CourtListener 10599199•People v. Lazaro CA4/3
Testo completo
Filed 6/5/25 P. v. Lazaro CA4/3
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION THREE
THE PEOPLE,
Plaintiff and Respondent, G064321
v. (Super. Ct. No. RIF1804114)
ENRIQUE LAZARO, OPINION
Defendant and Appellant.
Appeal from a judgment of the Superior Court of Riverside
County, Joshlyn R. Pulliam, Judge. Affirmed.
Christine M. Aros, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for
Defendant and Appellant.
Rob Bonta, Attorney General, Lance E. Winters, Chief Assistant
Attorney General, Charles C. Ragland, Assistant Attorney General, Arlene A.
Sevidal and Jon S. Tangonan, Deputy Attorneys General, for Plaintiff and
Respondent.
A jury found Enrique Lazaro guilty of second degree murder.
1
(Pen. Code, § 187. subd. (a).) He contends the jury should have instead
convicted him of voluntary manslaughter because the prosecution failed to
disprove beyond a reasonable doubt his claim that he was provoked into a
heat of passion. (§ 192, subd. (a).) We reject the contention because
substantial evidence supports the judgment. We affirm.
FACTS
I.
THE KILLING
In 2014, then 25-year-old Lazaro, met 19-year-old N.G. The
couple married about one year later.
N.G.’s first pregnancy was unsuccessful. By the spring of 2017,
she became pregnant again, but soon discovered Lazaro had a mistress.
Lazaro left N.G. in May and filed for divorce in June. N.G. was introduced to
Arturo Angel in August and gave birth to her son in December.
Lazaro began trying to reconcile with N.G. after their son was
born. By February 2018, Lazaro correctly suspected N.G. was dating another
person, but she denied it. N.G. would later testify that, at that time, she was
“in a way playing with [Lazaro’s] emotions because [she] was still hurt.” She
then realized she pitied him because she no longer loved him. In March, there
was a physical altercation between Lazaro and Angel.
For the sake of their son, N.G. tried to live with Lazaro in an
attempt to reconcile. She testified it lasted only three or four days because
she concluded she “couldn’t be with him.” The “last day” of her relationship
with Lazaro was in early August, when they went to a storage center to
1
All undesignated statutory references are to the Penal Code.
2
divide their personal property. Although N.G. dated Angel exclusively from
that point on, she continued to have contact with Lazaro, whose
communications increased.
Lazaro and N.G. knowingly had software on their cell phones
that tracked the other’s physical location. In addition to her trackable phone,
N.G. had two other phones, and she would regularly change phone numbers.
Lazaro would sometimes use N.G.’s phone to capture screenshots to send to
Angel. Out of fear and to calm Lazaro down, N.G. would occasionally say she
loved him.
Around noon on September 14, 2018, Lazaro confronted N.G. and
Angel in the parking lot of a shopping center where Angel worked. Angel was
with N.G. in her parked vehicle when Lazaro pulled his truck behind N.G.’s
vehicle, blocking it. Angel and N.G. both initially got out of her vehicle but
N.G. went back inside.
The parking lot had a security camera that recorded visual
images only. An investigator who later interviewed N.G. also reviewed the
video. The investigator testified that, based on his experience, after Lazaro
ducked down behind the car, his movements were consistent with racking a
handgun and concealing it. Lazaro then talked to Angel outside of the
vehicle; N.G. could not hear their conversation.
Angel returned to the car and told N.G. to go with Lazaro. Angel
stayed at the shopping center while N.G. followed Lazaro to a nearby parking
lot. Lazaro showed N.G. a gun and fired it into the air. Lazaro was frustrated
because N.G. was with Angel. Lazaro told N.G. that he was ready to kill
Angel if she did not leave with him. N.G. and Lazaro went to a park where
Lazaro gave N.G. a bullet. She would later testify that Lazaro told her “that
bullet was going to be for [her] if [she] were to go back with [Angel].”
3
When Lazaro reached out the next day about possibly going to
the beach, N.G. said she could not meet him because she was going to a
family gathering. After leaving her aunt’s house, N.G. picked up Angel and
later parked about a half mile from his house to talk about their relationship.
To make Angel feel better, N.G. called Lazaro on speakerphone and asked
when Lazaro and N.G. had last been physically intimate. After Lazaro stated
it had been “a while,” N.G., in order to “play [it] cool” and end the call,
suggested to Lazaro that they might meet later.
Lazaro found the call “very odd” and used the phone software to
track N.G. After she did not pick up his calls, Lazaro texted several messages
to her, including: “The wrath of God is going to fall on you.” About an hour
later, Lazaro arrived to see N.G. kissing Angel while on top of him in the
passenger seat of her car.
The window of Angel’s door was open and Lazaro tried to open
the passenger door as he pointed his gun at Angel’s head. Lazaro started
“being rough, trying to force [his gun] in [Angel’s] mouth.” Angel raised his
hand and opened his mouth. Lazaro fired the gun inside Angel’s mouth,
killing him.
N.G. started screaming. Lazaro went to her on the other side of
the vehicle and pulled the keys from the ignition. Lazaro requested N.G. to
help bury Angel’s body. N.G. told Lazaro she would give him 20 minutes
before calling the police, fearing she might also be shot, and Lazaro left.
II.
THE TRIAL
Lazaro was arrested two days after the killing and interviewed
by an investigating officer. The testimonies of N.G., Lazaro, and the officer all
included commentary on the recording of the parking lot events the day
4
before the killing, which was played for the jury. Lazaro claimed that what
the investigator thought was a gun was instead Lazaro’s cell phone.
Lazaro also disputed many points of N.G.’s testimony about the
events described above. For example, he claimed he never threatened N.G.
the day before the killing, that she “snatched” a bullet from his hand instead
of him handing it to her, and that it had been N.G.’s idea to go to the beach
the following day.
Lazaro also claimed that, the day before the killing, Angel
taunted him by saying N.G. and Angel had engaged in intercourse in all of
Lazaro’s vehicles and that he would not be needed if Lazaro “‘could take care
of business.’” Lazaro also claimed that within a month of the killing, he and
Angel had talked, and Angel had made threats against Lazaro, N.G., and
their son.
Lazaro testified that, on the night of the killing, he took out his
gun in part because he saw Angel reach down for something, but “mostly out
of the emotions that [he] was going through, . . . the rage that [he] was going
through.” He described that his feelings “fog[ged]” his mind.
Lazaro claimed Angel guided the gun into his own mouth in a
“challenging way.” Lazaro testified that the gun fired because he “was
distracted . . . trying to open the door” and that he felt “some type of pressure
at [his] hand.” Lazaro left the scene because he was in shock; he denied
N.G.’s claim that he asked her to help bury Angel’s body.
During closing arguments, the prosecutor argued that Lazaro
had committed willful, deliberate, and premeditated first degree murder.
Lazaro’s counsel argued that N.G. had been engaged in an affair and that the
sequence of events leading to the killing amounted to sufficient provocation to
mitigate liability to manslaughter.
5
The jury was instructed, inter alia, on the concept of provocation
for both determining the degree of murder liability (CALCRIM No. 522) and,
alternatively, for deciding whether Lazaro should be guilty of voluntary
manslaughter instead of murder (CALCRIM No. 570). The jury was also
instructed on CALCRIM No. 226, which addresses the jury’s role of
determining witness credibility.
The jury found Lazaro not guilty of first degree murder, guilty of
second degree murder (§ 187, subd. (a)), and that he caused the death by
personally and intentionally discharging a firearm (§§ 12022.53, subd. (d),
1192.7, subd. (c)(8)). Lazaro filed an unsuccessful motion to reduce his
conviction to voluntary manslaughter, pursuant to section 1181. The trial
court considered mitigation of Lazaro’s sentence based on claims of childhood
abuse and lack of criminal history, but noted those factors did not minimize
the violence of the crime. The court then imposed a prison term of 15 years to
life, plus 25 years to life for the firearm enhancement, for a total term of 40
years to life.
DISCUSSION
As noted, Lazaro contends the prosecutor did not meet his trial
burden to demonstrate Lazaro was guilty of murder rather than voluntary
manslaughter due to heat of passion provocation.
I.
STANDARD OF REVIEW
In reviewing a claim of insufficient evidence, we “‘“review the
entire record in the light most favorable to the judgment,”’ and then
determine whether it contains ‘“evidence that is reasonable, credible, and of
solid value”’ such that a reasonable jury could have found the defendant
guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. [Citations.] . . . [¶] We must ‘“presume in
6
support of the judgment the existence of every fact the jury could reasonably
have deduced from the evidence . . . ‘ . . . for it is the exclusive province of the
trial judge or jury to determine the credibility of a witness and the truth or
falsity of the facts upon which a determination depends. [Citations.]’”’”
(People v. Ware (2022) 14 Cal.5th 151, 167 (Ware).)
II.
LAW ON PROVOCATION
Malice aforethought is a necessary element of murder, other than
felony murder. (§ 188, subd. (a)(3).) By contrast, the lesser included offense of
“[m]anslaughter is the unlawful killing of a human being without malice.”
(§ 192; see People v. Duff (2014) 58 Cal.4th 527, 561.)
As the jury was correctly instructed in this case, “heat of passion”
voluntary manslaughter (§ 192, subd. (a)) requires an alignment of three
elements: (1) “The defendant was provoked”; (2) “As a result . . . , the
defendant acted rashly and under the influence of intense emotion that
obscured [the defendant’s] reasoning or judgment”; and (3) “the provocation
would have caused a person of average disposition to act rashly and without
due deliberation . . . from passion rather than judgment.” (CALCRIM
No. 570; accord People v. Beltran (2013) 56 Cal.4th 935, 942.) “‘[I]t is not a
matter of law but a matter of fact for the jury in each case to determine under
the circumstances of the case whether the assault or whether the blow, or
whether the indignity or whether the affront, or whatever the act may be,
was such as is naturally calculated to arouse the passions, and so lessen the
degree of the offense by relieving it from the element of malice.’” (Beltran, at
pp. 950–951.)
Heat of passion provocation can be based on taunting that does
not immediately precede the killing, but a killer cannot set up his or her
7
‘“own standard of conduct”’—it is the jury’s role to determine the
reasonableness of any taunting as legal mitigation for the defendant’s
reaction. (People v. Berry (1976) 18 Cal.3d 509, 515.) At trial, it is a
prosecutor’s burden to negate at least one of the three heat of passion
elements beyond a reasonable doubt. (See People v. Thomas (2013)
218 Cal.App.4th 630, 643.)
III.
ANALYSIS
We review the record to determine whether substantial evidence
supports a jury finding against at least one heat of passion element, beyond a
reasonable doubt. (Ware, supra, 14 Cal.5th at p. 167.) We conclude
substantial evidence supports an implied jury finding that any provocation
was insufficient to cause a person of average disposition to act rashly and
without due deliberation.
Consistent with our conclusion, the jury could have reasonably
disbelieved Lazaro’s version of the events. For example, Lazaro claimed
Angel taunted him about having “intercourse with [N.G.] in all of [Lazaro]’s
cars and that he[, Angel,] would not be needed if [Lazaro] could take care of
business.” But Lazaro’s only support was his own trial testimony, with no
corroborating evidence. The jury could have reasonably rejected his claim of
taunting. (See CALCRIM No. 226 [addressing jury’s prerogative to assess
testimony as not credible and its significance].)
8
True, there was undisputed evidence that could have supported
2
contrary jury findings. But that is not the light with which we view the
record. (Ware, supra, 14 Cal.5th at p. 167.) Lazaro presents no factual ground
to override the jury’s decision on heat of passion.
Nor does Lazaro present analogous precedent to show there was
insufficient evidence in this case. For example, he cites to People v. Borchers
(1958) 50 Cal.2d 321, 330 (Borchers) as an instance of the California Supreme
Court concluding there was insufficient evidence to negate a heat of passion
element. The defendant in Borchers was engaged to a woman who was
unfaithful to him. The woman pointed a gun at the defendant, and then
taunted him to shoot her before he actually fired. (Id. at pp. 325–326.) The
jury convicted the defendant of second degree murder, but the trial court
granted relief, on defendant’s motion pursuant to section 1181, by reducing
the conviction from murder to voluntary manslaughter. (Id. at pp. 323, 328.)
The high court affirmed. (Id. at p. 330.)
Borchers is factually inapposite to the events that transpired in
this case. Equally important, Borchers is precedent for a trial court
overriding a jury determination on provocation. Its affirmance rests on an
appellate conclusion that substantial evidence supported what the trial court
factually determined, as authorized by section 1181. (See Borchers, supra,
50 Cal.2d at p. 328 [“From the evidence viewed as a whole[,] the trial judge
could well have concluded that defendant was roused to a heat of ‘passion’”].)
In this case, implementing the same deference to factfinding would result in
2
For example, N.G. acknowledged that, about six months before
the killing, she “in a way play[ed] with [Lazaro’s] emotions” because she was
still hurt by him. Also around that time, it was undisputed that Lazaro and
Angel engaged in a physical altercation with each other.
9
affirming the judgment because, as noted, here the trial court agreed with
the jury’s decision on provocation by denying Lazaro’s section 1181 motion to
reduce his conviction. Borchers is both factually and analytically unhelpful to
Lazaro. Given that substantial evidence supports the jury’s verdict, there is
no ground for reversal.
DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed.
O’LEARY, P. J.
WE CONCUR:
MOTOIKE, J.
DELANEY, J.
10
Ti chiedi come si applica questo testo alla tua situazione?
Consulenza gratuita, senza impegno
Descrivi la tua situazione. Il nostro team ti ricontatterà via e-mail per la tua consulenza.
Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude
Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.