People v. Ortiz CA3

CourtListener 10654897Calctapp15 ago 2025

Testo completo

Filed 8/15/25 P. v. Ortiz CA3
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED

California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
THIRD APPELLATE DISTRICT
(Yolo)
----

THE PEOPLE,

Plaintiff and Respondent, C100972

v. (Super. Ct. No. CR202100731)

ESTEBAN ANTONIO ORTIZ,

Defendant and Appellant.

During the relevant time period, defendant Esteban Antonio Ortiz worked as a
security guard at Woodland Memorial Hospital. In August 2020, he and other security

1
guards believed the victim, J.S., was obstructing the hospital ambulance bay and moved
the victim forcefully to a nearby sidewalk. J.S. said he was having a seizure. A struggle
ensued in which J.S. said he was punched, kicked, and thrown to the concrete.
Following a bench trial, the trial court found defendant guilty of dependent adult
abuse under circumstances likely to produce great bodily harm, assault by means of force
likely to produce great bodily injury, and battery. The trial court placed defendant on
formal probation for two years.
Defendant now contends there is insufficient evidence to support the conviction
for dependent adult abuse. He argues the trial court should have granted defendant’s
motion for judgment of acquittal. In addition, defendant contends there is insufficient
evidence to support the conviction for assault by means of force likely to produce great
bodily injury. He argues we should modify the conviction from felony assault to simple
assault and remand for resentencing.
We conclude sufficient evidence supports the convictions. We will affirm the
judgment.
BACKGROUND
The victim, J.S., had suffered a traumatic brain injury in 2013 as the result of an
accident. He had difficulty with concentration and short-term memory, and used coping
mechanisms to remember things, such as recording conversations. Although he lived by
himself and drove, his family helped him with chores and medications. He had about
14 different medications in August 2020, including for seizures.
J.S. experienced epileptic and focal seizures. Lights, stress and anxiety could
cause seizures and make them worse. Symptoms of his epileptic seizures included falling
to the ground, losing control of his bladder, drooling, and blowing spit out of his mouth.
Although he could not tell when he was about to have an epileptic seizure, he
could tell when he was getting a focal seizure. He could control a focal seizure by
putting a cold towel over his head and neck and staying in a cool, dark and quiet place

2
for 15 minutes. His focal seizures started with muscle twitching in his legs, eye blinking,
and feeling warm in the back of his neck and head. His focal seizure could develop into
an epileptic seizure if not controlled.
On August 1, 2020, J.S. went to Woodland Memorial Hospital to obtain pain
medication. But he became increasingly anxious as he waited in the waiting room.
J.S. recorded what happened on his cell phone, and the audio recording was played at
trial.
On the recording, J.S. informed hospital security guard Brandon Binford he had to
go outside because the lights in the waiting room were bothering him. J.S. told Binford
he might get a seizure. Moaning and groaning sounds can be heard on the audio
recording after J.S. spoke with Binford. According to J.S., those sounds were vocal tics
or related to J.S.’s Tourette’s Syndrome. J.S. left the waiting room and went outside and
knelt down in the first dark spot he found, feeling dizzy and unable to walk. He was in
the hospital’s ambulance bay.
On the recording, a man asked what was wrong. J.S. requested a wet towel.
When a woman asked what was going on, J.S. said he needed a wet towel. A man
summoned J.S., telling him he was in the middle of the ambulance bay. J.S. and another
witness identified the male voice as that of Binford. When a woman inquired about
the circumstances, J.S. explained he was having a focal seizure and needed a wet towel.
A witness identified the female voice as possibly that of a hospital employee.
J.S. saw a cooler, removed some water bottles, poured water on his shirt, and put
the shirt on his neck. Water sounds can be heard on the recording. J.S. told security
guards he needed “something fuckin’ wet” and had asked for it. A man said J.S. was
“in the middle of the road” and that J.S. was cursing at them so his pain must have gone
away. J.S. said he was having a focal seizure. A man answered that he did not care what
J.S. was having, J.S. had gone through their things and the water was not for J.S.

3
A male voice asked whether J.S. had checked in. J.S. said that he had, but
repeated that he was having a focal seizure; he explained he would have an epileptic
seizure if he did not cool down. A male voice said J.S. was not checked in anymore
because he had walked outside.
A male voice said J.S. was in the middle of the ambulance bay and had to leave.
J.S. told the guards he had to be seen immediately. A male voice said J.S. came in for
pain pills, not for a seizure, and pain pills were not a priority. J.S. yelled that he was
having a seizure. A male voice said J.S. was being loud and he should chill. J.S. asked
to be left alone for 15 minutes, saying he would have a seizure if the guards moved him.
A male voice said no because J.S. was in the middle of the ambulance bay.
Shortly thereafter, a male voice told J.S. he would be escorted off the property.
The man ordered J.S. to gather his belongings and mentioned a wheelchair. J.S. testified
that he physically could not leave at that point. He asked the guards not to touch him.
A male voice replied that J.S. seemed alright. J.S. asked if the person saw his leg.
J.S. testified that his leg was twitching.
The guards tried to put J.S. in a wheelchair and he had a seizure. According to
J.S., the guards laid him across the handles of the wheelchair and pushed the wheelchair
down the driveway as his head hit the pavement.
Groaning sounds can be heard on the recording. Defendant told J.S. to shut up and
get in the “god damn chair.” A male voice accused J.S. of spitting at his partner and said,
“get in the fuckin’ chair.” J.S. testified one of the guards hit him hard in the face with a
closed-fist punch while the other guard held his shoulder and he was hit again when one
of the guards accused him of spitting on his partner. J.S. testified he was having a
seizure, his movements were involuntary, and he did not spit at anyone. He could be
heard groaning and making sounds of pain on the recording and being wheeled away
while male voices cursed at him. Then a male voice said something about a “nice little
bed.” J.S. testified the guards dumped him on the sidewalk.

4
J.S. testified the guards kicked him, he was “out of it,” and he was about to have
another seizure. On the recording, a male voice told J.S. to keep that spitting to himself,
and a male voice said something about getting punched in the face. Male voices
suggested J.S. had been faking a seizure. J.S. testified a guard got on top of him,
punched him, and held his wrist down, while another guard kicked him. He said one of
the guards cut off his hospital wristband. J.S. had another seizure and convulsed on the
sidewalk, hitting his head.
J.S. later called 911 to report that he had been assaulted. He had a bump on his
forehead, bruises, cuts, and scrapes. Responding police officer Marcuss Hernandez
testified that J.S. appeared disoriented. The officer interviewed J.S. and concluded J.S.
had some type of disability. The officer believed J.S. had a speech impediment or
Tourette’s Syndrome. A video recording of the officer interview with J.S. was played at
trial. The officer determined defendant was one of the security guards who interacted
with J.S.
Woodland Memorial Hospital security guard Elias Alexander testified at trial.
He helped defendant and Binford get J.S. in a wheelchair. He testified that J.S.’s body
was clenched up, his eyes were closed, his arms were crossed in a “mummy position,”
and he had a smirk on his face. The smirk made Alexander think J.S. was acting
intentionally. According to Alexander, defendant and Binford tilted the wheelchair to get
J.S. to stand up, but J.S. fell forward out of the wheelchair onto the sidewalk. Alexander
did not see anyone kick or punch J.S. He did not see J.S. spit, but he heard Binford say
that J.S. spat on him as they moved J.S. to the sidewalk.
Defendant provided the following account at trial. He went to the emergency
room (ER) entrance when he got a call from Binford. Defendant saw J.S. on his knees
with water on his head. J.S. was agitated and aggressive, and his speech was
unintelligible at times. Defendant thought J.S. was under the influence of a narcotic
or alcohol. Defendant did not observe any visual cues of a seizure. J.S.’s eyes were open

5
and he was able to speak with defendant. His legs were relaxed and he did not lose
consciousness. According to defendant, an ER technician tried to assess J.S., but J.S.
refused to speak and was aggressive with the technician. Defendant said the technician
concluded J.S. was not having a seizure and could be discharged. Defendant
acknowledged, however, that the alleged interaction with the technician was not on the
audio recording.
Defendant said he and Binford grabbed J.S.’s arms, put him in a wheelchair, and
moved him to the sidewalk. J.S. was not placed across the wheelchair handles, he sat in
the wheelchair. Defendant testified that J.S. spat at Binford. Defendant believed the
spitting was intentional because J.S.’s eyes were open, he made an effort to collect spit in
his mouth before he spat, and his spit came out forcefully. In response, defendant
forcefully placed his open palm on J.S.’s jaw and moved his face away to prevent J.S.
from spitting at them.
According to defendant, Alexander assisted in moving J.S. J.S.’s head did not hit
the pavement as they wheeled him. Defendant and Binford removed J.S. from the
wheelchair by picking him up by his arms and placing him on his knees on the sidewalk.
Defendant did not dump J.S. out of the wheelchair and he did not punch or kick J.S.
He added that Binford did not punch J.S. Defendant believed J.S. deliberately hit his
head against the concrete. Defendant and Binford placed J.S. in a landscape area after
defendant hit his head.
Defendant testified that he cut off J.S.’s wristband. Although not reflected on the
recording, defendant said he asked J.S. for permission to cut off the wristband and J.S.
nodded yes. J.S. eventually got up by himself and walked away without stumbling.
The trial court found J.S.’s testimony credible. It found defendant guilty of
dependent adult abuse under circumstances likely to produce great bodily harm

6
(Pen. Code, § 368, subd. (b)(1) – count 1),1 assault by means of force likely to produce
great bodily injury (§ 245, subd. (a)(4) – count 2), and battery (§ 242 – count 3). It found
true allegations that the crime involved great violence, great bodily harm, or other acts
disclosing a high degree of cruelty, viciousness or callousness; that the victim was
particularly vulnerable; and that defendant took advantage of a position of trust or
confidence. The trial court placed defendant on formal probation for two years.
DISCUSSION
I
Defendant contends there is insufficient evidence to support his conviction
for dependent adult abuse. He claims the trial court should have granted his motion
for judgment of acquittal.
After the People rested their case, defendant moved for judgment of acquittal
under section 1118. He claimed he did not know J.S. was a dependent adult. The trial
court denied the motion, finding from the evidence presented, including all reasonable
inferences, that there was sufficient evidence of each element of the offense.
In reviewing a section 1118 ruling, we review the whole record as it stood at
the end of the prosecution case “ ‘in the light most favorable to the judgment . . . to
determine whether it discloses substantial evidence -- that is, evidence which is
reasonable, credible, and of solid value -- such that a reasonable trier of fact could
find the defendant guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.’ ” (People v. Ringo (2005)
134 Cal.App.4th 870, 880; see People v. Zamudio (2008) 43 Cal.4th 327, 357, 360, fn. 17
(Zamudio).) We presume every fact in support of the judgment that the trier of fact could
reasonably have deduced from the evidence. (Zamudio, at p. 357.) “ ‘Conflicts and even
testimony [that] is subject to justifiable suspicion do not justify the reversal of a

1 Undesignated statutory references are to the Penal Code.

7
judgment, for it is the exclusive province of the trial judge or jury to determine the
credibility of a witness and the truth or falsity of the facts upon which a determination
depends. [Citation.] We resolve neither credibility issues nor evidentiary conflicts; we
look for substantial evidence. [Citation.]’ ” (Ibid.)
Section 368 provides that when someone knows or reasonably should know that
another person is a dependent adult, it is unlawful to willfully cause the dependent adult
to suffer, or to inflict upon the dependent adult unjustifiable physical pain or mental
suffering, under circumstances or conditions likely to produce great bodily harm or death.
(§ 368, subd. (b)(1); Stats. 2018, ch. 70, § 3.) A “dependent adult” is a person between
the ages of 18 and 64 with physical or mental limitations that restrict the person’s ability
to carry out normal activities or protect his or her rights, including a person with physical
or developmental disabilities. (§ 368, subd. (h).) The victim need not be incapable of
carrying out normal activities or of protecting his or her rights; it is sufficient if the
victim’s ability to do so is limited in some significant way. (People v. Matye (2008)
158 Cal.App.4th 921, 925 (Matye).)
Viewing the evidence presented by the People in their case-in-chief in the light
most favorable to the trial court’s decision, we conclude there is substantial evidence that
defendant reasonably should have known J.S. had physical or mental limitations that
restricted his ability to carry out normal activities or protect his rights. The audio
recording of J.S.’s encounter with defendant and Binford showed J.S. made sounds that
were verbal tics or related to Tourette’s Syndrome. Officer Hernandez testified J.S.
exhibited verbal tics. The officer believed J.S. had some sort of disability. J.S. testified
his leg had been twitching during the encounter with the security guards. On the
recording, J.S. asked if the guard saw J.S.’s leg. J.S. repeatedly told the guards he was
having a focal seizure and would have an epileptic seizure if he did not cool down.
J.S. testified he had an epileptic seizure when the guards grabbed him. The trial court
was able to observe J.S. on a body camera video and at trial, and it found J.S. credible.

8
(Matye, supra, 158 Cal.App.4th at p. 925 [considering the trier of fact’s ability to
personally observe a person in determining whether the person was a dependent adult].)
On this record, the trial judge could have reasonably found beyond a reasonable doubt
that defendant should have known from J.S.’s conduct and statements that J.S. had
physical or mental limitations that limited his ability to carry out normal activities or
protect his rights. Sufficient evidence supports the dependent adult abuse conviction.
II
In addition, defendant contends there is insufficient evidence to support the
conviction for assault by means of force likely to produce great bodily injury. He argues
we should modify the conviction from felony assault to simple assault and remand for
resentencing. Our standard of review for a sufficiency of the evidence challenge is the
same as for a challenge to the denial of a motion for judgment of acquittal. (Zamudio,
supra, 43 Cal.4th at pp. 357, 360, fn. 17; People v. Leonard (2014) 228 Cal.App.4th 465,
485-486.)
Section 245, subdivision (a)(4) proscribes “assault upon the person of another by
any means of force likely to produce great bodily injury.” “ ‘[L]ikely’ means more than
‘a mere possibility.’ [Citation.] Great bodily injury ‘means a significant or substantial
physical injury.’ [Citation.] Significant or substantial injury is more than a moderate
harm.” (People v. Medellin (2020) 45 Cal.App.5th 519, 527-528 (Medellin).) Whether
the defendant used force likely to produce great bodily injury turns on the force actually
used and not the force that could have been used. (Id. at p. 527.) The use of hands or
fists alone may support a section 245, subdivision (a)(4) conviction. (People v. Aguilar
(1997) 16 Cal.4th 1023, 1028; People v. Tallman (1945) 27 Cal.2d 209, 212.) When a
section 245, subdivision (a) charge is based on the use of hands or fists, we look at the
force of the impact, the manner in which it was used, and the circumstances under which
the force was applied to determine whether the force used would be likely to cause great
bodily injury. (Medellin, at p. 528.)

9
J.S. testified that defendant and Binford punched and kicked him. He said a guard
hit him hard in the face with a closed-fist punch. On the recording, J.S. is heard saying,
“Ow. You punched me.” He can then be heard groaning and making sounds of pain.
Defendant concedes in his appellate opening brief that J.S.’s testimony supported a
finding that defendant struck J.S. in the face with a closed fist. J.S. testified he could
not do anything because he was having a seizure. (See Medellin, supra, 45 Cal.App.5th
at p. 528 [stating that the victim was unaware the defendant was going to punch him,
increasing the likelihood it would result in great bodily injury].) Defendant denied
punching J.S., testifying that he only forcefully placed his open palm on J.S.’s jaw and
moved J.S.’s face. But toward the end of the audio recording, J.S. again said one of the
guards had punched him. Binford referenced J.S. getting punched in the face and noted
that J.S. had blood in his mouth.
J.S. identified the portions of the audio recording where the guards kicked and
punched him as his wristband was cut off. (People v. Roberts (1981) 114 Cal.App.3d
960, 965 [stating that kicking a defenseless man on the ground was unmistakably an
assault likely to produce great bodily harm].) Defendant admitted he removed J.S.’s
wristband. J.S. testified he was “black and blue” after the incident, had a hematoma on
his head and over 150 to 200 cuts and scrapes all over his body, and suffered neck and
back injuries. (Medellin, supra, 45 Cal.App.5th at p. 528 [considering the extent of the
victim’s injuries in determining whether the section 245, subdivision (a)(4) charges were
sufficiently proven]; People v. Beasley (2003) 105 Cal.App.4th 1078, 1086 [“if injuries
result, the extent of such injuries and their location are relevant facts for consideration” in
deciding a section 245, subdivision (a) charge].) Officer Hernandez testified that J.S. had
a bump on his forehead, bruises, cuts, and scrapes. J.S. said he received physical therapy
and treatment for thoracic nerve injury and needed cosmetic surgery on his forehead in
relation to the injuries he received.

10
On this record, the trial court could have reasonably found beyond a reasonable
doubt that the force defendant actually used was likely to cause J.S. great bodily injury.
DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed.

/S/
MAURO, Acting P. J.

We concur:

/S/
KRAUSE, J.

/S/
WISEMAN, J.

 Retired Associate Justice of the Court of Appeal, Fifth Appellate District, assigned
by the Chief Justice pursuant to article VI, section 6 of the California Constitution.

11

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.