In re A.N. CA5

CourtListener 10348749Calctapp3 mar 2025

Testo completo

Filed 3/3/25 In re A.N. CA5

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FIFTH APPELLATE DISTRICT

In re A.N., a Person Coming Under the Juvenile
Court Law.

FRESNO COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF F088711
SOCIAL SERVICES,
(Super. Ct. No. 22CEJ300202)
Plaintiff and Respondent,

v. OPINION
R.C.,

Defendant and Appellant.

THE COURT*
APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of Fresno County. Mary Dolas,
Judge.
Gregory M. Chappel, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for Defendant
and Appellant.
Daniel C. Cederborg, County Counsel, and Ashley N. McGuire, Deputy County
Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
-ooOoo-

* Before Levy, Acting P. J., Franson, J. and Snauffer, J.
R.C., mother of now 10-year-old A.N. (minor), appeals from orders terminating
her parental rights. (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 366.26.)1 Mother argues noncompliance with
the Indian Child Welfare Act (ICWA) (25 U.S.C. § 1901 et seq.) and related California
law, by the Fresno County Department of Social Services (department). Specifically, she
argues the department prejudicially erred in failing to comply with and document
ICWA’s initial duty of inquiry regarding Native American ancestry, requiring conditional
reversal.
We find no error and affirm.
STATEMENT OF THE CASE AND FACTS
We limit our recitation of the background information to that necessary for
disposition of the appellate issue.
Minor had been in a probate guardianship with maternal grandmother, Maria L.,
from 2016 to 2019. In October of 2019, minor was placed into legal guardianship with
paternal aunt M.N. After M.N. was denied a request to travel with minor out of state, she
relinquished custody of minor to a Sanger police officer in June of 2022. Mother was
reported as having substance abuse issues, and alleged father, A.N. (father), was in
prison.
A team decision making (TDM) meeting was held June 21, 2022, the day after
minor was removed. Present at the meeting were mother, guardian M.N., maternal
grandmother Maria L., minor’s adult half sister M.M., paternal aunt Maria N., maternal
aunt E.E., and maternal uncle R.C. The record does not indicate if any were asked about
possible Native American ancestry, nor were they asked about maternal grandfather.

1 All further statutory references are to the Welfare and Institutions Code unless
otherwise stated.

2.
Detention
The department filed a section 300 petition alleging minor was at risk of harm due
to mother and father’s neglect and inability to care for him. The detention report stated
that mother reported that father was not minor’s biological father, but she would not
name the biological father. Mother reported a lengthy criminal history and drug use.
Mother claimed to have last used any drugs or alcohol in 2020 but tested positive for
methamphetamine the day of the TDM meeting.
The report indicated that mother and guardian M.N. both reported that they did not
have any Native American ancestry.
Detention was held June 23, 2022. At that time, mother reported verbally that she
did not have any Native American ancestry. Minor was detained and a jurisdiction and
disposition hearing scheduled for July 28, 2022.
Jurisdiction/Disposition Report and Jurisdiction Hearing
The report prepared for jurisdiction/disposition recommended that the allegations
of the petition be found true. The report recommended that mother be offered
reunification services, but that father and additionally named alleged father, E.V., not be
offered services pursuant to section 361.5, subdivision (a).
The report stated that M.N., minor’s paternal aunt, stated that father had no Native
American ancestry. The report also stated that maternal grandmother Maria L. was asked
and denied any Native American ancestry. The department requested that the juvenile
court find the ICWA did not apply.
Neither mother nor father was present at the October 8, 2022 jurisdiction and
disposition hearing. The juvenile court found the allegations of the petition true and
found father to be minor’s presumed father. Disposition was continued to November 10,
2022.

3.
Disposition Hearing
Mother was present at the November 10, 2022 disposition hearing. The juvenile
court made a finding that the ICWA did not apply.
The juvenile court ordered mother receive reunification services, but denied
services to M.N., pursuant to section 361.5, subdivision (b)(14); to father pursuant to
section 361.5, subdivision (e)(1); and to E.V., pursuant to section 361.5, subdivision (a).
Mother and father each received once a week visits with minor.
A six-month review hearing was scheduled for April 27, 2023.
Interim Review Hearing
A December 20, 2022, interim hearing was held in which the juvenile court
granted the motion terminating minor’s guardianship. All other orders remained in full
force and effect.
Six-Month Status Review Report and Hearing
The department’s report in anticipation of the six-month review hearing
recommended that mother’s reunification services be continued, and that minor remain a
dependent of the court. Minor continued to be placed in the home of a maternal aunt and
uncle, who expressed a willingness in either adoption or guardianship of minor.
Ongoing efforts to locate alleged father E.V. were unsuccessful. Mother had
maintained her employment and continued to “strengthen” her relationship with minor
through supervised visits. Mother was told she could have unsupervised visits after at
least two months of clean testing. Minor was reported to be happy in his placement and
showed some improvement after regression in communication skills following visits with
mother. Minor was visiting father via video while father was in prison.
While mother completed her parenting class, she continued to have numerous “no
shows” and “unable to provide” drug tests, as well as refusing to test three times. She
was dropped from a substance abuse program but re-enrolled. She was dropped from

4.
random drug testing and the department recommended a hair follicle test. Mother was
attending mental health treatment but had numerous no shows.
On February 9, 2023, father completed an ICWA-020 form stating he had no
Native American ancestry.
At the six-month review hearing April 27, 2023, the juvenile court ordered minor
remain a dependent of the juvenile court and continued mother’s reunification services.
Mother was ordered to submit to a fair follicle test.
The 12-month review was scheduled for August 17, 2023, with an interim review
June 22, 2023.
Interim Review Report
On June 22, 2023, the department filed an interim review report recommending
that minor continue as a dependent of the court and reunification services be continued
for mother. Mother had been participating in substance abuse treatment but was
terminated for non-compliance. She tested positive for methamphetamine on April 7,
2023, and for amphetamines on May 5, 2023, and had numerous “no shows,” “unable to
provide” and refusals to test. Mother failed to submit to the hair follicle test.
Neither mother nor father was present at the hearing on the interim status report on
June 22, 2023. The juvenile court issued an order vacating the hair follicle test, but made
no other changes to the existing orders.
12-Month Status Review Report, Addendum, and Hearing
In its August 8, 2023, 12-month review report, the department recommended
family reunification services for mother be terminated and a section 366.26 permanency
planning hearing be set. Minor continued to be placed with a maternal aunt, where he felt
comfortable. The maternal aunt and uncle continued to be willing to adopt minor.
While mother completed her parenting education program, she failed to re-enroll
in substance abuse treatment or random drug testing. Her mental health treatment
revealed mother to display an increase in depressive and anxiety symptoms as well as

5.
irritability, sadness, and worry. Mother attended all scheduled visits with minor, who
was always “excited” to see her. Father had supervised, online visits with minor, which
appeared to go well.
An addendum report filed October 5, 2023, provided additional information
regarding the ICWA. Mother and father had previously reported no Native American
ancestry, as had M.N., maternal grandmother Maria L., and maternal aunt E.C.
(previously referred to as E.E.). Mother completed an ICWA-020 form June 10, 2023
indicating no known Indian ancestry.2 The department attempted to contact minor’s half
sister Maria M., paternal grandaunt R.C., maternal cousins Y.M. and V.M., maternal
uncle R.C., paternal aunt Maria N., and paternal cousins J.C. and G.N., but the phone
numbers provided were either not in service, did not allow for messages, or a message
was left and no return call received.
Mother was present at the October 5, 2023, 12-month review hearing. The
juvenile court found that there was a substantial probability that minor would return to
mother’s home within the following six months and continued reunification services.
The 18-month review hearing was scheduled for December 20, 2023.
18-Month Status Review Report and Hearing
In its 18-month status review report, the department recommended that
reunification services for mother be terminated. Mother had now moved to San Diego
with an adult daughter. She was unemployed and had failed to follow through on court
ordered substance abuse programs, random drug testing, and mental health treatment.
Mother visited minor once or twice a month “when she is in Fresno.”
At the February 6, 2024, contested 18-month status review hearing, mother
requested a bonding study, which was denied without prejudice. The juvenile court

2 Mother and father both completed multiple ICWA-020 forms, always indicating
they had no known Indian ancestry.

6.
ordered minor remain a dependent of the court and terminated mother’s reunification
services. A section 366.26 permanency planning hearing was set for June 4, 2024.
Permanency Planning Report and Hearing
The June 4, 2024, section 366.26 hearing report repeated earlier ICWA
information from 2022 and 2023. It also reported extensive inquiry completed in 2024.
In March of 2024, the department received the family findings document for mother and
father, and began calling family members to inquire about any updated Native American
ancestry. M.M., minor’s half sister, was called, but an automated voice stated the number
did not work and the department was unable to leave a voicemail. That same day, the
department also contacted another of minor’s half siblings, D.M., and left a voicemail
stating the purpose of the call and a call back number. The department also attempted to
contact the father of one of minor’s half siblings, and was able to leave a voicemail
stating the purpose of the call and a call back number. The department contacted
mother’s previous stepfather, who did not know if mother had any Native American
ancestry. He did know that mother had never lived on a reservation. Maternal
grandmother, Maria L., was again contacted and again stated mother had no known
Native American ancestry and had never lived on a reservation. Maternal grandmother
stated that no other family member would know more that she did about any Native
American ancestry. The department attempted to contact R.C.N., a paternal grandaunt,
but was unable to leave a voicemail.
The department also contacted maternal cousin Y.M., who returned a call after a
voicemail was left. Y.M., stated that she was unsure who mother was and did not think
she was related to her, but that mother’s last name matched her mother’s last name. The
department then contacted maternal cousin V.M., who ended the call by stating it was the
wrong number.
The department also called R.C., maternal uncle, who confirmed he was mother’s
brother but was unaware of any Native American ancestry. R.C. stated that the only

7.
family member who would know more was his grandmother, who was deceased.
Voicemail messages were also left with E.C., maternal aunt; B.E., minor’s uncle by
marriage; paternal grandfather A.N.; paternal aunt Maria N.; and paternal cousins, J.C.,
Joshua C., and J.A. The department spoke to former guardian and paternal aunt M.N.,
who again denied any Native American ancestry on father’s side.
The department requested again that the juvenile court find the ICWA
inapplicable.
. Mother was not present at the July 30, 2024, permanency planning hearing.
Mother’s counsel urged the juvenile court to apply the beneficial relationship exception
to termination of parental right and choose guardianship as the permanent plan.
Following argument, the juvenile court found minor was adoptable and terminated
mother, father, and alleged father E.V.’s parental rights. By taking judicial notice of all
prior findings, the juvenile court impliedly found the ICWA inapplicable.
DISCUSSION
General Legal Principles and Standard of Review
“The ICWA protects the interests of Indian children and promotes the stability and
security of Indian tribes by establishing minimum standards for removal of Indian
children from their families, and by permitting tribal participation in dependency
proceedings. [Citations.] A major purpose of the ICWA is to protect ‘Indian children
who are members of or are eligible for membership in an Indian tribe.’ ” (In re A.W.
(2019) 38 Cal.App.5th 655, 662.) The ICWA defines an “ ‘Indian child’ ” as a child who
“is either (a) a member of an Indian tribe or (b) is eligible for membership in an Indian
tribe and is the biological child of a member of an Indian tribe.” (25 U.S.C. § 1903(4).)
The juvenile court and the department have an affirmative and continuing duty,

8.
beginning at initial contact, to inquire whether a child who is subject to the proceedings
is, or may be, an Indian child. (§ 224.2, subd. (a); Cal. Rules of Court, rule 5.481(a).)3
The protective provisions of ICWA turn on a determination of whether a minor is
an “Indian child” as defined by statute. (25 U.S.C. § 1903(4).) A determination by an
Indian tribe that a child is or is not a member of, or eligible for membership in, that tribe,
or testimony attesting to that status by a person authorized by the tribe to provide that
determination, shall be conclusive.” (§ 224.2, subd. (h); see rule 5.481(b)(4); 25 C.F.R.
§ 23.108 (2024).) Of course, a tribe may only make such determination, or exercise its
right of intervention, if it is made aware of the ongoing proceedings. Accordingly, the
scheme requires the appropriate tribe be notified when the court or county welfare agency
has reason to know the child is Indian. (§ 224.3, subd. (a); see U.S.C.§ 1912(a); 25
C.F.R. § 23.111(a) (2024).)
Fulfilling the notification duty requires sufficient inquiry into the child's native
heritage. “The court, county welfare department, and the probation department have an
affirmative and continuing duty to inquire whether a child ... [facing a dependency or
delinquency proceeding] is or may be an Indian child.” (§ 224.2, subd. (a); rule
5.481(a).) California’s statutory scheme imposes a duty of initial inquiry on both the
department and the court. The inquiry “includes, but is not limited to, asking the child,
parents, legal guardian, Indian custodian, extended family members, others who have an
interest in the child, and the party reporting child abuse or neglect, whether the child is,
or may be, an Indian child and where the child, the parents, or Indian custodian is
domiciled.” (§ 224.2, subd. (b).) Then, on the first appearance upon a petition, “the
court shall ask each participant present in the hearing whether the participant knows or
has reason to know that the child is an Indian child.” (§ 224.2, subd. (c); rule 5.481(a)(2);
C.F.R. § 23.107(a) (2024).)

3 All further refences to the rules are to the California Rules of Court.

9.
The duty of further inquiry exists when “the court, social worker, or probation
officer has reason to believe that an Indian child is involved in a proceeding, but does not
have sufficient information to determine that there is reason to know that the child is an
Indian child ....” (§ 224.2, subd. (e), italics added.) There is reason to believe a child is
Indian when there exists “information suggesting that either the parent of the child or the
child is a member or may be eligible for membership in an Indian tribe.” (§ 224.2, subd.
(e)(1); see id., subd. (d).) Further inquiry includes, but is not limited to, interviewing the
parents and extended family members, contacting the BIA and the State Department of
Social Services for assistance, and contacting the relevant tribe and “any other person that
may reasonably be expected to have information regarding the child’s membership,
citizenship status, or eligibility.” (§ 224.2, subd. (e)(2)(C); see id., subd. (e)(2); rule
5.481(a)(4).)
If proper inquiry reveals information creating reason to know a minor is an
“Indian child,” the relevant tribe must be notified, and “the court shall treat the child as
an Indian child unless and until the court determines on the record and after review of the
report of due diligence ... and a review of the copies of notice, return receipts, and tribal
responses ... that the child does not meet the definition of an Indian child ....” (§ 224.2,
subd. (i)(1); see rule 5.481(b)(3); C.F.R. § 23.107(b) (2024).)
“[W]e review the juvenile court’s ICWA findings under the substantial evidence
test, which requires us to determine if reasonable, credible evidence of solid value
supports the court’s order.” (In re A.M. (2020) 47 Cal.App.5th 303, 314, overruled on
other grounds in In re Dezi C. (2024) 16 Cal.5th 1112, 1152, fn. 18.) Not every error by
an agency or department in discharging its duties under section 224.2 will undermine the
court's ICWA finding, but the court's ability to exercise discretion in this regard is
dependent on adequate record development by the department. “ ‘ “On a well-developed
record, the court has relatively broad discretion to determine whether the agency's inquiry
was proper, adequate, and duly diligent on the specific facts of the case. However, the

10.
less developed the record, the more limited that discretion necessarily becomes.” ’ (In re
Kenneth D. [(2024) 16 Cal.5th 1087] at pp. 1101-1102; see also In re H.B. (2023) 92
Cal.App.5th 711, 721.)” (In re Dezi C., supra, at p. 1141.)
Analysis
Mother’s sole argument is that the department failed to conduct a sufficient and
further inquiry because a single maternal relative, minor’s maternal grandfather, was not
contacted and asked whether the minor had any Native American ancestry. We disagree.
While the Supreme Court of California has not found “what constitutes an
adequate and proper inquiry necessary to satisfy section 224.2,” the Court explained that
their “conclusion does not require reversal in all cases in which every possible extended
family member has not been asked about the child’s Indian ancestry.” (In re Dezi C.,
supra, 16 Cal.5th at p. 1140.) The Court further stated that:

“[S]ection 224.2 ‘does not require the agency to “find” unknown relatives
and others who have an interest in the child, merely to make reasonable
inquiries. The operative concept is those people who are reasonably
available to help the agency with its investigation into whether the child has
any potential Indian ancestry should be asked.’” (Ibid.)
In In re K.H. (2022) 84 Cal.App.5th 566 (K.H.), this court found that the
department’s inquiry into the dependent child’s Indian heritage, which went no further
than the child’s parents, was inadequate to comply with the ICWA. In K.H., the parents
were of unknown reliability on the question of ancestry, due to being in the “throes of
serious drug addiction,” and the department had identified and located numerous
maternal and paternal relative, including grandparents, but did not inquire of any of them
regarding potential Indian heritage. (K.H., supra, at p. 605.) However, K.H. did not
indicate that automatic reversal is required in in all cases where some extended family
members are missed in inquiry. As stated in K.H.,

“Where a juvenile court’s finding that ICWA does not apply is challenged
on appeal, it is difficult to envision a successful claim premised on the
agency’s failure to question a second cousin or a family friend, if the

11.
agency inquired of a child's closer maternal and paternal relatives on both
sides, those relatives provided no information suggesting possible Indian
ancestry, and the agency documented its efforts in the record for the
juvenile court’s review. In other cases, in contrast, second cousins or family
friends may be the only individuals available to ask. A different situation
yet is presented if there is no one beyond the parents to ask because they
refused to provide any information and the agency exercised due diligence
but was unable to identify and locate anyone else to ask, or if a relative was
specifically identified as having information on the subject but the agency
neglected that lead.” (Id. at p. 604.)
Reversal is necessary where inquiries are “merely perfunctory” and there is
insufficient documentation in the record. (K.H., supra, 84 Cal.App.5th at p. 606.) In
other instances, the inquiry finding may be upheld. If a reviewing court finds that the
juvenile court’s ICWA finding is supported by substantial evidence, it did not abuse its
discretion in finding a “proper and adequate further inquiry and due diligence” (§ 224.2,
subd. (i)(2)), and if it did not otherwise commit an error of law, the inquiry ends. (Ibid.)
This court determined in K.H. that the primary question of error is whether the
department’s inquiry extends “far enough to reasonably ensure that if there is information
the child is or may be an Indian child, that information is gathered.” (K.H., supra, at p.
604.)
Here, the department made contact with six maternal relatives throughout the case,
including mother, maternal grandmother Maria L., maternal aunt E.C., maternal uncle
R.C., and care providers and maternal aunt and uncle D.F. and M.F. The department
attempted to contact two other maternal cousins, Y.M. and V.M. It contacted M.M., an
adult sister of minor’s, and a possible half sibling D.M. While the department’s records
do not indicate it had contact with maternal grandfather, there is no indication in the
record that his contact information was available. In Dezi C., our Supreme Court stated
that the department has a duty to contact extended family that were “reasonably
available.” (In re Dezi C., supra, 16 Cal.5th at p. 1140.) Here, none of the many
maternal family members questioned mentioned maternal grandfather in the course of the

12.
ongoing case, including maternal grandmother. In fact, maternal grandmother informed
the department that no one in the family would have more information about possible
Indian ancestry than she did.
We do not find conditional reversal is required for the purpose of investigating the
maternal grandfather’s name and contact information because neither the department nor
juvenile court had interacted with him or had contact information for him, and none of
the extensive relatives who were contacted mentioned him either.
We reject mother’s challenge to the juvenile court’s determination that the
department’s inquiry into possible Native American heritage was adequate and that the
ICWA did not apply. The juvenile court’s finding, based on the evidence provided, that
there was no reason to know minor was an Indian child and that the ICWA did not apply
was supported by substantial evidence.
DISPOSITION
The juvenile court’s orders are affirmed.

13.

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.