CourtListener 10372374•In re S.R. CA4/3
Testo completo
Filed 4/3/25 In re S.R. CA4/3
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION THREE
In re S.R. et al., Persons Coming
Under the Juvenile Court Law.
ORANGE COUNTY SOCIAL
SERVICES AGENCY,
G064485
Plaintiff and Respondent,
(Super. Ct. Nos. 24DP0410,
v. 24DP0411, 24DP0412)
LYNETTE P., OPINION
Defendant and Appellant.
Appeal from an order of the Superior Court of Orange County,
Julie Anne Swain, Judge. Affirmed.
Cristina Gabrielidis, under appointment by the Court of Appeal,
for Defendant and Appellant.
Leon J. Page, County Counsel, Debbie Torrez and Chloe R.
Maksoudian, Deputy County Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
No appearance for the Minors.
* * *
This juvenile dependency appeal essentially concerns an
evidentiary issue. Lynette P. (the mother) and Sean R. (the father), have
three children together (the children): S.R., age 6 (the daughter), C.R., age 5
(the oldest son), and D.R., age 2. The mother and father (collectively, the
parents) were involved in a custody dispute in family court (the family court
case) when Orange County Social Services Agency (SSA) initiated this
dependency case. In the family court case, the family court had ordered a
psychologist to prepare a custody report under Evidence Code section 730
(the section 730 report). In this case, the mother petitioned the juvenile court
to request and obtain the section 730 report from the family court. The
juvenile court denied the mother’s request and also denied her motion for
reconsideration of the issue (the reconsideration motion). On appeal, the
mother argues the juvenile court’s denial of the reconsideration motion was
an abuse of discretion. We disagree and affirm the ruling.
FACTS AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY
I.
THE FAMILY COURT CASE
The parents met in 2013. They never married but moved in
together during the mother’s first pregnancy and separated in 2021. The
father initiated the family court case in November 2022, by filing a parentage
petition seeking custody of the children. The next month, the family court
temporarily awarded the mother and father joint legal and physical custody,
which granted the father at least 72 hours of parenting time per week. Under
this temporary order, the children primarily lived with the mother and saw
the father Tuesday and Thursday from 4:30 p.m. to 8:00 a.m. the following
day and Saturday from 9:00 a.m. to Sunday at 9:00 a.m.
2
In January 2023, the family court ordered psychologist Dr. Thea
Reinhart to prepare the section 730 report and provide recommendations
regarding the permanent custody of the children.1 The report was to contain
interviews with the parents, the children, and collateral contacts.
Beginning in November 2023, the mother made multiple reports
that the father was sexually abusing the daughter. These reports were
determined to be inconclusive and/or unsubstantiated. Among other things,
the daughter made no independent disclosures of sexual abuse to SSA or law
enforcement (including during a Child Abuse Services Team (CAST)
interview) and there was no medical evidence of sexual abuse. However,
Dr. Reinhart did report to SSA that the daughter “told her that the father
repeatedly touched her vaginal area . . . and stated that [her vagina] was
hurting.” The father told police that the mother was fabricating these
allegations to gain full custody of the children, to punish him for leaving her,
and to get increased child support.
II.
SSA’S INVOLVEMENT
This dependency case arose from a CAST interview with the
oldest son on March 7, 2024, concerning the father’s alleged sexual abuse of
the daughter. During this interview, the oldest son stated that the mother
sometimes struck him on the face with an open hand. We note that SSA had
1 “When it appears to the court, at any time before or during the
trial of an action, that expert evidence is or may be required by the court or
by any party to the action, the court on its own motion or on motion of any
party may appoint one or more experts to investigate, to render a report as
may be ordered by the court, and to testify as an expert at the trial of the
action relative to the fact or matter as to which the expert evidence is or may
be required.” (Evid. Code, § 730.)
3
received several referrals concerning the children prior to this incident, but
they had been determined to be unsubstantiated or inconclusive.
SSA filed a noncustody petition for the children on March 22,
2024 (the petition). Among other things, the petition alleged that (1) the
children were at risk of serious harm due to conflict between the parents and,
in particular, the contentious family court case; (2) there were multiple but
unsubstantiated allegations that the father was sexually abusing the
daughter; and (3) the mother and father potentially had unresolved mental
health issues.2
A hearing on the petition was held on March 27, 2024. Both
parents denied the petition’s allegations. The court was unable to finish the
hearing on March 27, so it was trailed until April 2, 2024. In the meantime,
the court ordered the children to be detained but released to their parents
under certain protective orders.
SSA issued a report prior to the resumption of the detention
hearing on April 2. The report noted that a social worker had spoken with
Dr. Reinhart on March 21 and 29. Dr. Reinhart reported that she had “been
working with the family for about a year and a half.” She stated the mother
did most of the parenting and “is a smart [woman], loves the children and is
not inadequate.” She also reported that the father was participating in
therapy but “it took a lot of work” to get him to do so. Dr. Reinhart further
explained that the father was “initially . . . negative about the mother and
wanted the evaluation to show the mother was inadequate.” She also stated
2 The petition initially alleged that the mother used improper
physical discipline with the oldest son, but this allegation was later struck
from the petition.
4
that there were “questionable times with [the father] because he [was] often
late in returning the children and [initially] demonstrated no interest in
therapy because he thinks ‘he’s the evolved parent.’” Still, Dr. Reinhart
expressed no current concerns about either the mother or father. She believed
“that a fair 50/50 custody arrange[ment] should be advocated for because ‘the
children need both parents.’”3
A social worker interviewed a detective familiar with the sexual
abuse allegations against the father. The detective believed the mother had
been coaching the daughter to report the abuse. For example, during the
CAST interview, the detective had asked the daughter, “‘what do you like to
do with dad?’ [She] answered, ‘my dad likes to touch my vagina.’ [The
detective] expressed, ‘it seemed like she knew that’s what we were there to
talk about.’” He further noted her use of “‘the word vagina’” indicated that an
adult was telling her what to say. Finally, the detective “shared concerns the
mother [was] reading [the daughter] books of victims of sexual abuse when
there [was] no evidence of the child been sexually abused even after multiple
CAST interviews and sexual assault examinations.”
A social worker also contacted a pediatrician who had examined
the daughter for signs of sexual abuse in January 2024. The pediatrician
“stated there was no definitive evidence of sexual abuse to [the daughter] and
no need for a follow up exam.” He also expressed that his notes reflected that
“[the daughter] did not disclose anything.”
After the detention hearing resumed on April 2, 2024, the
juvenile court found the petition stated a prima facie case and the children
3 SSA had previously contacted Dr. Reinhart in November 2023
and February 2024, apparently concerning prior referrals.
5
were subject to Welfare and Institutions Code section 300.4 The court
released the children to the parents under the protective orders issued on
March 27, and it scheduled a jurisdiction hearing.
III.
SSA’S REPORTS
SSA prepared several reports prior to the jurisdiction hearing.
Generally, the children’s basic needs such as food, clothes, and
safety were met by both parents. However, the daughter reported the parents
“‘never get along.’” SSA also noted evidence that the mother was coaching the
children. For example, during an interview, the daughter told a social worker
that “‘mom said [the father] lied but it’s not true.’” Likewise, during the
oldest son’s interview, SSA asked if he knew the difference between a truth
and a lie. The oldest son promised to “tell the truth and then said, ‘Daddy
lie.’”
The mother continued to allege that the father was sexually
abusing the daughter, but the daughter denied any abuse to SSA. The mother
stated the children had been in her care full time from November 2023 to
January 2024. She believed that since the children had begun spending more
time with the father, the daughter had become more emotionally unstable,
gained weight, and developed a poor attitude. She also claimed the father
verbally demeaned her in front of the children.
The father told SSA that the mother had kept the children away
from him for months before the family court issued the temporary custody
order in December 2022. He denied the sexual abuse allegations and believed
the mother was coaching the daughter. For example, he claimed the daughter
4 All further undesignated statutory references are to the Welfare
and Institutions Code.
6
had once told him, “‘mommy says you touch my privates.’” The father also
claimed that when he refused to marry the mother, she became hostile and
began making false accusations against him.
SSA spoke with Dr. Reinhart again on April 28, 2024.
Dr. Reinhart characterized the parents’ relationship as “conflictual” and
“dysfunctional.” She believed the father lacked structure while the mother
was overly structured. When asked about the mother’s alleged “fixation on
sexual abuse,” Dr. Reinhart “denied knowing why [the mother] behaved this
way and did not think [the mother] was coaching the [daughter].” But
Dr. Reinhart agreed that the mother “overly exposed the children specifically
[the daughter] to multiple CAST interviews and forensic exams,” which was
detrimental to them. Dr. Reinhart was unable to provide any specific
recommendations because the section 730 report was still incomplete. She
also “reported that the current 730 evaluation ha[d] been suspended due to
[SSA’s] involvement.” However, Dr. Reinhart believed the children loved their
parents and thought both parents should be in the children’s lives.
IV.
MOTHER’S REQUEST FOR THE SECTION 730 REPORT
On May 23, 2024, the mother filed a request in the family court
case asking the family court to release the section 730 report to the juvenile
court and the parties to the dependency case. The family court set a hearing
for this request for July 12, 2024.
In this case, a jurisdiction hearing was held on May 30, 2024. At
the hearing, both SSA and the mother requested a continuation. SSA asked
for a continuance to June 12, 2024, so it could finish its investigation. The
mother requested the hearing be continued until after July 12, to allow the
family court time to rule on her request to release the section 730 report. She
7
argued the section 730 report was relevant to the jurisdiction hearing
because it was conducted over 14 months and contained “interviews with the
parents, the children, and collateral contacts, as well as a recommendation by
[Dr. Reinhart] regarding custody, services, and the welfare of these children.”
The juvenile court continued the jurisdiction hearing to June 12, 2024,
denying the mother’s request that it be set after July 12.
Due to the juvenile court’s ruling, the jurisdiction hearing would
occur before the family court could rule on the mother’s request to release the
section 730 report. As such, the mother petitioned the juvenile court to
request the section 730 report directly from the family court under
section 204, so the juvenile court could obtain it prior to the jurisdiction
hearing. In the alternative, the mother asked the juvenile court to order SSA
to obtain the section 730 report from the family court under section 204.5
After a hearing on June 4, 2024, the juvenile court denied the
mother’s petition concerning the section 730 report. As to her first request,
the juvenile court agreed that section 204 permitted it to obtain a copy of the
section 730 report from the family court. But, it explained, section 204 did not
allow the juvenile court to release the section 730 report to any of the parties
in the dependency case. Rather, “the release would have to either come from
the agency that requested it and had it or the court that has jurisdiction over
the document,” i.e., the family court. In other words, “no records . . . may be
5 Section 204 provides that “a family law court . . . shall, upon
request from the juvenile court in any county, provide to the court all
available information the court deems necessary to make a determination
regarding the best interest of a child . . . who is the subject of a proceeding
before the juvenile court . . . . The information shall also be released to a child
protective services worker or juvenile probation officer acting within the
scope of his or her duties in that proceeding.” (§ 204.)
8
disclosed to any party in the case unless the party requests the agency or a
court that originates the record [(i.e., the family court)] to release these
records and the request is granted.” The court then explained that it did not
“find it to be helpful for the Court to get [the section 730 report] and other
counsel not to be able to have it.”
The juvenile court also rejected the mother’s request to order SSA
to obtain the section 730 report from the family court under section 204. It
explained that it “generally allow[s] the lawyers to choose what evidence to
seek, how they choose to seek it, and what evidence to present, and then it’s
up to the Court to decide whether that evidence is admissible or relevant.”
V.
THE JURISDICTION HEARING AND THE RECONSIDERATION MOTION
The jurisdiction hearing was later continued to July 1, 2024, and
combined with the disposition hearing. At the combined hearing, the juvenile
court found the petition to be true by a preponderance of the evidence and the
children to be subject to the court’s jurisdiction under section 300,
subdivision (b)(1). It vested custody of the children with the parents under
SSA’s supervision. The court scheduled a review hearing to address custody
and visitation for July 30, 2024, and set a six-month review hearing in
December 2024.
A few weeks later, on July 16, 2024, the mother filed the
reconsideration motion, asking the juvenile court to reconsider her petition to
request the section 730 report directly from the family court or order SSA to
obtain it. The reconsideration motion explained that the family court had
denied the mother’s request to release the section 730 report under a
protective order. The family court had ruled that only the juvenile court or
SSA could make such a request.
9
At the July 30 custody hearing in this case, the juvenile court
denied the reconsideration motion. It explained, “we’ve heard [jurisdiction],
we’ve heard [disposition], we’re set for six-month review, and the Court
understands that those evaluations [for the section 730 report] were
conducted under the purview of family law court with a different focus than
this court requires.” The court ordered a new section 730 evaluation to be
prepared for purposes of the dependency case. It explained that “[i]t’s
important that the Court have current updated information in relation to the
orders that the Court has made regarding disposition in this case and what is
happening going forward.”6
On appeal, the mother argues the juvenile court’s denial of the
reconsideration motion was an abuse of discretion.
DISCUSSION
I.
STANDARD OF REVIEW
Both parties contend the juvenile court’s decision not to request
the section 730 report directly from the family court, or order SSA to obtain
it, is reviewed for an abuse of discretion. While they have not cited any direct
authority on this point, we agree. Section 204 requires a family court to
provide “all available information the [juvenile] court deems necessary to
make a determination regarding the best interest of” the child in dependency
proceedings. (§ 204, italics added.) Put differently, the statute allows the
juvenile court to determine, in its discretion, what information is necessary
from the family court to evaluate a child’s best interest. Here, the juvenile
6 At the July 30 custody hearing, the juvenile court also ordered
“SSA to make [a] visitation schedule as close to 50/50 as possible.”
10
court determined the section 730 report was unneeded. This determination
was akin to a discretionary evidentiary ruling, which is reviewed for an abuse
of discretion.7 (Jones v. Solgen Construction, LLC (2024) 99 Cal.App.5th 1178,
1188.)
“A trial court abuses its discretion if its ruling exceeds ‘“‘the
bounds of reason, all of the circumstances before it being considered.’”’”
(Jones v. Solgen Construction, LLC, supra, 99 Cal.App.5th at p. 1188.) “‘The
abuse-of-discretion standard requires us to uphold a ruling which a
reasonable judge might have made, even though we would not have ruled the
same and a contrary ruling would also be sustainable. We cannot substitute
our own judgment.’” (Harman v. City and County of San Francisco (2007) 158
Cal.App.4th 407, 428.)
II.
ANALYSIS
Essentially, the juvenile court did not request the section 730
report because it found the report had little probative value. The mother
asserts it was in the children’s best interests for the court to grant the
reconsideration motion and obtain it. She claims the 730 report contained
valuable information that would have informed the juvenile court’s custody
decisions. However, as we explain below, it was not unreasonable for the
7 There is scant case law interpreting section 204. None of the
parties have addressed whether this statute was the proper vehicle for the
mother’s request. Nor have they addressed whether the juvenile court
correctly interpreted the statute. Since these issues were not briefed, we will
not address them and presume the court correctly applied section 204. (See
Cahill v. San Diego Gas & Electric Co. (2011) 194 Cal.App.4th 939, 956 [trial
court’s order is presumed correct on appeal.)
11
juvenile court to conclude that the section 730 report offered little probative
value given the state of the proceedings.
“The best interest of the child is the fundamental goal of the
juvenile dependency system . . . .” (In re William B. (2008) 163 Cal.App.4th
1220, 1227.) “When ruling in dependency proceedings, the welfare of the
minor is the paramount concern of the court. . . . [T]he child’s future is as
vitally affected as is that of the parties competing for his or her custody.”
(Guadalupe A. v. Superior Court (1991) 234 Cal.App.3d 100, 106.) As such,
“the court should avail itself of all evidence which might bear on the child’s
best interest.” (Ibid.) “Concern for the minor’s welfare necessarily requires
the court to consider all the information available.” (In re Hadley B. (2007)
148 Cal.App.4th 1041, 1048.)
However, the above case law does not mean that a juvenile court
must always allow or request evidence from a family court case that might
have some relevance to the dependency proceeding. Such a rule would waste
time and render “juvenile court judges . . . powerless to exclude cumulative
evidence or time-consuming evidence of marginal probative value.” (See In re
Romeo C. (1995) 33 Cal.App.4th 1838, 1844.) Rather, juvenile courts are
tasked with “control[ling] all proceedings during the hearings with a view to
the expeditious and effective ascertainment of the jurisdictional facts and the
ascertainment of all information relative to the present condition and future
welfare of the person upon whose behalf the petition is brought.” (§ 350, subd.
(a)(1), italics added.)
Here, the juvenile court could reasonably conclude the section
730 report was cumulative. SSA’s reports included five interviews with
Dr. Reinhart. Interviews concerning prior SSA referrals were conducted on
November 6, 2023, and February 1, 2024. And in this case, SSA interviewed
12
Dr. Reinhart on March 21 and 29, and April 28, 2024. Thus, Dr. Reinhart’s
observations concerning the parents and the children were already reflected
in SSA’s reports.
Further, there is little evidence the section 730 report would have
added new information that was not already in SSA’s reports. Nothing in the
record shows Dr. Reinhart had any further contact with the parents or the
children after her interview with SSA on April 28, 2024. Indeed, Dr. Reinhart
told SSA on April 28 that the section 730 report was incomplete and “ha[d]
been suspended due to Social Services involvement.” Neither party has cited
any evidence showing Dr. Reinhart ever resumed the section 730 report or
that it was ever completed.
The juvenile court also found the section 730 report had “a
different focus than this court requires.” The mother does not contest this
finding, so we must accept it. (Hernandez v. First Student, Inc. (2019) 37
Cal.App.5th 270, 277.) Given the different focus of the juvenile and family
court proceedings, the juvenile court could reasonably decide the section 730
report was not sufficiently relevant to the dependency case and order a new
report to be prepared.
For the above reasons, it was not irrational for the juvenile court
to conclude the section 730 report had little probative value. Thus, it did not
abuse its discretion by refusing to request the section 730 report directly from
the family court or by refusing to order SSA to obtain it. (See Harman v. City
and County of San Francisco, supra, 158 Cal.App.4th at p. 428.)
Finally, we note that the mother’s opening brief states that she is
also appealing the juvenile court’s dispositional rulings from July 1, 2024.
Her briefs do not identify any errors in these rulings. They only address the
reconsideration motion. As such, we find the mother has waived any
13
argument that the court erred in its dispositional rulings from July 1, 2024.
(Cahill v. San Diego Gas & Electric Co., supra, 194 Cal.App.4th at p. 956.)
DISPOSITION
The juvenile court’s order denying the reconsideration motion is
affirmed.
MOORE, ACTING P. J.
WE CONCUR:
DELANEY, J.
SCOTT, J.
14
Ti chiedi come si applica questo testo alla tua situazione?
Consulenza gratuita, senza impegno
Descrivi la tua situazione. Il nostro team ti ricontatterà via e-mail per la tua consulenza.
Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude
Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.