CourtListener 10323222•People v. Carrillo CA1/2
Testo completo
Filed 1/29/25 P. v. Carrillo CA1/2
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication or
ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FIRST APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION TWO
THE PEOPLE,
Plaintiff and Respondent, A168626
v.
FERNANDO CARRILLO, (Solano County
Defendant and Appellant. Super. Ct. No. FC29528)
Defendant Fernando Carrillo appeals from the trial court’s order
extending his civil commitment at Patton State Hospital, pursuant to Penal
Code section 1026.5.1 He contends that substantial evidence did not support
the recommitment order and, upon reversal, the petition to extend
commitment should be dismissed because double jeopardy and res judicata
principles apply when a recommitment order is dismissed for insufficient
evidence. Carrillo additionally contends the recommitment order should be
reversed because he did not voluntarily waive his right to a jury trial.
We reverse because the record does not affirmatively demonstrate that
Carrillo’s waiver of his right to a jury trial was voluntary and intelligent.
1 All undesignated statutory references are to the Penal Code.
1
Further, in light of Carrillo’s claim that the lack of substantial evidence
supporting the extension of his commitment precludes a retrial under double
jeopardy or res judicata principles, we will address his substantial evidence
challenge. We conclude there was substantial evidence to support the
extension of his commitment.
BACKGROUND
I.
The Criminal Proceedings and Recommitment Petition
In 1991, Carrillo was committed to Atascadero State Hospital for a
maximum term of six years after being found not guilty by reason of insanity
(NGI) relative to his assault of three correctional officers while he was
serving a separate sentence for attempted rape. Carrillo was later
transferred to Patton State Hospital.
From 1996 to 1999, Carrillo was treated in community outreach
through the Los Angeles County Conditional Release Program (CONREP).
However, in March 1999, Carrillo was remanded back to the state hospital
when he asked a female passenger on a public bus for her phone number and
then later touched the breast of a female staff member who was supervising
him.
Thereafter, the trial court extended Carrillo’s commitment numerous
times pursuant to section 1026.5.
In April 2022, the People filed the petition to extend Carrillo’s
commitment under section 1026.5 that is at issue in the present appeal. In
support of the petition, the People submitted a February 2022 written report
by Dr. Troy Freimuth, a Senior Psychologist Specialist (Forensic) at Patton
State Hospital.
2
II.
Dr. Freimuth’s Written Report
Dr. Freimuth began his February 2022 report by detailing the original
offense that led to Carrillo’s commitment in a state hospital and the later
offense that formed the basis of his current commitment. In the original
offense, which occurred in 1985, Carrillo followed his female victim down the
street before masturbating and propositioning her for sex. When she did not
comply, he tore her blouse and bra and sexually assaulted her. Carrillo ran
from the scene when the victim screamed for help. He was later charged and
convicted of attempted rape. While serving his prison term for that offense,
Carrillo physically assaulted three female correctional officers at the
Vacaville Medical Facility when they denied him entry into a day room; this
was the offense that led to his current commitment.
During his commitment, Dr. Freimuth noted that though Carrillo was
conditionally released and treated in CONREP between 1996 and 1999, he
was remanded back to the state hospital after he inappropriately touched a
female staff member.
The report went on to list Carrillo’s diagnoses, which include
schizophrenia, various substance abuse disorders and borderline intellectual
functioning. It also indicated that past symptoms of Carrillo’s schizophrenia
included “auditory hallucinations,” such as “hearing voices that told him
people were out to get him” or that “instructed him to rape women and to
have sex with them.”
A psychiatric note from the month before Dr. Freimuth wrote his report
indicated that Carrillo continued to be “ ‘preoccupied’ ” with “ ‘having a
woman as a romantic companion/wife in the future’ ” and that he
“ ‘continue[d] to focus on having sex’ ” and “ ‘look[ed] at female staff
3
inappropriately.’ ” Further, during an interview with a female psychologist
for his September 2021 court report, Carrillo engaged in behavior that could
have been construed as problematic—namely, asking to sit closer to the
evaluator based on claims of a hearing disorder and then asking to go to the
bathroom and not returning for over 10 minutes. Prior to that, a March 2021
CONREP evaluation stated that Carrillo continued to engage in
“ ‘inappropriate behaviors toward female staff and with a female peer.’ ”
The report also indicated that Carrillo continued to suffer from
auditory hallucinations. In fact, during the February 2022 interview
Dr. Freimuth had with Carrillo before drafting his report, Carrillo reported
periodically hearing the voices of family members though he seemed unsure if
these voices were a symptom of his mental illness. Further, Carrillo did not
seem to understand the role his mental illness played in the commission of
his past offenses; more particularly, Carrillo was only able to describe his
actions and was less able to articulate what symptoms he was having during
the offenses apart from stating that he was hearing voices and was feeling
“ ‘confused’ ” and “ ‘paranoid.’ ” Dr. Freimuth concluded that Carrillo was
unable to clearly identify triggers or early warning signs for a relapse of his
mental illness.
When asked about his future treatment needs, Carrillo failed to
appreciate the important role medication played in helping to manage and
reduce his psychotic symptoms. For example, Carrillo stated he would
“ ‘probably’ ” need medication once released but continued to focus on hoping
that the dosage would be lowered. Dr. Freimuth also cited a June 2021
psychological risk review wherein Carrillo expressed his belief he could
manage his mental illness outside of the state hospital through a good sleep
routine and avoiding too much caffeine. Lastly and most significantly,
4
Dr. Freimuth noted that Carrillo had reported that he “ha[d] not consistently
complied with taking his psychotropic medication when he was living in the
community.”
Based on the foregoing, Dr. Freimuth concluded that Carrillo “remains
a danger related to his mental illness, and he would have serious difficulty
controlling his behavior, due to ongoing symptoms (auditory hallucinations)
and a sexual preoccupation, similar to his mental state at the time he
committed his sexual assault.” Dr. Freimuth noted that in the highly secure,
supervised setting of the state hospital, Carrillo is able to “limit his behavior
to just inappropriately staring at female staff members and, up until
recently, inappropriately touching a transexual peer.” However,
Dr. Freimuth expressed concern that in a community setting “where he does
not have trusted staff around 24/7 to remind him to stop staring at the
females or to stop touching his transexual peer inappropriately,” Carrillo’s
risk for sexual assault and potential violence would “increase substantially.”
This was particularly the case given that Carrillo was “ambivalent” about
whether he would continue taking his medication and “likely . . . would not
agree to medication adjustments to manage his increased symptomatology”
thereby increasing his risk.
III.
Jury Trial Waiver
In August 2022, the trial court conducted a trial readiness conference,
which Carrillo attended remotely. At the conference, Carrillo’s counsel
confirmed a jury trial but also requested additional time to speak with
Carrillo about a section 1026.2 petition,2 stating that it could affect the trial
2Section 1026.2 allows a person committed to a state hospital after
pleading NGI to petition the court for release based on restoration of sanity.
5
on the People’s petition to extend commitment. Counsel then asked if the
court was allowing individuals at the state hospital to appear remotely for
jury trials, and the court responded: “I mean, if you get a waiver from him, I
think I would permit that.” Nonetheless, the court and the parties also
discussed obtaining a removal order that would enable Carrillo to be present
for the trial in September, which could be cancelled if it turned out to be
unnecessary.
Two weeks later, the trial court conducted another trial readiness
conference, which Carrillo attended remotely. Carrillo’s counsel asked for
and the court agreed to a few more days so counsel could discuss with
Carrillo whether he wanted to have a court trial or a jury trial.
In September 2022, the trial court held a trial readiness conference,
which Carrillo attended remotely. Carrillo’s counsel stated she spoke with
Carrillo about whether he wanted a court or jury trial, and “believe[d]” he
was going to waive a jury trial. The following colloquy ensued:
“MS. EVANS: Good morning. So Mr. Carrillo, I’m going to first explain
to you your right to have a jury trial. Okay?
“THE DEFENDANT: Okay.
“MS. EVANS: So in this matter, you do have a right to have a jury trial
where you would help me pick twelve people from the community that
would come into court and hear all the evidence in the case. And it
would be those twelve jurors who would decide whether or not the
District Attorney has proven beyond a reasonable doubt that you have
a mental disorder, and that because of that mental disorder you
6
currently represent a substantial danger of physical harm to others,
keeping in mind your commitment would not be extended unless all
twelve jurors agree the District Attorney has met their burden of proof
of beyond a reasonable doubt. Do you understand your right to have a
jury trial?
“THE DEFENDANT: Yes, Your Honor. I mean, yes, Ms. Evans,
definitely.
“MS. EVANS: I’m sorry, Mr. Carrillo, do you understand your right to
have a jury trial?
“THE DEFENDANT: Yes. I understand my right to a jury trial. I
want to ask you if I was to go over there in Solano county or—how will I
stay in a cell?
“MS. EVANS: I don’t have an answer to that, Mr.—
“THE DEFENDANT: Okay. Okay. It’s okay. Thank you, Tiffany.
Yes, I understand my rights, Tiffany.
“MS. EVANS: So having understood your rights to a jury trial, do you
wish to waive the right and proceed with a court trial where the judge
will hear all the evidence and decide whether or not the District
Attorney has proved their case beyond a reasonable doubt?
“THE DEFENDANT: I couldn’t understand you.
7
“MS. EVANS: Okay. First of all, Mr. Carrillo, do you want to come to
Solano county and have a jury trial?
“THE DEFENDANT: No. No, I mean—
“MS. EVANS: Okay. So you’re telling us you don’t want to come to
have a jury trial. Do you want to proceed and have a court trial where
you can appear on video?
“THE DEFENDANT: Yes.
“MS. EVANS: Okay.
“THE DEFENDANT: Yes. Right now I’m living—
“MS. EVANS: Mr. Carrillo, do you understand that with a court trial
you’ll appear on video, and the judge will hear all the evidence in the
case, and the judge will decide whether or not your commitment should
be extended?
“THE DEFENDANT: Okay, yes.
“MS. EVANS: Do you understand that?
“THE DEFENDANT: Yes. Yes, if I went to court I be extended again.
8
“MS. EVANS: Okay. So you want to have a court trial, correct?
“THE DEFENDANT: Court trial, yes.
“THE COURT: All right. And would you join in that?
“MS. EVANS: Yes, Your Honor.
“THE COURT: Okay. So I’ll make a finding the defendant’s waived his
right to a jury trial. We’ll instead hold a court trial.”
IV.
The Court Trial
The court trial was set for October 2022 but was then continued a few
times to July 2023. During the one-day trial, the People presented two
witnesses: (1) Dr. Kevin Quinonez-Truong, and (2) Dr. Freimuth.
A. Dr. Quinonez-Truong’s Testimony
Dr. Quinonez-Truong worked as a contract psychiatrist at Patton State
Hospital and was meeting with Carrillo monthly. In the few months before
the recommitment hearing, the two were meeting almost weekly as Carrillo
would reach out to Dr. Quinonez-Truong to go over homework from groups he
was a part of and to discuss his symptoms. Among other things, Dr.
Quinonez-Truong testified that Carrillo regularly discussed his paranoid
feelings that the medication he was taking or the food he was eating in public
restaurants was poisoning him and disrupting his sexual abilities. Carrillo
also mentioned ongoing auditory hallucinations wherein he would hear
family members saying his name.
Further, in the few weeks leading up to the trial, Dr. Quinonez-Truong
9
had observed an increase in Carrillo’s symptoms, including heightened
paranoia that he was being poisoned by his medications, and a
“hypersexuality” that included increasing references to “sexual delusions”
whereby Carrillo felt like he wanted to have relationships with several of the
female staff members once released, wanted them to touch him, and believed
that they also wanted to have a relationship with him. Carrillo also reported
that he was masturbating in his room several times a day when imagining
these staff members and failed to realize the inappropriate nature of these
sexual fantasies and behaviors.
Due to the increase in Carrillo’s symptoms, Dr. Quinonez-Truong
increased Carrillo’s medication dosage but expressed concerns about whether
Carrillo would stop taking his medication once released in the community.
B. Dr. Freimuth’s Testimony
Dr. Freimuth testified that Carrillo suffered from schizophrenia and
that he continued to experience symptoms such as auditory hallucinations,
though it was unclear to Carrillo himself that these were a symptom of his
mental illness. As for the offenses that resulted in his commitment (i.e. the
attempted rape and the later assault on three female correctional officers),
Carrillo had difficulty explaining what was going through his mind when
those offenses occurred, though he did say he was hearing voices or feeling
paranoid. Carrillo also did not understand the connection between symptoms
he was experiencing and how those could make him dangerous. For example,
Carrillo did not appreciate the fact that hearing voices contributed to the
offenses he had committed.
Dr. Freimuth concluded that Carrillo only had “partial insight” into his
illness in that he understood he had a mental illness but did “not fully
10
understand the severity and clonicity”3 of the illness. For example, Carrillo
understood that he could be paranoid but did not understand that his belief
around his medications poisoning him was a paranoid belief. Carrillo also
believed his mental illness was caused by being poisoned when he goes out to
eat and therefore concluded that avoiding restaurants would help keep him
mentally well. This is despite the fact he acknowledged, when questioned,
that he was not taking his medication when he assaulted the correctional
officers.
Dr. Freimuth therefore expressed concern about Carrillo’s ability to
monitor and be aware of his symptoms once released in the community.
Dr. Freimuth also said there was a danger Carrillo would stop taking his
medication given his belief his medication was poisoning him or affecting his
sexual functioning, and his fixation with lowering the dosage. Dr. Freimuth’s
concerns regarding the danger Carrillo posed to others were amplified by the
fact Carrillo had a “very high-level of sex drive or sexual preoccupation” and
had engaged in multiple instances of inappropriate behavior over the years.
Based on the foregoing, Dr. Freimuth opined that Carrillo had serious
difficulty controlling his dangerous behavior and continued to pose a
substantial danger of physical harm to others.
C. Carrillo’s Argument
Carrillo’s counsel did not present any additional witnesses but did
3
It is unclear why Dr. Freimuth used the word “clonicity,” which has to
do with clonus, a neurological condition producing rapid muscle contractions.
(See Merriam-Webster Dict. <https://www.merriam-
webster.com/medical/clonic> [as of Jan. 28, 2025]; Cleveland Clinic
<https://my.clevelandclinic.org/health/symptoms/24822-clonus> [as of Jan. 28,
2025].) It seems possible the word he said or intended to say was
“chronicity,” meaning that Carrillo did not understand that his symptoms
and his disease are chronic.
11
cross-examine both Dr. Quinonez-Truong and Dr. Freimuth.
During the cross-examinations, both doctors confirmed that Carrillo
had not engaged in any recent acts of “physical aggression,” had been
consistent in taking his medication, and had stated that he needed to
continue taking medication even after his release to prevent decompensation.
Counsel also asked both doctors to confirm that, on rare occasions, the
medication Carrillo was taking could result in erectile dysfunction or an
inability to achieve an orgasm, and the doctors stated this was the case.
Further, Dr. Quinonez-Truong agreed that the voices Carrillo was
hearing had not been commanding him to hurt anybody but were just the
voices of his family members saying his name or saying encouraging things.
Dr. Freimuth confirmed that Carrillo had been diagnosed with borderline
intellectual functioning which makes it more challenging for Carrillo to have
an in-depth understanding of his mental illness.
In her closing argument, Carrillo’s counsel acknowledged that Carrillo
had a mental illness. However, counsel contended that Carrillo did not pose
a substantial danger of physical harm to others because there had been “no
incidents of physical aggression, verbal threats or damage to state property.”
Counsel also asserted Carrillo’s worries about his medication affecting his
sexual functioning were “logical” because both doctors testified on cross-
examination that some psychotropic medications can affect an individual’s
sex drive or ability to have an erection or orgasm. In any event, counsel
pointed out that Carrillo told both doctors that he would continue taking his
medication once released. Counsel also argued that the recent increase in
Carrillo’s symptoms could have been attributed to the stress of the upcoming
trial.
As for Carrillo’s masturbation in his bedroom, counsel framed it as the
12
usage of a “coping skill[]” and argued it indicated that Carrillo was not
dangerous to others because he was “removing himself from any situation”
and handling his thoughts in a “healthy way . . . without presenting himself.”
She also asserted this behavior merely evidenced a desire for “human
connection” but did not mean that Carrillo was dangerous. Lastly, with
respect to Carrillo’s auditory hallucinations, counsel pointed out Carrillo was
just hearing the voices of his family members saying his name and not voices
that were telling him to commit acts of aggression; thus, she asserted it was
“hard to see” the connection between the hallucinations and any future
dangerousness especially given that there had been no recent acts of physical
aggression by Carrillo.
D. Trial Court Decision
The trial court ultimately found the People had proved beyond a
reasonable doubt that Carrillo continued to represent a substantial danger of
physical harm to others and extended his commitment.
DISCUSSION
I.
Carrillo’s Waiver of a Jury Trial Was Invalid.
Section 1026.5, subdivision (b)(4) provides in relevant part that the
trial on a petition to extend commitment “shall be by jury unless waived by
both the person and the prosecuting attorney.” “[A] defendant’s waiver of the
right to jury trial may not be accepted by the court unless it is knowing and
intelligent, that is, ‘ “ ‘made with a full awareness both of the nature of the
right being abandoned and the consequences of the decision to abandon it,’ ” ’
as well as voluntary ‘ “ ‘in the sense that it was the product of a free and
deliberate choice rather than intimidation, coercion, or deception.’ ” ’ ”
(People v. Collins (2001) 26 Cal.4th 297, 305 (Collins).)
13
There is no “specific method for determining whether a defendant has
made a knowing and intelligent waiver of a jury trial in favor of a bench
trial.” (People v. Sivongxxay (2017) 3 Cal.5th 151, 167.) Instead, we
“examine the totality of the circumstances” (ibid.) and find a waiver valid
only “ ‘if the record affirmatively shows that it is voluntary and intelligent
under the totality of the circumstances’ ” (Collins, supra, 26 Cal.4th at
p. 310). “The voluntariness of a waiver is a question of law which we review
de novo.” (People v. Vargas (1993) 13 Cal.App.4th 1653, 1660.)
Here, Carrillo asserts the record does not affirmatively demonstrate his
waiver of a jury trial was knowing, intelligent and voluntary. Rather, he
contends the colloquy that preceded his waiver of a jury trial at the
September 2022 trial readiness conference implicitly conditioned his ability
to appear remotely at trial on a waiver of his right to a jury trial. As such,
Carrillo argues the circumstances surrounding his waiver were similar to
those in Collins, where the trial court suggested defendant might receive a
benefit if he waived his right to a jury trial and the California Supreme Court
held this inducement violated defendant’s right to due process and rendered
the waiver involuntary. (See Collins, supra, 26 Cal.4th at pp. 309, 312.)
Carrillo’s argument is well-taken.
In Collins, when discussing whether defendant would waive his right to
a jury trial, the trial court informed defense counsel that not taking two
weeks’ time to try the case “ ‘has some effect on the court.’ ” (Collins, supra,
26 Cal.4th at p. 309.) The court then went on to say: “ ‘I didn’t specify and
I’m not specifying that there’s any particular benefit, but that by waiving jury,
you are getting some benefit, but I can’t tell you what that is because I don’t
know yet. Understood?’ ” (Id. at p. 302.) The defendant stated he understood
and proceeded to waive a jury trial. (Id. at pp. 302−303.) The high court held
14
that the defendant’s waiver was involuntary because the trial court’s
“negotiation” presented a “ ‘substantial danger of unintentional coercion.’ ”
(Id. at p. 309.)
The record here similarly indicates that Carrillo’s waiver of his right to
a jury trial was not knowing, intelligent and voluntary as it may have been
based on his belief he could only gain the benefit of a remote appearance at
trial if he waived his right to a jury. From the beginning, the record indicates
that Carrillo may have been concerned about having to appear in person for a
trial but, up until the end, never clearly understood that remote appearances
were a possibility for both jury trials and court trials.
For example, during the first trial readiness conference in August 2022,
Carrillo’s counsel asked the trial court if it was allowing individuals at state
hospitals to appear remotely for jury trials, to which the court responded that
it would probably permit that. Carrillo’s counsel then represented at the
September 2022 trial readiness conference that she had spoken with Carrillo
about his options between a court or jury trial. Notwithstanding this fact,
during the waiver colloquy that followed, Carrillo seemed to link a jury trial
with an in person appearance. Notably, when asked if he understood his
right to a jury trial, Carrillo responded: “Yes. I understand my right to a
jury trial. I want to ask you if I was to go over there in Solano county or—
how will I stay in a cell?”
Carrillo’s counsel’s response did not clear up this ambiguity, as she first
stated, “I don’t have an answer to that” before the following dialogue
occurred:
“MS. EVANS: So having understood your rights to a jury trial, do you
wish to waive the right and proceed with a court trial where the judge
15
will hear all the evidence and decide whether or not the District
Attorney has proved their case beyond a reasonable doubt?
“THE DEFENDANT: I couldn’t understand you.
“MS. EVANS: Okay. First of all, Mr. Carrillo, do you want to come to
Solano county and have a jury trial?
“THE DEFENDANT: No. No, I mean—
“MS. EVANS: Okay. So you’re telling us you don’t want to come to
have a jury trial. Do you want to proceed and have a court trial where
you can appear on video?
“THE DEFENDANT: Yes.
“MS. EVANS: Okay.
“THE DEFENDANT: Yes. Right now I’m living—
“MS. EVANS: Mr. Carrillo, do you understand that with a court trial
you’ll appear on video, and the judge will hear all the evidence in the
case, and the judge will decide whether or not your commitment should
be extended?”
(Italics added.)
In framing her questions this way, Carrillo’s counsel appeared to suggest
16
twice that Carrillo would have to “come” to Solano County if he wanted a jury
trial but could “appear on video” with a court trial.
Compounding this ambiguity was the additional fact Carrillo may also
have believed that going to court would result in an extension of his
commitment. Specifically, after Carrillo’s counsel asked if he understood that
having a court trial would mean a judge would decide whether to extend his
commitment, Carrillo responded: “Yes. Yes, if I went to court I be extended
again.” Counsel then confirmed Carrillo wanted a court trial and Carrillo
said, “Court trial, yes.”
Taking these things together and considering the totality of the
circumstances, including the fact Carrillo has been diagnosed with borderline
intellectual functioning, we conclude the record does not affirmatively
demonstrate Carrillo’s waiver of a jury trial was voluntary and intelligent.
Rather, the record suggests Carrillo’s waiver may have been based on a
misunderstanding that he could only obtain the benefit of a remote
appearance at trial if he waived his right to a jury.
II.
Substantial Evidence Supports the Extension of Commitment
Decision.
Under section 1026.5, the commitment of a person found not guilty by
reason of insanity can be extended “only if the person has been committed
under Section 1026 for a felony and by reason of a mental disease, defect, or
disorder represents a substantial danger of physical harm to others.”
(§ 1026.5, subd. (b)(1).) The last element “requires proof that the person has
serious difficulty controlling his dangerous behavior.” (People v. Williams
(2015) 242 Cal.App.4th 861, 872.)
We review an order to extend a commitment under section 1026.5 for
substantial evidence. (People v. Williams, supra, 242 Cal.App.4th at p. 872.)
17
Under that test, we “examin[e] the entire record in the light most favorable to
the order to determine whether a rational trier of fact could have found the
requirements of the statute satisfied beyond a reasonable doubt.” (Ibid.) “A
single psychiatric opinion that an individual is dangerous because of a
mental disorder constitutes substantial evidence to support an extension of
the defendant’s commitment under section 1026.5.” (People v. Bowers (2006)
145 Cal.App.4th 870, 879.) However, “ ‘expert medical opinion evidence that
is based upon a “ ‘guess, surmise or conjecture, rather than relevant,
probative facts, cannot constitute substantial evidence.’ ” [Citations.]’ ”
(People v. Redus (2020) 54 Cal.App.5th 998, 1011.)
In the case before us, Carrillo does not dispute the fact he has a mental
disorder. But he asserts there was insufficient evidence for the trial court to
find that he has serious difficulty controlling his dangerous behavior such
that there is a substantial danger of physical harm to others. We conclude
substantial evidence supports the trial court’s finding and decision to extend
Carrillo’s commitment.
Dr. Quinonez-Truong testified that in the weeks leading up to the trial,
Carrillo was experiencing an increase in symptoms including a “very high-
level of sex drive,” sexual delusions and ongoing sexual preoccupations
whereby he wanted to have relationships with several of the female staff
members at the state hospital and believed they also wanted to have
relationships with him. Carrillo was also engaging in sexually improper
behaviors such as looking at female staff inappropriately, masturbating
several times a day when imagining them, and inappropriately touching a
transexual peer. Thus, Dr. Freimuth noted in his written report that
although Carrillo was able to “limit his behavior to just inappropriately
staring at female staff members” in the setting of a highly secure, supervised
18
state hospital, Carrillo’s risk for sexual assault and potential violence would
“increase substantially” in a community setting where he “does not have
trusted staff around 24/7 to remind him to stop staring at the females or to
stop touching his transexual peer inappropriately.”
Further, Carrillo was continuing to suffer from auditory
hallucinations—a symptom of his mental illness that existed at the time he
committed his original offenses of attempted rape and assault upon the three
female correctional officers. He also seemed to have difficulty understanding
that these voices were a symptom of his mental illness, did not appreciate
that hearing voices contributed to his prior offenses, and failed to understand
the triggers or early warning signs for relapse of his illness.
Finally, the risk of Carrillo not being able to control his potentially
dangerous behavior was compounded by evidence in the record indicating it
was likely he would stop taking his medication once released in the
community. Both doctors testified that Carrillo was suffering from paranoia
that he was being poisoned by his medication or that it was affecting his
sexual functioning. Carrillo also ambivalently stated that he would
“ ‘probably’ ” need medication but was more focused on reducing the dosage
while expressing a belief his mental illness could be managed through
avoiding public restaurants, a good sleep routine and avoiding too much
caffeine. Further, there was evidence that Carrillo had not consistently
taken his medication when living in the community. All these factors are of
particular concern because Carrillo was not taking his medication when he
committed one of his prior offenses.
Carrillo contends that the last time he inappropriately touched a staff
member was while he was out on CONREP in 1999 and cites cases in which
recommitment orders were reversed where there was no evidence the
19
defendants had engaged in dangerous behavior for decades even despite
lapses in medication. Carrillo argues the evidence fails to demonstrate he
will have serious difficulty controlling his dangerous behavior as he has only
been masturbating in the privacy of his own room and has been respectful in
his interactions with female staff. Thus, Carrillo asserts that despite his
increased symptoms, he did not act out in an aggressive way; in fact, he
reached out to Dr. Quinonez-Truong to discuss his symptoms.
Carrillo’s arguments do not persuade us. Significantly, despite his
contention that he was not “aggressive,” Carrillo fails to address the evidence
in the record that he continued to engage in other forms of inappropriate
behavior such as staring inappropriately at female staff members and, until
recently, touching a transexual peer. He also glosses over the fact that he
continues to experience the same symptoms of his illness (i.e. auditory
hallucinations) that he admitted led to the offenses that resulted in his
commitment. Lastly, Carrillo does not address his prior failure to take
medication when in the community, which is of particular concern given the
correlation between his failure to take his medication and his commission of
at least one of his prior offenses. As such, Carrillo’s situation is
distinguishable from those in the cases he relies on. (See, e.g., People v.
Redus, supra, 54 Cal.App.5th at p. 1012 [no evidence of dangerous behavior
over multiple decades even through CONREP releases and medication
lapses], People v. Cheatham (2022) 82 Cal.App.5th 782, 785, 792 [defendant
had not engaged in any violent behavior and had been committed because he
fled from criminal custody twice after he heard voices tell him his life was in
danger]; People v. Johnson (2020) 55 Cal.App.5th 96, 109 [no incidents of
violence or aggression while under CONREP supervision despite fact he
stopped taking medication for two months].)
20
We therefore conclude substantial evidence supports the trial court’s
finding that Carrillo had serious difficulty controlling his dangerous behavior
and represented a substantial danger of physical harm to others.
Accordingly, we need not reach Carrillo’s contention that the petition to
extend commitment should be dismissed because double jeopardy or
res judicata applies when a recommitment order is reversed for insufficient
evidence.
DISPOSITION
The trial court order extending Carrillo’s commitment is reversed, and the
case is remanded for retrial at the option of the People.4
4
This court is aware that a new petition has been filed and a jury trial
has been scheduled for January 28, 2025.
21
STEWART, P. J.
We concur.
RICHMAN, J.
MILLER, J.
People v. Carrillo (A168626)
22
Ti chiedi come si applica questo testo alla tua situazione?
Consulenza gratuita, senza impegno
Descrivi la tua situazione. Il nostro team ti ricontatterà via e-mail per la tua consulenza.
Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude
Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.