CourtListener 10595695•In re E.V. CA2/2
Testo completo
Filed 5/30/25 In re E.V. CA2/2
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION TWO
In re E.V., a Person Coming B339231
Under the Juvenile Court Law. (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No.
24CCJP01171A)
LOS ANGELES COUNTY
DEPARTMENT OF
CHILDREN AND FAMILY
SERVICES,
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v.
D.V.,
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of Los
Angeles County. Mary E. Kelly, Judge. Affirmed.
Jamie A. Moran, under appointment by the Court of
Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, Kim Nemoy,
Assistant County Counsel, and Bryan Mercke, Deputy County
Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
__________________________________________
In this juvenile dependency appeal, D.V. (mother)
challenges the juvenile court’s order removing her six-month-old
son E.V. (son) from her custody and care. Mother argues
substantial evidence does not support the court’s removal order.
We find no error and affirm.
BACKGROUND
1. The Family
Mother met son’s father F.H. (father) in February 2023.
Soon after, mother became pregnant with son and moved in with
father. Mother and father lived together on and off and had a
tumultuous relationship. After their first four months living
together, mother and father had a fight and father obtained a
“TRO.” Mother moved in with her mother (maternal
grandmother). Sometime later, father also moved in with
maternal grandmother. After a few months, maternal
grandmother “kicked [father] out because he disrespected her.”
Mother moved out with father, and they rented a garage. In
January 2024,1 mother and father became engaged. When the
underlying proceedings began, mother and father had been living
together in an apartment with son for a few months. Father was
1 Unless otherwise noted, all referenced dates are in the
year 2024.
2
26 years old, mother was 19 years old, and son was three months
old. Neither mother nor father has any other children.
2. Events Preceding Petition
On April 4, mother and father had an argument that
turned physical. Mother was sitting on the couch at their
apartment, holding son. She and father were arguing when
father slapped mother’s head and, accidentally, also hit son’s
head, causing son to cry. Mother did not believe father purposely
hit son. Father denied hitting son. Son was not injured. Mother
put son in the bedroom, then returned and hit father “all over his
body.” Mother asked father to leave, which he did. After hearing
screaming and banging coming from mother and father’s
apartment, the apartment manager was concerned for son’s
safety and called the police. Father also called law enforcement
before leaving.
The April 4 incident generated a referral to the Los Angeles
County Department of Children and Family Services
(Department). Mother told a Department social worker she
planned to move herself and son in with maternal grandmother
until she could begin working and living on her own. Mother
stated she had not worked since getting pregnant because father
wanted her “to be a stay at home wife.” Mother said father was
unfaithful to her. Mother also said that, on five or six occasions,
father had kicked her out of their shared living arrangements
and thrown her belongings onto the street. She said father
previously had hit her, “backhanded” her on her face, punched
her arm, strangled her, and sexually assaulted her, sometimes
when son was present and when she was pregnant with son.
When mother was pregnant, father was arrested after he pinned
her against a wall and choked her. Mother said she usually
3
defended herself by kicking father in the groin. Nonetheless,
mother denied feeling unsafe around father.
Mother reported keeping son up to date on his doctor’s
appointments and immunizations, as well as providing food and
toys for him. Mother said father was not involved in son’s care,
did not want to interact with him, and only wanted to hold son
when he (father) was drunk. Nonetheless, father bought
whatever son needed.
Mother told the social worker she drank alcohol and her
drink of choice was Hennessy. She said she drank every other
day before becoming pregnant, but did not drink while pregnant.
Since son was born, mother reported drinking again, but “denied
alcohol challenges.” Mother also reported smoking marijuana
(but not very often), using cocaine (but not since being pregnant),
and having a Xanax addiction in high school (but had not used in
the past two years). Mother previously had participated in
substance abuse counseling and anger management classes.
Mother believed father had a drinking problem. She said
father was “an aggressive drunk” and had been “arrested for
DUIs multiple times.” She said father tried to drink and drive
with son, but mother did not allow him to do so.
The Department social worker also spoke with father.
Father stated he was “the provider for the family.” He did not
want mother to work and did not give her money or keys to their
apartment. He said he was able to buy whatever she needed,
even in an emergency. Father said he helped care for son, but
mother was son’s primary caregiver. Father reported having a
good relationship with mother. He said they had future plans
and wanted to stay together. Besides the April 4 incident, father
denied domestic violence with mother or anyone. As to the
4
April 4 incident, although father admitted hitting mother, he
stated mother hit him first. Father reported “DUIs from 2021
and 2022,” stating he had completed his classes and community
service. He said he no longer drank alcohol. A “CLETS” search
for father revealed five arrests (and two convictions) for driving
under the influence between 2021 and 2023.
With help from the social worker, mother and father agreed
to a temporary safety plan. Mother and son planned to stay with
mother’s friend V.C., with whom mother often stayed when she
and father had a fight. Mother and father repeatedly indicated
they wanted to continue their relationship and asked if they
could resume their relationship after the safety plan ended.
The social worker also spoke with maternal grandmother,
with whom mother and father previously had lived for
approximately four months. Maternal grandmother stated father
was “ ‘violent’ ” and “was always mad over everything.” She
heard him “screaming and cussing at mother.” There were nights
when maternal grandmother could not sleep because mother and
father were yelling at each other. Maternal grandmother told the
social worker father was often drunk and “was more verbally
aggressive when he was drinking.” She was concerned father
forced mother to be intimate with him. Maternal grandmother
said father did not give mother money, did not leave her with
food or necessary items for son, and did not care for son.
The social worker also spoke with paternal grandmother
and a paternal aunt. Both reported mother and father often had
verbal and physical altercations. Similarly, both reported father
had multiple DUI arrests. Paternal grandmother was concerned
for son because of his young age and because mother and father
5
“just do not get along.” The paternal aunt described mother and
father’s relationship as “ ‘toxic.’ ”
On April 11, the Department requested an expedited
removal of son from mother and father. The juvenile court
granted the removal order as to father only. Son remained in
mother’s care.
In its detention report filed a few days later, the
Department stated father showed “no accountability or insight as
to his actions” and mother “lacks understanding and insight as to
how her tumultuous relationship with the father, which includes
ongoing intimate partner violence, places their infant child at
risk of physical and emotional harm.” The Department reported
mother was hesitant to leave father and asked if she could
continue to see father.
On April 14, mother and three friends broke into father’s
apartment. They physically assaulted father and two females,
smashed an apartment window, and broke the windows of
father’s friend’s car. Mother and her friends were gone by the
time law enforcement arrived. Father and one of his friends were
injured, but both refused medical treatment. At the time, father
was “heavily intoxicated” and unable to give a statement other
than to say he had been in a fight and believed he had been shot.
Father had not been shot. A restraining order was entered
protecting father from mother. Son was not present during the
April 14 incident.
3. Petition
On April 15, the Department filed a four-count Welfare and
Institutions Code section 300 petition on behalf of son (petition).2
2 Undesignated statutory references are to the Welfare and
Institutions Code.
6
The petition alleged son was at risk due to mother and father’s
history of domestic violence, mother’s failure to protect son from
the domestic violence, mother’s history of and current substance
abuse and father’s failure to protect, and father’s history of and
current substance abuse and mother’s failure to protect.
The initial hearing on the petition was held at the end of
April. That day, the Department reported mother and father
appeared to want to reconcile and move back in together. At
some point, mother and son had moved in with maternal
grandmother. However, maternal grandmother reported mother
left with son for one week and she did not know where they were.
The Department was concerned both that, despite the
Department’s involvement, mother had engaged in domestic
violence with father (on April 14) and that both mother and
father continued to lack insight into their actions. Based on
mother’s aggressive behavior and continued lack of insight, the
Department asked the juvenile court to remove son from mother.
At the initial hearing, counsel for mother asked the court
not to detain son from mother. Counsel disputed the description
of the April 14 incident. Noting father had been intoxicated,
counsel urged the juvenile court “not to give any weight to
father’s statement or report of this event.” Counsel also noted
mother was residing with maternal grandmother, who was able
to help care for son. On the other hand, counsel for the
Department and counsel for son argued the court should detain
son from both mother and father.
After hearing argument, the juvenile court detained son
from mother and father and ordered monitored visitation. The
court also entered a “stay away” order, stating there was “to be
7
no contact between mother and father.” Son was placed with
maternal grandmother.
4. Continued Investigation
In May, a Department social worker again spoke with
mother. Mother reiterated what she previously had reported.
Additionally, mother stated she only hit father in self-defense.
She never hit father first. She said they often argued but April
was the first time father hurt her. She denied father forced her
to be intimate with him without her consent. Mother also denied
any current substance abuse problems.
The social worker also again spoke with father. He denied
many of the allegations against him. He stated mother “gets
aggressive and she hits me and I grab her to stop hitting me and
I tell her to calm down and to stop.” He denied hitting mother,
strangling mother, or forcing mother to have sex. He said he
never accidentally hit son. He stated, “All [mother] wants me to
do is look like a bad guy.” Father stated the last time he drank
alcohol was less than two weeks earlier, on his birthday. He
denied being drunk in front of son and said, “The alcohol does not
control me.” Father told the social worker he previously had
participated in a drug and alcohol program, but he could not
remember the name of the agency. Since son had been removed
from father, father had missed three drug tests and once tested
negative for substances. Father wanted “ ‘to try and work it out
with [mother] and for the baby.’ ”
In its May adjudication and disposition report, the
Department expressed concerns for son’s safety in the care of
mother and father. As support for its concerns, the Department
pointed to mother and father’s “ongoing and history of substance
abuse” and their “violent behavior.” The Department believed
8
mother and father had “unresolved issues of domestic violence,”
with both demonstrating behaviors of an aggressor. Additionally,
the Department stated neither mother nor father had
demonstrated an ability to stay sober. Especially in light of son’s
very young age, the Department recommended the juvenile court
sustain the petition and order reunification services.
In June, the Department reported maternal grandmother
monitored mother’s visits with son, which were going well. By
July, however, the Department reported mother was not visiting
consistently. Mother also was not drug testing consistently.
Between April and July, mother missed seven of nine drug tests
and tested positive for marijuana twice, including at her most
recent test conducted in early July. Mother had not enrolled in
services to address her substance use.
5. Adjudication and Disposition
The combined jurisdiction and disposition hearing was held
on July 10. At the hearing, counsel for mother argued mother
was the victim of father’s violence, her substance abuse was
remote in time, her current drug use did not put son at risk, and
she did not fail to protect son. Counsel asked the court to return
son to mother’s care under a safety plan requiring mother to live
with maternal grandmother. Counsel argued there was no clear
and convincing evidence of risk to son, who already was placed
with maternal grandmother. Counsel noted mother was 19 years
old, son was an infant who needed his mother, and mother had
not had contact with father for more than two months. Counsel
for father noted father “vehemently denies” the allegations of the
petition as they pertained to him. Father claimed mother was
the aggressor and his substance abuse was all in the past.
Counsel for son argued the juvenile court should strike the
9
allegations of sexual abuse by father, as well as reference to
certain drug use by mother, but otherwise sustain the petition
and remove son from both mother and father. Counsel noted
mother was not drug testing and was not consistently visiting
son. Finally, counsel for the Department asked the juvenile court
to sustain the petition as plead and remove son from both mother
and father. Counsel noted mother and father “continually asked
if they could resume their relationship and continue living
together,” “lacked insight,” and were not focused on their child.
Counsel believed it was “premature to allow the mother to live in
the maternal grandmother’s home.”
After hearing argument, the juvenile court amended the
petition by deleting references to father’s alleged sexual abuse of
mother as well as father’s alleged history of cocaine use. The
court sustained the petition as amended. The court declared son
a dependent of the court under subdivisions (a) and (b) of section
300 and ordered him removed from mother’s and father’s custody
and care. The court adopted the arguments made by counsel for
the Department and counsel for son.
The court ordered mother to enroll in a drug and alcohol
program with after care, submit to drug testing, participate in a
12-step program, attend a domestic violence program for
aggressors and victims, to participate in a parenting program,
and to participate in individual counseling. Mother was granted
monitored visitation. The Department was authorized to
liberalize her visits.
6. Appeal
Mother appealed the juvenile court’s July 10 order.
10
Father also appealed the court’s July 10 order. We
dismissed father’s appeal in accordance with In re Phoenix H.
(2009) 47 Cal.4th 835.
DISCUSSION
1. Applicable Law and Standard of Review
When a child has been adjudged a dependent child within
the meaning of section 300, the juvenile court “may limit the
control to be exercised over the dependent child by any parent” if
necessary to protect the child. (§ 361, subd. (a)(1).) Section 361,
subdivision (c)(1) permits the juvenile court to order a child
removed from his or her parent if the court finds by clear and
convincing evidence that the child is, or would be, at substantial
risk of harm if returned home and there are no reasonable means
by which the child can be protected without removal. “ ‘ “The
parent need not be dangerous and the minor need not have been
actually harmed before removal is appropriate. The focus of the
statute is on averting harm to the child.” ’ ” (In re A.S. (2011) 202
Cal.App.4th 237, 247, disapproved on another ground by
Conservatorship of O.B. (2020) 9 Cal.5th 989, 1010, fn. 7 (O.B.).)
In making its determination, the juvenile court may consider the
parent’s past conduct as well as present circumstances. (In re
A.S., at p. 247.)
We review the juvenile court’s removal order under the
substantial evidence standard of review, bearing in mind the
heightened burden of proof by clear and convincing evidence. (In
re I.J. (2013) 56 Cal.4th 766, 773; In re A.F. (2016) 3 Cal.App.5th
283, 292; O.B., supra, 9 Cal.5th at pp. 1011–1012; see In re V.L.
(2020) 54 Cal.App.5th 147, 155 [“O.B. is controlling in
dependency cases”].)
11
2. Substantial evidence supports the juvenile court’s
removal order.
Mother challenges only the juvenile court’s order removing
son from her custody and care. Mother argues substantial
evidence does not support the removal order and, instead, the
juvenile court should have ordered mother and son to live with
maternal grandmother with family maintenance services in
place. We disagree.
As mother does not challenge the juvenile court’s
jurisdictional findings, it is undisputed mother and father’s
relationship was violent and volatile. Mother and father engaged
in violent altercations while mother was pregnant as well as in
son’s presence after his birth. Indeed, when he was only three
months old, son was struck during one such altercation. Even
Department involvement did not stop the violence between the
parents. After the parents’ domestic violence triggered the
Department’s involvement and mother and son had moved out of
the family apartment, mother returned to the apartment with
friends and violently attacked father and his friends.
Mother demonstrated neither insight into nor an ability to
leave her relationship with father. Throughout most of the
underlying proceedings, mother and father indicated they wanted
to reunite and had plans for their future. This was consistent
with their pattern of breaking up, then reconciling. Despite all
their volatility, mother denied feeling unsafe around father.
During the Department’s investigation, mother stated father hurt
her for the first time in April, when months earlier father had
been arrested for physically assaulting her when she was
pregnant. “[D]enial is a factor often relevant to determining
whether persons are likely to modify their behavior in the future
12
without court supervision.” (In re A.F., supra, 3 Cal.App.5th at
p. 293.) “One cannot correct a problem one fails to acknowledge.”
(In re Gabriel K. (2012) 203 Cal.App.4th 188, 197.)
It is similarly undisputed mother had unresolved substance
abuse issues. Although mother had indicated a willingness to
engage in services and drug test for the Department, mother had
not enrolled in any services and had missed most of her drug
tests. When she did test, she tested positive for marijuana,
including just days before the adjudication
Mother argues the juvenile court should have placed son
with her and ordered them to live with maternal grandmother
under Department supervision. It was reasonable, however, for
the juvenile court to reject such a proposal. After the underlying
proceedings had begun and mother and son were living with
maternal grandmother, mother disappeared with son for one
week. Maternal grandmother did not know where they were.
This supports a finding that placing son with mother at maternal
grandmother’s home was not a safe alternative to removal.
Similarly, although mother states maternal grandmother was
“her first and primary support person,” the record reveals mother
also had support in her friend V.C., with whom mother often
stayed after fighting with father. Indeed, V.C. opened her home
to mother and son during the underlying proceedings when
mother and father made a safety plan following their April 4
altercation.
Finally, in addition to the parents’ “toxic” and violent
relationship and their unresolved substance abuse issues, son
was very young. After only three months of life, father struck son
(albeit accidentally) while fighting with mother. By the time of
the adjudication, son was six months old—i.e., still an infant and
13
still very vulnerable. At that time, mother had shown neither an
ability to understand or break her cycle of violence with father
nor an ability to stay free of substances.
In light of the entire record, it was not unreasonable for the
juvenile court to reject mother’s preferred plan of living with son
at maternal grandmother’s home under Department supervision.
Although maternal grandmother certainly provided support for
mother, the court could not overlook the unfortunate and perilous
situation in which mother had placed son. On this record, and
bearing in mind the applicable clear and convincing standard
below, we conclude substantial evidence supports the removal
order.
DISPOSITION
The juvenile court’s July 10, 2024 order is affirmed.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED.
LUI, P. J.
We concur:
CHAVEZ, J.
RICHARDSON, J.
14
Ti chiedi come si applica questo testo alla tua situazione?
Consulenza gratuita, senza impegno
Descrivi la tua situazione. Il nostro team ti ricontatterà via e-mail per la tua consulenza.
Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude
Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.