CourtListener 10662713•In re Aiden C. CA2/1
Testo completo
Filed 8/28/25 In re Aiden C. CA2/1
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION ONE
In re AIDEN C., a Person B342549
Coming Under Juvenile Court
Law. (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No. 18CCJP07889)
LOS ANGELES COUNTY
DEPARTMENT OF
CHILDREN AND FAMILY
SERVICES,
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v.
A.R.,
Defendant and
Appellant.
APPEAL from orders of the Superior Court of Los Angeles
County, Mary E. Kelly, Judge. Affirmed.
Lillian Hamrick, under appointment by the Court of
Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, Kim Nemoy,
Assistant County Counsel, and Sally Son, Deputy County
Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
__________________________________
In October 2024, the juvenile court denied a petition
brought by appellant mother A.R. under Welfare and Institutions
Code section 388 asking the court to return her son Aiden C.
(born May 2013) to her care or, in the alternative, reinstate
reunification services.1 Immediately afterward, the court
appointed a legal guardian for Aiden in a section 366.26 hearing.
On appeal, Mother contends the juvenile court erred in
denying the section 388 petition because she demonstrated both
changed circumstances and that her request was in Aiden’s best
interest, and erred in appointing a legal guardian for Aiden
“because the court’s section 366.26 findings and orders were
reached only after the improper denial of mother’s section 388
petition.”2 Finding no error, we affirm.
1 Undesignated statutory references are to the Welfare and
Institutions Code.
2 Mother also initially claimed that the court’s written
minute order arising from the section 366.26 hearing incorrectly
reflected the visitation order orally articulated by the court but
has since conceded this argument, after DCFS pointed out that a
second, correct minute order was entered a few minutes after the
incorrect one.
2
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND3
A. Prior Child Welfare History
Before the referral that occasioned this case, DCFS
received seven referrals concerning Aiden. In June 2015, DCFS
received a referral for physical and emotional abuse—the
physical abuse was deemed unfounded, and the emotional abuse
inconclusive. In October 2015, DCFS received a referral for
physical abuse that was deemed inconclusive. In May 2016,
DCFS received a referral for general neglect and physical
abuse—the general neglect was substantiated and the physical
abuse unfounded. From May 2016 to February 2017, the family
had a voluntary family maintenance case; Mother did not fully
complete her services and objectives during that time but
promised to continue with her services after the case closed.
In July 2017, DCFS received a referral for emotional and
physical abuse—all allegations were deemed inconclusive. In
October 2017, DCFS received a referral for physical abuse that
was found inconclusive. In April 2018, DCFS received a referral
for physical abuse that was found inconclusive. And in June
2018, DCFS received a referral for general neglect, physical
abuse, and emotional abuse—the allegations were found
inconclusive and unfounded.
B. DCFS Investigates a Referral
In November 2018, DCFS received a referral reporting that
a child said his stepfather broke his hand; the child’s mother
claimed the child broke his hand playing a “coin video machine”
3 We limit our summary to the facts and procedural history
relevant to the issues appellant raises on appeal.
3
at the laundromat. There was also suspicion of “coaching” as,
after the child stated the stepfather broke his hand, Mother
spoke to him in Spanish. The reporting party relayed that
“hospital staff reported the child reported that he was trying to
get a coin out of a machine and the step father [sic] grabbed his
wrist really hard.” Tests showed no fracture or dislocation or
swelling.
1. Initial Investigation
A children’s social worker (CSW) responded to the hospital
where the child—Aiden—was being treated, and clarified that
“stepfather” referred to Mother’s boyfriend, Luis. A nurse
informed the CSW that Mother “admitted to law enforcement
that the child was playing with a video game when [step]father
grabbed the child’s hand, possibly causing the injury.”
The CSW spoke with Mother, who was with her newborn,
Anthony (born October 2018).4 Mother explained that, while at a
laundromat, Aiden became upset when she refused to give him
quarters for the video game machines there. Aiden began having
a tantrum, wanting to go where the machines were, and Luis
grabbed him by the arm. Aiden tugged his hand from Luis’s grip
and began complaining of pain shortly afterward. When the
complaints continued even after the family had returned home,
they brought Aiden to the Emergency Room. Mother denied Luis
intentionally hurt or ever abused Aiden. Mother claimed Aiden
4 Both Mother and Luis denied he was Anthony’s biological
father but both stated Luis “gave the child his last name and is
listed on the child’s birth certificate”; Luis added he had
“adopted” Anthony. Anthony and Aiden have different biological
fathers.
4
talked back to her a lot and challenged her when she tried to set
rules and boundaries. Luis lived with the family and helped with
the bills and childcare.
Mother denied any domestic violence issues with Luis but
reported “multiple incidents” of domestic violence with Aiden’s
father Juan C., against whom she had a restraining order.5
Mother stated Father both abused Aiden and abused her in front
of Aiden. Mother also stated Aiden had been receiving behavioral
therapy but “she stopped taking him a couple of months ago
because . . . the child’s therapist insisted mother allow the child
to have contact with father.” Mother denied any current drug
use, although she admitted to smoking “rock” before she was
pregnant with Aiden. The CSW noted that throughout the
interview, she “had to often repeat the questions to mother in
both English and Spanish, as mother would at times provide
answers that were irrelevant to the questions being asked.”
The CSW spoke with Aiden, who first refused to tell her
what happened, then stated he did not know. When pressed,
Aiden revealed he had gone with Mother and Luis to wash a lot of
dirty clothes. Eventually, he claimed he broke his hand jumping
from the bed; he denied anyone else caused the injury. He also
denied any physical abuse or discipline by Mother but claimed
that when Luis picked him up from school on Friday, Luis hit his
left knee with a belt. Aiden stated Luis had hit him other times
in the left knee with a belt.
5 In her application for a restraining order, Mother stated
that when Father dropped Aiden off after spending the day with
him, he became “very aggravated” and drunkenly pushed her into
a door while she was holding Aiden. Mother also stated Father
had threatened to hit her in the past.
5
The CSW spoke with Luis who reported he had been at the
laundromat with the family when Aiden started “running
around.” Luis grabbed his arm to get him to stop, but Aiden
“started pulling himself and started crying.” When the pain
persisted, they brought Aiden to the hospital. Luis denied
intentionally hurting Aiden or ever hitting Aiden.
2. Continued Investigation
Ten days later, a second CSW spoke with Mother, Luis, and
Aiden at the family’s home. The gist of Mother’s and Luis’s story
regarding Aiden’s injury remained the same. Aiden now said he
was injured when Luis “carried him” at the laundromat. Aiden
denied corporal punishment but “did not respond when asked
if . . . Luis used any discipline with him.” Luis denied any
corporal punishment.
In late November 2018, Luis tested negative for all
substances but Mother tested positive for methamphetamine.
When the CSW spoke with Mother about the test, she admitted
to experimenting with “crack” in the past, claiming she last used
it before her recent pregnancy. When the CSW explained the
drug test Mother took “reflect[s] approximate detection times of
about 1 or 2 days”—meaning it would have been impossible for
Mother to test positive after almost a year—“Mother remained
silent.” After the CSW commended Mother for not taking any
substances while pregnant, Mother “broke down” and stated she
had used “Friday[,] maybe a little.”6 Mother refused to provide
any more details about her drug use but agreed to enroll in an
outpatient drug treatment program. Mother later had her sister
6 Mother had drug tested on a Saturday.
6
enroll her in a program; the sister told the CSW Mother denied
having a substance abuse problem.
C. The Court Detains the Children
In December 2018, DCFS obtained a removal order for the
children, who were placed into foster care. Two days later, DCFS
filed a petition on behalf of Aiden and Anthony under section 300,
subdivisions (a), (b)(1), and (j). Counts a-1, b-1, and j-1
identically alleged that Luis struck Aiden with a belt, causing
unreasonable pain and suffering, and that Mother failed to
protect Aiden, endangering both children. Count b-2 alleged
Mother had a history of substance abuse and was a current user
of amphetamine and methamphetamine, rendering her incapable
of caring for the children.
At the detention hearing, the court found a prima facie case
for detaining the children and granted Mother and Luis
monitored visits. The court also ordered DCFS to investigate
whether the children could be placed with maternal great-aunt
Julia G., granting DCFS discretion to place the children with her
if appropriate. The children were subsequently released into
Julia’s care.
D. DCFS Continues Investigating
1. Aiden
When a dependency investigator (DI) spoke with Aiden in
early 2019, when he was almost six years old, he claimed Luis
“broke my hand.” He explained they were at a laundromat when
Luis grabbed his wrist. Aiden also reiterated Luis would hit him
with both a belt and a sandal, and would hit him “sometimes one
7
time, sometimes three times.” Aiden claimed to have “bruises all
over and red.”
Aiden did not know what drugs were but reported Mother
and Luis both “smoked.”
2. Mother
The DI spoke with Mother, observing that Mother “has a
difficult time following a conversation”; the DI often had to
rephrase questions in order to help Mother understand.
Mother denied Luis ever hit or hurt Aiden with a belt,
sandal, or anything else. She repeated her previous explanation
that the family had been at a laundromat when Aiden threw a
tantrum because she would not give him a quarter to play on a
video game machine. Aiden hurt his hand pulling away from
Luis, who had grabbed his arm. Mother told the DI, “I knew he
was going to say I hurt him, we are working on saying the truth
because he lies a lot.” When the DI explained that Aiden
reported Luis had hurt him, Mother responded: “It’s a lie, I can’t
believe my own son is doing this to me, I told him[, if] you keep
saying these things, I’m never getting you back, just say ‘bye bye’
to mommy, you’re stupid.” She claimed she and Luis were still
cohabiting and in a romantic relationship.
Mother denied using any drug other than crack, which she
stated Father introduced her to when she was pregnant with
Aiden. She used it twice or thrice daily throughout her
pregnancy, stopping when Aiden was around three years old,
because “it made me skinny, depressed.” However, she started
using it again when she met Luis three years ago because she felt
“depressed.” She returned to using it twice or thrice daily. She
stated the last time she used cocaine was September 2018. She
could not explain why she tested positive for methamphetamine
8
and claimed she did not know what amphetamine or
methamphetamine was. She denied ever smoking cocaine at
home or in front of the children. She claimed her drug use did
not interfere with her ability to care for the children and added
that “although she would be ‘all drugged out, all stupid’ she
would still take the child Aiden to school daily. She stated
cocaine helped her go to work even though she would go ‘all drug
addict.’ ” In February and March, Mother missed two drug tests
and tested negative once.
Mother visited Aiden thrice weekly; each visit lasted two
hours. Julia reported Mother behaved appropriately during the
visits.
In a March 2019 conversation with a therapist treating
both Aiden and Mother, the therapist voiced her belief that
Mother “may have a mental delay.” She elaborated that Mother
“did not seem to understand basic instructions and may have a
hard time with understanding the Court proceedings and orders.”
3. Father
Father stated he had not seen Aiden since July 2018, when
Mother obtained a restraining order. He claimed that during
many visits with Aiden, Aiden would have bruises he could not
explain. He also claimed that, in his presence, Mother
threatened to hit Aiden if Aiden told Father what happened.
Father denied ever hitting Mother and claimed Mother was only
able to obtain the restraining order because he went to the wrong
courthouse the day of the hearing.
Father claimed Mother had been using methamphetamine
since he met her in 2012. When Mother became pregnant with
Aiden, she told Father she stopped using drugs, but he suspected
she had not. Father stated Mother separated from him when
9
Aiden was about six months old; thereafter, she would sometimes
send him pictures of alcohol bottles and coolers filled with beer.
Father denied using any drugs or having alcohol issues. He
agreed to drug test but then claimed he could not because he
lacked valid identification. “Despite the Department making
several efforts to drug test the father due to his suspected drug
use, the father has not provided a picture of himself so the
Department can give him an identification letter to drug test.”
Father also did not try to schedule visits to see Aiden.
Father appeared at an April 2019 hearing. Although non-
offending under the petition, he submitted to the court’s
jurisdiction. The court ordered monitored visitation for Father.
The order specified “[v]isits [were] to be monitored by a
Department of Children and Family Services approved monitor
in a Department of Children and Family Services approved
setting.”
4. Paternal Grandmother and Paternal Aunt
The DI spoke with the paternal grandmother (PGM), who
stated Father often lived on the streets, occasionally stopping by
her home to eat, sleep, or shower. PGM added that when Father
would arrive at her house, he would be “filthy and under the
influence of either drugs or alcohol.” PGM stated Father had
never taken appropriate care of Aiden and “she often found the
child dirty, hungry and playing with his electronics” while in
Father’s care. She described Father as “aggressive,” claiming he
“steals, lies excessively and has many legal issues.”
The paternal aunt confirmed Father lacked stable housing
and often lived on the streets “for days.” The aunt stated Father
did not work and smoked marijuana.
10
5. Luis
Luis reported that, as of January 8, 2019—two weeks
before the DI spoke with Mother—he had not lived with Mother,
was no longer in a romantic relationship with her, and wanted
nothing to do with either child. Luis denied intentionally hurting
Aiden and repeated his claim that the injury occurred when he
grabbed Aiden by the wrist at a laundromat, and Aiden fought to
free himself. Luis denied ever hitting Aiden with a belt but
admitted hitting him once on the buttocks with a sandal. He
denied ever leaving Aiden with any bruises or redness.
Luis stated that, after living with Mother for three months,
he discovered she smoked methamphetamine. He estimated she
smoked on a weekly basis and had seen her care for the children
while under the influence.
E. The Court Removes the Children
At the May 2019 adjudication and disposition hearing, the
court granted Luis’s motion to set aside his previous voluntary
declaration of paternity and declared he had no “paternal
findings” in the case. The court then dismissed counts a-1 and j-1
and accepted Mother’s no contest plea to a slightly modified count
b-1 and b-2, finding those counts true.7
The court removed the children from Mother and granted
her thrice weekly visits, three hours per visit, unmonitored if in
7 Count b-1 was modified to read that Luis only struck
Aiden once with a belt (as opposed to “[o]n prior occasions”) and
that Mother was “unable” to protect Aiden (rather than stating
she “failed” to do so). Count b-2 was modified to read that
Mother was a “recent user of methamphetamine” (instead of a
“current abuser of amphetamine and methamphetamine”).
11
maternal great-aunt Julia’s home, and monitored elsewhere.8
The court granted Father monitored visitation with the same
frequency and duration. The court also ordered Mother to
undergo drug treatment and random drug testing and to attend
parenting classes and mental health counseling.
F. Six-Month Review Hearing
A November 2019 status report stated Aiden was doing
well in Julia’s care, although he exhibited behavioral issues at
school. Mother visited Aiden consistently and worked hard to
bond with him. Aiden’s therapist stated Mother showed up to
every session and was open to learning the therapist’s parenting
techniques. In October 2019, DCFS permitted Mother to have
unmonitored visits outside Julia’s home.
Mother was reported to be following the court’s case plan,
attending individual counseling, parenting classes, and a 12-step
program. Mother tested negative in seven random drug and
alcohol tests administered by the program. Mother also missed
several random drug tests requested by DCFS; she claimed she
was unable to follow the instructions for testing and did not hear
the letter of her last name when she called in to find out whether
she needed to test. Between May and October 2019, Mother
tested negative eight times and missed eight tests. Mother’s
counselor noted she seemed to have some developmental delay
and sometimes became upset or emotional when she did not
understand what was being discussed. Anthony’s therapist made
a similar observation.
8 Julia was to be present in the home but did not need to be
around Mother “all the time.”
12
Father visited Aiden thrice but “has not made an effort to
continue the visits.” Father also was not following his case plan.
At the November 2019 six-month review hearing, the court
continued reunification services for Mother but terminated them
for Father. The court admonished Mother to consistently
participate in drug testing and granted her permission to have
overnight visits with the children in Julia’s home.
G. Twelve-Month Review Hearing
The children continued to do well in Julia’s home. Mother
continued visiting them, and Julia opined that Aiden loved
Mother and enjoyed the visits. Aiden said he wanted to live with
Mother and felt happy and safe with her.
In mid-July and late August 2020, Mother tested positive
for methamphetamine. Mother denied taking any
methamphetamine but admitted she had been taking “pain
medication.” Mother continued participating in parenting classes
and individual therapy. She completed her drug-treatment
program.
At the September 2020 twelve-month review hearing, the
court found that, due to the recent “relapse,” Mother was only in
partial compliance with her case plan. However, the court
expressed optimism this was just “a little bit of a setback,” and
Aiden could be returned to Mother at the next hearing. The court
continued reunification services.
H. Eighteen-Month Review Hearing
Mother tested positive for methamphetamine on September
15, 2020, October 5, 2020, November 9, 2020, and December 10,
2020. She also missed two tests. Mother “denied using any type
of narcotic or being around a user of any type of drug” and “stated
13
that she believes that the testing location is to blame for the
positive drug tests.” However, from mid-December 2020 to the
beginning of March 2021, Mother took 12 drug tests and tested
negative each time.
At the March 2021 eighteen-month review hearing, the
court ordered continued family reunification services and ordered
Mother to attend an in-patient drug treatment program.
I. Twenty-Four-Month Review Hearing
From January to September 2021, Mother drug tested
weekly, testing negative each time for all substances. DCFS
reported she had completed all court-ordered services. At the
October 2021 review hearing, the court ordered the children
returned to Mother, with six months of family preservation
services.
J. Section 364 Hearing
According to an April 2022 status report, Mother continued
testing negative for all substances. Mother reported being
stressed and asked to re-enroll in therapy. DCFS received four
referrals: one in January 2022, two in February 2022, and one in
March 2022. The January 2022 referral alleged Mother slapped
Father, thereby causing emotional harm to the children; the
allegations were deemed unfounded.
The first February referral alleged Aiden had told Mother
the previous day he needed to bring snacks to school for a
celebration; she became very upset and began hitting him. The
reporting party also stated Mother had claimed Aiden was trying
to manipulate her. Mother elaborated that during the
Thanksgiving break, Aiden said he would tell his teacher Mother
was hitting him so Mother would go to jail, and Aiden could
14
return to his previous “foster family.” When a CSW investigated,
Aiden claimed Mother did hit him. When asked how, Aiden
stated Mother scratched him and showed the CSW marks on his
cheek that resembled scratches. When the CSW asked if Mother
had hit him in the past, he responded she did not hit him “that
much.” Aiden stated Mother hit him when he misbehaved. A
police report indicates Aiden told a police officer Mother “has hit
him with a shoe and her hands while pointing to his upper body
and his legs.”
When asked about the scratches, Mother reported she
“accidentally scratched the child’s face.” Mother explained the
two were walking to school when Aiden became angry that
Mother lacked the funds to buy him a treat. Aiden swore at
Mother, began to run away from her, and, when she told him to
stop, threw himself on the ground. Mother’s response “was to
grab the child’s face.” Mother told police that when Aiden “does
not get what he wants he scratches himself to get attention.”
DCFS deemed the allegations inconclusive.
The second February 2022 referral alleged Aiden had
accused Mother of hitting him twice on the head with a closed
fist, kicking him in the leg, and trying to break his pinky finger.
When Mother was asked about the allegations, she stated she
had spanked Aiden for running away from her in the morning,
and he had responded by threatening to speak to a teacher and
have Mother sent to jail. When a CSW spoke with Aiden, he
reported Mother scratched him and pulled his pinky. Aiden also
stated Mother had hit him that morning, but not in the head. He
did not know why Mother hit him. The CSW saw no visible
marks or bruises, and Aiden did not appear to be in pain. DCFS
deemed the allegations inconclusive.
15
The March 2022 referral alleged the maternal grandfather
hit Mother twice on the head; these allegations were deemed
inconclusive.
In March 2022, a nurse practitioner spoke with both
Mother and Aiden about suspected child abuse. As soon as the
examiner entered the room where both Mother and Aiden were
waiting, Mother immediately began complaining about Aiden,
accusing him of misbehaving and lying. When asked what Aiden
did that made her happy, Mother “looked at this examiner
blankly and did not have anything to say and was shaking her
head.” When the examiner spoke privately with Mother, she
“stated she wants Aiden to be taken to foster care but not his
brother. Mom reports she cannot handle Aiden.” However, she
later said tearfully that DCFS “better not take away Aiden . . .
because she does not know what she would do.”
At the April 2022 section 364 hearing, the court loosened
Mother’s drug testing requirements to testing only if DCFS had a
reasonable suspicion she was using and continued the section 364
hearing for three months so DCFS could assist Mother with
moving out of the home she shared with her parents.
K. DCFS Files a Section 342 Petition
In May 2022, DCFS received a referral alleging Mother was
physically abusing Aiden. Aiden had shown his teacher a bruise
on his arm, explaining Mother had become upset and forced him
to shower when he did not want to. While in the shower, Mother
hit him on the arm “with something from the shower.” The
bruise appeared new and had not been there the previous day.
A CSW spoke with Mother. Mother claimed she and Aiden
were struggling in the shower. Aiden wanted the showerhead
removed and, when she removed it, he pulled it from her and lost
16
his balance. She grabbed his wrist to prevent him from falling.
Mother also reported that the day before the shower incident,
Aiden had told Mother to hit him and called her a “Fucking hole
[sic].” Mother claimed Aiden verbally provoked and hit her.
Mother told the CSW she was thinking of changing schools
because she believed that would stop DCFS involvement in her
life. She also told the CSW that if Aiden misbehaved, she would
spank him. She asked, “How should I respect him when he
doesn’t respect me?”
The CSW spoke with Aiden and asked how he sustained
the bruise on his wrist. Aiden reported that Mother grabbed his
arm. He added that Mother told him “he will not be getting a
cake as a result of this investigation because mother believes he
is lying.” Aiden explained he did not want to shower with Mother
because he did not want a woman to see his body. Aiden later
told a family nurse practitioner who examined him that, while in
the shower, he was “screaming at [Mother] and telling her to stop
touching me with the shower thing. I didn’t like it[,] and she hit
me for that.” Mother told the same nurse practitioner: “I tell
him to keep his mouth shut when I whoop him because I need to
teach him the consequences of his actions. He always wants me
to hurt him and I ask him what I am doing wrong. I will leave
him with my mom where he is bad. I don’t know how to handle
him. He didn’t want to shower himself. He wanted to take the
shower head off. I took it from him and he was falling and I
grabbed him. I pulled him tight to try and control him. He was
kicking at me. He had a bad behavior problem. My dad talks to
him about what he does, but he will even spit on him. I always
want to find out what to do to make things better. I want to fix
things.”
17
A CSW also spoke with one of Aiden’s teachers regarding
an inconclusive referral from February 2022, in which Aiden
accused Mother of hitting him after he told her he needed to
bring snacks to school the next day. The teacher told the CSW
that Aiden had said to her, “I’m not supposed to talk to you. I’m
supposed to be quiet. Mom said if I say anything again she’s
going to hit me hard.” The teacher added she had spoken to
Mother, “who reported she was upset because the child is not
being truthful and mother denied hitting the child Aiden.”
In June 2022, DCFS sought an order to remove Aiden from
Mother’s care. The court granted DCFS’s request, and Aiden was
again placed with maternal great-aunt Julia. When a CSW
asked Aiden if he knew why he was being removed, he responded
it was because he lied.
Four days later, DCFS filed a section 342 petition on behalf
of the children, under section 300, subdivisions (a), (b)(1), and (j).
Counts a-1, b-1, and j-1 identically alleged Mother physically
abused Aiden, including bruising his wrist in May 2022,
scratching his face in February 2022, and striking Aiden with a
shoe, a showerhead, and her hands, which endangered both
children. The court found a prima facie case to detain Aiden.9
L. The Court Removes Aiden
Mother re-enrolled in parenting classes and individual
therapy and consistently visited Aiden. When a DI tried to ask
her about the most recent allegations, Mother “immediately
expressed frustration and anger” with Aiden’s school, blaming it
for “interrogat[ing]” him. After a few minutes, Mother explained
9 No findings were made as to Anthony, and he was not
detained.
18
that Aiden’s wrist got bruised because she grabbed it to prevent
him from falling in the shower and, when she did so, the
showerhead fell off the wall and hit him. She later stated she
was holding the showerhead in her hand and, when she reached
for Aiden, she released the showerhead, causing it to fall on
Aiden’s wrist. Mother refused to discuss the incident where
Aiden’s face got scratched.
Later in the interview, Mother complained, “Aiden is a
manipulator. He has an anger problem and he threatened me. I
couldn’t touch him. He threw shoes at me. You think I’m going
to let him mistreat me?” She related an incident in which she
refused to give Aiden her phone and he responded, “If you don’t
give me the phone[,] bitch[,] I’m going to fuck you up.” Mother
added that when she spoke with Aiden on the phone and he said
he missed her, she would tell him she did not miss him, so Aiden
could learn how to respect her. Mother said, “I know I was a drug
addict[,] but I’m changing.” Mother claimed she disciplined
Aiden by raising her voice, and that she has told him: “[I]f you
want to come back, you have to change; you have to prove that
you really miss me. You made this happen.” She added that she
told Aiden, “Don’t tell people at school when I scold you.”
A DI spoke with Aiden about the most recent allegations;
he was constantly evasive and avoided answering questions
about the incident. When asked if he knew why he was removed
the most recent time, Aiden answered, “Yes, because I told the
school that my mom hits me but it was not true. She does hit me
when I don’t listen.” However, when asked about the bruise on
his wrist, he reiterated it resulted from Mother hitting him with
the showerhead because he was refusing to shower. As for the
scratches on his face, Aiden confirmed he had run away from
19
Mother after a disagreement about buying juice for a birthday
celebration at school, and Mother grabbed and scratched him.
Aiden also discussed an incident in which Mother pulled his shirt
from the back, causing a little pain and a scratch. Mother
apologized and put makeup on his neck to cover the mark. When
asked what happened to him when he disobeyed Mother, Aiden
was uncomfortable and said, “I don’t know, I forgot.”
At the August 2022 adjudication hearing on the section 342
petition, the court sustained counts b-1 and j-1. At the
September 2022 disposition hearing, the court removed Aiden
from Mother and set a section 366.26 hearing to select a
permanent plan. The court ordered no reunification services
because Mother “has run out of time.”10
M. Mother Files Her First Section 388 Petition
Mother continued visiting Aiden, although maternal great-
aunt Julia reported Mother did not show affection toward Aiden.
Father also began consistently visiting with Aiden. In March
2023, the court set legal guardianship as the permanent plan.
In April 2023, on the same day as the section 366.26
hearing, Mother filed a section 388 petition, requesting the court
either return Aiden to her care or grant six more months of
reunification services with unmonitored visits. Mother asserted
that, since the court’s removal of Aiden, she “has completed two
parenting programs, has been in therapy since 2021, . . . has
continue[d] to participate in weekly psychotherapy through
10 Although the court expressed grave misgivings at doing
so, it terminated jurisdiction as to Anthony, based on the
recommendations of DCFS’s counsel and Anthony’s counsel, who
both opined Anthony was situated differently than Aiden.
20
BHS[, and] . . . has been substantially involved in regional center
services through Passport for Learning and is addressing anger
management, and substance abuse history. She [has] been
visiting consistently, three times per week.” The court set a
hearing for mid-June 2023 and continued the section 366.26
hearing to the same date.
DCFS opined that, since the court’s most recent removal of
Aiden, Mother had “demonstrated behavior change while in visits
with the child,” noting that Mother had “completed a 12-week
parenting course, continues to attend individual counseling,
conjoint counseling with Aiden, substance abuse relapse
prevention and anger management.” DCFS recommended the
court grant Mother’s petition. In June 2023, the court granted
the petition and took the section 366.26 hearing off-calendar.
N. The Court Terminates Reunification Services
In a September 2023 status report, Aiden was reported as
thriving with maternal great-aunt Julia but preferring to return
home to Mother. Mother had unmonitored visits with Aiden from
10:00 a.m. to 7:00 p.m. on Sundays. Aiden reported Mother no
longer yelled at him and instead spoke nicely to him. The pair
were making progress in family therapy. Taking into account
Mother’s progress, DCFS recommended Aiden could begin
overnight visits with Mother. In a September 2023 review
hearing, the court followed DCFS’s recommendation and granted
Mother overnight visits.
In November 2023, DCFS received information that Aiden’s
behavior in class had worsened since he began overnight visits
with Mother. Aiden stated he “wants to die and hates his life.”
Aiden also reported Mother made him drink beer with Father,
even though Aiden told Mother he did not want to drink.
21
A CSW spoke with Aiden who reported that, during the
previous overnight visit, Mother and Aiden met up with Father.
Aiden told Mother he was thirsty, and Father told him to “have
some beer.” Aiden did not want to drink but did not know what
to do as Mother did not say anything. Aiden had a sip of the
beer.
The CSW called Mother. When Mother answered the
phone, she immediately said: “I already know why you are
calling. I don’t know why Aiden is making up lies, I told him if he
doesn’t want to live here he can stay with his aunt.” Mother then
said the phone was going to run out of battery and the call ended.
Maternal great-aunt Juila told the CSW she had not observed
anything amiss when Aiden returned from the previous overnight
visit.
The CSW spoke with Mother the following week. Mother
claimed she and Aiden ran into Father and did no more than
exchange greetings. She denied Aiden drank any beer. However,
due to DCFS’s concerns, Mother volunteered to return to having
her visits monitored. Maternal grandmother (MGM) and the
maternal uncle assisted Mother in supervising visits.
In a December 2023 status report, Mother reported that
Aiden often talked back to her and, when she tried to impose a
consequence for his actions, he would tell her: “[Y]ou can’t do
anything to me. Ima [sic] tell my teacher and the social worker.”
In that same report, DCFS noted the paternal aunt had
called the CSW to inform her that Mother had given Father
access to Aiden more than once. The paternal aunt provided a
picture she claimed Mother sent her of Aiden and Father in late
October 2023—Aiden appeared to be in a Halloween costume.
The aunt also stated Mother had brought Father back to the
22
home where she was staying with the maternal grandparents,
and MGM permitted him to enter. The aunt told Mother she
would be reporting this information to the CSW because Father
“is not doing well with his substance abuse.”
At the December 2023 review hearing, the court recognized
Mother was a Regional Center client and had intellectual and
comprehension issues. Nevertheless, the court noted that Mother
had received “extensive” services. Impliedly disbelieving
Mother’s claim that she and Aiden had just run into Father and
exchanged greetings, the court found this to be “a different
situation. They are sitting down, visiting. The child says he’s
thirsty. Instead of giving him water, they’re offering him beer.
He’s ten. This is a serious violation.” The court pointed to
Mother’s “pattern” of “put[ting] things off on other things” (i.e.,
blaming other events or people instead of her own actions). The
court described Mother’s claims that Aiden lied about things
rather than taking accountability, and telling Aiden not to tell
the school when she scolded him. The court also cited to Mother’s
statement that Aiden “can go back to live with the caregiver,”
opining this demonstrated a “lack of concern for his well-being
and his best interest.” The court terminated reunification
services and set a section 366.26 hearing. The court granted
Mother monitored visits.
O. Mother Files Another Section 388 Petition
Mother continued visiting with Aiden. Visits took place
between 9:00 a.m. and 5:00 p.m. on Saturdays at the
grandparents’ home and were monitored by MGM. In various
status reports, DCFS stated: “Mother indicated that Aiden can
be ‘difficult’ and she expressed that ‘Aiden doesn’t know what he
wants.’ Mother stated that she wants what is best for Aiden and
23
if Aiden does not want to return home and [wants to] stay with
maternal great aunt then ‘he can do what he wants.’ Mother
stated that Aiden can be a ‘liar’ sometimes.”
In February 2024, Father was arrested.
A CSW monitored a visit with Aiden in April 2024. Mother
was appropriate and actively interacted with him. However, at a
July 2024 visit, Mother spent most of the time speaking with the
CSW about issues unrelated to the case, despite the CSW’s
“frequent attempts to redirect mother to focus on the child.”
When Aiden appeared bored, Mother bought him breakfast and
gave him her phone. However, after an hour, Aiden asked
Mother if he could get his hairline fixed. Mother agreed and
interacted with Aiden during the walk to the barbershop.
The CSW observed that Mother seemed to be suffering
from paranoia. She “often tells CSW that she is being
harassed/followed by father’s ex-girlfriend and/or neighbors.
Mother would tell CSW incidents that occurred while she is
running errands. Mother indicated that father’s ex-girlfriend
wants to fight her and ‘hangs out’ around areas that mother
frequents.” In July, Mother and the CSW were walking out of
Mother’s apartment building when a neighbor greeted her in a
sincere and amicable manner; after the neighbor left, Mother told
the CSW, “You see they’re always watching me.” During that
visit, Mother made a comment about Father’s girlfriend “hanging
out” around the apartment building but did not respond when
Aiden said, “[I]sn’t that a homeless woman?” Two days later,
Mother texted the CSW pictures of what appeared to be a
homeless woman and said, “This is why I have cameras at my
house because she’s trying to get in.”
24
In August 2024, Mother filed another section 388 petition,
again asking the court to either return Aiden to her custody or
reinstate reunification services with unmonitored visits. Among
other things, Mother recognized “the Court was concerned about
Mother allowing unmonitored contacting between Aid[e]n and
Father” and so, “[t]aking the Court’s concerns to heart, Mother
has had no contact with Father for over six months.” Mother also
continued to participate in therapy and other life-skills and
parenting programs.
P. The Court Denies the Petition and Appoints a
Legal Guardian
DCFS’s opposition to Mother’s petition noted that in mid-
September 2024, while a CSW was transporting Aiden to a visit
with Mother, Aiden told the CSW he enjoyed visiting with Mother
but was bothered when MGM yelled at Mother, or was rude or
“mean” to her. Aiden added that a few weeks ago, while he was
visiting, Mother, MGM, and the maternal uncle had a “fight,”
resulting in Mother locking herself in the bathroom because
MGM was yelling at her. Aiden was in the living room playing
games. The maternal uncle then became upset that Mother
would not exit the bathroom and began banging on and hitting
the door while cursing at Mother to open the door. Mother
refused and waited until the uncle returned to the bedroom.
Aiden also revealed Mother had been accepting calls from
Father from jail during Aiden’s visits. Because Father did not
call the last Saturday, Mother called the jail to ask about him
and learned Father was being punished and thus was not allowed
to make calls. Aiden said Father asked about school and
promised to buy him presents after he was released.
25
During the visit to which the CSW was transporting Aiden,
Mother spent most of the time talking with the CSW about
Father’s girlfriend, issues she had with MGM, and issues with
the Regional Center.
When the CSW asked Mother about the incident with the
maternal uncle, Mother admitted the uncle had “gotten violent
towards her,” but had not “hit her.” After confirming she had
locked herself in the bathroom, she said: “Aiden stayed in the
living room because he was dumb. He should have come inside
the bathroom.” When asked about contacting Father, Mother
“quickly denied the claim” and accused Aiden of lying.
The court heard Mother’s section 388 petition in October
2024. Mother’s counsel asked the court to grant it, noting Mother
was still participating in services even though she was no longer
required to do so. Counsel added that Aiden and Mother shared
a close bond, and there were no safety concerns when the two
were together. Aiden’s counsel acknowledged the bond between
Aiden and Mother but stated he would be “submitting on the
Department’s recommendation for both 388 and 26 hearing[s]
today.” DCFS’s counsel opposed Mother’s request, arguing that
despite Mother’s ongoing participation in programs, she still had
problems controlling her emotions and anger. Counsel also
pointed to the incidents with the maternal uncle and Mother’s
allowing Aiden to have unmonitored contact with Father as well
as the fact that she accused Aiden of lying when confronted about
the contact with Father. Finally, DCFS voiced concerns with
Mother’s apparent paranoia.
The court denied Mother’s petition “for the reasons set
forth by [DCFS’s counsel],” stating it was “particularly concerned
for those reasons.” The court appointed maternal great-aunt
26
Julia as Aiden’s legal guardian, and granted Mother a minimum
of nine hours of unmonitored visits with Aiden, on the condition
that MGM, the maternal uncle, and Father were not present
(telephonically or otherwise) at the visits.11
Mother timely appealed.
DISCUSSION
“Section 388 allows a parent to petition to change, modify,
or set aside any previous juvenile court order. (§ 388, subd. (a).)
‘The petitioner has the burden of showing by a preponderance of
the evidence (1) that there is new evidence or a change of
circumstances and (2) that the proposed modification would be in
the best interests of the child.’ ” (In re J.M. (2020) 50
Cal.App.5th 833, 845.) “We review a juvenile court’s denial of a
section 388 petition for abuse of discretion, and review its factual
findings for substantial evidence.” (Id. at p. 846.) “A court
exceeds the limits of legal discretion if its determination is
arbitrary, capricious or patently absurd. The appropriate test is
whether the court exceeded the bounds of reason.” (In re L.W.
(2019) 32 Cal.App.5th 840, 851, citing In re Stephanie M. (1994) 7
Cal.4th 295, 318–319.) “ ‘ “When two or more inferences can
reasonably be deduced from the facts, the reviewing court has no
11 In the court’s original minute order, Mother was granted
“Monitored visits, minimum 3 times per week for 3 hours per
visit. Father is not to monitor Mother’s visits.” Two minutes
later, another minute order was entered, differing only in that it
granted Mother “Unmonitored visits, minimum 9 hours per week.
Father, Maternal Grandmother, and Maternal Uncle are not to
be present during visits.”
27
authority to substitute its decision for that of the trial court.” ’ ”
(Stephanie M., at p. 319.)
A. The Court Did Not Err in Finding No Changed
Circumstances
“To support a section 388 petition, the change in
circumstances must be substantial.” (In re Ernesto R. (2014) 230
Cal.App.4th 219, 223.) Mother argues she demonstrated such a
substantial change because, after the court’s order terminating
reunification services, “[s]he completed individual and conjoint
therapy, continued participating in specialized parenting and
adaptive living services.”
When the court terminated Mother’s reunification services
for the second time, it pointed to Mother’s “pattern” of blaming
other people and events rather than taking accountability for the
abuse Aiden suffered, her accusations that Aiden lied when he
recounted the abuse, her admonition to Aiden not to tell the
school if she scolded him, and her seeming indifference to
whether Aiden lived with Julia or her. Additionally, as Mother
recognizes, the court concluded she “had not adequately
demonstrated protective capacity following the November 2023
incident” in which Father told Aiden to drink beer when he was
thirsty.
DCFS does not deny Mother continued engaging in classes
and programs designed to help ameliorate her parenting issues.
But, despite Mother’s participation, nothing in the record
demonstrates a substantial change in her behavior. When
Mother and the maternal uncle got into a “fight” where he “got
violent towards her,” Mother again did not demonstrate
protective capacity. Instead of ensuring Aiden was safe, she
locked herself in the bathroom, leaving Aiden in the living room.
28
When later asked about Aiden, instead of claiming he was safe in
the living room or expressing remorse for not taking him with
her, she ridiculed him as “dumb” for not joining her in the
bathroom. Mother also told the court she had no contact with
Father for six months as of the time she filed her second section
388 petition. Yet Aiden later informed the CSW that Mother had
been accepting calls from Father during Aiden’s visits. When the
CSW asked Mother about being in contact with Father, Mother
accused Aiden of lying.12 And she expressed that if Aiden wanted
to live with Julia, “he can do what he wants.” These statements
and actions amply support a conclusion that Mother failed to
demonstrate a substantial change in circumstances.
Mother also complains the court “failed to consider the role
of her intellectual disability in both her challenges and her
progress.” But she does not explain how her intellectual
disability prevented her from knowing she should protect her son.
Nothing in the record suggests Mother’s intellectual disability
prevented her from understanding Aiden should not drink beer at
ten years old, or understanding the court was concerned with
Father having unmonitored contact with Aiden. There is no link
between her intellectual disability and her being untruthful with
the court and DCFS about whether she was in contact with
12 While Mother attempts to argue that DCFS inaccurately
portrayed Father as a danger to Aiden, Mother obtained a
restraining order against Father both for abusing her and for
abusing Aiden. Additionally, both the paternal aunt and
paternal grandmother attested to Father’s extensive substance
abuse problem, and Father offered a 10-year-old boy a beer when
he said he was thirsty. We do not agree with Mother that DCFS’s
“expressions of concern that father presented a serious danger to
Aiden were somewhat overstated.”
29
Father. When confronted about these incidents, Mother did not
express confusion about what she had done wrong—Mother lied.
In fact, not only did Mother lie, Mother also accused Aiden of
lying to cover up her own actions.13
In short, on this record, we hold the court acted well within
the bounds of reason in concluding that, despite Mother’s
continued participation in programs, the circumstances
surrounding the December 2023 termination of reunification
services had not substantially changed.
B. The Court Did Not Err in Finding Mother’s
Request Was Not in Aiden’s Best Interest
“[W]hen a child has been placed in foster care because of
parental neglect or incapacity, after an extended period of foster
care, it is within the court’s discretion to decide that a child’s
interest in stability has come to outweigh the natural parent’s
interest in the care, custody and companionship of the child.” (In
re Jasmon O. (1994) 8 Cal.4th 398, 419.) “As to the best interests
element, after the court has bypassed or terminated reunification
services and set the matter for a section 366.26 hearing, the focus
of the case shifts from the parents’ interest in the care, custody,
and companionship of the child to the needs of the child for
13 Nor is Mother’s citation to In re K.C. (2012) 212
Cal.App.4th 323 well taken. There, the appellate court held that
the father’s paranoia did not “relieve the Department of its duty
to tailor services to address that condition, its effects, or both.”
(Id. at p. 333.) Here, in contrast, there is no suggestion that
Mother was provided with services that were inappropriate to her
because of her intellectual disability.
30
permanency and stability.” (In re N.F. (2021) 68 Cal.App.5th
112, 121.)
Mother argues that granting her additional reunification
services would have been in Aiden’s best interest because he was
bonded with Mother, enjoyed his visits with her, and wanted to
reunify. Mother claims there was no indication that granting
further services would have undermined Aiden’s placement with
Julia or that Aiden was experiencing distress due to a lack of
permanency.
Even if Aiden did not express distress regarding a lack of
permanency, and even if Julia would have been willing to
continue caring for Aiden, “[i]n assessing the best interests of the
child, ‘a primary consideration . . . is the goal of assuring stability
and continuity.’ ” (In re Mickel O. (2011) 197 Cal.App.4th 586,
616.) And although it is undisputed that Aiden mostly enjoyed
his visits with Mother and had expressed his desire to reunify
with her, it is also undisputed that when he did reunite with her,
DCFS received several referrals alleging physical abuse, Mother
frequently expressed frustration at how Aiden allegedly treated
her, and the court was ultimately required to remove Aiden for
his own safety. Moreover, the court’s denial of Mother’s petition
did not prevent Mother from continuing to visit with Aiden. And,
considering Aiden’s permanent plan was legal guardianship and
not adoption, Mother was not foreclosed from regaining custody
of Aiden if she could demonstrate that circumstances had
changed and she could safely care for him.
31
Therefore, we hold the juvenile court did not abuse its
discretion in finding that granting Mother’s petition was not in
Aiden’s best interest.14
DISPOSITION
The court’s orders are affirmed.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED
M. KIM, J.
We concur:
ROTHSCHILD, P. J.
BENDIX, J.
14 Mother’s only argument that the court erred in its order
under section 366.26 is that it was based on the improper denial
of her section 388 petition. Because Mother fails to demonstrate
the denial of her section 388 petition was erroneous, her
challenge to the court’s section 366.26 order fails as well.
32
Ti chiedi come si applica questo testo alla tua situazione?
Consulenza gratuita, senza impegno
Descrivi la tua situazione. Il nostro team ti ricontatterà via e-mail per la tua consulenza.
Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude
Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.