CourtListener 10742284•Thomas v. Robinson Helicopter Co. CA2/2
Testo completo
Filed 11/25/25 Thomas v. Robinson Helicopter Co. CA2/2
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION TWO
SOPHIE THOMAS, Individually B338740
and as Successor in Interest, etc.,
et al., (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No.
Plaintiffs and Appellants, 23TRCV03486)
v.
ROBINSON HELICOPTER
COMPANY, INC.,
Defendant and Respondent.
APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of Los
Angeles County, David K. Reinert, Judge. Affirmed.
Wisner Baum, Timothy Ananda Loranger, Ari Friedman
and William Crawford Appleby for Plaintiffs and Appellants.
Tim A. Goetz for Defendant and Respondent.
___________________________________
Australian citizens sued a California helicopter
manufacturer for a fatal crash in Australia. Applying the
doctrine of forum non conveniens, the trial court stayed the case,
ruling that any litigation must be pursued in Australia. We
conclude that (1) Australia is a suitable alternative forum for
litigation and (2) the court did not abuse its discretion by
weighing public and private interests and finding California is an
inconvenient forum.
The trial court’s determination makes abundant common
sense. The victims and plaintiffs are Australian citizens and
residents. Accident investigators and eyewitnesses live in
Australia. Mechanics who tested and serviced the helicopter live
in Australia, and their attendance in California—as witnesses or
potential cross-defendants—cannot be compelled. The California-
based defendant will submit to Australian jurisdiction, provide
technical evidence and witnesses, and pay damages ordered by
Australian courts. California has little interest in adjudicating
the rights of foreign citizens arising from an accident in their
country. Australia has a greater interest in litigation involving
its citizens, airspace, and registered aircraft. We affirm.
FACTS AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY
The Lawsuit Arising From an Accident in Australia
In 2020, a helicopter owned and piloted by Troy Robert
Thomas (decedent) had a catastrophic mechanical failure in
Broome, Western Australia. During takeoff, the tail rotor and
empennage broke off. Decedent and a passenger perished; two
people were seriously injured. A lawsuit was brought in
California against the manufacturer, respondent Robinson
2
Helicopter Company, Inc. Plaintiffs are citizens and residents of
Australia.1 Robinson is based in California.
The complaint alleges that the helicopter was designed,
manufactured, tested, assembled, distributed, licensed,
marketed, warranted, and sold in the County of Los Angeles.
Manufacturing defects allegedly led to the crash, and Robinson
did not disclose that the aircraft was susceptible to loss of its
rotor system. The pleading asserts causes of action for strict
product liability, breach of warranty, and negligence.
Forum Non Conveniens Motion
Respondent moved to dismiss or stay the action, claiming
Australia is the appropriate forum for the lawsuit and California
is an inconvenient forum. Appellants and decedent are
Australian citizens and residents; the accident occurred in
Australia; the flight was subject to Australian aviation
regulations; the Australian Transport Safety Bureau (ATSB) had
jurisdiction over the accident investigation; potential defendants
who maintained, serviced, repaired, and piloted the helicopter are
outside the jurisdiction of California; and maintenance records
and witnesses are in Australia.
Respondent’s aviation law expert declared that Australia is
part of the International Civil Aviation Organization, created by
an international convention with the status of a treaty. It makes
Australia responsible for determining airworthiness of its
registered aircraft, as well as pilot and mechanic training and
proficiency. Decedent’s helicopter was registered in Australia,
1 Decedent’s widow, Sophie Thomas, is administrator of his
estate; Mia, Cooper, and Sailor are their minor children. Plaintiff
Maddison Nancy Down was a passenger injured in the crash.
3
and the mechanics are licensed there. Australia has a fair and
independent judiciary.
Twelve days before the accident, a pilot notified decedent of
a vibration in the helicopter’s tail rotor pedals. Decedent flew on
July 2, 2020, and confirmed in a text message that there was a
vibration. One day later, an engineering team examined the
helicopter; their worksheet stated, “Pilot reported tail rotor vibe.”
The team inspected the tail rotor and empennage, and tested the
aircraft on the ground, without detecting vibrations; it advised
testing by a pilot, first on the skids, then hovering, then in flight,
to troubleshoot the vibration. It is unclear if decedent was
notified of the need for a flight check. On July 4, before having
solo pilot testing, decedent loaded three passengers into the
helicopter and made “a high-power maximum performance take-
off from a confined area.” As the aircraft climbed, four
eyewitnesses heard a loud bang and the tail rotor broke away.
Decedent lost control and collided with the terrain.
Sources of proof are located in Australia, and crucial
witnesses are outside the reach of California’s subpoena power.
Australian engineers who participated in maintenance must be
called as witnesses, along with other operators of the helicopter,
to determine what caused a stress fracture. Eyewitnesses to the
accident and pilots who were aware of a vibration must testify,
along with Australian officials who investigated the crash and
analyzed the wreckage.
Respondent’s employee helped Australian authorities
investigate the accident. He declared that the helicopter was
registered in Australia, which issued a certificate of
airworthiness. The owner/pilot and mechanics were licensed in
Australia. The ATSB performed a detailed examination of the
4
accident. The United States government was not involved.
Critical evidence regarding the aircraft’s operation, inspections,
and maintenance is in Australia, as are percipient witnesses and
accident investigators. Attached to the declaration is a copy of
the ATSB report on the accident.
Respondent is amenable to process in Australia. It will
consent to the jurisdiction of Australian courts; make available
any evidence or witnesses in the United States; toll the
Australian statute of limitations for one year; and satisfy any
judgment rendered or settlement reached in Australia.
Respondent will provide testing results by the United States
Federal Aviation Administration on this type of helicopter.
As a member of the Commonwealth of Nations, Australia
provides a suitable forum for product liability and wrongful death
suits. Respondent’s aviation law expert declared that Australia
provides remedies similar to California. Different quanta of proof
or damages are irrelevant. Respondent’s inability to implead
third parties outside of California would be prejudicial and
unfair. Australia has a greater interest in a local controversy
than California.
Opposition to the Motion
In opposition, appellants argued that Robinson, a
California based company, did not meet its burden of showing
California is so inconvenient that the case should be dismissed.
They claimed “most of the key evidence” is in California, which
has a substantial interest in the safety of products manufactured
and sold here. Robinson’s facilities, production, employees and
executives are in California, as are expert witnesses. State law
will produce “far better and more significant evidence” than
would be produced under Australian law. Appellants requested a
5
jury trial, which is not available in Australia. They claim “the
bad acts and omissions took place” in California.
An international law expert, Martin Davies, discussed
Australian law and the Hague Convention; the latter allows
access to evidence in transnational litigation. He agreed that
appellants “have a remedy in an Australian court,” which has
“jurisdiction to hear the case.” However, remedies are
“significantly more restricted than it would be in this court in
California.” They cannot recover for bereavement or loss of
consortium, only their financial loss. Punitive damages are
unavailable, and they would not be entitled to a jury trial.
Davies averred that discovery is limited in Australia.
Parties may obtain documents “directly relevant to issues that
have already been raised,” but any attempt to get documents “to
discern what issues or arguments might be available is popularly
described as a ‘fishing expedition’ and is not allowed.”
Depositions are rarely permitted, and it is difficult to obtain
documents from outside Australia. Australia requires a court
order to obtain discovery from nonparties. The ATSB report on
the crash is inadmissible because it was not prepared to help
determine liability or assist in court proceedings; as a result, it
would not be possible to depose ATSB officials or obtain their
notes.
Australian courts may order examination of witnesses
outside the country, if a witness is unwilling or unable to testify
in Australia. The Hague Convention may be invoked to obtain
oral testimony from a reluctant witness. In practice, courts are
hesitant to subpoena citizens in foreign countries, particularly if
there is a threat of punishment, and it is difficult to enforce the
order.
6
Australian lawyers cannot work on a contingent fee basis,
but may make “ ‘conditional costs agreements’ ” that are “ ‘no
win, no fee’ ” arrangements. Australian courts comply with the
Hague Convention by allowing production of witnesses,
documents, or property in response to a request from a foreign
court, even if it would not be discoverable under Australian law.
Willing witnesses in Australia could be deposed by a court-
appointed examiner and give video testimony in California
proceedings.
Respondent’s Reply
Counsel for respondent declared that Robinson has
participated in litigation in Canada, Australia, and New Zealand,
following forum non conveniens dismissals. The helicopter was
serviced by Australians, who failed to correct a reported problem
with the rotor; their testimony is critical to the case. California
courts cannot compel the testimony of crucial witnesses or force
potentially responsible Australian parties—those who
maintained, serviced, and repaired the aircraft—to submit to the
state’s jurisdiction. Respondent will produce all relevant
documents about the helicopter in Australia. As foreign citizens,
plaintiffs’ choice of forum is given little deference; greater
importance is placed on California’s interest in avoiding undue
court congestion and the burden on jurors of trying cases arising
abroad.
By contrast, there is no guarantee evidence in Australia
will be produced in California. The ATSB report shows that
responsibility for the accident lies with Australian citizens who
allowed the helicopter to remain in service and with the pilot who
allowed passengers on board despite his report of a rotor problem.
Courts have noted that using the Hague Convention for discovery
7
is inefficient, protracts litigation, and increases costs. The choice
of law is in all likelihood Australian law. The country where the
accident occurred has the greatest interest in applying its own
law, and an international convention provides that the country of
registration, where the flight occurred, is the exclusive law.
California has little interest in applying its law to compensate
citizens of a foreign country.
The Trial Court’s Ruling
The court presumed that California is a convenient forum
because respondent is incorporated and has its principal place of
business here. Australia is a suitable forum that provides
plaintiffs with a remedy; it is not unsuitable even if its laws are
different. Respondent will consent to Australian jurisdiction;
make available any evidence or witnesses; toll any limitations
period; and satisfy any judgment or settlement in Australia.
The court weighed private interests and found California is
a seriously inconvenient forum. Access to proof and compulsory
process weigh against California. The accident occurred in
Australia, where percipient witnesses and Australian accident
investigators reside. Multiple factors contributed to plaintiffs’
damages, beyond the design of the aircraft, including decisions
made by the pilot. It would be difficult to obtain evidence and
witnesses in Australia for litigation in California.
The court concluded, “the incident occurred in Australia,
when the aircraft was being flown by an Australian citizen,
ferrying Australian passengers, having been serviced by
technicians in Australia, after the aircraft was certified for use in
Australia by Australian civil aviation authorities, and each of
those steps created a potential witness necessary to litigating the
action. Finally, the plaintiffs themselves are both witnesses to
8
the incident as well as citizens and residents of Australia.
Therefore, the private factors weigh in favor of granting the
motion.”
Public factors also show California is a seriously
inconvenient forum. Robinson’s manufacture of the helicopter in
California does not overcome Australia’s interests. Australia
certified the aircraft, which was maintained in accordance with
its regulations. Australia is the site of the accident that killed
and injured Australians. Given Australia’s greater interest, the
burden on California courts and citizenry weigh against keeping
the litigation here. The court granted Robinson’s motion.
DISCUSSION
1. Appeal and Review
“When a court upon motion of a party or its own motion
finds that in the interest of substantial justice an action should
be heard in a forum outside this state, the court shall stay or
dismiss the action in whole or in part on any conditions that may
be just.” (Code Civ. Proc, § 410.30, subd. (a).) The defendant
bears the burden of proof. (Stangvik v. Shiley, Inc. (1991) 54
Cal.3d 744, 751 (Stangvik); Kiely v. HYPH (USA), Inc. (2025) 113
Cal.App.5th 95, 106 (Kiely).) An order granting the motion is
appealable. (Code Civ. Proc., § 904.1, subd. (a)(3).)
On appeal, we address two issues with different standards
of review. First, we determine if the alternate forum is a suitable
place for trial. The threshold determination is subject to de novo
review. Second, we “consider the private interests of the litigants
and the interests of the public in retaining the action for trial in
California.” The trial court’s balancing of interests is reviewed
for abuse of discretion, and its factual determinations are upheld
if supported by substantial evidence. (Stangvik, supra, 54 Cal.3d
9
at pp. 751–752; Kiely, supra, 113 Cal.App.5th at pp. 106–107.)
The court’s determination “deserves substantial deference.”
(Piper Aircraft Co. v. Reyno (1981) 454 U.S. 235, 257 [102 S.Ct.
252, 70 L.Ed.2d 419] (Piper); Stangvik, at p. 751; Denham v.
Superior Court (1970) 2 Cal.3d 557, 566 [a court abuses its
discretion if it exceeds the bounds of reason and causes a
miscarriage of justice].)
2. Suitability of the Alternative Forum
Courts presume California is a convenient forum when the
defendant is a California resident, but the presumption may be
overcome by showing an alternate forum is a more convenient
place for trial. (Stangvik, supra, 54 Cal.3d at pp. 755–756.) “ ‘An
alternative forum is suitable if it has jurisdiction and the action
in that forum will not be barred by the statute of limitations.’ ”
(EpicentRx, Inc. v. Superior Court (2025) 18 Cal.5th 58, 72
(EpicentRx); Kiely, supra, 113 Cal.App.5th at p. 106.)
The two critical factors are met here. First, plaintiffs’
expert conceded that Australian courts have jurisdiction over an
accident in Australia with Australian victims. Second,
respondent agreed to toll the statute of limitations to allow
refiling in Australia.2
Australia is not unsuitable because it has different laws on
product liability or offers less generous awards. (See Piper, supra
454 U.S. at p. 250 [“dismissal on the grounds of forum non
conveniens may be granted even though the law applicable in the
alternative forum is less favorable to the plaintiff’s chance of
recovery”]; Stangvik, supra, 54 Cal.3d at p. 754 [“the fact that
2 The opening brief states that appellants filed suit in
Australia to protect their interests, but prefer to litigate in
California.
10
California law would likely provide plaintiffs with certain
advantages of procedural or substantive law cannot be considered
as a factor in plaintiffs’ favor”].) “ ‘[A] forum is suitable where an
action “can be brought,” although not necessarily won.’ ” (Chong
v. Superior Court (1997) 58 Cal.App.4th 1032, 1037; Kiely, supra,
113 Cal.App.5th at p. 106.)
Unfavorable laws are a factor only “if the remedy provided
by the alternative forum is so clearly inadequate or
unsatisfactory that it is no remedy at all.” (Piper, supra, 454 U.S.
at p. 254.) The “no remedy” exception applies if “ ‘ “the
alternative forum is a foreign country whose courts are ruled by a
dictatorship, so that there is no independent judiciary or due
process of law.” ’ ” (EpicentRx, supra, 18 Cal.5th at p. 72; Auffret
v. Capitales Tours, S.A. (2015) 239 Cal.App.4th 935, 940.)
Appellants do not claim Australia is a dictatorship offering
“no remedy at all.” Though they “may not be able to rely on a
strict liability theory, and although their potential damages
award may be smaller, there is no danger that they will be
deprived of any remedy or treated unfairly.” (Piper, supra, 454
U.S. at p. 255 [discussing the effect of filing suit in Scotland for
the deaths of Scottish citizens in an accident in Scotland in an
aircraft manufactured in the United States].)
Australia is suitable even if it does not permit a jury trial.
If some remedy is afforded in the alternate jurisdiction, the
unavailability of a jury trial “should not be accorded any weight.”
(EpicentRx, supra, 18 Cal.5th at p. 73; Investors Equity Life
Holding Co. v. Schmidt (2011) 195 Cal.App.4th 1519, 1530.) The
same is true if the forum does not allow contingent fee
arrangements. (Magnin v. Teledyne Continental Motors (11th
Cir. 1996) 91 F.3d 1424, 1430 [no weight given to the
11
unavailability of a jury trial or contingent fees in litigation
arising from an airplane crash in France]; In re Air Crash over
the Taiwan Strait on May 25, 2002 (C.D.Cal. 2004) 331 F.Supp.2d
1176, 1186–1187.) Accordingly, we need not consider the
unavailability of a jury trial in Australia.3
Appellants argue that we must defer to their choice of
forum. They are mistaken. Though a California plaintiff’s choice
of California courts is rarely disturbed, we need not defer to a
foreign plaintiff’s choice of California. (Piper, supra, 454 U.S. at
pp. 255–256; Stangvik, supra, 54 Cal.3d at p. 755.) As citizens of
Australia claiming no ties to California, appellants are not in the
same position as Californians. They have a suitable alternative
forum in their home country of Australia.
3 The opening brief cites cases involving mandatory forum
selection clauses giving “ ‘vital certainty’ ” to contracting parties
of having a neutral venue for dispute resolution. (EpicentRx,
supra, 18 Cal.5th at pp. 73–74.) Even then, “where enforcement
of a forum selection clause may effectively deprive a plaintiff of
the right to trial by jury, this circumstance alone does not provide
a basis to avoid its enforcement.” (Id. at p. 78; see Rincon EV
Realty LLC v. CP III Rincon Towers, Inc. (2017) 8 Cal.App.5th 1,
7–9 [contractual choice of law and jury waiver clauses].)
Appellants’ reply brief acknowledges that contract cases do
not apply, given our Supreme Court’s recent ruling in EpicentRx,
supra, 18 Cal.5th at page 84, footnote 7, reversing EpicentRx, Inc.
v. Superior Court (2023) 95 Cal.App.5th 890 and overruling
Handoush v. Lease Finance Group, LLC (2019) 41 Cal.App.5th
729 and The Comedy Store v. Moss Adams LLP (2024) 106
Cal.App.5th 784.
12
3. Balancing of Private and Public Interests
A. Private Interest Factors
“The private interest factors are those that make trial and
the enforceability of the ensuing judgment expeditious and
relatively inexpensive, such as the ease of access to sources of
proof, the cost of obtaining attendance of witnesses, and the
availability of compulsory process for attendance of unwilling
witnesses.” (Stangvik, supra, 54 Cal.3d at p. 751.) Substantial
evidence supports the trial court’s determination that private
interest factors favor respondent.
Appellants, potential parties, and witnesses are in
Australia. This includes the team that serviced the helicopter
one day before it crashed, four eyewitnesses, and accident
investigators who examined and tested the damaged helicopter
parts. (Compare Roulier v. Cannondale (2002) 101 Cal.App.4th
1180, 1188, in which there was “only one percipient witness” to a
bicycle accident in Switzerland.) The accident site—in a confined
commercial area requiring a steep, maximum power ascent—is in
Australia and cannot be viewed in person by a California jury.
(Compare Roulier, at p. 1184, where the accident site was
“ ‘collateral’ ” to product liability issues.) Appellants’ medical
providers are in Australia, as are others with information
relating to damages.
Evidence relating to the design, manufacture, and testing
of the helicopter is in California. Our Supreme Court has
rejected the idea that the presence of manufacturing or design
records in California makes this state more convenient than the
location where injury occurred. (Stangvik, supra, 54 Cal.3d at
p. 757.) This is particularly true where documentary evidence
and testing information can be readily transferred abroad. (Id. at
13
p. 762.) Appellants do not dispute that proof related to individual
damage claims is in Australia. (Ibid. [“virtually all the evidence
relating to damages is in Scandinavia”].)
The trial court properly concluded that a forum is
inconvenient if the defendant cannot implead third party
defendants or “many crucial witnesses are located beyond the
reach of compulsory process, and thus are difficult to identify or
interview.” (Piper, supra, 454 U.S. at p. 258.) Respondent may
try to prove this accident was caused not by a design or
manufacturing defect, but rather by the negligence of the pilot,
aviation mechanics, or engineers responsible for maintaining the
helicopter, who are beyond the reach of California’s jurisdiction.
Appellants’ expert declared that “[w]illing witnesses” in
Australia could be deposed in Australia or give testimony in
California. They offer no reason to believe helicopter repair team
members are “willing witnesses,” given their possible exposure to
liability if they submit to the jurisdiction of California courts. By
contrast, respondent promises to submit to Australian
jurisdiction and make available “any evidence or witnesses”
Australian courts deem relevant in an action filed there. On
balance, respondent is at a distinct disadvantage hoping “willing
witnesses” will participate in California litigation.
The law supports the trial court’s determination that using
the Hague Convention to secure evidence is expensive and
difficult. “The Hague Convention would not allow Defendants to
compel live testimony at trial,” which “ ‘create[s] a condition not
satisfactory to court, jury or most litigants.” (In re Air Crash at
Madrid (C.D.Cal. 2011) 893 F.Supp.2d 1020, 1032; Melgares v.
Sikorsky Aircraft Corp. (D.Conn. 2009) 613 F.Supp.2d 231, 243,
fn. 8 [securing testimony from unwilling witnesses regarding a
14
helicopter crash in Spain through letters rogatory is “a difficult
and time-consuming—if not altogether futile—endeavor”].) As
one court has observed, “[t]o the extent the parties could employ
treaty requests or letters rogatory, these vehicles are notoriously
inefficient and tend to protract and make litigation more costly.”
(Da Rocha v. Bell Helicopter Textron, Inc. (S.D.Fla. 2006) 451
F.Supp.2d 1318, 1325.) Finally, “[t]he mere likelihood or
possibility that foreign law would apply weighs in favor of
dismissal.” (In re Air Crash at Madrid, at pp. 1040–1041 [“courts
have concluded that a foreign forum’s law likely applied in a suit
against an aircraft manufacturer arising out of the deaths of
foreign victims in a crash on foreign soil”].)
B. Public Interest Factors
“The public interest factors include avoidance of
overburdening local courts with congested calendars, protecting
the interests of potential jurors so that they are not called upon
to decide cases in which the local community has little concern,
and weighing the competing interests of California and the
alternate jurisdiction in the litigation.” (Stangvik, supra, 54
Cal.3d at p. 751.) Forum non conveniens “is designed in part to
help courts avoid conducting complex exercises in comparative
law. . . . [P]ublic interest factors point towards dismissal where
the court would be required to ‘untangle problems in conflict of
laws, and in law foreign to itself.’ ” (Piper, supra, 454 U.S. at
p. 251.) The attractiveness of American laws to foreign
plaintiffs—with respect to strict liability, for example—“would
increase and further congest already crowded courts.” (Id. at
p. 252.)
A foreign country has “a very strong interest” in accidents
occurring in its airspace, if the victims and potential parties are
15
citizens of that country. (Piper, supra, 454 U.S. at p. 260.)
“[T]here is ‘a local interest in having localized controversies
decided at home.’ ” (Ibid.) The local interest is not outweighed
by California’s interest “in ensuring that American
manufacturers are deterred from producing defective products”
because “the incremental deterrence that would be gained if this
trial were held in an American court is likely to be insignificant.
The American interest in this accident is simply not sufficient to
justify the enormous commitment of judicial time and resources
that would inevitably be required if the case were to be tried
here.” (Id. at pp. 260–261; Nai-Chao v. Boeing Co. (N.D.Cal.
1982) 555 F.Supp. 9, 19–20 [product liability claim against an
American company does not outweigh the interest of Taiwan,
where the plane crash occurred]; Campbell v. Parker-Hannifin
Corp. (1999) 69 Cal.App.4th 1534, 1541 (Campbell) [“California’s
interest in deterring wrongful conduct did not outweigh the
foreign jurisdiction’s interest in the death of its citizens.”].)
This case parallels Campbell, supra, 69 Cal.App.4th 1534.
In Campbell, Australians sued a California airplane parts
manufacturer over a fatal crash in Australia. The Australian
government determined that the plane’s gyroscopes failed. (Id. at
pp. 1538–1539.) The defendant successfully moved to stay the
action. The appellate court affirmed. Australia had jurisdiction
over an accident involving its citizens and investigated by its air
safety agency. California was inconvenient, though
manufacturing evidence was here, because the defense would
“call Australian witnesses regarding the maintenance and
operation of the plane in Australia and the training and
proficiency of the pilot,” and percipient witnesses to the crash.
(Id. at p. 1543.) As foreigners, plaintiffs’ choice of California was
16
not accorded weight, nor was the generosity of California legal
remedies. (Ibid.) The public interest favored granting the motion
to avoid contributing to court congestion. (Id. at p. 1542.)4
The reasoning in Campbell applies here. The plaintiffs and
witnesses are in Australia. Australians will testify about the
training and proficiency of the pilot, and the maintenance and
condition of the helicopter. Eyewitnesses are in Australia, as are
ATSB accident investigators. California’s interest in the
litigation is outweighed by Australia’s interest. California’s
“overworked” judges (in appellants’ words) and a jury of its
citizens should not have to wade through technical evidence to
decide fault for an accident occurring 8,000 miles away. The trial
court did not abuse its discretion by weighing the relevant
interests in favor of staying this case, allowing the dispute to be
litigated in Australia.
4 The reply brief leans heavily on an opinion by Division
One of this district (not “this court,” as counsel mistakenly
suggests) involving a contract dispute over insurance coverage for
environmental contamination. (Ford Motor Co. v. Insurance Co.
of North America (1995) 35 Cal.App.4th 604.) It is more
appropriate to rely on cases involving aircraft crashes abroad,
such as Piper and Campbell.
17
DISPOSITION
The order granting respondent’s motion to stay litigation in
California on the basis of forum non conveniens is affirmed.
Respondent is awarded its costs on appeal.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED.
LUI, P. J.
We concur:
RICHARDSON, J.
SIGGINS, J.*
* Retired Presiding Justice of the Court of Appeal, First
Appellate District, Division Three, assigned by the Chief Justice
pursuant to article VI, section 6 of the California Constitution.
18
Ti chiedi come si applica questo testo alla tua situazione?
Consulenza gratuita, senza impegno
Descrivi la tua situazione. Il nostro team ti ricontatterà via e-mail per la tua consulenza.
Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude
Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.