’s now-adult sibling Y.M. when
she was a minor—and Mother knew about Father abusing
Audrey but still allowed Father access to her.
Counts b-2 and j-2 contained the same allegations of
physical abuse as count a-1, and counts b-3 and j-3 contained the
same allegations of domestic violence as count a-2, but
additionally alleged Mother knew of the abuse and failed to
protect the children by allowing Father access to the children.
At the detention hearing, counsel for DCFS asked the court
to keep the children detained from the parents, to permit Mother
to have monitored visits with the children, to permit Father to
have monitored visits with Ethan and N.B. only, and to order
Father to have no contact with Aidan and Audrey. Counsel for
Aidan, counsel for Audrey, and counsel for Ethan and N.B.
expressed their clients’ desire to return home to Mother—Ethan
and N.B. wanted to return to Father as well—but stated that,
under their duty per section 317, subdivision (e), they agreed or
would not argue against DCFS’s recommendation to detain the
children from Mother (and Father as well, in the case of Ethan
and N.B.).4 Mother’s counsel argued the children could be
returned home with safety measures put in place. Father’s
counsel asked the court to release the children into his and
Mother’s custody with safety measures put in place or, if the
court were not inclined to do so, to release them to Mother with

4 Section 317, subdivision (e) provides in pertinent part:

“When counsel is appointed to represent a nonminor dependent,
counsel is charged with representing the wishes of the nonminor
dependent except when advocating for those wishes conflicts with
the protection or safety of the nonminor dependent.”

16
safety measures put in place. The court found a prima facie case
to detain all children from both parents. The children were to
remain with the relatives with whom they were placed, with
DCFS being given discretion to place Audrey with Nancy T.,
whom she preferred to stay with. The court granted the parents
monitored visits.

C. DCFS Conducts a Pre-Release Investigation

1. Viviana C.
On September 30, 2024, a CSW received a call from one of
Mother’s friends, Viviana C. Viviana reported that her daughter
and Audrey were friends and once, after her daughter had slept
over at Audrey’s house, she reported to Viviana that Audrey kept
a knife under her pillow, and had warned her daughter to “be
careful.” During a second sleepover in February 2023, when both
Viviana’s children slept over at Audrey’s house, Audrey and Y.M.
slept in their room, and Viviana’s daughters slept in the office.
One daughter reported that, when she got up during the night to
use the bathroom, she saw Father in Y.M. and Audrey’s room
without a shirt. Viviana stopped letting her children sleep over
after that.
Shortly after the second incident, Mother had a weeklong
trip planned and asked Viviana if Y.M. and Audrey could stay
with her; Viviana agreed. Before Mother left, she insisted
Viviana not let Y.M. and Audrey go home under any
circumstances because “[y]ou just never know, you know?” After
driving Mother to the airport and returning to her home, Viviana
spoke with Y.M. and Audrey about sexual abuse and asked the
children whether Father had ever “touched” them. The girls
“quickly looked at each other and then looked down and said

17
‘No.’ ” After a little more probing and assurances they were safe,
Y.M. admitted Father “had been touching her since she was
‘little.’ ” “Audrey began to disclose as well. [Viviana] reported
that both girls shared with her that there were times that they
would wake up nude, or their underwear missing, and not know
how this occurred. She reported that Audrey told her that on one
occasion, she woke up and she had ‘oil’ all over her buttocks and
back. She stated that Audrey also said that it hurt to walk after.”
When Viviana asked when the abuse last occurred, Y.M.
stated she did not remember, and Audrey said “about three
weeks ago,” when Mother left for the store. Father came into
Audrey’s room and tried to take her pants off. Y.M. discovered
what was happening and pushed Father off Audrey, causing
them to “tussle[] a bit.” Mother returned home early because she
had forgotten something, and Father ran out of the room. Mother
saw Audrey was disheveled and asked if there was a problem;
Audrey said nothing had happened. Shortly after this incident,
Audrey and Y.M. were forced to share a room.
After the disclosures, both Y.M. and Audrey begged Viviana
not to say anything. Viviana told them she needed to tell Mother.
When Mother returned from her trip, Viviana “had a private
detailed conversation with her about what the girls had
reported.” Rather than express concern, Mother said, “They are
lying. They hate [Father] so much they are making things up. I
will talk to them.” Viviana and Mother became “very distant”
after that conversation.

2. DCFS Speaks With Mother
In October 2024, a dependency investigator (DI) spoke with
Mother as part of an ordered “Pre-Release Investigation.”
Mother denied the allegations, claiming “the information

18
provided was all a confusion and misunderstanding. Mother
minimizes the situation and reports that the information
provided by the minors was from a previous case with the father,
Jaime G[]. For instance, the mother reported that the minor,
Aidan observed father Jaime G[.] hit her while pregnant with
Audrey,” not Father. Mother denied any domestic violence
between her and Father, or any physical discipline by Father.
Mother denied any knowledge of sexual abuse by Father.
Although Father had moved out of the home, Mother and Father
continued to be in a relationship. DCFS concluded the children
would be at “high risk of abuse and neglect if they are released”
to Mother and recommended against it.
At the Pre-Release Investigation hearing, counsel for Aidan
informed the court Aidan preferred to live with Mario and visit
Mother on the weekends. Mother’s counsel stated she would
agree with Aidan’s request, as well as with Audrey’s request to
stay with Nancy T. The court ordered Aidan to stay released to
Mario and Audrey to stay placed with Nancy T., but ordered
DCFS to arrange overnight, weekend visits with Mother. The
court released Ethan and N.B. to Mother, while ordering them to
remain detained from Father.

D. DCFS Continues Investigating
The DI spoke with several individuals regarding the
allegations.

1. Mother
Mother maintained neither she nor Father ever hit the
children. Regarding the incident with Aidan, she repeated it was
an accident caused by Father and Aidan struggling over the
laptop charger. Mother also denied Father ever hit her—she

19
again claimed Aidan was confusing an incident in which Jaime
hit her when she was pregnant with Audrey. As for the sexual
abuse allegations, Mother stated they were untrue, that Audrey
had never told Mother anything about being abused, and that she
believed MGM made the allegations and she “is not sure why.”

2. Father
Father informed the CSW that he was adhering to his
attorney’s advice to keep silent.

3. Aidan
Aidan told the DI Father hit him with a computer charger
and claimed he could not walk for two days. Aidan stated this
was the only time Father hit him. Aidan said that while Mother
and Father would argue, he never heard or saw Father hit
Mother.
As for sexual abuse, Aidan recalled a time when Ethan and
Audrey were sharing a room, and Ethan told Aidan that Father
was “touching Audrey.” However, Aidan did not see anything
“inappropriate,” and Audrey never told Aidan about such abuse.
Y.M. told Aidan that Father would “touch Audrey” while Mother
was at work.

4. Audrey
Audrey claimed Father did not hit Aidan or any of the other
children. She also denied Father ever sexually abused her and
stated she never saw him abuse Y.M. As to the text messages
with her ex-boyfriend, Audrey said they were about her uncles,
not Father. Audrey admitted Father would go into her room and
lie down next to her, but claimed Ethan was also present.

20
5. Ethan
Ethan stated he was in the room when Father was
purported to have hit Aidan, and Father did not do so. He also
denied there were any physical altercations between Mother and
Father, and any sexual abuse by Father.

6. Y.M.
Y.M. claimed that, one night after Aidan yelled at Ethan,
she heard Father say, “I’m going to come to the room and whoop
you.” Father “got the charging cable and went inside Aidan’s
room.” Aidan then told Father, “Your nasty ass rape my little
sister [sic].” Y.M. heard Father hit Aidan, and she came out of
her room and cursed at Mother and Father. Y.M. stated “she was
going to open up” about what Father had done to her, “and he
laughed and said, ‘No one is going to believe you.’ ” Mother told
Y.M. she did not believe what she was saying.
Y.M. also saw Father touch Audrey’s vagina. She repeated
her claim that Father used to “put[] his thing inside of” Y.M.
Y.M. claimed she told Mother about it, but Father denied the
accusations. Y.M. also claimed she saw Father punch Mother
when she was pregnant with N.B.

7. Maternal Aunt Veronica
Veronica stated that, after the family moved to Lancaster,
she observed Father “mistreat the minors by hitting them and
pulled Aidan’s ear.”5 Veronica also had heard that, during the
incident with Aidan and the charger, “Audrey got a knife and told

5 While the record did not disclose when the family moved

to Lancaster, Y.M. said it occurred when she was in the seventh
or eighth grade.

21
[Father] to leave her brother alone.” Veronica did not witness
any domestic violence but “the girls” told her that Father would
hit, yell, and insult Mother. She also said she did not recall when
Y.M. first disclosed the abuse she was suffering, but it was “a
while ago.”

8. Maternal Grandmother
MGM told the DI the parents had promised Audrey a car if
she denied the allegations. MGM played a video of Y.M., Audrey,
and Aidan arguing in her home, and Aidan was heard telling
Audrey to tell what Father did to her.

9. Nancy T.
Nancy T. stated she saw Audrey send a text message to
Father that read: “I only want you to look at me as your
daughter and not touch me. Do not mistreat my mom.” Nancy T.
also stated she saw a message from Audrey’s ex-boyfriend to
Father stating: “You should be in jail for what you have done.”6

E. The Court Finds the Children Dependents
In a November 2024 last minute information, DCFS told
the court Audrey “tested positive for a medical condition that is
sexually transmitted.” Immediately prior to the initial
adjudication hearing (which was continued so the parties could
participate in a settlement conference), the court ordered that
Father, Ethan, and N.B. be tested for the same issue, over the

6 The record does not disclose how Nancy saw this message.

22
“vehement[]” objection of Father’s counsel.7 The court also
encouraged Mother to test for the same issue, although it did not
order her to do so.
In a December 2024 last minute information, DCFS told
the court that Audrey had received treatment for her medical
condition but that both Mother and Father had canceled their
appointments to be tested and had not rescheduled them. Aidan,
Ethan, and N.B. all tested negative. Y.M. tested positive. A
Public Health Nurse stated that both Y.M. and Audrey’s medical
condition was “early” meaning that “acquisition occurred 2023-
2024. ‘DPH has a confirmed diagnosis and clinical findings to
support sexual abuse vs. a verbal/historical report by a person.’
The medical condition is acquired through sexual contact by an
infected person.”
In another December 2024 last minute information, DCFS
told the court that a CSW had observed some of Father’s
belongings in the family home, and that both Mother and Father
confirmed that, when the case closed, he would return to the
family home.
At the January 2025 adjudication hearing, counsel for
DCFS asked the court to sustain each count brought in the
petition, pointing to Aidan’s and Y.M.’s statements that Father
physically abused Aidan and punched Mother in the stomach,
text messages Audrey sent to her ex-boyfriend about Father’s
sexual abuse, and statements from family friend Viviana about
Y.M. and Audrey informing her about Father’s sexual abuse, and
Mother’s inaction. Additionally, DCFS’s counsel pointed out that

7 On December 18, 2024, after Father filed a motion to

reconsider the court’s order that he test for the condition that
Audrey had, the court vacated its previous order.

23
sexual abuse of a girl did “not mean the risk is nonexistent or so
insubstantial that the court cannot take steps to protect the male
siblings from such abuse,” and that abuse of a stepsibling could
also indicate risk of abuse of biological children. Here, Father
was a father-figure in Aidan and Audrey’s lives.
Aidan’s counsel “largely” joined in the argument made by
DCFS’s counsel, except she requested the court dismiss the
counts based on domestic violence between Father and Mother
because there was insufficient evidence and there was no current
risk to the children.
Audrey’s counsel argued that Audrey was not at risk from
any physical abuse or domestic violence between the parents.
Audrey’s counsel also expressed his client’s position that the
sexual abuse did not occur, and that Audrey felt safe around both
Mother and Father. However, Audrey’s counsel added that, as
Audrey’s “CAPTA guardian ad litem,” he believed DCFS had met
its burden regarding counts b-1 and d-1 (alleging Father sexually
abused Audrey and Mother failed to protect her from the abuse).
Ethan and N.B.’s counsel asked the court to dismiss the
domestic violence counts, arguing there was insufficient proof
they occurred, and no evidence they put Ethan and N.B. at
current risk of harm. Counsel conveyed Ethan’s position that the
sexual abuse did not occur, and that Ethan felt safe around
Father, and then expressed his own request that the court make
a specific determination of risk as to each of his clients. Finally,
counsel asked the court to dismiss the physical abuse allegations
regarding Aidan as to Ethan and N.B., as DCFS had failed to
show a connection between those allegations and risk to Ethan
and N.B.

24
Father’s counsel asked the court to dismiss the petition in
its entirety. As to domestic violence, counsel argued it was
alleged to have occurred more than five years ago, and Aidan had
stated he did not witness any such violence. As to the physical
abuse of Aidan, Father’s counsel argued it did not occur and there
was no risk of harm to the children from the allegation. Finally,
as to the sexual abuse allegations, Father’s counsel again argued
it did not occur and there was no risk of harm to Aidan, Ethan, or
N.B.
Mother’s counsel also asked the court to dismiss the
petition in its entirety, arguing DCFS failed to prove any of the
counts. Counsel urged the court to believe Audrey’s denials of
sexual abuse and to discount the text messages to the ex-
boyfriend as a product of her anger toward Father for his
infidelity. Counsel also argued that even if the sexual abuse
occurred, there was insufficient evidence to conclude Mother
knew about it and failed to protect Audrey. Counsel echoed other
arguments that the domestic violence allegations did not occur.
Finally, counsel argued there was no evidence Mother failed to
protect Aidan from physical abuse.
DCFS’s counsel countered that in Audrey’s text messages,
she indicated she had told Aidan and Ethan about the abuse, that
the more reasonable interpretation of the conflicting evidence
was that the sexual abuse had occurred, and that the fact that
Father punched Mother several years ago did not mean the risk
had abated.
As to counts a-1, b-2, and j-2 (regarding Father’s physical
abuse of Aidan), the court dismissed count j-2, amended counts a-
1 and b-2 to strike allegations that Audrey, Ethan, and N.B. were
in danger, and sustained those counts as amended. The court

25
found the physical harm Father inflicted on Aidan was
nonaccidental and that “there is sufficient evidence to show that
there were items used, including a cell phone charger, a belt, and
a hanger, and that there were repeated infliction [sic] of the
injuries.”
The court dismissed counts a-2, b-3, and j-3 (regarding
domestic violence), finding that the conduct occurred, but the
evidence was “insufficient to show that the past conduct alleged
in those counts presents a current substantial risk of harm.”
As to counts b-1, d-1, and j-1 (regarding Father’s sexual
abuse of Audrey), the court sustained all three counts. The court
found significant the text messages Audrey sent to her ex-
boyfriend, Audrey’s admission of the abuse to Mother’s friend
Viviana, and the text message to Father that family friend Nancy
T. saw. The court also believed there was sufficient evidence to
find Mother knew about the abuse and failed to protect the
children. The court found that Aidan and Ethan were aware of
the abuse as shown by Audrey’s text messages, and all three
brothers were aware of Father’s and Mother’s denial the abuse
occurred. Discussing the sliding scale articulated by our
Supreme Court in In re I.J. (2013) 56 Cal.4th 766, the juvenile
court found “the magnitude of the harm is potentially very great”
and that “the abuse occurred while the other children, that is
Aidan, Ethan, and [N.B.], resided in the home.”

F. The Court Removes the Children
Turning to disposition, DCFS’s counsel asked the court to
remove Aidan from Mother and release him to Mario, remove
Audrey from Mother and Jaime, and remove Ethan and N.B.
from Mother and Father.

26
Aidan’s counsel agreed that he should be removed from
Mother and released to Mario.
Audrey’s counsel informed the court that Audrey wanted to
live with Mother full time, but Audrey’s counsel argued the court
should remove her from Mother and Father and maintain her
unmonitored visits with Mother.
Ethan’s and N.B.’s counsel informed the court that both
children wished to be released to Mother and Father, with Ethan
again reminding the court that he felt safe with Father.
However, counsel asked the court to remove both children from
Father and release them to Mother.
Mother’s counsel agreed that Aidan could be removed from
Mother and released to Mario. Counsel argued Audrey should be
released to Mother, citing the uneventful weekend visits that had
been occurring. Counsel also argued Ethan and N.B. should be
released to Mother.
Father’s counsel argued that because he was not living
with Mother, there was no current risk to Ethan and N.B., and
the court should release those two to him. If the court were not
inclined to do so, it should release them to Mother and grant him
unmonitored visits.
The court removed Aidan and Audrey from Mother and
Ethan and N.B. from Father.8 The court released Aidan to Mario
and released Ethan and N.B. to Mother. Father received
monitored visitation with Ethan and N.B., with the court
excluding Mother as a monitor.
Father timely appealed. DCFS timely cross-appealed.

8 The court also removed Audrey from Jaime.

27
G. The Court Terminates Jurisdiction
In August 2025, the court held a section 364 hearing,
awarding joint legal custody of Ethan and N.B. to both parents,
and sole physical custody to Mother. The court granted Father
unmonitored visitation with Ethan and N.B. but noted that
“[w]hile Father is incarcerated, the visits must be in compliance
with the rules or policies of Father’s facility.”9 The court then
terminated jurisdiction pending receipt of juvenile custody
orders. Two days later, the court received, signed, and filed the
juvenile custody orders and terminated jurisdiction.10 Nothing in
the record indicates any party appealed these orders.

9 The record is silent as to why Father was incarcerated.

10 Although the court awarded Father joint legal custody of

Ethan and N.B., his appeal is not moot because the court
awarded sole physical custody of the two children to
Mother. Were we to reverse the court’s finding of jurisdiction
over Ethan and N.B. due to Father’s actions, the court’s
subsequent order awarding sole physical custody to Mother
would potentially be erroneous as well (both because, if
substantial evidence did not support a conclusion that Father
abused the children, then substantial evidence also arguably
would not support a conclusion that Mother failed to protect the
children from Father and thus the court would lack a basis for
jurisdiction, and because the court’s exit order was presumably
based at least in part on a finding that Father abused the
children). Moreover, were we to reverse the court’s finding of
jurisdiction based on Father’s actions, Father could avoid the
negative consequences arising from DCFS’s requirement to
report Father’s abuse to the Department of Justice for inclusion
in the Child Abuse Central Index. (See In re S.R. (2025) 2025
Cal.LEXIS 7977, *2–*4 [DCFS’s requirement to report abuse
allegation to DOJ for inclusion in CACI renders case not moot].)

28
DISCUSSION

A. The Court Did Not Err in Finding Jurisdiction
We review jurisdictional findings for substantial evidence.
(In re T.W. (2013) 214 Cal.App.4th 1154, 1161–1162.) “In a
challenge to the sufficiency of the evidence to support a
jurisdictional finding, the issue is whether there is evidence,
contradicted or uncontradicted, to support the finding. In making
that determination, the reviewing court reviews the record in the
light most favorable to the challenged order, resolving conflicts in
the evidence in favor of that order, and giving the evidence
reasonable inferences. Weighing evidence, assessing credibility,
and resolving conflicts in evidence and in the inferences to be
drawn from evidence are the domain of the trial court, not the
reviewing court. Evidence from a single witness, even a party,
can be sufficient to support the trial court’s findings.” (In re
Alexis E. (2009) 171 Cal.App.4th 438, 450–451.)
Father argues the court erred in finding jurisdiction over
Aidan, Ethan, and N.B. We disagree.

1. Aidan
The court found jurisdiction over Aidan under section 300,
subdivisions (a) and (b)(1), because Father intentionally hit
Aidan with various items “including a cell phone charger, a belt,
and a hanger,” and “there were repeated infliction [sic] of the
injuries.” Father argues the court erred in finding jurisdiction
under section 300, subdivision (a), because Aidan did not suffer
serious physical harm and there was no history of repeated
abuse. The record belies his claim.
Aidan told a DI that after Father hit him with the charger,
he could not walk for two days. That constitutes serious physical

29
harm.11 Moreover, Y.M. stated she saw Father hit Aidan.
Maternal aunt Veronica stated when Father first married
Mother, he hit Y.M., Aidan, and Audrey with a belt and pulled on
their ears. Family friend Nancy T. told a CSW that Audrey had
confirmed Father and Aidan “had gotten in several physical
altercations.” That constitutes substantial evidence of repeated
abuse. “When a finding of fact is attacked on grounds that it is
not supported by substantial evidence, the power of an appellate
court begins and ends with a determination as to whether there
is any substantial evidence, contradicted or uncontradicted,
which will support the findings.” (In re Cheryl E. (1984) 161
Cal.App.3d 587, 598.)12

11 Father cites to Gonzalez v. Santa Clara County Dept. of

Social Services (2014) 223 Cal.App.4th 72 for the proposition that
“it is not unlawful for a parent to spank a child for disciplinary
purposes with an object other than the hand.” Gonzalez is
inapposite. There, the appellate court reviewed whether a lower
court had erred in substantiating a finding that a mother
committed child abuse under the Child Abuse and Neglect
Reporting Act when the Mother spanked her child on the
buttocks with a wooden spoon because her hands hurt and
spanking her daughter with her hand hurt the mother more than
the daughter. (Id. at pp. 75, 77, 80, fn. 8.) The appellate court
expressed no opinion on whether and when striking a child with
an object warranted jurisdiction under section 300.
12 Father also argues the court erred in finding jurisdiction

over Aidan under section 300, subdivision (b)(1) because there
was insufficient evidence that, at the time of the adjudication
hearing, Aidan was at current risk of harm from Father. Because
we find the court did not err either in assuming jurisdiction
under section 300, subdivision (a), we need not address this
contention. (See, e.g., In re I.J., supra, 56 Cal.4th at p. 773
(Fn. is continued on the next page.)

30
2. Ethan and N.B.
The court found Father sexually abused Audrey on multiple
occasions. It cited the text messages Audrey sent to her ex-
boyfriend, Audrey’s admission of the abuse to Mother’s friend
Viviana, and the text message to Father that Nancy T. saw. It
then found that Father’s sexual abuse of Audrey put Ethan and
N.B. at risk, too.
Father contends substantial evidence does not support the
court’s findings that Father sexually abused Audrey, or that
Ethan and N.B. were at risk from Father. We address each
contention in turn.

(a) Substantial Evidence Supports the
Court’s Finding that Father Sexually
Abused Audrey
Father contends the court erred in finding Father sexually
abused Audrey, citing Audrey’s denials that the abuse occurred
and arguing Y.M. and MGM “were motivated to get back at

[“ ‘When a dependency petition alleges multiple grounds for its
assertion that a minor comes within the dependency court’s
jurisdiction, a reviewing court can affirm the juvenile court’s
finding of jurisdiction over the minor if any one of the statutory
bases for jurisdiction that are enumerated in the petition is
supported by substantial evidence. In such a case, the reviewing
court need not consider whether any or all of the other alleged
statutory grounds for jurisdiction are supported by the
evidence’ ”].)
Father also argues substantial evidence does not support
the finding that Mother physically abused Aidan. Father fails to
demonstrate how this finding aggrieved him; he thus lacks
standing to appeal it.

31
Father.” Father expressly asks this court to “reweigh the
evidence and substitute its judgment for that of the juvenile
court.” That is not the function of an appellate court. As stated
above, “[w]eighing evidence, assessing credibility, and resolving
conflicts in evidence and in the inferences to be drawn from
evidence are the domain of the trial court, not the reviewing
court.” (In re Alexis E., supra, 171 Cal.App.4th at p. 451.)
“ ‘ “ ‘[W]hen two or more inferences can reasonably be deduced
from the facts,’ either deduction will be supported by substantial
evidence, and a ‘reviewing court is without power to substitute its
deductions for those of the trial court.’ ” ’ ” (In re Misako R.
(1991) 2 Cal.App.4th 538, 545.)
Father also argues that the text messages from Audrey to
her ex-boyfriend the court relied on were unreliable because
“[t]he context indicates the sender was not Audrey” as they
include the statement, “and Audrey even said it her self that she
didnt call the cops for [N.B.] and ethan and all and he was like
okay i understand [sic].” Presumably, Father is arguing Audrey
would not have referred to herself in the third person. First,
Audrey admitted she sent those messages. Furthermore, the
entirety of the text message in which “Audrey” was mentioned
was: “i repeated everything i told my mom and stuff in front of
him when he was saying it wasn’t him and he was saying that im
lying and stuff and he just kept on saying that we can do wtv we
want with him like sent him to jail or something yk or that he
can just move out nd my mom said no we’re not gonna do that
until we see that if was actually u and not adain and Audrey even
said it her self that she didnt call the cops for [N.B.] and ethan
and all and he was like okay i understand [sic].” In context, it is
reasonable to interpret the statement that “Audrey even said it

32
her self [sic]” to be part of what Mother said to Father, not
something the sender of the text messages said.13

(b) Substantial Evidence Supports
Finding Jurisdiction Over Ethan and
N.B.
“[A] father’s prolonged and egregious sexual abuse of his
own child may provide substantial evidence to support a finding
that all his children are juvenile court dependents,” including his
sons, even “when there is no evidence the father sexually abused
or otherwise mistreated the boys,” the boys “had not witnessed
any of the sexual abuse and were unaware of it before this
proceeding began,” and “[t]he boys said they felt safe in the home
and liked living with their parents.” (In re I.J., supra, 56 Cal.4th
766, 770–771.) In I.J., our high court concluded substantial
evidence supported the juvenile court’s finding of dependency
because the father’s behavior was “ ‘aberrant in the extreme’ ” in
that “ ‘he sexually abused his own daughter “by fondling the
child’s vagina and digitally penetrating the child’s vagina and
forcefully raped the child by placing the father’s penis in the
child’s vagina.” ’ ” (Id. at p. 778.) Our Supreme Court also
considered “the violation of trust shown by sexually abusing one
child while the other children were living in the same home and
could easily have learned of or even interrupted the abuse.”
(Ibid.) The court stated that “[s]exual or other serious physical

13 Father also argues that because the messages contain

the phrase “[I] didn’t get out because idk if he would do the same
to my sister,” this indicates Audrey did not send the message.
Father fails to explain why Audrey could not have been
concerned Father would sexually abuse Y.M.

33
abuse of a child by an adult constitutes a fundamental betrayal of
the appropriate relationship between the generations. . . . When
a parent abuses his or her own child, . . . the parent also
abandons and contravenes the parental role.” (Ibid.) The
Supreme Court concluded that “[t]he serious and prolonged
nature of father’s sexual abuse of his daughter under these
circumstances supports the juvenile court’s finding that the risk
of abuse was substantial as to all the children.” (Ibid.)
Here, while Audrey was not Father’s biological daughter,
he married Mother when Audrey was five or six years old, and
was likely in Audrey’s life at least from the time she was three
years old (when Ethan, Father’s biological son with Mother, was
born). Father played a parental role in Audrey’s life, and Audrey
called him “dad.” Like the father in I.J., Father’s abuse of
Audrey was also “ ‘aberrant in the extreme’ ” in that he
penetrated her vagina with both his fingers and his penis.
Further, he did so while other children were in the home and
could easily have learned of or even interrupted the abuse.
Indeed, there is evidence that Y.M. interrupted the abuse several
times, and that Aidan and Ethan were aware of the abuse.
Additionally, while Audrey denied the abuse, she admitted that
when Father lay in bed with her, sometimes Ethan would be
there as well. On this record, substantial evidence supports the
juvenile court’s finding that the risk of abuse was substantial to
Ethan and N.B.
Father argues the court erred in finding jurisdiction over
Ethan and N.B. because there was no evidence that Father
sexually abused either child or had a propensity to abuse boys.
But, as our Supreme Court found in I.J., these are not dispositive
factors.

34
Moreover, as the juvenile court noted, “[T]he magnitude of
the harm [to the other children] is potentially very great.” “[T]he
more severe the type of sibling abuse, the lower the required
probability of the child’s experiencing such abuse to conclude the
child is at a substantial risk of abuse or neglect under section
300.” (In re I.J., supra, 56 Cal.4th at p. 778.) Even if there were
a lower probability that Father would abuse Ethan or N.B., the
severity of his abuse of Audrey supports the juvenile court’s
conclusion that Ethan and N.B. were at substantial risk of harm.

B. The Court Did Not Err in Removing Ethan and
N.B. From Father
The court found by clear and convincing evidence that
Father placed Ethan and N.B. at substantial risk of harm and
there were no reasonable means to protect them short of removal.
Father argues the court erred in this finding because Father had
followed the court’s orders, Father had enrolled in programs
before he was required to do so, and Ethan had said he felt safe
with Father.
“ ‘On appeal from a dispositional order removing a child
from a parent we apply the substantial evidence standard of
review, keeping in mind that the trial court was required to make
its order based on the higher standard of clear and convincing
evidence.’ ” (In re I.R. (2021) 61 Cal.App.5th 510, 520.)
As discussed above, substantial evidence supports the
finding that Ethan and N.B. were at risk from Father because of
his sexual abuse of Audrey. Further, Father never admitted to
his abuse of Audrey. “One cannot correct a problem one fails to
acknowledge.” (In re Gabriel K. (2012) 203 Cal.App.4th 188, 197.)
Thus, whether Father followed court orders or preemptively
enrolled in programs, substantial evidence still supports the

35
court’s finding that Ethan and N.B. were at risk from Father
because he had not addressed the issues that resulted in their
removal.

C. The Issue of Monitored Visitation is Moot
Father contends the court abused its discretion in requiring
his visits with Ethan and N.B. to be monitored. DCFS disagrees.
We find the issue moot because, in August 2025, the court
granted Father unmonitored visitation with Ethan and N.B., and
nothing in the record indicates either party appealed this order.
Therefore, even were we to agree with Father, we can grant him
no effective relief. (See, e.g., In re D.P. (2023) 14 Cal.5th 266, 276
[“A case becomes moot when events ‘ “render[] it impossible for
[a] court, if it should decide the case in favor of plaintiff, to grant
him any effect[ive] relief” ’ ”].)

DISPOSITION
We dismiss as moot DCFS’s cross-appeal and the portion of
Father’s appeal relating to the court’s order of monitored
visitation with Ethan and N.B. The court’s orders are otherwise
affirmed.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED

M. KIM, J.

We concur:

BENDIX, Acting P. J. WEINGART, J.

36

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.