Schrader v. Watts CA2/6

CourtListener 10656737Calctapp19 ago 2025

Testo completo

Filed 8/19/25 Schrader v. Watts CA2/6

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION SIX

ERIC SCHRADER, 2d Civ. No. B334308
(Super. Ct. No. 17FL-0248)
Respondent, (San Luis Obispo County)

v.

STEPHANIE WATTS,

Appellant.

Stephanie Watts (Mother) appeals an order of the family
court denying her request to modify the permanent order
granting Father sole legal and physical custody. We have
examined the record and conclude no abuse of discretion
occurred. We will affirm.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
Original Custody and Visitation Order
Mother and Father began divorce proceedings in San Luis
Obispo County in 2017. Their only child, daughter S.S., was born
in 2015. Mother returned to her hometown in Tulare County
after the couple separated. Father remained in San Luis Obispo.
A protracted custody dispute followed, driven largely by Mother’s
allegations that Father and paternal grandmother had physically
and sexually abused S.S.
The family court held a trial on custody and visitation over
17 days in 2022. It issued a 41-page statement of decision in
November of that year. The court found Mother did not prove her
allegations of abuse. “[T]he evidence supports the more likely
conclusion,” it stated, “that Mother’s statements to and actions
toward [S.S.] since the parties’ separation have caused [S.S.] to
incorrectly report incidents of sexual and physical abuse. Mother
has been persistent – in fact, relentless – in her efforts to have
the court make abuse findings against Father and Father’s
family members. It appears that Mother believes that Father is a
risk to [S.S.], so Mother has resorted to manipulating and
enlisting others – including [S.S.] – to support contrived abuse
allegations so that [S.S.] will not have unsupervised time with
Father. While the court may never know what occurred between
Mother and [S.S.] or Father and [S.S.], Mother’s actions have
severely damaged Mother’s credibility and are harmful to [S.S.]’s
current and long-term well-being.”
The family court entered judgment in March of 2023.1
Father received sole legal and physical custody. The court
required a professional supervisor to attend Mother’s visits with
S.S. It limited her contact with S.S. during non-custodial time to
written, prescreened communications. It specified Mother “shall
not accompany the minor child to the bathroom, [and] that
[Mother] shall not look under, take off or change child’s clothes
during visits.” It directed Father to ensure S.S. attended “regular

1 We take judicial notice of the March 1, 2023 judgment on

our own motion. (Evid. Code, §§ 452, subd. (c), 459.)

2
health care appointments” and “therapy until released . . . by the
therapist.” Mother did not appeal the judgment.2
Mother’s Request for Order Denying S.S.’s Move
and Modifying Custody and Visitation
Father told Mother in April of 2023 that he intended to
move from San Luis Obispo County to Ventura County, where he
planned to work for a business owned by his wife’s family.
Mother objected. She filed a request, later amended, for an order
denying the move and modifying the judgment to award her sole
legal and physical custody. In her supporting declaration,
Mother questioned Father’s motives in choosing to move, and
stated that moving would make visiting S.S. more difficult and
expensive. Mother also criticized the family court’s custody and
visitation findings supporting the judgment, especially those
relating to her allegations of physical and sexual abuse. She
alleged “significant changes in circumstances” required a change
in custody.
The Family Court Grants Father’s Move Request
and Denies Mother’s Request to Modify
The family court bifurcated mother’s requests. It received
testimony from Mother, maternal grandmother, Father and
Father’s wife on July 26, 2023 on the issue of whether moving to
Ventura would be detrimental to S.S. It granted the move
request. It then ordered the parties to mediate related custody
and visitation issues.
The parties returned to court on December 4, 2023 after
failing to resolve any issues in mediation. The family court

2 Mother did appeal the family court’s order awarding

Father spousal support. We affirmed the award in a prior
opinion. (Schrader v. Watts (Feb. 20, 2025, B330648) [nonpub.
opn.].)

3
announced it would first decide the “threshold issue of whether or
not there’s a material change of circumstances shown by [Mother]
in order for the Court to entertain a modification of custody and
visitation.” Mother represented herself. She testified and argued
first, followed by Father’s counsel and minor’s counsel. The
family court announced its ruling from the bench. It explained
that each issue raised by Mother was previously adjudicated at
trial in 2022. The court denied Mother’s request, stating: “What
that means is that things are unchanged, that there’s a lack of a
material change of circumstance.” Written findings and order
were filed on April 23, 2024. Mother appealed the December 4
decision.3
DISCUSSION
Father did not file a respondent’s brief. Regardless, it
remains Mother’s “affirmative burden to show error.” (In re
Marriage of Davies (1983) 143 Cal.App.3d 851, 854.) We review
custody and visitation orders for abuse of discretion. (In re
Marriage of Burgess (1996) 13 Cal.4th 25, 32.)
Mother contends her due process rights were violated
because the court refused to give her an adequate hearing on her
request to modify custody and visitation. We disagree.
Family Code section 217 mandates that the court receive
“live, competent testimony that is relevant and within the scope
of the hearing” at a hearing on any family law motion absent a
stipulation of the parties or a finding of good cause. (Fam. Code,

3 Mother appealed before the family court filed its written

findings and order. We exercised our discretion to treat her
premature notice of appeal as timely in our order dated July 12,
2024. (Cal. Rules of Court, rule 8.104(d)(2).) This notice
identifies the family court’s December 4 decision as the appealed
judgment. It does not refer to the July 26 move-away decision.

4
§ 217, subd. (a).) A party seeking to present live testimony from
a witness other than a party must “prior to the hearing, file and
serve a witness list with a brief description of the anticipated
testimony.” (Id., subd. (c).) A court finding good cause not to
receive live testimony “shall state its reasons for the finding on
the record or in writing.” (Id. subd., (b).)
Mother testified at the modification hearing about her
concerns over Father’s care for S.S. Mother stated S.S.’s
maternal grandmother and other witnesses were present to
testify about her concerns. When asked if she was finished,
Mother stated, “I request that the Court hears the rest of the
witnesses on my modification of custody.” The court did not
respond directly to this request but explained that Mother had
not shown a material change in circumstance. It then denied her
request to modify custody or visitation.
Mother was not entitled to present any additional live
testimony because she did not file a witness list or summarize
anticipated testimony as required under Family Code section
217, subdivision (c). Mother also forfeited any right she may
have had to cross-examine Father by failing to serve him with a
notice to appear pursuant to Code of Civil Procedure section
1987, subdivision (b). (In re Marriage of George & Deamon (2019)
35 Cal.App.5th 476, 483.) The family court did not abuse its
discretion in not allowing additional live testimony.
To the extent Mother also contends there was insufficient
evidence to support the court’s order, Mother waived that
contention by failing to summarize the evidence favorable to the
court’s order. (Brockey v. Moore (2003) 107 Cal.App.4th 86, 96
[“Failure to set forth [all of] the material evidence on an issue
waives a claim of insufficiency of the evidence”].)
We would affirm even if Mother had not waived. No abuse
of discretion occurred. Substantial evidence supports the family

5
court’s finding that Mother did not make a sufficient showing of
changed circumstances. “[A] party seeking to modify a
permanent custody order can do so only if he or she demonstrates
a significant change of circumstances justifying a modification.”
(Montenegro v. Diaz (2001) 26 Cal.4th 249, 256.)
Mother devoted a significant part of her moving papers and
testimony to the same allegations of abuse and neglect the family
court considered after a lengthy trial. She does the same in her
briefing on appeal. The post-judgment circumstances she
describes, e.g., S.S.’s upper respiratory issues, sunburns, and
school difficulties, echo concerns she raised at trial about Father’s
alleged inattention to S.S.’s wellbeing. Her ongoing concerns,
without more, do not constitute a significant change of
circumstances justifying a modification of custody or visitation.
We have reviewed Mother’s other contentions and find
them to be without merit.
DISPOSITION
The trial court’s findings and order dated April 23, 2024,
denying Mother’s request to modify custody and visitation is
affirmed. Respondent did not appear and shall not recover costs
on appeal.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED.

CODY, J.

We concur:

GILBERT, P. J. BALTODANO, J.

6
Erin Childs, Judge
Superior Court County of San Luis Obispo
______________________________

Stephanie Watts, in pro per, for Appellant.
No appearance for Respondent.

7

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.