CourtListener 10674438•In re A.V. CA4/3
Testo completo
Filed 9/19/25 In re A.V. CA4/3
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION THREE
In re A.V., Jr., et al., Persons
Coming Under the Juvenile Court
Law.
ORANGE COUNTY SOCIAL G065213
SERVICES AGENCY,
(Super. Ct. Nos. 24DP1298,
Plaintiff and Respondent, 24DP1299, 24DP1300,
24DP1301, 24DP1302)
v.
OPINION
Y.S.,
Defendant and Appellant.
Appeal from orders of the Superior Court of Orange County,
Daphne Grace Sykes, Judge. Affirmed.
Mansi Thakkar, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for
Defendant and Appellant.
Leon J. Page, County Counsel, Debbie Torrez, Supervising
Deputy, and Chloe R. Maksoudian, Deputy County Counsel, for Plaintiff and
Respondent.
Y.S. (Mother) challenges the juvenile court’s jurisdictional
findings under Welfare and Institutions Code1 section 300. We affirm. The
record contains substantial evidence that two of her children were
inappropriately physically disciplined and that they and their siblings are at
a substantial risk of serious physical harm.
FACTS
Given the limited issue on appeal, we provide only a brief
summary of the proceedings in this case.
Mother and Father have five children together: a 15-year-old son,
A.V., Jr.; an 11-year-old daughter; six-year-old twins, J.V. and Y.V.; and a
one-year-old daughter. Mother and Father briefly separated some years back
but then reunited.
Mother and Father have a history of engaging in domestic
violence against one another, sometimes in the children’s presence. In 2016,
for example, A.V. (then age six) observed Mother and Father fighting with
closed fists, and Mother later admitted she slapped Father while he was
holding A.V.’s younger sister in his arms. In 2020, A.V. reported to police that
Father and Mother threw glass at and struck one another during a fight,
drawing blood. And in 2022, Mother reported that Father headbutted her
during an argument about money, and Mother punched the back of Father’s
head; later that evening, Mother locked herself and the children in the
bedroom and Father attempted to kick down the door.
Mother and Father also have a history of using excessive physical
force to discipline their children. In 2019, for example, Mother slapped A.V.
(then age 10) for fighting with his sister, leaving a large bruise on his
1 All further statutory references are to this code.
2
cheekbone. In the ensuing investigation, Mother admitted to having slapped
A.V. She also admitted she punched him on a previous occasion.
The family most recently came to the Orange County Social
Services Agency’s attention in October 2024 because J.V. (then age five) was
observed to have a three-inch-long red mark between his eyebrows. J.V.
initially said Father had hit him in the face with a sandal because he was not
getting ready for school quickly enough. In the subsequent investigation,
however, J.V. gave several inconsistent reports about how he got the mark—
including that it was from a marker and that it was caused by various
classmates.
That same day, J.V.’s twin sister, Y.V., confirmed she saw Father
slapping J.V. with a sandal, though she remained silent when asked if she
knew the difference between a truth and a lie. Y.V. also disclosed that Mother
hit her on her legs and bottom before school because she had vomited in the
living room. The social worker observed a small bruise on the girl’s bottom.
Mother confirmed she hit Y.V. because she threw up and admitted that she
sometimes disciplines the children by hitting them on the mouth or the
bottom with an open hand.
Father denied hitting J.V. or using a sandal to discipline the
children. He was not cooperative during the investigation and told the
children not to speak with the social worker. Police briefly detained him for
being combative.
The Agency filed a section 300 petition based on Father striking
J.V. in the face, Mother striking Y.V. on the legs and bottom, the parents’
history of using inappropriate physical discipline, and their history of
domestic violence, among other grounds. A protective custody warrant was
granted, but the juvenile court released the children to the parents’ custody.
3
In the following months, the parents continued to deny the
physical abuse allegations and declined to provide information about their
domestic violence history. The children likewise denied that their parents
had ever used any physical discipline. Mother reported the entire family was
traumatized and stressed by the Agency’s involvement, and the children were
afraid of being removed from their care.
At the jurisdictional hearing, after “look[ing] at the totality of the
information or evidence presented,” including “the age and maturity of the
speakers, whether the statements are consistent with statements by others,
[and] the motivation of the speakers to make the statements,” the juvenile
court found Father had hit J.V. in the face with the sandal and Mother had
used physical force to discipline Y.V., resulting in bruising. The court also
expressed concern that these are not “one-time incidents,” but rather there
was “a history of this exact behavior.” Finding J.V., Y.V., and their siblings
were at a substantial risk of future physical harm, the court sustained the
petition (as amended).
At the subsequent disposition hearing, the juvenile court ordered
that custody of the children remain vested with the parents. It then struck
the substance abuse services and domestic violence services from the case
plan and ordered the parents to participate in general counseling and
parenting education.
DISCUSSION
A juvenile court may assert jurisdiction over a child when the
child has suffered, or there is a substantial risk the child will suffer, serious
physical harm as a result of the parent’s failure or inability to adequately
protect the child. (§ 300, subd. (b)(1)(A).) The court may also assert
jurisdiction when there is a substantial risk the child’s siblings will be abused
4
in that manner. (Id., subd. (j).) Jurisdictional findings are made by a
preponderance of the evidence. (§ 355, subd. (a).)
“Although ‘the question under section 300 is whether
circumstances at the time of the hearing subject the minor to the defined risk
of harm’ [citation], the court may nevertheless consider past events when
determining whether a child presently needs the juvenile court’s protection.
[Citations.] A parent’s past conduct is a good predictor of future behavior.” (In
re T.V. (2013) 217 Cal.App.4th 126, 133.) “‘The court need not wait until a
child is seriously abused or injured to assume jurisdiction and take the steps
necessary to protect the child.’” (Ibid.)
We review a juvenile court’s jurisdictional findings for
substantial evidence and will affirm if substantial evidence, contradicted or
uncontradicted, supports those findings. (In re I.J. (2013) 56 Cal.4th 766,
773.) “‘“In making this determination, we draw all reasonable inferences from
the evidence to support the findings and orders of the dependency court; we
review the record in the light most favorable to the court’s determinations;
and we note that issues of fact and credibility are the province of the trial
court.” [Citation.] “We do not reweigh the evidence or exercise independent
judgment, but merely determine if there are sufficient facts to support the
findings of the trial court.”’” (Ibid.)
Mother claims the juvenile court’s jurisdictional findings are not
supported by substantial evidence. She insists that aside from a few
photographs of the children’s injuries, the only evidence supporting the
allegations about J.V. and Y.V. is a single out-of-court statement by five-year-
old Y.V. (who could not differentiate between the truth and a lie) that Father
had slapped J.V. with a sandal and that Mother hit her with a sandal.
Mother alternatively contends there is no evidence linking the marks on the
5
children to the parents, the sandals at issue appear physically incapable of
causing their injuries, and in any event, there is no current risk of harm.
We conclude the juvenile court’s findings are sufficiently
supported. Before having an opportunity to speak with their parents, J.V.
and Y.V. both disclosed that their parents had hit them with a sandal.2 The
marks left on their bodies were still visible hours later.3 Mother admitted to
using physical discipline on the children, and the parents have previously
used physical discipline in an inappropriate manner on their older child, A.V.
The parents also have a known history of engaging in domestic violence
against one another, often in the presence of their children. Taken together,
this constitutes substantial evidence that J.V. and Y.V. were inappropriately
physically disciplined and that they and their siblings are at a substantial
risk of serious physical harm.
2 Mother insists J.V. “never disclosed that the red mark on his
face was caused by Father hitting him with a sandal.” But according to the
Agency’s detention report, when the reporting party questioned J.V. about
the red mark on his face, J.V. disclosed that his “father had hit him in the
face with a chancla sandal” earlier that morning “because [he] was not fast
enough in getting ready for school.”
3 Mother contends no evidence showed the spanking was
excessive. She does not develop this argument beyond briefly citing In re
D.M. (2015) 242 Cal.App.4th 634 (D.M.), which rejected a “categorical view
that ‘hitting children with shoes’ is ‘physical abuse’ and ‘not a proper form of
discipline . . . .’” (See id. at p. 637.) One can reasonably question the attempt
to constrain dependency jurisdiction with general criminal and tort law
principles. (Id. at p. 649 (dis. opn. of Chavez, J.).) In any event, the record
would sufficiently support implied findings that slapping a five-year-old with
a sandal to the point of leaving a mark because the child vomited or was slow
to get ready for school was neither “genuinely disciplinary,” “‘warranted by
the circumstances,’” nor ‘“reasonable.”’ (See id. at p. 641 [three factors].)
6
We recognize the children later repeatedly denied any physical
abuse. However, the juvenile court discredited those later denials, noting that
“[a]n inconsistency does not necessarily mean that none of the statements can
be believed.” With J.V. in particular, the court believed “the child was
attempting to move away from [his] original statement which incriminated
his father, likely out of thinking that his parents were not going to like what
he said.” The court was entitled to give greater weight to the children’s initial
reports of abuse than to their subsequent denials. We decline Mother’s
invitation to reweigh the evidence and substitute our judgment for that of the
juvenile court. (In re E.G. (2025) 112 Cal.App.5th 707, 722.)4
4 Mother asserts the Agency’s appellate brief is “riddled with
inconsistencies, inaccuracies, and misleading assertions” and “blatantly
misrepresents facts.” This seems to be an overstatement. Viewing the facts
differently is not a moral shortfall, and there is no need to assail opposing
counsel’s integrity.
7
DISPOSITION
The jurisdictional findings are affirmed.
SCOTT, J.
WE CONCUR:
MOORE, ACTING P. J.
GOODING, J.
8
Ti chiedi come si applica questo testo alla tua situazione?
Consulenza gratuita, senza impegno
Descrivi la tua situazione. Il nostro team ti ricontatterà via e-mail per la tua consulenza.
Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude
Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.