CourtListener 10740574•In re Michael U. CA2/1
Testo completo
Filed 11/21/25 In re Michael U. CA2/1
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION ONE
In re MICHAEL U. JR. et al., B345236
Persons Coming Under the (Los Angeles County
Juvenile Court Law. Super. Ct. No. 24CCJP03845)
LOS ANGELES COUNTY
DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN
AND FAMILY SERVICES,
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v.
TERESA U. et al.,
Defendants and Appellants.
APPEALS from orders of the Superior Court of Los Angeles
County, Kristen Byrdsong, Judge Pro Tempore. Affirmed in part,
dismissed in part.
Johanna R. Shargel, under appointment by the Court of
Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant Teresa U.
John P. McCurley, under appointment by the Court of
Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant Michael U. Sr.
Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, Kim Nemoy,
Assistant County Counsel, and Sarah Vesecky, Principal Deputy
County Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
______________________
Teresa U. (Mother) and Michael U. Sr. (Father) have four
children: Michael Jr. (born 2012), Theodore (born 2014), Raven
(born 2017), and Nathaniel (born 2023). Mother and Father both
appeal from the juvenile court’s assertion of jurisdiction over
their children based on domestic violence between the parents, as
well as from an order removing the children from both parents.
Neither Mother nor Father denies their history of domestic
violence. They instead argue the children were no longer at risk
of harm from that violence by the time of the adjudication
hearing. They support this argument by pointing to inferences
and portions of the record that differ from the inferences drawn
and the evidence relied upon by the juvenile court. We, however,
do not “reweigh the evidence, or resolve evidentiary conflicts.”
(In re L.Y.L. (2002) 101 Cal.App.4th 942, 947.) Instead, “we draw
all reasonable inferences in support of the findings, consider the
record most favorably to the juvenile court’s order, and affirm the
order if supported by substantial evidence even if other evidence
supports a contrary conclusion.” (Ibid.) Applying that standard
of review, as we must, we conclude substantial evidence supports
the court’s assertion of jurisdiction.
2
With regard to the removal order, during the pendency of
this appeal the juvenile court returned the children to Mother’s
care. Given that the children are no longer removed from
Mother, her challenge to the removal order is moot. Before the
juvenile court, Father requested that the children be returned to
Mother as opposed to him, and his appeal of the removal order is
therefore also moot.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
We limit our summary of the factual and procedural
background to what is necessary to explain our disposition.
A. Facts Leading to the Filing of the Dependency
Petition
1. Prior Referral History
The family was first referred to the Los Angeles County
Department of Children and Family Services (DCFS) in May
2014. The referral alleged that Father had committed domestic
violence against Mother in Michael Jr.’s presence by pushing her
against a vehicle and grabbing her by the neck. Mother reported
the incident to law enforcement and entered a domestic violence
shelter. Mother also stated there had been numerous prior
unreported incidents of domestic violence. Mother was issued an
emergency protective order and granted temporary custody of
Michael Jr. (who was at that point the parents’ only child).
DCFS closed the referral as inconclusive.
A second referral occurred in September 2019. The caller,
who lived near Mother and Father, reported hearing Father
beating Mother every night for the past two weeks. The referral
stated that the caller also had received information from the
caller’s family (who was present when the caller was away from
3
home) that yelling and screaming was coming from Mother and
Father’s house, that it sounded like the parents were hitting each
other, and that the children in Mother and Father’s home were
screaming for someone to call the police. The caller reported
Father belonged to a gang and had made threats when told he
needed to stop fighting or his children would be removed from
him. DCFS closed the referral as inconclusive.
A third referral, in June 2020, alleged Father had violated
a domestic violence restraining order (DVRO) against him that
protected Mother, Michael Jr., Theodore, and Raven, and that
Father otherwise endangered those three children. The referral
stated that Father had entered Mother’s home through a second
story window and gone into the children’s bedroom. Mother and
maternal grandmother became aware Father was in the house.
Maternal grandmother offered to call 9-1-1 to report Father’s
restraining order violation; Mother stopped maternal
grandmother from doing so, stating the children were happy to
see Father and “ ‘he was alright.’ ” Father later became agitated
after learning Mother was going to move out of the home, and
maternal grandmother called 9-1-1. When police arrived, Father
had barricaded himself inside the bedroom with Michael Jr.,
Theodore, and Raven, and used them as human shields when
officers forced entry into the room to arrest Father. DCFS
substantiated the referral for general neglect and promoted it to
a court case. The case was later closed in August 2020 because
Father went to prison for violating the DVRO. In connection
with his criminal case, Father was subjected to a 10-year
criminal protective order (CPO) restraining his contact with
Mother; the CPO was issued in December 2020 and expires in
December 2030.
4
A fourth referral, in April 2022, alleged emotional, physical,
and at-risk sibling abuse. According to the referral, Theodore
reported Father scratched the child’s wrist when trying to spank
him. The referral further alleged Theodore was misbehaving at
school, that the parents had a history of domestic violence, and
that it was unknown if there was current domestic violence.
DCFS closed the referral as inconclusive/unfounded.
2. October 16, 2024 Referral
On October 16, 2024, DCFS received a referral stating that
police officers had responded to a call reporting domestic violence
involving Mother that ended in Father’s arrest. The reporting
party spoke with Mother, who said that Father kicked her side
and slapped her face causing a bloody nose. All four children
were present during the violence. The reporting party provided
information that law enforcement had been to the home 12 times
before this incident.
When contacted on October 22, 2024 by DCFS, Mother said
she was at home but unavailable to meet until the following
week. This also stymied DCFS from speaking with the children
as Mother homeschooled them. Mother did not respond to
attempts by DCFS to contact her on October 30 and 31. Mother
texted DCFS on November 3, 2024 stating her phone was broken,
that it had taken longer than she expected to get a replacement,
and that she was still too busy to meet but was available the
following week. Mother eventually spoke with DCFS by phone on
November 5, 2024. Mother reported she was afraid to go home
and was staying in a hotel. Father was gang affiliated and out on
bail, and Mother’s friends had told her he was in the area where
her home was located. Mother also said paternal grandmother
had threatened her.
5
During the call on November 5, Mother agreed to bring the
children to a local park on November 12, 2024, to meet with
DCFS. Mother never showed up and was not at home when
DCFS looked for her there. DCFS continued to be unable to
reach Mother when contacting her on multiple occasions in
November and December 2024 to follow up. Mother refused to
cooperate with police following Father’s arrest; she further denied
an assistant district attorney permission to speak with the
children.
As Mother made herself unavailable, DFCS consulted law
enforcement to get further information about what occurred on
October 16, 2024. The officers on scene had spoken with Mother
but did not interview the children. Mother told the police she
and Father were married but had been separated for
approximately four years. Father came to her home
unannounced approximately two weeks before the assault and
had remained there since. Once he was at the home, Father did
not permit Mother to leave it. In the days leading up to
October 16, Father hit Mother, including with clothes hangers.
Mother did not call law enforcement because Father had taken
her telephone. Mother and Father argued the day of the incident
and Father slapped the side of her face, causing her nose to bleed;
he also kicked her leg. The children witnessed the assault.
Mother was eventually able to leave the house when Father was
showering, find a telephone, and call the police. When the police
arrived, they found Father inside the home. Although Mother
did not have marks or bruises on her, she showed the police the
bloody clothing she was wearing when her nose bled. The police
arrested Father for intimate partner battery.
6
A DCFS records search found a DVRO protecting Mother,
Michael Jr., Theodore, and Raven from Father that was in effect
between December 13, 2019, and December 12, 2022. The DVRO
required Father to participate in a 52-week batterers’
intervention program and that he not be alone with the children
“pending agreement of Mother – or further court order.” The
records search also showed Father had a lengthy criminal history
that included multiple arrests between 2000 and 2024, and
convictions for possession of a controlled substance for sale, being
a felon in possession of a firearm, obstruction/resisting an
executive officer, stalking, inflicting corporal injury on a spouse
or cohabitant, and driving under the influence.
DCFS attempted to contact Father in November 2024
without success.
B. Dependency Petition and Initial Hearings
On December 9, 2024, DCFS filed a Welfare and
Institutions Code1 section 300 petition alleging all four children
were at risk of harm due to the parents’ history of domestic
violence and the parents not complying with the terms of the
CPO. As Mother remained incommunicado, the court issued
protective custody warrants for the children and arrest warrants
for the parents. Mother eventually surrendered the children to
DCFS on December 27, 2024, and the court recalled the
warrants. The court placed the children with paternal
grandmother.
1 Unspecified statutory references are to the Welfare and
Institutions Code.
7
C. Additional Investigation Before the Adjudication
and Disposition Hearing
After the children were detained, DCFS conducted further
investigation. The family’s legal history included Mother filing
for a DVRO against Father in May 2014. Mother failed to
prosecute the request, and the temporary restraining order was
dissolved in June 2014. Mother filed another DVRO request in
November 2019. This time she went forward with the case and
the court granted her a three-year DVRO against Father. As
mentioned previously, this order was in effect from December
2019 until December 2022; it also granted Mother sole custody of
Michael Jr., Theodore, and Raven with Father having monitored
visits.
Mother continued to dodge engaging with DCFS. She
refused to consent to DCFS speaking with the children regarding
the issues in the section 300 petition.2 Mother initially refused to
meet with DCFS until she had legal counsel or another advocate
with her; she later sent a message agreeing to speak
telephonically but not in person. At some point, criminal charges
against Father related to the October 16, 2024 incident were
dismissed. Mother refused to provide information to DCFS about
the October 16, 2024 incident, saying because the criminal case
was dismissed “I won’t bother commenting [on] it because it was
struck out.” She later provided some confirmatory details about
Father’s actions on October 16. She also stated Father had come
by the family home beforehand to say he would later return to
2 DCFS was able to speak with the children about things
such as sleeping arrangements in the home and to confirm they
had no marks or bruises indicative of abuse.
8
drop off money to help Mother out. She responded, however, to a
follow-up question about how long Father was in the home when
he returned by saying, “I don’t really want to get into details
because the court threw it out.”
Mother said she was being harassed by Father and needed
help to move as she had no family support. Mother said she and
Father had an altercation approximately five years ago, after
which they separated and were no longer together. Since that
time, Father no longer lived in the family home. Mother did not
explain how Nathaniel (who was born in August 2023) was
conceived if she was no longer seeing Father.3 Paternal
grandmother also appeared to partially contradict Mother’s claim
about the length of the parents’ separation, saying Mother and
Father had been separated for “quite some time” but before that
had been in an on-again, off-again relationship for years.
Mother told DCFS she obtained a restraining order after
the 2020 incident, which she initially thought lasted for 10 years
3 Mother’s reply brief hypothesizes, without any supporting
citation to the record, that the “likely scenario” was “that
Nathaniel’s birth was the consequence of [F]ather raping
[M]other.” “It is axiomatic that an appellant must support all
statements of fact in [her] briefs with citations to the record.”
(Pierotti v. Torian (2000) 81 Cal.App.4th 17, 29.) “We look
askance at . . . stating what purport[s] to be facts—and not
unimportant facts—without support in the record. This is a
violation of the rules . . . with the consequence that such
assertions will, at a minimum, be disregarded.” (Liberty National
Enterprises, L.P. v. Chicago Title Ins. Co. (2011) 194 Cal.App.4th
839, 846.)
9
but later learned was only in effect for three years.4 Father
continued to harass her, and she usually would call the police
when this happened. Mother said she was granted an emergency
protective order on October 16, 2024, but did not file a request for
a DVRO when the emergency order expired because she had gone
to Las Vegas. Mother claimed she left a voicemail with DCFS
that she was in Las Vegas and would be unable to meet on
November 12; DCFS disputed this claim, stating its last contact
with Mother was on November 5 when she agreed to meet with
DCFS on November 12 at a local park, and that Mother never
informed DCFS she was in Las Vegas or would be unable to meet
as promised.
DCFS later gave Mother an opportunity to clarify any other
information in its jurisdiction/disposition report she thought was
incorrect. Mother initially declined, saying it was pointless
because DCFS had already perpetrated a story about her that
others would believe. She then claimed that she had accidentally
damaged her phone and was unable to replace it so that she did
not know if DCFS was trying to call her after November 5.
4 Mother’s confusion on this point was understandable.
She obtained a three-year DVRO in 2019. After the 2020
incident, the criminal court issued a 10-year CPO against Father
with Mother as a protected party. It appears that for some
unknown and to this court quite concerning reason the CPO did
not show up when the police or DCFS initially searched for it
after the October 16, 2024 incident, leading them to believe the
then-expired three-year DVRO was the only restraining order in
existence. Mother herself ultimately had to provide a copy of the
CPO protecting her.
10
Mother also told DCFS the statement that she refused to let law
enforcement speak with the children was false.
Mother said she had PTSD from her interactions with
Father, and talking about those interactions in counseling or
hearing about them in court aggravated her trauma. Mother was
residing with a friend because she was afraid Father would show
up at her home, and stated she had an intake appointment with a
program that provided women and their children shelter at a
confidential location. The shelter confirmed Mother had
completed her intake and would be able to move in there in early
February 2025. Mother also said she was on a waitlist for mental
health services; DCFS confirmed this was accurate. Mother
began attending parenting classes and individual counseling.
She had an intake appointment for a domestic violence program
but had not yet started participating in the program.
Mother said she homeschooled Michael Jr., Theodore, and
Raven; Nathaniel was not yet school-aged. Mother said all four
children had autism and two of them were regional center clients.
The regional center, however, had no record that the children
were current clients. During an early interview, one of the boys
described the children’s homeschooling as “play[ing] video games
all day.” Mother denied this and described the children’s daily
routine including the homeschooling program she used. Mother
was not opposed to enrolling the children in traditional schooling
so long as it met the children’s special needs. DCFS undertook
working with Mother to enroll the children in in-person school
and to receive regional center services.
Mother visited with the children when they were in
paternal grandmother’s care. These visits included overnights
that were not court-approved. When DCFS was finally able to
11
speak with the children, each of them stated they could not
remember or did not want to share key facts about what had
happened between Mother and Father. Theodore said he had not
seen Mother and Father fight, but also said that he wished
“peace” for his family “[l]ike when there is no fighting, no arguing
and separating.” Michael Jr. said he could not remember details
about law enforcement responding to the home because “there’s
been too many police visits.”
Father continued to refuse to make himself available to
DCFS or to provide information despite multiple outreach
attempts. Father did not visit with the children due to the CPO.
D. The Jurisdiction and Disposition Hearing
The juvenile court held a combined jurisdiction and
disposition hearing on March 25, 2025, at which both Mother and
Father were present. Counsel for DCFS and the minors asked
the court to sustain the petition. Mother’s counsel asked the
court to strike Mother from the petition, alleging there was no
current risk to the children given her participation in services
and that she was not around Father. Father’s counsel asked the
court to dismiss the petition entirely.
The court sustained the petition as pleaded and asserted
jurisdiction over all four children. The court found a long-
standing and still unresolved history of domestic violence
between the parents based on (1) Mother’s reluctance to enforce
the protective order in 2020 when Father came to her home,
which ended in the children “being used as barricades,”
(2) Mother not enforcing the restraining order in place from 2020
until 2023, and instead engaging in an “on-again, off-again
relationship with [Father that resulted in] having Nathaniel,”
(3) the police description in connection with the October 16, 2024
12
incident that they had been called to Mother’s house 12 previous
times, and (4) the statements from Theodore and Michael Jr.
indicating their exposure to domestic violence. The court found a
current risk to the children because Mother had continued to “put
herself and her children in a situation and minimized [the
problem of] domestic violence, which is why she really needs . . .
counseling to address her longstanding history and have the
strength to make better choices in the future.”
As for disposition, the court removed the children from both
parents’ custody and ordered them suitably placed, made
visitation orders, and ordered DCFS to provide both parents with
reunification services.
E. The Court Returns the Children to Mother
While this appeal was pending, on August 12, 2025, the
juvenile court terminated its removal and suitable placement
order, and ordered the children returned to Mother’s home.
DISCUSSION
A. Substantial Evidence Supports the Court’s
Jurisdictional Orders
Mother does not deny the past domestic violence between
Father and her, or that the children were present during it. She
instead asserts the juvenile court erred in asserting jurisdiction
because, by the time of the March 25, 2025 adjudication hearing,
there was no longer any significant risk of harm to the children
that would support exercising dependency jurisdiction. Father
joins in Mother’s contentions but makes no independent
argument.
13
1. Relevant Law and Standard of Review
For an assertion of jurisdiction to stand, “a significant risk
to the child must exist ‘ “at the time of the jurisdiction
hearing.” ’ ” (In re J.N. (2021) 62 Cal.App.5th 767, 775.) It is the
substantial evidence supporting this jurisdictional element, and
only this element, that Mother challenges on appeal.
We review a jurisdictional finding for substantial evidence
in light of the entire record. (In re I.C. (2018) 4 Cal.5th 869, 892.)
“ ‘To be substantial, the evidence must be of ponderable legal
significance and must be reasonable in nature, credible, and of
solid value.’ ” (In re Cole L. (2021) 70 Cal.App.5th 591, 602.) “We
do not evaluate the credibility of witnesses, reweigh the evidence,
or resolve evidentiary conflicts.” (In re L.Y.L., supra, 101
Cal.App.4th at p. 947.) “[W]e draw all reasonable inferences in
support of the findings, consider the record most favorably to the
juvenile court’s order, and affirm the order if supported by
substantial evidence even if other evidence supports a contrary
conclusion.” (Ibid.)
2. The Children Still Faced Substantial Risk of Harm at
the Time of the March 2025 Jurisdictional Hearing
In arguing against the court’s finding of a current risk of
harm, Mother highlights the following post-October 16, 2024
facts: there were no additional domestic violence episodes after
the October 16 incident; the parents had stayed away from one
another since that incident; Mother had not let Father see the
children after the October 16 incident; and Mother was willing to
and had already begun engaging in services.
Those facts did tip in Mother’s favor, and we commend
these efforts on behalf of her children and herself. However, the
juvenile court was entitled to credit other evidence that indicated
14
the children remained at significant risk of substantial harm.
Despite Mother’s claim that she and Father had not been in a
relationship for approximately five years (since the 2020 incident
where Father used the children as human shields against police),
paternal grandmother reported that Mother and Father had been
in an on-again, off-again relationship and Nathaniel’s birth in
late August 2023 indicated the parents continued to have an
intimate relationship. Mother declined to provide details on how
long Father was in the home before the October 16, 2024
incident, leading to the inference he had been there longer with
Mother’s permission before the domestic violence that led to the
referral. Mother did not comply with protective orders at least
twice: when initially refusing to contact the police in 2020 when
Father visited the home, and later when Nathaniel was
conceived. There was also evidence that Mother refused to
cooperate with law enforcement following the October 16, 2024
incident, sought to evade DCFS by fleeing to Nevada and giving a
false explanation of her failure to inform DCFS of the children’s
whereabouts, and kept the children from speaking with DCFS
until she felt sufficiently confident they would not say anything
incriminating about the relationship between Mother and Father
(including how long he was in the home before Father’s
October 16, 2024 arrest). Additionally, Mother had started the
process to enroll in domestic violence counseling but had not yet
attended any sessions. Considered together, these facts could
reasonably lead the court to doubt Mother had yet sufficiently
separated from Father or taken sufficient steps to break the cycle
she had been in for many years, and thus that the children
continued to be at substantial risk of harm as of the time of the
jurisdictional hearing.
15
Mother’s reliance on In re Ma.V. (2021) 64 Cal.App.5th 11,
In re M.W. (2015) 238 Cal.App.5th 1444, and In re Daisy H.
(2011) 192 Cal.App.4th 713, disapproved on another ground in In
re D.P. (2023) 14 Cal.5th 266, 278, to argue there was no current
risk of harm is unpersuasive. Ma.V. involved a single act of
domestic violence, after which it was undisputed that the
perpetrator left the family home and the mother had ended her
relationship with him. (In re Ma.V., supra, at pp. 14, 22-23.)
M.W. involved a single act of domestic violence that occurred
more than seven years before the juvenile court asserted
jurisdiction. (In re M.W., supra, at pp. 1451, 1454.) The domestic
violence in Daisy H. occurred outside the children’s presence and
“happened at least two, and probably seven, years before the
DCFS filed the petition.” (In re Daisy H., supra, at p. 717.) In
contrast, the violence between Mother and Father here was both
repeated and recent, occurred in the children’s presence, and the
court could reasonably infer that Mother had not yet taken
necessary steps to protect the children from the risk of harm
posed by the domestic violence.
We accordingly conclude substantial evidence supports the
juvenile court’s assertion of jurisdiction as to Mother. As Father
makes no argument independent of Mother, we likewise conclude
the court did not err in asserting jurisdiction as to Father.
B. The Parents’ Appeal of the Removal Order is Moot
Mother concedes her challenge to the removal order is moot
as the juvenile court has since returned the children to her home.
As Mother does not argue we should address this now moot issue,
we dismiss her appeal of that order. (Parkford Owners for a
Better Community v. County of Placer (2020) 54 Cal.App.5th 714,
16
722 [“ ‘When events render a case moot, the court . . . should
generally dismiss it’ ”].)]
Father makes no argument that the court erred in
removing the children from his care. At the disposition hearing,
Father did not ask the juvenile court to return the children to
him; he asked the court to return the children to Mother. As that
has now occurred, his appeal of the removal order is likewise
moot and should be dismissed.
DISPOSITION
The juvenile court’s jurisdictional orders are affirmed.
Mother and Father’s appeals of the removal orders are dismissed
as moot.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED
WEINGART, J.
We concur:
ROTHSCHILD, P. J.
M. KIM, J.
17
Ti chiedi come si applica questo testo alla tua situazione?
Consulenza gratuita, senza impegno
Descrivi la tua situazione. Il nostro team ti ricontatterà via e-mail per la tua consulenza.
Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude
Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.