In re L.J. CA1/5

CourtListener 10407783Calctapp29 apr 2025

Testo completo

Filed 4/29/25 In re L.J. CA1/5
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication or
ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

FIRST APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION FIVE

In re L.J. et al., Persons Coming
Under the Juvenile Court Law.

SAN FRANCISCO HUMAN
SERVICES AGENCY, A171554

Plaintiff and Respondent, (San Francisco County
v. Super. Ct. Nos. JD24-3071 &
JD24-3072)
M.J.,
Defendant and Appellant.

In these dependency actions, M.J. (Mother) appeals the juvenile court’s
orders assuming jurisdiction over her two children, L.J. and M.B.
(collectively, Minors), under Welfare and Institutions Code section 300.1
Mother does not challenge the juvenile court’s jurisdiction, but argues solely
that findings regarding alcohol use and domestic violence are not supported
by substantial evidence. We affirm.

1 All undesignated statutory references are to the Welfare and

Institutions Code.

1
BACKGROUND
In April 2024, the San Francisco Human Services Agency (Agency) filed
section 300 petitions seeking to detain then-11-month-old L.J. and newborn
M.B. from Mother and Minors’ respective fathers. As relevant here, the
petitions alleged Mother had substance abuse issues impeding her ability to
care for Minors.2 Amended petitions later added an allegation that Minors
were also at risk due to a history of domestic violence between Mother and
M.B.’s father (Father).
According to the Agency’s detention report, Minors both tested positive
for methamphetamine at birth. Mother had been investigated by a different
county after L.J.’s birth; the county closed that referral but noted Mother
“ ‘has a history of drug use’ ” and “ ‘continues to minimize it.’ ” Nurses
observed that Mother was not attentive to M.B. while in the hospital after his
birth. Mother told the Agency she used methamphetamine when she was
homeless in 2022, but stopped after she got housing. Mother also said she
drank excessively before her pregnancy with L.J. but stopped because she did
not like the way it made her feel. Mother denied any current drug use, said
her last use was in 2022, and said she had no idea how either Minor tested
positive for methamphetamine.
The Agency allowed M.B. to be discharged to Mother and Father on the
condition that they stay with the maternal grandmother, who agreed to
supervise them at all times. The following day, the Agency learned that
Mother and Father brought M.B. in for a pediatric checkup without the
maternal grandmother. At the checkup, the parents said M.B. had turned
purple on two occasions, but were not able to answer follow-up questions.

2 We recite only those background facts relevant to the narrow issues

asserted on appeal.

2
Medical staff advised them to take M.B. to the emergency room but the
parents did not do so, and they cancelled a follow-up pediatric visit. When
the Agency contacted the parents to discuss concerns about M.B.’s health and
their noncompliance with the agreed-on plan of supervision by the maternal
grandmother, the parents refused to meet with the Agency. Mother told the
Agency the maternal grandmother had kicked her out of the house. The
juvenile court ordered Minors detained.
In a May 2024 report, the Agency stated Mother was currently on
probation for a 2021 conviction for driving under the influence (DUI), and she
also had a 2016 DUI. Mother’s probation officer told the Agency she had
failed to comply with her probation conditions, which included drug testing
and a drug treatment program. The Agency referred Mother to drug testing
and a residential treatment program, but at the time of the report, Mother
had neither tested nor entered treatment.
The Agency also reported that Mother and Father had a history of
domestic violence, with the first documented incident in 2018, when Father
pulled Mother downstairs by her hair and attempted to choke her.3 An
emergency protective order issued, but a few months later, police were called
after Father choked Mother. Father and Mother said they had been living
together for a month despite the restraining order. In 2020, Father was
convicted twice of battery on a spouse and, in 2021, Father was convicted of
corporal injury on a spouse. The Agency reported that the last incident of
domestic violence was in 2022, and Father was convicted at that time of

3 A police report from this incident submitted with a subsequent

Agency report included a neighbor’s statement that he saw Father dragging
Mother down the stairs by her hair, and an officer’s statement that there was
a broken mirror and broken furniture in the parents’ house.

3
violating a protective order and sentenced to prison for 16 months. An active
restraining order protecting Mother from Father was in place, expiring in
December 2024.
In July and August 2024 addendum reports, the Agency said that in
June, Mother entered two drug treatment programs but left both within
days. Drug tests during these brief stays were positive for amphetamine and
methamphetamine. When the Agency asked Mother about the history of
domestic violence with Father, she denied any physical violence and stated
the documented incidents were “blown out of proportion[].” In early July,
Mother told the Agency she had asked Father to leave and he was no longer
living with her. Mother’s attorney subsequently told the Agency that Mother
was looking for a domestic violence class.
Mother testified at the August 2024 jurisdiction/disposition hearing.
She testified she started using methamphetamine two years earlier, but
stopped using during both pregnancies except for one relapse each. She last
used the month before the hearing; when she used after L.J. was born, she
left him with her mother; and she did not think she needed help with
substances. With respect to alcohol, Mother testified she drank alcohol daily
before she stopped drinking about a year after her second DUI. Mother
testified that, “[a]s of now,” she did not intend to live with Father when the
active restraining order expired. She admitted there was domestic violence
in their relationship in the past, she had never received domestic violence
counseling, and “[p]ossibly” she could use such counseling.
The trial court sustained the allegations of the amended petitions. The
court emphasized Mother’s lack of credibility and failure to acknowledge her
substance abuse problem: “We have a history of her denying any use, denying
a drug problem, denying relapses . . . . [¶] We have a restraining order that is

4
repeatedly violated. We have a problem following court orders. We have the
efforts of not being able to follow the DUI orders. All of these things seem to
have the same underlying root cause, which is an untreated fairly well
unacknowledged substance abuse addiction.”
With respect to disposition, Minors’ counsel expressed concern that the
Agency’s proposed case plan did not include domestic violence services and
stated his intention to “ask the Court to amend the service plan to include
domestic violence counseling.” The court agreed “it is important to do that,”
and ordered the Agency to add domestic violence counseling to the case plan.
DISCUSSION
“On appeal, ‘[a] dependency court’s jurisdictional findings are reviewed
under the substantial evidence test. [Citation.] Under this test, we resolve
all conflicts in the evidence, and indulge all reasonable inferences that may
be derived from the evidence, in favor of the court’s findings.’ ” (In re
Madison S. (2017) 15 Cal.App.5th 308, 318.)
The juvenile court sustained the petitions’ allegation that there was a
substantial risk to Minors because of Mother’s substance abuse issues.
Several of the supporting facts described Mother’s methamphetamine use
and the impact on Minors. Additionally, the petitions included the following
supporting fact: “[Mother] reported that she drank excessively prior to the
birth of [L.J.] and then stopped as she did not like the way it made her feel.”
(Capitalization altered.) Mother does not dispute the factual accuracy of this
statement, nor does she dispute that multiple other facts support this
jurisdictional finding. Mother’s sole complaint is that her past drinking does
not provide support for the jurisdictional finding because the juvenile court
took “at face value” her testimony that she was no longer drinking. We

5
disagree.4 “Although ‘the question under section 300 is whether
circumstances at the time of the hearing subject the minor to the defined risk
of harm’ [citation], the court may nevertheless consider past events when
determining whether a child presently needs the juvenile court’s protection.
[Citations.] . . . ‘Facts supporting allegations that a child is one described by
section 300 are cumulative.’ [Citation.] Thus, the court ‘must consider all
the circumstances affecting the child, wherever they occur.’ ”
(In re T.V. (2013) 217 Cal.App.4th 126, 133.) While the fact of Mother’s past
alcohol use would not be sufficient alone to support the jurisdictional finding,
it was properly considered by the juvenile court as part of Mother’s ongoing
history of substance abuse.
Mother also challenges the following additional jurisdictional finding:
“The child is at risk of serious physical harm because [Mother and Father]
have an extensive history of domestic violence. A criminal protective order
was issued in 2018 protecting [Mother] from [Father] and another criminal
protective order was issued in 2021. The 2021 [criminal protective order] is
still in effect until December 2024. The parents have remained together in a
relationship in violation of those orders. Mother has acknowledged the
domestic violence, but minimizes it.” (Capitalization altered.) Again, Mother
does not dispute the factual accuracy of the finding, but argues it cannot
support jurisdiction because there is no substantial evidence of current

4 As the Agency contends, we need not address this contention because

Mother does not challenge the overall jurisdictional finding. (See In re D.P.
(2023) 14 Cal.5th 266, 283 [“ ‘ “[a]s long as there is one unassailable
jurisdictional finding, it is immaterial that another might be
inappropriate” ’ ”].) We nonetheless exercise our discretion to consider the
challenge.

6
domestic violence. Mother seeks to strike both this finding and the domestic
violence counseling ordered as part of her case plan.5
Substantial evidence supports the juvenile court’s finding that the risk
of domestic violence is ongoing. It is undisputed that Mother and Father
have a years-long history of domestic violence. While the last known incident
was in 2022, this was followed by Father being sentenced to prison for 16
months. The juvenile court stated that Father “has served his time in prison
on this count, presumably has been rehabilitated and acknowledges and
understands what he did wrong,” but further noted that the lack of a known
incident in the past “two, two and a half years” was “not a long track record.”
Mother has minimized the domestic violence and never received domestic
violence counseling or treatment. We affirm the juvenile court’s orders
sustaining this allegation and directing domestic violence counseling.
DISPOSITION
The orders are affirmed.

SIMONS, Acting P. J.

We concur.
BURNS, J.
CHOU, J.

(A171554)

5 Because Mother has “demonstrated a specific legal or practical

consequence that will be averted upon reversal, . . . merits review is
required.” (In re D.P., supra, 14 Cal.5th at p. 283.)

7

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.