CourtListener 10353268•In re Aaron L. CA2/3
Testo completo
Filed 3/10/25 In re Aaron L. CA2/3
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION THREE
In re AARON L., a Person B336317
Coming Under the Juvenile
Court Law. Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No.
LOS ANGELES COUNTY 23CCJP03974
DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN
AND FAMILY SERVICES,
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v.
L.R.,
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from orders of the Superior Court of Los Angeles
County, Kristen Byrdsong, Juvenile Court Referee. Affirmed.
William Hook, under appointment by the Court of Appeal,
for Defendant and Appellant.
Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, Kim Nemoy,
Assistant County Counsel, Melania Vartanian, Deputy County
Counsel for Plaintiff and Respondent.
_________________________
Mother challenges the juvenile court’s jurisdictional
findings and order declaring her then-10-year-old son Aaron
a dependent of the court under Welfare and Institutions Code
section 300, subdivisions (a) and (b)(1).1 Mother contends there
was no substantial evidence that Aaron was at substantial risk
of serious harm due to mother’s or father’s alleged conduct.
We affirm.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND2
The Department received a call in mid-October 2023
alleging mother had left Aaron (born May 2013) at maternal
grandmother’s house and was living on the streets, doing drugs.
Before mother left, maternal grandmother (MGM) had called
the police “to get mother out of her home.” On October 26, 2023,
a Department social worker called mother and told her the
Department was investigating allegations of general neglect.
Mother refused to speak with the social worker.
1 Statutory references are to the Welfare and Institutions
Code.
2 Mother challenges the jurisdictional findings based on
both her and father’s conduct. Father has not appealed. As
we conclude below, substantial evidence supports the court’s
jurisdictional findings based on mother’s conduct. Accordingly,
we do not discuss in detail father’s separate conduct or his
domestic violence against mother. (See In re I.J. (2013) 56
Cal.4th 766, 773 (I.J.) [where substantial evidence supports
at least one statutory ground for jurisdiction, appellate court
need not consider validity of other alleged grounds for
jurisdiction].)
2
That same day, the social worker interviewed Aaron
at his school. He confirmed mother had dropped him off about
three weeks earlier. He had not seen her, but he had spoken
to her on his cell phone the day before. Aaron said his mother
had dropped him off before, but this was the longest time she
had left him. They had been homeless, staying at hotels or on
others’ couches. When they didn’t have a place to stay, Aaron
said his mother would drop him off at his aunt’s or grandmother’s
home. He stated his mother took good care of him when they
were together and he always had enough to eat. As for his father,
Aaron told the social worker he did not like him and had not
seen him in “a long time.” Aaron stated father had mental health
issues—he had gotten angry and hit his mother in the past.
He had seen father “shove” and “punch” mother. Aaron denied
fearing mother or father and said mother always had been
“available to meet his needs.” Aaron felt safe in his aunt’s home.
The social worker also spoke to maternal aunt by phone.
Maternal aunt said she had told mother she would watch Aaron
until mother was better. Maternal aunt told the social worker
mother was mentally unstable and addicted to drugs. Mother’s
drug addiction had gotten worse over the last two years.
Maternal aunt explained mother initially had not made a plan
with her to care for Aaron—she “just left” Aaron at the home
of MGM, who had said she could not care for the child. Another
of mother’s sisters could not care for Aaron either, so maternal
aunt told mother she would watch him. Aaron currently was
sleeping on her couch, but she was in the process of moving
to a bigger home and would have more space for Aaron.
The next day, October 27, 2023, the social worker
interviewed MGM at her home. MGM had mother “removed
3
from her home a couple of weeks ago because she was ‘acting
crazy.’ ” Mother told her she would return for Aaron, but mother
never did. MGM told the social worker mother was a drug addict
and had mental health issues. She did not know what kind of
drugs mother used or her mental health diagnosis. MGM was
not willing to care for Aaron due to her age. She said maternal
aunt, a nurse, had agreed to care for Aaron, and MGM was
willing to supervise him after school.
On November 1, 2023, the social worker assessed maternal
aunt’s home and found it was appropriate. Maternal aunt told
the social worker mother had messaged her that day and asked
if Aaron could stay with her a little longer. Mother did not say
when she planned to pick Aaron up. Maternal aunt was willing
to care for Aaron “as long as needed”—she wanted him “to be safe
and not out in the streets.” Maternal aunt told the social worker
MGM had kicked mother out of her home because mother “was
being aggressive.” According to maternal aunt, MGM had raised
mother’s two adult sons.
The social worker reached mother by phone on November 8,
2023. Mother denied the allegations. She said MGM “had kicked
her out of her home with all her belongings in bags.” She was
embarrassed to walk around the streets with her bags and child
and also did not want to expose Aaron to the streets. Mother
told MGM she would return to pick up Aaron. Mother said she
had not returned for Aaron because she still was on the streets,
which were dangerous and no place for a child. When the
social worker asked mother what her plan was for Aaron, she
responded, “ ‘Does it matter if I make a plan[?]’ ” Mother said
maternal aunt had offered to “keep Aaron until she was ready.”
Mother wasn’t sure when that would be—she wanted to find
4
“a place for them” first; she did not want Aaron on the streets.
Mother denied having any issues with or using drugs. She was
not willing to drug test for the Department without a court order,
however. Mother told the social worker she was spending her
money on hotels—not drugs—because she was homeless. (MGM
had said mother received $800 a month and had no money by
the third day because she was out doing drugs.) Mother said she
had been staying with different people and was in the process
of moving. She did not want to tell the social worker where
she was living. When the social worker asked mother about
giving maternal aunt temporary custody, mother refused.
Mother identified Aaron’s father but did not have his
contact information. Mother hadn’t had any contact with him
“for a long time.” Parents had a “past referral history of domestic
violence” with the Department corroborated by law enforcement
incident reports. In May 2022, Aaron saw father slap mother on
the head with an open hand. In March 2022, a caller reported
father put mother in a chokehold in front of Aaron; the incident
report stated father punched mother.
The court authorized Aaron’s removal from mother
and father on November 16, 2023. On November 20, 2023,
the Department filed a section 300 petition alleging Aaron was
at risk of harm due to father’s violent conduct against mother,
and mother’s failure to make an appropriate plan for his safety
and wellbeing when she left him with MGM. At the initial
hearing on November 21, 2023, the juvenile court detained Aaron
from mother and father, who were not present, and ordered
they have monitored visits. The court also ordered drug testing
referrals for parents. On December 29, 2023, the Department
filed a first amended section 300 petition adding allegations
5
that mother had a history of mental and emotional problems,
and father had a history of violent and assaultive behaviors,
that endangered Aaron’s physical health and safety and placed
him at risk of serious physical harm and danger.
The Department filed its jurisdiction/disposition report
on January 3, 2024. On December 5, 2023, the dependency
investigator (DI) interviewed Aaron at maternal aunt’s home,
where he remained placed. Aaron had not seen his mother
since she left but had spoken to her by cell phone. He hadn’t
seen or spoken to his father. He did not have father’s phone
number or know where he was. Aaron said he missed his
parents but “mother need[ed] to find stable housing and get
herself together.” He also wanted to see and live with father.
Aaron nevertheless stated, “ ‘I love being here,’ ” referring
to maternal aunt’s home.
When asked, Aaron told the DI this was the first time
mother had left him with family for an extended period. They
had been living with MGM for about a year when she “kicked
[mother] out” after she and mother got into an argument about
an issue with a bathroom fixture. Aaron stated, “ ‘She (mother)
left and I . . . went to school.’ ” Aaron didn’t know why mother
didn’t pick him up from MGM’s home after school that day.
Nor did mother call Aaron to explain he would be staying with
maternal aunt. Aaron said, “ ‘My grandma wanted me to stay
because my grandma didn’t know where my mom was going
to go.’ ” Aaron did not know where mother was living.
The DI asked Aaron about domestic violence. He saw
father punch mother in the face once about a year or two earlier.
Mother pushed father away and called the police. The DI asked
Aaron if he remembered an incident where father placed mother
6
in a chokehold. Aaron replied, “ ‘Oh yeah they were arguing
and my dad put my mom in a chokehold and I was trying to
stop it and then he stopped.’ ‘We were in the car.’ ‘I think to
buy something to eat.’ ‘They were arguing.’ ” When asked if
his parents argued frequently, Aaron responded, “ ‘Yeah but
they don’t hit a lot.’ ” He didn’t know what they argued about
and didn’t think they were in a current relationship. Aaron also
denied having seen mother or father use drugs. Aaron denied
ever seeing mother display signs of mental illness.
The DI also spoke with maternal aunt. She told the DI
mother communicated with her “ ‘here and there and she asks
how he’s [Aaron] doing.’ ” Mother was thankful Aaron was
with maternal aunt. Mother had called the day before, but she
did not speak with Aaron, who was at school. Maternal aunt was
concerned about mother’s mental health. She described mother
as “ ‘not all there’ ” since their father (maternal grandfather)
died. On the day MGM kicked mother out of her home, law
enforcement had arrived and asked maternal aunt if she could
care for Aaron. She agreed and picked Aaron up after school
that same day. Mother asked her if Aaron could stay with
her for a few days, and maternal aunt agreed. Mother called
maternal aunt again a few days later and asked if Aaron could
stay with her a little longer. Maternal aunt said she agreed and
told mother Aaron “ ‘could stay with me because [I] didn’t want
him in the street.’ ” Maternal aunt told the DI this was the
first time Aaron had been in her care for this length of time.
He sometimes visited for a weekend to play with her daughters,
but never had stayed this long. Maternal aunt similarly
explained that mother would drop off Aaron with MGM
for a day visit but no longer.
7
When asked about substance use concerns, maternal aunt
said she believed father had introduced mother to drugs. She
had no evidence of mother’s drug use—and mother had denied
using any substances—but believed mother looked different.
Maternal aunt did not have concerns for Aaron in mother’s care
in terms of neglect or physical abuse. Rather, her main concern
was mother’s lack of stable housing.
The DI spoke with paternal uncle about father. The
paternal family had an active criminal protective order protecting
them from father. Father would become violent with the family
while under the influence of drugs. Aaron had stayed with
paternal family for a few days at the beginning of the year.
On December 13, 2023, the DI spoke with MGM. MGM
had not seen mother since she left the home. She was worried
mother was alone on the streets. MGM believed mother was
using drugs based on her appearance. MGM confirmed this
was the longest period of time mother ever had left Aaron in
the family’s care. Mother and Aaron had been living with her
for about a month and a half. Before that, mother used hotel
vouchers, and mother and Aaron had lived with maternal uncle.
MGM also had mental health concerns about mother. MGM
said she never witnessed any domestic violence incident between
parents, but mother had told her about them. She often observed
marks and bruises on mother’s arms, face, legs, and thighs,
however. MGM stated she last saw mother with bruises about
a month earlier.
On December 15, 2023, mother called the DI, who
interviewed her about the petition’s allegations. Mother insisted
she had made a plan with maternal aunt for Aaron’s care before
the Department became involved. She did not believe Aaron
8
had been detained from her. The DI told mother the court
had ordered the Department to give mother a testing referral.
Mother denied using drugs. She said she had consumed alcohol
in the past but had stopped after her father had died four years
earlier. Mother also admitted smoking marijuana eight years
earlier. She thought her family believed she was on drugs
because of her unstable housing and her skin problems. When
the DI asked mother if she would drug test, mother replied,
“ ‘No why am I gonna go today?’ ‘I have no clothes to shower.’
‘I haven’t eaten all day today . . . .’ ‘I have no money to wash.’
‘I haven’t eaten I feel we[a]k.’ ‘I don’t want to go.’ ‘I’m not
gonna go until [I] talk to the judge.’ ”
The DI also asked mother about her mental health. Mother
explained she received therapy and psychiatric assistance in 2022
for about six months. She stopped attending therapy when her
housing became unstable. Mother stated she was diagnosed
with major depression in 2019 and with a mood disorder in 2022.
She took Lexapro for a year but stopped. She stated, “ ‘I didn’t
feel like I needed it anymore.’ ”
As far as Aaron having been left in maternal aunt’s care,
mother explained MGM had called law enforcement when she
told mother she had to leave. Law enforcement would not let
mother take Aaron with her and insisted on taking him to school.
Mother said she told her sister, “ ‘I’m not sure if I can come back
because I had nowhere to go.’ ” Before Aaron’s school let out,
mother said she called her sister and asked her, “ ‘ “[C]ould
[he] please stay with you so that I can get a room?” ’ ” Mother
continued, “ ‘I was in the street alone, literally alone with
no money and no support.’ ” Mother confirmed this was the
first time she had left Aaron with family for this length of time.
9
When asked about her current plan, mother responded, “ ‘I’m
planning on getting my contacts back from my phone because
it broke and get started on my housing and look for perm[anent]
housing.’ ”
The DI explained to mother that the court had ordered her
to have monitored visits with Aaron. Mother did not want any
visits with Aaron with a monitor present. The DI tried to explain
visits were important for the reunification process. Mother
replied she did not want visits “as she [did] not need a monitor.”
After interviews with mother and Aaron, the
Multidisciplinary Assessment Team (MAT)/Child and Family
Team (CFT) met on January 31 about their findings. Aaron
wanted to stay in his aunt’s care. He needed to know he would
be “taken care of by his family.” Aaron had reported he was
“constantly worried about what will happen to him.” The
assessor was concerned mother would stop her mental health
services. The MAT report noted mother would benefit from
individual therapy sessions and continuing to participate
in mental health services.
The Department filed a last minute information (LMI)
on February 9 and on February 22, 2024. Mother had failed
to show for drug testing the last four weeks. Mother had
not visited Aaron nor made herself available for educational
decisions. Mother also had canceled a February 21 meeting
with the social worker. The Department noted Aaron needed
an Individual Education Plan (IEP), but parents had not
made themselves available to sign the documentation. The
Department asked the court to appoint maternal aunt co-holder
of Aaron’s educational and developmental rights. The court
did so on February 23.
10
During an interview with the DI at his place of
incarceration, father admitted he recently had used “ ‘crystal
meth’ ” and had used heroin in the past. Accordingly, on
February 24, 2024, the Department filed a second amended
petition, adding allegations regarding father’s drug use. On
February 29, the court continued the adjudication hearing
to March. The court also ordered the Department to confirm
whether the parenting class in which mother had enrolled
was Department-approved and, if not, to refer mother to
an approved class.
At the March 22 adjudication hearing, mother—through
her counsel—“vehemently denie[d]” that she failed to make
a plan for Aaron’s care. She insisted she had made a plan for
maternal aunt to care for him. Counsel argued it was only after
MGM escalated the situation by calling the police that mother
was unable to be there for Aaron, but she “immediately made
plans for the child to be with maternal aunt.” Counsel also
argued the Department had not proved mother had any mental
or emotional issues, which mother denied. Even if she had
such issues, counsel argued they did not affect mother’s
parenting, as Aaron “was safely cared for, attending school
and had food and clothing.”
Minor’s counsel submitted on the Department’s
recommendation. Counsel stated, “We believe mother does have
mental health issues and did not create the appropriate plan
and essentially dumped her child with family who did not expect
to care for the child, long-term. Our hope is that mother will
start cooperating with the Department and then be in a position
to take her son back in, but we don’t seem to be there, yet.”
11
The court sustained the petition as alleged. The court
declared Aaron to be a person described by section 300 and found,
by clear and convincing evidence, that he could not remain
safely in parents’ care. The court found there were no reasonable
means to prevent the child’s removal “given the unresolved issues
of domestic violence, substance abuse, and untreated mental
health.” The court ordered mother to complete random or
on-demand testing, to participate in a domestic violence
support group, parenting classes, and individual counseling,
and to submit to an Evidence Code section 730 evaluation.
Mother appealed.
DISCUSSION
Mother challenges the juvenile court’s sustaining of the
amended petition’s allegations under section 300 subdivisions
(a) and (b). The subdivision (a) allegation was based on parents’
history of engaging in domestic violence in Aaron’s presence.
The subdivision (b) allegations were based on the same domestic
violence count and four others: mother having left Aaron in the
care of MGM without making an appropriate plan for his care;
mother’s untreated mental health and emotional issues; father’s
history of violent behaviors; and father’s history of substance
abuse. Mother contends substantial evidence did not show Aaron
was at a current or future risk of harm from domestic violence,
mother’s mental health issues, or father’s violent behaviors
and drug use, and substantial evidence did not support finding
mother abandoned Aaron at MGM’s home.3
3 A child’s exposure to domestic violence may serve as
the basis of dependency jurisdiction. (In re R.C. (2012) 210
Cal.App.4th 930, 941.) There must be a reason to believe the
12
1. Standard of review and applicable law
“ ‘In reviewing the jurisdictional findings and the
disposition, we look to see if substantial evidence, contradicted
or uncontradicted, supports them. [Citation.] In making this
determination, we draw all reasonable inferences from the
evidence to support the findings and orders of the dependency
court; we review the record in the light most favorable to the
court’s determinations; and we note that issues of fact and
credibility are the province of the trial court.’ ” (In re R.T. (2017)
3 Cal.5th 622, 633; I.J., supra, 56 Cal.4th at p. 773.) Inferences
that are the result of speculation or conjecture, however, are
insufficient to support a jurisdictional finding. (In re B.D.
(2024) 103 Cal.App.5th 315, 324.) “ ‘The parent has the burden
on appeal of showing there is insufficient evidence to support
the juvenile court’s order.’ ” (In re L.B. (2023) 88 Cal.App.5th
402, 412 (L.B.).) “ ‘[A] reviewing court can affirm the juvenile
court’s finding of jurisdiction over the minor if any one of the
statutory bases for jurisdiction that are enumerated in the
petition is supported by substantial evidence.’ ” (I.J., at p. 773.)
domestic violence will recur to demonstrate a child is at future
risk of physical harm based on past exposure. (In re S.F. (2023)
91 Cal.App.5th 696, 714.) We need not reach the issue because
we find sufficient evidence supports the other two grounds—
based on mother’s conduct—for jurisdiction under section 300,
subdivision (b)(1): her failure to make an appropriate plan
for Aaron and her untreated mental health issues. (I.J., supra,
56 Cal.4th at p. 773.) As discussed, we similarly need not
consider the jurisdictional grounds based on father’s other
violent behaviors or his drug use. (See fn. 2, ante.)
13
A child comes within the jurisdiction of the juvenile court
under subdivision (b)(1) of section 300 if, as relevant here, “there
is a substantial risk that the child will suffer, serious physical
harm or illness,” as a result of: the failure or inability of the
child’s parent to adequately supervise or protect the child;
the willful or negligent failure of the parent to provide the child
with adequate food, clothing, shelter, or medical treatment;
or the inability of the parent to provide regular care for the
child due to the parent’s mental illness or substance abuse.
(§ 300, subd. (b)(1)(A), (C), (D).) A child cannot be found to
be a person described by subdivision (b)(1), however, solely
due to “[h]omelessness or the lack of an emergency shelter
for the family.” (§ 300, subd. (b)(2)(A).)
A jurisdictional finding under section 300, subdivision
(b)(1) requires the Department to prove: “(1) the parent’s . . .
neglectful conduct or failure or inability to protect the child;
(2) causation; and (3) serious physical harm or illness or
a substantial risk of serious physical harm or illness.” (In re
Cole L. (2021) 70 Cal.App.5th 591, 601.) The statute permits
jurisdiction under this subdivision “only so long as is necessary
to protect the child from risk of suffering serious physical harm
or illness.” (§ 300, subd. (b)(3).) Thus, “[t]he relevant inquiry
under section 300, subdivision (b)(1), is whether circumstances
at the time of the jurisdictional hearing ‘ “subject the minor
to the defined risk of harm.” ’ ” (L.B., supra, 88 Cal.App.5th at
p. 411.) The juvenile court need not wait for the child actually
to be abused or neglected before it can assume jurisdiction,
however. (I.J., supra, 56 Cal.4th at p. 773.) “The court may
consider past events in deciding whether a child presently
needs the court’s protection. [Citations.] A parent’s ‘ “[p]ast
14
conduct may be probative of current conditions” if there is reason
to believe that the conduct will continue.’ ” (Cole L., at p. 602.)
In other words, the Department “must establish a nexus between
the parent’s past conduct and the current risk of harm.” (In re
J.N. (2021) 62 Cal.App.5th 767, 775.)
2. Substantial evidence supports the juvenile
court’s assertion of jurisdiction over Aaron
Mother contends the evidence does not support
the finding that she did not make a plan for Aaron’s care.
As mother argues, she left Aaron with MGM because she
did not want him on the streets with her. She insisted
she had made a plan for Aaron’s care with maternal aunt
before the Department became involved. As mother notes,
in its February 9, 2024 LMI the Department acknowledged,
“Both mother and [maternal aunt] disclosed that prior to
[the Department’s] involvement, mother made a verbal
plan that Aaron would remain with [maternal aunt] given
mother did not have a stable place to live and neither
mother nor [maternal aunt] wanted Aaron on the street.”
As detailed above, when mother was kicked out
of MGM’s home, authorities asked maternal aunt to keep
Aaron and she agreed. Mother then asked aunt if she could
keep Aaron and later asked if he could stay longer with her.
Although mother and maternal aunt may have come to an
informal agreement after mother left, substantial evidence
—viewed in the light most favorable to the order—supports
the court’s finding that mother did not make an appropriate
plan for Aaron’s “safety and well being” when she left him
with MGM.
15
Mother did not arrange for Aaron’s long term care.
After MGM kicked mother out, mother did not tell anyone
—not even Aaron—when she would return. Critically,
MGM had said she could not take care of Aaron. Nor
could another aunt care for him, so maternal aunt agreed
she would. Maternal aunt thus already had stepped in
when mother asked her to keep Aaron. It was unexpected
that mother would leave Aaron for such a long time. She
never had done that before. And mother left Aaron without
provisions. Maternal aunt had to buy clothes for him.
Mother argues Aaron was not at substantial risk
of harm because maternal aunt was caring for him at all
times and had agreed he could stay with her until mother
was ready. True, Aaron was safe in maternal aunt’s care
at the time of the jurisdictional hearing. Nevertheless,
mother never gave MGM or maternal aunt any written
authorization to make decisions about Aaron’s care.
Mother did not make herself available for important
educational decisions. Nor does anything in the record
reflect she gave MGM or maternal aunt any type of
authorization to make medical decisions for Aaron in the
event of an emergency. Mother also refused to consider
giving maternal aunt temporary custody while she got
“herself together.” Given neither MGM nor maternal
aunt ever had cared for Aaron long term—and mother’s
whereabouts were unknown to them—the court reasonably
could find maternal relatives had no authority to stand in
for mother should Aaron require any type of medical
attention or other parental permission.
16
Moreover, the record shows mother lacked insight
into how leaving Aaron without a clear plan could affect
him. When the social worker asked mother what her
plan was for Aaron, she responded, “ ‘Does it matter if
I make a plan[?]’ ” Indeed, during the MAT assessment,
Aaron reported he was “constantly worried” about what
would “happen to him.” Nor could the Department confirm
mother’s participation in an online parenting course—
or verify the course’s curriculum—to assess if mother
had taken steps to gain insight.4 Mother also had
acknowledged she had untreated mental health issues
that the court could find impeded her ability to make
an appropriate plan for Aaron. For example, she refused
to visit Aaron because she didn’t want the visits to be
monitored. By the time of the jurisdictional hearing,
mother still had not arranged to visit her son. Indeed,
she had not seen him since leaving him at MGM’s home.
Accordingly, based on the totality of the circumstances,
the juvenile court reasonably could find mother again
would leave Aaron without making an appropriate plan.
And mother’s failure to give maternal relatives official
authorization to make decisions on Aaron’s behalf—or
to tell them her whereabouts—put Aaron at a current
risk of harm despite his aunt’s care of him.
Similarly, there is ample evidence in the record that
mother had unresolved mental health issues. Mother
4 The course apparently was provided by a company
in Ireland, but the documentation listed no phone number
or other contact information.
17
admitted she had been diagnosed with major depression
and a mood disorder in 2019 and 2022, respectively, and
had been prescribed psychotropic medication. Mother
stopped taking her medication because she didn’t feel she
needed it, however, and discontinued therapy due to her
unstable housing situation. Mother argues the Department
failed to prove a nexus between her mental health issues
and a current risk of harm to Aaron. “[H]arm may not be
presumed from the mere fact of a parent’s mental illness.”
(In re A.L. (2017) 18 Cal.App.5th 1044, 1050.)
Here, however, substantial evidence supports the
juvenile court’s finding that Aaron faced a risk of harm.
Based on the record, the juvenile court reasonably could
find mother’s untreated mental health issues affected
her judgment and her ability to put Aaron’s needs first.
For example, despite mother’s lack of housing being a
main impediment to her ability to care for Aaron, she left
a stable housing situation because she “did not want to live
in shared housing with strangers.” Mother also refused
to tell the Department—or Aaron or her family—where
or with whom she was staying.
Maternal aunt told the social worker mother “was
paranoid stating that people were stealing her identity
and looking for her.” Mother also told the social worker
about identity theft issues she had experienced due to her
older child’s father having taken financial aid owed to her.
She said that she sometimes thought people were laughing
at her. Mother—who had not attended the detention
hearing—also insisted Aaron had not been detained
from her. Again, she refused to visit Aaron because a
18
monitor would be present. Mother stated, “ ‘I do not want
visits I want to be all the way with him. I don’t want
anyone there and that’s what I am saying I want to give
that up right now.’ ” The court reasonably could find
mother’s position—her desire to be with her son, but
refusal to visit him at all with a monitor—demonstrated
irrational behavior that put her wishes above her son’s
best interests. Accordingly, viewing the record in the light
most favorable to the juvenile court’s findings, we conclude
the court reasonably could find mother’s apparent paranoia
was impairing her ability to care for Aaron and thus placed
him at a substantial risk of harm.
Moreover, mother did not seem to appreciate the
importance of treating her mental health issues for Aaron’s
sake. In November 2023, mother told the social worker
she had sought mental health services but could not make
her appointments due to her homelessness. In December
2023, mother told the MAT assessor her mental health
had deteriorated in 2019 because she was having trouble
grieving her father’s death. The MAT report implies
mother told the assessor that she was then being seen by
a psychiatrist. But nothing in the record indicates mother
was participating in mental health services at that time.
Mother presented no such evidence at the jurisdiction
hearing. In any event, the assessor was concerned mother
would stop her mental health services. In an LMI, the
Department also noted its concern that mother had stopped
attending therapy and taking her medication despite her
mental health diagnoses. Minor’s counsel expressed his
19
concern about mother’s mental health issues at the
jurisdiction hearing, as well.
Accordingly, we affirm the court’s jurisdictional
finding that Aaron is a child described under section 300,
subdivision (b), without considering the court’s subdivision
(a) finding, or its subdivision (b) findings based on father’s
conduct and parents’ domestic violence.
DISPOSITION
We affirm the court’s jurisdiction and disposition orders.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
EGERTON, J.
We concur:
EDMON, P. J.
HANASONO, J.*
* Judge of the Los Angeles County Superior Court, assigned
by the Chief Justice pursuant to article VI, section 6 of the
California Constitution.
20
Ti chiedi come si applica questo testo alla tua situazione?
Consulenza gratuita, senza impegno
Descrivi la tua situazione. Il nostro team ti ricontatterà via e-mail per la tua consulenza.
Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude
Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.