In re Anthony C. CA2/1

CourtListener 10687801Calctapp2 ott 2025

Testo completo

Filed 10/2/25 In re Anthony C. CA2/1
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS

California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION ONE

In re ANTHONY C., a Person B343797
Coming Under Juvenile Court
Law. (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No. CK83027)

LOS ANGELES COUNTY
DEPARTMENT OF
CHILDREN AND FAMILY
SERVICES,

Plaintiff and Respondent,

v.

N.C.,

Defendant and Appellant.

APPEAL from orders of the Superior Court of Los Angeles
County, Marguerite D. Downing, Judge. Affirmed.
Elizabeth Klippi, under appointment by the Court of
Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, Kim Nemoy,
Assistant County Counsel, and Courtney Fisher, Deputy County
Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
__________________________________

In July 2012, the juvenile court terminated jurisdiction
over minors Anthony C. (born March 2008) and Aliyah B. (born
November 2009) after ordering a legal guardianship with the
children’s paternal grandmother (PGM) serving as the guardian.
Twelve years later, appellant mother N.C. brought a
petition under Welfare and Institutions Code section 388, asking
the court to reinstate jurisdiction to “enforce” her visitation with
Anthony, and to “explore potential termination of the
guardianship if it is determined that the legal guardian is
neglecting the child’s needs and if the child no longer wishes to
reside there.”1 Respondent Los Angeles Department of Children
and Family Services (DCFS) recommended the court deny the
petition, and the court did so without an evidentiary hearing.
On appeal, Mother contends the court erred in denying her
an evidentiary hearing because she presented a prima facie case
of both changed circumstances and that her request was in
Anthony’s best interest. We conclude the court did not err in
denying Mother’s petition both because Mother’s requested relief
was moot and because substantial evidence supports the court’s
conclusion that the requested relief was not in Anthony’s best
interest. We therefore affirm without considering whether the

1 Undesignated statutory references are to the Welfare and

Institutions Code.

2
court erred in finding Mother failed to demonstrate changed
circumstances.2

FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND3

A. The Court Sustains a Petition
When Mother gave birth to Aliyah in November 2009, both
tested positive for methamphetamine. Mother denied using
methamphetamine but could provide no explanation for the test
results. DCFS convened a “Team Decision Making” (TDM)
meeting with the parents and Mother agreed, among other
requirements, to participate in drug treatment and testing. In
January 2010, a voluntary reunification contract was initiated;
Anthony and Aliyah were placed with PGM. Mother attended
programs until May 2010 and then dropped out and stopped
returning calls from the children’s social worker (CSW). PGM
reported that the maternal grandmother had stated Mother was
using drugs again. Mother missed 11 drug tests between
January and June 2010.
Another TDM meeting was held in July 2010, where
Mother admitted she smoked marijuana daily, and that she last
used methamphetamine in January 2010. Five days later, DCFS
filed a petition under section 300, subdivisions (b) and (g) on
behalf of Anthony and Aliyah. The petition alleged Mother had a
history of drug use and was a current user of methamphetamine

2 We note also that Anthony’s legal guardianship will end

when he turns 18 in March 2026, approximately six months from
now.
3 We limit our summary to the facts and procedural history

relevant to the issues appellant raises on appeal.

3
and marijuana, rendering her incapable of caring for her
children. The petition noted Mother had tested positive for
methamphetamine at Aliyah’s birth, and that “[r]emedial
services failed to resolve the family problems in that the mother
failed to regularly participate in a substance rehabilitation
program and random drug testing.”4 The court found a prima
facie case for detention, and DCFS placed the children with
PGM.5
In a conversation with a dependency investigator (DI) in
August 2010, Mother admitted to using methamphetamine the
night before Aliyah was born, saying it was “easy” to do, and that
she “didn’t think about what could happen.” Mother claimed she
had a “couple of hits that night” and went into early labor.
Mother admitted to previously using methamphetamine but
denied using around Anthony. She stated she first tried
methamphetamine when she was 15 years old and the last time
she used it was around July 9, 2010. She last smoked marijuana
around July 23, 2010.

4 The petition also alleged the children’s father, Victor C.,

who was incarcerated, failed to provide them with the necessities
of life. Father is not a party to this appeal.
5 While the minute order from the hearing states the

children were placed with the maternal grandmother, this
appears to be a typographical error as both parties and DCFS
reports acknowledge the children were placed with PGM.

4
In September 2010, the court sustained an amended
petition and declared the children dependents of the court.6
Mother was granted monitored visits.

B. The Court Appoints PGM the Legal Guardian
and Terminates Jurisdiction
Mother attended a drug program from December 2010 to
February 2011 and tested negative on January 27, February 14,
February 25, and March 7, 2011. She also consistently visited
the children, and DCFS permitted Mother to have four-hour,
unmonitored visits. However, on March 10, 2011, Mother tested
positive for amphetamine and methamphetamine. At the six-
month review hearing, the court ordered further reunification
services for Mother and reverted to monitored visitation.
Mother missed three drug tests in March and April 2011
but tested negative once in April as well. She stated she did not
know why she relapsed in March. She reentered a drug program
around May 2011 but left in July 2011 because she needed to find
employment and because she was “having some problems with
the program staff.” Mother did not reenroll in another program;
she missed drug tests in June and July 2021. In November 2021,
the court terminated reunifications services for Mother. In July
2012, the court appointed PGM the legal guardian of both
Anthony and Aliyah and terminated jurisdiction. The court’s
order granted visitation to Mother but left blank the space to
specify the visitation schedule.

6 Instead of stating Mother “failed to regularly participate

in a substance abuse program,” the amended petition stated she
“failed to complete a substance abuse program.”

5
C. The Court Denies Mother’s First Section 388
Petition

1. Mother Files a Petition
In March 2022, Mother, who at the time lived in
Washington, filed a section 388 petition, asking the court to
return custody of Anthony to her.7 Mother stated that, since the
time PGM was made Anthony’s guardian, Mother had obtained
stable housing and had cared for two children their entire lives.8
She also stated that for “a few years” now, she had been going to
counseling and had “[her] life together.” She added that Anthony
lived with her for a year starting April 2020, and it “went very
well.” Mother claimed Anthony was attending school and
adjusting well when PGM “came and got him without notice,” and
Anthony called her weekly asking when he could return. Mother
asked the court to “[r]eturn custody back to me so my family
could be reunited.”
Attached to the petition was a letter from a YWCA “family
advocate” working with Mother. The letter stated that Anthony
lived with Mother from April 2020 to November 2021; that
Mother discovered Anthony had not received any vaccinations
while under PGM’s care; that Mother had him vaccinated and
enrolled in school, where he received good grades; that, since
PGM retrieved Anthony, he was “failing in school,” “struggling in
California,” and wanting to return to Mother; that Mother put
the needs of her family first; and that Mother took good care of

7 Mother simultaneously filed a section 388 petition asking

for Aliyah’s return.
8 Mother was living with her son Victor C. (born September

2012) and daughter A.W. (born January 2014).

6
her nine-year-old son and eight-year-old daughter—presumably
Victor and A.W.—both of whom had been in her care since birth.9
Also attached to the petition were: (1) a notarized document
entitled “Temporary Guardianship,” in which PGM appointed
Mother as “temporary guardianship [sic]” of Anthony from April
3, 2020 “until terminated by” PGM; (2) a declaration of a friend of
Mother’s, attesting to her “selfless . . . devotion” to her children,
and recounting a statement from Anthony that he was proud to
call Mother his mom; (3) a letter from a survivor advocate from a
human trafficking program at API Chaya, describing Mother as
proactive, resourceful, and sincere; and (4) a letter from a case
manager for the Washington Anti-Trafficking Response Network
who described Mother as an “outstanding community member
who sets goals for her[self], and her children.”

2. DCFS Investigates
In April 2022, the court ordered DCFS to respond to
Mother’s petition and set a hearing “on whether the court should
grant or deny an evidentiary hearing.”

(a) Mother
In June 2022, a DI interviewed Mother remotely through a
video call. When the DI asked Mother the name of the facility
where she had completed her classes and programs, Mother did
not know, stating only that it was a faith-based program. Mother
then “began to get upset and stated, ‘I didn’t know you were
going to ask all these questions and need all this.’ ” Mother
showed the DI a few certificates of completion, but they did not

9 The family advocate did not explain how she knew how

Anthony was faring in California or what he wanted.

7
indicate specifically what she completed. Mother also said “she
was receiving substance abuse services and was being drug
tested” but she “did not have the test results nor a letter of
completion indicating that she received illicit substance abuse
treatment.”
When the DI asked Mother if she had completed any
classes in Los Angeles during the open case, Mother “stated that
she never attended Court or had an attorney,” “that she was
never told by the Court nor the Department of any services she
had to complete,” and “that she never had a social worker
assigned to her nor did she ever speak to anyone from the
Department of Children and Family Services.” Mother claimed
she learned of everything through PGM. However, Mother then
claimed DCFS had informed her the case was closed and that a
CSW had put her in a drug program to “get clean.” Mother
informed the CSW she could not attend the program “right now,”
so she asked DCFS to close the case, and Mother left for
Portland. When the DI asked Mother to clarify given her
previous statements that she had no contact with DCFS or a
social worker, Mother became upset and said, “No, I left and close
that case and I left [sic].” When the DI asked Mother if she had
completed any of her case plan, Mother responded, “I didn’t get
anything. I just knew what she (referring to [PGM]) would tell
me. I didn’t have a worker in Los Angeles. I’m not going to say
anything. I see you writing everything. You’re contradicting
everything I’m saying. I had nothing to do with this! You can
call all this off!” Mother then walked off and began pacing.
After some time, Mother agreed to continue the interview.
Mother stated that when she lived in Portland, she “did
parenting, drug test, behavior program” but, when the DI asked

8
her why she did those classes, Mother responded, “I don’t really
know. I don’t know, I don’t know. I have short memory loss.”
The DI asked Mother if she had participated in any
services while living in Washington; Mother stated social workers
had come to her house. When asked why, Mother reported,
“Anthony was bullying kids at school and there was a case open
for Anthony. And my parenting coach didn’t like how he was
treating me and yelling at me. She didn’t like what she saw. He
(Anthony) was giving me attitude.” Mother denied the social
workers were from Child Protective Services, describing them as
“people from YWCA” and “[s]ervices that they were giving
Anthony because he was screaming, mistreating my youngest
kid. He (referring to the child, Anthony) feels like I left him
behind. He (Anthony) said that I abandoned him. There was no
one there to care for me emotionally and physically. I have
PTSD, anxiety!” Mother claimed Anthony began having issues
after he arrived in Washington, and that both she and Anthony
received services for four months.
When the DI reminded Mother they had spoken in October
2021 and Mother had reported both that she was homeless and
that she had used illicit drugs ten months prior, Mother denied
saying either of those things. When the DI asked Mother when
she last used illicit drugs, she stated it was before Anthony came
to live with her. When asked where her children Victor and A.W.
were when she used the drugs, Mother stated, “I went to classes.
That’s why I completed my classes.” When the DI asked Mother
her drug of choice, Mother responded, “I don’t have all this right
now. I should just forget about all this! I wasn’t prepared for all
this. You’re bringing trauma to me! This isn’t working.” Mother
clarified her reference to trauma was the DI “[t]alking about my

9
case and when my kids were taken away. It’s still gonna be a
fucken case! Everything I did is wrong!” Mother walked away,
saying: “I don’t even care! Fucken shit!” The DI heard Mother
dialing from another phone and saying, “Can you please see me.
I’m not feeling well.” The DI asked Mother who she was
speaking to and Mother responded it was her daughter’s father.
Mother appeared to still be upset and was crying; the DI asked
Mother if she wanted to end the interview, but Mother did not
respond. The DI ended the interview.
During the call, Mother claimed that when she had video
calls with Anthony, she saw drugs and drug paraphernalia in the
background, and that Father was living with PGM. These
allegations triggered a DCFS investigation.10

(b) Parenting Coach
The DI also spoke with a mental health professional that
Mother called her parenting coach. The professional stated she
had become involved with Mother because her youngest
children’s school attendance was poor. She had also met Anthony
and opined Anthony was having a difficult time with Mother and
his siblings. She stated CPS became involved because Anthony
was “bullying his younger brother.” The coach stated Mother had
been “participating in parenting for about 2 years and recently
took 2 months off” because Mother was “burnt out.”

3. Mother Amends Her Petition
In July 2022, Mother amended her petition to add that she
“completed a full substance abuse program with Exodus,

10 The investigation resulted in the referral being closed

“with no safety concerns.”

10
aftercare, parenting, anger management,” and that PGM was
“struggling” to care for the children. Mother stated her belief
that PGM was neglecting Anthony, “leading him to using
marijuana, and failing in school.” Mother claimed PGM had not
addressed these issues and had “failed to followup [sic] with the
appropriate medical immunizations for Anthony.” Mother asked
the court to “Reinstate jurisdiction----Order home of parent
mother, or in the alternative, reinstate reunification services
with unmonitored visits.”
Accompanying the amended petition were: (1) a July 24,
2021 certificate for completing “Functional Family Therapy
Program”; (2) a March 13, 2015 certificate for completion of “the
Exodus Program”; (3) an October 6, 2014 certificate for
completion of “Mommy, Daddy, and Me”; (4) an October 6, 2014
certificate for completion of “Parenting Education”; (5) a May 8,
2014 certificate for completion of “Anger Management”; (6) a July
4, 2014 certificate for completion of “Alcohol and Drug
Education”; (7) a July 31, 2014 certificate for completion of
“Relapse Prevention Group”; (8) a May 7, 2014 certificate for
completion of “Life Skills Group”; and (9) a March 11, 2022 letter
from Anthony’s middle school stating he did not meet the
requirements to participate in the eighth grade graduation
because his GPA was 0.60.

4. DCFS Investigates Further
The DI attempted to speak with the provider of the
programs from which Mother had obtained certificates but was
told Mother would need to authorize the provider to speak with
the DI. Mother agreed to do so but never did. When asked later
whether she had provided the requested authorization, Mother

11
stated she had not and directed the DI to speak with her attorney
if she had any questions.
Anthony told the DI he had never lived with Mother and
“was just thinking of staying here” with PGM. He acknowledged
living with Mother in Washington the previous year and
described the situation as a “good experience,” but stated he had
more opportunities where he currently lived, and he felt more
connected with his friends and family in his current living
situation. He also said he did not talk with Mother “that often.”
When directly asked whether he wanted to try reunifying with
Mother, Anthony responded, “Not at this time.”11

5. The Court Denies Mother’s Petition
In August 2022, the court denied Mother’s petition without
an evidentiary hearing because “there isn’t really a change in
circumstance, but if there were, it would not be in the best
interest of these children at this time to return them home or to
provide reunification services to the mother at this time.”

D. The Court Denies Mother’s Second Section 388
Petition

1. Mother Files a Petition
In October 2024, Mother filed another section 388 petition
about Anthony, asking the court to “[r]einstate jurisdiction to
enforce mother’s visitation, and to explore potential termination

11 The DI also spoke with Aliyah, who said she did not want

to live with Mother and referred to PGM’s home as “my home.”
Aliyah voiced her desire to have PGM adopt her. A later DCFS
report contained information that PGM’s adoption of Aliyah
would be finalized in November 2024.

12
of the guardianship if it is determined that the legal guardian is
neglecting the child’s needs and if the child no longer wishes to
reside there.” Mother claimed PGM “has reportedly been
refusing to allow any visitation or contact between mother and
the minor” and that Mother “has information and concerns
received from relatives that the legal guardian is neglecting the
child’s medical needs and that the child no longer wishes to
reside there.” Mother argued her request was in Anthony’s best
interest because it was “detrimental” for Anthony “to have visits
terminated unilaterally” and he should be “in a safe and
nurturing home.” The court again ordered DCFS to respond and
set a hearing “on whether the court should grant or deny an
evidentiary hearing.”

2. DCFS Opposes Mother’s Petition
DCFS interviewed various individuals about the issues
raised in Mother’s petition.

(a) Anthony
A DI spoke with Anthony and informed him Mother had
asked the court to terminate the legal guardianship if it was
determined PGM was neglecting his medical needs, and he no
longer wished to live there. Anthony responded, “I don’t want to
be here anymore. I need my space to grow.” When asked to
elaborate, Anthony said he was “pretty sure” Mother had her own
home, and he would “have his own space compared to sharing a
bedroom with” his 17-year-old paternal uncle when living with
PGM. When asked if PGM was neglecting him, Anthony said he
did not eat Fridays after school because PGM did not cook. He
“confirmed plenty of food being in the home” but reported he did
not know how to cook. He admitted he could “make himself a

13
sandwich and operate a microwave to heat up leftover or other
microwaveable foods.”
Anthony also reported that two years prior, he was hit by a
car while riding an electric scooter, resulting in scarring on his
knees and elbows. Anthony complained PGM did not ask how he
felt or take him to the hospital, although he also admitted he did
not tell PGM he needed medical attention. Anthony said PGM
“does not take him to the doctor when he is sick with a cold nor
reminds him to take his medicine when sick.” Anthony denied
getting sick on a regular basis. Anthony voiced his desire to have
someone take care of him, which PGM could not do because she
also had to care for three other kids. Anthony reported PGM did
not talk to him and did not care where he went or whether he had
completed his homework. Anthony believed Mother would
provide him with more “attention,” “structure,” and “guidance.”
When asked why his feelings about living with Mother had
changed, Anthony responded, “I don’t feel this place is for me.
I’m stuck. I’m useless.” He felt like “everyone’s experiencing
more than me,” asking, “aren’t kids my age supposed to drive and
have an ID?” Anthony stated he had asked PGM for help to get a
state identification card, but she ignored him, so he did not ask
again. Anthony also claimed PGM would not give him any
money. Anthony was not receptive to any advice the DI gave on
how he might improve his living situation or relationship with
PGM “because he was adamant that nothing will change based
on her being occupied with his other siblings.”
When the DI explained to Anthony that even if the court
reinstated reunification services, it could take a minimum of six
months to reunify with Mother, Anthony “was in disbelief” and
appeared disappointed, mentioning he had only a year before he

14
turned 18 years old. When asked how frequently he spoke with
Mother, Anthony was unsure but stated it was not very often,
perhaps once a week.

(b) Mother
In November 2024, the DI contacted Mother for an
interview. At the outset, the DI informed Mother “the interview
may take two phone calls given that she had a mandatory
training and will call her back after to resume if necessary.
Mother understood and agreed.”
Mother reported that in 2022, she was receiving individual
counseling from a service called “Victims of Crime- Rest
Program.” Mother explained she had been the victim of domestic
violence from A.W.’s father, against whom she and her daughter
had a five-year restraining order that expires in February 2027.
Regarding Mother’s sobriety, she stated she relapsed with
methamphetamine and marijuana in 2020 but had subsequently
enrolled in an outpatient drug program and had been sober since.
The DI asked Mother about her allegations that PGM was
neglecting Anthony’s health. Mother repeated her claim that,
when she attempted to enroll Anthony in school in 2020, she
discovered he was missing multiple vaccinations. She also
claimed PGM would not take Anthony to the doctor after he was
struck by a car and complained of leg pain, and that the maternal
aunt took Anthony to the doctor instead.
Mother claimed she could pay more attention to Anthony
than PGM. She believed she could “provide emotional support,
experience activities, help with homework, and make him hot
meals.” Mother claimed PGM did not cook homemade meals and
lacked the time to take Anthony to “do fun things.” She claimed
Anthony wore ripped clothes and was not given money to buy

15
snacks at school. Mother could not describe how his clothes were
ripped but said he brought them to the maternal grandmother for
mending. Mother also reported she was sending Anthony money
on a weekly basis because PGM was not giving him any.
Additionally, she claimed Anthony was forced to walk home from
school because PGM would not pick him up, unlike the other
children in PGM’s care. Mother alleged all Anthony’s paternal
uncles were in a gang, and worried Anthony would “fall into that
lifestyle.”
When the DI explained to Mother that her request to
“reinstate jurisdiction” was a request for the juvenile court to
“open a dependency case to service the family and support
reunifying a child to their parents,” Mother stated she did not
know that and did not want an open case but would agree to one
if that was the only way to get Anthony back.
When asked about Anthony’s previous interactions with
Mother’s younger children, she denied any bullying, stating
Anthony was just being “rough” with Victor, “but didn’t hurt
him.”
The DI needed to leave the interview to attend her
mandatory training and informed Mother she would call her
back. Mother agreed. However, Mother did not answer a call the
DI made that day, the next day, or the day after that.
Two weeks after the initial interview, the DI was able to
speak with Mother, who stated she had ignored the DI’s previous
calls because she was “going through some things.” The next day,
the DI conducted a video assessment of the appropriateness of
Mother’s three-bedroom home for Anthony to visit. Mother
informed the DI that, should Anthony visit, he would share a
room with Mother’s child Victor.

16
In mid-December 2024, DCFS received records from the
Washington Department of Children, Youth, and Families
(DCYF) which recounted a March 2021 referral where Mother
reportedly told the referring party “that she feels afraid for her
two younger children, Victor and [A.W.]. [H]er oldest son,
Anthony has been choking Victor, body slamming him on the
couch, bending his fingers back trying to break them, and is also
assaulting to [A.W.] [sic]. Victor gets the worst of it. Mom said
the assaults are so violent that she refuses to leave Anthony
home alone with his siblings. Mom said when she has to leave
the home to get groceries, etc., she makes Anthony go with her
because she is afraid he will hurt his siblings if left home alone
with them. . . . Mom is concerned that she cannot keep her two
younger children safe. Mom was so concerned for the safety of
the two younger children that she set up a video camera that
shows Anthony assaulting Victor when mom stepped out of the
room. When mom confronts Anthony[,] he denies he assaults his
siblings. Mom has video of her stepping out of the room and
when mom was not in the room Anthony choked Victor and body
slammed him. Mom was especially concerned about the choking
because it went on for some time. . . . Mom does not want
Anthony removed from the home but needs help in keeping her
children safe. . . . [The referring party] said that mom seems to
be trying but does not feel capable of protecting her children for
an eventual incident where one or more of them will be hurt or
injured.”
When DCYF investigated, Mother denied Anthony had
choked Victor but admitted he would “drag Victor across the floor
and . . . lay on top of him and put his arm on his chest.” Mother
reported “Anthony has anger issues and will throw tantrums and

17
she is needing some service to help deal his issues.” Anthony
reported being angry Mother “gave him up but kept Victor and
[A.W.]”; Anthony felt Victor “took his place.” He denied hurting
Victor but admitted to “pick[ing] him up and toss[ing] him on the
bed” and “push[ing] him and grab[bing] him.” Anthony said he
was “just really mad at” Victor. Victor denied Anthony choked
him or bent his fingers back; he said Anthony would slam him
onto the bed “like wrestling.” DCYF closed the case without
identifying any safety threats.
When the DI informed Mother that overnight visits with
Anthony would be inappropriate in part due to “Anthony’s prior
aggressive behaviors towards siblings and mother’s minimization
of it when asked,” Mother became angry that DCFS had
requested and obtained these records, saying that doing so
“violated her civil rights” as a victim of domestic violence.
Mother refused to listen to any further explanation or suggestion
from the DI.

(c) Maternal Grandmother
In a November 2024 conversation with the DI, Anthony’s
maternal grandmother claimed he visited her about two times a
week. Anthony would tell her he was “stressed out” and would
ask for money because he was hungry. She reported giving
Anthony $20 to $25 per week because PGM did not send Anthony
to school with money. She confirmed having to “sew the holes in
Anthony’s pants, underwear, and sweaters” and stated she had
seen him wearing wrinkled and stained clothes. She believed
PGM’s family treated Anthony differently because they did not
believe Father was Anthony’s biological father.
The maternal grandmother denied any concerns with
Mother’s sobriety, stating that, although she lived in a different

18
state, she could “tell” when Mother was not sober, because
Mother “does not remain in contact with her.” When asked for
the last time Mother “did not contact her for a while, MGM stated
that it was perhaps a few months ago but could not recall the
exact time.”

(d) PGM
PGM told the DI she had no problem with Anthony visiting
Mother, as long as the flights were planned for school breaks.
She stated she never prohibited Anthony from speaking with
Mother, and if Anthony wanted to live with Mother, PGM would
support him because he was “old enough to care for himself.” In a
later conversation, she qualified her support with the condition
that Mother was “capable of raising Anthony.” As for Anthony’s
medical needs, PGM stated that his immunizations were current,
and that she treated his colds and coughs with over-the-counter
medication. If further medical attention became necessary, she
would take him to a doctor, but such a situation had yet to arise.
She also contradicted Anthony’s statement about not taking him
to the doctor after he was hit by a car.12 PGM explained Anthony
did not tell her about the accident until the day after, when she
noticed he was in pain. While Anthony insisted he did not need a
doctor, PGM took him when he “could not take the pain.” PGM
reported Anthony sustained no major bodily injuries but was sore
for some time; the doctor advised he take Tylenol for the pain.
As for school transportation, PGM stated Anthony often
voluntarily chose to walk home or to go hang out with his

12 As to Mother’s statement that the maternal aunt took

Anthony, PGM stated the aunt offered, but PGM took Anthony
herself.

19
girlfriend after school. Anthony had not done well academically
in school the previous year, leading PGM to request an
assessment for an Individualized Education Program, which
found him eligible for services. He would be transferred to a new
high school “next semester to make up the missed credits faster
and be able to graduate high school next year.”
PGM confirmed she did not cook on Fridays but stated
there were always leftovers or simple meals Anthony could make
on his own. She explained Anthony wanted to be “babied,” but he
was old enough to do things independently and be self-sufficient.
PGM insisted she did give Anthony an allowance but no longer
gave him the entire amount at once because she was concerned
he would use it to buy refills for his vape pen—PGM did not know
if Anthony smoked marijuana or nicotine with the vape pen.
However, PGM also stated she confiscated the vape pen a year
prior and, since then, had no concerns Anthony was abusing any
substances. PGM opined Anthony got depressed over his
relationship with his girlfriend and because he missed his
siblings that lived with Mother.
PGM reported she bought Anthony “a new wardrobe every
birthday and start of the school year.” She also claimed she
bought him socks, undershirts, and undergarments periodically
or whenever he told her he needed some. She denied knowing he
was taking clothes to the maternal grandmother to be mended
and claimed Anthony chose to wear only a few things in his
closet, speculating this repeated wear may have caused some of
his clothes to tear.
Based on these interviews, DCFS again recommended the
court deny Mother’s petition, opining that Mother and Anthony
lacked sufficient time together as the “parent-child bond is

20
limited to only telephone/virtual calls,” that Mother lacked the
ability to financially provide for Anthony, that Mother minimized
the challenges she faced previously when Anthony came to live
with her, and that Mother did not want and would not benefit
from further reunification services.
In January 2025, the court denied Mother’s petition
without an evidentiary hearing, again “finding that there is not a
change in circumstance and finding that if there were, it is not in
the best interest of this child, at this time, to grant the mother’s
388.” Mother timely appealed.

DISCUSSION
“Section 388 allows a parent to petition to change, modify,
or set aside any previous juvenile court order. (§ 388, subd. (a).)
‘The petitioner has the burden of showing by a preponderance of
the evidence (1) that there is new evidence or a change of
circumstances and (2) that the proposed modification would be in
the best interests of the child.’ ” (In re J.M. (2020) 50
Cal.App.5th 833, 845.) “We review a juvenile court’s denial of a
section 388 petition for abuse of discretion, and review its factual
findings for substantial evidence.” (Id. at p. 846.) “A court
exceeds the limits of legal discretion if its determination is
arbitrary, capricious or patently absurd. The appropriate test is
whether the court exceeded the bounds of reason.” (In re L.W.
(2019) 32 Cal.App.5th 840, 851, citing In re Stephanie M. (1994) 7
Cal.4th 295, 318–319.) “ ‘ “When two or more inferences can
reasonably be deduced from the facts, the reviewing court has no
authority to substitute its decision for that of the trial court.” ’ ”
(Stephanie M., at p. 319.)

21
A. The Court Did Not Err in Denying the Petition
Because the Requested Relief Was Moot
Mother’s petition asserted that PGM “has reportedly been
refusing to allow any visitation or contact between mother and
the minor” and that Mother “has information and concerns
received from relatives that the legal guardian is neglecting the
child’s medical needs and that the child no longer wishes to
reside there.” Mother asked the court to “[r]einstate jurisdiction
to enforce mother’s visitation, and to explore potential
termination of the guardianship if it is determined that the legal
guardian is neglecting the child’s needs and if the child no longer
wishes to reside there.”

1. Right to Visitation
Mother’s right to visitation did not need to be enforced. As
Mother lived in Washington, any visits would need to be planned
so as not to affect Anthony’s attendance at school. PGM did not
object to Anthony visiting Mother over a school break. Nor did
she prevent Anthony from speaking with Mother whenever he
wanted; Anthony estimated he spoke to Mother on a weekly
basis. Mother cites nothing in the record demonstrating her right
to visitation had been impeded by anything other than her
decision to move to a different state.

2. Termination of Guardianship
Mother also asked the court to reinstate jurisdiction to
“explore potential termination” of the legal guardianship if PGM
was neglecting Anthony’s medical needs and if Anthony no longer

22
wanted to live with PGM.13 It is undisputed Anthony wanted to
live with Mother instead of PGM. But the record supports the
court’s implied finding that PGM was not neglecting Anthony’s
medical needs, and thus there was no need to explore potential
termination of the legal guardianship.
The only examples Mother provides of medical neglect
were: (1) PGM did not take Anthony to the doctor when he had a
cough or cold; (2) Anthony was found to be under-vaccinated in
2020; and (3) PGM did not take Anthony to the doctor after he
was hit by a car, two years before Mother filed her second section
388 petition.
It was undisputed PGM gave Anthony over-the-counter
medicine for his coughs and colds and stated she would take him
to a doctor if he ever needed further medical attention.
Additionally, Mother presented no evidence that, at the time she
filed her petition in 2024, Anthony was missing any required
vaccinations.14 Finally, as to whether PGM took Anthony to the
doctor after he was hit by a car in 2022, the court was presented
with three versions of events. Anthony claimed PGM neither
asked him how he felt nor took him to the hospital after the

13 As the petition had claimed PGM was neglecting

Anthony’s medical needs, we read Mother’s request as one to
reinstate jurisdiction to explore potential termination of the
guardianship if PGM was neglecting Anthony’s medical needs.
14 Moreover, California requires students to have several

vaccinations to attend school, and all parties agree Anthony was
attending school. (See
<https://www.cdph.ca.gov/Programs/CID/DCDC/Pages/Immuniza
tion/School/tk-12-immunizations.aspx> [as of October 1, 2025],
archived at <https://perma.cc/W5VP-KP2V> [listing student
immunizations requirements].)

23
accident. However, Anthony also admitted he did not tell PGM
he needed medical attention. PGM, on the other hand, asserted
she did take him to the doctor the day after the accident, when
she noted he appeared to be in pain. Mother claimed PGM
refused to take Anthony to the doctor, but that the maternal aunt
did.
Regardless of the truth of an incident that happened over
two years before it was brought to the attention of the court, the
court was entitled to discredit Mother’s version of events—given
that she had no personal knowledge of what occurred—and
conclude that either PGM did not take Anthony to the doctor
because he did not tell her he needed to go, or that she did take
him. Under either version of events, the court reasonably
concluded PGM was not neglecting Anthony’s medical needs.
Therefore, because Mother only asked the court to ‘explore’
terminating the guardianship if Anthony no longer wanted to live
with PGM and PGM was neglecting Anthony’s medical needs,
Mother’s request was never triggered.

B. The Court Did Not Err in Finding Mother’s
Request Was Not in Anthony’s Best Interest
“[W]hen a child has been placed in foster care because of
parental neglect or incapacity, after an extended period of foster
care, it is within the court’s discretion to decide that a child’s
interest in stability has come to outweigh the natural parent’s
interest in the care, custody and companionship of the child.” (In
re Jasmon O. (1994) 8 Cal.4th 398, 419.)
Although Anthony had lived with PGM for over a decade,
Mother argues it was now in Anthony’s best interest to live with
her because he wanted to live with her. But Anthony wanted to
live with Mother because he wanted his own space and was

24
“pretty sure” that if he lived with her, he would “have his own
space compared to sharing a bedroom with” his 17-year-old
paternal uncle. This did not appear to be the case. Mother lived
in a three-bedroom home and stated that, were Anthony to visit,
he would need to share a bedroom with Victor, Mother’s younger
son, with whom Anthony already had serious physical conflicts
the last time he stayed with Mother. While Anthony professed
his belief that Mother could pay him more attention than PGM—
Anthony admitted he wanted someone to “take care” of him,
while PGM insisted he needed to learn how to do things on his
own—Mother was already raising two younger kids, and
Anthony’s last visit to Mother’s home had required DCYF
involvement.
It was also unclear that Mother was in a position to
adequately care for Anthony. While Mother claimed to have been
sober since 2020, in November 2024, the maternal grandmother
claimed Mother would not stay in contact with her when Mother
was not sober, and that such a period of no-contact occurred
“perhaps a few months ago”—implying Mother was using drugs
perhaps a few months ago. Additionally, although Mother had
been involved in domestic violence with A.W.’s father resulting in
a five-year-restraining order protecting both Mother and A.W.,
she nevertheless called him and asked him to see her during the
pendency of that restraining order because she was not feeling
well.15 Further, in interviews with the DI regarding both of her
section 388 petitions, Mother demonstrated that she was quick to

15 Mother stated she had obtained a five-year restraining

order that expires in February 2027, meaning the order was
issued in February 2022. The call Mother made to A.W.’s father
occurred in June 2022.

25
anger and easily agitated—a temperament that would make it
difficult to care for a teenager also experiencing a wide range of
negative emotions.
On this record, we hold the juvenile court reasonably
concluded it would not be in Anthony’s best interest to reinstate
jurisdiction to “explore” terminating the legal guardianship.

DISPOSITION
The court’s orders are affirmed.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED

M. KIM, J.

We concur:

ROTHSCHILD, P. J.

BENDIX, J.

26

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.