CourtListener 10322287•Hart v. Rushmore Loan Management Services CA2/8
Hart v. Rushmore Loan Management Services CA2/8
CourtListener 10322287Calctapp28 gen 2025
Testo completo
Filed 1/28/25 Hart v. Rushmore Loan Management Services CA2/8
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION EIGHT
GUY HART, B333200
Plaintiff and Appellant, Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No. 21SMCV01658
v.
RUSHMORE LOAN
MANAGEMENT SERVICES, LLC
et al.,
Defendants and Respondents.
APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of
Los Angeles County, Mark H. Epstein, Judge. Affirmed.
Shapero Law Firm and Sarah Shapero for Plaintiff and
Appellant.
Houser and Neil J. Cooper for Defendants and
Respondents.
Guy Hart appeals the trial court’s order granting a motion
for summary judgment by Rushmore Loan Management Services,
Inc. (now known as Nationstar Mortgage, Inc.)and Athene
Annuity and Life Insurance Company. We affirm.
I
Hart bought a Santa Monica condo in 1998 and has lived
there since then. In 2004, Hart took out a $367,000 conventional
loan secured against his condo. This loan was not backed by the
government. Rushmore was Hart’s loan servicer, and Athene
was the loan’s beneficiary and owner.
Until March 2020, Hart was current on his loan. Because
of the COVID-19 pandemic, Hart applied for and received a
three-month forbearance of loan payments from Rushmore.
Under the forbearance, Hart’s next loan payment would be due
on June 1, 2020.
Hart failed to make his June 2020 payment. At the end of
the month, Rushmore sent him a letter informing him of possible
workout options that would allow him to avoid foreclosure. The
letter advised Hart to contact Rushmore to discuss potential
workout options and enclosed a borrower assistance application.
In mid-August of 2020, Rushmore sent another letter to
Hart, explaining Rushmore’s process for evaluating options to
assist Hart. It informed Hart that Rushmore could not move
forward with evaluating Hart for workout options because Hart
failed to provide the required documentation, including a signed
and dated hardship letter thoroughly explaining what caused his
inability to maintain payments on the loan, bank statements, and
proof of income.
Hart responded by calling Rushmore, claiming to be
“officially on the one-year” government forbearance program. In
2
another call, Hart argued it was “bullshit” for Rushmore to
require him to provide bank statements as part of his application
for assistance. Hart also accused Rushmore of “illegal
foreclosure” activity, disputed the validity of his loan, and
threatened to sue.
Rushmore sent Hart multiple letters reiterating the
instructions for applying for borrower assistance and requesting
that Hart send in the loan modification application form and the
required supporting documents. When it became apparent that
sending these letters was a fruitless endeavor, Rushmore hired
ZBS Law as foreclosure trustee to conduct a nonjudicial
foreclosure of Hart’s condo. ZBS became the trustee of the
property in March 2021. At Rushmore’s instruction, ZBS caused
a Notice of Default and Election to Sell Under Deed of Trust to be
recorded in the Recorder’s Office in April 2021.
In July 2021, Rushmore retained ZBS as legal counsel to
assist in its communications with Hart, who still refused to
provide the documents Rushmore had repeatedly requested and
had grown increasingly hostile. That same month, ZBS caused a
Notice of Trustee’s Sale to be recorded against Hart’s property.
The sale was initially scheduled for August 10, 2021.
In an August 12, 2021 letter, ZBS informed Hart that the
sale would be postponed to September 14, 2021, but “[his]
outright rejection of Rushmore’s efforts to assist [him] with a
foreclosure prevention alternative has led to the determination
that Rushmore has fully satisfied any and all state and federal
obligations to engage with [him] for loss mitigation purposes.”
Nevertheless, Rushmore was willing to provide Hart with a final
opportunity to submit a borrower assistance application if he sent
in a completed loan modification application by August 27, 2021.
3
If Hart did not meet this deadline, there were only two
foreclosure alternatives that would allow Hart to keep his home:
a full reinstatement of the loan delinquency or a full payoff of the
total outstanding loan balance.
Hart responded by letter on August 23, 2021. He denied
refusing or rejecting assistance by Rushmore and insisted he had
provided all of the necessary documentation. Hart also asked
that Rushmore and Athene “restrain themselves from any further
misrepresentation of facts” and that they “call off/cancel the
illegal foreclosure sale.”
Hart did not submit a complete loan modification
application by the deadline. In an August 27, 2021 letter, ZBS
informed Hart that it had postponed the trustee’s sale to October
19, 2021 and advised Hart to contact Rushmore to request a
payoff or reinstatement quote.
In September 2021, Rushmore sent Hart a mortgage
statement, the first page of which stated twice that the
reinstatement amount due was $34,286.04 if he paid before
October 1.
According to Hart, he “continued to try to work with
[Rushmore and ZBS] for a modification or forbearance,” but
Rushmore and ZBS “continued to play [him] as a yoyo as
Rushmore referred [him] to speak with ZBS while ZBS would
guide [him] towards Rushmore.” Per ZBS, however, Hart’s
“ongoing and well-documented refusal to work with Rushmore in
good faith . . . [his] persistent threats of litigation, and the recent
bombardment of calls to Rushmore and Athene” resulted in
Rushmore flagging his loan as “litigated/contested.” ZBS sent
Hart a letter on September 30, directing him to cease and desist
4
further direct communications with Rushmore and Athene, and
to direct all further communications to ZBS.
On October 1, Hart sent Rushmore and ZBS a document
titled “Request for QWR and Re-Instatement.” The letter stated,
in relevant part: “While account is being reconciled and reviewed
for loan modification we are requesting Re-instatement
statement that is good for (3) days for review and consideration.”
Hart submitted a complete loan modification application in
October 2021. Rushmore acknowledged receipt of the application
on October 12. On October 19, Rushmore notified Hart that he
was not eligible for a loan modification because of his $0.00
monthly income. On October 20, ZBS provided Hart with a
reinstatement quote of $42,066.00.
Hart did not pay the reinstatement amount, but rather,
submitted a second request for a reinstatement quote “to ensure
[he] had sufficient time to reinstate the loan” before the trustee’s
sale, which was postponed to December 7, 2021. ZBS responded
on December 1, informing Hart that the reinstatement amount
was now $44,803.41.
Hart did not pay the reinstatement amount. Instead, Hart
filed the operative complaint in December 2021. Hart’s
complaint included the following causes of action: (1) interfering
with his right of reinstatement, in violation of Civil Code § 2924c;
(2) failure to comply with forbearance notice requirements, in
violation of Civil Code § 3273 et seq.; (3) failure to respond to a
borrower’s qualified written request, in violation of 12 U.S.C. §
2605(e); (4) negligence; (5) using false, deceptive, or misleading
means to collect a debt, in violation of 15 U.S.C. § 1692(e); and (6)
unfair business practices, in violation of Business and Professions
Code § 17200 et seq.
5
Rushmore, Athene, and ZBS moved for summary judgment
on all of Hart’s causes of action. The trial court granted their
motion in its entirety and entered judgment in their favor. Hart
then voluntarily dismissed ZBS as a defendant before filing his
notice of appeal.
II
We independently review the trial court’s decision to grant
summary judgment, considering all evidence set forth in the
moving and opposing papers except that to which the court
sustained objections. (State Dept. of Health Services v. Super. Ct.
(2003) 31 Cal.4th 1026, 1034-35.) We liberally construe evidence
in support of Hart, and resolve doubts concerning this evidence in
his favor. (Id.) Nonetheless, it is Hart’s burden to demonstrate
affirmatively any error by the trial court with support from
citations to the record. (Claudio v. Regents of the Univ. of Cal.
(2005) 134 Cal.App.4th 224, 230 & 252.) Hart fails to meet this
burden.
With respect to his first cause of action, Hart argues the
trial court erred in granting summary judgment to Rushmore and
Athene because the evidence demonstrates they “failed to timely
provide a reinstatement calculation” as required by Civil Code
§ 2924c. However, the evidence shows that Rushmore did comply
with the statute, as it provided or caused ZBS to provide
reinstatement quotes to Hart within 21 days both times that he
requested them, and in monthly mortgage statements from
September to December 2021, giving him ample opportunity to
reinstate. The evidence also shows Hart never took any of these
opportunities.
On his second cause of action, Hart claims that Rushmore
and Athene did not offer any evidence that they complied with
6
§ 3273.11, which requires mortgage servicers to comply with
“applicable federal guidance” regarding borrower options after a
COVID-19 related forbearance. Again, Hart’s claim is belied by
the record, which shows that Rushmore and Athene complied by
reviewing Hart for “a solution that is consistent with guidance to
servicers . . . provided by Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac [or other
government agencies].” (See § 3273.11(c).) Specifically,
Rushmore provided Hart with a forbearance based on his
COVID-19 hardship, did not charge interest on the forborne
payments, and did not otherwise change the terms of his loan.
We agree with Rushmore that these actions are consistent with
applicable federal guidance. For instance, Fannie Mae advises
services to “defer the past-due principal and interest (P&I)
payments as a non-interest bearing balance, due and payable at
the maturity of the mortgage loan . . .” and to leave all other
terms of the loan unchanged. (See <https://singlefamily.
fanniemae.com/media/22341/display> [as of Jan. 27, 2025],
archived at https://perma.cc/ECY6-WSZK.)
Hart forfeited any argument with respect to his third,
fourth, and fifth causes of action because his opening brief did not
comply with Rule 8.204(a)(1)(B) of the Rules of Court, as he failed
to make any cogent argument or cite authority explaining how
the trial court erred in granting summary adjudication on these
claims. (See Lee v. Kim (2019) 41 Cal.App.5th 705, 721 [appellate
court only reviews issues appellant properly raises and
supports].)
Hart’s final cause of action for unfair business practices
under Business and Professions Code § 17200 fails because the
predicate causes of action failed. (See Medical Marijuana, Inc. v.
7
ProjectCBD.com (2020) 46 Cal.App.5th 869, 895 [unfair
competition claim stands or falls with its underlying claim].)
DISPOSITION
We affirm the judgment and award costs to Rushmore and
Athene.
WILEY, J.
We concur:
STRATTON, P. J.
GRIMES, J.
8
Ti chiedi come si applica questo testo alla tua situazione?
Consulenza gratuita, senza impegno
Descrivi la tua situazione. Il nostro team ti ricontatterà via e-mail per la tua consulenza.
Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude
Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.