In re A.J. CA2/3

CourtListener 10764393Calctapp23 dic 2025

Testo completo

Filed 12/23/25 In re A.J. CA2/3
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS

California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION TWO

In re A.J. et al., Persons Coming B342504
Under the Juvenile Court Law. (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No.
24CCJP03159A-B)

LOS ANGELES COUNTY
DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN
AND FAMILY SERVICES,

Plaintiff and Respondent,

v.

I.J.,

Defendant and Appellant.

APPEAL from orders of the Superior Court of Los Angeles
County. Cathy J. Ostiller, Judge. Affirmed in part, dismissed in
part.
Benjamin Ekenes, under appointment by the Court of
Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, Kim Nemoy,
Assistant County Counsel, and Sally Son, Senior Deputy County
Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.

__________________________________________

In this juvenile dependency appeal, I.J. (father) challenges
dispositional orders made by the juvenile court. In particular,
father argues substantial evidence does not support the court’s
order removing his daughter and son from his care. Father also
argues the juvenile court abused its discretion when it ordered
monitored visits with his children.
After father filed his appeal, the juvenile court terminated
jurisdiction and ordered unmonitored visits for father, including
overnight visits. Thus, the visitation issue father raises on
appeal has been rendered moot. As to the removal order, we find
no error and affirm.
BACKGROUND
1. The Family
Father and A.W. (mother) have been together as a couple
for 15 years and married for five of those years. They have two
children, A.J. (daughter) and I.J. (son). When the underlying
proceedings began, daughter was ten years old and son was four
years old. Mother has an older adult daughter, S.C. (half sister),
from a different relationship. Although father is not half sister’s
biological parent, he considers her his biological child and
“practically raised her as his.”
Although mother and father were married, they did not live
together. Mother lived with daughter, son, and half sister.
Father visited them at home a few times a week and sometimes
stayed the night. Mother explained father did not live with them
“because she is currently under Section 8, and father is not on the

2
contract.” According to mother, father “bounces” between
different homes of relatives and friends.
Father joined a gang when he was a teenager. However,
for the past year or more, father, now in his thirties, had been
“staying away from the gang life” and was “focused on being a
family man.”
2. Events Preceding Petition
In August 2024, father was arrested after he physically
assaulted mother. The children were home during the
altercation. Son was asleep but daughter and half sister
witnessed some of the incident. Half sister called 911 prompting
father to leave the home. Soon after, mother heard a gunshot
from outside. Daughter saw father in the alley outside the home
shoot a gun approximately two times into the air.
Mother reported to the responding officers that father had
strangled her by grabbing her neck, pinning her against a door
and lifting her off the ground. Father held mother’s neck for five
to six seconds, during which time she could not breathe.
Daughter also reported seeing father pin mother to the wall with
both of his hands on mother’s throat. Half sister saw father push
mother into a staircase railing outside the apartment when
mother tried unsuccessfully to call police. Mother and daughter
both reported father headbutted mother two times in the head.
Daughter said this caused mother to fall backward in the chair
on which she was sitting. Mother told the officers this was not
the first incident of domestic violence. Mother declined an
emergency protective order.
The officers apprehended father nearby. Father
acknowledged his actions and expressed regret, stating “ ‘I
shouldn’t have put my hands on her.’ ” When questioned about
the gun, father stated both, “ ‘I tossed it, I gave it to a friend’ ”
and “ ‘I don’t carry guns no more.’ ”

3
A few days after the incident, the criminal court issued a
criminal protective order protecting mother and daughter from
father.
The Los Angeles County Department of Children and
Family Services (Department) opened an investigation. One
week after the altercation, a Department social worker spoke
with mother. Recalling the incident, mother stated “everything
happened so fast” and “was a bit of a blur.” She felt it was her
fault because she had angered father. She explained they were
experiencing financial stress and that night she was irritated and
tired. She said “she took out her stress and frustration on
father.” Although mother confirmed father had “put his hands
around her neck and pinned her into the door,” she said she could
breathe and did not lose consciousness. Mother also clarified she
believed father accidentally bumped into her head and did not
headbutt her. She said daughter did not appear scared during
the incident, but daughter did cry afterward because father had
been taken to jail. Mother did not believe the incident impacted
daughter because it was the only time she had seen domestic
violence at home.
Although mother confirmed she heard a gunshot after
father left the home, she noted there were “always shootings in
the area, so it could have been anyone.” Mother told the social
worker father did not own a gun and she had never seen him
with a gun. She said father was not an angry or violent person
and this was the first time she had seen him so upset. Mother
was not afraid of father and was not concerned for the children in
his care. She denied previous domestic violence incidents with
father and denied reporting that there had been earlier incidents.
She also denied an October 2023 incident that appeared in 911
call logs indicating police responded to her home after a call was
made that included “male in background

4
screaming/threatening/violent struggle heard then line
disconnected.”
Mother participated in a three-hour interview for a family
preservation assessment. The counselor who conducted the
interview “did not find any unusual or adverse outcomes.”
However, she reported mother minimized the level of domestic
violence. It was noted, “Mother appears to minimize and
overlook the severity of violence demonstrated by father; and the
traumatic impact this may have had on the children.” Although
mother identified the August altercation as the only incident of
domestic violence, an assessment summary also referenced the
Department referral which stated there was a history of domestic
violence. The assessment summary stated the parents were
complying with the criminal protective order but mother “expects
to reunite ASAP” and “plans to reunify with father ASAP.”
The Department social worker also spoke with father.
Father acknowledged he was wrong to grab mother by the throat
but he did not believe the incident was as severe as had been
reported. He indicated he and mother were under financial
stress, which exacerbated the situation and made it different
from past arguments. Father explained mother had referenced a
rival gang during their argument, which father interpreted as a
threat to his life. He said he did not intend to hurt mother. He
denied headbutting, choking, or hurting her. He denied grabbing
her throat with any force or pressure. Instead, father said he
grabbed mother by the throat and pinned her against the wall
because he was trying to get mother’s attention “for her to stop.”
He said it was a “one time incident,” mother could breathe, and
she did not lose consciousness.
Father also consistently denied owning a gun or firing one
into the air. He said he did not own weapons because he was not
allowed to after being arrested in 2022 on a gun charge. Father

5
explained he told law enforcement on the night of the incident he
gave the gun to a friend because he wanted law enforcement to
stop interrogating him about the gun.
Father acknowledged daughter, son, and half sister were
present when the incident took place. He said half sister told him
and mother to stop arguing and that they should not be fighting
in front of the children. He did not know if daughter or son
witnessed the incident. He did not believe the incident affected
the children.
After being released from jail on bail, father stated he was
“bouncing around” between relatives’ homes. He indicated he
could not stay with his mother (paternal grandmother) because
“there is no space available” there. Father was “open to
cooperating with the Department” and willing to participate in
services. He did not want to violate the criminal protective order.
The social worker also spoke with daughter one week after
her parents’ domestic violence incident. Daughter described
what she witnessed, stating “father was slightly picking up
mother by the neck.” She told the social worker she was scared
and screamed at father, trying to get him to stop. As father was
leaving the home, he said, “ ‘I’m going to kill myself.’ ” Father
appeared in the alley outside their home, where daughter saw
him shoot a gun into the air. Daughter “heard a pop.” This was
the second time daughter saw father with the gun. Daughter told
the social worker that night was the first time daughter had
heard mother and father argue. Daughter indicated she felt
better and the incident had not affected her.
Approximately one week after the social worker first spoke
with daughter, daughter asked to meet again with the social
worker. When they met for a second time, daughter changed her
statement about seeing father with a gun. She told the social
worker she had not seen father shoot a gun into the air.

6
Daughter explained she felt pressured to say that on the night of
the altercation when law enforcement responded to the home.
The social worker noted daughter’s body language was different
during their second meeting. The first time they spoke, daughter
“appeared relaxed, calm, and happy” whereas daughter
“appeared tense, nervous, and monotone” during their second
visit. However, daughter denied anyone had asked her to change
her statement.
The social worker also spoke with half sister. Half sister
did not witness the entire altercation. She came out of her room
to tell mother and father to stop fighting and that they should not
be arguing like that in front of the children. Half sister called
911 from the bathroom. She had heard mother and father argue
before, “but nothing like this night.” She did not see father pick
mother up by the neck or headbutt mother. Half sister did not
hear a gunshot that night and had not seen father with a gun.
The social worker also spoke with paternal grandmother
and a paternal aunt. The paternal grandmother said she saw the
children every day and cared for them while the parents worked.
Paternal grandmother was “very close” with mother and father.
She said this was the first domestic violence incident between
them and it “shocked” her. Paternal grandmother believed
mother and father had learned from the incident and that father
was remorseful. She also mentioned the financial pressure the
family was experiencing. She believed father picked up “bad
habits and morals” from his friends and would benefit from
parenting and anger management classes. The paternal aunt
told the social worker she saw the family once a week. She
believed mother and father’s recent altercation was their first
domestic violence incident.
Daughter and half sister both reported having a good
relationship with father. Daughter felt safe with father and said

7
she had “a tight knit” and “strong” relationship with him. She
called herself “ ‘daddy’s girl.’ ” Half sister said “father is an
amazing father” and “he basically raised her.” Half sister said
father was “a good father to the children,” cared for them, and did
“everything for them.” Mother similarly said father was an
“amazing” and “loving” father. Paternal grandmother believed
father was an attentive, affectionate, and protective father. She
had no safety concerns for the children. Similarly, the paternal
aunt said father was an “amazing” father and “very loving and
attentive” toward the children. The paternal aunt described
father as a “calm person” and not aggressive. She had no safety
concerns for the children.
Mother and father agreed to attend marriage counseling
and to live separately for the time being. They agreed to a safety
plan, which required them to comply with the criminal protective
order and allowed monitored contact between father and son
(whom the protective order did not cover). Father told the social
worker he and mother had agreed to fix and work on their
marriage.
In September 2024, father entered pleas of nolo contendere
to three misdemeanor charges stemming from the domestic
violence incident. The criminal court found father guilty of those
charges and sentenced him to probation. The criminal court
ordered father to complete a domestic violence treatment
program, an anger management program, community labor, and
a gun safety course. The court also entered a three-year criminal
protective order, again protecting mother and daughter from
father. The new criminal protective order allowed father to have
“peaceful contact” with mother and daughter in order to facilitate
visitation or exchange of children in compliance with a family,
juvenile, or probate court order. By late September 2024, father
reported he was participating in domestic violence and anger

8
management classes. The family appeared to be abiding by the
criminal protective order.
In early October 2024, the juvenile court denied the
Department’s request for an order removing the children from
father. The court determined the Department had not shown
there was no reasonable means to protect the children without
removal from father. The court pointed to the existing criminal
protective order and the parents’ compliance with that order.
3. Petition
In October 2024, the Department filed a two-count Welfare
and Institutions Code section 300 petition on behalf of daughter
and son.1 The two counts of the petition were brought under
subdivisions (a) and (b) of section 300. Both counts alleged
father’s domestic violence against mother put the children at risk
of harm. The subdivision (b) count also alleged the children were
at risk of harm due to mother’s failure to protect.
The Department asked the juvenile court to detain the
children from father. The Department noted not only did mother
and father minimize the severity of their domestic violence
incident and the impact it had on the children, but they also
intended to reconcile once the protective order expired. Although
mother and father had been abiding by the criminal protective
order, the Department did not believe that was sufficient to
mitigate identified risks because son was not protected by the
order. The Department argued monitored visits with father
would maintain the children’s relationship with father.
At the initial hearing on the petition, over father’s
objection, the juvenile court detained the children from father.

1 Undesignated statutory references are to the Welfare and
Institutions Code.

9
The children were released to mother under Department
supervision. The court granted father monitored visits with the
children.
4. Further Investigation
In early November 2024, a few months after the domestic
violence incident, a Department social worker again spoke with
mother. Mother reiterated what she previously had reported
about the August domestic violence incident. In some respects,
however, she adjusted her description. For example, mother was
not sure if father had lifted her off the ground when he grabbed
her by the throat and pinned her to the door. She also clarified
father “ ‘did . . . more of a push type of choke’ as he pushed her
away with his hands on her neck but did not hold on to her.” She
said father caused no marks or bruises and, although “ ‘it
probably felt like’ ” she could not breathe while father was
choking her, she explained she “ ‘was hysterical’ ” and “ ‘probably
over exaggerated [sic] at the time.’ ” Mother said they had never
had an argument like that before. She said daughter confided
she was trying to protect mother when she told law enforcement
father had a gun. Mother said daughter told her she did not see
a gun that night.
Mother was not fearful of father, did not think he would
hurt her again, and believed he had “learned his lesson.” She
said, “ ‘I want to be with my husband for sure. I love him. I
know he love [sic] me.’ ” Mother described father as “ ‘a great
father,’ ” a “ ‘protector,’ ” and “ ‘a great husband.’ ”
The social worker also spoke again with daughter in early
November 2024. Daughter could not think of anything she would
want to change about her parents. Daughter told the social
worker she had not seen father since the domestic violence
incident but, before that, she saw him “ ‘a lot.’ ” When asked
about the domestic violence incident, daughter stated she did

10
“not recall the incident” and did not remember how she felt
during the incident. Daughter said, “ ‘I think I was worried
about my mom, my dad. Because I don’t like them getting into
arguments.’ ” She had never seen or heard “incidents” between
mother and father before.
The social worker also spoke with mother’s sister (maternal
aunt). Maternal aunt recounted what mother had told her
concerning the domestic violence incident. According to maternal
aunt, mother stated father put his hands around her throat,
“ ‘[s]he blacked out and thought her life was going to end.’ ”
Maternal aunt also stated mother told her father had slapped
mother six months earlier. Maternal aunt did not want mother
to reunite with father “given she nearly lost her life.” She
believed mother took the situation seriously. Nonetheless,
maternal aunt had no abuse or neglect concerns regarding either
parent.
The social worker spoke with father as well. Father again
expressed regret for his actions, took responsibility, and said he
had learned a lesson. However, father continued to state he
neither choked nor headbutted mother. Nonetheless, and despite
previous denials, father admitted he had a gun that night. He
insisted, however, he did not shoot it in the air. He explained he
carried a gun for protection. He also acknowledged saying he was
going to harm himself that night. Father was not sure how the
domestic violence incident affected the children. He believed
daughter was “ ‘distraught’ ” without him physically there for
emotional support. Contrary to maternal aunt’s statement,
father denied slapping mother six months earlier. As of
November 2024, father did not have a permanent home and was
“couch surfing.”
Father wanted to work on his marriage and reunite with
mother. He took pride in being a father and a husband. He said,

11
“ ‘I know we can make this work.’ ” Father stated this was their
first domestic violence incident and they already “kind of moved
past it” because they had been able to share messages with one
another through paternal grandmother. Father worried the
dependency case was keeping the family separated and making
things harder on mother. He said, “ ‘I’m not doing my fatherly
duties’ ” and mother had to do everything on her own. Father
described mother as “ ‘the gel for our family’ ” and “ ‘very
supportive’ ” of father.
In its Jurisdiction and Disposition report, the Department
asked the juvenile court to continue court supervision over the
family, maintain the children’s removal from father and
placement with mother, and continue monitored visits for father.
Among other things, the Department was concerned that
daughter had recanted portions of her description of the domestic
violence incident and later could not remember any details of the
event, mother and father wanted to reconcile, and mother and
father both minimized the domestic violence they admitted
occurred as well as denied previous incidents despite reports to
the contrary.
5. Adjudication and Disposition
A combined adjudication and disposition hearing was held
on November 18, 2024. As to adjudication, counsel for the
children as well as counsel for the Department argued the court
should sustain the petition. It was undisputed the domestic
violence incident occurred and, given reports of previous less-
severe altercations between the parents, counsel for the children
expressed concern the domestic violence was escalating. Counsel
for the Department further noted father minimized the severity
of the incident. Counsel also explained the Department did not
oppose mother and father reunifying. However, the Department

12
wanted to be sure “they do so in a manner that’s safe for the
children and that there will be no more domestic violence.”
On the other hand, counsel for mother and counsel for
father urged the court to dismiss the petition. Counsel for
mother argued the August domestic violence incident was an
isolated incident, the evidence to the contrary was insignificant,
and there was no current risk to the children given father’s
criminal case and related protective order. Counsel for father
argued the children were not scared of father, father had never
been aggressive toward the children, and there was no current
risk to the children because of the criminal court’s involvement.
After hearing argument, the juvenile court sustained the
petition. The court noted the severity of the domestic violence
and found there was “at least . . . some prior domestic violence in
this family.” The court further found the Department had shown
current risk in the combination of the parents’ strong and
laudable desire to reunify and the short amount of time that had
elapsed since father began his criminal court programs. The
court wanted to be “satisfied that father has resolved his issues.”
As to disposition, counsel for father asked the court to
release the children to father with a safety plan or, at the least,
grant him unmonitored visits with the children. Counsel
reiterated father had never been aggressive toward the children
and the August domestic violence incident was “somewhat of an
isolated incident.” Counsel also stated although the parents
wanted to reunify, there were no immediate plans to move in
together and they were abiding by the criminal protective order.
Counsel for the Department, on the other hand, argued the
court should not yet release the children to father. Counsel
believed “this is without a doubt a reunification case and without
a doubt the children will be going back to the father as long as he
stays on track.” Counsel noted the relatively short amount of

13
time (three months) between the August domestic violence
incident and the disposition hearing. Counsel argued the
juvenile court needed more time “to feel assured that things
really have calmed down and things really are fine.” Counsel for
the children noted daughter wanted to be released to both
parents, but counsel could not recommend that and submitted on
the Department’s recommendations.
The juvenile court declared daughter and son dependents of
the court under subdivisions (a) and (b) of section 300. The
children were removed from father’s custody and care and were
released to mother. The court explained that it based its removal
order on the severity of the domestic violence at issue, that it
likely was not the first incident between the parents, the fact the
children were present during the incident, and father’s
minimization of the incident. The court believed father needed
“more time in his programs before it is safe to place the children
with him.” The juvenile court ordered father to complete a 52-
week domestic violence program and granted father monitored
visits with the children. The Department was given discretion to
liberalize his visits.
6. Appeal and Post-Appeal Orders
Father appealed the juvenile court’s November 18, 2024,
orders.
Almost one year later, on October 24, 2025, the juvenile
court determined its jurisdiction was no longer necessary. The
court granted sole physical custody of the children to mother and
joint legal custody to both parents. Father was granted
unmonitored visitation with the children, including overnight
visits. The court stayed termination of its jurisdiction pending
receipt of the final custody order. On October 28, 2025, the

14
juvenile court received and filed the final custody order and
terminated its jurisdiction.2
DISCUSSION
1. Removal
a. Applicable Law and Standard of Review
When a child has been adjudged a dependent of the court
within the meaning of section 300, the juvenile court “may limit
the control to be exercised over the dependent child by any
parent” if necessary to protect the child. (§ 361, subd. (a)(1).)
Subdivision (d) of section 361 provides in part, “A dependent child
shall not be taken from the physical custody of their parents . . .
with whom the child did not reside at the time the petition was
initiated, unless the juvenile court finds clear and convincing
evidence that there would be a substantial danger to the physical
health, safety, protection, or physical or emotional well-being of
the child for the parent . . . to live with the child or otherwise
exercise the parent’s . . . right to physical custody, and there are
no reasonable means by which the child’s physical and emotional
health can be protected without removing the child from the
child’s parent’s . . . physical custody.” The juvenile court must
both determine “whether reasonable efforts were made to prevent
or to eliminate the need for removal of the minor from their
home” and “state the facts on which the decision to remove the
minor is based.” (§ 361, subd. (e).)
“ ‘ “The parent need not be dangerous and the minor need
not have been actually harmed before removal is appropriate.

2 We grant the Department’s October 30, 2025, motion for
judicial notice, through which the Department sought judicial
notice of the juvenile court’s October 24, 2025, orders. On our
own motion, we take judicial notice of the juvenile court’s
October 28, 2025, orders.

15
The focus of the statute is on averting harm to the child.” ’ ” (In
re A.S. (2011) 202 Cal.App.4th 237, 247, disapproved on another
ground by Conservatorship of O.B. (2020) 9 Cal.5th 989, 1010,
fn. 7 (O.B.).) In making its determination, the juvenile court may
consider the parent’s past conduct, present circumstances, and
“the parent’s response to the conditions that gave rise to juvenile
court intervention.” (In re D.B. (2018) 26 Cal.App.5th 320, 332.)
We review the juvenile court’s removal order under the
substantial evidence standard of review, bearing in mind the
heightened burden of proof by clear and convincing evidence.
(O.B., supra, 9 Cal.5th at pp. 1011–1012; In re I.J. (2013) 56
Cal.4th 766, 773; In re A.F. (2016) 3 Cal.App.5th 283, 292; see In
re V.L. (2020) 54 Cal.App.5th 147, 155 [“O.B. is controlling in
dependency cases”].) “When reviewing a finding that a fact has
been proved by clear and convincing evidence, the question before
the appellate court is whether the record as a whole contains
substantial evidence from which a reasonable fact finder could
have found it highly probable that the fact was true. In
conducting its review, the court must view the record in the light
most favorable to the prevailing party below and give appropriate
deference to how the trier of fact may have evaluated the
credibility of witnesses, resolved conflicts in the evidence, and
drawn reasonable inferences from the evidence.” (O.B., supra, 9
Cal.5th at pp. 1011–1012.)
b. Substantial evidence supports the removal
order.
Father argues substantial evidence does not support the
juvenile court’s order removing the children from his custody.
Specifically, father contends substantial evidence did not support
a finding either that there would be a substantial danger of harm
to the children if released to him, or that there were no
reasonable alternatives to removal. We are not persuaded.

16
Father highlights evidence that weighs against the juvenile
court’s decision to remove the children from his custody. For
example, father generally responded well to the juvenile court’s
intervention. He was cooperative, had enrolled in domestic
violence treatment and anger management programs as required
by the criminal court, and showed some insight into his actions.
He and mother were abiding by the existing criminal protective
order. Father expressed love for and dedication to his children as
well as remorse and accountability for the domestic violence
against mother. Father also notes there was a lack of evidence
that he was a violent person generally.
On the other hand, however, other evidence supports the
juvenile court’s decision to remove the children from father. As
father does not challenge the jurisdictional findings, it is
undisputed father violently attacked mother, causing her to be
unable to breathe while he pinned her against a door and choked
her and then headbutted her twice. Moreover, father had a gun
with him the evening of the domestic violence incident, a fact
about which he lied repeatedly only later to admit he did in fact
have a gun with him that night. In addition, the children were
present during the altercation, during which daughter was
scared, screaming and, without success, begging her parents to
stop fighting. On his way out of the home, father declared that
he was going to kill himself, then he shot his gun into the air in
the alley outside, all of which daughter heard and witnessed.
The severity of the incident cannot reasonably be disputed.
Despite the severity of the domestic violence incident,
father downplayed aspects of it. He insisted, for example, that he
did not apply force or pressure when he grabbed mother’s neck
with both of his hands but was only trying to get her attention
“for her to stop.” He also denied headbutting mother, although
mother and daughter both said otherwise when describing the

17
incident to law enforcement. Although father denies it, the
juvenile court considered the evidence and found the August 2025
incident was not the first domestic violence incident between
mother and father, although it was the most violent. By
continuing to minimize the incident, father revealed a lack of
understanding of the seriousness of the matter. As the juvenile
court and Department indicated below, only three months had
passed between the domestic violence incident and the
disposition hearing. It was reasonable for the juvenile court to
determine father needed more time to participate in his programs
before it was safe to release the children to him.
In effect, father asks us to reweigh the evidence. This we
cannot do. “ ‘The power of the appellate court begins and ends
with a determination as to whether there is any substantial
evidence, contradicted or uncontradicted, which will support the
conclusion reached by the trier of fact.’ ” (In re A.F. (2016) 3
Cal.App.5th 283, 289.)
Father also argues it was internally contradictory for the
juvenile court to allow the children to remain with mother but
not with him. We do not see it that way. Although, as father
correctly points out, mother also minimized the domestic violence
incident and played a role in escalating the argument, she was
not the aggressor, was not arrested, and was not criminally
convicted. Another distinction between mother and father is
mother had a stable home for the children while father “bounced
around” from place to place. On appeal father suggests the
Department should have considered releasing the children to him
on the condition he live with paternal grandmother, who was a
great support to the family, or another paternal relative.
However, father stated below there was no space for him (let
alone for two children) at paternal grandmother’s home, and it
stands to reason that the fact he had to “bounce around” indicates

18
other homes also lacked the ability to house father and the
children. Father notes a lack of housing alone cannot support
dependency jurisdiction or removal of a child from a parent.
While we take no issue with this general proposition, it does not
require reversal here. As discussed above, a lack of housing
alone was not the court’s reason for removing the children from
father.
Father further asserts the Department failed to comply
with its duty not only to explore alternatives to removal but also
to include in its report for the court a discussion of reasonable
efforts made to prevent removal of the children. Father failed to
raise these issues below and, therefore, has forfeited them. (In re
M.V. (2014) 225 Cal.App.4th 1495, 1508.) Accordingly, we need
not consider these arguments.
Finally, father relies on In re I.R. (2021) 61 Cal.App.5th
510 to support his position. As the Department states in its
respondent’s brief, that case is factually distinct and
unpersuasive here.
On record before us, which includes an incident of severe
domestic violence, father’s minimization of that incident,
previous incidents of domestic violence, and the short amount of
time father had spent in his criminal court programs, it was not
unreasonable for the juvenile court to remove the children from
father. Bearing in mind the applicable clear and convincing
standard below, we conclude substantial evidence supports the
removal order.
2. Monitored Visitation
Although on appeal father also challenges the juvenile
court’s order of monitored visitation, this issue has been rendered
moot. “An appeal becomes moot when, through no fault of the
respondent, the occurrence of an event renders it impossible for
the appellate court to grant the appellant effective relief.” (In re

19
Esperanza C. (2008) 165 Cal.App.4th 1042, 1054.) After father
appealed the juvenile court’s November 18, 2024, orders, the
court terminated jurisdiction and granted father unmonitored
visitation including overnight visits. We agree with the
Department that we cannot provide effective relief to father on
this issue as it has been resolved. Although discussed by the
Department in its respondent’s brief, father did not address the
issue of mootness in his reply brief on appeal. We conclude
father’s challenge to the order of monitored visitation is moot.
DISPOSITION
We dismiss as moot that portion of father’s appeal
challenging the juvenile court’s November 18, 2024, order of
monitored visitation. The juvenile court’s November 18, 2024,
removal order is affirmed.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED.

LUI, P. J.
We concur:

CHAVEZ, J.

SIGGINS, J.*

* Retired Presiding Justice of the Court of Appeal, First
Appellate District, Division Three, assigned by the Chief Justice
pursuant to article VI, section 6 of the California Constitution.

20

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.