CourtListener 10331190•Soaris v. Aikhionbare CA2/5
Testo completo
Filed 2/11/25 Soaris v. Aikhionbare CA2/5
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION FIVE
JOSEPH SOARIS, B322910
Plaintiff and Appellant, (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No.
v. 20STCV05228)
TONY AIKHIONBARE et al.,
Defendants and
Respondents.
APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of Los
Angeles County, Kristin S. Escalante, Judge. Affirmed.
Law Office of Winston K. McKesson and Winston K.
McKesson for Plaintiff and Appellant.
Law Office of Alaba Ajetunmobi and Alaba Ajetunmobi for
Defendants and Respondents.
I. INTRODUCTION
Plaintiff Joseph Soaris sued his former contractors,
defendants Tony Aikhionbare and Ota Enterprises, for breach of
contract and breach of the implied covenant of good faith and fair
dealing. Following a bench trial, the trial court ruled against
plaintiff on his claims and issued judgment accordingly.1
Plaintiff contends the trial court erred by denying him
leave to amend his complaint to add a cause of action for violation
of Business and Professions Code sections 7031, subdivision (b)
and 7125.2. Plaintiff also contends the court’s judgment is not
supported by substantial evidence. We affirm.
II. BACKGROUND
A. Underlying Facts
In May 2019, plaintiff entered into a written contract with
Aikhionbare and Ota Enterprises, in which defendants agreed to
perform construction work on plaintiff’s home. The parties
agreed that plaintiff would pay a total sum of $164,500 for
material and labor. According to plaintiff, defendants failed to
perform the agreed upon work pursuant to the terms of the
agreement.
1 Defendants also cross-complained, arguing, among other
things, breach of contract and quantum meruit. The court ruled
against defendants on their claims, and defendants appealed. On
March 10, 2023, defendants’ cross-appeal was dismissed for being
in default.
2
On February 7, 2020, plaintiff filed a complaint against
defendants for breach of written contract and breach of the
implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing.2 The complaint
alleged that defendants “breached the contract by not performing
the agreed upon work in the terms called for in the Contract.”
B. Trial
Prior to trial, plaintiff filed a trial brief in which he
explained that his complaint alleged defendants “breached their
oral and written contracts b[y] failing to return the [purported
$20,000] loan amount to [p]laintiff and/or order the supplies for
the Project.” Plaintiff also alleged that defendants breached the
covenant of good faith and fair dealing “[b]y failing to repay the
loan and/or failing to purchase supplies to complete the Project.”
A bench trial commenced on December 16, 2021. There is
no reporter’s transcript, agreed statement, or settled statement of
the December 16, 2021, proceeding. Trial continued on
February 23, 24, and 25, 2022.
During the trial proceedings for which we do have a record,
plaintiff testified that he entered into a written contract with
defendants in which defendants agreed to “complete the
Construction of the Residential Remodel” in phases, for a total
cost of $164,500. Plaintiff testified that he paid defendants
$57,000 before terminating their relationship. Although plaintiff
2 Plaintiff also alleged that defendants breached an oral
contract, purportedly entered on October 16, 2019, in which
plaintiff agreed to loan defendants $20,000. The trial court found
against plaintiff on this cause of action. Plaintiff does not
challenge that finding.
3
initially testified that defendants only performed demolition work
on the project, he later admitted that defendants also performed
framing, plumbing, and foundation work.
Defendant Aikhionbare testified that he completed work on
numerous phases described in the written contract, including
demolition, foundation, framing, replacing the subfloor and floor
joists, plumbing, and electrical work. He did not, however,
complete other portions of the construction. On cross-
examination, Aikhionbare admitted that he did not have workers’
compensation insurance. Aikhionbare confirmed that he received
$57,000 from plaintiff for work performed at the residence.
After the close of evidence, plaintiff orally moved to amend
the pleadings to conform to proof. Specifically, plaintiff sought to
add a claim for violation of Business and Professions Code
sections 7031, subdivision (b) and 7125.2, alleging defendants
were unlicensed contractors because they had not obtained
required workers’ compensation insurance. The trial court
declined to rule on the oral motion and advised plaintiff that he
could file a written motion to amend.
C. Motion to Amend Pleadings
On March 2, 2022, plaintiff filed his motion for leave to file
a first amended complaint to add an allegation for a cause of
action for violation of Business and Professions Code sections
7031 and 7125.2. Plaintiff submitted a declaration from his
counsel, who stated that during trial, “it was discovered” that
defendants did not have proper workers’ compensation insurance
and counsel made an oral motion to amend the complaint “at the
earliest moment available.” Defendants opposed the motion.
4
On March 22, 2022, the trial court granted the motion to
amend. The court also reopened the trial proceedings to allow
the parties to present further evidence as to whether defendants
had workers’ compensation insurance.
D. Further Hearing
On May 27, 2022, the trial court held an evidentiary
hearing to consider additional evidence regarding the new claim.
Plaintiff and Aikhionbare both testified. The record does not
include a reporter’s transcript, agreed statement, or settled
statement of this proceeding.
E. Ruling and Judgment
On July 11, 2022, the trial court issued its ruling, finding
against plaintiff. The court found that plaintiff “was not credible”
and that defendant Aikhionbare “was generally credible.” The
court further found that plaintiff did not perform his obligations
under the written contract, did not have an excuse for his
nonperformance, and failed to demonstrate defendants did not
adequately perform their contractual obligations. Further, even
if plaintiff had proven defendants breached the agreement, the
court would still find in favor of defendants because plaintiff
failed to prove the amount of damages.
The trial court then reconsidered its order granting
plaintiff’s motion to amend the complaint, citing the evidence
presented at the May 27, 2022, hearing. Rejecting plaintiff’s
assertion that he was not aware, until trial, that defendants
lacked workers’ compensation insurance, the court found that
5
plaintiff was aware of this fact before he filed the complaint. It
also found that defendants would be prejudiced if the court were
to permit the amendment, construing plaintiff’s motion as an
attempt to “sandbag” defendants and “gamesmanship.” The
court denied the motion.
On July 28, 2022, the trial court entered judgment against
plaintiff on his complaint against defendants. Plaintiff timely
appealed.
III. DISCUSSION
Plaintiff argues that the trial court abused its discretion by
reconsidering its prior order granting a motion to amend the
pleadings. Plaintiff also contends the court’s entry of judgment
on his claims is not supported by substantial evidence.
A. Motion to Amend
The decision whether to grant a plaintiff leave to amend a
complaint is within the sound discretion of the trial court and
“‘“[t]he exercise of that discretion will not be disturbed on appeal
absent a clear showing of abuse.”’” (Branick v. Downey Savings
& Loan Assn. (2006) 39 Cal.4th 235, 242.) Code of Civil
Procedure section 473 allows a party to amend its pleadings in
the furtherance of justice and Code of Civil Procedure section 576
allows a trial court to grant leave to amend even after the
commencement of trial.
Code of Civil Procedure section 469, which governs motions
for leave to amend to conform to proof at trial, provides in
pertinent part: “Variance between the allegation in a pleading
6
and the proof shall not be deemed material, unless it has actually
misled the adverse party to his or her prejudice in maintaining
his or her action or defense upon the merits.” Amendments to
conform to proof at trial, “if not prejudicial, are favored since
their purpose is to do justice and avoid further useless litigation.”
(Union Bank v. Wendland (1976) 54 Cal.App.3d 393, 400.) Leave
to amend should be denied “‘when [the proposed amendments]
raise new issues not included in the original pleadings and upon
which the adverse party had no opportunity to defend.
[Citations.]’ [Citations.]” (Trafton v. Youngblood (1968) 69
Cal.2d 17, 31.) “The basic rule applicable to amendments to
conform to proof is that the amended pleading must be based
upon the same general set of facts as those upon which the cause
of action or defense as originally pleaded was grounded.” (Union
Bank v. Wendland, supra, 54 Cal.App.3d at pp. 400–401.)
“Generally, ‘the trial court has wide discretion in
determining whether to allow the amendment, but the
appropriate exercise of that discretion requires the trial court to
consider a number of factors: “including the conduct of the
moving party and the belated presentation of the amendment.
[Citation.] . . . The law is well settled that a long deferred
presentation of the proposed amendment without a showing of
excuse for the delay is itself a significant factor to uphold the trial
court’s denial of the amendment. [Citation.]” [Citation.] “The
law is also clear that even if a good amendment is proposed in
proper form, unwarranted delay in presenting it may—of itself—
be a valid reason for denial.” [Citation.]’ [Citations.]” (Emerald
Bay Community Assn. v. Golden Eagle Ins. Corp. (2005) 130
Cal.App.4th 1078, 1097.)
7
“As a general rule, trial courts have inherent jurisdiction to
reconsider, vacate, or otherwise modify their interim orders.
(Phillips v. Sprint PCS (2012) 209 Cal.App.4th 758, 768; Le
Francois v. Goel (2005) 35 Cal.4th 1094, 1106–1107.)” (Paul
Blanco’s Good Car Co. Auto Group v. Superior Court (2020) 56
Cal.App.5th 86, 97.)
The trial court revisited its ruling on the motion to amend
following an evidentiary hearing on May 27, 2022. The record,
however, does not include a reporter’s transcript or suitable
substitute from that hearing. “[T]he absence of a court reporter
at trial court proceedings and the resulting lack of a verbatim
record of such proceedings will frequently be fatal to a litigant’s
ability to have his or her claims of trial court error resolved on
the merits by an appellate court. This is so because it is a
fundamental principle of appellate procedure that a trial court
judgment is ordinarily presumed to be correct and the burden is
on an appellant to demonstrate, on the basis of the record
presented to the appellate court, that the trial court committed
an error that justifies reversal of the judgment. [Citations.] ‘This
is not only a general principle of appellate practice but an
ingredient of the constitutional doctrine of reversible error.’
[Citations.] ‘In the absence of a contrary showing in the record,
all presumptions in favor of the trial court’s action will be made
by the appellate court. “[I]f any matters could have been
presented to the court below which would have authorized the
order complained of, it will be presumed that such matters were
presented.”’ [Citation.] ‘“A necessary corollary to this rule is that
if the record is inadequate for meaningful review, the appellant
defaults and the decision of the trial court should be affirmed.”’
[Citation.] ‘Consequently, [the appellant] has the burden of
8
providing an adequate record. [Citation.] Failure to provide an
adequate record on an issue requires that the issue be resolved
against [the appellant].’ [Citation.]” (Jameson v. Desta (2018) 5
Cal.5th 594, 608–609, fn. omitted.)
Here, the trial court found, based on the evidence presented
at the hearing on May 27, 2022, that plaintiff delayed presenting
his additional claims until the close of trial in order to “sandbag”
defendants and defendants would be prejudiced by the late
amendment. Contrary to plaintiff’s contention, we do not have a
sufficient record to evaluate these findings. (See Faigin v.
Signature Group Holdings, Inc. (2012) 211 Cal.App.4th 726, 736
[“We review findings by the trier of fact under the substantial
evidence standard”]; Fair v. Bakhtiari (2011) 195 Cal.App.4th
1135, 1148–1149 [“As a general rule, ‘even where there are no
express findings, we must review the trial court’s exercise of
discretion based on implied findings that are supported by
substantial evidence’”].) Plaintiff cannot demonstrate, based on
the inadequate evidence presented on appeal, that the court
abused its discretion in denying his motion to amend. (See Rhule
v. WaveFront Technology, Inc. (2017) 8 Cal.App.5th 1223, 1228
[rejecting plaintiff’s argument that attorney fees award was
abuse of discretion because of plaintiff’s failure to provide
reporter’s transcript or agreed or settled statement of
proceedings].)
B. Sufficiency of the Evidence
We also reject plaintiff’s sufficiency of the evidence
challenge to the trial court’s judgment based on the inadequacy of
the record on appeal. (Jameson v. Desta, supra, 5 Cal.5th at
9
pp. 608–609.) As we note above, the record does not include a
reporter’s transcript, or a suitable substitute, of the trial
proceedings from December 16, 2021. Moreover, on the record
that we do have, we would find no error. Plaintiff’s challenge to
the sufficiency of the evidence is premised on his theory that
defendants were unlicensed contractors, a theory on which the
court denied leave to amend.3
IV. DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed. Defendants are awarded costs
on appeal.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
KIM (D.), J.
We concur:
HOFFSTADT, P. J.
BAKER, J.
3 Defendants also contend they are entitled to an award of
attorney fees on appeal pursuant to contract. Defendants’
entitlement to such fees is not an issue before us on appeal.
10
Ti chiedi come si applica questo testo alla tua situazione?
Consulenza gratuita, senza impegno
Descrivi la tua situazione. Il nostro team ti ricontatterà via e-mail per la tua consulenza.
Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude
Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.