CourtListener 10675583•In re E.B. CA5
Testo completo
Filed 9/22/25 In re E.B. CA5
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FIFTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
In re E.B. et al., Persons Coming Under the
Juvenile Court Law.
KINGS COUNTY HUMAN SERVICES F089170, F089337
AGENCY,
(Super. Ct. Nos. 22JD0029,
Plaintiff and Respondent, 22JD0030)
v.
OPINION
J.B. et al.,
Defendants and Appellants.
THE COURT*
APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of Kings County. Richard J.
Guiliani, Judge.
Roshni Mehta, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for Defendant and
Appellant J.B.
Laura D. Pedicini, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for Defendant and
Appellant B.L.
Laurie Avedisian-Favini, County Counsel, Thomas Y. Lin and Ana Dominguez,
Deputy County Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
* Before Franson, Acting P. J., Peña, J. and Snauffer, J.
-ooOoo-
J.B. (mother) and B.L. (father) appeal from the January 9, 2025, orders
terminating their parental rights to now eight-year-old twins, O.B. and E.B. (together the
children) pursuant to Welfare and Institutions Code section 366.26.1 Mother alleges that
the juvenile court erred when it found the beneficial parent-child relationship exception to
termination of parental rights was inapplicable. Both mother and father contend the
Kings County Human Services Agency (agency) did not comply with its inquiry duties
under the Indian Child Welfare Act (ICWA) (25 U.S.C. § 1901 et seq.). The agency
concedes it did not fully comply with aspects of its inquiry duties and therefore agrees
that a limited remand is appropriate.
We find no merit to mother’s claim of error on the part of the juvenile court in
finding the beneficial parent-child relationship exception inapplicable, but we accept the
agency’s concession as to its duties of ICWA inquiry. We conditionally reverse the order
terminating parental rights, and remand for the limited purpose of compliance with
ICWA and its related statutory provisions. In all other respects, we affirm.
STATEMENT OF THE CASE AND FACTS
Background
In December of 2021, the agency conducted an investigation after it was alleged
mother was overconsuming alcohol while the children were in her care. The agency
implemented a 30-day safety plan with mother and, eventually, mother was able to
establish therapeutic services to address her alcohol use and the referral was closed.
On March 20, 2022, the agency received a referral that one of the children called
maternal grandmother to say an unknown male had dropped alcohol off at the house and
mother was drinking. Law enforcement arrived, determined mother to be under the
1 All further statutory references are to the Welfare and Institutions Code unless
otherwise stated.
2.
influence, and took the children to their maternal grandparents’2 home. Mother was later
placed on a psychiatric hold after she voiced suicidal thoughts. Maternal grandmother
reported that she thought mother had been drinking to the point of “blacking out” for
about a year. She also stated that she and maternal grandfather were the primary
caregivers for the children as mother worked long hours as a dispatcher.
When mother spoke to the social worker, she stated that she had been sober since
December of 2021, but had just begun drinking again due to the toxic environment with
her boyfriend. She stated that, while she had been drinking when law enforcement came
to her home, she was not intoxicated. Mother also refuted claims of doing harm to
herself and that she was never placed on a psychiatric hold but released.
Detention
On March 22, 2022, the agency filed a section 300 petition alleging the children
were at risk of harm due to mother’s inability to provide care for them due to her alleged
alcohol addiction. No allegations were filed against father, who was living separately in
Los Angeles at the time.
When the agency spoke to father, he stated he had weekly FaceTime calls with the
children. Father stated he was leaving for Tennessee at the end of the month and hoped
the children could be returned to mother.
The detention report filed March 22, 2022, stated that both mother and father
denied Native American Ancestry.
The children were detained at the March 23, 2022, detention hearing. At that time,
both mother and father were present and asked if they had any Indian ancestry. Both
replied that they did not, and the juvenile court found that the ICWA did not apply. Both
completed ICWA-020 (parental notice of Indian status) forms stating each was without
2 Maternal grandmother and step-maternal grandfather are designated as the
maternal grandparents. Maternal grandmother and maternal biological grandfather are
divorced. Maternal grandfather is designated as the biological maternal grandfather.
3.
Indian ancestry. Maternal grandparents were present at the detention hearing, but they
were not asked about Indian ancestry. A jurisdiction and disposition hearing was set for
April 14, 2022.
On April 11, 2022, the agency filed a first amended section 300 petition, which
eliminated certain specific details about the incident in December 2021 involving mother,
but again did not include any allegations against father.
Jurisdiction and Disposition
The report filed by the agency in anticipation of jurisdiction and disposition
recommended family reunification services for both mother and father. Mother reported
that she began drinking heavily due to issues with her then boyfriend, and hit “rock
bottom” in December of 2021. She alleged that she stayed sober until March of 2022, but
then relapsed when she broke up with her boyfriend. As a result, she also lost her job.
Mother had been attending therapy sessions since January of 2022. She did not like the
religious principles of Alcoholics Anonymous (AA), but said she would attend another
type of support group.
The agency report discussed father’s relationship with paternal grandmother, with
whom he was temporarily living. Father described his relationship with paternal
grandmother as a good relationship.
The children, both diagnosed with autism and described as thriving off of
structure, were placed with maternal grandparents. An initial supervised visit between
mother and the children went well.
The agency report stated it would be premature to release the children to the care
of father, as the children had had minimal contact with him and he was now out of state
in Tennessee. The agency was unable to begin the process of completing an interstate
compact on the placement of children (ICPC) until father provided information.
On April 14, 2022, both mother and father submitted on the agency’s report as to
jurisdiction and disposition. The juvenile court found the allegations of the first amended
4.
petition true and the children were adjudged dependents of the court. Both mother and
father were offered reunification services. A six-month review hearing was set for
October 6, 2022.
Six-Month Review Report and Hearing
The report prepared for the six-month review hearing stated that mother had been
assisted with housing, but she was terminated for not being in compliance with the
program. Thereafter, mother moved to San Bernardino County and got employment at an
indoor playground and family activity center. Mother claimed to have attended 20
psychotherapy sessions and enrolled in alcohol and other drug services (AOD) where she
attended groups twice a week. She tested negative for all substances on two occasions
and positive for marijuana on three occasions, but she denied using marijuana. Mother
reported that she had consumed alcohol twice at work events because she felt pressured
to do so. She had not participated in AA/NA meetings due to philosophical differences,
but had a support person in recovery. Mother failed to provide the name or contact for
her support person when requested by the agency.
Weekly visits with the children went well, and in September of 2022, mother was
allowed an overnight visit with the children at maternal grandparents’ home. However,
the maternal grandmother reported that mother slept during the visit and did not engage
with the children.
Father moved back to California from Tennessee during the review period, but had
not had contact with the agency and his whereabouts were unknown.
At the six-month review hearing October 6, 2022, the juvenile court ordered
reunification services for mother and father continued, finding mother had made
moderate progress and father minimal progress toward alleviating or mitigating the
causes necessitating the placement of the children in out of home care. Maternal
grandparents were both present at the hearing. A 12-month review hearing was scheduled
for March 30, 2023.
5.
12-Month Review Report and Hearing
The agency filed a 12-month review report and several addendum reports. In
November of 2022, mother was allowed an unsupervised visit at her home in Yucaipa
with the children. But when the children were dropped off at mother’s home, there was
an unidentified male at the home as well, even though mother had said he would not be
there. Mother told the social worker she “did not know what to do” when the male came
over, but she was not going to be seeing him anymore.
In December of 2022, mother tested positive for alcohol. In January of 2023,
mother enrolled in behavioral health services and had attended eight of 11 treatment
groups. In February of 2023, mother tested negative for alcohol but tested positive for
THC. Mother claimed not to know why she tested positive and thought her urine test had
been switched with someone else’s. Mother was attending virtual AA meetings and had
a temporary sponsor.
Father moved to San Jose in December of 2022, but was unable to have the
children with him as he had roommates. He admitted to not having spoken to the
children since October of 2022, but blamed it on their caregivers.
At an agency meeting on January 23, 2023, mother expressed frustration with
maternal grandparents, stating they were keeping the children from her. Mother
described her relationship with maternal grandparents as toxic, and their relationship,
along with her attempt to “stay clean,” were reasons she moved out of Kings County.
Mother admitted drinking “here and there,” and she last drank two weeks prior. Paternal
grandparents were present at the agency meeting, and it also appears that the biological
maternal grandfather was present as well.3
3 The record reflects that a “Mr. B. (paternal grandfather)” was present. However,
as that is mother’s last name it can be inferred this is her biological father, or the
biological maternal grandfather. The maternal stepgrandfather’s name is S.L.
6.
Mother and father had a supervised visit with the children in February 2023, which
had gone well, although the children were heard referring to father by his first name after
he asked them if they remembered him.
The agency recommended that reunification services be terminated and a section
366.26 hearing set.
At the 12-month review hearing held April 19, 2023, the juvenile court granted the
maternal grandparents’ request for de facto parent status and followed the
recommendations of the agency and terminated reunification services for both mother
and father, finding both had made only moderate progress in the services provided. At
the conclusion of the hearing, county counsel inquired, “[w]hile we have the mother, the
father, and the maternal grandparents present … It’s my understanding that [the] children
do not have any Native American ancestry and that it is also true for their extended
family. Is that the case?” In response, everyone shook their heads no.
A section 366.26 hearing was scheduled for August 9, 2023.
Section 366.26 Report
The section 366.26 hearing agency report described visits between mother and the
children as going well. The report reflects that on May 25, 2023, maternal grandmother
denied having any Native American ancestry in her family. The report also stated that
the children visited with the biological maternal grandfather and the paternal grandfather
via video chat.
The agency recommended termination of parental rights, stating it would not be
detrimental to the children as they had been cared for by the caregivers “for most of their
life on and off.” The report noted mother’s visits with the children had gone well, but
that they had not been able to advance to unsupervised visits as mother had violated the
safety plan by having an unidentified male in the home. Father last visited the children in
April of 2023, and had not kept contact with the agency.
7.
Section 388 Petition
On August 7, 2023, mother filed a section 388 petition asking that she receive
either family maintenance or additional reunification services because she completed out-
patient substance abuse treatment, was attending AA/NA meetings two to three times a
week, had a sponsor, was employed, and maintained visitation with the children.
In its response, the agency noted mother had completed substance abuse services
in July of 2023, but had not drug tested since. It recommended a continuance for a
hearing on the section 388 petition so that the agency could check into mother’s “current
circumstances” and mother could participate in additional drug testing. Subsequently, in
September of 2023, the agency filed a continued response and this time recommended
that mother be granted additional reunification services. Mother had now moved back to
Kings County and planned to move closer to the children. August 2023 drug tests on
mother were negative. Overnight visits with the children at maternal grandparents’ home
had gone well.
On September 21, 2023, the juvenile court held a section 388 hearing. Mother
withdrew her contest to the section 388 petition and instead submitted on the
recommendation of the agency for services. The juvenile court granted the section 388
petition and ordered mother an additional six months of services, requiring her to attend
agency meetings, complete a mental health assessment, participate in codependency
courses, maintain stable housing, demonstrate independent living skills, participate in the
children’s medical and school appointments, complete an outpatient program, and submit
to random drug testing. The 18-month review hearing was scheduled for March 14,
2024.
18-Month Review Report and Hearing
In its status review report and addendum reports for the 18-month review hearing,
the agency recommended termination of reunification services. Mother lived in an
apartment in Lemoore and worked full time. During the review period, mother attended
8.
an outpatient program and completed a mental health assessment but missed three out of
four therapy appointments and one of four case management appointments. Mother was
also enrolled in a co-occurring treatment program at Kings View and was attending
groups, but acknowledged that she relapses to alcohol to the point of blacking out when
she is alone. She blamed it on missing her children. Mother took part in AA/NA
meetings between September and November of 2023, but indicated that they were
reminders of generational trauma she had experienced. Mother tested positive for alcohol
on December 7, 2023; she was “visibly intoxicated” when transported to the testing
center. While mother attended parent-teacher conferences for the children, she did not
attend their medical or dental visits, although she was informed of them. Mother
attended the majority of weekly visits with the children and interacted appropriately.
However, the social worker felt mother’s behavior at a November 9, 2023, visit was
“irregular”, but could not determine why.
At the contested review hearing March 21, 2024, mother and father withdrew their
request to contest the agency’s recommendation to terminate services and submitted on
the reports. The juvenile court terminated reunification services and mother was advised
of her right to file a writ petition.
The section 366.26 hearing was scheduled for July 11, 2024.
Section 366.26 Report
The agency filed a section 366.26 report June 28, 2024, recommending
termination of parental rights. The children did not have any major academic or health
issues and were comfortable in maternal grandparents’ home. The maternal grandparents
were committed to adopting the children. Mother continued to visit the children, and she
interacted with them appropriately. Both children stated that they wanted to visit mother
but wished to stay in maternal grandparents’ home. It was mentioned in the report that a
social worker supervised a visit in March of 2024 in which father FaceTimed with the
paternal grandmother.
9.
Section 388 Petitions
On July 3, 2024, mother filed a second section 388 petition requesting either
family maintenance services or additional family reunification services. Attached to the
petition were various documents: mother’s declaration that she was attending an
outpatient program and that her sober date was January 15, 2024; she was prescribed
medication to aid in her recovery and she was seeing a therapist to address trauma that
contributed to her use of alcohol; she completed two eight-hour parenting classes; and
she attached a letter from a marriage and family therapist whose opinion was that mother
could provide a safe and nurturing environment for the children.
On July 5, 2024, father filed a section 388 petition requesting that the children be
placed in his care with family maintenance services or that he receive additional
reunification services.
The agency’s response to both section 388 petitions requested that the juvenile
court deny them. The agency’s response to mother’s petition noted that mother voiced
her concern that the agency’s involvement was out of proportion to her issues and that
she blamed her drinking on an abusive relationship with an ex-boyfriend and later on
missing her children. The agency noted mother’s difficulty in stabilizing housing; and
while she was actively engaged in an outpatient program at Kings View, she refused to
sign a release. While the agency acknowledged that mother was engaging in services and
able to articulate her path to recovery, it did not recommend affording mother additional
services because of her inability to sustain sobriety over time.
Caregiver Information Form
Maternal grandparents filed a caregiver information form on August 16, 2024,
indicating that the children had relationships with their maternal and paternal
grandparents, aunts, uncles, and cousins.
10.
Contested Section 366.26 and Section 388 Hearing
After several continuances, the contested hearings were held November 20 and 21,
2024.
Testimony of Brenna Kantner
Brenna Kantner, a licensed marriage and family therapist, was found to be an
expert “for the purposes of safety assessment.” Katner testified that she met with mother
“a handful of times” and opined mother had the ability to provide a safe environment for
the children. Kantner did not meet with the children, maternal grandparents, or agency
social worker. Kantner referred mother to therapy so that mother could address her
trauma issues and gain a support system.
Testimony of Marc Koch
As a result of the Kantner’s referral to therapy, mother received services from
Marc Koch, a licensed family and marriage therapist. He had been working with mother
since May of 2024.
Koch testified he met weekly with mother and assisted mother through cognitive
behavioral therapy in dealing with her court case and how it was affecting her. Koch felt
that mother was fully engaged during sessions and had gotten better at processing
stressors, which would help her in parenting. On cross-examination, Koch acknowledged
that his sessions with mother dealt more with her mental health and did not necessarily
address any issues with her alcoholism. Koch’s opinion that mother be given full custody
of the children was based on what mother told him during their sessions. Koch had no
interaction with the children.
Testimony of Kari Herbert
Kari Herbert, designated as an “expert in certified alcohol and drug counseling,”
conducted a “level of care placement” assessment for mother. Herbert met with mother
on one occasion on October 24, 2024, for an hour. At the time, mother reported she had
been sober for nine months. Herbert testified that mother was engaged in cognitive
11.
behavioral therapy to address her alcohol abuse, she was taking medication for anxiety
and depression, and was taking Naltrexone. Herbert opined that these factors, along with
a supportive family, assisted mother in maintaining her sobriety.
Mother’s Testimony
Mother testified that the children were born in October 2016, mother and father
separated in October 2017 and divorced in August 2018. The children were born
prematurely at 26 weeks and remained in the hospital for three months. Mother visited
them every day and took them to see many specialists. The children then lived with
mother until they were removed in March of 2022. Mother testified that she sought out
services for the children, who were diagnosed with autism, she was involved in their
school, and she was able to procure an Individualized Education Plan (IEP) for them.
Mother testified that, during the dependency proceedings, she visited regularly, brought
toys and games to the visits, brought snacks, and the children interacted with her. She
had been able to have unsupervised visits for a few months at the end of 2022.
Mother currently lived in a two-bedroom apartment in Lemoore and had beds and
a dresser for the children. She was employed and able to create her own schedule. She
was working on her college degree online and anticipated obtaining her bachelor’s degree
before the end of October 2025. Mother married A.A. in May of 2024, and he was an
emotional and financial support for her, as was his extended family.
Mother testified that she met with Dr. Mark Lasher, an addiction specialist, who
prescribed mother Naltrexone in January of 2024. She continued to take the medication,
which made mother nauseous at the smell of alcohol.
Mother’s outpatient program included co-occurring classes once a week, which
she began in January of 2024. The classes were intended to prevent relapse.
Mother testified on cross-examination that she thought her current section 388
petition was different from the first petition as she was now on Naltrexone, she was
working with a therapist, and she was engaged in an outpatient program focused on
12.
relapse prevention. She testified that, although she had been through two previous
alcohol abuse programs, the current one was of longer duration, and she last tested
positive for alcohol in January of 2024.
Mother acknowledged that, after her divorce, the children lived with her at
maternal grandparents’ for about one year. Mother described her relationship with
maternal grandparents as rocky, but she was learning to deal with her emotions through
her therapy sessions.
Mother acknowledged that, one to two weeks prior to her testimony, she sent an
angry text to maternal grandmother that included foul language. Mother had tried to
reach out and reconcile with maternal grandmother, but she was not willing to
reciprocate.
On redirect, mother testified that at the last visit, the children said they wanted to
live with her. Mother felt that, if her parental rights were terminated, the children would
suffer detriment. Mother believed maternal grandmother was coaching the children
against her.
Testimony of Maternal Grandmother
Maternal grandmother testified for the agency that the children had lived with her
off and on since they were 11 months old. Following mother’s divorce, mother and the
children lived with maternal grandparents. After mother moved out, she got an apartment
down the street from maternal grandparents, and they provided childcare when mother
worked.
Maternal grandmother first noticed mother inebriated in 2019, and it progressed
from there. In October of 2023, maternal grandmother went to mother’s apartment to
check on her and found her on the floor lying in her own vomit and urine.
At the beginning of November 2024, mother sent a text to maternal grandmother
asking what she was going to testify to in court. The text also included mother’s
statement that she wished relatives who had passed would haunt maternal grandmother
13.
and that mother would be better off with maternal grandmother dead. Maternal
grandmother felt threatened by the texts and informed the social worker.
Maternal grandmother, who supervised visits between mother and the children,
testified that there were no behavioral issues with the children at the end of visits. They
would say goodbye to mother and give her hugs. The children were aware of what
alcohol was, and they discussed scary times they had had with alcohol present. Maternal
grandmother was listed as the primary contact with the school for the children, but
mother interfered in August of 2024 and removed maternal grandmother from that role.
Testimony of Cristal Amigon
The agency’s social services supervisor, Cristal Amigon, testified that she was the
social service practitioner for the children in the adoption unit. She worked with mother
and the family from April to August of 2024, and felt that the visitation between mother
and the children went well. During the visits that Amigon supervised between the
children and father, the children asked that the maternal grandparents stay.
In July of 2024, maternal grandmother reached out to Amigon because mother had
sent her ex-boyfriend a text message which resulted in a police report being generated,
although no charges filed. Mother had also sent an inappropriate text message to
maternal grandmother.
Amigon was concerned that it had taken three years to develop a permanent plan
for the children. Adoption was the preferred plan because it offered the children stability.
Amigon testified that, when the children were with the maternal grandparents, they were
engaged and positive. The children were familiar with alcohol, were able to identify
mother’s use of it, and stated they were scared. Amigon viewed a video taken during one
video visit in which mother asked the children if they wished to return to her home, and
what they should tell the agency. Amigon acknowledged that she had not supervised a
visit between mother and the children.
14.
Mother’s Rebuttal Testimony
Mother disagreed that maternal grandmother had been the children’s primary
caregiver since they were 11 months old, only that mother and the children lived with
maternal grandmother for a year after mother’s divorce. Mother testified that maternal
grandmother had provided childcare while she was at her employment as a dispatcher,
which involved 12-hour shifts.
On cross-examination, mother was asked why the experts she called to testify all
stated mother’s heavy drinking began at the beginning of her dependency case in March
of 2022, when mother testified her heavy drinking began in July of 2021. Mother
testified that she first started drinking heavily in July of 2021 because of an emotionally
abusive relationship. In November of 2021, she was given a 30-day safety plan by the
agency, which closed in January of 2022. According to mother, she was “cleared,” and
the March 2022 incident was a “brand new infraction.” Mother admitted having issues
with alcohol in March of 2022, when the children were removed from her care, and she
told the experts that was when she accepted the addiction even though her actual drinking
began in July of 2021.
Argument by Counsel
Counsel who represented both mother and father argued, as to the section 388
petitions, that mother and father had ameliorated the concerns that brought the children to
the attention of the department and they could provide a stable home for the children.
Counsel argued that mother had shown substantial change by being sober since January
of 2024, attending therapy sessions, and having taken parenting classes. Counsel also
argued it would be in the best interest of the children to return to her care as there was a
strong bond between mother and the children.
As to the section 366.26 hearing, counsel argued that the parent-child relationship
exception applied as both parents had maintained regular visitation, the children both had
15.
a substantial emotional attachment to the parents and would benefit from that continued
relationship; and severing that relationship would be “hugely detrimental” to them.
County counsel questioned the opinions of the experts who testified, noting they
had “limited knowledge about the case and what was going on,” because they relied on
mother for information. As to the section 388 petitions, counsel argued they showed
changing but not changed circumstances. Counsel also argued granting the petitions was
not in the best interests of the children. Counsel argued there was no evidence to support
the beneficial parent-child relationship exception, and father even failed to meet the
regular visitation requirement.
Counsel for the children joined in county counsel’s argument. While mother had
made some changes, and there was some bond between the children and mother, counsel
argued it was not in the children’s best interest to go back to mother’s care. Counsel
asked that mother and father’s parental rights be terminated.
Juvenile Court’s Ruling
The juvenile court rendered a decision on January 9, 2025, in which it addressed
both mother and father’s section 388 petitions and the section 366.26 request by the
agency to terminate mother and father’s parental rights. Because the parties stipulated
that the evidence received at the hearing related to both the section 388 petitions and the
section 366.26 hearing, we include the juvenile court’s analysis as to both, even though it
is only the section 366.26 analysis that is at issue.
In its ruling, the juvenile court first summarized the history of the case and then
addressed father’s section 388 petition. The juvenile court noted that, while father was
the non-offending and non-custodial parent of the children, he had had fewer than 20
contacts with the children since their births and did not really have a relationship with the
children. The juvenile court found no “change in circumstance” as required under section
388 related to father’s relationship with the children.
16.
As for mother’s section 388 petition, the juvenile court noted mother was actively
engaged in an outpatient program to address her alcohol issues, was seeing an addiction
specialist, has tested negative, has been seeing a private therapist, has been taking needed
medication, had developed a strong support network, attended parenting classes, and
participated in supervised visits with the children. The juvenile court noted Kantner’s
report on mother, which highlighted her strong support network, her commitment to
sobriety, her access to professional support, a positive parenting approach, employment
stability, a prepared living environment, and resilience and determination. But the court
noted Kantner’s report also included risk factors of ongoing legal issues, mental health
issues, and past trauma. The juvenile court voiced concern that Kantner’s opinion was
based on several court reports, but also self-reported information from mother, her
husband, and mother’s therapist Koch. Kantner did not meet or observe interaction with
the children, grandparents, social workers, or CPS. While Kantner tried to meet with
maternal grandparents or the agency, and offered to do so, “mother and her attorney did
not take her up on her offer.”
The juvenile court also noted mother’s refusal to sign a release so the agency
could confirm with her outpatient program regarding her treatment and testing. The
juvenile court was particularly concerned that there were no drug test results between
June 12 and September 3, 2024, “a period of 83 days.” The test results had been
provided by mother and the agency was unable to confirm that mother attended all
scheduled tests. The juvenile court also noted concerns with mother’s mental health and
treatment, which it could not verify, especially since mother had an “extensive history of
being untruthful” to the agency and the court. Because none of the experts — Kantner,
Koch, or Herbert — spoke to mother’s outpatient treatment facility to confirm that
mother’s statements were true, the juvenile court found the evidence provided was
“insufficient to determine whether the mother has changed circumstances or simply
changing circumstances.”
17.
The juvenile court stated that, even if it were to find that mother and father’s
circumstances had changed, it was unable to find that “the parent’s requested orders
would be in the best interests of the children.” The juvenile court noted that the children
had been in maternal grandparents’ care for three years, where they were “thriving,”
promoting the children’s need for permanency and stability. While mother had made
positive strides, she continued to have issues related to her mental health and concerning
behaviors. While the children knew mother as their mother, and enjoyed spending time
with her, the juvenile court questioned whether the children were “especially bonded” to
mother.
The juvenile court found the children were bonded to maternal grandparents from
the beginning of the proceedings. As of the section 366.26 report, the juvenile court
noted that the children were still struggling “with trauma related to mother’s drinking.”
The juvenile court noted mother was working towards sobriety, but that “[s]obriety is
precarious, and relapse is a part of recovery.”
The juvenile court noted mother and father’s unsuccessful attempts at reunification
and stated, “Nearly three years have passed since detention while these children have
waited for permanency and stability.” It then denied both mother and father’s section
388 petitions.
In regards to the section 366.26 hearing, the juvenile court stated it would “adopt
the factual findings from the ruling in the 388 Petition, inasmuch as they are relevant to
the Selection and Implementation Hearing, and … will not repeat them in this ruling, but
… will incorporate them herein by this reference.” The juvenile court then found that the
children were likely to be adopted and addressed the beneficial parent-child relationship
exception to adoption, citing the three-prong test enunciated in In re Caden C. (2021) 11
Cal.5th 614 (Caden C.).
As to the first prong, the juvenile court found mother had regular visitation and
contact with the children. It found father had not met the first prong.
18.
The second prong addressed whether there is a relationship between the children
and parent, the continuation of which would benefit the children, .i.e., whether the
children have “a substantial positive emotional attachment” to the parent. The juvenile
court found that the children enjoyed their time with each parent, they have a bond with
mother and have affection for her, but “it is difficult for the court to find that the children
are substantially, emotionally attached to their mother,” especially since the children have
continued expressed fear regarding returning to mother’s home. The juvenile court
determined that the children had “some attachment, the continuation of which may
benefit the children,” but it was “difficult to tell how substantial or positive [the]
attachment is.” The juvenile court found no such attachment between the children and
father.
As to the third prong, “whether or not the relationship is such that the termination
of parental rights would be detrimental to the child,” the juvenile court stated that it must
“weigh the detriment of severance of parental rights versus benefits of adoption.” The
juvenile court stated it would not address that issue as to father as he had not met his
burden for the first two prongs. As to mother, the juvenile court found that the children
had been in maternal grandparents’ home for almost three years and even longer than that
before dependency; they were emotionally stable; concerns were expressed by the
children’s therapists that their stability may falter if their placement was interrupted; the
children had excelled in school without problems; and the children expressed a desire to
stay with the maternal grandparents. In finding the beneficial parent-child relationship
exception to adoption did not apply, the juvenile court concluded by stating:
“Given the facts before the Court and the clear legislative preference, the
Court believes that these children need to know they have stability,
security, safety and permanence that they will receive[] by being adopted
by the grandparents. [¶] The Court believes that this need outweighs the
harm in severing the relationship with their parents.”
It found the ICWA inapplicable and terminated mother and father’s parental rights.
19.
DISCUSSION
I. DID THE TRIAL COURT ERR WHEN IT FOUND THE BENEFICIAL
PARENT-CHILD RELATIONSHIP EXCEPTION TO ADOPTION
INAPPLICABLE?
Mother argues that the juvenile court erred when it found the beneficial parent-
child relationship exception to adoption did not apply. We disagree.
Applicable Law
At a section 366.26 hearing, the court’s goal is to select and implement a
permanent plan for the children. (Caden C, supra, 11 Cal.5th at p. 630.) If “there has
been a previous determination that reunification services be terminated” and the court
“determine[s] by clear and convincing evidence ... the child is likely to be adopted,” the
court must terminate parental rights unless a statutory exception applies. (Id. at pp. 630-
631.)
One such exception is the section 366.26, subdivision (c)(1)(B)(i) beneficial
parent-child relationship exception, which requires a parent to prove three elements: “(1)
regular visitation and contact, and (2) a relationship, the continuation of which would
benefit the child such that (3) the termination of parental rights would be detrimental to
the child.” (Caden C., supra, 11 Cal.5th at p. 631.) This exception “is limited in scope.”
(Id. at p. 631.) It applies when “ ‘severing the natural parent/child relationship would
deprive the child of a substantial, positive emotional attachment such that,’ even
considering the benefits of a new adoptive home, termination would ‘harm[ ]’ the child.”
(Id. at p. 633.) In other words, “[w]hen the relationship with a parent is so important to
the child that the security and stability of a new home wouldn’t outweigh its loss,
termination would be ‘detrimental to the child due to’ the child’s beneficial relationship
with a parent.” (Id. at pp. 633–634.) Throughout this analysis, “the focus is on the best
interests of the child.” (Id. at p. 632.)
20.
Regular Visitation and Contact
In examining the regular visitation and contact element, “[t]he question is just
whether ‘parents visit consistently,’ taking into account ‘the extent permitted by court
orders.’ ” (Caden C., supra, 11 Cal.5th at p. 632.) We review the court’s determination
as to this element for substantial evidence. (Id. at p. 639.) “In reviewing factual
determinations for substantial evidence, a reviewing court should ‘not reweigh the
evidence, evaluate the credibility of witnesses, or resolve evidentiary conflicts.’ ” (Id. at
p. 640.) Here, the juvenile court found that this first prong had been met by mother.
Neither party contests this prong and we need not discuss it further.
Substantial, Positive Attachment
To satisfy the second element, “the parent must show that the child has a
substantial, positive, emotional attachment to the parent—the kind of attachment
implying that the child would benefit from continuing the relationship.” (Caden C.,
supra, 11 Cal.5th at p. 636.) Factors involved in determining the benefit of the
relationship include “ ‘[t]he age of the child, the portion of the child’s life spent in the
parent’s custody, the “positive” or “negative” effect of interaction between parent and
child, and the child’s particular needs,’ ” as well as “how children feel about, interact
with, look to, or talk about their parents.” (Id. at p. 632.) “A positive attachment
between parent and child ... is nurturing and provides the child with a sense of security
and stability,” and “an emotional attachment is one where the child views the parent as
more than a mere friend or playmate.” (In re B.D. (2021) 66 Cal.App.5th 1218, 1230.)
The required “significant attachment” arises from an “adult’s attention to the child’s
needs for physical care, nourishment, comfort, affection and stimulation.” (In re Autumn
H. (1994) 27 Cal.App.4th 567, 575.)
We review the court’s determination on this element for substantial evidence.
(Caden C., supra, 11 Cal.5th at p. 639.)
21.
Although the record shows that the children had some bond with mother,
substantial evidence supports the juvenile court’s finding that the relationship was not a
substantial, positive and nurturing one that benefitted the children at the time of the
section 366.26 hearing. The children had been with maternal grandparents for almost
three years at the time of the section 366.26 hearing, and had spent significant time with
them prior to the current dependency case. The evidence before the juvenile court was
that, while the children enjoyed visits with mother and were affectionate with her during
visits, it did not appear that the bond was a “substantial, positive, emotional attachment”
that would satisfy this second prong. When the agency conducted an exercise with the
children to determine their perspective on the family’s dynamic, both children identified
maternal grandparents as their parents. One of the children alternated between calling
mother “mommy” and her first name; the other placed mother in the grandmother
position on a family chart. When asked about living with mother, both children said they
wished to visit mother when they were older. Even two years into the dependency case,
both children continued to express worry about events that occurred in mother’s home
and mother’s continued use of alcohol. While “[a] parent’s continued struggles with the
issues leading to dependency are not a categorical bar to applying the exception,” they
may have a negative effect on the children such that they are relevant to determining the
benefit of continuing the relationship. (Caden C., supra, 11 Cal.5th at pp. 637-638.) And
neither child showed any negative effect when separating from mother after visits or
video calls.
Detriment from Termination
To determine whether “termination would be detrimental, the trial court must
decide whether the harm from severing the child’s relationship with the parent outweighs
the benefit to the child of placement in a new adoptive home.” (Caden C., supra,
11Cal.5th at p. 632.) This determination is based on “how the child would be affected by
losing the parental relationship—in effect, what life would be like for the child in an
22.
adoptive home without the parent in the child’s life.” (Id. at p. 633.) “In many cases,
‘the strength and quality of the natural parent/child relationship’ will substantially
determine how detrimental it would be to lose that relationship, which must be weighed
against the benefits of a new adoptive home.” (Id. at p. 634.) Some “relationship[s]
involve[ ] tangled benefits and burdens” which the court must “disentangl[e].” (Ibid.) As
with the second element of the exception, the parent’s struggles leading to dependency
may be relevant to determining whether terminating the relationship would be
detrimental to the child. (Id. at pp. 637-638.)
We review underlying factual determinations for substantial evidence, but “the
ultimate decision—whether termination of parental rights would be detrimental to the
child due to the child’s relationship with his parent—is discretionary and properly
reviewed for abuse of discretion.” (Caden C., supra, 11 Cal.5th at p. 640.)
Analysis
Based on the evidence before the juvenile court, we conclude the juvenile court
did not abuse its discretion in finding that the harm of severing the relationship between
mother and the children did not outweigh placement in an adoptive home. While the
children had pleasant visits with mother, “A ‘ “showing [that] the child[ren] would
derive some benefit from continuing a relationship maintained during periods of
visitation” ‘ is not a sufficient ground to depart from the statutory preference for
adoption.” (In re Andrew M. (2024) 102 Cal.App.5th 803, 818.) At this stage of the
proceedings, after reunification services have been terminated, “to justify withholding the
‘security,’ ‘stability,’ and ‘ “sense of belonging a new family would confer[,]” ’ ” there
must be “some type of harm beyond the fact that [a parent’s] loving visits would cease.”
(Id. at p. 820.) Here, the record contains no evidence of anything other than enjoyable
visits between the children and mother. There is no evidence, for example, that the
children were upset when visits ended or when mother missed a visit. (Id. at p. 819.)
The children still became upset when they spoke about mother’s drinking, and there was
23.
no evidence that mother “played a meaningful role” by taking part in the children’s
medical appointments. (Ibid.)
In sum, considering the totality of the evidence, a reasonable conclusion in this
case is that the benefits of adoption—security and stability—outweighed the harm of
severing the parental relationship—loss of the potential for enjoyable visits. We find no
abuse of discretion on the part of the juvenile court in making this determination.
II. DID THE AGENCY FAIL TO FULFILL ITS DUTY OF INQUIRY AS
REQUIRED BY THE ICWA?
Both mother and father contend the agency failed to comply with its duties of
initial inquiry pursuant to ICWA and section 224.2. Although the juvenile court held that
ICWA did not apply, the agency concedes that it did not fulfill its inquiry duties with
respect to certain relatives with whom the children had contact. We accept the agency’s
concession as to its duties of inquiry, and we therefore conclude the juvenile court’s
ICWA findings were inadequately supported by the evidence. (See In re D.S. (2020) 46
Cal.App.5th 1041, 1051 [“where the facts are undisputed, we independently determine
whether ICWA’s requirements have been satisfied”].)
Section 224.2 imposes an “affirmative and continuing duty” upon the agency and
the juvenile court to inquire whether a child subject to juvenile dependency may be an
Indian child. (§ 224.2, subd. (a).) Section 224.2, subdivision (b) creates an
expanded duty of initial inquiry that requires the agency to ask “extended family
members” and “others who have an interest in the child” whether the child may be an
Indian child. ICWA defines “ ‘extended family member’ ” by “the law or custom of the
Indian child’s tribe” or, absent such law or custom, as “a person who has reached the age
of eighteen and who is the Indian child’s grandparent, aunt or uncle, brother or sister,
brother-in-law or sister-in-law, niece or nephew, first or second cousin, or stepparent.”
(25 U.S.C. § § 1903(2); Welf. & Inst. Code, § 224.1, subd. (c).)
24.
The record indicates that biological maternal grandfather and paternal
grandparents were present at an agency team meeting on January 23, 2023, the children
had video visits with their biological grandfather, and the paternal grandmother was
present at a court hearing via telephone and also during a video call between the children
and father. In addition, maternal grandparents submitted a caregiver information form
indicating that the children had contact with their various extended family members.
However, as conceded by the agency, there does not appear to be any information
indicating that an inquiry was completed with any of these relatives (other than maternal
grandmother) or that the relatives could not be identified or contacted.
We accept the agency’s concession, and therefore conclude that conditional
reversal and remand is appropriate for the limited purpose of allowing the agency to
conduct an adequate ICWA inquiry. (See In re Dezi C. (2024) 16 Cal.5th 1112, 1125.)
DISPOSITION
We conditionally reverse the juvenile court’s order terminating mother and
father’s parental rights and remand the matter to the juvenile court with directions that the
agency comply with the inquiry provisions of Welfare and Institutions Code section
224.2. If, after appropriate completion of initial inquiry, neither the agency nor the
juvenile court has reason to believe the children are Indian children, the juvenile court
shall reinstate the order terminating mother and father’s parental rights. Alternatively, if
after completing further inquiry, the agency or the juvenile court has reason to believe
that the children are Indian children, the court shall proceed accordingly.
25.
Ti chiedi come si applica questo testo alla tua situazione?
Consulenza gratuita, senza impegno
Descrivi la tua situazione. Il nostro team ti ricontatterà via e-mail per la tua consulenza.
Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude
Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.