CourtListener 10661805•People v. Carruthers CA5
Testo completo
Filed 8/27/25 P. v. Carruthers CA5
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FIFTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
THE PEOPLE,
F088063
Plaintiff and Respondent,
(Super. Ct. No. BF171176A)
v.
MARVELL CARRUTHERS, OPINION
Defendant and Appellant.
THE COURT*
APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of Kern County. John D.
Oglesby, Judge.
Marvell Carruthers, in pro. per.; and Francine R. Tone, under appointment by the
Court of Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Office of the Attorney General, Sacramento, California, for Plaintiff and
Respondent.
-ooOoo-
* Before Hill, P. J., Franson, J. and Peña, J.
Appellant Marvell Carruthers appeals the denial of his request for resentencing
after a hearing to determine whether he was entitled to relief under Penal Code
section 1172.6.1 Appellant’s counsel initially filed a brief requesting this court
independently review the record in line with principles defined in People v. Delgadillo
(2022) 14 Cal.5th 216 (Delgadillo). Appellant then submitted a separate supplemental
letter brief raising points he wishes to have reviewed. For the reasons set forth below, we
affirm.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
This is the second time an appeal from appellant’s petition for resentencing has
reached this court. We incorporate our factual and procedural background from
appellant’s first appeal (People v. Carruthers (June 22, 2022, F082407) [nonpub. opn.]),
which is repeated in relevant part below. We then provide additional factual and
procedural information following remand.
On March 9, 2018, an information was filed alleging Robert Williams and
appellant had committed attempted murder, attempted robbery, assault with a firearm, and
various other related firearm and gang offenses and enhancements. Appellant eventually
pleaded no contest to attempted murder and a misdemeanor gang offense, along with
certain firearm enhancements. Appellant was sentenced to a term of 15 years’
imprisonment.
On November 10, 2020, appellant petitioned for resentencing under former
section 1170.95 (now § 1172.6).2 The trial court denied appellant’s petition, concluding
appellant was ineligible for relief under the law.
1 Undesignated statutory references are to the Penal Code.
2 Effective June 30, 2022, section 1170.95 was renumbered section 1172.6, with no
change in text (Stats. 2022, ch. 58, § 10).
2.
In the first appeal, this court remanded for further proceedings based on a change
in the law that permitted those convicted of attempted murder to petition for resentencing.
Upon remand, the trial court found a prima facia showing for relief had been made and
issued an order to show cause.
The evidence presented at the hearing included a video of the event that was
summarized by the trial court. This video showed that appellant, wearing a yellow
reflective vest, and Williams, wearing an orange reflective vest, were let into a marijuana
dispensary by an armed security guard. Once inside, appellant pulled out a gun, and a
struggle ensued where shots were fired. The security guard fled from the building.
Appellant and Williams took cover in the building, and appellant fired in the direction the
security guard had fled. Appellant and Williams appeared to be injured by shots fired in
their direction and eventually fled from the building. Additional testimony from the
preliminary hearing showed that several 9-millimeter shell casings were found outside
the building, but none were found inside, and damage was found to the inside and outside
of the building, as well as to the building’s door. In addition, during the preliminary
hearing, the prosecutor confirmed that the only theory they were proceeding on to support
the attempted murder charge was actual intent to kill.
Only appellant was initially charged with personally discharging a firearm, while
Williams was charged with being a principal in the offense where another principal
discharged a firearm. As noted above, appellant eventually pleaded no contest to
attempted murder with an enhancement under section 12022.5, subdivision (a). Counsel
stipulated to a factual basis for the plea based on the preliminary hearing transcript.
Based on these facts, the trial court entered an order denying appellant’s petition.
The order first provided a detailed summary of the factual and procedural history of the
case, then outlined the evidence the trial court considered,3 defined the burden of proof
3 Appellant’s letter does not challenge the scope of the evidence considered. Upon
review, this court perceives no error in how the trial court limited the admissibility of the
3.
for the proceedings, and reviewed relevant legal principles. The trial court made factual
findings from each relevant source of evidence and then several determinations, including
that appellant was the actual shooter, acted with an intent to kill, and was a major
participant acting with reckless indifference to human life. Based on these findings, the
trial court concluded appellant was not eligible for relief because he was not being held
liable based on a natural and probable consequences theory and because the evidence
showed beyond a reasonable doubt that he was the person who engaged in a shootout
with the victim.
This appeal timely followed.
DISCUSSION
Appellant claims in his letter brief there is “no factual evidence that fits the criteria
of attempted murder” in this case. Across four points, appellant argues that he did not
fire a weapon, the victim was not injured, his youth at the time of the event precludes a
finding of intent, and his plea bargain was affected by the length of the sentences he was
allegedly facing.
Applicable Law
In Delgadillo, our Supreme Court set out the principles to follow when counsel
finds no arguable issues for appeal following denial of a resentencing request under
section 1172.6: “When appointed counsel finds no arguable issues to be pursued on
appeal: (1) counsel should file a brief informing the court of that determination,
including a concise recitation of the facts bearing on the denial of the petition; and (2) the
court should send, with a copy of counsel’s brief, notice to the defendant, informing the
defendant of the right to file a supplemental letter or brief and that if no letter or brief is
filed within 30 days, the court may dismiss the matter. [Citations.]
preliminary hearing transcript and considered the remaining evidence presented. (See
§ 1172.6, subd. (d)(3) [excluding reliance on hearsay evidence presented at a preliminary
hearing].)
4.
“If the defendant subsequently files a supplemental brief or letter, the Court of
Appeal is required to evaluate the specific arguments presented in that brief and to issue a
written opinion. The filing of a supplemental brief or letter does not compel an
independent review of the entire record to identify unraised issues.” (Delgadillo, supra,
14 Cal.5th at pp. 231–232.) “While it is wholly within the court’s discretion, the Court of
Appeal is not barred from conducting its own independent review of the record in any
individual section 1172.6 appeal.” (Id. at p. 232.)
A “person convicted of … attempted murder under the natural and probable
consequences doctrine … may file a petition” for resentencing if certain criteria are met.
(§ 1172.6, subd. (a).) “At the hearing to determine whether the petitioner is entitled to
relief, the burden of proof shall be on the prosecution to prove, beyond a reasonable
doubt, that the petitioner is guilty of … attempted murder under California law as
amended by the changes to [s]ection 188 or 189 made effective January 1, 2019.”
(§ 1172.6, subd. (d)(3).) “To determine ‘whether a trial court correctly denied a
section 1172.6 petition following an evidentiary hearing, “ ‘ “we review the factual
findings for substantial evidence and the application of those facts to the statute de
novo.” ’ ” ’ ” (People v. Rodriguez (2024) 103 Cal.App.5th 451, 457 (Rodriguez).)
Appellant Could Be Convicted of Attempted Murder
The trial court’s ruling in this case essentially found that appellant was not
convicted under a natural and probable consequences theory and the evidence supported
the conclusion that appellant was the shooter in the attempted murder. Appellant’s
arguments in this appeal challenge the underlying factual claim that he actually fired any
shots in the course of the robbery and, even if he did, the evidence could not show intent
to kill. Appellant’s arguments are not germane to the issues that arise under
section 1172.6 and thus cannot demonstrate error.
The flaw in appellant’s argument is fully set forth in Rodriguez. In that case, the
facts alleged asserted that the defendant had pulled up to another car containing his ex-
5.
girlfriend and fired a single shot at the car, resulting in no damage to the car and no
injuries. (Rodriguez, supra, 103 Cal.App.5th at p. 455.) The defendant was charged with
attempted murder, waived his preliminary hearing, and accepted a plea deal to attempted
second degree murder. (Ibid.) At the evidentiary hearing for his resentencing petition,
the defendant testified that he had fired a single shot into the air but did not aim at
anyone. (Ibid.) On appeal, the defendant alleged the trial court erred when it failed to
determine whether or not he had fired shots at anyone and because there was no evidence
aside from his statement that he fired into the air, he could not have been found to have
attempted to murder anyone. (Id. at p. 456.)
In rejecting this argument, the Rodriguez court explained that a “section 1172.6
petition for resentencing is a continuation of the petitioner’s underlying criminal
proceeding [citation] and applies ‘only to attempted murders based on the natural and
probable consequences doctrine.’ ” (Rodriguez, supra, 103 Cal.App.5th at p. 457.)
Accordingly, the process “does not permit ‘ “litigant[ing] anew” any trial issues or
allowing “a petitioner to challenge any aspect of the factfinding from the original trial
that [they] wish[] to revisit.” ’ ” (Ibid.)
In such a proceeding, a “guilty plea is a judicial admission” that “ ‘amounts to an
admission of every element of the crime,’ ” conceding “ ‘ “the prosecution possesses
legally admissible evidence sufficient to prove defendant’s guilt beyond a reasonable
doubt. Accordingly, a plea of guilty waives any right to raise questions regarding the
evidence .…” ’ ” (Rodriquez, supra, 103 Cal.App.5th at p. 458.) This meant that the
defendant’s “guilty plea admitted and established generally the existence of ‘intent to
kill.’ However, it did not admit whether the intent was personal to him or imputed to
him.” (Ibid.) Once “the theoretical possibility he aided and abetted an accomplice was
eliminated by evidence received at the hearing, his guilty plea was an admission of his
personal intent to kill.” (Ibid.)
6.
The same is true in these proceedings. Appellant is challenging the underlying
facts of the offense, but the only issue in dispute given his guilty plea is whether or not
the intent to kill he previously admitted to was personal to him or imputed to him.
Appellant does not have the right to challenge his admission to factual issues such as
whether a shot was fired or whether his youth limited his capacity to form an intent to
kill, as neither of these issues are germane to whether he was convicted of an offense
under which resentencing is permissible. The record evidence shows he admitted to the
necessary intent, was the only person with a gun involved in the shooting, and could
therefore, beyond a reasonable doubt, be convicted of attempted murder even after the
changes to sections 188 and 189. As explained in Rodriguez, “In light of appellant’s
admission by plea of an intent to kill, the sole issue at the evidentiary hearing was
whether he acted alone. His guilty plea precluded the trial court from making factual
findings regarding his conduct or credibility determinations regarding his intent.”
(Rodriguez, supra, 103 Cal.App.5th at p. 459.) In the end, appellant’s challenges are to
issues related to his guilty plea and not to issues related to his resentencing petition under
section 1172.6. The court did not err in denying is petition for resentencing.
An Independent Review of the Record Shows No Error
In order to review the issues raised in appellant’s letter brief, this court was
required to undertake a thorough review of the record. Based on this, the court chose to
exercise its discretion to review the entire record for any additional error. (Delgadillo,
supra, 14 Cal.5th at p. 232 [“While it is wholly within the court’s discretion, the Court of
Appeal is not barred from conducting its own independent review of the record in any
individual section 1172.6 appeal.”].) Upon review, this court finds no potential error that
would warrant reversing the trial court’s determination that appellant is ineligible for
relief.
DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed.
7.
Ti chiedi come si applica questo testo alla tua situazione?
Consulenza gratuita, senza impegno
Descrivi la tua situazione. Il nostro team ti ricontatterà via e-mail per la tua consulenza.
Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude
Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.