In re A.M. CA5

CourtListener 10370762Calctapp28 mar 2025

Testo completo

Filed 3/28/25 In re A.M. CA5

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FIFTH APPELLATE DISTRICT

In re A.M. et al., Persons Coming Under the
Juvenile Court Law.

FRESNO COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF F088433
SOCIAL SERVICES,
(Super. Ct. Nos. 0087183-2,
Plaintiff and Respondent, 0087183-3)

v.
OPINION
MARIA A.,

Defendant and Appellant.

THE COURT*
APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of Fresno County. Amythest
Freeman, Judge.
Amanda K. Moran, for Defendant and Appellant.
Daniel C. Cederborg, County Counsel, and Lisa R. Flores, Deputy County
Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
-ooOoo-

* Before Peña, Acting P. J., Meehan, J. and Snauffer, J.
Appellant Maria A. (mother) is the mother of twin seven-year-old daughters, A.M.
and E.M. (collectively, the children), who are the subjects of this dependency case.
Mother challenges the juvenile court’s order issued at a Welfare and Institutions Code
section 366.261 hearing that resulted in her parental rights being terminated. On appeal,
mother contends the judgment terminating parental rights should be reversed because she
was denied reasonable services during the reunification period. The Fresno County
Department of Social Services (department) claims that this issue was addressed in
mother’s petition for extraordinary writ proceeding; and the doctrines of res judicata and
law of the case bar mother from relitigating this issue. We affirm.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
A. Facts and Procedural Background Prior to Writ Proceeding2
“Initial Removal
“On June 14, 2022, the [department] received a suspected child abuse report that
the children were exposed to domestic violence. An investigating social worker
responded to a rural intersection to meet a deputy from the Fresno County Sheriff’s
Department. The deputy explained that a passerby had contacted law enforcement after
mother and Juan R. (father)[3] were seen fighting in their vehicle. The children were
found in the back seat of the vehicle when the deputy arrived at the intersection. The
family was familiar to the deputy because he responded to their home several times, and
there was currently a restraining order between mother and father. Father was arrested

1 All further undesignated statutory references are to the Welfare and Institutions
Code.
2 The summary of facts and procedural history through the 12-month review hearing
is derived from our previous opinion in this case (Maria A. v. Superior Court of Fresno
County (June 10, 2024, F087643) [nonpub. opn.] (Maria A.).)
3 “Father is not a party to this appeal.”

2.
for violating the restraining order, and he was transported to the Fresno County jail. [¶]
… [¶]
“Later that day, the social worker visited the children at their foster home. A.M.
did not want to speak with the social worker, but E.M. was willing to talk in the presence
of her care providers. E.M. reported that she lived with her mother, father, and A.M. She
stated that she never felt unsafe in her home, and she was not afraid of anyone in her
home. E.M. denied that she was spanked, and she claimed to have a good relationship
with mother and father. A.M. reportedly hit E.M. ‘all the time,’ but they were still
friends.
“E.M. responded that father hit mother in the face when asked about the previous
day. She was crying and telling her parents to stop during the incident. E.M. indicated
that she was ‘really scared,’ and her parents would not stop fighting. She understood that
father went to jail and mother went to see a doctor. E.M. stated that she wanted to stay
with her care providers, and she did not want to go back home.
“On June 16, 2022, the department filed an original petition alleging the children
were described by section 300, subdivision (b)(1). The allegations of the petition
involved ongoing domestic violence between the parents and mother’s untreated mental
illness. The petition alleged that mother was driving carelessly without the children
buckled. It further alleged that the parents were involved in a physical altercation in the
presence of the children.
“The department filed a detention report on June 17, 2022, which set forth the
above events surrounding removal. At a detention hearing held on June 17, 2022, the
juvenile court ordered the children detained from mother and father’s custody, and both
parents were provided supervised visits with the children at least once per week for
one hour. A combined jurisdiction and disposition hearing was set for July 28, 2022.

3.
“Jurisdiction and Disposition
“The department’s jurisdiction and disposition report dated July 22, 2022,
recommended that the allegations in the original petition be found true and family
reunification services be provided to mother and father. The children remained placed
together in a family foster agency home, and no relatives were available for placement.
An adult brother was willing to adopt the children, but he could not facilitate
reunification because he lived in Los Angeles. Both children appeared to be
developmentally on track at five years of age. A.M. had not had a seizure in over a year,
but she was prescribed emergency seizure medication. Ongoing mental health treatment
was recommended for A.M., but E.M. was not found to meet medical necessity for
mental health treatment.
“The report detailed previous child welfare referrals involving the children. In
October 2018, a referral alleged mother shook the children when she became upset, and
the children fell from their crib due to a lack of supervision. The following year, a
referral stated A.M. was seen at a hospital due to seizure activity and a burn-like mark. In
September 2021, the department received a referral alleging mother was aggressive and
appeared to be under the influence of a controlled substance. Each of the referrals was
either deemed ‘unfounded’ or ‘evaluated out.’
“On May 17, 2022, a referral alleged law enforcement responded to the family’s
home after father was arrested for domestic violence. There were also concerns for dirty
conditions of the home and mother’s mental health issues. The referral was ‘evaluated
out’ because it was determined that mother ‘appeared to be stable.’ The next day, a
referral stated that the children lived with relatives for an entire month while mother was
in a mental health facility in April 2022. It was reported that mother was bipolar and
c[ould] become aggressive. The referral was eventually substantiated due to the June 14,
2022 incident.

4.
“A social worker contacted mother by phone on June 28, 2022. Mother explained
that she needed a ride to attend her visit with the children, but the social worker
responded that it would not be possible at that time. The social worker offered to provide
a bus pass, but mother became upset and yelled profanities at the social worker. The
phone call was terminated after mother was advised that continued yelling and cursing
would end the phone call. The social worker then informed mother that the visit would
be virtual because she had no transportation and there were no buses within her area of
residence.
“On July 7, 2022, a maternal aunt, C.A., told the social worker that mother was
recently hospitalized at a behavioral hospital. C.A. indicated that she did not know the
details surrounding mother’s hospitalization. The social worker reached mother by phone
on July 11, 2022. Mother had been discharged from her hospitalization, and she was
taking her medication. She explained that she was diagnosed with bipolar disorder,
anxiety, and depression, and she was prescribed Abilify and Oxcarbazepine. [¶] … [¶]
“There were no concerns noted during mother’s supervised virtual visit that
occurred on June 28, 2022. A July 5, 2022 supervised virtual visit was cancelled after
mother failed to join the visit. On July 11, 2022, a supervised virtual visit was terminated
early because mother refused to comply with visitation guidelines. Mother was advised
that she needed to speak in English for the supervised visit, but mother continued to
speak to the children in Spanish and use profanities. The next day, mother argued with
the visitation supervisor after she was advised that she could not make promises to see
the children or have additional phone calls with the children.
“During a July 18, 2022 virtual visit, mother told the children that they should kick
and hit dogs in the face if they are licked by them. The children were playing with
building blocks during the visit, and mother promised that she would buy them building
blocks. After mother was asked not to make promises to the children by the visitation
supervisor, mother began shouting that she talks to the children this way, and she also

5.
used an expletive. The visit was terminated after only 20 minutes due to mother’s
behavior.
“Mother’s proposed case plan included the following objectives: 1) show your
ability and willingness to have custody of your children; 2) comply with all orders of the
court; 3) pay attention to and monitor your children’s health, safety, and well-being; and
4) consistently, appropriately, and adequately parent your children. Her recommended
services included: 1) complete a mental health assessment and any recommended
treatment; 2) complete a domestic violence assessment and any recommended treatment;
3) participate in an approved parenting program; 4) demonstrate her knowledge of
age-appropriate behaviors, expectations and discipline techniques during her visits with
the children; 5) complete a substance abuse evaluation and recommended treatment; and
6) participate in random drug testing. Any missed drug tests would be considered a
positive test result by the department.
“The department recommended that mother participate in a psychological
evaluation to determine if she had a disabling mental disorder that would prevent her
from benefitting from reunification services. It was also recommended that mother
participate in a risk assessment to determine the level of risk that the children would
experience if returned to mother’s care.
“At the jurisdiction and disposition hearing held on July 28, 2022, mother and
father were both present and represented by counsel. The juvenile court found the
allegations in the original petition true, removed the children from the parents’ custody,
and ordered family reunification services for mother and father. Both parents were
ordered to participate in parenting classes, substance abuse, mental health and domestic
violence evaluations and recommended treatment, and random drug testing. Mother was
ordered to participate in a psychological evaluation and risk assessment. Visitation was
to be supervised once per week by the department, an approved third party, or an
approved agency. A six-month review hearing was set for January 26, 2023.

6.
“Six-Month Review Period
“In its report for the six-month review hearing dated January 20, 2023, the
department recommended the juvenile court continue family reunification services for
mother and father. Both parents were living together, and there were no active restraining
orders between them. The children remained placed in the same foster home, and they
felt safe and comfortable in the placement. Both children expressed their desire to return
to their parents’ care, but they also reported being afraid because of the constant fighting
between their parents. They had witnessed their mother bleed after father put his hand
over her face. The children also stated that mother fought with ‘everyone,’ including
people at the store, school, and neighborhood.
“A.M. was taken off of her seizure medication, and it was determined that she had
likely outgrown her seizure risk. Both children were developing on track and enrolled in
kindergarten through a homeschool based charter school. A.M. began mental health
treatment in August 2022, and she was learning coping skills. The care providers
explained that A.M. had a difficult time opening up to the therapist, but she enjoyed
participating in play therapy. E.M. completed a second mental health assessment in
October 2022, and she was found to meet medical necessity for services. E.M.
participated in weekly therapy sessions, and a case manager provided her with emotional
behavior support. [¶] … [¶]
“Mother completed her parenting class on October 19, 2022. She learned that
hitting the children was not a solution, and she was taught about the importance of
communicating with the children. In October 2022, mother began an online child abuse
intervention program according to the recommendation of her domestic violence
assessment. Mother’s program was placed on a hold in November 2022 due to
consecutive missed classes. An intake appointment was scheduled for January 23, 2023,
to allow mother to reenroll in the child abuse intervention program.

7.
“Initially, mother refused to sign a release of information to allow the department
to obtain information from her ongoing mental health provider. Mother was reportedly
participating in weekly therapy, and she declined to participate in mental health services
through the department. She provided proof of attendance for four different dates in July
and August 2022, but the department did not receive any information on her treatment
goals, diagnoses, or psychiatric services. On January 17, 2023, mother indicated that she
would be signing a release of information for her mental health provider, but
confirmation was not made at the time of the report. The social worker referred mother
for a psychological evaluation in August 2022, and mother was on the waitlist at the time
of the report. [¶] … [¶]
“During the six-month review period, the parents were transitioned from
supervision being provided by the department to an agency for intensive supervised
visits. On July 25, 2022, mother shouted at the department’s visitation supervisor
because she was admonished to speak English to the children during the supervised visit.
The parents were referred to an agency for intensive supervised visits on August 5, 2022.
At a virtual visit on August 8, 2022, mother became angry when one of the children
referred to their care provider as ‘mom,’ and mother shouted that she should not call the
care providers ‘mom’ or ‘dad.’ Later in the same visit, mother shouted that the children
were disgusting for walking barefoot in the care providers’ home while dogs were inside.
The department’s visitation supervisor ended the visit because mother was shouting,
cursing, and speaking in an aggressive tone towards the children.
“According to visitation narrative forms prepared by the parents’ visitation coach,
intensive supervised visits began on August 19, 2022. Overall, the visitation notes
indicated that the parents kept the children engaged and were verbally affectionate, but
the parents were often admonished for failing to follow guidelines and set boundaries.
“On August 26, 2022, the visitation coach reminded the parents to follow
guidelines and not discuss future visits or living arrangements at the outset of a virtual

8.
visit. During the visit, the parents began to discuss the date that the children would return
home, and mother told the children that they would return home in six days. The
visitation coach attempted to redirect the parents, but both parents began using
inappropriate language toward the coach. The coach ended the virtual visit due to the
parents’ violation of visitation guidelines.
“At a two-hour in-person visit on September 16, 2022, both parents were present
and provided snacks for the children. The visitation coach turned on a show for the
family while they were sitting together on a couch. A.M. nodded in the affirmative after
mother asked if she was doing alright. Afterwards, E.M. told mother that she talked
about mother and father with her therapist. E.M. initially stated that she could not talk
about what she told the therapist because it was ‘ “bad.” ’ However, mother inquired
further, and she stated, ‘ “[i]t is you and daddy fighting. Do you still fight?” ’ Mother
hugged and kissed E.M., and the visit continued.
“The children told the parents that they were sad because they wanted to return
home during a virtual visit on October 7, 2022. The parents comforted the children and
explained that they would bring their favorite snacks to the next visit. The next week, the
children ate snacks and watched a movie with the parents. E.M. began to cry at the end
of the visit, and both children stated that they wanted to go home. On October 21, 2022,
mother denied that she still fought at home when E.M. asked her. The visitation coach
noted that both parents had learned to follow intensive supervised visitation guidelines by
the end of October 2022.
“On November 4, 2022, A.M. did not wish to participate in the visit with her
parents and E.M. due to a stomachache. The visitation coach asked A.M. if she wanted to
join the visit for a small amount of time, but A.M. took a step back and declined. Father
acknowledged that A.M. told him that she had a stomachache the previous week. E.M.
participated in the visit by eating snacks, watching a movie, and playing cornhole. A.M.
apologized to her parents for missing their time during the next visit.

9.
“During a makeup visit on December 15, 2022, E.M. told mother that the children
were not allowed to sit on their parents’ laps or go to the restroom with them. During the
visit, mother took the children to the restroom and visitation staff suggested that E.M. go
into the restroom stall by herself. The family watched a movie together, and visitation
staff told the children that they could sit on their parents’ laps.
“On December 23, 2022, and December 30, 2022, the children informed visitation
staff that they did not want to go in to their scheduled visit with the parents. Each time,
they expressed a desire to see their parents the following week instead. Mother became
agitated after the children declined to attend a January 6, 2023 visit. The children were
advised that they would not be alone with their parents, but they continued to refuse.
“Arrangements were made to have a virtual visit on January 13, 2022, but the
children still refused to participate. The visitation supervisor inquired if both children
would attend a visit the following week to watch movies and have snacks. Both children
agreed to attend. However, A.M. only agreed because she was scared, and E.M. still
wanted to think about it. The visitation center indicated that the referral for intensive
supervised visits would be closed due to a fourth refusal.
“The social worker’s assessment for the review report stated that the parents’
visitation did not progress because of their lack of compliance with the case plan. In
addition, the children refused to participate in visits because they did not wish to return to
their parents’ care, and they did not want to be tricked into returning to their parents. The
children also reported that they were afraid to return to their parents’ care because of their
fighting. The social worker advised that visitations would be supervised and they would
return to the care providers after the visit, but they continued to state that they would not
visit. The children were told to contact the social worker if they wanted to visit with their
parents.
“At the six-month review hearing held on January 26, 2023, both parents were
present and represented by counsel. After submitting on the department’s

10.
recommendation, mother’s counsel requested ‘either video, telephonic, … [a]nd maybe
even separate visits,’ to address any fear that an argument would break out during the
parents’ visitation. Her counsel also indicated that mother was willing to separate from
father, if necessary, to have the children returned. In response, counsel for the department
suggested that the juvenile court could order that ‘intensive supervised therapeutic visits’
be provided again. Mother’s counsel then agreed with the department’s offer to
coordinate intensive supervised visits.
“The juvenile court adopted the department’s recommendation to continue family
reunification services, and it also found that reasonable services were provided to aid the
parents in overcoming the problems that led to the children’s removal. The previous
visitation orders were modified to allow ‘therapeutic intensive visits,’ and the department
was provided with the discretion to determine if visits should be separate for the parents.
The 12-month review hearing was set for July 11, 2023.
“Twelve-Month Review Period
“ The children refused to attend scheduled visitations with their parents for most of
the 12-month reporting period. The social worker arranged a virtual visit between the
children and parents on February 10, 2023. A.M. began crying during the visit, and she
left the video screen. E.M. smiled and interacted with the parents during the virtual visit.
E.M. told her parents that A.M. was crying because she missed them. Later in the visit,
A.M. reappeared for a moment while she was still crying.
“The following week, the social worker supervised another virtual visit between
E.M. and the parents. A.M. did not participate in the visit, and mother stated that it was
‘ok’ that she did not join. The social worker redirected mother when she told E.M. that
the children would be home in a couple of months. Mother informed E.M. that she did
not fight anymore, and she shared that she was taking her medication now.
“On February 23, 2023, the social worker supervised an in-person visit between
E.M. and the parents. A.M. was encouraged to join in the visit, but she declined to

11.
participate. The parents brought pizza, cake, and candy for E.M. to celebrate father’s
upcoming birthday. During the visit, mother asked the social worker if she could provide
cell phones to the children because she wanted to make sure that the care providers were
telling the children that they were in the care provider’s home temporarily. The social
worker admonished mother to focus on the visit.
“Another in-person supervised visit took place between the parents and E.M. on
March 2, 2023. A.M. indicated that she did not want to participate even though the social
worker would be present and supervising the visit. Mother became confrontational with
the social worker after she observed that E.M. was the only child present. Mother
continued to state that the children were coming home, and she wanted the care providers
to understand. The social worker informed mother that this was not an appropriate place
to discuss the issue because E.M. was present, but mother continued to discuss her
concern that A.M. was not present.
“In the visitation room, mother began to ask if E.M. told her sister about the things
she does with her parents during visits. The social worker redirected mother to focus on
the visit when mother asked about topics she would like to discuss during an upcoming
meeting. Mother stated that the social worker was always rude, and E.M. looked to
mother for a reaction during a subsequent admonishment from the social worker.
“On March 10, 2023, an intensive supervised visit was scheduled for the parents
and children, and the previous visitation coach was present to supervise the visit. The
children were brought to the agency, but they both told the visitation coach that they did
not want to attend the visit. The parents asked if they had other options to speak to the
children, and mother wished that she knew why her children refused the visit.
“The social worker arranged separate visitations for each parent and the children
on March 24, 2023. The children refused to participate in either visit. According to the
care provider, the children had a tough week after a visit took place the previous week.
The social worker noted that one of the children believed mother was lying about being

12.
better than she was before. The visitation coach encouraged mother to hold off on
bringing toys and focus on talking about the children’s feelings. Mother indicated that
she was looking to have family therapy with the children, and she would bring notebooks
to the visits to discuss their feelings.
“The following week, the children refused to attend their intensive supervised visit
with either parent. The visitation coach explained that they would visit each parent
separately and return to the care provider afterwards, but the children still chose not to
participate.
“On April 3, 2023, mother’s counsel filed a section 388 petition requesting that the
juvenile court order that the children be ‘mandated’ to attend visits. As changed
circumstances, the petition stated that mother completed all of her family reunification
services. The request was alleged to be in the children’s best interests because it would
allow the children to reunify with mother. The court denied the request without a hearing
due to a lack of changed circumstances or new evidence.
“On April 7, 2023, the children indicated that they did not want to visit because
they did not want to go home with either parent. The visitation referral at the agency
providing intensive supervision was closed due to three consecutive refusals by the
children.
“Attempts were made by the social worker to supervise virtual visits between the
parents and children on April 14, 2023, and April 21, 2023. The social worker explained
to the children that the visits would be online, but they still declined to participate. The
department was unable to refer the parents to an agency for visitation because the
children were refusing, and the cancelled visits would take spots from other families who
were on the waiting list.
“The social worker agreed to allow the parents to send a video of themselves to
the children in an attempt to encourage them to visit. On April 28, 2023, the social
worker asked the children about their thoughts on the video and desire to visit. Both

13.
children continued to state that they did not want to see their parents. Mother’s mental
health case manager had agreed to supervise a visit, but the visit had to be cancelled
because the case manager’s supervisor did not give her approval.
“The children’s counsel submitted a report from its investigator, which
documented interviews of the children and their care providers on May 2, 2023. The care
providers informed the investigator that the children had not engaged in any visits since
March 17, 2023. A.M. agreed to participate in that visit after E.M. told her about how
much fun a previous visit was. The children displayed no concerning behaviors prior to
the visit. A.M. cried for the first five minutes of the visit, and father told A.M. that the
parents no longer fought with each other. During the night following the visit, A.M.
began crying and stating that she believed father was lying about the parents no longer
fighting. A.M. reportedly cried at random during the following week.
“The children’s care providers also described an occasion where A.M. started to
cry while they were driving in the car. A.M. asked if the care providers were taking her
back to the parents’ home while she was crying in the car. A.M. became calm once the
care providers explained that they were driving to a store. Later that same day, A.M.
screamed when the front door opened because she thought her parents were coming to
take her home. There were also incidents where A.M. would urinate in her bed or have
nightmares prior to visits with her parents. The children had informed the care providers
that they did not wish to return to their parents’ care because they believed the parents
would continue to fight with each other.
“At the start of A.M.’s interview, the investigator determined that A.M. knew the
difference between the truth and a lie. A.M. explained that she felt ‘really safe’ with the
care providers because there was ‘ “no one fighting” ’ in the home. Even though her last
visit with father went well, she believed that father lied to her and E.M. about the parents
no longer fighting. A.M. stated that she no longer wished to visit because she believed
the parents would continue to fight with each other.

14.
“The investigator asked A.M. about her reasoning for not wishing to have phone
or virtual visits, and A.M. responded that she did not want to see her parents anymore.
A.M. wished to remain placed with her current care providers, but she believed that she
and E.M. may return to the parents in the future. In the event that A.M. was returned
home, she expressed that she would feel sad. A.M. denied that any person had instructed
her on what to say regarding her wishes to visit with her parents.
“The investigator also spoke separately to E.M., and it was determined that E.M.
also knew the difference between the truth and a lie. E.M. shared that she did not wish to
have further visits with her parents because she did not want to return home. She was
afraid that her ‘ “mommy and daddy” ’ would fight again, and she also described how she
previously witnessed mother fight one of father’s friends. E.M. explained that she did
not like people fighting with each other because it made her sad. She also denied that any
persons instructed her about how to respond regarding her desire to visit with her parents.
“On May 19, 2023, the social worker attempted to coordinate a visit between the
parents and children at a park. A third party had been cleared to supervise the visit. The
social worker arrived at the visit to find the third-party supervisor and mother standing by
the care providers’ vehicle and asking the children why they did not want to visit. Both
children quickly responded that they did not want to visit with their parents when asked
by the social worker. The children also refused the social worker’s offer to play on the
playground.
“Mother asked the children if they could try again next week. A.M. responded,
‘ “I’m not doing visits anymore,” ’ and E.M. shook her head in disagreement. Next, the
children were asked to provide a reason for their refusal by mother. A.M. told mother,
‘ “because I don’t want to go home.” ’ Mother asked the children why they did not want
to return home, and A.M. explained that she was scared. The social worker advised that
mother should stop making the children feel like they were being interrogated, and the
care provider was given permission to leave with the children.

15.
“Mother indicated that she wanted her therapist to speak to the children’s therapist
because mother believed the social worker and care providers were telling the children to
refuse visits. Additional attempts were made by the social worker to encourage the
children to visit on May 23, 2023, and June 9, 2023. The social worker informed the
children that they could see their parents anytime, but the children continued to state that
they did not want to visit with their parents.
“The department’s report for the 12-month review hearing dated June 23, 2023,
recommended termination of mother and father’s family reunification services. Mother
and father were still living together, and they hoped to get through the case together. The
children remained placed together in the home of the same foster family. There were no
significant medical or developmental concerns for either of the children. Both children
were participating in individual therapy with separate clinicians, and they also had group
therapy as siblings.
“A.M. began working with a new mental health clinician, Amanda L., in
April 2023. Amanda noted that A.M. had behavior and attachment issues, and she was
having difficulty separating from the care provider. The care provider noted that A.M.
continued to have difficulties opening up to the clinician, but she appeared to be able to
express her feelings well to the care provider and social worker.
“E.M.’s mental health clinician, G.F., stated that E.M. was always engaged in her
sessions, and she talked about the domestic violence between her parents on occasion.
On May 15, 2023, the social worker asked both children’s clinicians if they would
recommend family therapy with their parents, and the clinicians responded that they did
not believe the children were ready for family therapy.
“Mother was participating in individual therapy with mental health clinician L.L.
once per month. Her clinician provided the social worker with an update by phone in
June 2023. According to the clinician, mother was attending consistently, and she was

16.
working on managing her emotions with coping skills. Mother also participated in group
therapy once per month where she worked on arts and crafts.
“In June 2023, mother completed another substance abuse assessment, and she did
not meet medical necessity for treatment. Her last random drug test was a negative result
in February 2023, and she had not been requested to test since that date. As of June 13,
2023, mother had completed 16 sessions of her child abuse intervention program.
Mother was fifth on the waitlist for a psychological evaluation at the time of the report.
“During the review period, father participated in his substance abuse program, but
he missed one or two sessions each week due to his work schedule. He also missed
several drug tests and tested positive for alcohol on five occasions. On June 6, 2023,
father completed the 12-week anger management program that was ordered through his
criminal case.
“Twelve-Month Review Hearing
“At the 12-month review hearing held on July 11, 2023, the children’s counsel
requested that the juvenile court order the children’s therapists to provide a letter
detailing whether intensive supervised visitation or conjoint therapy with the parents was
therapeutically recommended. Any patient privilege regarding that specific assessment
would be waived by the children’s counsel. Mother’s counsel requested that a child
psychiatrist from mother’s mental health provider be allowed to either ‘collaborate’ with
the children’s therapists or have access to the children in order to prepare his own report.
“Both parents requested a contested hearing, which was set for August 29, 2023.
The juvenile court noted that it only wanted to hear from the children’s therapists, but it
would be open to additional referrals in the future. Each of the children’s therapists was
ordered to provide a letter explaining why they are not recommending that the children
participate in intensive supervised visits or conjoint therapy with the parents as well as
the basis for that opinion.

17.
“The department submitted an addendum report on August 11, 2023, which
included a letter from each of the children’s mental health clinicians and their clinical
supervisor. The letter provided a summary of the children’s treatment and a
recommendation for future mental health services. Both children were assessed for
mental health services on July 11, 2022. The assessment provided diagnoses of
posttraumatic stress disorder and disinhibited social engagement disorder for both
children.
“E.M.’s current clinician, G.F., had been providing her with individual therapy
since December 2022. E.M.’s initial symptoms included nightmares, reenactments of
trauma during play, feelings of guilt and fear, social withdrawal, difficulty concentrating,
difficulty sleeping, over-familiarity with adults, willingness to leave with unfamiliar
adults, and reduced reticence in interacting with unfamiliar adults. A.M.’s current
clinician, Amanda, had been providing individual therapy since April 2023. A.M.’s initial
symptoms included spontaneous intrusive memories regarding witnessing domestic
violence, socially withdrawn, irritability, angry outbursts, easily attaching to adult
figures, absence of reticence when approaching unfamiliar adults, and overly familiar
verbal or physical behaviors with adults.
“The letter concluded that the children were not ready to begin family therapy due
to their history of trauma and impairment. The clinicians’ plan was to continue to prepare
the children for family therapy, however, it was not in the children’s best interests to
begin family therapy at that time.
“On August 29, 2023, the children’s counsel requested a continuance of the
contested hearing to allow additional time for the children’s clinicians to explore the
possibility of family therapy between the children and parents. The juvenile court
acknowledged that it had previously ordered that the children participate in therapeutic
visits. However, it ordered that the children should not be forced to attend visits, and

18.
anyone putting undue stress on the children would not be viewed favorably by the court.
Without objection from the parties, the court continued the hearing to November 2, 2023.
“In an addendum report dated October 30, 2023, the department provided
additional information on its attempts to encourage visitation between the parents and
children. The social worker indicated that the children were asked weekly about their
willingness to visit with their parents since April 2023, but the children continued to
refuse any type of visitation. The report also detailed several positive test results for
alcohol from father’s random drug testing. Father explained that he drank beer after
work, and he did not see any problems with his alcohol use.
“After the previous hearing, the social worker asked the children’s clinicians if
they could observe an in-person visit. The clinicians explained that observing the visit
could damage the therapeutic relationship between the children and clinicians. The
department and children’s clinicians put together a plan to start family therapy when the
children were ready to start visitation. The report also noted that the visits that were
cancelled at the agency due to the children refusing were considered ‘[t]herapeutic
[i]ntensive visits.’
“On September 8, 2023, a mental health provider sent the social worker a family
case plan for the children and parents with a goal to engage all of them in family therapy.
The services would be provided weekly for both parents and children once all parties
were ready to participate in family therapy.
“There was some progress toward family therapy according to a September 20,
2023 update from the children’s clinicians. A.M. declined to paint a picture for her
parents, but she was willing to view the pictures that her parents drew. E.M. requested to
write a letter for her parents without prompting during her session. The letter to her
parents indicated that she wanted to stay in the care provider’s home. E.M. also shared
stories about the parents fighting, father grabbing mother’s face, and father going to jail.

19.
“Both clinicians continued to work on building a bond and working through any
fears the children had about seeing their parents. The clinicians were also able to have
sessions with each parent by providing psychoeducation on the effects of trauma on
young children. Mother was updated on the progress toward family therapy, and the
clinician believed mother was developing an understanding of the need for a slow pace
towards family therapy.
“During a monthly contact on October 2, 2023, the social worker had the children
express themselves through an activity by drawing three different houses: house of
dreams, house of good things, and house of worries. Both children drew the care
providers and their foster siblings in their house of dreams. Both parents were drawn in
each child’s house of worries. A.M. explained that mother was hitting father in the face,
and she was worried that her parents would hit each other if she had to go back home.
E.M. stated that she worried that her parents would fight if she went back home, and she
began to tear up.
“A child and family team meeting took place on October 10, 2023, to discuss
progress towards family therapy. Amanda stated that A.M. experienced increased sadness
during therapy and at the care providers’ home. Amanda was working with mother since
the previous month to pace her with therapy for the children and provide updates on
progress. G.F. explained that E.M. was encouraged to try family therapy, but E.M.
refused to see her parents. The clinical supervisor reported that both clinicians were
doing well with encouraging the children to try family therapy, but the process could not
be pushed to happen sooner. The social worker had noticed that A.M. was tearful and
fearful during monthly contacts, and A.M. had to be reminded that the social worker was
not there to take her home.
“The children’s counsel submitted an additional report from its investigator on
October 31, 2023. The care providers told the investigator that A.M. cried multiple times
per day as a result of her fear that she would return to the parents’ care. A.M. was also

20.
becoming more aggressive by hitting E.M. and her foster siblings. E.M. stated that she
no longer wished to have visits with her parents because she was close to being returned
to her parents’ care, and she did not want to return to her parents. E.M. expressed her
understanding that her parents were participating in services to allow the children to
return home, but she indicated that she would not feel safe in her parents’ care. A.M.
reiterated her previous statements that she did not want to visit or return to the parents
because she was afraid of their fighting.
“The contested hearing was continued to November 16, 2023, due to the
unavailability of a Spanish interpreter. An additional continuance was granted after a
conflict resulted in father being appointed new counsel. At a January 9, 2024 settlement
conference, the matter was confirmed for a contested hearing to be held on January 23,
2024. The next day, new counsel filed a substitution of attorney on mother’s behalf to
replace her court-appointed counsel.
“The department prepared a third addendum report dated January 17, 2024, which
incorporated mother’s psychological evaluation and risk assessment. The
recommendation for the review hearing remained the same, and its assessment stated that
mother had not benefitted from her programs. Mother had completed a parenting
program, and she was still participating in a child abuse program.
“The children continued to refuse visits with their parents despite the social
worker’s repeated efforts to coordinate visits in the months leading up to the contested
review hearing. Mother had regular meetings with A.M.’s clinician to receive
psychoeducation regarding the effects of trauma in children and how she may rebuild the
parent-child relationship in the future. Mother provided letters, photos, and positive
memories in an attempt to bond with the children.
“The children were attending individual therapy weekly, but E.M. refused to
attend a session in November 2023. A.M. was willing to keep a toy that mother provided
for her, but she refused all other items from mother. E.M. refused to take any items,

21.
letters, or paintings that mother provided for her. Both of the children’s clinicians
attempted to offer the children a brief visit where they could play a game with their
parents with them present, but the children still refused to meet with either of their
parents. The children’s display of increased sadness, irritability, and aggressiveness both
at the care providers’ home and during sessions resulted in a temporary hold on offering
the children items from their parents. The subject of family therapy would be pursued
once symptoms decreased, and conjoint sessions between both children would be
assessed.
“Dr. Alexander Johnson, a licensed psychologist, completed a report for mother’s
psychological evaluation and risk assessment on November 29, 2023. The report
described a clinical interview between mother and Johnson that took place on
September 25, 2023. Mother explained how her parents separated due to domestic
violence perpetrated by her father, and she recalled witnessing her father physically abuse
her mother several times as a child. On one occasion, mother intervened in a fight by
hitting her father with a pot of boiling beans because she feared that her father was going
to kill her mother.
“Mother indicated that the domestic violence aspects of her relationship with
father began one year prior to the children’s removal. The parents were participating in
couples’ therapy, but she did not offer any perceived growth or benefit from therapy. In
total, mother estimated that she had been placed under a psychiatric hold pursuant to
section 5150 approximately eight to 10 times since 2003. Her current psychiatric
treatment included weekly therapy and psychiatric medication. At least one of her
psychiatric hospitalizations was related to her history of medication noncompliance.
“Johnson inquired about mother’s understanding of the children’s refusal of visits,
and mother responded, ‘ “if the care providers had been talking good about it there’s no
reason why they wouldn’t want to be visiting with us.” ’ It was noted that mother made
an effort to minimize her current life stressors during the assessment. The report

22.
concluded with a diagnostic impression of ‘Bipolar I Disorder, Unspecified,’ which
mother had been previously diagnosed with. Her disorder did not appear to be disabling
because she was medication and treatment compliant at the time of the assessment.
“Bipolar I disorder was described as a mental health condition that does not
typically resolve spontaneously, and most individuals who are diagnosed with bipolar I
disorder require medication interventions to manage their manic and depressive episodes
across their life span. Due to mother’s past disregard for her medication treatment,
Johnson opined that her ‘currently tenuous medication compliance’ was a point of
concern that would likely impair her ability to parent. A remedy for this concern was for
mother to demonstrate medication compliance and engagement with therapy treatment
for a sustained period of time of no less than nine months.
“Based upon the totality of the evidence in the report, Johnson concluded that
there was a moderate risk of the children being physically, sexually, and/or emotionally
abused by mother if they were allowed to visit or return home. Mother continued to lack
awareness of her role in the children’s refusal to visit, and she did not take responsibility
for her own behaviors that created tension in their relationship. During the assessment,
mother verbalized her continued belief that the children did not visit with her because
they were being improperly counseled by their current care providers.
“Johnson recommended that the children be allowed to decline or terminate
visitation at any time due to the ‘clear schism that has arisen between [mother] and her
children .…’ Supervised in-person visitation could be appropriate once the children were
willing to consistently engage in visitation with mother.
“After a final continuance at the request of mother’s new counsel, a contested
12-month review hearing began on February 8, 2024. The contested hearing started with
testimony from mother’s mental health case manager, N.G. Mother became a patient of
N.G.’s after she was elevated to a higher level of care in November 2022. N.G. provided

23.
coaching, education, and support for her assigned patients, but she resigned from the
mental health provider in January 2024.
“During N.G.’s initial contacts with mother, she noticed that mother was agitated,
crying, and unable to control herself. After several months, mother began taking her time
to breathe and calm herself down. N.G. testified that mother was engaged in her services
and maintained her appointments throughout the previous year. Mother told N.G. about
her belief that the care providers were telling the children to not participate in visits.
There were also occasions that mother expressed her lack of understanding about the
reasons the children stopped visiting with her.
“The social worker’s supervisor, Abigail M., testified that the children’s case was
assigned to her unit in March 2023. Abigail had reviewed the reports that were prepared
for the review hearings, and she acknowledged that mother was participating in her
court-ordered services. Conjoint family counseling had been part of the case plan, but
Abigail was not aware of any specific order for mother to participate in conjoint family
counseling.
“The children were refusing visits at the time that Abigail was supervising the
children’s case, and she had conversations with the assigned social worker about ways to
get the children to participate in visits. In situations where children refuse to visit, the
department consults with treating clinicians and attempts family therapy. Family therapy
was delayed between mother and the children because the department was consulting
with the treating clinicians.
“In her 25 years of experience with the department, Abigail had observed children
begin to refuse visits after past participation. She believed such refusals could be based
upon a sense of not feeling safe and remembering past trauma. Children may begin to
remember past trauma from removal while participating in therapy, which may cause
them to refuse visits with a parent.

24.
“The children continued to participate in therapy, and their clinicians did not
believe that either of them were ready for visitation or family therapy. The children’s
clinicians expressed that the children were not ready because they had not processed their
trauma. The department was not aware of any evidence that the children were coached to
refuse visits after inquiring of the care providers and the children’s clinicians. It was the
department’s position that additional trauma would be inflicted if the children were
forced to participate in visits with their parents, and a social worker is unable to
physically force a child to attend a visit.
“The parents indicated that they were living in separate residences, but father also
stated that he would move back into the home if the children returned to mother’s care.
Abigail testified that visitations appeared to be detrimental to the children’s well-being.
Mother had completed a parenting program, and she continued to participate in a child
abuse program and therapy. However, mother reportedly made statements that she did
not believe that domestic violence had any impact on her children.
“Mother testified on her own behalf. She described the children as loving and
playful, and the children had a ‘[v]ery good’ relationship with each other. Prior to the
children’s removal, father worked for 10 hours each day while mother took care of the
children. Mother testified that her mental health was poor on the date of the children’s
removal, and she indicated that she was not sleeping well due to prescription
medications. Mother also acknowledged that the children were traumatized by mother’s
mental health episode and arguments between the parents. She denied ever using any
physical discipline on the children.
“Her hospitalization for three days pursuant to section 5150 was her third hospital
stint in 2022. Mother testified that she was devastated when she returned home to find
that the children had been removed. She was emotional during her first virtual visit after
the removal, and the children and mother told each other ‘I love you.’ At their

25.
first in-person visit, the children were happy during the visit, but mother observed the
children to be sad at the end of the visit.
“Mother felt the children began to act differently during a visit in December 2022.
She testified that the children reported being told not to sit on the parents’ laps by the care
providers. The children appeared hesitant to get close to the parents, but A.M. still gave
mother a kiss at the end of the visit. The first declined visit occurred just before
Christmas, and mother did not know why the children did not attend. At an attempted
visit in a park, mother told the children that she loved them, and E.M. reportedly
responded, ‘I love you more.’
“Mother was previously connected with a mental health provider, but she was not
engaged in therapy until after the children’s removal. She testified that therapy taught her
how to manage her depression and anxiety. Her parenting class taught her how to
discipline and set boundaries with the children. She was still attending a 52-week child
abuse program, which taught her about the effects of trauma on children. A psychiatrist
prescribed two medications to treat mother’s mental health issues, which she identified as
Wellbutrin and Trileptal. She attributed two of her past hospitalizations to interactions
between her medication that interfered with her sleep.
“Mother desired to participate in counseling with the children, and the social
worker provided her with information about potentially participating in counseling due to
the refused visits. However, she was never able to participate in any counseling with the
children during the case. Mother testified that she was no longer living with father. She
did not intend to get back together with father because their relationship had ‘a lot of
arguing,’ and she was disappointed in his positive drug test results. Mother was informed
that the children refused to visit due to the parents excessive arguing. Mother testified
that she and father never argued during any of their visits with the children. Mother did
not believe that she ever had the opportunity to … prove to the children that she would no
longer expose them to fighting.

26.
“On cross-examination, mother acknowledged that she and father had physical
altercations in the presence of the children on more than one occasion. She understood
that the department scheduled her for ‘therapeutic or intensive supervised visits’ after it
was reported that staff did not feel safe with mother’s behavior at the previous visitation
facility. Mother denied that she ever yelled at social workers, but she admitted to
disagreeing with the social worker and raising her voice on occasion. She also testified
that she did not believe the care providers were coaching the children, but she felt that
they were not motivating them to visit. Mother never observed any physical reactions in
the children to suggest they were afraid of her during visits.
“Father testified that he completed a parenting class and anger management
program. He stated that he would complete his substance abuse program if his
reunification services were continued. Father was not aware of the reasons that the
children refused visits, but he hoped to have the opportunity to reunify with the children.
“The next day, the contested hearing continued with closing arguments from the
parties. Counsel for the department argued that it met its burden of proof that it would be
detrimental to return the children to the parents’ care. It also asserted that the department
had shown by clear and convincing evidence that reasonable services were provided.
Counsel for the children agreed with the department’s position. She asserted that there
would be an emotional detriment to the children if returned home with citation to the case
of In re Joseph B. (1996) 42 Cal.App.4th 890 .…
“Mother’s counsel argued that mother did not pose a risk to the children because
she was living separately from father and had benefited from her services. Both mother
and father’s counsel claimed that the department failed to provide reasonable services.
“After hearing argument from all counsel, the juvenile court continued the hearing
for a ruling on February 16, 2024. In its ruling, the court acknowledged that both parents
had likely made moderate progress in reaching their goals. However, it reasoned that the
focus of its inquiry should be on the emotional well-being of the children even when the

27.
parents had been compliant with services. The court also indicated that conjoint therapy
with the parents would be detrimental to the children.
“The juvenile court ultimately found that return of the children to mother would
create a substantial risk of detriment to the children, and it also found that the department
provided reasonable services. Both parents family reunification services were
terminated, and a section 366.26 hearing was scheduled for June 11, 2024.”

B. Facts and Procedural Background After Writ Proceeding Commenced
Extraordinary Writ Petition
Mother filed a petition for extraordinary writ relief seeking review of the juvenile
court order setting the section 366.26 hearing. (Maria A., supra, F087643.) In her
petition, mother asserted insufficient evidence supported the juvenile court’s finding that:
1) return of the children to her custody would create a substantial risk of detriment; and
2) reasonable services were provided. Specifically, mother argued that the department
failed to provide reasonable services because conjoint family therapy was required under
the circumstances. In our opinion filed June 10, 2024, we rejected mother’s claim that
reasonable services were not provided, and we affirmed the juvenile court’s orders.
Section 366.26 Hearing
The department’s section 366.26 report, dated June 6, 2024, recommended the
juvenile court terminate the parental rights of mother and father and order a permanent
plan of adoption for the children. The children remained placed in the home of the same
resource family since June 14, 2022. At six years of age, both children had no noted
health concerns, and they were developing on target for their ages. Both children were
receiving mental health services to learn coping skills and express their feelings. The
children’s care providers were committed to providing a permanent plan of adoption for
the children.
The children continued to refuse visits with mother. Mother had not been able to
demonstrate consistent participation in visits with the children due to their refusal for

28.
over a year. The social worker concluded that it would not be detrimental to the children
to terminate parental rights. The current care providers were observed to meet the
children’s needs for security, nurturing, support, and guidance during the social worker’s
monthly visits.
A continued section 366.26 hearing was held on July 2, 2024. Mother was present
and represented by counsel for the hearing. Mother’s counsel submitted with comments
regarding the children’s refusal to visit with mother. Counsel concluded her comments as
follows: “It’s just concerning that given what’s at stake and the orders that are about to
be made, that the [d]epartment didn’t do its job to ensure that the children have the
opportunity to actually see their mother and the changes that she had made, given how
much they said they loved and missed her when they were first removed. Submitted.”
The juvenile court responded by asking if all the things stated by mother’s counsel
were subject to litigation at the contested 12-month review hearing in February. Mother’s
counsel responded, “[t]hat is correct.” The juvenile court proceeded to adopt the
department’s recommendation by terminating the parental rights of mother and father and
selecting a plan of adoption for the children. Mother filed a timely notice of appeal.
DISCUSSION
Mother’s only contention on appeal is that reasonable services were not provided
to mother because the reunification plan did not include conjoint therapy between the
children and mother. The department argues that the doctrines of law of the case and res
judicata prevent mother from relitigating the issue of reasonable services.
Under section 366.26, subdivision (l), “[a]ll court orders, regardless of their
nature, made at a hearing in which a section 366.26 permanency planning hearing is set
must be challenged by a petition for extraordinary writ.” (In re Merrick V. (2004) 122
Cal.App.4th 235, 247.) Such orders may not be reviewed on appeal from a later
appealable order. (In re Anthony B. (1999) 72 Cal.App.4th 1017, 1024 [“[T]he
Legislature, by its enactment of section 366.26, subdivision (l), sought to outlaw review

29.
by appeal of all decisions made in conjunction with a setting order.”].) As the court
observed in In re Diana G. (1992) 10 Cal.App.4th 1468, 1477–1478, “the findings made
[at the 12-month review that] … subsequently formed the basis of the termination ruling
… following the section 366.26 permanency planning hearing, have become res
judicata.”
“ ‘Res judicata’ describes the preclusive effect of a final judgment on the merits.
Res judicata, or claim preclusion, prevents relitigation of the same cause of action in a
second suit between the same parties or parties in privity with them. Collateral estoppel,
or issue preclusion, ‘precludes relitigation of issues argued and decided in prior
proceedings.’ ” (Mycogen Corp. v. Monsanto Co. (2002) 28 Cal.4th 888, 896.) Direct
estoppel precludes relitigation of issues based on the prior decision when the
second action is on the same claim. (Sabek, Inc. v. Engelhard Corp. (1998) 65
Cal.App.4th 992, 997.)
The analysis for direct or collateral estoppel is the same: “ ‘ “First, the issue
sought to be precluded from relitigation must be identical to that decided in a former
proceeding. Second, this issue must have been actually litigated in the former
proceeding. Third, it must have been necessarily decided in the former proceeding.
Fourth, the decision in the former proceeding must be final and on the merits. Finally,
the party against whom preclusion is sought must be the same as, or in privity with, the
party to the former proceeding.” ’ ” (Sabek, Inc. v. Engelhard Corp., supra, 65
Cal.App.4th at pp. 997–998.)
In the present case, mother had the opportunity to challenge the court’s finding
that reasonable services were provided at the 12-month review hearing in these same
proceedings with the same children. In fact, mother sought an extraordinary writ petition
from the order terminating her reunification services. Mother’s argument was based in
part on the lack of conjoint family therapy between mother and the children. We rejected
mother’s argument that there was insufficient evidence to support the juvenile court’s

30.
finding that reasonable services were provided to her during the review period. Those
orders are final now, and mother may not collaterally attack them.
On appeal from the section 366.26 hearing, mother makes the identical argument:
that the department’s reunification plan was unreasonable because it “inexplicably failed
to contain a plan for conjoint therapy between [m]other, [the children], and their
therapists.” In her reply brief, mother asserts that res judicata may not be applied “ ‘ “if
injustice would result or if the public interest requires that relitigation not be
foreclosed.” ’ ” (Consumer Advocacy Group, Inc. v. ExxonMobil Corp. (2008) 168
Cal.App.4th 675, 686.)
We find mother’s argument unpersuasive. To permit additional appellate review of
an order finding that reunification services were adequate would only delay dependency
proceedings, contrary to the strong public policy against protracted litigation in these
cases. (In re Rebecca H. (1991) 227 Cal.App.3d 825, 836–837.) In light of the
importance of expediting the process where children are placed in a permanent home and
minimizing the uncertainties occasioned by such delay, we conclude that the doctrine of
res judicata bars mother from relitigating the reasonable services issue on appeal. (In re
Diana G., supra, 10 Cal. App. 4th at p. 1477–78.)
The department also relies on the law of the case doctrine. (See Searle v. Allstate
Life Ins. Co. (1985) 38 Cal.3d 425, 435.) Pursuant to the doctrine of law of the case,
“when, in deciding an appeal, an appellate court ‘states in its opinion a principle or rule
of law necessary to the decision, that principle or rule becomes the law of the case and
must be adhered to throughout its subsequent progress, both in the lower court and upon
subsequent appeal …, and this although in its subsequent consideration this court may be
clearly of the opinion that the former decision is erroneous in that particular.’ ” (Kowis v.
Howard (1992) 3 Cal.4th 888, 893.) Moreover, as in the present case, the doctrine
applies to a prior writ proceeding, not resulting in a summary denial, but rather where the

31.
review of the matter “necessarily includes a consideration of and ruling upon the merits
of the petition.” (Lewis v. Superior Court (1999) 19 Cal.4th 1232, 1260.)
“Thus, the law-of-the-case doctrine ‘prevents the parties from seeking appellate
reconsideration of an already decided issue in the same case absent some significant
change in circumstances.’ ” (People v. Boyer (2006) 38 Cal.4th 412, 441.) As mother
notes, the doctrine can be disregarded to avoid an unjust decision. (People v. Shuey
(1975) 13 Cal.3d 835, 841.) Mother contends “ ‘exceptional circumstances’ ” allow this
court to “ ‘decide the case without regard to what has gone before.’ ” (Searle, supra, 38
Cal.3d at p. 434.) Mother’s reply brief states that the present appeal is sought because
mother “believes the prior rulings of the trial court and the prior ruling of this [c]ourt
were incorrect, and that her parental rights should not be terminated.”
For the “ ‘unjust decision’ ” exception to apply, however, “there must at least be
demonstrated a manifest misapplication of existing principles resulting in substantial
injustice.” (People v. Shuey, supra, 13 Cal.3d at p. 846.) The doctrine of law of the case
is generally followed “not because the court is without power to reconsider a former
determination, but because the orderly processes of judicial procedure require an end to
litigation.” (Gore v. Bingaman (1942) 20 Cal.2d 118, 122–123.)
In our prior opinion, this court affirmed the judgment of the juvenile court from
the 12-month review hearing where the court found reasonable services were provided
and terminated mother’s family reunification services. (Maria A., supra, F087643.) On
appeal, mother merely reiterates her prior complaints surrounding the absence of conjoint
family therapy in her case plan during the reunification period. She provides no valid
arguments to support her claim that an erroneous decision resulted in substantial
injustice. As stated in our prior decision, the department made extensive efforts to
resolve the problems that led to the removal of the children. The subsequent termination
of her parental rights is an unfortunate result for mother, however, it cannot be attributed

32.
to the misapplication of existing legal principles in a prior decision. (Maria A., supra,
F087643.)
In sum, we conclude the law of the case doctrine is also applicable to mother’s
appeal. Neither the application here of res judicata principles or the law of the case
doctrine will render an unfair result. Therefore, we decline to revisit arguments on appeal
dealing with the reasonableness of reunification services. Given mother’s failure to
address any issues stemming from the section 366.26 hearing, we affirm the juvenile
court’s order.
DISPOSITION
The order is affirmed.

33.

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.