CourtListener 10617039•People v. Padilla CA2/1
Testo completo
Filed 6/25/25 P. v. Padilla CA2/1
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION ONE
THE PEOPLE, B335159
Plaintiff and Respondent, (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No. TA156824)
v.
HECTOR PADILLA,
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of Los
Angeles County, Laura Walton, Judge. Affirmed.
Brad Kaiserman, under appointment by the Court of
Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Rob Bonta, Attorney General, Lance E. Winters, Chief
Assistant Attorney General, Susan Sullivan Pithey, Assistant
Attorney General, Idan Ivri and David A. Wildman, Deputy
Attorneys General, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
__________________________________
Hector Padilla appeals from a judgment entered after a
jury found him guilty of first degree murder and found true the
allegation that he personally used a firearm in the commission of
the murder. The trial court sentenced him to 35 years to life in
state prison.
Padilla asks us to reverse his conviction, arguing the trial
court erred in allowing a detective who investigated the murder
to offer his lay opinion that Padilla was one of the individuals
seen on surveillance video at the crime scene at the time of the
murder. We conclude Padilla forfeited this contention, and we
reject his claim that his trial counsel rendered ineffective
assistance, as admission of the evidence was proper.
In the alternative, Padilla challenges the firearm
enhancement, arguing the trial court was required to dismiss it
under Penal Code1 section 1385 because the “application of [the]
enhancement could result in a sentence of over 20 years.”
(§ 1385, subd. (c)(2)(C).) We conclude Padilla misinterprets the
applicability of this statutory provision, and he has asserted no
valid ground for dismissal of the enhancement. Accordingly, we
affirm the judgment.
BACKGROUND
On December 9, 2021, Eldon Meighan was killed by a
gunshot wound to the head. Appellant Padilla was charged with
the murder. Before Padilla’s case went to trial, his codefendant,
1 Undesignated statutory references are to the Penal Code.
2
Jose Arturo Garza, pleaded no contest to being an accessory after
the fact to the murder of Meighan.
The following is a summary of pertinent evidence the
prosecution presented at Padilla’s trial. Padilla did not present
any evidence in his defense.
A. The Homicide
No trial witness presented an eyewitness account of the
shooting. Geraldine Tench, Meighan’s mother, was in the home
she shared with Meighan and her two other sons2 when Meighan
was shot outside at the end of their driveway. Tench did not see
the shooting or hear a gunshot. She testified at trial about
circumstances she observed before and after the shooting.
Tench arrived home from work in the evening on December
9, 2021, and saw Meighan painting in the living room. She went
to her bedroom to take a nap. She awoke when someone banged
on her bedroom door and shouted, “ ‘Mom. Mom, Indio shot
Eldon [Meighan]. Mom. Mom.’ ” She opened the door and saw
Alan Magana, who “looked scared and frantic, [and] just kept
repeating, ‘Indio shot Eldon.’ ” Magana, who was friendly with
Meighan and one of Meighan’s brothers, was a frequent visitor at
Tench’s home, and he typically called her mom.3
Tench exited her home and ran down a driveway that led
from her home and an adjacent apartment building to Imperial
2 References in this opinion to “Meighan” are to the victim
Eldon Meighan, although one of Tench’s other sons shares the
same surname.
3 Magana did not testify at trial.A detective interviewed
him six weeks after the shooting but could not locate him
thereafter.
3
Highway. Magana followed her out. Tench found Meighan lying
at the end of the driveway at Imperial Highway. She did not
notice anyone else outside until she screamed for help and
neighbors came outside. Meighan died from a gunshot wound to
the head.
During the investigation of the shooting, Tench provided a
detective with a photo of a profile picture from a social media
account, and she told the detective the man in the photo was
“Indio.” The username on the social media account was “Indio
Hector Padilla.” At trial, Tench identified appellant Padilla as
Indio. She provided the detective with another photo of a man
she called “Turo.” The name on the social media account
associated with this photo was “Turo Garza”; and the man in the
photo was Padilla’s former codefendant Jose Arturo Garza.
B. The Investigation of the Shooting
There were no shell casings found at the crime scene, and
the murder weapon was not identified at trial.
1. Discovery of surveillance video
A police officer who canvassed the area after the shooting
observed a camera mounted on a residential building next door to
Tench’s home, east of the driveway where the shooting occurred.
The officer spoke with a woman inside the building, who said she
had heard an argument next door but did not see what happened.
Using an iPad, she showed the officer surveillance video from the
camera, which captured several people on the driveway around
the time of the shooting. The officer used his cell phone to record
a 90-second clip of the surveillance video from the iPad. The
prosecutor played this video at trial (People’s Exhibit No. 36).
4
Los Angeles Police Department (LAPD) Detective Francisco
Zaragoza was assigned as the lead investigator in this case.
After he reviewed the officer’s cell phone recording of surveillance
video, he asked the homicide bureau’s intelligence gathering unit
to try to obtain additional surveillance video of the crime scene.
An officer from that unit contacted the owner of the same
residential building next door to Tench’s home and received
permission to download 65 minutes of surveillance video captured
by the camera on the building. As presented at trial, this
surveillance video (People’s Exhibit No. 10) was split into two
video files, each around 30 minutes in length, and each showing
the area around the crime scene from three different camera
angles.
In this appeal, Padilla challenges the admissibility of
Detective Zaragoza’s lay opinion testimony that Padilla is one of
the individuals shown in the surveillance video in People’s
Exhibit No. 10.4 Before we describe Zaragoza’s testimony
regarding the events depicted in the video, we set forth his
testimony explaining the methods he used to identify the
individuals in the video.
2. Detective Zaragoza’s investigation to determine
the identities of the individuals in the
surveillance video
The surveillance video captured five people on the driveway
at the time of the shooting, including Meighan.
4 Hereafter, references to the surveillance video are to
People’s Exhibit No. 10.
5
a. Derrick Elder
A few days after the shooting, Detective Zaragoza went
back to the crime scene and saw a man on the driveway.
Zaragoza spoke to him and learned that his name was Derrick
Elder. He agreed to go to the station for an interview but never
appeared. Zaragoza identified Elder as one of the individuals in
the surveillance video. During her trial testimony, Tench also
identified Elder in the video, referring to him as “Mad Ru.” She
explained that she knew him because he was “always there in the
driveway.”
b. Alan Magana
During his investigation, Detective Zaragoza spoke with
Magana. According to Tench’s trial testimony, Magana is the
man who told Tench immediately after the shooting that Indio
shot Meighan. Zaragoza’s interview with Magana (and an
interview with Tench) helped Zaragoza identify the other men in
the surveillance video, including appellant Padilla. According to
Zaragoza’s trial testimony, although Magana said during the
interview that he only heard the gunshot and did not actually see
the shooting occur, he disclosed other observations he made on
the driveway that night that were consistent with his statement
that Indio shot Meighan and with what Zaragoza observed on the
surveillance video.5 Zaragoza testified that Magana was one of
the individuals shown in the video.
c. Jose Arturo Garza
The surveillance video showed a car pull up to the driveway
before the shooting. Two men exited. After the shooting, the
5 Detective Zaragoza did not elaborate as to what Magana
said he observed.
6
vehicle left the area with the same two men. Based on the
characteristics of the vehicle as depicted in the video, Detective
Zaragoza believed the vehicle was a Chevrolet Malibu. He was
able to obtain the vehicle’s license plate number from the video,
and he used software available to the LAPD to identify the
registered owner of the Malibu as Jose Arturo Garza. The
residential address listed for Garza on registration and
ownership documents associated with the vehicle was located
around four blocks from the crime scene. Through additional
research, Zaragoza determined that a woman named Virginia
Padilla Garza lived at the same address. He also determined
during the course of his investigation that Garza and Padilla
were cousins.
Zaragoza obtained a search warrant for cell phone records
in Garza’s name. The records indicated that at the time of the
shooting, Garza’s cell phone was connected to a cell tower located
within two-tenths of a mile of the crime scene. The records also
showed that the cell phone account in Garza’s name was
terminated on December 10, 2021, the day after the shooting.
Zaragoza also obtained a search warrant for Facebook
records of social media activity on an account in Garza’s name.
The records showed that Garza and one of Meighan’s brothers
communicated through Facebook’s direct messaging application
between October 21 and December 4, 2021.
Based on these vehicle, cell phone, and social media
records, as well as interviews with Tench and Magana, and a
booking photo of Garza, Zaragoza identified Garza as one of the
7
individuals in the surveillance video. He did not speak with
Garza during his investigation.
d. Appellant Hector Padilla
Detective Zaragoza obtained a search warrant for Facebook
records of social media activity on accounts in Padilla’s name that
used a photo of Padilla as the profile picture. One account in the
name “Hector.Padilla.547” used the screen names “Indio the
Man” and “Indio 211” and included Turo Garza and Mad Ru
(Elder) as followers of the account. Another account in the name
“Indio Hector Padilla” listed Jose Garza as a follower, and the
records showed communications between Padilla’s and Garza’s
accounts.
When Padilla was arrested for Meighan’s murder on
February 23, 2022, an officer took photos of Padilla as part of the
booking process. One of the photos showed a tattoo of the name
“Indio” on Padilla’s back.
Zaragoza testified that he interviewed Padilla after
Padilla’s arrest for around 40 minutes. During the interview,
Zaragoza showed Padilla a still photograph from the surveillance
video, depicting the location where the shooting occurred. Padilla
said Tench’s residence was a “hangout” spot and he had been
there before. He knew that Meighan lived there with his mother
and two brothers and he was able to describe the layout of the
residence. He admitted he had been there on December 9, 2021,
the day of the shooting, but said he was there earlier in the day
in the morning. Zaragoza showed Padilla a photo of Garza, and
Padilla identified him by name and said he was his cousin.
Padilla sought information from Zaragoza, including whether the
surveillance video clearly showed his face and whether the police
8
had recovered the gun used in the shooting. Padilla denied that
he shot Meighan.
Based on Padilla’s social media and booking photos, the
interviews with Tench and Magana, and the 40 minutes he spent
interviewing Padilla at the station, Zaragoza testified that in his
opinion Padilla was one of the individuals in the surveillance
video. He stated that he observed a point in the video when the
glow from a lit cigarette illuminated the face of one of the
individuals and he could discern the man’s features: “short bushy
hair,” “medium to dark complexion,” and a “bony” facial structure
with high cheekbones and a “well defined” jawline. He identified
Padilla as the man in the video with these features.6
3. Detective Zaragoza’s trial testimony regarding
the events shown in the surveillance video
Detective Zaragoza testified that the surveillance video
showed the following:
At around 8:40 p.m. on December 9, 2021, Magana was
sitting on the front steps of Tench’s home. The front door was
closed and the lights were on inside the house. Through the
window, a person was visible who was painting. Elder was
sitting in a vehicle in the driveway.
A Chevrolet Malibu traveled west on Imperial Highway
and stopped in front of the driveway leading to Tench’s residence.
Garza exited from the driver seat and Padilla exited from the
front passenger seat. Elder walked toward the street and made
contact with Garza and Padilla. The three men walked onto the
6 In the Discussion section of this opinion, post, we
summarize the exchange between the parties and the trial court
regarding the admissibility of Detective Zaragoza’s identification
of Padilla in the surveillance video.
9
driveway together. Elder lit a cigarette which “illuminate[d]” his
face in the video. Padilla also had a cigarette in his mouth, and
“the flame illuminat[ed] his face.”
As Garza, Padilla, and Elder spoke, Padilla waved his
hand, pointing north. Meighan and Magana were walking south
on the driveway, away from Tench’s home and toward Imperial
Highway. Padilla greeted Meighan and Magana with a
handshake or a “fist bump.” Padilla and Meighan moved away
from the rest of the group, walking closer to the Malibu. The
passenger side door was open.
Garza walked around the back of the Malibu and toward
the driver side of the car. Elder walked toward the car, but
before he got there, he raised both hands and “started to
backpedal away” from the area. According to Detective Zaragoza,
the video showed some type of “fast motion” in the area where
Padilla was standing, and Padilla entered the front passenger
seat of the car. Elder jumped and looked back at the car,
appearing “startled.” The car drove off. Meighan was lying on
the sidewalk “in a fetal position.”7
C. Jose Garza’s Trial Testimony
Garza testified at trial and admitted he pleaded no contest
to being an accessory after the fact to the murder of Meighan. He
also conceded that he was the man in the social media photo
7 Detective Zaragoza did not identify anything else in the
video indicating that a shooting occurred, and the prosecution did
not argue that there was (e.g., a gun in a hand or a muzzle flash).
10
associated with the account name “Turo Garza” that Tench
provided to Detective Zaragoza.
Garza denied that he ever owned the Chevrolet Malibu
shown in the surveillance video. He acknowledged that the
Department of Motor Vehicles registration and ownership
documents for the vehicle listed his name and correct home
address, but he asserted that the documents were “falsified.”
He also denied that he used the nickname Turo or the
Facebook account that was in his name and displayed his photo
as the profile picture. He claimed someone else made the
account, and the communications between him and Meighan’s
brother reflected on the account (referenced above) were not his.
He said he did not know Meighan’s brother.
Garza also testified that he did not know anyone named
Hector Padilla, and he was not familiar with the nickname Indio.
The prosecutor showed Garza a Facebook business record
showing contacts for “Cuzzo Indio” and “Hec. Indio” on the
account in him name. Garza said he did not know who those
people were and he did not have a cousin who used the name
Indio. He also said he did not recognize anyone in the courtroom
(i.e., Padilla).
D. Verdicts and Sentencing
The jury found Padilla guilty of first degree murder and
also found true the allegation that he personally used a firearm
in the commission of the murder, within the meaning of section
12022.5, subdivision (a).
In a sentencing memorandum, the district attorney urged
the trial court to sentence Padilla to 35 years to life in state
prison, 25 years to life for the murder, plus the high term of 10
11
years for the firearm enhancement. The district attorney
acknowledged in the memorandum that Padilla’s potential
exposure was more than 35 years to life based on prior conviction
allegations in the information: a prior serious felony allegation
(§ 667, subd. (a)) and a prior strike conviction allegation (§§ 667,
subds. (b)-(i) & 1170.12, subds. (a)-(d)).
In his sentencing memorandum, Padilla asked the court to
impose a sentence of 25 years to life. He requested the court
dismiss the prior conviction allegations and the firearm
enhancement. Among other things, he argued section 1385
required the dismissal of an enhancement when the “application
of [the] enhancement could result in a sentence of over 20 years.”
(§ 1385, subd. (c)(2)(C).)
The trial court found the prior conviction allegations to be
true, but exercised its discretion to strike the prior serious felony
enhancement and dismiss the prior strike. Both sides submitted
without argument on sentencing. The court sentenced Padilla to
35 years to life in state prison, 25 years to life for the murder,
plus the high term of 10 years for the firearm enhancement. The
court explained that it selected the high term based on the facts
of the case, Padilla’s criminal history, and the fact the court
declined to impose punishment for the prior serious felony
enhancement and the prior strike.
12
DISCUSSION
A. Padilla Forfeited His Challenge to the Admission of
Detective Zaragoza’s Opinion That Padilla Was
Shown in the Surveillance Video, and His Counsel
Did Not Render Ineffective Assistance
Padilla contends “the prosecution laid an insufficient
foundation for the admission of Det. Zaragoza’s lay opinion
identifying Padilla in the surveillance footage,” and the trial
court should have excluded the testimony. He also contends the
admission of the evidence rendered his trial fundamentally unfair
in violation of his federal and state constitutional rights.
1. Proceedings below
During Detective Zaragoza’s trial testimony, after he had
narrated the events he observed in the surveillance video without
offering his opinion that Padilla was one of the men in the video,
the prosecutor showed Zaragoza a still photograph from the video
(People’s Exhibit No. 50) and asked him if the man in the photo
“with the lit cigarette” was in the courtroom. Defense counsel
objected based on lack of foundation and speculation. The parties
and the trial court had a conference at sidebar.
The court asked the prosecutor “what foundation [he had]
to lay and offer for this detective to make an identification from
the video.” The prosecutor responded:
“The identification is his own lay opinion after reviewing it
dozens of times, zooming in.
“He said he checked social media. He checked booking
photos. He actually had an interview with the defendant that
hasn’t been established as of yet. But it’s just asking for his own
13
lay opinion, which the jurors themselves will have to do, in fact,
as finders of fact, to say that it’s the man who is on the video.
“So, it’s just a lay opinion, not -- nothing more. Nothing
more than his own lay opinion from his investigation and the
multiple photographs and time spent investigating this case.”
Defense counsel responded:
“I think having him identify based on his own opinion is
prejudicial. The jury can look at the video, look at the pictures
themselves. They will get all of that stuff themselves and they
can make that decision themselves.
“But what he testified to is the picture, the video itself is
grainy. He talked about certain features that he noticed from the
person that is in the video and in the photograph. But then to let
him draw the conclusion and give the jurors, basically, his own
positive I.D. based on grainy video and photographs that he,
himself, used that word ‘grainy,’ is – is far too prejudicial.[8]
“Again, they are gonna be able to see the picture. They are
watching the defendant here in court. They will be able to make
8 Detective Zaragoza did not testify that the surveillance
video was grainy. He stated that People’s Exhibit No. 50, the still
photograph from the surveillance video that the prosecutor
showed him, was “a lot grainer” than the video.
In closing argument, the prosecutor indicated the reason a
muzzle flash was not visible in the surveillance video was
because the video was “dark[,] grainy, albeit poor quality.” She
added, “But you know what’s not poor quality? What is not poor
quality is the moment that that cigarette is lit, giving you the
ability to see the facial contours of Hector Padilla’s face. Very
distinct bone structure, cheek structure, goatee, which is the hair
that is around his upper lip and lower chin, the posture and the
slimness of his body throughout the entire video.”
14
that decision themselves whether they think that the grainy
video looks like Mr. Padilla.
“I don’t think – I think it’s far too prejudicial to allow the
detective at this point to identify Mr. Padilla and make that a
definitive positive I.D.”
The prosecutor added:
“And the People do not agree with everything just said.
But what he essentially says, it goes to weight, not admissibility.
“And the cross-examination of his identification likely will
be like an identification expert or handwriting expert, anyone can
give their lay opinion or their expert opinion. It’s up for cross-
examination because it goes to the weight and not the
admissibility.
“So if this detective of 15 years reviewing the surveillance a
dozen times, possibly on equipment that is more clear than what
is presented in the courtroom’s material, further investigation
with the name, social media, booking photos, interview, he can
give his own lay opinion, which the defense attorney can explore
to her heart’s content on cross-examination as it goes to the -- it
goes to the weight. That information is for the jury to ultimately
determine on their own.”
The court stated that a police officer could not make a
positive identification of a suspect in a video unless the officer
had personal contact with the suspect, “an opportunity to meet,
see, speak to the defendant, and then peruse the videos.”
Therefore, the court sustained defense counsel’s objection “until
and unless [the prosecutor could] lay that proper foundation.” In
an exchange with the prosecutor regarding how to lay the
foundation, the court stated: “Did you interview the defendant?
[¶] Yes. [¶] When? Where? How long did that interview take
15
place? What did the interview consist of? Was anybody else
present -- to lay that he’s, at least, had some personal contact
throughout his investigation with him. And then after having
that personal interview with him, however -- and that goes to the
weight -- the length, the time, the location of the interview goes
to the weight of his lay opinion as to who was in the video.”
Defense counsel did not dispute that Detective Zaragoza could
offer his lay opinion that Padilla was the person shown in
People’s Exhibit No. 50 and throughout the surveillance video if
Zaragoza testified to personal contact with Padilla during a post-
arrest interview.
When the direct examination of Zaragoza resumed, the
prosecutor showed Zaragoza a photograph and asked if he knew
when it was taken. Zaragoza said it was a booking photo of
Padilla. The prosecutor asked if Zaragoza had personally come
into contact with Padilla on the day he was booked. Zaragoza
testified that on that day, he had contact with Padilla for around
40 minutes and had an opportunity to see and observe him. After
that contact with Padilla, Zaragoza went back and reviewed the
surveillance video and social media content. The prosecutor
asked Zaragoza, “After you reviewed that information -- going
back to People’s 50 -- with the time that you spent personally
with the defendant, Mr. Padilla, can you identify in your own lay
opinion who that is depicted in People’s 50?” Zaragoza identified
Padilla. Defense counsel raised no further objection to Zaragoza’s
identification of Padilla in the surveillance video.9
9 Later in his testimony, Detective Zaragoza discussed the
substance of his interview with Padilla, as summarized above.
And he reiterated that his interaction with Padilla on the day he
16
2. Padilla forfeited his challenge to the admission
of the evidence
The Attorney General argues Padilla forfeited his challenge
to the admission of Detective Zaragoza’s lay opinion testimony
identifying Padilla in the surveillance video. We agree.
To preserve an appellate challenge to the admission of
evidence, a defendant must make a timely objection to the
evidence, making “clear the specific ground of the objection.”
(Evid. Code, § 353, subd. (a); People v. Partida (2005) 37 Cal.4th
428, 433.) “An objection is sufficient if it fairly apprises the trial
court of the issue it is being called upon to decide.” (People v.
Scott (1978) 21 Cal.3d 284, 290.) A corollary of this rule is that a
“party cannot argue [on appeal that] the [trial] court erred in
failing to conduct an analysis it was not asked to conduct.”
(Partida, at p. 435.)
Defense counsel objected to Zaragoza’s opinion testimony
based on lack of foundation and speculation before the
prosecution ultimately laid a foundation by eliciting testimony
that Zaragoza had personally interacted with Padilla. The
parties and the trial court had a discussion about how the
prosecution could lay a sufficient foundation for the opinion
testimony. The court noted that the foundation for the opinion
should include when and where the contact took place, how long
it lasted, and the nature of the contact. When the prosecutor
indicated that the contact was a post-arrest interview with
Padilla, defense counsel did not dispute that testimony regarding
was arrested assisted him in forming his opinion that Padilla was
shown on the surveillance video. He had an opportunity that day
to observe Padilla sitting and standing and he was able to
ascertain his size and physique.
17
such an interview could establish a sufficient foundation. The
court sustained the defense’s objection “until and unless” the
prosecution could lay a sufficient foundation. The court did not
rule that the testimony was inadmissible.
In accord with the trial court’s ruling, the prosecutor
examined Zaragoza about the nature and extent of his personal
contact with Padilla, and Zaragoza testified in response. Then,
the prosecutor asked Zaragoza for his opinion as to the identity of
the person in a still photograph from the surveillance video, and
Zaragoza identified Padilla. The court allowed the questions and
answers, and there was no further discussion on the issue.
Padilla’s contention on appeal that there was “insufficient
foundation for the admission of Det. Zaragoza’s lay opinion
identifying Padilla in the surveillance footage” is forfeited. The
prosecution laid a foundation for the opinion testimony in the
manner suggested by the court and with the acquiescence of
defense counsel. The defense gave no indication it believed the
foundation remained insufficient. To preserve this contention for
appellate review, it was incumbent on the defense to raise an
objection to the sufficiency of the foundation the prosecution
ultimately laid (or to make a motion to strike the testimony if
defense counsel believed a renewed objection was unnecessary
but the foundation was still insufficient). Instead, by its silence,
the defense indicated it believed the prosecutor cured the lack of
foundation issue, and the testimony was admitted. Padilla
cannot challenge the sufficiency of the foundation now, without
having given the prosecutor an opportunity to respond to an
objection or a motion to strike, or the court an opportunity to
rule.
18
We reject Padilla’s assertion that, “Because the trial court
ruled that the prosecution only needed to prove essentially any
personal contact between Det. Zaragoza and Padilla, and because
the prosecution did so, any further objection would have been
futile in light of the court’s ruling.” If the defense believed the
post-arrest interview was insufficient personal contact to lay a
foundation for the opinion, it was required to say so in order to
preserve the contention for review. Instead, as discussed above,
defense counsel remained silent when the court outlined how the
prosecutor could lay a foundation for the opinion, and defense
counsel registered no objection to the proposed method or to the
testimony itself.
Padilla’s claim that the admission of the evidence rendered
his trial fundamentally unfair in violation of his federal and state
constitutional rights is also forfeited. To preserve a
constitutional claim arising out of a trial court’s decision to
exclude or admit evidence, a defendant must raise the claim in
the trial court. (People v. Riggs (2008) 44 Cal.4th 248, 292.)
Before the prosecutor laid a foundation for the opinion testimony,
defense counsel asserted admission of the evidence was
“prejudicial,” arguing that the jury was in the same position as
Detective Zaragoza to identify Padilla in the surveillance video.
However, defense counsel did not raise a constitutional claim or
even maintain that the admission of the evidence was prejudicial
in light of Zaragoza’s testimony regarding his personal contact
with Padilla.
Padilla argues, if there was a forfeiture, his counsel
rendered ineffective assistance. Accordingly, we must address
the merits of his challenge to the admission of the evidence.
19
3. Defense counsel was not ineffective in deciding
not to challenge the sufficiency of the
foundation the prosecution laid or raise a
constitutional challenge to the admission of the
evidence
To prevail on an ineffective assistance of counsel claim, a
defendant must show: “(1) that defense counsel’s performance
fell below an objective standard of reasonableness, i.e., that
counsel’s performance did not meet the standard to be expected of
a reasonably competent attorney, and (2) that there is a
reasonable probability that defendant would have obtained a
more favorable result absent counsel’s shortcomings.” (People v.
Cunningham (2001) 25 Cal.4th 926, 1003, citing Strickland v.
Washington (1984) 466 U.S. 668, 687-694.) We conclude Padilla
has not established the first prong of this test, so we need not
reach the second.
“A lay witness may offer opinion testimony if it is rationally
based on the witness’s perception and helpful to a clear
understanding of the witness’s testimony. (Evid. Code, § 800.)
‘[T]he identity of a person is a proper subject of nonexpert
opinion. . . .’ ” (People v. Leon (2015) 61 Cal.4th 569, 601 (Leon).)
“Court of appeal decisions have long upheld admission of
testimony identifying defendants in surveillance footage or
photographs.” (Ibid.)
On appeal, Padilla argues there was insufficient foundation
for Detective Zaragoza’s opinion identifying him in the
surveillance video because Zaragoza had no contact with him
until after the crime. Defense counsel’s performance did not fall
below an objective standard of reasonableness in deciding not to
argue to the trial court that a post-arrest interview was
20
insufficient foundation to support Zaragoza’s opinion. Long
before Padilla’s trial, in Leon, supra, 61 Cal.4th 569, our Supreme
Court rejected the defendant’s argument that post-arrest contact
between the detective and the defendant—as opposed to pre-
arrest contact—was insufficient to support the detective’s opinion
that the defendant was shown in surveillance videos of two
robberies, deeming it a “distinction without a difference.” (Id. at
pp. 600, 601.) The Supreme Court explained, “It is undisputed
[the detective] was familiar with defendant’s appearance around
the time of the crimes. Their contact began when defendant was
arrested, one day after the . . . robbery. Questions about the
extent of [the detective]’s familiarity with defendant’s appearance
went to the weight, not the admissibility, of his testimony. . . .
Moreover, because the surveillance video was played for the jury,
jurors could make up their own minds about whether the person
shown was defendant. Because [the detective]’s testimony was
based on his relevant personal knowledge and aided the jury, the
court did not abuse its discretion by admitting it.” (Id. at p. 601.)
Padilla attempts to distinguish Leon, arguing, “[U]nlike in
Leon, in which the detective saw the defendant nearly ten times
after his arrest [citation], here, Det. Zaragoza only testified to the
single interview with Padilla.[10] Moreover, unlike in Leon, in
which the detective was familiar with the defendant’s distinctive
jacket that was worn in the surveillance footage and worn on the
day of the defendant’s arrest, here, there was no distinctive
clothing that Det. Zaragoza was familiar with.” While these
factors may be relevant to the weight of Zaragoza’s opinion
10 The detective in Leon “spent about two hours” total with
the defendant during the course of “nearly 10” contacts with him.
(Leon, supra, 61 Cal.4th at p. 600.)
21
testimony, they do not bear on the admissibility of the testimony.
In closing argument, defense counsel commented on the weight of
Zaragoza’s opinion testimony:
“Another thing he [Detective Zaragoza] said was he spent
approximately 40 minutes with Mr. Padilla and made a
determination that the person in the video has to be Padilla.
That was the only time he ever met Mr. Padilla. He never had
any prior contacts, and since then he hasn’t had any other
contacts. 40 minutes. [¶] You as jurors have been sitting here
with Mr. Padilla for days. Can you, having sat here with Mr.
Padilla, say with certainty that the person in that video is
actually him, with the poor quality, the poor lighting? And not
actually knowing him or anyone else in his family that might look
like him? Can you say with certainty that that is him?”
“The constitutional guaranty of effective assistance of
counsel . . . does not require counsel make every conceivable
[objection] to avoid being deemed incompetent.” (People v. Kelley
(1990) 220 Cal.App.3d 1358, 1374.) Defense counsel was not
ineffective for failing to object to the foundation set forth by the
prosecution; as just explained, any such objection would not have
been well-taken, and the trial court properly admitted the lay
opinion testimony. The prosecution established that Zaragoza
had close, personal contact with Padilla near the time of the
shooting and was familiar with his physical characteristics.11
Such “relevant personal knowledge” was helpful to the jury, but
the “jurors could make up their own minds about whether the
person shown” in the video was Padilla (Leon, supra, 61 Cal.4th
11 Padilla was arrested two and a half months after the
crime. No evidence was presented at trial indicating his
appearance changed during that time.
22
at p. 601), as defense counsel encouraged them to do. There was
no state law error or violation of Padilla’s constitutional rights.
B. The Trial Court Did Not Err in Imposing the Firearm
Enhancement
Padilla contends section 1385, subdivision (c)(2)(C),
required dismissal of the firearm enhancement, and the trial
court erred in imposing it. The Attorney General argues Padilla
forfeited this contention because he did not make clear in his
sentencing memorandum that his citation of this statutory
provision related to the firearm enhancement; rather, he asserted
it precluded imposition of punishment for a prior strike
conviction. (But see, e.g., People v. Olay (2023) 98 Cal.App.5th
60, 67 [“[S]ection 1385, subdivision (c) does not apply to the Three
Strikes law”].) Although we agree with the Attorney General
that Padilla’s sentencing memorandum could have been clearer
on this point, we conclude that his discussion of section 1385,
subdivision (c)(2)(C), and its application to enhancements,
preserved the issue for review. But even if we found forfeiture,
we would address the issue on the merits because our resolution
of the contention involves a pure question of law. (See People v.
Welch (1993) 5 Cal.4th 228, 235 [cases reviewing the merits of a
claim of sentencing error, raised for the first time on appeal,
“generally involve pure questions of law that can be resolved
without reference to the particular sentencing record developed
in the trial court”].)
Under section 1385, “Notwithstanding any other law, the
court shall dismiss an enhancement if it is in the furtherance of
justice to do so, except if dismissal of that enhancement is
prohibited by any initiative statute.” (§ 1385, subd. (c)(1).)
23
Section 1385 lists nine mitigating circumstances, each of which
“weighs greatly in favor of dismissing the enhancement, unless
the court finds that dismissal of the enhancement would
endanger public safety.” (§ 1385, subd. (c)(2).)
Padilla contends that one of the nine mitigating
circumstances applies here and requires that the firearm
enhancement imposed under section 12022.5, subdivision (a), be
dismissed. He invokes subdivision (c)(2)(C) of section 1385,
which provides, “The application of an enhancement could result
in a sentence of over 20 years. In this instance, the enhancement
shall be dismissed.”
Padilla misinterprets the applicability of this mitigating
circumstance. On its face, subdivision (c)(2)(C) of section 1385
applies only when a sentence of over 20 years could result
because of the application of the enhancement. (See Couzens,
Bigelow & Prickett, Sentencing Cal. Crimes (The Rutter Group
2024) § 12:11, subd. (F)(3) [“There will be no entitlement to relief
[under section 1385, subdivision (c)(2)(C)] unless it is the
application of the term for the enhancement that results in a
sentence longer than 20 years”].)
Here, the trial court could not have imposed a lesser
sentence for the first degree murder than it did—25 years to life.
(See § 190, subd. (a).) Given that sentence, the application of the
firearm enhancement here could not have resulted in a sentence
of over 20 years, and Padilla is not eligible for relief under
subdivision (c)(2)(C) of section 1385. He cites no case indicating
section 1385 forecloses imposition of a firearm enhancement on a
first degree murder conviction, and we are aware of none.
Padilla also argues the trial court erred in imposing the
firearm enhancement because the court did not make a finding
24
that “dismissal of the enhancement would endanger public
safety,” under subdivision (c)(2) of section 1385. The trial court
need only make such a finding if it first finds one of the
mitigating circumstances enumerated in subdivision (c)(2)(A)-(I)
of the statute: “Proof of the presence of one or more of these
[mitigating] circumstances weighs greatly in favor of dismissing
the enhancement, unless the court finds that dismissal of the
enhancement would endanger public safety.” (§ 1385, subd.
(c)(2).) Padilla only cites one mitigating circumstance and, as we
have already concluded, it is inapplicable here. Thus, the court
was not required to make a finding regarding whether dismissal
of the enhancement would endanger public safety.
Padilla raises no other argument indicating it was in the
furtherance of justice to dismiss the firearm enhancement under
section 1385. Thus, we have no cause to order dismissal of the
enhancement.
DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED
M. KIM, J.
We concur:
BENDIX, Acting P. J.
WEINGART, J.
25
Ti chiedi come si applica questo testo alla tua situazione?
Consulenza gratuita, senza impegno
Descrivi la tua situazione. Il nostro team ti ricontatterà via e-mail per la tua consulenza.
Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude
Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.