People v. Oicles CA6

CourtListener 10623694Calctapp7 lug 2025

Testo completo

Filed 7/3/25 P. v. Oicles CA6
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SIXTH APPELLATE DISTRICT

THE PEOPLE, H051339
(Santa Clara County
Plaintiff and Respondent, Super. Ct. No. B1795099)

v.

CHRISTOPHER TODD OICLES,

Defendant and Appellant.

Christopher Todd Oicles appeals from his convictions for stalking, criminal
threats, several drug offenses, and unlawful weapons possession. Oicles’s sole argument
on appeal is that the drug and weapons charges against him were improperly joined with
the stalking and criminal threats charges. Because Oicles has not shown that joinder of
these charges caused a miscarriage of justice, we affirm.
I. BACKGROUND
The facts recounted below are drawn from the record, including the evidence
presented at trial, which is viewed in the light most favorable to the verdict. (See People
v. Banks (2015) 61 Cal.4th 788, 795.)
In November 2017, Oicles was charged with six offenses. The first charge was
stalking S.D., a colleague from work, between March 2017 and November 2017. (To
protect the privacy of the victim, we use initials to refer to her. (Cal. Rules of Court,
rule 8.90(b)(4).) Oicles also was charged with making a criminal threat against S.D. on
or about November 22, 2017. Finally, Oicles was charged with unlawful possession of a
controlled substances while armed, manufacturing a controlled substance, and two counts
of possession of an assault weapon.
Before trial, Oicles moved to sever the drug and weapons charges from the
stalking and criminal threats charges. After a hearing, the trial court denied the motion.
Observing that the police discovered the evidence underlying the drug and weapons
charges in serving a protective order on Mr. Oicles related to the stalking and criminal
threat charges, the trial court reasoned that all the charges against Oicles in the second
trial were “part of a continuous course of investigation.” The court also found the danger
of prejudice outweighed by the benefits of joinder because the drug and weapons charges
were unlikely to unusually inflame the jury against Oicles and the stalking and criminal
threats charges were well supported.
At trial S.D. testified that she worked at Advanced Micro Devices (AMD) where
Oicles, whom she had met through her ex-husband, also worked. Beginning in
January 2017, S.D. started encountering Oicles when she took smoking breaks outside
and had friendly conversations with him. In February or March 2017, after Oicles told
her that he had been ill and had no one to help him, S.D. gave Oicles her phone number.
A month or two later, Oicles texted S.D. from a bathroom at AMD that he needed
help. After finding Oicles on the floor surrounded by blood, S.D. told a security guard
that Oicles needed help. Oicles said to the guard that S.D. would take him home, but she
refused, and the guard instead called an ambulance which took Oicles to the hospital.
A few hours later, Oicles returned and complained to S.D. about the cost of the
ambulance. Around the same time, Oicles texted S.D. that he was “very in love” with
her. When S.D. told Oicles that she did not share his feelings, things turned “very bad.”
Oicles said he would put his hand inside her vagina and gestured obscenely. S.D. was
shocked, and the next day she told Oicles that what he had said was hurtful and

2
inappropriate. Oicles became angry and said that he would “put a bullet” in his head if
she went to the police.
S.D. decided to stop interacting with Oicles, going to a different smoking area,
blocking his phone number, and changing her own number.
However, Oicles was able to continue contacting S.D. by using an IP address
tracing service to find her new number and an online phone service to shield his own.
S.D. found some messages Oicles sent her “completely insane.” In addition, one time
when she happened to walk past Oicles, he got up, stood “extremely close” to her, and
said, “I want to fuck you now, fuck you now. Get in the car now. Get in the car. Get in
the car.” S.D. was “[e]xtremely scared” and “terrorized.” Afterwards, Oicles texted S.D.
and apologized for the “kidnap attempt.” Oicles also told S.D. that he had firearms and
knew a sniper who could “take care of” S.D.’s ex-husband.
On November 20, 2017, S.D. found an unstamped letter from Oicles in the
doorway of her home, even though she had never told him where she lived. In addition
to containing “pages of nonsense,” the letter falsely claimed that S.D.’s ex-husband was
controlling her and that she was having an affair with her manager. Two days later, S.D.
found a second letter from Oicles in her doorway. In this letter, Oicles said that he
“cannot be stopped” and had “blanche cart [sic] to do anything to wreck” S.D. and her
ex-husband. Although she had not wanted to get Oicles in trouble, S.D. decided to
contact the police.
After S.D.’s testimony, a police officer testified that on November 22, 2017 Oicles
was arrested, and methamphetamine capsules were found nearby. Another officer
testified that he searched Oicles’ car and discovered a loaded gun in the center console as
well as AR-15 magazines and another loaded handgun in the trunk.
In addition, once S.D. obtained an emergency protective order against Oicles,
officers went to his home to retrieve four firearms registered to him. There, officers

3
found a total of nine firearms as well as laboratory equipment and other materials
consistent with a makeshift methamphetamine manufacturing lab.
The defense rested without calling witnesses, and the jury convicted Oicles on all
charges.
On August 14, 2023, in a joint sentencing with another case, the trial court
sentenced Oicles to a total of five years consecutive to the sentence in that case.
Oicles filed a timely notice of appeal.
II. DISCUSSION
On appeal, Oicles challenges his convictions based on the denial of his motion to
sever the stalking and criminal threats charges against him from the drug and weapons
charges. As explained below, we conclude that any error in joining these charges did not
create a miscarriage of justice.
California has “a policy of promoting judicial economy through the joinder of
appropriately related offenses, subject to severance as necessary to protect the interests of
the defendant.” (People v. Henson (2022) 13 Cal.5th 574, 590; see also People v. Bean
(1988) 46 Cal.3d 919, 939-940 [discussing the benefits to the state of joinder]; People v.
Ochoa (1998) 19 Cal.4th 353, 409 [noting that joinder of related charges “ ‘ordinarily
avoids needless harassment of the defendant’ ”].) Accordingly, section 954 permits
joinder of two or more different offenses if those offenses are “of the same class of
crimes or offense” or “connected together in their commission.” (§ 954 [“An accusatory
pleading may charge two or more different offense connected together in their
commission, or different statements of the same offense or two or more different offenses
of the same class of crimes or offenses.”].) Moreover, in light of the policy favoring
joinder of appropriately related offenses, denial of a motion to sever is reviewed for
abuse of discretion. (People v. Westerfield (2019) 615 Cal.5th 632, 689.)
We need not determine whether the stalking and criminal threats charges against
Oicles were properly joined with the drug and weapons charges against him because,

4
even if they were not, there was no miscarriage of justice. As Oicles acknowledges,
when charges are improperly joined, a defendant is not entitled to reversal unless
misjoinder caused a miscarriage of justice. (See Cal. Const., art. VI, § 13 [“No judgment
shall be set aside . . . for any error as to any matter of procedure, unless, after
examination of the entire cause, including the evidence, the court shall be of the opinion
that the error complained of has resulted in a miscarriage of justice.”].) Oicles contends
that, in determining whether there was a miscarriage of justice, we should apply the
federal harmless error standard and find a miscarriage of justice unless misjoinder was
harmless beyond a reasonable doubt. However, in dealing with misjoinder of parties, the
California Supreme Court has applied the state’s harmless error standard in People v.
Watson (1956) 46 Cal.2d 818, 836 and examined whether it is “reasonably probable” that
the defendant “would have obtained a more favorable verdict at a separate trial.” (People
v. Massie (1967) 66 Cal.2d 923-924; see also People v. Ortiz (1978) 22 Cal.3d 38, 46.)
Misjoinder of charges no more raises federal constitutional issues than misjoinder of
parties. Consequently, we apply the Watson test here and examine whether there is
reasonable probability that Oicles would have obtained a more favorable verdict had the
drug and weapons charges not been joined with the stalking and criminal threats charges.
We conclude there is no reasonable probability of a more favorable verdict. The
evidence on the stalking and criminal threats charges was strong. S.D. testified that
Oicles’ offensive behavior began in April 2017 when Oicles made graphic and shocking
comments to her and reacted angrily when she objected to the comments. Despite S.D.’s
attempts to avoid him as well as blocking his phone number and changing hers, Oicles
continued to text her, apparently using online services to trace her new number and mask
his own. In addition, several weeks after the first incident, Oicles approached S.D. and,
“towering over” her, said “I want to fuck you now” and “get in the car.” Later, Oicles
told S.D. that he had firearms. And in November 2017 he left two letters in S.D.’s
doorway, even though she had never told him her address. The first letter accused S.D.

5
of working with her ex-husband and having an affair with a third man. In the second
letter, Oicles told S.D. he had “blanche cart [sic] to wreck me” and “to wreck my
husband.” Scared that Oicles would physically harm her or her ex-husband, Oicles
warned her ex-husband about the threat and went to the police
S.D.’s testimony was supported by copies of the November letters as well as
emails and texts—including one in April or May 2017 in which Oicles apologized for
“the attempted kidnap.” In addition, because Oicles chose not to present any evidence in
his defense, S.D.’s testimony and the documentary evidence supporting it was essentially
uncontroverted. Thus, there was strong evidence that Oicles engaged in stalking and
made criminal threats.
Oicles nevertheless contends that, absent joinder of the drug and weapons charges,
there is a substantial probability the jury would have acquitted him of the stalking and
criminal threats charges because it might have been persuaded that his threats were the
mere “outlandish rantings of a person with a severe mental condition.” It is true that the
stalking and the criminal threats charges against Oicles both require a threat that created a
reasonably sustained fear. (Penal Code, § 422, subd. (a) [requiring a threat that causes
the victim “reasonably to be in sustained fear” for the victim’s or an immediate family’s
safety]; id., § 646.9, subd. (a) [requiring a credible threat intended to put the victim “in
reasonable fear” for the safety of the victim or immediate family].) In addition, S.D.
testified that Oicles’ text messages were “completely insane” and the first letter left in her
doorway contained “pages of nonsense.”
However, Oicles has failed to show how joinder of the drug and weapons charges
significantly impeded his ability to argue that the stalking and criminal threats charges
were based on the innocuous and outlandish rantings of a mentally ill person. Oicles
contends that the evidence concerning the drug and weapons charges showed an
“unequivocal and ongoing threat to S.D.’s safety by one with immediate access to a cache
of lethal weapons and a patent disregard for the safety of others,” thereby preventing him

6
from arguing plausibly that his statements were outlandish rantings. However, when
Oicles was arrested, the police searched his car and found small arsenal: a Heckler &
Koch .45-caliber pistol loaded with eight rounds, a Smith & Wesson .40-caliber
ammunition magazine loaded with 10 round, five 30-round .223-caliber rifle magazines,
and five 20-round .223-caliber rifle magazines. Moreover, Oicles has acknowledged that
this evidence would have been presented even if the gun and weapons charges had not
been joined. But this arsenal undermines Oicles’ contention that his threats were mere
outlandish rantings in the same way as the larger arsenal in his home: They both show
that Oicles had ample means for realizing his threats. In addition, Oicles fails to explain
how, in light of the arsenal in his car, either the larger arsenal in his house or the
equipment for manufacturing methamphetamines likely swayed the jury.
Consequently, we conclude that there is no reasonable probability that Oicles
would have obtained a more favorable verdict on the stalking and criminal threats
charges if they had not been joined with the drug and weapons possession charges, and
therefore Oicles’ objection to joinder of the charges provides no basis for reversing the
judgment.
III. DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed.

7
____________________________
BROMBERG, J.

WE CONCUR:

____________________________________
GREENWOOD, P. J.

____________________________________
LIE, J.

People v. Oicles
H051339

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.