People v. Baldonado CA4/1

CourtListener 10764115Calctapp23 dic 2025

Testo completo

Filed 12/23/25 P. v. Baldonado CA4/1
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

COURT OF APPEAL, FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION ONE

STATE OF CALIFORNIA

THE PEOPLE, D086352

Plaintiff and Respondent,

v. (Super. Ct. No. FWV21001208)

MARGIE NIEVES BALDONADO,

Defendant and Appellant.

APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of San Bernardino
County, Michael Knish, Judge. Affirmed.
Jason L. Jones, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for
Defendant and Appellant.
Rob Bonta, Attorney General, Lance E. Winters, Chief Assistant
Attorney General, Charles C. Ragland, Assistant Attorney General, Melissa
Mandel and Seth M. Friedman, Deputy Attorneys General, for Plaintiff and
Respondent.
INTRODUCTION
Margie Nieves Baldonado appeals her conviction for first degree
murder. She asserts the trial court erred by denying her motion to suppress
evidence. The evidence she sought to exclude was the location of another
person’s vehicle obtained from an automatic license plate reader database.
Given that Baldonado did not own the vehicle and was not in the vehicle at
the time of the data collection, we conclude she is not entitled to assert a
Fourth Amendment challenge to exclude this evidence. At Baldonado’s
request, we have also reviewed the reporter’s transcript of an in camera
hearing for potential exculpatory evidence from the investigation of an
unrelated murder and conclude the trial court did not abuse its discretion in
determining no exculpatory evidence existed as part of that investigation.
Accordingly, we affirm the judgment.
BACKGROUND
I.
Trial Evidence
Margarito Villasenor and Luis Sanchez were both members of the El
Sereno Criminal Street Gang. In January 2021, Villasenor sent Sanchez

Facebook messages suggesting there was hostility between them.1
On February 2, 2021, Sanchez sent Baldonado messages on Facebook
telling her he “want[ed] a rider” and asking if she was “down or not.” On
February 15, Baldonado sent Sanchez a Facebook message stating she loved
him and, “I want to be your Bonnie and I want you to be my Clyde.”

1 The messages read: “Lame ass don’t forget you was 86 out the hood
until ‘I’ talk to the homies if letting your lame ass come back. Your hefita got
shot by some punk ass movies and you still and done shit about it but smoke
that crap. . . Right now I’m chilling laying low but I’ll be at your door step
soon. You ask my primo for my address” you “ask me for it sucka – [address]
– Come on through lame;” and, “Keep Ithaca out your mouth to sucka.”
Ithaca is a subgroup of the El Sereno gang, of which Villasenor claimed to be
part.

2
Around February 21, 2021, Baldonado contacted Villasenor on
Facebook messenger. On March 11 or 12, the conversation moved to text
messages, and the two discussed meeting in person. The text message
exchange ended the morning of March 14, when the two met in person and
drove together to a restaurant in Fontana, California. They arrived there
shortly before 11:00 a.m.

Just after 11:00 a.m., a City of Fontana automatic license plate reader2
captured a picture of Sanchez’s vehicle, a black Cadillac CTS sedan with
California license plate number 8UCY488, approximately two miles from the
restaurant where Baldonado and Villasenor were dining. At around
11:47 a.m., a surveillance camera at a nearby residence captured a black
Cadillac sedan parked on a residential street near the restaurant. A man

wearing black clothes exited the car and removed the license plates.3
Circumstantial evidence suggested it was Sanchez in the same black Cadillac
on the surveillance footage.
While Baldonado and Villasenor were at the restaurant, at
approximately 11:50 a.m., the restaurant surveillance camera showed a black
Cadillac sedan without license plates park next to the restaurant. A man
wearing black clothes, a hat, and a bandana over his face exited the car with
a gun. According to a diner, when the man entered the restaurant, he
screamed, “Where is he at?” Baldonado answered, “Here. Here.” The man

2 The City of Fontana Police Department operates an automatic license
plate reader system to assist with investigations. Upon entry of a license
plate number, the system provides the date, time, intersection, and direction
of travel of the vehicle for each license plate read.

3 On March 11, 2021, Sanchez obtained a new set of license plates,
number 8UCY488, claiming his prior license plates were lost.

3
fired multiple shots at Villasenor, killing him. The man then fired additional
shots at another customer, ran out of the restaurant, and fled the scene in the
black Cadillac. Restaurant surveillance footage showed Baldonado leaving
the restaurant with the shooter before separately running from the scene on
foot.
Five days later, on March 19, 2021, Baldonado posted a photograph of
her and Sanchez on Facebook, captioned, “We are now officially together.”
That same day, Sanchez was arrested for the murder of Villasenor. Police
seized a Cadillac key fob from him.
A few days after his arrest, Sanchez called Baldonado from jail on a
recorded line. Baldonado stated, “Your cousin just told me to just hide out,”
and mentioned someone “want[ed] to get rid of the Blackbird.”
On March 25, 2021, Baldonado was arrested after leaving a hotel room.
Inside the room, there was a love letter addressed to Sanchez. Police
collected her phone as evidence and discovered that Baldonado searched, “I
do not have my keys to my CTS 2008 Cadillac how do I turn off my alarm.”
She also sent a message to someone stating “im on the run forn187 [sic],” the
Penal Code section for murder.
II.
Relevant Trial Proceedings
The People charged Sanchez and Baldonado with first degree murder

(Pen. Code,4 § 187, subd. (a)).5

4 Undesignated statutory references are to the Penal Code.

5 Sanchez was also charged with possession of a firearm by a felon
(§ 29800, subd. (a)(1)) and various prior convictions.

4
Prior to trial, Sanchez’s counsel brought a section 1538.5 motion to
suppress the evidence obtained by the license plate reader without a warrant.
Sanchez contended this warrantless search violated his Fourth Amendment
rights based on his expectation of privacy in his movements, citing Carpenter
v. United States (2018) 585 U.S. 296 (Carpenter), and United States v. Jones
(2012) 565 U.S. 400. At the hearing, Baldonado’s counsel joined that
objection without making any separate argument. The trial court denied the
motion, ruling there was no reasonable expectation of privacy in a single
location in the public domain based on United States v. Knotts (1983) 460
U.S. 276, 281 (“A person travelling in an automobile on public thoroughfares
has no reasonable expectation of privacy in his movements from one place to
another.”).
Sanchez and Baldonado were tried concurrently with separate juries.
At trial, the People moved to admit the photograph of Sanchez’s Cadillac
sedan from the license plate reader. Counsel for Sanchez objected based on
foundation, and Baldonado’s counsel joined. The court admitted the
evidence.
During trial, the prosecution discovered that Sanchez’s Cadillac was
involved in another homicide being investigated in Los Angeles which
occurred several days before Villasenor’s murder. The prosecutor disclosed
the fact of this investigation to the defense.
The prosecutor’s understanding was that the shooter was the passenger
of the vehicle and was not Sanchez, and the police had no information as to
the identity of the driver. Sanchez’s counsel moved for discovery to obtain
those records to examine for exculpatory evidence. The prosecutor suggested
a section 1054.7 in camera hearing, which the court held. At the hearing, a
witness testified regarding the investigation. Following the hearing, the

5
court ruled that the police did not possess any exculpatory evidence required
to be disclosed to the defense.
Baldonado’s jury convicted her of first degree murder, and the trial

court sentenced her to 25 years to life in prison.6
DISCUSSION
I.
Baldonado Is Not Entitled to Contest the Legality of the Challenged Search
Baldonado contends the trial court erred by denying her motion to
suppress the license plate reader evidence, which she claims violated her
Fourth Amendment rights. The People respond that Baldonado lacks
standing to assert the Fourth Amendment claim and, regardless, the claim is
meritless. We agree that Baldonado is not entitled to assert a Fourth

Amendment violation here.7 For that reason, we do not address the merits of

the claim.8

6 According to the respondent’s brief, Sanchez’s case ended in a mistrial,
but he was later convicted of Villasenor’s murder in a subsequent trial.

7 As noted in the respondent’s brief, the United States Supreme Court
explained that when a criminal defendant seeks to exclude evidence based on
a violation of the Fourth Amendment, “the analysis belongs more properly
under the heading of substantive Fourth Amendment doctrine than under
the heading of standing.” (Rakas v. Illinois (1978) 439 U.S. 128, 140
(Rakas).) Thus, rather than using the term standing, we refer to whether
Baldonado was “entitled to contest the legality of [the] search and seizure.”
(Ibid.)

8 Because we dispose of the Fourth Amendment claim on the grounds
that Baldonado cannot bring the claim, we deny as unnecessary her request
for judicial notice of the Fontana Police Department Policy Manual on
Automatic License Plate Readers.

6
Baldonado contends Fontana’s license plate reader system tracked
movements of individuals such that the search required a warrant under
Carpenter, supra, 585 U.S. at pages 310–311, and Leaders of a Beautiful
Struggle v. Baltimore Police Department (4th Cir. 2021) 2 F.4th 330, 345
(Beautiful Struggle). Because her argument is based on Sanchez’s
expectation of privacy in his movements, not Baldonado’s expectation of
privacy in her own movements, she cannot challenge the evidence the license
plate reader obtained regarding Sanchez’s vehicle’s location.
“Fourth Amendment rights are personal rights which, like some other
constitutional rights, may not be vicariously asserted. A person who is
aggrieved by an illegal search and seizure only through the introduction of
damaging evidence secured by a search of a third person’s premises or
property has not had any of his Fourth Amendment rights infringed.”
(Rakas, supra, 439 U.S. at pp. 133–134 [cleaned up]; People v. Madrid (1992)
7 Cal.App.4th 1888, 1895 [The same standard applies in California: “[T]he
courts of this state may exclude evidence seized pursuant to an unlawful
search or seizure ‘only if exclusion is also mandated by the federal
exclusionary rule applicable to evidence seized in violation of the Fourth
Amendment.’ ”].) “The established principle is that suppression of the
product of a Fourth Amendment violation can be successfully urged only by
those whose rights were violated by the search itself, not by those who are
aggrieved solely by the introduction of damaging evidence. Coconspirators
and codefendants have been accorded no special standing.” (Alderman v.
United States (1969) 394 U.S. 165, 171–172.) “The proponent of a motion to
suppress has the burden of establishing that his own Fourth Amendment
rights were violated by the challenged search or seizure.” (Rakas, at p. 131,
fn. 1.)

7
“When the standing issue is not litigated in the trial court, the
appellate court can reach a legal conclusion as to whether the defendants had
standing if the record is adequate. The record must contain the facts
necessary to determine whether the defendant had an interest in connection
with the searched premises that gave rise to a reasonable expectation on his
part of freedom from governmental intrusion upon those premises.” (People
v. Workman (1989) 209 Cal.App.3d 687, 694.) We review this issue de novo
when the facts are undisputed. (Ibid.)
Here, Baldonado does not dispute that the license plate reader did not
register her location, as she was either driving in a different vehicle to the
restaurant or already at the restaurant with Villasenor at the time. It is also
undisputed that the vehicle captured by the license plate reader belonged to
Sanchez, not Baldonado. Therefore, she is not asserting a violation of a
personal right as required to bring a Fourth Amendment claim. She cannot
vicariously assert Sanchez’s Fourth Amendment right.
To circumvent this clear rule, Baldonado argues “the public” has “an
expectation of privacy . . . against mass surveillance” of people’s “movement
over time.” While it is true that all members of the public have certain
privacy rights, an individual may only assert a Fourth Amendment right
when she has suffered a personal violation of her own right. The cases
Baldonado relies on do not hold otherwise.
Contrary to Baldonado’s argument, Carpenter does not stand for the
proposition she can assert a Fourth Amendment violation of another
individual based on a societal expectation of privacy. (See Carpenter, supra,
585 U.S. at pp. 310–311.) There, the appellant’s ability to bring his Fourth
Amendment claim was not at issue because the case dealt with “Carpenter’s
anticipation of privacy in his physical location” and movements based on his

8
cell phone’s location. (Id. at p. 311, italics added; see id. at pp. 301–302, 306,
310–311.) The court recognized that “individuals have a reasonable
expectation of privacy in the whole of their physical movements.” (Id. at
p. 310, italics added.)
Likewise, Beautiful Struggle, where the plaintiffs sought an injunction

based on potential future harm to themselves,9 does not permit a defendant
in a criminal proceeding to challenge the admission of evidence of another
individual’s past location information. The principles discussed in Rakas and
Alderman have not been overruled.
Baldonado contends the reference in Beautiful Struggle to “everyone’s
movements” supports her argument that mass collection of data results in
collective harm. In full, the court explained while “[p]eople understand that
they may be filmed by security cameras on city streets, or a police officer
could stake out their house and tail them for a time[,] . . . capturing
everyone’s movements outside during the daytime for 45 days goes beyond
that ordinary capacity.” (Beautiful Struggle, supra, 2 F.4th at p. 345.) This
language does not eliminate the requirement that one seeking to exclude
evidence under the Fourth Amendment assert a violation of her own rights.
Similarly, in the final case cited by Baldonado, the plaintiff claimed a
violation of his own Fourth Amendment rights. (Sanchez v. Los Angeles Dept.
of Transportation (9th Cir. 2022) 39 F.4th 548, 554 [“Sanchez alleges that the

9 The court did not engage in an in-depth discussion of standing, stating,
“Plaintiffs are grassroots community advocates in Baltimore. Their advocacy
necessarily involves traveling through and being present outdoors in areas
with high rates of violent crime. For example, Erricka Bridgeford leads
Ceasefire Baltimore and, in that capacity, visits scenes of gun violence as
soon as possible after a crime takes place.” (Beautiful Struggle, supra, 2
F.4th at p. 335.)

9
collection of the MDS location data itself—without more—violates his
constitutional rights today.” (Italics added.)].)
II.
No Abuse of Discretion in Section 1054.7 Ruling
Baldonado also requests that we examine the transcript of the section
1054.7 in camera hearing and review the trial court’s decision denying the
motion for discovery related to the other criminal investigation. The People
do not object to this request. We have reviewed the transcript of the in
camera hearing and see no abuse of discretion by the trial court.
The Penal Code requires the prosecution to disclose exculpatory
evidence to the defense. (§ 1054.1, subd. (e).) Required disclosures may be
“denied, restricted or deferred” for specified “good cause,” including “possible
compromise of other investigations by law enforcement.” (§ 1054.7.) The
trial court has discretion to permit a party to make the good cause showing in
camera. (Ibid.) We review the trial court’s ruling on discovery matters,
including the disclosure of exculpatory evidence, for abuse of discretion.
(People v. Thompson (2016) 1 Cal.5th 1043, 1105.) It is not an abuse of
discretion to deny a defendant’s motion to compel non-exculpatory evidence.
(People v. Elder (2017) 11 Cal.App.5th 123, 133.)
Having independently reviewed the in camera hearing, we conclude the
trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying Sanchez’s discovery motion
based on lack of exculpatory evidence. The information available in the
investigation of the other homicide on a separate occasion, in a different
location, involving unknown perpetrators, was irrelevant to Baldonado’s and
Sanchez’s roles in the murder of Villasenor.

10
DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed.

DO, Acting P. J.

WE CONCUR:

KELETY, J.

CASTILLO, J.

11

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.