In re C.N. CA4/2

CourtListener 10651479Calctapp11 ago 2025

Testo completo

Filed 8/11/25 In re C.N. CA4/2

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION TWO

In re C.N., a Person Coming Under the
Juvenile Court Law.

RIVERSIDE COUNTY DEPARTMENT
OF PUBLIC SOCIAL SERVICES, E085050

Plaintiff and Respondent, (Super.Ct.No. RIJ2200163)

v. OPINION

I.N.,

Defendant and Appellant.

APPEAL from the Superior Court of Riverside County. Mona M. Nemat, Judge.

Affirmed.

Emily Uhre, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for Defendant and

Appellant.

Minh C. Tran, County Counsel, Teresa K.B. Beecham and Julie Jarvi, Deputy

County Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.

1
Defendant and appellant, I.N. (father), filed a Welfare and Institutions Code

section 388 petition,1 which the juvenile court denied. Thereafter, the court terminated

father’s parental rights to C.N. (minor born May 2020). On appeal, father contends the

court erred in denying his petition. We affirm.

I. FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND

On February 21, 2022, officers responded to parents’ home regarding an apparent

overdose. Parents had arranged for minor to stay at the maternal grandmother’s home the

previous night. Parents and two friends went out drinking. Father awoke the next

morning to find mother’s lips blue. Mother and the female friend had both overdosed on

Fentanyl.

Officers found a crushed-up Fentanyl pill on the table and marijuana residue in the

home. The parents’ male friend was a well-known Fentanyl user. Officers confiscated a

loaded gun left in a shoebox and 50 pills of Fentanyl found in the male friend’s satchel.

Father denied using Fentanyl and did not appear to be under the influence of a

controlled substance. Father admitted to using marijuana. He declined to drug test.

During father’s interview with law enforcement, father yelled at them loudly,

called them vulgar names, threatened them, and eventually assaulted one of the officers.

Officers arrested father.

The social worker interviewed father while he was at the police station. Father

denied domestic violence between he and mother; however, the social worker confirmed

1 All further statutory references are to the Welfare and Intuitions Code unless
otherwise stated.

2
that police and personnel from plaintiff and respondent, the Riverside County Department

of Social Services (the department), had previously come to the home in response to

allegations of domestic violence.

Father said he and mother had planned to relocate to Georgia in the next couple of

weeks to be closer to his family. He planned on taking minor to Georgia in the coming

week.

Father arranged for minor to stay with the maternal grandmother while father was

in mourning. However, he was adamant that he did not want the maternal grandmother

to provide long-term care for minor.

The maternal grandmother “requested that [minor] remain in her care, stating she

has helped care for him since birth. She was on her way to court to try to file for legal

guardianship, saying she does not feel it is safe for [minor] to be in the father’s care, as he

has violent explosive outbursts. She stated he threatened to kill the maternal grandmother

and other maternal relatives on February 21, 2022, if they kept his son from him. The

father allowed [minor] to be in the maternal grandmother’s care only short term.”

“The maternal grandmother said she has been actively involved and has been the

primary caregiver, as the mother only trusted her with [minor]. The maternal

grandmother said the father’s family met [minor] when they visited them in Georgia in

February 2022, emphasizing that the father’s family is not involved. The child does not

know the paternal relatives. The maternal grandmother conveyed concern about the

father’s ability to provide adequate care and supervision, as the mother had been the

3
primary caregiver before her passing. The father did not want the responsibility of being

a caregiver/parent previously. The father loves [minor], but he did not want to be a full-

time parent, according to the maternal grandmother.”

A previous department referral dated December 4, 2021, regarding parents had

been substantiated. Officers were called to parents’ home in response to a domestic

violence incident. Parents were uncooperative with law enforcement. Officers were

called back to the home again a half-hour after they left by neighbors who heard

screaming inside parents’ home.

Mother, who had possibly been thrown out of the residence naked, left on foot.

Father was found at the residence with minor. The residence’s interior was destroyed:

“There was food thrown against the wall, the glass shower door was shattered, and there

was glass all over. Law enforcement [were] unable to determine if a crime had occurred.

Law enforcement retrieved two firearms from inside the residence[:] one registered to the

father and one unregistered rifle. The guns were taken for safekeeping. The father had

marijuana lying around the home. The mother was on probation for robbery.”

“[P]arents admitted engaging in verbal altercations due to the father sending text

messages to other women. This caused a lack of trust from the mother. She contacted

the paternal grandfather and paternal great-grandmother. As a result, the father lost

control of his anger and shattered the bathroom shower door. The parents’ one-year-old

son . . . was in a different room during the incident. However, he was at risk as he heard

4
the altercation and the parents’ actions, directly and indirectly, placed him at risk of

harm/neglect.”

On January 4, 2021, law enforcement contacted mother, who was then living

separately from father, after father went to the mother’s home demanding money, which

mother refused to give him. Father kicked down the mother’s front door causing minor

injuries to her foot. Father then went into the mother’s bedroom and grabbed minor, put

minor into a car seat, and attempted to drive off; however, law enforcement arrived about

the same time and arrested him. The department offered parents preventative services

prior to closing the referrals.

On February 23, 2022, the department took minor into protective custody and

placed him with the maternal grandmother. On February 25, 2022, the department filed a

section 300 juvenile dependency petition alleging that father had been arrested for felony

battery on a police officer (b-1), had a history of abusing controlled substances (b-2),

suffered from unresolved mental health issues (b-3), and had a history of domestic

violence (b-4). On February 28, 2022, the juvenile court detained minor.2

In the jurisdiction and disposition report filed March 16, 2022, the social worker

recommended that the court find the allegations in the petition true, remove minor from

father’s custody, and grant father reunification services. The social worker opined father

“would benefit from parenting education, anger management, substance abuse services,

domestic violence, and individual counseling.”

2 At the department and minor’s counsels’ requests, father agreed to drug test
prior to being granted visitation with minor; the court ordered the testing.

5
Father had relocated to Georgia on March 5, 2022, to be closer to family.3 Father

described minor as “his best friend.” He said minor was a happy baby and enjoyed

“doing boy things.” Father had a supervised virtual visit on March 10, 2022. He would

continue to “have ongoing virtual visits supervised by the maternal grandmother

Mondays and Thursdays.” The social worker explained to father that there was a

statutory time frame of six months for reunification services due to minor being under the

age of three.

At a hearing on March 21, 2022, father’s counsel stated, “Father did drug test prior

to leaving for Georgia. Those results were not included in the latest report, so I ask that

those be made available for the next hearing.” The court ordered the department “to

include an addendum with any drug test results that may be available for the next

hearing.”

On April 22, 2022, at the contested jurisdictional hearing, father’s counsel

disputed the allegations and requested family maintenance services. Otherwise, father’s

counsel requested liberalized visits: “I would ask that [visits] be liberalized to include

unsupervised, weekends, overnights, and eventually move into family maintenance, Your

Honor. I understand he’s in Georgia, but he will be planning to come visit his son as

soon as possible and as soon as those visits become available for him.” Father’s counsel

noted that “father drug tested before leaving for Georgia on or about February 28th,

3 It does not appear the People ever filed formal charges against father for the
battery.

6
2022[.]” “It seems the Department is having some difficulty securing the results. I just

ask . . . for continued efforts on the Department to get those results.”

The court found the allegations in the petition true, sustained the petition,

adjudged minor a dependent of the court, removed minor from father’s custody, and

granted father reunification services. The court ordered, “The next report should include

any drug test results for father, and certainly the one that [father’s counsel] has indicated

that father submitted to on February 28th, 2022.”

In the September 29, 2022, status review report, the social worker recommended

the court continue reunification services for father and authorize an Interstate Compact

for the Placement of Children (ICPC) on behalf of father in the state of Georgia. The

department had previously submitted an ICPC on behalf of father, which was denied

because defendant had not completed 75 percent of his case plan. Father had several

active warrants issued due to unresolved vehicle infractions.

The previous social worker had provided father “with general counseling,

domestic violence, parenting education, and substance abuse treatment service referrals in

the State of Georgia.” That social worker made three attempts to contact father between

May 18, and July 28, 2022. Father had apparently changed his phone number and

provided the new number to the previous social worker on August 3, 2022.

The new social worker had reached out to the Department of Children and Family

Services (DeKalb) located in DeKalb County to request community resources for the

father in regard to his general counseling, domestic violence, parenting education,

7
substance abuse treatment, and substance abuse testing.”4 She “was informed [father]

would need to come into to his local [DeKalb] office . . . and request a . . . ‘[p]acket,’

which was reported to have the general counseling, domestic violence, parenting

education, and substance abuse treatment services.” DeKalb would not provide

information regarding the resources to the social worker personally because she was not a

social worker in the State of Georgia.

The social worker contacted father with the information she had received from

DeKalb. She also requested that he send her information on the drug testing site of his

choice. Father reported he was attending general counseling and receiving psychiatric

care. He reported he had enrolled in services at the end of August 2022, and had already

completed eight sessions. Father said he attended therapy once or twice a week and sees

a psychiatrist once a month. The social worker attempted to verify the information, but

she had yet to receive a response from either father’s therapist or psychiatrist.

Father reported he was scheduled to begin a 24-week anger management and

domestic violence class program; his intake appointment had been set for October 3,

2022, and classes were set to begin on October 13, 2022. The social worker verified

father’s enrollment and the program dates.

4 The social worker acknowledged that the court had previously ordered the
department to include an update on father’s drug test results. However, no results for any
previous test appear in this or any subsequent report.

8
Father reported he had a scheduled an intake appointment for substance abuse

treatment for September 29, 2022, which the social worker confirmed. Father reported

that he had not used marijuana “in the past few months.”

Father had virtual visitation with minor every Monday and Thursday for at least

one hour. The maternal grandmother reported father was a “no show” for visits on May

13, June 23, July 4, 11, 18, and 25, 2022. Father missed a visit due to illness on July 27,

2022.

In an addendum report, the social worker confirmed father’s enrollment in

parenting education services. The maternal grandmother informed the social worker that

if reunification failed, she was willing to adopt minor.

At the six month review hearing on October 24, 2022, the court granted father six

additional months of services.

In the June 1, 2023, 12-month status review report, the social worker

recommended additional reunification services for father. The social worker could not

confirm father’s participation in his anger management and domestic violence class,

therapy, and parenting class because father had yet to sign a release. The social worker

requested father complete the release, which he stated he would, but he had yet to do so.

Father told the social worker he had not participated in any substance abuse program: ““ I

. . . just stopped smoking all in total.’”

The maternal grandmother reported that father had been inconsistent with

visitation. Father visited with minor on November 25, once in December 2022, on

9
February 11, and April 2023; the latter visit lasted for 20 minutes. Father failed to visit

with minor in October 2022, January, or March 2023.

Father reported “that he frequently visits [minor], he stated [father] flies out to see

[minor]. The last visit was in April 2023; [father] expressed that at the beginning there

was an adjustment period. [Father] reported that [minor] is happy to see him and [minor]

gets sad when he leaves.”

At the hearing on June 13, 2023, the court filed father’s certificate of completion

of a parenting program. Father’s counsel noted that father informed him “that he’s

engaged with all of his other case plan. He turned in a release of information.” “He’s

going to be starting substance abuse shortly. He’s been engaged with counseling. He

continues be to be engaged in domestic violence and has a plan to complete in a few

months. He did finish the parenting.” “He just wanted me to state he was in substance

abuse treatment. He was progressing well; however, he was dropped because he went to

a visitation in California and missed two sessions and was dropped because of that, so he

had to restart, which he will be soon.”

The court noted that “visitation has been very sporadic. I understand father is out

of state, but it looks like even when he is here, his visitation is very limited.”

Father’s counsel reported that father “states that he has phone or FaceTime contact

with [minor] on average about two times a week, anywhere from 30 minutes to an hour

and a half. And he has been doing that steady for the last year. This most recent visit

was on his birthday; it was [May] of this year. He visited for three days for hours. One

10
of the visits [was] two-and-a-half hours; another visit was for four hours on his actual

birthday.” “In April, he had one visit that was a longer visit. It was above six hours.”

“In February, he had two visits for two hours on the 11th and 12th. And then on

the 6th another two-hour visit. October there were no visits in person, but he’s had

steady phone FaceTime. In November, he had two visits, one for four hours and one for

an hour and a half. In December was one visit for an hour. And then in January no visits

in person, but he’s having a steady FaceTime or phone all the while.”

The court reset the matter for a contested hearing. It directed the department to

confirm visitation with the maternal grandmother. The court ordered father to complete a

hair follicle drug test.

In the August 24, 2023, 18-month status review report, the social worker

recommended the court terminate father’s reunification services and set the section

366.26 hearing. Father had enrolled in domestic violence services in October 2022;

however, in November 2022, father was disqualified due to excessive absences. Father

reenrolled on April 10, 2023; he had completed 12 out of 24 classes.

Father had not been consistently attending counseling sessions. His last verified

session occurred on March 2, 2023. The social worker was still having problems

receiving confirmation of services because father had yet to file a release. On August 17,

2023, the social worker again requested father sign a release.

With respect to substance abuse treatment, on May 24, 2023, father again told the

social worker that he had not attended substance abuse classes, but he had stopped using.

11
On July 28, 2023, father told the social worker he had last used marijuana two to three

weeks earlier and was looking for a program in which to enroll. The social worker

provided father program information and later attempted to confirm his enrollment. All

attempted contacts with him went unanswered. Father had yet to confirm enrollment in a

substance abuse treatment program.

The social worker on July 27, 2023, consulted with a “drug test liaison worker in

order to send [sic] hair follicle test in [sic] Georgia.” The social worker was still waiting

to hear back.

The maternal grandmother again reported that father failed to show or call for

visits scheduled on May 13, June 23, July 4, 11, 18, and 25, 2022. On August 8, 2022,

and August 11, 2022, [father] had in-person visit[s] with [minor], which [were]

supervised by the caregiver. The caregiver denied having any concerns regarding the in-

person visits between [father] and the [minor]. She maintained visitation went well and

reported [minor] was comfortable with his-father.”

“Father [] stated that he frequently visits [minor]. He stated [father] flies out to

see [minor]. The last visit was in April 2023; [father] expressed that at the beginning

there was an adjustment period. [Father] reported that [minor] is happy to see him and

[minor] gets sad when he leaves.”

The maternal grandmother again reported that father was inconsistent with

visitation. She reported that father did not visit with minor in October 2022, January, or

March 2023. The maternal grandmother stated father had one, one-hour visit with minor

12
in November 2022; one, two-hour visit in December 2023; one, one-hour visit in

February 2023; and two, 20-minute visits in April 2023, when father was in California for

more than a week.

On August 10, 2023, the maternal grandmother again stated father was

inconsistent with both his in-person and virtual visits. The last in-person visits between

them occurred for two hours on July 3, 2023, and for 20 minutes on July 24, 2023. She

reported that father sometimes visited minor with his friends. She said she sometimes

smelled marijuana; father would smoke marijuana outside the maternal grandmother’s

home when he came to visit.

In an addendum report filed November 9, 2023, the social worker reported she had

received a release of information from DeKalb with father’s signature on October 18,

2023. Father’s therapist reported that father had been participating in telemedicine

therapy sessions every few weeks since April 9, 2022. The social worker was unable to

obtain father’s progress report.

The social worker received an email regarding father’s progress in a domestic

violence class. The report indicated father’s performance was satisfactory in every

category. Father had attended 10 classes, was late one day, and had one absence between

August 7, 2023, to November 7, 2023.

On October 31, 2023, the social worker received confirmation that father had been

admitted to a substance abuse treatment program on September 5, 2023: “The program

included eight weeks of treatment and [father] began to gradually show improvement by

13
meeting his treatment goals. [Father] was compliant, cooperative, and active during

treatment and completed [the program] on October 31, 2023.”

On October 3, 2023, the social worker received confirmation that father had failed

to show for a hair follicle test she had submitted on his behalf. On October 25, 2023, the

social worker submitted another referral; father tested positive for Cannabinoid.

On October 17, 2023, father visited minor for 20 minutes. Father said he would

visit minor on October 18, 2023, but he failed to show. On October 19, 2023, father had

an in-person visit with minor at a park. Minor “appeared to be happy to see [father] as

evidenced by running to him and showing the pumpkin he brought from home. [Father]

was providing adequate supervision to [minor] while they are playing at the playground.”

The visit continued at the maternal grandmother’s home and lasted for a total of four

hours. Father’s last in-person visit with minor occurred on October 22, 2023, for

approximately six hours.

At the 18-month review hearing on November 15, 2023, the social worker testified

father was provided a case plan which included “parenting education, individual

counseling, substance abuse program, and substance abuse testing.” Father had

completed the parenting and substance abuse treatment components of his plan. Father

had not completed the therapy, domestic violence, or testing components. The social

worker was also concerned about father’s continued marijuana use.

Father testified the department did not provide him with referrals to any services.

He was given one referral for a hair follicle drug test, but the entity to which he was

14
referred was closed. Father had completed his reunification services. He had drug tested

negatively four times. Father never tested positive for anything other than THC. He had

been regularly visiting with minor. The maternal grandmother did not want him to get

minor back. She incorrectly reported that he had no showed to visits or had shortened

visits. Father had never failed to show for a visit.

Minor screams father’s name when he sees him. He then pulls father “into the

house, starts showing [him] all his toys and whatever else new he has, cloth[e]s, anything

around the house that he would like to show me. Then he sets [father] down in his area to

start playing with his toys.”

Father would never use marijuana before or during visits with minor. When he

tested positive for marijuana, “What they had told me is that I’m a bigger person, so I

think my test results said I was 30 and the cutoff level was 20. So they just said it took a

little longer for it to get out of my system. But throughout that whole time, I did not use

marijuana.” The last time he used was three and a half months earlier.

The department noted they were already three months past 18 months of services.

Minor’s counsel noted, “Generally speaking, this should be a six-month case. We have

gone out past 18 months on this case. 18 months expired in August.”

The court found the department had failed to provide reasonable services. The

court granted father additional reunification services and scheduled the 24-month

hearing. The court ordered father to submit to a hair follicle drug test before he left for

Georgia.

15
The January 30, 2024, addendum report, reflected that father had drug tested

negative for all illicit substances on November 16, 2023. On January 16, 2024, the social

worker submitted a referral for father to drug test in Georgia; father failed to show for

testing.

Father reported that the domestic violence class he was scheduled to complete had

been shut down. He reported he had enrolled in another program; however, the social

worker had not received any confirmation. Father had been attending individual therapy

regularly, on a monthly basis.

Father came to visit minor at the maternal grandmother’s home on November 22,

2023. Father continued to have regular virtual visitation. The social worker asked minor

if he liked talking to father on the phone; minor responded that he did not. The social

worker had submitted an ICPC referral on behalf of father on November 21, 2023; she

was still awaiting its completion.

In an addendum report filed February 16, 2024, the social worker recommended

the court terminate reunification services and set the section 366.26 hearing. On January

30, 2024, father failed to show for a random drug test. Father reported completing his

domestic violence program. Father drug tested on February 2, 2024; the department had

yet to receive the results. Father failed to show for virtual visits scheduled on February 1,

5, 8, and 12, 2024.

In an addendum report filed March 5, 2024, the social worker reported that she

had inquired about the status of the ICPC assessment twice since the last report, but she

16
had not received a response. Father supplied the social worker with the results of a hair

follicle drug test he submitted on February 13, 2024; the results were negative; however,

the collection facility was not the one to which the department had submitted the referral;

the social worker indicated it was not clear whether the laboratory used an approved test.

Father reported he had visited with minor on February 7, 12, and 14, 2024. Father

refused visitation monitored by the department. The maternal grandmother reported that

father failed to show for visitation on February 15, 19, 22, and 26, 2024. The maternal

grandmother reported that visitation on February 29, 2024, lasted 17 minutes: “They just

said hi to each other. Then [father] was eating dinner and [minor] started playing with his

toy. The [maternal grandmother] stated there [was] not much conversation during the

visitation.”

A criminal records search reflected that father was convicted of obstruction of a

police officer (§ 148, subd. (a)(1)) on January 4, 2021. A court issued a bench warrant

for father’s arrest on April 12, 2022.

The social worker noted: “Although [father] completed a substance abuse

treatment program, the program recommended that [father] continue to obtain therapeutic

support upon discharging from the program. [Father] reported he is not attending [an]

aftercare program []or NA meetings and has not provide[d] the Department of his plans

to maintain his sobriety.” Father had still failed to verify completion of his domestic

violence program.

17
At the 24-month hearing on March 8, 2024, father testified he had missed two

drug tests. He had missed visits with minor.

Father failed to complete his domestic violence program because it closed. The

social worker failed to find him a new program; he was unable to find any in-person

programs on his own. All the in-person programs required a referral, which the social

worker would not give him. Eventually he completed an online domestic violence

program, which he believed involved 120 hours of work. He refused department

monitoring of visitation.

Father twice tested negative by hair follicle test. None of his tests had come back

positive. He had completed a domestic violence program, for which he had provided a

certificate of completion to his attorney.

The social worker testified she gave father a new referral for a domestic violence

class once he informed her his original program closed. She never received a certificate

of completion from father despite asking. Father told her his online course included 24,

one-hour sessions.

The court terminated father’s reunification services and set the section 366.26

hearing. The court found that father had failed to prove he had completed a domestic

violence program, failed to provide proof of completion of counseling, had failed to drug

test consistently, and failed to visit minor consistently. The court authorized a bonding

study.

18
In the section 366.26 reports filed July 16, 2024, the social worker recommended

the court find adoption as the most appropriate plan and terminate father’s parental rights.

Father reported that he was scheduled to have an intake session for individual counseling,

had attended a 16 hour domestic violence class, and attended a substance abuse program.

The social worker was unable to confirm father’s completion of the domestic violence

course. Father still had a bench warrant for his arrest. Virtual visitation had occurred on

April 22, and June 27, 2024.

The social worker noted that the department had placed minor with the maternal

grandmother, the prospective adoptive parent, on February 23, 2022. Minor was “making

lifelong connections with relatives as his cousins visit the maternal grandmother’s home

weekly, which the caregiver reported [minor] looks forward to.”

“The prospective adoptive mother expressed her priority is caring for [minor] and

his well-being.” “[S]he reported she and her sister did live together in the same house

with all of their children.” “The prospective adoptive mother is motivated to adopt

[minor]. She expressed [minor] was her daughter[’s] son and she loves him. She stated

she wished to give him a better life and provide him a permanent home.” “She reported

she has had a relationship with him since he was born. She stated her daughter and

[minor] were often at her home and she would keep him on and off for days at a time.

She reported the day her daughter passed away, [minor] was with her. She reported

[minor] calls her mom. She shared she has explained to [minor] that he has two moms,

19
her and her daughter who passed. She stated they have a strong attachment and love each

other.”

On September 3, 2024, father filed a section 388 petition requesting the court

transfer the case to Georgia to let social services there complete the case, terminate

jurisdiction and return minor to father’s care, or give father enhancement services and

finish the ICPC so that services could be completed in Georgia. Father contended he had

completed his case plan,5 had consistently tested negative for illicit substances,6 and had

a bond with minor such that the requested changes were in minor’s best interest. The

court ordered a hearing on the petition.

On September 20, 2024, father filed the bonding study, in which the psychologist

concluded, “While the bond between minor and father is positive, there was no data that

would suggest current placement arrangements be altered.” The psychologist conducted

the bonding study over one hour in his office: “Father brought several new toys for the

minor. Father sat on the couch leaning back most of the time.” “Minor sat on a stool

facing the couch and played with his toys. Sometimes father would interact with the

minor, other times he just leaned back and talked with the evaluator . . . .” Father and

minor hugged at the end of the visit.

5 Father attached certificates of completion of domestic violence classes dated
January 27, and June 21, 2024.

6 Father attached negative test results dated March 22, April 18, May 30, June 17,
July 15, 2024.

20
A social worker observed a video visit between father and minor on August 29,

2024. She stated their interaction was limited as minor was occupied by the toys in the

visitation rooms.

At the hearing on November 15, 2024, father testified he had finished his domestic

violence, therapy, and parenting classes and had drug tested negative going back a year.

Minor was like father’s best friend: “Even with what’s going on now, when we get

together and stuff like that, we could always laugh, make jokes. And one of our favorite

things to do is play basketball, play catch. He loves showing me a lot of toys. He loves

his Ninja Turtle toys. Last time I [saw] him, I got a Ninja Turtle set where you could

mismatch the bodies and stuff like that. We played with that. Yeah, [minor] is definitely

my best friend.” Minor called father “Daddy, dad.” Minor tells father he loves him.

It was in minor’s best interest to be placed with father, “Because I’m his father, his

dad. I have a support system to help raise him. Yeah, I mean, he already lost his mother.

And I don’t really see why he [sh]ould lose two parents.” Georgia approved father for an

ICPC after the court terminated his reunification services.

Since the court terminated father’s reunification services, he visited with minor

once monthly. Some of those visits were in person. Father missed one visit due to a

switch in social workers.

The psychologist testified that he conducted a bonding study of father and minor:

“I did find there was a positive bond between father and the minor.” “[M]y finding was

that while [the] bond between minor and father is positive, there was no data that would

21
suggest current placement arrangements be altered. There was no data that would

suggest [the] current visiting schedule be altered . . . .” “I think [minor] would benefit

from continuing a relationship with his father.”

The court found that father had shown a change in circumstances. However, the

court noted minor had been with the maternal grandmother for two-and-a-half years: “A

four-and-a-half year old who has been with the same caretaker for two-and-a-half years,

to move him and to remove him from that home to a different state with a whole different

set of people is not in his best interest.”

The court stated that it did not have the ability to grant father additional services:

“By statute, he was given 24 months[’] worth of services, which is the maximum that he

can be given.” The court denied father’s section 388 petition “based on the best interest

because the Court finds it is not in the best interest of the child.”

The court then found the parental bond exception to termination of parental rights

inapplicable, found minor adoptable, and terminated father’s parental rights.

II. DISCUSSION

Father contends the court erred in denying his section 388 petition. Specifically,

father maintains the court erred in finding that it lacked legal authority to provide

additional services. We disagree.

“Section 388 provides for modification of juvenile court orders when the moving

party (1) presents new evidence or a change of circumstance and (2) demonstrates

modification of the previous order is in the child’s best interest. [Citations.] ‘“The

22
petitioner has the burden of showing by a preponderance of the evidence (1) that there is

new evidence or a change of circumstances and (2) that the proposed modification would

be in the best interests of the child.”’” (In re Matthew M. (2023) 88 Cal.App.5th 1186,

1194.)

“When, as in this case, a section 388 petition is filed after family reunification

services have been terminated, the juvenile court’s overriding concern is the child’s best

interests. [Citation.] The parent’s interests in the care, custody and companionship of the

child are no longer paramount; and the focus shifts to the needs of the child for

permanency and stability. [Citations.] Nonetheless, a parent may rebut the presumption

that continued care is in the best interest of the child after termination of reunification

services by showing that circumstances have changed and would warrant further

reunification services. [Citation.]” (In re Malick T. (2022) 73 Cal.App.5th 1109, 1122-

1123 (Malick).)

“We review the court’s best interest determination, the second step, for abuse of

discretion and may disturb the exercise of that discretion only in the rare case when the

court has made an arbitrary or irrational determination. [Citations.] We do not inquire

whether substantial evidence would have supported a different order, nor do we reweigh

the evidence and substitute our judgment for that of the juvenile court. [Citation.] We

ask only whether the juvenile court abused its discretion with respect to the order it made.

[Citation.]” (In re Matthew M., supra, 88 Cal.App.5th at pp. 1194-1195.) “The denial of

23
a section 388 motion rarely merits reversal as an abuse of discretion.” (In re Amber M.

(2002) 103 Cal.App.4th 681, 685-686.)

“However, when the court’s denial is based on a mistake of law, our review is de

novo.” (Malick, supra, 73 Cal.App.5th at p. 1123.) The juvenile court errs when it

concludes “that, prior to a properly noticed section 366.26 hearing at which [the parents’]

parental rights are terminated, additional reunification services, even if warranted, could

not be ordered to assist [the parents] in attempting to regain custody of [their] . . .

children.” (Id. at p. 1126.)

“The harmless error doctrine applies in dependency cases. [Citations.] . . . .

‘“Reversal is justified ‘only when the court, “after an examination of the entire case,

including the evidence,” is of the “opinion” that it is reasonably probable that a result

more favorable to the [petitioning] party would have been reached in the absence of the

error.’”’ [Citation.]” (Malick, supra, 73 Cal.App.5th at p. 1128; see In re J.P. (2014)

229 Cal.App.4th 108, 128-129 [harmless where juvenile court erroneously failed to hold

a hearing on a § 388 petition]; In re G.B. (2014) 227 Cal.App.4th 1147, 1162.)

Here, citing Malick, father maintains that the court erred as a matter of law in

denying his section 388 petition based on its understanding that it could not legally grant

father additional reunification services. The court stated that it did not have the ability to

grant father additional services: “By statute, he was given 24 months[’] worth of services,

which is the maximum that he can be given.”

24
As the department notes, father did not request additional reunification services.

Rather, he requested enhancement services.

Enhancement services are “‘child welfare services offered to the parent not

retaining custody, designed to enhance the child’s relationship with that parent.’

[Citations.]” (In re Destiny D. (2017) 15 Cal.App.5th 197, 212; accord, In re A.C. (2008)

169 Cal.App.4th 636, 642, fn. 5 [“‘enhancement’ services are ‘not designed to reunify the

child with that parent’”]; accord, In re C.S. (2022) 80 Cal.App.5th 631, 636-637.)

Thus, by requesting enhancement services, the court was not required to consider

granting father reunification services “even if warranted, . . . to assist [father] in

attempting to regain custody of [his] . . . child[].” (Malick, supra, 73 Cal.App.5th at

p. 1126.) This is because “‘enhancement’ services are ‘not designed to reunify the child

with that parent.’” (In re A.C., supra, 169 Cal.App.4th at p. 642, fn. 5.)

Moreover, the court properly denied the petition based on its finding that the

requested services would not be in minor’s best interest. Finally, even if the court erred

as a matter of law in determining it could not award father additional services,

reunification or enhancement, any error was harmless.

Here, the maternal grandmother was already considerably involved in minor’s life

prior to the department’s intervention. Minor was only just over one and one-half years

old when the department intervened. The maternal grandmother had been one of his

primary caregivers. Parents had arranged for her to take care of minor the night of the

25
incident. The department placed minor with the maternal grandmother on February 23,

2022.

Just over a week after the department filed the juvenile dependency petition, father

moved to Georgia. We are not unsympathetic to the fact that father was in mourning and

that by moving closer to family, father would have company to ease him through that

process; however, there is no question that by moving to the other side of the country,

father would have a much more difficult time maintaining a relationship with minor; this

is especially true due to minor’s young age and the difficulty of having in-person

visitation.

Father then continuously failed to show for the limited visitation he could have

since moving to Georgia, sometimes going whole months without visitation. Visitation

often lasted only around 20 minutes.

Minor indicated at least twice that he did not like speaking to father on the phone.

There was evidence that some visitation between father and minor involved little

interaction. There was evidence that father had been using marijuana immediately prior

to and even during visitation. Father never proceeded to unsupervised visitation.

During the reunification period, father had over 24 months of services in a case in

which services ideally would have been limited to only six months (§ 361.5,

subd. (a)(3)(C)); father still failed to successfully reunite with minor.

26
Although the psychologist found that minor and father had a bond, he found that

there was no data to suggest the current visiting schedule or placement should be

changed. Minor did not know his relatives in Georgia.

Minor was “making lifelong connections with relatives as his cousins visit the

maternal grandmother’s home weekly, which the caregiver reported [minor] looks

forward to.” At the time of the hearing on father’s petition, minor had been in the

maternal grandmother’s care for well over two-and-one-half years. She and minor had a

strong bond. The maternal grandmother was dedicated to adopting minor and providing

for his well-being. Minor called her “mom.” Thus, the juvenile court acted within its

discretion in denying the petition based on minor’s best interest in acquiring stability and

permanency in an adoptive home with the maternal grandmother.

III. DISPOSITION

The judgment is affirmed.

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS

McKINSTER
Acting P. J.

We concur:

CODRINGTON
J.

RAPHAEL
J.

27

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.