Siri v. Cooper CA2/8

CourtListener 10709921Calctapp23 ott 2025

Testo completo

Filed 10/23/25 Siri v. Cooper CA2/8
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS

California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION EIGHT

DEREK SIRI, B338137

Plaintiff and Appellant, (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No. 19PSCV00178)
v.

DUANE COOPER,

Defendant and Respondent.

APPEAL from a judgment and orders of the Superior Court
of Los Angeles County. Peter Hernandez, Judge. Affirmed with
directions.
Timothy J. Donahue for Plaintiff and Appellant.
Seki, Nishimura & Watase and Andrew C. Pongracz for
Defendant and Respondent.

**********
A jury found that defendant and respondent Duane Cooper
assaulted plaintiff and appellant Derek Siri and awarded
plaintiff damages of $345,666.67, which included $300,000 in
punitive damages. The trial court granted, on its own motion, a
partial judgment notwithstanding the verdict, finding in favor of
defendant on the issues of punitive damages and medical
expenses. The court also struck, on its own motion, an item of
costs from plaintiff’s cost bill. Plaintiff appeals, contending the
trial court’s orders and modification of the judgment were
without legal authority and void.
We affirm with directions to the superior court on remand
to enter an amended judgment that includes the recoverable costs
awarded to plaintiff.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
We were not provided a record from the jury trial and
therefore rely on the parties’ briefing regarding the facts to
provide some context for our ruling. Put succinctly, plaintiff
apparently walked in on defendant having sexual relations with
plaintiff’s wife. Upon being caught in “the act,” defendant
charged at plaintiff, knocked him to the ground and fled.
Plaintiff filed this action against defendant for assault, battery
and related torts, seeking damages for pain and suffering,
medical expenses, and punitive damages.
In July 2023, the case proceeded to a jury trial. The trial
proceedings were not reported by a court reporter, nor recorded
by an electronic monitoring device. According to the court’s
minute orders during trial, plaintiff and defendant were the only
witnesses to testify. At the conclusion of testimony, defendant
made an oral motion for directed verdict. The minute order does
not reflect any ruling on defendant’s motion.

2
The jury found in favor of plaintiff and awarded
compensatory damages of $45,666.67, consisting of $5,666.67 in
past medical expenses, $20,000 for past pain and suffering, and
$20,000 for future pain and suffering. The jury also awarded
$300,000 in punitive damages. The court entered a judgment in
plaintiff’s favor on August 10, 2023. A line item for costs was left
blank, to be determined at a later date after the filing of a
memorandum of costs.
Plaintiff filed and served notice of entry of judgment on
August 17, 2023. The register of actions indicates defendant filed
a notice of intent to move for a new trial on September 1, 2023,
and a motion for judgment notwithstanding the verdict on
September 5, 2023.
On October 13, 2023, the court issued a nonappearance
minute order, denying defendant’s motion for judgment
notwithstanding the verdict as untimely. The court said
defendant’s motion was filed on September 5, 2023, more than
15 days after service by plaintiff of notice of entry of judgment.
(Code Civ. Proc., § 629, subd. (a).) The court went on to explain
that it was noticing a hearing for October 31, 2023, to consider a
sua sponte motion for judgment notwithstanding the verdict, to
be heard concurrently with defendant’s motion for new trial.
On October 31, 2023, after briefing and argument from the
parties, the court denied defendant’s motion for new trial. On the
court’s sua sponte motion, the court “partially GRANT[ED] its
own Motion for Judgment Notwithstanding the Verdict.” The
court’s order stated that its “findings are reflected in the Court’s
Memorandum, which is filed and incorporated into the court file.”
Defendant was ordered to submit an amended judgment within
10 days. The minute order reflects the hearing was transcribed

3
by a court reporter but a copy of the transcript was not included
in the record filed with this court.
The trial court’s memorandum supporting its partial grant
of judgment notwithstanding the verdict was filed on
November 6, 2023. The memorandum summarized the
procedural history of the case and the jury trial, and elaborated
on the court’s findings for granting a partial judgment
notwithstanding the verdict. The court pointed out that “Neither
party sought nor was willing to present to the court stipulated
facts that governed the trial testimony. As shown below, the
evidence was scarce, unreliable and, as to certain issues, non-
existent.” The court concluded the evidentiary record did not
support an award of punitive damages or medical expenses in
any amount and found in favor of defendant on those issues.
The court left intact the balance of the jury’s verdict in favor of
plaintiff in the amount of $40,000.
Defendant submitted a modified judgment in plaintiff’s
favor in the amount of $40,000 that was entered by the court on
November 13, 2023. The modified judgment does not include any
mention of recoverable costs. There is nothing in the record
showing that notice of entry of the modified judgment was given.
The register of actions indicates that later that same day,
plaintiff filed a motion to reconsider or set aside the court’s order
granting the partial judgment notwithstanding the verdict.
Plaintiff’s motion argued the order was void because it was issued
after the court lost jurisdiction to make such a ruling, and
because it was an improper means of “reducing” a damage award.
On November 30, 2023, plaintiff filed a memorandum of
costs seeking total costs of $24,850.67. One of the cost items

4
sought by plaintiff, under item 16 titled “Other,” was “County
costs $12,031.62.”
On March 5, 2024, the court denied plaintiff’s motion for
reconsideration, explaining it had no jurisdiction to reconsider its
ruling because plaintiff’s motion was filed after the modified
judgment had already been entered. The court also said plaintiff
had failed to show any substantive basis for reconsideration and
denied it on that basis as well.
On March 11, 2024, the court issued an order
acknowledging receipt of plaintiff’s proposed modified judgment
which included his requested costs of $24,850.67. The court said
it would amend the judgment to include recoverable costs, but
that it was striking the $12,031.62 requested by plaintiff to cover
the amount plaintiff had been previously ordered to pay to the
county following its successful summary judgment motion.
The court gave plaintiff an opportunity to brief the legal basis for
recovering that item of costs. Plaintiff filed a brief arguing
entitlement to the costs, without identifying any statutory basis
for such costs. The register of actions does not indicate that a
modified judgment, amended to include plaintiff’s recoverable
costs, was filed.
This appeal followed.
DISCUSSION
1. The appeal was timely
Defendant says plaintiff’s appeal is untimely because the
notice of appeal was filed more than 60 days after service of the
court’s order on the motion for judgment notwithstanding the
verdict. The contention is without merit.
The trial court’s order of October 31, 2023 granting, on its
own motion, a partial judgment notwithstanding the verdict was

5
not an appealable order. The order was reviewable, however,
from a timely appeal of the modified judgment entered pursuant
to that order. (7 Witkin, Cal. Procedure (6th ed. 2025) Trial,
§ 433.) The modified judgment was filed by defendant and
entered in the court’s register of actions on November 13, 2023.
Nothing in the record indicates that notice of entry of that
modified judgment was served by a party or by the clerk. The
judgment shows it was served by mail on November 6, 2023 as a
“proposed” judgment, but the record does not contain any
indication the signed and file-stamped judgment of November 13,
2023 was served. (Palmer v. GTE California, Inc. (2003)
30 Cal.4th 1265, 1267–1268 [service of file-stamped judgment
starts statutory time periods for postjudgment filings].) When
neither the clerk nor a party serves notice of entry of judgment,
an appellant has 180 days from entry of judgment to file a notice
of appeal. (Kimball Avenue v. Franco (2008) 162 Cal.App.4th
1224, 1228; Cal. Rules of Court, rule 8.104(a)(1).)
Plaintiff’s notice of appeal, filed April 24, 2024, gave notice
the appeal was from the court’s entry of judgment on November
13, 2023, and the postjudgment orders issued on March 5 and 11,
2024. Plaintiff’s notice was filed 163 days after entry of the
November 13, 2023 judgment and was therefore timely.
The postjudgment cost order of March 11, 2024, was
separately appealable. (Kajima Engineering and Construction,
Inc. v. Pacific Bell (2002) 103 Cal.App.4th 1397, 1402.) Plaintiff’s
notice of appeal as to that order, filed less than 60 days later, was
timely. To the extent plaintiff’s appeal of the March 5, 2024
order denying the motion for reconsideration was appealable, the
notice was also filed within 60 days of the entry of that order.

6
2. The trial court’s sua sponte order granting partial
judgment notwithstanding the verdict
Plaintiff contends the trial court’s order is void due to
various procedural irregularities. We disagree.
The trial court had the authority to sua sponte grant a
motion for judgment notwithstanding the verdict under Code of
Civil Procedure section 629, subdivision (a). “[A] trial court on its
own motion, with five days’ notice to the parties, can grant j.n.o.v.
so long as it acts before expiration of its power to rule on a motion
for a new trial, 60 days, and after expiration of the time within
which a motion for a new trial must be served and filed—15 days.
Otherwise, no express time limit within which the court must
make its motion for j.n.o.v. has been imposed by the Legislature.”
(Sturgeon v. Leavitt (1979) 94 Cal.App.3d 957, 964, italics added.)
The court complied with these statutory requirements
before holding a hearing on October 31, 2023 and issuing its
order.
The court also had the authority to grant a partial
judgment notwithstanding the verdict. “Since a trial court has
the authority to grant a motion for judgment notwithstanding the
verdict ‘whenever a motion for a directed verdict for the
aggrieved party should have been granted’ and a directed verdict
may be granted ‘as to some, but not all, of the issues involved in
the action,’ it follows, as surely as the greater includes the lesser,
that a trial court may grant judgment notwithstanding the
verdict as to some but not all issues.” (Beavers v. Allstate Ins. Co.
(1990) 225 Cal.App.3d 310, 323 [affirming grant of partial
judgment notwithstanding the verdict on issue of punitive
damages and two of the plaintiff’s causes of action].)

7
The trial court’s written order states it found no
evidentiary basis for an award of punitive damages. Despite
plaintiff’s assertion to the contrary, this was not a situation
where the court sought only to reduce the amount of punitive
damages to a reasonable amount. Had the court found the award
of punitive damages merely excessive as opposed to improper as a
matter of law, the trial court would have been required to follow
the procedures for remittitur set forth in Code of Civil Procedure,
section 662.5. (Teitel v. First L.A. Bank (1991) 231 Cal.App.3d
1593, 1604–1605; accord, Ena North Beach, Inc. v. 524 Union
Street (2019) 43 Cal.App.5th 195, 213.) The court here plainly
did not find the amount of punitive damages awarded excessive.
It concluded there was no legal basis for an award of punitive
damages in any amount. The court was well within its authority
to grant a partial judgment notwithstanding the verdict on that
discrete issue.
Plaintiff also contends the court’s order is void because the
court did not file its written order explaining the reasons for its
ruling until November 6, 2023, and the last day to issue such an
order was October 31, 2023. We are not persuaded.
Code of Civil Procedure section 629 states that “[t]he power
of the court to rule on a motion for judgment notwithstanding the
verdict shall not extend beyond the last date upon which it has
the power to rule on a motion for a new trial. If a motion for
judgment notwithstanding the verdict is not determined before
that date, the effect shall be a denial of that motion without
further order of the court.” (Id., subd. (b).)
The last day the trial court could rule on a motion for new
trial was 75 days from the date plaintiff served notice of entry of
the original judgment. (Code Civ. Proc., § 660, subd. (c).)

8
The 75th day was October 31, 2023. The trial court timely issued
its order on October 31, 2023, and entered it in the permanent
minutes. That the court followed up that timely minute order
with a longer written order elaborating on the reasons for its
decision does not render the order of October 31, 2023 void.
Plaintiff disagrees, arguing that the filing of motions for
judgment notwithstanding the verdict must be done in
accordance with the filing periods specified in Code of Civil
Procedure section 659. This is true. Section 629, subdivision (b),
specifically cross-references section 659 and states that a “motion
for judgment notwithstanding the verdict shall be made within
the period specified by Section 659 for the filing and service of a
notice of intention to move for a new trial.” (§ 629, subd. (b).)
Section 629 also cross-references section 659a and section 660,
incorporating the time periods for filing briefs and setting a
hearing on a motion for new trial.
But, plaintiff then relies on language from Code of Civil
Procedure section 657—a statute that is not cross-referenced in
section 629. Section 657 pertains solely to motions for new trial,
enumerating the “grounds” for new trial motions and specifying
rules for orders granting a new trial. Section 657 provides that
an order granting a new trial “must state the ground or grounds
relied upon by the court, and may contain the specification of
reasons. If an order granting such motion does not contain such
specification of reasons, the court must, within 10 days after
filing such order, prepare, sign and file such specification of
reasons in writing with the clerk.” (Ibid.) Plaintiff cites no case
that imposes this requirement for new trial orders on orders
granting a motion for judgment notwithstanding the verdict.
We are not persuaded there is any sound reason to do so.

9
Moreover, to the extent plaintiff asks us to assess the
propriety of the court’s finding that the trial evidence did not
support the award of any punitive damages, we cannot do so.
The parties chose not to have the trial proceedings transcribed or
reported in any manner. Plaintiff also chose not to present this
court with a summary of the trial court proceedings in accordance
with rule 8.836 or rule 8.837 of the California Rules of Court.
Plaintiff, as the appellant, had a duty to present an adequate
record that allowed for meaningful review. (Ballard v. Uribe
(1986) 41 Cal.3d 564, 574–575 (Ballard); accord, Hotels Nevada,
LLC v. L.A. Pacific Center, Inc. (2012) 203 Cal.App.4th 336, 348
[appellant’s failure to provide adequate record “ ‘requires that the
issue be resolved against appellant’ ”].)
As our Supreme Court has explained, “ ‘[a] judgment or
order of the lower court is presumed correct. All intendments and
presumptions are indulged to support it on matters as to which
the record is silent, and error must be affirmatively shown. This
is not only a general principle of appellate practice but an
ingredient of the constitutional doctrine of reversible error.’ ”
(Denham v. Superior Court of Los Angeles County (1970) 2 Cal.3d
557, 564 (Denham).) Without a record, we presume the trial
court’s order was correct and plaintiff has failed to affirmatively
show error.
The trial court also granted judgment notwithstanding the
verdict on the issue of past medical expenses, which is just one
item of compensatory damages awarded by the jury. Whether
this is appropriately an “issue” on which partial judgment may be
granted under Code of Civil Procedure section 629, plaintiff failed
to argue or develop this issue at all. We are not obliged to

10
develop this argument for plaintiff. (United Grand Corp. v.
Malibu Hillbillies, LLC (2019) 36 Cal.App.5th 142, 153.)
3. The postjudgment order of March 5, 2024
On March 5, 2024, the trial court denied plaintiff’s motion
for reconsideration of its order granting partial judgment
notwithstanding the verdict. The trial court correctly ruled it
had no jurisdiction to reconsider its order because the modified
judgment had already been entered. The register of actions
established the modified judgment was entered on November 13,
2023, and that plaintiff’s motion for reconsideration was filed
thereafter. The trial court no longer had jurisdiction to entertain
plaintiff’s motion for reconsideration. (Marshall v. Webster (2020)
54 Cal.App.5th 275, 281 [“It is settled law that a motion for
reconsideration is ineffectual if it is filed after entry of
judgment”]; accord, Ballona Wetlands Land Trust v. City of
Los Angeles (2011) 201 Cal.App.4th 455, 479.)
However, the trial court had the authority to treat
plaintiff’s motion as a motion for new trial or other appropriate
postjudgment motion and consider it on the merits. “The
proposition that a trial court may construe a motion bearing one
label as a different type of motion is one that has existed for
many decades. . . . [S]everal courts have tacitly approved the
treatment of a motion for reconsideration as a motion for a new
trial, and vice versa. [Citations.] The principle that a trial court
may consider a motion regardless of the label placed on it by a
party is consistent with the court’s inherent authority to manage
and control its docket. (Code Civ. Proc., §§ 128, subd. (a), 187.)”
(Sole Energy Co. v. Petrominerals Corp. (2005) 128 Cal.App.4th
187, 193.)

11
The trial court’s order purports to deny plaintiff’s motion on
the merits as an alternative to its finding that it lacked
jurisdiction to reconsider its prejudgment order. As we already
explained above, to the extent plaintiff asks us to reverse the
court’s order on the merits, we are unable to do so because
plaintiff failed to present a record of the trial proceedings. It was
plaintiff’s burden to do so. In the absence of a meaningful record
from which error is affirmatively shown, we presume the
correctness of the trial court’s order. (Ballard, supra, 41 Cal.3d
at pp. 574–575; Denham, supra, 2 Cal.3d at p. 564.)
4. The postjudgment order of March 11, 2024
Plaintiff contends the trial court had no authority to strike
an item of costs from the cost memorandum because defendant
did not file a motion to tax costs or otherwise object to the cost
memorandum. Plaintiff says that once the time to file a motion
to tax costs had elapsed, the clerk was required by rule 3.1700 of
the California Rules of Court to enter his requested costs in their
entirety. (Id., rule 3.1700(b)(4) [“After the time has passed for a
motion to strike or tax costs or for determination of that motion,
the clerk must immediately enter the costs on the judgment”].)
We do not agree. Recoverable costs by a prevailing party in
a civil action are only those expressly “authorized by statute.”
(Parker v. City of Los Angeles (1974) 44 Cal.App.3d 556, 566;
accord, Ladas v. California State Auto. Assn. (1993)
19 Cal.App.4th 761, 774; see also Code Civ. Proc., § 1033.5.)
Plaintiff sought to recover from defendant the $12,031.62
plaintiff was previously ordered to pay to the County of
Los Angeles when the county, earlier in the action, prevailed on
summary judgment. Plaintiff did not cite to any statutory

12
provision or other express legal authority that allows a prevailing
party to recover such costs.
Items of costs not expressly authorized by statute “may be
allowed or denied in the court’s discretion.” (Code Civ. Proc.,
§ 1033.5, subd. (c)(4).) Plaintiff has not shown the trial court
abused its discretion in sua sponte striking $12,031.62 from his
requested costs.
However, the modified judgment entered on November 13,
2023, does not contain any reference to plaintiff’s recoverable
costs, with or without the amount stricken by the court. The
register of actions does not indicate that any amended judgment
with a cost award was filed after the motion hearings in March
2024. Defendant does not contest that plaintiff is indeed entitled
to costs as the prevailing party, minus the amount at item 16
stricken by the court. On remand, the trial court is directed to
amend the judgment to reflect the correct amount of total costs
awarded to plaintiff.

13
DISPOSITION
The judgment entered November 13, 2023 in favor of Derek
Siri in the amount of $40,000 is affirmed. On remand, the
superior court is directed to enter an amended judgment that
includes the correct total of recoverable costs awarded to plaintiff
($12,819.05).
The parties shall bear the own respective costs of appeal.

VIRAMONTES, J.

WE CONCUR:

WILEY, Acting P. J.

RUBIN, J. 


Retired Presiding Justice of the Court of Appeal, Second
Appellate District, assigned by the Chief Justice pursuant to
article VI, section 6 of the California Constitution.

14

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.