CourtListener 10622069•In re E.G.
Testo completo
Filed 6/10/25; Certified for Publication 7/1/25 (order attached)
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION EIGHT
In re E.G. et al., Persons B338002
Coming Under the Juvenile
Court Law. (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No. 23CCJP03814A–C)
LOS ANGELES COUNTY
DEPARTMENT OF
CHILDREN AND FAMILY
SERVICES,
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v.
ERICK C.,
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of Los
Angeles County, Pete R. Navarro, Juvenile Court Referee.
Affirmed.
Gina Zaragoza, under appointment by the Court of Appeal,
for Defendant and Appellant.
Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, Kim Nemoy,
Assistant County Counsel, and Jessica Buckelew, Deputy County
Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
_________________________
The juvenile court found siblings E.G., I.G., and K.G. came
within its jurisdiction pursuant to Welfare and Institutions Code1
section 300, subdivisions (b)(1), (d), and (j). Presumed father
Erick C. contends the court’s jurisdictional findings were not
supported by substantial evidence. We affirm the judgment.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
I. Referral and Initial Investigation
The family came to the attention of the Los Angeles County
Department of Children and Family Services (DCFS) in
September 2023 after E.G., age 11, reported being sexually
abused by her stepfather Erick C. After attending a school
assembly concerning safety, boundaries, and inappropriate
behavior, E.G. had asked to speak to her school counselor and
reported being uncomfortable during the assembly because she
had experienced something similar. E.G. said Erick C. would
direct her to take off her clothes and then place his body against
hers, both with and without clothing. E.G. disclosed she had
been raped once and that penetration had occurred; the touching
and groping happened multiple times. E.G. appeared nervous
and “genuinely upset” while confiding in her counselor. She did
not want to say much about the abuse, because when she had
previously confided in her friend Luz about it, Luz told E.G.’s
mother Evelyn B. (Mother), and Mother said it was not true.
E.G. seemed worried and did not want the counselor to tell
Mother about the abuse.
1 Undesignated statutory references are to the Welfare and
Institutions Code.
2
E.G. reported to police investigating the allegations that
Erick C. touched her inappropriately and placed his penis inside
her vagina. The first incident occurred when she was six years
old and sleeping in bed with Mother and Erick C. After Mother
got up in the night and left for work, Erick C. told E.G. to be
quiet and took off her clothes. Erick C. touched E.G.’s breast,
inserted his fingers inside her vagina, kissed her, and nibbled on
her ear. He turned E.G. onto her side and inserted his semi-erect
penis into her vagina. He did not use birth control, and he did
not ejaculate. E.G. refused Erick C.’s instruction to get on top of
him, at which time he got up and brushed his teeth. He returned
to the bed and held E.G. by the wrist until Mother texted she was
on her way home.
E.G. told the police the second incident was similar and
occurred when she was eight years old. E.G. was sleeping in bed
with Mother and Erick C.; Mother left for work, and Erick C.
removed E.G.’s clothes and touched her. Erick C. placed her on
her side and inserted his semi-erect penis into her vagina.
In the third incident, when E.G. was nine years old, she
was sleeping with her siblings when Erick C. attempted to touch
her inappropriately. (When describing what Erick C. had done,
E.G. motioned to her vaginal area.) E.G. kicked him. Erick C.
said he only wanted to hug her, but E.G. responded, “No, you
don’t, back away.”
E.G. told the police that a few months earlier, Erick C.
hugged her from behind and touched her chest while they were
swimming. Mother noticed and told Erick C. not to touch her.
Erick C. released E.G., and Mother grabbed and pulled her away
from him.
3
Mother told the police Erick C. was “never around” E.G., so
what E.G. had reported was “a shocker.” However, Mother also
said the sexual abuse had been brought to her attention in March
2023, when she picked up E.G. from the home of E.G.’s friend
Luz. Luz asked Mother if she knew Erick C. had raped E.G., and
E.G. nudged Luz to shut up and not tell Mother. When Luz’s
mother asked what was going on, Mother repeated what Luz had
said. Mother stated she did not know about it and, if it were
true, she would have reported it and left Erick C. On the car ride
home, Mother asked E.G. why she had said what she said and
asked if E.G. knew what rape was. E.G. said no. Mother told
E.G. she should not make such serious allegations, especially if
she does not know what they mean, as they could negatively
affect an innocent person and get them in trouble. Mother
continued to speak to E.G., who then denied the abuse.
Mother told police E.G. made the accusation because Erick
C. gave E.G.’s siblings more attention, love, and affection than he
gave her. Erick C. denied abusing E.G.
DCFS social worker Jeanette Arzate spoke to E.G. on
September 28, 2023. Arzate asked E.G. why she (Arzate) was
there, and E.G. said, “ ‘So you could talk to me about what
happened about my father doing sexual abuse to me.’ ” E.G. said
she did not feel comfortable talking with Arzate about what
happened and refused to provide a statement. She denied
concerns about sexual abuse of her siblings and denied there was
anything she wanted to report to DCFS. E.G. said Erick C.
looked at her in “a weird way” and said she did not feel safe with
him in the home. She said she was willing to stay in the home if
Erick C. left, and she asked that he leave for at least two weeks.
4
E.G. told Arzate her best friend Luz told Mother about the
abuse, but Mother thought it was a lie. E.G. then denied the
abuse to Mother because she felt Mother would not believe her.
E.G. reported the family needed money “ ‘because we struggle
and don’t have money to pay for food. [Erick C.] gives my mom
food and he’s the one who mostly pays for everything.’ ”
E.G. admitted self-harm and suicidal thoughts. She told
Arzate she was “ ‘a little useless right now’ ” and felt like
harming herself. E.G. said she had been feeling suicidal “ ‘[s]ince
this happened[,] when I saw the police come[,] because I knew
that this was going to happen.’ ” E.G. said she felt suicidal three
or more times per month and engaged in self-harm once or twice
per month.
E.G. said she sometimes had homicidal ideation when
someone made her angry or sad. The last time she felt that way
had been a few months ago when her friend called her a bad
name, pulled her hair, and said she looked like a witch. E.G. had
not had a plan to kill her friend—she just wanted to get revenge
by pushing her or pulling her hair.
E.G. said she had slight difficulty eating and sleeping, both
symptoms of depression. E.G. told Arzate she had played with
fire in the past and had a history of lying. She admitted
outbursts of rage, verbal and/or physical acts of aggression, and
hallucinations in which she heard someone say her name and
saw a person in the hallway who was not there.
E.G. said Erick C. disciplined her by yelling and grabbing
her wrist or slapping her face, leaving redness. E.G. reported
Erick C. had slapped her that day because she did not wash her
dish. Mother confirmed Erick C. had hit E.G., but said it was
because E.G. was about to hit him.
5
When speaking with DCFS, Mother confirmed she had
worked at night for three months in 2020. She acknowledged
that in March or April 2023, Luz asked her if Erick C. was raping
E.G. In the car afterwards, Mother asked E.G. if she knew what
rape was. When E.G. said no, Mother “ ‘told her making
accusations like that could get us in trouble, and she can even be
taken away from me and the kids.’ ” Mother admitted, “ ‘I did
snap on her. I asked her again why she said that. She started
crying. I told her: “[E.G.] tell me the truth. Is it true that he is
doing that?” She said: “No.” I asked her again, and she still said
no. I said: “Why you lying? Why you saying stuff like that?” and
she was just crying. She wouldn’t say anything. I told her to not
be making lies or stuff like that because it could get her or
anyone in trouble, and if it was true to actually speak up and to
not be afraid because I was not going to do anything bad to her.
I told her that I would take action on that if it was true, but she
said no. That was it.’ ”
Mother denied the children had been sexually abused.
When asked if she believed E.G., “[M]other stated that she does
and she does not, as she is confused. Mother stated that she is in
shock; however, she does believe her daughter despite her
confusion. Mother stated that she will do everything possible to
protect her and to ensure that her children are protected. Mother
stated that she would like all exams to be completed in order to
determine the truth.”
Erick C. told DCFS it had been more than a year since he
last had slept in the same bed as the children. He denied ever
striking them. He denied abusing E.G. and said it would never
cross his mind to do so. He had never disrobed the children or
touched them sexually. When asked why E.G. would make such
6
an accusation, Erick C. described E.G. as strange and said they
did not get along. He said she misbehaved and did not listen
when punished. Just that day, Erick C. said, “ ‘I told her to do
something, but in her rebellion, she doesn’t want to do anything
and on the contrary, she wants to control us (parents). I told her
that I was going to slap her. I did raise my hand, but I didn’t hit
her.’ ” The only time he had actually hit E.G. was about five
months earlier; he hit her on the arm, leaving no marks, when
she did not listen to him. Erick C. agreed to leave the home for
two weeks.
E.G.’s two younger siblings denied sexual abuse.
In October 2023, E.G.’s school counselor told DCFS that
when E.G. came back to school after disclosing the sexual abuse,
E.G. said the police initially said they were going to take E.G.
away, but they told Erick C. to leave instead. E.G. said Mother
had looked at her like she was not happy with her and it made
E.G. feel terrible; Mother had also made a comment blaming E.G.
for what was happening.
During a forensic interview on October 10, 2023, E.G.
“stated when she was 6 years old her stepfather took off his
clothes and then her clothes. He put his penis in her butthole,
flipped her over and put it in her vagina and then repeated both
acts again. She stated he grabbed her chest, arms, stomach and
back with his hands. [E.G] said he kissed her on the mouth
putting his tongue in her mouth. She stated the kissing was
rough. She said he put his fingers into her private part and
moved them up and down making her body shake a little and
then he stopped. [E.G] said he asked her to get on top of him but
she said no. [E.G.] said she never said anything because she was
scared her parents would get in trouble and that they would not
7
have enough money for rent. She said the same thing happened
again when she was 8 years old. [E.G.] said another time she
was getting out of the shower and he tried to touch her private
part but she covered herself with a towel and he did not touch
her. [E.G.] said in the 4th grade she told her friend Lu[z] and
then last year her friend Lu[z] told her mother. [E.G.] said she
didn’t think her mom would believe her so when her mom [a]sked
her she said nothing had happened.”
The forensic physical examination of E.G. was normal, but
that did not mean that no sexual abuse had occurred because the
most recent incident was alleged to have taken place three years
earlier, and children heal quickly.
In October 2023, the maternal grandmother told DCFS she
did not believe E.G. or the sexual abuse allegations, and Erick C.
“would never do such a thing.” Maternal aunt Gloria M. said
Erick C. was a good, calm person who loved children. She said
she never thought Erick C. would abuse E.G. and that “ ‘we are
all hoping that it is not true.’ ” She believed if Erick C. had raped
E.G., there would have been screaming and trauma because E.G.
was so small.
On October 25, 2023, a DCFS social worker told Mother
DCFS was considering opening a voluntary case that would avoid
court with a six-month contract between Mother and DCFS.
Mother asked if this was a six-month contract for Erick C. to be
out of the home and “that would be it.” The social worker said
E.G. had disclosed that Erick C. had sexually abused her, and he
needed to remain out of the home. Mother became upset and
asked who would pay her rent and bills. Mother said she was
already stressed over finances, but the social worker said she
could not let Erick C. back in the home just because she needed
8
financial assistance. Mother complained the investigation was
taking too long and accused DCFS of trying to make money from
it.
The following day, Mother spoke with a supervising social
worker (SCSW) at DCFS. “Mother spoke about her need for this
case to be ‘resolved,’ as she needs to be able to work and pay her
bills. The SCSW described for mother that, in general, when
there is a credible report of sexual abuse in a family, DCFS will
either request that the perpetrator remain out of the home or will
request that the child stay with a family member, friend, or, as a
last resort, be placed in foster care, in order to protect the child
while the family receives services. However, if the mother is
protective and the perpetrator is out of the home, the children
can remain in the home. The SCSW explained that having the
children remain in the home is the best option for the children, if
possible, and that DCFS is still evaluating whether she is able to
be protective. Mother said that she is being protective because
the step-father is currently out of the home but she wanted to
know how long that would need to continue. The SCSW
explained that the department will expect mother to be protective
of the children, ongoing. Mother asked what ‘ongoing’ means.
The SCSW stated that she will be expected to be protective of her
children until they turn 18. Mother again began to speak about
her bills and wanted to know if DCFS will help her.”
Mother asked the SCSW, “ ‘Well what if all of this isn’t
true? What if my daughter is lying?’ The SCSW explained that
few children lie about sexual abuse and her daughter has given a
very credible statement. Mother said she does not know the
details about what her daughter has said. She said her daughter
has spoken with friends at school and the friends told her that
9
this has happened to them as well, ‘so now everyone is saying
they’re a victim.’ ” Mother agreed to protect E.G., but she “never
expressed any concern for her daughter or any outrage that this
could have happened to her daughter. She did not appear to be
entertaining the idea that her daughter’s allegations even could
be true. She repeated her expressions of worry about finances
several times during the interview, as well as expressions of
doubt about her daughter’s credibility.”
Mother continued to see and speak with Erick C., although
she said she did not discuss the sexual abuse allegations with
him. She said she would not allow him to have contact with the
children.
On November 6, 2023, DCFS filed a petition alleging all
three children came within the jurisdiction of the juvenile court
under section 300, subdivisions (b)(1) (failure to protect) and (d)
(sexual abuse) due to Erick C.’s sexual abuse of E.G. The
younger siblings were also alleged to be subject to juvenile court
jurisdiction under section 300, subdivision (j) (abuse of sibling).
An allegation concerning substance abuse by Mother was initially
made but later dismissed.
At the detention hearing, the court ordered the children
released to Mother and ordered Erick C. to stay away from E.G.
II. November and December 2024
E.G. began online therapy in November 2023. The
therapist could see Mother in the background during sessions.
The therapist was unaware of the sexual abuse allegations and
reported both E.G. and Mother denied any type of child abuse or
trauma.
10
E.G. recounted the sexual abuse to social worker Alejandra
Carranza on December 7, 2023. E.G. said it happened at night
when she was six years old. E.G. slept in Mother’s room because
she had nightmares. E.G. said after Mother left for work, Erick
C. “ ‘would take off his clothes, then he would do the same to me.
He would put his private part in my butthole and flip me and put
it in my private part.’ ” Erick C. put his penis halfway inside her.
E.G. said she did not know how many times it happened, but it
was more than once. She described Erick C. touching her private
parts, stomach, arm, back and chest. He nibbled on her ear, put
his finger on her vagina, and moved his finger up and down. E.G.
said Erick C. tried to put her on top of him but she said no; he
stopped after she refused a second time.
E.G. said the last incident happened when she was eight
years old. When Carranza asked about Erick C. hugging her
from behind and touching her chest in the pool, E.G. said that
incident was true.
E.G. reported she had told her friend about the abuse when
she was in second grade, and her friend told Mother. She did not
tell Mother about the sexual abuse for several years because she
was scared. She explained, “ ‘I would act like nothing happened
because I didn’t want to get in trouble and separate my family.’ ”
E.G. denied her siblings had been sexually abused.
While speaking with Carranza, E.G. denied depression or
suicidal thoughts and claimed she was comfortable with her
therapist, whom she had seen three times. E.G. wanted “all this
to be over with because she does not want any more problems for
her mom.” She said, “ ‘I feel sad that my mom is sad. I don’t
want her going through a lot, like being on time for
appointments.’ ” While being interviewed, E.G. appeared
11
nervous: her legs were shaking, she continuously bit her nails,
and she kept looking toward the bedroom to make sure no one
was coming out.
Mother told DCFS she did not want to believe E.G.’s
allegations and denied any knowledge of sexual abuse. Mother
said Erick C. was never home, although she did admit leaving the
children home with him at night approximately two years earlier.
Mother said she and Erick C. were both shocked by E.G.’s
allegations of abuse in March 2023. Mother told DCFS, “ ‘I’m not
saying I didn’t believe her. [E.G] didn’t mention it again and I
left it at that.’ ” Mother felt stuck between her daughter and her
husband, and she wanted to know the truth. Less than a week
later, Mother spoke with the police and “denied everything [E.G.]
said because it could not have happened.”
DCFS spoke with multiple maternal relatives in December
2023, all of whom praised Erick C. and were, at a minimum,
skeptical of E.G.’s allegations. The maternal grandmother denied
the children had been abused. She said Erick C. was very
dedicated and worked hard to provide for the family. She could
not answer when asked about the allegations of sexual abuse.
The maternal grandmother said, “ ‘I will try to support her but I
don’t know.’ ” She described E.G. as spoiled, rude to Erick C.,
and having “ ‘a really bad attitude.’ ”
Maternal uncle Cesar E. called Mother and Erick C. perfect
parents. He found the sexual abuse allegations upsetting, and he
did not believe E.G. He said he did not know why E.G. “ ‘would
say something dumb.’ ” He said E.G. had lied before, “snitching”
on her cousins during play. Cesar E. felt sorry for Mother.
Maternal aunt Gloria M. described the parents as loving
and responsible, and the children as very spoiled. Erick C. was
12
good to the children. Gloria M. never had concerns about sexual
abuse, nor had she seen E.G. act afraid or depressed. Gloria M.
was shocked by the allegations because the children “ ‘tell us
everything. Everything is saddening and I’m trying to support
my sister and [E.G.]’ ” When asked if she believed E.G., Gloria
M. responded, “ ‘I’m supporting her and no one treats her
different due to this case.’ ”
Maternal aunt Cindi P. told DCFS she supported the
family, but she felt that if there had been abuse Mother would
have noticed and E.G. would have said something. Erick C. was
a good father and she had no concerns about abuse or neglect of
the children. She had never seen Erick C. behave
inappropriately, there were no red flags, and E.G.’s behavior had
not changed.
III. Recantation
On February 15, 2024, E.G. met with Carranza at school.
E.G. appeared nervous and scared. Hesitating to approach
Carranza, she looked back and forth at the staff and Carranza
and then “abruptly asked, ‘Who are you and who do you work
for?’ ” Once reminded they had spoken before, E.G. agreed to
speak with Carranza.
E.G. told Carranza her maternal aunt Janet2 had taken her
to a room in private and asked if the allegations were true. Janet
told E.G. DCFS would “take her away” if she was lying about the
allegations but she would be able to “stay” if she was honest.
2 No last name is provided for Janet in the record. From
names in the record, it appears Janet may be the same person as
Gloria M., but this cannot be conclusively determined from the
record on appeal.
13
Janet said that if Erick C. had done what E.G. alleged, she would
have felt pain, and she suggested E.G. had dreamed the abuse.
E.G. told Carranza, referring to the abuse, “ ‘I didn’t feel it but I
saw it so it must have been a dream.’ ” E.G. said the allegations
were not true and it had all been a dream because her parents
watched movies that depicted kissing, hugging and touching.
E.G. said Janet was the first person she told she had lied,
and then she and Janet spoke about it with Mother. According to
E.G., Mother asked if she wanted to be “ ‘taken away as a
punishment’ ” for making false allegations, and Mother and Janet
had spoken with someone to prevent her from being taken away.
Mother told her she was disappointed E.G. had lied but happy
that she was telling the truth.
When reminded that she had told six different people about
the abuse and had provided detailed information, E.G. said,
“ ‘I know but I lied.’ ” E.G. asked Carranza, “ ‘Are you going to
tell the court? Not because I’m scared but just to know.’ ”
Carranza told her the information would be given to the court.
Carranza told E.G. she wanted to make sure E.G. would feel safe
and comfortable if Erick C. returned home. E.G. said Erick C.
would not be home because he worked a lot, then asked if the
social workers would continue to check on them.
E.G. denied anyone at home talked about the case, made
her feel bad, or said negative things about her. She said she
wanted to visit with Erick C. E.G. reported she did not have
privacy during therapy sessions, and she always told the
therapist she was happy. Throughout the interview with
Carranza, E.G. “appeared to be nervous/jittery as she shook her
leg, looked around the room and moved her hands around. [E.G].
14
appeared to be very concerned about the time and how long the
interview was taking.”
Mother told DCFS that maternal aunt Janet spoke with
E.G. because E.G. trusted her, and E.G. admitted lying because
she was upset Erick C. had not let her go out with a friend.
Mother wanted to know if Erick C. could start visiting E.G. The
social worker told her it was too soon for visits and E.G. needed
continued therapy. She advised Mother that no one in the family
should discuss the allegations with E.G.
E.G.’s therapist reported to DCFS that both E.G. and
Mother said the abuse allegations were not true. The therapist
told DCFS that during sessions she spoke first to Mother, then to
E.G. Mother reported no concerns about E.G.’s behavior and said
everything was going well, which struck the therapist as strange
because E.G. had been referred for therapy due to “bad and out of
control” behavior.
Mother was always nearby while the therapist and E.G.
spoke, and when asked a question, E.G. tended to look around
the room or ask Mother for permission to answer the question.
E.G. seemed to have a “ ‘nervous twitch and/or fear aspect about
her.’ ” She was very careful in her responses and seemed
uncomfortable answering certain questions. The therapist
expressed concern whether E.G. was able to be fully honest
during sessions because of Mother’s constant proximity, and she
believed in-person therapy would be a good idea.
Because neither E.G. nor Mother reported any issues, the
therapist was planning to discharge E.G. from therapy soon. The
therapist wanted to support E.G. but could not force her to share
in therapy if she did not want to do so. Despite all the concerns,
15
E.G. and Mother seemed to have a strong relationship and to get
along well.
DCFS advised the court E.G. could be recanting due to the
conversations at home and expressed concern that Janet might
have planted a story in E.G.’s mind that the abuse was merely a
dream. DCFS also found it concerning that E.G.’s explanation of
why she had lied changed over time: At first, E.G. said she lied
because she was upset that day, but when the social worker
interviewed her, E.G. did not mention anything about being
upset. E.G. now claimed to have lied because she had spoken to
her aunt and believed that what occurred was simply a dream.
DCFS reported, “It is evident that [E.G.] is feeling pressured by
[M]other and maternal aunt since they continue to talk to her
about the allegations. Maternal aunt made comments about
being honest or else she could be ‘taken away.’ It should be
noted, that [M]other showed [E.G] the court report and
questioned [E.G.] about being honest.” DCFS also noted E.G.’s
story could not be reconciled with her March 2023 confidential
disclosure of abuse to Luz.
DCFS believed E.G. recanted because she did not want to
cause further problems for her family. She could be feeling
scared, guilty and sad about having an open investigation with
DCFS. The social worker reminded the court that when E.G.
first disclosed the sexual abuse, she felt Mother did not believe
her. She expressed fear of being in trouble and she did not want
to separate her family. E.G. had also reported that when Luz
told Mother about the sexual abuse, Mother appeared upset that
E.G. was saying Erick C. molested her, so she denied everything.
Mother and maternal relatives continued to appear doubtful of
E.G.’s statements, question E.G., and discuss the allegations.
16
DCFS opined that Mother and the maternal family’s repeated
questioning of E.G. “may have actually developed a false memory
or belief. Most concerning, is that the family’s actions are
emotionally and psychologically affecting [E.G.] further. It is
strongly recommended that [M]other and maternal family be
admonished for discussing and questioning” E.G. (Boldface
omitted.)
IV. Adjudication Hearing
At the adjudication hearing in April 2024, E.G. testified
Erick C. had not sexually abused her. She testified no one had
promised her anything or pressured her into changing her
account. E.G. testified that Mother had been disappointed in her
and sad when she reported the abuse. E.G. felt Mother had
protected her after she found out about the abuse allegation.
E.G. testified she made the allegations against Erick C.
because she was upset with him. The court asked what she was
upset about. E.G. responded by describing herself in terms
similar to those used by E.G.’s family and Erick C.: a spoiled brat
with an attitude who tried to control her parents and take
advantage of them. She concluded by saying Erick C. had said
she could not attend a certain middle school, “So I was upset
because he would not say yes to anything because it was—
because I was angry and would take advantage.” She testified
that it was after this argument that she reported to her school
counselor that Erick C. had abused her. E.G. denied recanting
because she felt bad about what had happened to her family.
Counsel for Mother and for Erick C. requested the petition
be dismissed. Minor’s counsel acknowledged the difficulty of
determining what happened to E.G. and why she recanted, but
noted the evidence and timeline, as well as the consistency in her
17
accounts of the abuse, made her initial accusations more likely to
be true. DCFS argued the sexual abuse allegations in the
petition should be sustained in their entirety.
The juvenile court amended and sustained the sexual abuse
allegations under all three subdivisions alleged in the petition.
The court explained its reasoning at length: “[R]ecantation is not
uncommon. Often times the youthful victims will regret making
these allegations in the first place because of the consequences it
has on disrupting the family unit, on exacerbat[ing] already
strained economic circumstances. And sometimes youth have a
sense of remorse or guilt or betrayal towards their parent. [¶] The
facts of this case are that—in seeking for a motive, searching for
a motive, there is really not compelling evidence that [E.G] had
such a motive to manufacture these allegations. [¶] The first
person she confided in was her best friend, Luz, someone she
trusted.· Someone that she was close enough to share this with,
also, was her counselor. [¶] What was quite revealing to the court
was her comments in the forensic interview that she was mad.
She got mad at the counselor for, maybe in her view, breaching
her confidentiality and making a report to the authorities. This
was something that at this time was the motive for her and was
more to seek assistance in handling—in dealing with her
allegation of sexual molestation. The motivation in the court’s
view was not to penalize the stepfather for something he had
done, but for her to be able to express in a therapeutic setting
how it impacted her. [¶] I looked closely at the child’s demeanor
and responses to the questions. Her responses were thoughtful
and did not appear to the court to be rehearsed or expressed in a
rote ma[nn]er. When asked a question, she would actually think
about it and then provide her response. If the motivation was to
18
get back at her stepfather for something he had done to her, the
court believes that she would have gone directly to the police or
the authorities or her mother for that. And so it comes down to
whether or not it is more likely than not that the allegation of
sexual misconduct by the stepfather is true. [¶] Based upon the
minor’s demeanor, her consistency—overall consistency in the
specifics, for the most part there are slight discrepancies. But for
the most part, her recollection, description of the events, were
consistent. I am sure she regrets having made the initial
allegation. But she did so because it was bothering her. And
clearly bothering her, [as] she was engaging in self-harm. [¶] And
so the court finds that it is more likely than not that the
allegations that she made were true. And that her subsequent
recantation was the result of the impact it had on splitting this
family up, on putting her mother in a difficult situation.”
The court declared the children dependents of the juvenile
court, removed them from Erick C., and released them to Mother.
Erick C. appealed. In November 2024, the juvenile court
terminated jurisdiction with an exit order granting Mother and
Erick C. joint physical and legal custody of the children.
DISCUSSION
We previously granted Erick C.’s request to take judicial
notice of the orders terminating jurisdiction and determining
custody. On behalf of DCFS, County Counsel declined to argue
the appeal is moot, and at Erick C.’s unopposed request we
exercise our discretion to adjudicate the appeal on the merits due
to the gravity and stigma of the jurisdictional findings. (In re D.P.
(2023) 14 Cal.5th 266, 285–287.)
19
In reviewing a challenge to the sufficiency of the evidence
supporting jurisdictional findings and related dispositional
orders, we examine the record in the light most favorable to the
findings and conclusions of the juvenile court and defer to the
juvenile court on issues of credibility of the evidence and
witnesses. (In re R.T. (2017) 3 Cal.5th 622, 633 (R.T.).) We “ ‘ “do
not reweigh the evidence or exercise independent judgment, but
merely determine if there are sufficient facts to support the
findings of the trial court.” ’ ” (In re I.J. (2013) 56 Cal.4th
766, 773 (I.J.).) We uphold the juvenile court’s findings unless
they are “ ‘ “so lacking in evidentiary support as to render them
unreasonable.” ’ ” (Jamieson v. City Council of the City of
Carpinteria (2012) 204 Cal.App.4th 755, 763.) If there is
substantial evidence to support the court’s order, we must uphold
it even if other evidence supports a contrary conclusion. (In re
Megan S. (2002) 104 Cal.App.4th 247, 251.) “The parent has the
burden on appeal of showing there is insufficient evidence to
support the juvenile court’s order.” (In re Isabella F. (2014)
226 Cal.App.4th 128, 138.)
I. Jurisdictional Findings Concerning All Children
Erick C. contends there was no substantial evidence to
support the jurisdictional findings as to E.G. because she was not
sexually abused, and therefore there was no substantial evidence
to support the findings that the abuse of E.G. placed her younger
siblings at substantial risk of serious physical harm.
The evidence is unquestionably sufficient to support the
court’s findings. E.G. gave a largely consistent, detailed report of
Erick C.’s sexual abuse to at least six people over a series of many
months. She later recanted, but there is abundant evidence in
the record from which the juvenile court very reasonably
20
determined it was her recantation, not her original account, that
lacked credibility: her family did not believe her allegations and
exerted pressure on her to recant, including telling her she could
be taken away by DCFS and implanting the idea that the sexual
abuse was just a dream. E.G. also gave inconsistent reasons for
recanting, at one point saying the abuse was a dream and at
another point saying she was angry at Erick C. Her anger
explanation, moreover, could not be reconciled with her
disclosure of the abuse to her friend months before she reported
the abuse to her counselor out of alleged anger. The court
described its reasons for its credibility determination in detail,
and we defer to its determination of the credibility of both the
evidence and the witnesses. (R.T., supra, 3 Cal.5th at p. 633.)
Erick C.’s argument that the evidence was not sufficient to
support the findings boils down to a contention that the juvenile
court should have weighed the evidence differently. He notes
E.G. admitted a history of lying, had experienced hallucinations,
did not believe her siblings were at risk, did not want to speak
with a social worker originally, did not say she wanted Erick C.
to leave permanently, later recanted, and denied anyone had
pressured her to recant or made her feel bad. He points out
inconsistencies in E.G.’s accounts, such as variations in the dates
given for the assaults and how many times she was raped versus
groped. He argues E.G.’s description of being penetrated
vaginally and anally at a young age lack credibility because she
denied feeling pain. He points out that E.G. recanted her
allegations and said she had been angry at Erick C. Erick C. also
disagrees with the court’s conclusion that the evidence was “not
compelling” that E.G. had a motive to manufacture the
allegations against Erick C., directing us to evidence in the
21
record of hostility between E.G. and Erick C. Finally, he directs
our attention to the evidence that members of E.G.’s maternal
family said they had not seen Erick C. act in a way that would
raise concerns of abuse and that E.G.’s behavior had not changed
during the time period the abuse had occurred.
These arguments demonstrate the juvenile court could
have resolved the evidentiary and credibility conflicts differently,
but they do not show there was no substantial evidence to
support the findings. The court was entitled to believe the
evidence supporting the findings and to give greater weight to
E.G.’s repeated, detailed descriptions of abuse than to her
recantation after months of family pressure. We decline Erick
C.’s invitation to reweigh the evidence and substitute our
judgment for that of the juvenile court.
II. Arguments Concerning Siblings Only
Erick C. presents additional arguments challenging the
jurisdictional findings concerning the younger children, I.G. and
K.G., on the abuse of sibling count under section 300,
subdivision (j), but the arguments are difficult to parse. First, he
correctly observes that section 300, subdivision (j) directs the
court to “consider the circumstances surrounding the abuse or
neglect of the sibling, the age and gender of each child, the nature
of the abuse or neglect of the sibling, the mental condition of the
parent, and any other factors the court considers probative in
determining whether there is a substantial risk to the child.” He
then states, “[I]n examining the age and gender of the affected
children, I.G. and K.G. had not experience[d] or witnessed any
inappropriate touching in the family home.” Erick C. does not
explain how not witnessing sexual abuse relates to age and
gender. He instead cites, without explanation, two cases in
22
which the court found a substantial risk of harm to one sibling
when they were present during the sexual abuse of another
sibling. To the extent Erick C. intends to argue these cases
establish the siblings were not placed at risk because they had
not experienced or witnessed any inappropriate touching in the
family home, that would be a logical fallacy—the fact that some
courts have found a substantial risk of harm when a child was in
the same room as the sibling at the time of the abuse does not
mean that if the children were not in the same room when the
abuse occurred, they were not at substantial risk of harm.
Next, Erick C. accurately sets forth the standard set by the
California Supreme Court in I.J.. supra, 56 Cal.4th at page 778
for determining whether abuse of one child supports dependency
jurisdiction over siblings. The Court wrote, “Among the factors
cited in [section 300,] subdivision (j) for the court to consider are
the circumstances surrounding, and the nature of, father’s sexual
abuse of his daughter. By citing these factors, subdivision (j)
implies that the more egregious the abuse, the more appropriate
for the juvenile court to assume jurisdiction over the siblings.
(§ 300, subd. (j).) ‘Some risks may be substantial even if they
carry a low degree of probability because the magnitude of the
harm is potentially great. . . . Conversely, a relatively high
probability that a very minor harm will occur probably does not
involve a “substantial” risk. Thus, in order to determine whether
a risk is substantial, the court must consider both the likelihood
that harm will occur and the magnitude of potential harm . . . .’
[Citation.] In other words, the more severe the type of sibling
abuse, the lower the required probability of the child’s
experiencing such abuse to conclude the child is at a substantial
risk of abuse or neglect under section 300. If the sibling abuse is
23
relatively minor, the court might reasonably find insubstantial a
risk the child will be similarly abused; but as the abuse becomes
more serious, it becomes more necessary to protect the child from
even a relatively low probability of that abuse.” (Id. at p. 778.)
Erick C. then states the siblings denied seeing
inappropriate conduct by Erick C. with E.G., they were
comfortable disclosing that their parents physically disciplined
them, and the juvenile court allowed Mother to monitor Erick C.’s
visits with the children; he concludes there was no substantial
evidence that the siblings were at risk at the time of the
jurisdiction hearing. We are at a loss to understand how these
factors establish an absence of risk, or how they relate to the case
law that preceded them. Presumably, Erick C. intends to suggest
these factors tended to establish that there was a low probability
of harm to the siblings, although he does not make any such
argument explicitly.
While not identical in their facts, both this case and I.J.
involve digital penetration and rape of a child, and both assess
the risk to siblings present in the home during the abuse. Like
the I.J. Court, we find the sexual abuse “ ‘aberrant in the
extreme.’ ” (I.J., supra, 56 Cal.4th at p. 778.) “Also relevant to
the totality of the circumstances surrounding the sibling abuse is
the violation of trust shown by sexually abusing one child while
the other children were living in the same home and could easily
have learned of or even interrupted the abuse. ‘[S]exual or other
serious physical abuse of a child by an adult constitutes a
fundamental betrayal of the appropriate relationship between the
generations. . . . When a parent abuses his or her own
child, . . . the parent also abandons and contravenes the parental
role. Such misparenting is among the specific compelling
24
circumstances which may justify state intervention, including an
interruption of parental custody.’ ” (Ibid.) The serious and
repeated abuse of E.G. under these circumstances supports the
juvenile court’s finding that the risk of abuse was substantial as
to all the children.
DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed.
STRATTON, P. J.
We concur:
WILEY, J.
MATTHEWS, J.*
* Judge of the Los Angeles Superior Court, assigned by the
Chief Justice pursuant to article VI, section 6 of the California
Constitution.
25
Filed 7/1/25
CERTIFIED FOR PUBLICATION
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION EIGHT
In re E.G. et al., Persons Coming B338002
Under the Juvenile Court Law.
(Los Angeles County
LOS ANGELES COUNTY Super. Ct. No. 23CCJP03814A–C)
DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN AND
FAMILY SERVICES, ORDER CERTIFYING OPINION
Plaintiff and Respondent, FOR PUBLICATION
v. [NO CHANGE IN JUDGMENT
ERICK C.,
Defendant and Appellant.
THE COURT:
The opinion in the above-entitled matter filed on June 10, 2025, was
not certified for publication in the Official Reports. For good cause, it now
appears that the opinion should be published in the Official Reports, and it is
so ordered.
There is no change in the judgment.
________________________________________________________________________
STRATTON, P. J. WILEY, J. MATTHEWS, J.*
* Judge of the Los Angeles Superior Court, assigned by the Chief Justice
pursuant to article VI, section 6 of the California Constitution.
Ti chiedi come si applica questo testo alla tua situazione?
Consulenza gratuita, senza impegno
Descrivi la tua situazione. Il nostro team ti ricontatterà via e-mail per la tua consulenza.
Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude
Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.