In re K.N. CA2/2

CourtListener 10346974Calctapp27 feb 2025

Testo completo

Filed 2/27/25 In re K.N. CA2/2
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS

California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION TWO

In re K.N., a Person Coming Under
the Juvenile Court Law. B333489
LOS ANGELES COUNTY
DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN (Los Angeles County Super.
AND FAMILY SERVICES, Ct. No. 23CCJP02725A)

Plaintiff and Respondent,

v.

K.B.,

Defendant and Appellant.

APPEAL from orders of the Superior Court of Los Angeles
County, Lisa A. Brackelmanns, Judge Pro Tempore. Affirmed.
Anne E. Fragasso, under appointment by the Court of
Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, Kim Nemoy,
Assistant County Counsel, and Avedis Koutoujian, Deputy
County Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
___________________________
INTRODUCTION
K.B. (mother) appeals from jurisdictional findings and
dispositional orders after the juvenile court asserted jurisdiction
pursuant to Welfare and Institutions Code1 section 300,
subdivision (b)(1) over her then 14-year-old daughter, K.N.
(born September 2008) and removed her from mother’s care.
Mother contends the juvenile court erred when it found she was
unable to curtail K.N.’s increasing acts of misbehavior, including
running away from home and criminal activity that placed the
teen at substantial risk of serious physical harm. Mother does
not challenge the court’s dispositional orders on independent
grounds. Rather, she asserts only that because there is
insufficient evidence to support the jurisdictional findings, the
dispositional orders also fail. We conclude otherwise and affirm.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
A. The Family’s Prior History of Referrals
The family has a lengthy history with respondent Los
Angeles County Department of Children and Family Services
(DCFS). In 2011, DCFS investigated a referral alleging
emotional abuse of K.N. (who was aged 3 at the time) after
mother was arrested for a domestic violence incident involving
the father of K.N.’s younger half-brother, I.L. Mother physically
attacked I.L.’s father during an argument, leaving scratch marks
on his head. K.N. was placed with her maternal grandmother
(MGM) pending mother’s release from jail. The allegation as to
mother was deemed substantiated, and the family successfully
participated in a voluntary family maintenance plan until
October 2012.

1 Further statutory references are to this code.

2
In August 2012, a referral alleged that mother left K.N.
unattended in a tub of ice water for 10 minutes because she was
upset that K.N. wet herself. K.N., not yet four years old, also had
been observed playing with knives and threatening to kill
mother. It was also reported that mother left both children
unattended in the car for 30 minutes. These incidents took place
at MGM’s home, where mother and the children spent most of
their time. The household also included a maternal uncle, who
reportedly exposed the children to domestic violence incidents
with his girlfriend, including one in which the children witnessed
the uncle push his girlfriend’s head through a wall and drag her
across the floor by her hair. The referral was deemed
inconclusive.
In April 2022, a referral alleged that mother physically
abused K.N. after K.N. arrived at the reporting party’s office with
a swollen face and a mark under her eye, which K.N. said were
the result of mother hitting her multiple times with both an open
hand and fist. K.N. said the violence occurred during an
argument about K.N.’s clothing wherein K.N. talked back to
mother. K.N. reported that mother had also hit her previously,
most recently a few weeks earlier. Mother told the clinical social
worker (CSW) she had smacked K.N. on the mouth but ended up
hitting her face and, apart from smacking K.N. on the mouth
once before, denied any prior violence. The referral was deemed
inconclusive after the CSW educated mother about appropriate
discipline and later observed that the situation had stabilized.
Mother enrolled in individual counseling and K.N. opted to rely
on her school counselor if necessary.

3
In January 2023,2 a referral alleging general neglect of
both children by an unnamed perpetrator was evaluated out.
Mother told the reporting party that K.N. had been diagnosed
with PTSD. Mother had argued with K.N. and taken her phone
away. K.N. left and went to MGM’s home. At MGM’s home K.N.
told the CSW that mother made her uncomfortable, made her
clean up after her brother and called her a slut. K.N. had
sustained a bruise on her neck during a struggle in which mother
tried to take K.N.’s phone. K.N. also disclosed that, when she
was seven years old, mother made her remove all her clothing
because she wore a crop top, and made K.N. go outside naked.
K.N. had never reported that incident because her counselor told
mother everything K.N. disclosed. Mother agreed to let K.N. stay
with MGM a few days until the situation calmed down.
In February, a referral alleging general neglect of both
children by mother was deemed unfounded. K.N. had stated
during a class that mother tried to run her over, but the reporting
party was not sure what happened. The reporting party said
K.N. had tried to hurt herself the previous fall by running into
the street after breaking windows and furniture in the home.
The reporting party worried that K.N. was “in an environment
[that was] not stable enough for her recovery.” K.N. was expelled
from school the day after the referral was made. In March 2023,
a referral was made alleging physical abuse and general neglect
of both children by mother, the same narrative as in the
February 2023 referral. The referral was deemed inconclusive.

2 Unless otherwise stated, further date references are to
calendar year 2023.

4
On July 26, a referral alleging general neglect of K.N. by an
unnamed perpetrator was evaluated out. The reporting party
said K.N. had mental health issues, a possible personality
disorder, and was no longer receiving services. Mother said she
needed help with K.N., who was reportedly drinking alcohol and
using drugs, frequently ran away from home, and had physically
hurt mother and broken items in the home. K.N.’s most recent
runaway incident occurred from July 22 to July 25, when the
child was arrested and released to MGM’s care. The referral was
evaluated out because DCFS believed the family could benefit
from the provision of assistance navigating various support
services, including mental health services, substance abuse
treatment for teenagers, a parent’s project, parent/teen conflict
resolution, and possibly an informal probation.
A July 30 referral alleged that K.N. had been sexually
abused by an unnamed perpetrator. The referral was evaluated
out to law enforcement because the alleged perpetrator was not a
caregiver. It was reported that mother took K.N. to the
emergency room on July 29. The reporting party had learned
from law enforcement that K.N. had reported waking up two
weeks earlier experiencing vaginal pain and with blood in her
underwear. This occurred after K.N. drank alcohol and took
nitrous oxide at a party, passed out multiple times and hit her
head and pushed off a male friend who tried to touch her while
driving her home before K.N. again lost consciousness. It was
reported that K.N. might have signs of a sexually transmitted
disease and lab results were pending. K.N. told mother about the
assault when mother picked her up at someone’s house after K.N.
had been reported missing since July 26. Mother took K.N. to the
hospital and requested a mental health evaluation. According to

5
the reporting party, mother said K.N. had Bipolar Disorder but
had ceased participating in any services. K.N. told the reporting
party that she did not have suicidal or homicidal thoughts.
A referral on August 1 alleged sexual abuse, exploitation,
general neglect, caretaker absence/incapacity. The reporting
party said K.N. was supposed to have been discharged from the
hospital that day but mother refused to pick her up. Mother
wanted K.N. placed somewhere she could not leave. Mother said
she had taken K.N. to the hospital on July 31, because of suicidal
ideation and sexual exploitation. K.N. denied having suicidal
thoughts or being exploited, and the reporting party lacked any
other information as to why mother believed K.N. had been
exploited. K.N. was reportedly a chronic runaway last reported
missing on July 31. The referral was deemed inconclusive.
B. Events Leading to K.N.’s Detention in this Proceeding
On August 14, DCFS received a referral alleging that K.N.
and I.L. were victims of mother’s absence/incapacity. DCFS was
informed that police officers had responded the night before to a
call from the mother of K.N.’s boyfriend reporting that K.N. was
a runaway. The police picked up K.N., who had by then
previously been reported missing at least 10 times, most recently
by mother on August 12.
DCFS children’s social worker spoke with an officer at the
station who confirmed the facts in the referral and said mother
had refused to pick up K.N. K.N. told the CSW that she had been
staying at her boyfriend’s home since August 11, without
mother’s permission. K.N. admitted having left mother’s home
without permission on previous occasions, because mother would
not let her go and do what she wanted and was always seeking to
have K.N. hospitalized or otherwise trying to keep her out of

6
mother’s home. On one occasion, mother had succeeded in having
K.N. involuntarily hospitalized on a 72-hour hold claiming K.N.
wanted to hurt herself, which K.N. denied.
Late on August 14 and into the early morning hours of
August 15, police officers and a CSW spent several hours making
numerous unsuccessful attempts to contact mother at her home
and by phone. K.N. said mother was home but refusing to
answer the phone or door. K.N. told the CSW that mother called
her boyfriend’s mother threatening to call the police unless the
boyfriend’s mother called them first. Mother did not respond
when the boyfriend’s mother tried to get her to pick up K.N.
The CSW contacted K.N.’s father, E.G., who claimed he
could not care for the child because he was out of state for several
weeks. The CSW returned with K.N. to mother’s home. After
several attempts, mother finally answered the door but left the
security door closed. Mother refused to allow K.N. back into her
home because the child had engaged in escalating misbehavior,
including stealing, not listening to and physically abusing
mother, and bringing drugs into the home. Mother felt unsafe
and also worried for her son’s safety. K.N. was taken into
protective custody.
In a subsequent phone conversation, mother told DCFS
that K.N. had been sexually victimized and diagnosed with
several mental health disorders specifically, Oppositional
Defiance Disorder (ODD), Post Traumatic Stress Disorder
(PTSD) and Bipolar Disorder, but had no prescribed medications.
After the police became involved, mother had enrolled K.N. in
counseling which the child discontinued. Mother told DCFS she
would not permit K.N. to return home unless services were put in
place with which K.N. had to comply. DCFS determined that

7
K.N.’s continued detention was necessary as mother was not
providing for K.N.’s basic needs, had multiple previous referrals
for abuse and neglect, and previous cases with DCFS. DCFS
determined that mother was meeting I.L.’s needs and he was not
detained nor is he a subject of the instant petition.
On August 16, DCFS filed a petition on behalf of K.N.
Pursuant to section 300, subdivision (b)(1), the petition alleged
that mother was unwilling and unable to provide appropriate
parental care and supervision of K.N. due to the teen’s behavioral
issues and mental and emotional problems, and involuntarily
hospitalization due to suicidal ideation. The petition further
alleged that K.N. was a chronic runaway who had exhibited
violent behavior toward mother, and that mother’s unwillingness
and inability to provide K.N. care and supervision endangered
the child’s physical and emotional health and safety and placed
her at risk of serious physical harm and danger.
At the detention hearing on August 17, the juvenile court
found E.G. to be K.N.’s presumed (and non-offending) father and
detained the child from parental care.3 Mother was given
monitored visitation.
On the morning of August 20, the caregiver with whom
K.N. had been placed told DCFS that K.N. had left his home the
night before by climbing out of her bedroom window, as shown on
his security cameras. The caregiver filed a missing person’s
report.
The CSW called mother on August 21. Mother was aware
that K.N. had disappeared and told DCFS that K.N. and her
friend had broken into mother’s home and taken her car keys.

3 E.G. is not a party to this appeal.

8
Mother did not know where K.N. was, but suspected she was at
her boyfriend’s. DCFS tried (but was unable) to locate K.N.
On August 24, DCFS received a report that K.N. was at her
boyfriend’s house from which she had posted a photo on social
media while “smoking weed, wax and drinking alcohol.” The
reporting party said K.N. had broken a window to enter mother’s
home and tried to steal her car. DCFS and police officers went to
the boyfriend’s house on August 25, but K.N. was not there. The
boyfriend’s sister told DCFS that her family had not seen K.N. for
two weeks, and that the boyfriend was out of the country in a
behavioral institution. DCFS sought a Protective Custody
Warrant (PCW) for K.N., which the court issued on August 28.
On August 31, DCFS collected K.N. from the police station
after the police picked her up at a friend’s home on a missing
person’s warrant. The CSW escorted K.N. to a clinic, where K.N.
claimed she had to use the restroom, then ran away while the
CSW was checking her in. DCFS filed another missing person
report.
On September 8, DCFS was notified that K.N. was again in
police custody, having been picked up on a missing person
warrant. The next day, a CSW again transported K.N. to the
clinic, where K.N. ran away again while being escorted inside.
DCFS filed another missing person report.
On September 11, DCFS made an unannounced visit to
K.N.’s boyfriend’s home. His sister said K.N. was not there and
had not been seen since leaving the family’s apartment with the
police on September 8.
On September 12, DCFS learned the police found K.N. in a
stolen car with other minors and she was again in police custody.
Again, K.N. ran away again after the CSW picked her up at the

9
police station. The police informed the CSW that K.N. had three
criminal cases pending and that a search for the child was
underway. The CSW spoke with mother, who was then residing
in a shelter because she feared K.N. A police officer assigned to
K.N.’s case reported concerns about the child’s ongoing criminal
behavior, which included breaking into mother’s home,
participating in stealing a car (which resulted in K.N.’s arrest for
armed carjacking), and involvement in a robbery with two
companions in which a store video showed one of K.N.’s
companions pulling out a gun in front of a clerk. The officer said
K.N. would face criminal carjacking charges.
On September 14, DCFS learned K.N. had been booked for
carjacking, and was in police custody headed to juvenile hall.
That same day, the Dependency Investigator (DI) reviewed the
petition’s allegations with mother who stated, “ ‘I want to say
part of it is true.’ ” When asked which part was true, mother
replied, “unable,” but said the “unwilling” allegation was not
true. Mother was asked if she could provide care for K.N. in the
event the child was released her care after the jurisdictional
hearing. Mother responded, “ ‘if [K.N.] has the appropriate
services, yes, but if not, no.’ ” Mother said that, by “ ‘appropriate
services,’ ” she meant “ ‘[K.N.] needs a break, she needs a hold.
She is not thinking straight. She [sic] doing drugs is making it a
bigger risk. . . . I need her to be in rehab. I need her to take
classes.’ ” Mother opined that K.N. needed anger management
counseling because she did not understand the meaning of
consequences, and lacked respect for authority at home, school
and in public. Mother suggested K.N. would benefit from “ ‘a
booth [sic] camp. She needs to straighten herself out[,]’ ” and
added, “ ‘now [K.N.] has criminal charges. Since I gave her up to

10
[DCFS].’ ” Mother said the police no longer paid attention to her
because K.N. was a chronic runaway. Each time they simply
wrote a report and said there was nothing they could do.
Mother shared information with the DI about what mother
believed was an inpatient program from which K.N. could
benefit. The DI informed mother that the program was an
outpatient program for adults previously hospitalized on an
inpatient basis. Mother said an inpatient program would be a
better fit for K.N.’s chronic runaway episodes. Mother was
informed that the adjudication report would include DCFS’s
recommendation that K.N. receive wraparound services. With
regard to her unwillingness to provide care for K.N., mother
informed DCFS that, “ ‘like I said, I gave her up to the system.
The reason I gave her to the system is because that weekend she
ran away, she got shot by a gang.’ ” In mother’s opinion, the onus
was on DCFS “ ‘to protect the child, and that is what [mother]
wanted for [K.N.] to be protected.’ ”
Mother confirmed that the diagnoses for K.N. reflected in
the petition were true as alleged and agreed that K.N. “ ‘[was] at
risk for physical harm, damage, and danger.’ ” Mother said
K.N.’s diagnosis for PTSD was made when the child was in
middle school, and that K.N. was diagnosed with ODD in July
2023. Mother said law enforcement returned K.N. after she ran
away and the “ ‘protocol was to take her to the ER and that is
what I did. That is where she was diagnosed.’ ” Mother also said
K.N. had been diagnosed with bipolar disorder the year before
“ ‘when she was at the hospital when she had the suicidal
attempt.’ ” Mother told DCFS that K.N. had attempted suicide
more than three times and was receiving services. In the past,
K.N. made statements to mother such as “ ‘you better fucking go

11
or I will jump out of the window.’ ” Mother was advised to let
K.N. go. Mother also said K.N. told MGM that “ ‘she was going to
kill herself with [a] gun.’ ”
Mother told DCFS she had not spoken to K.N. recently, but
she had received a call from the police on September 8 after K.N.
was again detained. MGM called mother after K.N. found MGM
at a nail salon on September 9. MGM said K.N. had been in the
restroom for over 15 minutes, and MGM was instructed to call
the police. Mother went to the nail salon where she found K.N.
unconscious on the floor and, after she was unable to wake her,
called 911. K.N. had consumed alcohol and smoked “pens.” At
the hospital, K.N. tested positive for marijuana. Mother told
hospital staff that K.N. was in DCFS custody, but the hospital
released the child anyway. Mother asked “ ‘How is it that [K.N.]
escapes and she runs away? [She] is manipulative and tends to
lie.’ ” Mother said that K.N.’s runaway behavior had begun in
March or April 2023 when “ ‘she ran away . . . for 2 weeks and
ended up at [MGM’s] house. [MGM] said she wouldn’t mind
having [K.N.] under her care.’ ” Mother said K.N. stayed with
MGM for about a month, then called mother to pick her up.
Mother’s was concerned about K.N. who was defiant,
manipulative, a liar, and aggressive. In short, it had to be
‘ “[K.N.’s] way or the highway.’ ” Mother was currently residing
in a shelter because she had become afraid of K.N. and her
friends after they broke into her home. She asked that her
address remain confidential.
The DI interviewed MGM who said K.N. had done well
when she stayed with MGM for about two months. MGM told the
DI that K.N. had problems with drugs, alcohol, violence, talking
back, and running away from home. MGM was not concerned

12
about mother’s care of K.N. but said that K.N. and mother lied a
lot. MGM disagreed with mother’s decision to call the police on
K.N. after the two fought and also disagreed with mother’s
decision to press criminal charges against her daughter, thereby
creating a criminal record for the teen. MGM told the DI that
K.N. had come to her house during a recent AWOL episode. She
told MGM that she had a gun, had sold it and had given the
money to her boyfriend’s mother. K.N. showed MGM videos
displaying drugs and guns. K.N. told MGM that she had given
her boyfriend’s mother a lot of money to save. MGM believed
K.N. had money because “ ‘they were stealing cars. [K.N.] and
the other children, they cannot be more than 12 and 14.’ ”
The PCW was recalled on September 25. DCFS informed
the court the petition’s allegations were true as alleged because
mother was unable and unwilling to provide care for K.N. and
had not wanted the child released to her care during DCFS’s
initial investigation. Later mother told DCFS she would be able
to care for K.N. with appropriate services in place, but also said
she was living in a shelter because she feared K.N., whom mother
said was affiliated with a gang. Mother again confirmed K.N.’s
past diagnoses and said K.N. did not have medication, although
the child previously had been prescribed medication which K.N.
did not want to take.
In its report for the jurisdiction/disposition hearing, DCFS
informed the court that K.N. was currently in law enforcement
custody, and the agency would submit a supplemental report
with K.N.’s statements. DCFS recommended that the petition be
sustained as alleged, and that K.N. be declared a dependent of
the court. DCFS also recommended that K.N. be assessed and
participate in services including mental health and wraparound

13
services, and that the family receive reunification services.
DCFS also recommended that a case plan for mother include
individual therapy to address case issues (including her history
as a perpetrator of domestic violence), parenting classes, random
drug tests (and, in the event she tested positive for drugs or
alcohol, completion of a drug program), as well as joint counseling
with K.N. once the teen’s therapist deemed it appropriate.
The DI interviewed K.N. at juvenile hall on September 21,
where the child had been housed since her arrest on September
15 for carjacking. K.N. denied engaging in any criminal
wrongdoing. She told DCFS that she ran away because of
mother, whom she did not believe was able to care for her.
K.N. did not believe she had been diagnosed with ODD or bipolar
disorder but wanted to be evaluated. K.N. denied the allegation
of gun possession and started to leave the interview when they
asked her about mother’s claim that K.N. was involved in gang
activities and had been shot. K.N. told the DI, “ ‘[mother] is
lying.’ ”
C. Jurisdiction Hearing
The jurisdiction hearing was conducted on September 28.
Mother’s counsel requested that the hearings be continued.
In part, this request was made because mother wanted the court
to consider K.N.’s statements, which DCFS had indicated would
be included in a supplemental report, and because K.N. had been
AWOL for several weeks and the parties had not heard from her
since the last court date. Mother’s attorney said she planned to
seek release of K.N. to mother’s care and noted that mother was
concerned because K.N. had called her on September 26
threatening to harm herself. The court proceeded with the
jurisdiction hearing but indicated its intent to obtain additional

14
information relative to K.N.’s placement before conducting the
disposition hearing.
Proceeding with the adjudication, K.N.’s counsel requested
that the court sustain the petition, with an amendment
eliminating language about K.N.’s mental health diagnoses as
the record contained only mother’s statements as to those.
Counsel observed that mother had a lengthy history of referrals
regarding her care of K.N., and that the teen’s behavioral and
emotional problems manifested in her running away. The court
observed that mother seemed willing to care for K.N. but needed
help managing her daughter’s mental health and behavioral
issues.
Mother’s counsel requested that the court strike the entire
petition. Counsel noted that because mother had “initially [been]
unable to take care of” K.N., DCFS added the “unwilling”
language after mother sought DCFS assistance. Counsel noted
that mother said she had “give[n] [K.N.] up to the [DCFS] . . .
‘because the weekend she ran away, she got shot by a gang.’ . . .
[M]other believe[d] that it was [DCFS’s] responsibility to protect
the child.” Counsel said mother remained willing to care for K.N.
with “appropriate services” in place, such as an inpatient drug
program, and behavior or anger management classes with
wraparound services. Mother’s counsel observed that mother had
rushed K.N. to the hospital and sought medical help multiple
times. Counsel also noted that K.N. had run away multiple
times since the initiation of the instant dependency proceeding
and found it ironic that DCFS claimed mother was unable to care
for K.N., when DCFS itself was unable to keep K.N. from running
away.

15
Mother’s counsel stated that, “the most important thing to
note is the child has never faced any criminal charges while
under mother’s custody[,]” adding, “clearly, we see [DCFS] is not
able to take care of [K.N.] and help mother. [¶] We have law
enforcement now intervening. I think the agency that should
take over is L.A.P.D. [¶] [K.N.] should . . . ultimately . . . be
released to mother’s custody when this petition is dismissed, and
the mother will work with L.A.P.D. . . . to resolve the issues that
[DCFS] failed to help mother resolve.” Counsel observed that the
CSW had “blown [mother] off”, telling her “ ‘I have a lot of other
children that I need to tend to, and your daughter is not my only
priority.’ ”
DCFS requested the court sustain the petition as pled as
the evidence demonstrated mother was both unable and
unwilling to care for K.N. The juvenile court struck the language
regarding K.N.’s mental health diagnoses and mother’s
unwillingness to care for the child and sustained the petition as
amended. In doing so, the court explained: “I think the
statements that [mother] made to the social worker indicate her
being desperate, and this has been going on for quite a long time.
So, [mother] clearly doesn’t have the tools to be able to handle
[K.N.] at this time, and that’s why I’m finding the word ‘unable’ is
a more appropriate reflection of how mother feels and the
evidence before the court.”
The disposition hearing was continued pending updates
regarding K.N.’s well-being and services available in the juvenile
justice system, and details regarding the criminal charges
against her. DCFS was ordered to establish a schedule for
mother’s monitored visitation.

16
At the disposition hearing on December 13, the court
declared K.N. a juvenile court dependent, found it would be
detrimental to return the child and removed her from parental
care. Mother’s case plan included drug testing of mother (upon
reasonable suspicion of drug use), joint counseling with K.N.
(when deemed appropriate by the child’s therapist), and
individual and parenting counseling. Mother was given
monitored visitation.
Mother filed this timely appeal.
DISCUSSION
Mother’s sole contention on appeal is that the record
contains insufficient evidence to support the juvenile court’s
assertion of jurisdiction over K.N.4 We disagree.
I. Substantial Evidence Supports the Jurisdictional
Findings.
A. Controlling Legal Principles and the Standard of
Review
The juvenile court’s exercise of jurisdiction in this action
rests on section 300, subdivision (b)(1). In pertinent part, that
provision authorizes the assertion of dependency court
jurisdiction where a child “has suffered, or there is a substantial
risk that the child will suffer, serious physical harm . . . as a
result of” a parent’s “inability . . . to adequately supervise or
protect the child.” (§ 300, subds. (b)(1)(A) & (b)(1)(D).) A
jurisdictional finding under this provision does not require a
showing that the child’s parent is “ ‘neglectful,’ ”
“ ‘blameworthy,’ ” “ ‘unfit,’ ” or “at fault” for their inability to
supervise or protect their child. (In re R.T. (2017) 3 Cal.5th 622,

4 Mother appealed from but does not take independent issue
with the court’s dispositional orders.

17
627, 630 (R.T.).) The statute merely requires a showing of “the
parent’s . . . ‘inability . . . to adequately supervise or protect the
child.’ ” (Id. at p. 629.) The Legislature’s omission of a
culpability requirement in “ ‘was purposeful.’ ” (Id. at p. 630.)
We review a court’s jurisdictional findings for substantial
evidence, asking whether the record—viewed as a whole and
drawing all reasonable inferences in support of the court’s
findings—contains “ “ ‘sufficient facts to support [its
jurisdictional] findings.’ ” ” (In re I.J. (2013) 56 Cal.4th 766, 773.)
We do not reweigh the evidence or exercise our independent
judgment. Our job is only to determine if the record contains
sufficient evidence, contradicted or not, to support the
jurisdictional findings. (Ibid.; accord, R.T., supra, 3 Cal.5th at
p. 633.) As appellant, mother bears the burden to show there is
no substantial evidence to support the juvenile court’s order.
(In re L.B. (2023) 88 Cal.App.5th 402, 412.) Substantial evidence
is evidence that is reasonable, credible and of solid value, and
“may include inferences, so long as any such inferences are based
on logic and reason and rest on the evidence.” (In re Madison S.
(2017) 15 Cal.App.5th 308, 318.)
B. Application
Mother asserts that the evidentiary record does not support
the court’s finding that, at the time of the jurisdictional hearing,
she lacked the ability to provide care for K.N. Rather, she
maintains that her efforts to obtain DCFS’s assistance with her
child’s behavioral problems by seeking placement for the child in
an inpatient program, demonstrates her “acknowledgement that
[K.N.] needed help beyond what was available in the
community.” Mother maintains that her request for DCFS’s help
demonstrates her ability to care for K.N., not an inability to do

18
so. DCFS correctly points out that mother advances contrary
assertions: “Mother simultaneously advocates that she was able
to care for K.N. from the very moment the juvenile court
dismissed the petition while also acknowledging that her ability
to care for K.N. was contingent on K.N. being placed in a secure
facility rather [than] in mother’s home.”
Mother’s attempt to distinguish this case from R.T., supra,
3 Cal.5th 622, is unavailing. In R.T., the California Supreme
Court concluded a mother appeared to have given up on and was
unable to supervise her 17-year-old whose behavior included
running away from home, making false reports of parental abuse,
and giving birth at age 15 and shortly thereafter to two children
who themselves became juvenile court dependents. (Id. at pp.
624-625, 627, 633-637 [affirming dependency court jurisdiction
where child “faced an ongoing risk of harm based on her
increasingly self-destructive behavior, behavior that mother
simply could not control.”].) Mother attempts to distinguish R.T.
and demonstrate her willingness to care for K.N. and the fact
that she never gave up on her daughter. Mother points to her
past efforts to obtain therapy for K.N., having the teen
hospitalized for suicidal ideation, her unsuccessful efforts to
obtain assistance from the police who knew K.N. was a chronic
runaway and regularly picked her up, and her efforts to reach out
to DCFS for help prior to the incident that prompted this
proceeding. Mother argues that her efforts to address K.N.’s
delinquency court involvement, behavioral issues and
hospitalization, and her unsuccessful attempts to obtain help

19
from DCFS, demonstrate that, unlike the parent in R.T., she
“had clearly not given up.”5

5 In her brief, mother twice mentions that, before the
juvenile court became involved, she tried addressing K.N.’s issues
with therapy and hospitalizations, and then “[w]hen [she]
reached out to DCFS . . . she received no” meaningful assistance.
The record does not support mother’s claim that she had not
“giv[en] up.” The portions of the record mother claims evidence
her ability to care for K.N. by way of seeking DCFS’s help consist
of two referrals DCFS received in July 2023 in which the
reporting parties were anonymous Second, regardless of who
called in those referrals, mother’s contention that “she received
no help” and “DCFS had not provided meaningful assistance” is
belied by the contents of the narratives to which mother points.
DCFS concluded that the first referral dated July 26
alleged neither harm to K.N. nor neglect of the child’s basic
needs. DCFS concluded the allegations did not constitute
appropriate child abuse referrals and the referral was instead
“[e]valuated out to CPL [Community Prevention Linkages]”
because DCFS believed the family might benefit from assistance
navigating support services such as “mental health services,
[s]ubstance abuse treatment for teenagers, parent’s project,
parent teen conflict. . .” Mother told the CSW that she was
already working with DCFS which was servicing the family.
The record reflects that K.N. was arrested on July 25 for battery,
and one way DCFS was able to assist the family was by holding a
multi-disciplinary team (MDT) meeting, which occurred on July
31.
The second referral from July 30 which mother claims
resulted in no help from DCFS involved an allegation of sexual
abuse of K.N. by an unnamed perpetrator, which was evaluated
out to law enforcement because the alleged perpetrator was not a
caregiver. Also notable with respect to mother’s claim that she
received no help from DCFS after making this referral is the fact
that another referral was generated the next day after mother

20
On the contrary, mother’s contention that she had not
“given up” on K.N. notwithstanding DCFS’s purported failure to
help her actually reflects mother’s historical and ongoing
inability properly to provide appropriate care for K.N., which
resulted in mother leaving K.N. with either MGM and, on
occasion, the boyfriend’s mother, or simply refusing to retrieve
the child from the hospital so mother would not be burdened by
bringing K.N. home, only to have her leave again.
Mother also relies on In re David M. (2005) 134
Cal.App.4th 822 (David M.), to support her contention that
“[e]ven if [her] initial refusal to have [K.N.] returned to her can
be characterized as ‘previous neglect,’ she was willing to have
[K.N.] returned with help from DCFS at the time of the
jurisdictional hearing.” Her reliance is misplaced. In David M.,
a toddler and his newborn sister were detained due, in part, to
their mother’s drug abuse during her pregnancy. (Id. at p. 826,
abrogated by other grounds in R.T., supra, 3 Cal.5th at pp. 628-
630.) The court found that, even if the parent’s past conduct was
probative of current conditions, the question was whether, at the
time of the jurisdictional hearing, the child remained subject to
the defined risk of harm. (Id. at p. 831.) In David M., the court
found no evidence that mother’s substance abuse impacted her
ability to care for the children. (Id. at p. 830.) Moreover, the
mother had 18 negative drug tests between the detention and
jurisdictional hearings. (Ibid.) Accordingly, the court concluded
that no risk of substantial harm existed at the time of the
jurisdictional hearing. (Id. at pp. 831–832.)

refused to pick K.N. up from the hospital because she wanted the
child placed somewhere she could not leave.

21
This case is different. Mother’s assertion that she was at
all times willing and able to care for K.N. ignores the fact that
the court struck “unwilling” from the petition. Her argument
fails because it was mother’s inability to care for K.N., not her
unwillingness to do so, that was at issue and, unlike David M.,
that inability had not abated by the time of the jurisdictional
hearing. Mother maintains that she was able to care for K.N. on
the condition that DCFS place the teen in an inpatient program
or secure facility. This argument is consistent with mother’s
stated requirement in the initial referral that K.N. comply with
services before mother would let her back into the home. Thus,
unlike David M., mother does not claim or show that anything
changed by the time of the jurisdiction hearing to demonstrate
her ability to care for K.N. in ways she had not been able to do
two months before when she forbade K.N. from returning home.
The record supports the juvenile court’s reasoned conclusion that
mother remained unable to care for K.N. at the time of the
jurisdictional hearing.6
Section 300, subdivision (b)(1), permits the assertion of
jurisdiction when a parent is unable to care for a child despite the
parent’s efforts to address the child’s behavioral issues. (§ 300,

6 Also without merit is mother’s argument that “her
assessment of her child’s needs, namely that she needed some
sort of setting where [K.N.] could not avoid treatment, was
validated by the section 241.1 report” on which DCFS signed off.
First, that report does not demonstrate that mother was unable
to provide appropriate care for K.N. absent court intervention.
Moreover, the section 241.1 report was prepared after the
petition was sustained and considered facts that had were not in
evidence at the time the court made the findings challenged on
appeal.

22
subd. (b)(1).) It is undisputed that K.N. had “mental and
emotional problems.” Not only did K.N. “refus[e] mother’s efforts
to provide treatment for her,” but she also had problems in school
which resulted in her expulsion, ran away with increasing
frequency, and had begun associating with gang members and
engaging in criminal behavior. K.N. acted out at school and at
home, often violently. It was because of these increasingly
serious and threatening behaviors that mother feared K.N. and
refused to let her return home. Mother has consistently
maintained that the only way she would accept K.N. back was if
the child remained “in a placement where she could not leave and
refuse services.”
Furthermore, as a result of her daughter’s troubling
behavior, mother felt unsafe in her own home, had moved into a
confidential shelter at the time of the jurisdiction hearing, and
asked that her location not be divulged. When interviewed by the
DI, mother conceded she was unable to care for K.N.
Without assessing blame, the evidence is clear that the
assertion of dependency jurisdiction was warranted. (R.T., supra,
3 Cal.5th at p. 634 [“Whether it was [the child]’s misbehavior and
disobedience, or [the] parent’s inability to supervise or protect
[the child], that initiated this cyclical pattern of conflict, does not
matter . . . . The basis for jurisdiction under section 300(b)(1) is
whether the child is at ‘substantial risk’ of ‘serious physical harm
. . . .’ ”].) “ ‘The loss of parental control is rarely if ever
attributable solely to the parent or the child. It is instead the
result of a long and complicated chain of actions and reactions
culminating in the child’s refusal to submit to parental
authority.’ ” (Id. at p. 635.) Like the mother in R.T., “there is

23
little question that mother was unable to ‘adequately’ supervise
or protect [K.N.] as required under section 300(b)(1).” (Ibid.)
Based on the evidentiary record, the juvenile court
reasonably concluded that mother was unable “to adequately
supervise or protect [K.N.]” and we must affirm. (§ 300, subd.
(b)(1); In re Savannah M. (2005) 131 Cal.App.4th 1387, 1394,
abrogated on other grounds by R.T., supra, 3 Cal.5th at pp. 628-
630 [When the juvenile court’s findings are reasonable in light of
the whole record, the findings sustaining the section 300 petition
should be affirmed.].)
II. The Juvenile Court’s Dispositional Order is
Affirmed.
Mother has not challenged the court’s dispositional orders
on appeal on any independent basis. She argues only that,
because the assertion of jurisdiction was unsupported, the
dispositional orders also must fail. In light of our conclusion that
substantial evidence supports the court’s jurisdictional findings,
we also affirm the dispositional orders.
DISPOSITION
The jurisdictional findings and dispositional orders are
affirmed.

RICHARDSON, J.
We concur:

LUI, P. J.

ASHMANN-GERST, J.

24

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.