In re A.L. CA4/1

CourtListener 10307816Calctapp6 gen 2025

Testo completo

Filed 1/6/25 In re A.L. CA4/1
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

COURT OF APPEAL, FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION ONE

STATE OF CALIFORNIA

In re A.L., a Person Coming Under
the Juvenile Court Law.
D084095
SAN DIEGO COUNTY HEALTH
AND HUMAN SERVICES
AGENCY, (Super. Ct. No. NJ15940)
Plaintiff and Respondent,

v.

J.H.,

Defendant and Appellant.

APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of San Diego County,
Nadia J. Keilani, Judge. Affirmed.
Michelle D. Pena, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for
Defendant and Appellant.
Claudia G. Silva, County Counsel, Lisa M. Maldonado, Chief Deputy
County Counsel, and Kristen M. Ojeil, Deputy County Counsel, for Plaintiff
and Respondent.
J.H. (Mother) appeals a placement order following a contested six-

month review hearing (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 366.211), which denied her
request to return A.L. (Minor) to Mother’s home. Mother contends the trial
court lacked substantial evidence to support its finding that it would be
detrimental to return Minor to Mother’s home. She asks this court to reverse
the order with directions to return Minor to Mother’s home under the
supervision of the San Diego County Health and Human Services Agency
(Agency). The Agency contends substantial evidence supports the detriment
finding based on Mother’s lack of insight into the issues that led to detention
and her delayed participation in services, including a child abuse course. We
agree with the Agency and affirm the order.
BACKGROUND
A. Family History
Minor was taken into protective custody in another state after Mother
was arrested in 2018 for criminal conversion and resisting arrest at a

shopping mall.2 Minor was out of Mother’s care for over two years.3
In October 2021, a couple of months after authorities returned Minor to
Mother’s home on a trial visit, child services investigated another allegation
of abuse based on a report that Mother cut Minor’s lip when she hit Minor
with a belt. The child services agency could not substantiate the allegations

1 Further undesignated statutory references are to the Welfare and
Institutions Code.
2 Conversion, as described by statute in the other state, appears to be
equivalent to theft in California. The statutory definition of resisting arrest
in the other state is also similar to the California definition.
3 Mother attributes much of this time to COVID-related court slowdowns
in Indiana.

2
by a preponderance of evidence, but noted Minor’s safety was being
monitored through the reunification case. The out-of-state case terminated
in May 2022 after Mother and Minor relocated to another state.
B. Initiation of California Dependency Matter
Mother and Minor moved to California in early 2023. In June 2023, the
Agency received two referrals on the same day. When Mother was called to
pick up Minor from an after-school program due to a behavioral problem,
Mother said in Minor’s presence, “I don’t know if I want her. I’m going to put
my foot up her ass.” Mother made Minor stand on one foot to apologize for
the behavior. The reporting party said Minor appeared fearful of Mother.
Minor previously said she was afraid Mother would give her a “whooping.”
A second party reported that Mother constantly screamed and yelled
profanities at Minor. When neighbors complained, Mother became
aggressive and yelled, “It’s my fucking daughter.” The second reporting party
was concerned that Mother was emotionally abusing Minor and had concerns
about Mother’s mental health.
About a week later, Mother pinched Minor’s arm when Mother learned
Minor had misbehaved at an after-school program. The pinch left a visible
welt and torn skin. Minor ran back to the after-school center saying she had
to go to the bathroom because she soiled her clothing. Minor reported the
incident to a staff member. She further reported that Mother physically
abused her, including hitting her with a belt buckle and choking her. Minor
had visible marks on her upper chest. Local police responded, arrested
Mother, and took Minor into protective custody. Minor was detained at
Polinsky Children’s Center (PCC), an emergency shelter for children.
Mother acknowledged she disciplined Minor by whipping her with a
belt. Minor has a scar from a belt buckle, which Mother said occurred

3
because a belt broke while Mother hit Minor with it. Mother did not believe
using a belt or pinching Minor was child abuse because this is how Mother
was disciplined when she was young. Mother said Minor got into trouble at
the after-school program because Minor hit, screamed at, spat on, and kicked
people there. Mother acknowledged yelling at Minor because of Minor’s
behaviors, which Mother found embarrassing.
Maternal grandfather said Mother was removed from her own mother’s
care due to abuse. Minor’s maternal great-grandmother (Mother’s
grandmother) primarily raised Mother. Maternal grandfather suggested that
maternal great-grandmother should also care for Minor.
Maternal great-grandmother was not surprised Minor was removed
from Mother’s care again. Maternal great-grandmother said Mother had
mental health “episodes” and was diagnosed with a mental health condition.
She said Mother did not take recommended medications.
The Agency filed a petition on July 6, 2023 alleging Minor was a child
who required the protection of the court under section 300, subdivision (a)
because she was subjected to serious nonaccidental physical harm due to
Mother’s excessive discipline, which included pinching and hitting Minor
with a belt that left marks and scarring on Minor’s body. Minor was placed
in the home of a nonrelative extended family member.
At the detention hearing, the court found the Agency made a prima
facie showing on the petition and ordered Minor’s continued detention out of
Mother’s home. The court instructed the Agency to initiate interstate
compact proceedings to evaluate the maternal great-grandmother for possible
placement and to evaluate a possible local nonrelative extended family
member. The court also ordered voluntary services for Mother and liberal
visitation with Minor.

4
C. Jurisdiction and Disposition Phase
Minor told the social worker that Mother pinched her “all the time” and
the pinches leave marks and bruises. She also said Mother “whoops” her “on
the butt” and her “private part” with a belt using the “solid part, meaning the
most hurting part.” She pointed to a scar on her shoulder. Minor reported
that Mother called her names, said she hated Minor, said she thought Minor
was ugly, and she wanted Minor to die. This made Minor feel like she
wanted to die. Minor did not feel safe near Mother. Minor acknowledged
having incontinence episodes in her clothing.
The court placed Minor with temporary caregivers. Minor disclosed to
these caregivers that Mother administered numerous beatings with a belt
buckle and Mother once broke a locked door to inflict punishment on Minor.
Minor also disclosed an incident when Mother strangled Minor, held her
against a wall, and punched her in the face for trying to get away. In one
instance, after Minor hit the caregivers’ child, Minor cowered and shook in
the corner when the caregiver told Minor she was not allowed to hit their
child. After caregivers explained the no-hitting boundary, Minor asked the
caregivers if they hated her.
Mother told the Agency she did not believe hitting Minor with a belt or
pinching was physical abuse. She said this was how she was disciplined and
it was passed down to her from her culture. Mother told the caregiver that
she came from “a strong discipline background” and she disciplined Minor so
that she knew how to behave.
A child abuse evaluator said Minor’s reports that Mother hit her with a
belt could account for the patterned lesion on Minor’s chest. It was also a
plausible explanation for several other linear hyper-pigmented lesions on
Minor’s abdomen, back, and right arm. These injuries were consistent with

5
physical abuse. Although corporal punishment is used as a form of discipline,
the evaluator stated it is never appropriate to strike a child with an object.
The evaluator noted the bystander reports that Mother would make
statements in Minor’s presence saying Minor was a product of rape, that
Mother did not want her, or that she wished Minor would die. The evaluator
believed these statements were consistent with psychological maltreatment
and emotional abuse in the form of spurning and terrorizing, which can lead
to short and long-term effects on a child’s health. The evaluator believed
Minor’s incontinence issues could be a trauma symptom.
During a child and family team meeting in July 2023, Mother became
verbally aggressive and told Minor to “keep her mouth shut.” She escalated
to the point that Minor started to cry and Mother had to be removed from the
meeting due to continued traumatization of Minor.
The initial case plan stated a safety goal for Mother to develop a
strategy to show positive disciplinary methods that do not involve physical or
emotional harm. The Agency would need to see Mother use this new
discipline approach for at least six months. Mother’s plan included a
parenting education program, a 52-week child abuse treatment program, and
conjoint therapy with Minor when appropriate.
Mother was given paperwork to enroll in a 52-week child abuse group
class in early August 2023. However, Mother said she had “a problem” with
how many classes she needed to attend and thought the length of the
program was too long. She wanted to wait to see if the court ordered her to
participate.
In mid-August, Minor’s behaviors regressed. Minor defecated on
herself at the after-school program. She showed other children and staff

6
members and smeared feces around the room. Minor was not allowed to
return to the after-school program after this incident.
Minor began individual therapy, but did not initially engage with the
therapist. Minor’s caregiver believed Minor had attention deficit
hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) and needed an individual education plan.
The caregivers expressed concerns about Minor’s behaviors and stated they
could not keep Minor in their home for long term care. Minor returned to
PCC in September 2023.
D. Contested Adjudication and Disposition Hearing
At the contested adjudication hearing in October 2023, the court
sustained the petition finding by a preponderance of the evidence that Minor
was a person described by section 300, subdivision (a). The court commented
that Mother admitted using physical discipline which left documented
bruises and scars on Minor, perhaps emotional scars as well.
At the disposition hearing the following day, Minor’s counsel stated
Minor wished to live with Mother on the condition that Mother does not
spank her. Minor’s counsel, as guardian ad litem, agreed with the Agency’s
recommendation saying Mother needed to make some progress in her case
plan and engage in services to make sure corporal punishment does not occur
in the future.
The court found by clear and convincing evidence that removal from
Mother’s care was appropriate. The court found there was a substantial
danger to Minor’s physical health, safety, protection, and emotional well
being if she returned to Mother’s care. The court referred to numerous
descriptions of severe corporal punishment Minor suffered at the hands of
Mother which left Minor with lifelong scars and serious bruising. The court

7
also noted that Minor had exhibited fear of Mother and sounded “terrified”
when they discussed placing her in Mother’s care.
Mother asked to strike the child abuse class from the case plan and
objected to a psychological evaluation. The court rejected Mother’s argument
that a child abuse class was not necessary, saying such a class “is probably
the most pivotal art of her case plan given the allegations that the [c]ourt has
already found to be true.” The court determined that psychological
evaluations of both Mother and Minor were appropriate given concerning
behaviors exhibited by each of them.
E. Six-month Review Period
Minor’s psychological evaluation was completed in December 2023 and
included a diagnosis of ADHD with hyperactive, impulsive, and disruptive
behavior. The evaluator thought Minor’s bowel and urinary incontinence
may be related to difficulties coping with her living situation and a
combination of both challenges recognizing bodily cues that she needed to use
a restroom along with problems regulating her emotions. Based on the
records and Minor’s reports, the evaluator also diagnosed probable
posttraumatic stress disorder. The evaluator recommended that Minor
needed consistent engagement in services for six to nine months to determine
her progress as well as whether Minor continues to face “new stressors.”
Mother’s psychological evaluation was completed in January 2024. The
evaluator found Mother met the criteria for delusional disorder as well as a
personality disorder not otherwise specified with primary features of
paranoid personality and borderline personality disorders. Mother exhibited
“fixed beliefs of a persecutory nature” which were “primarily related to racial
injustice and bias.” She had limited coping, communication, and conflict
resolution skills. Her ability to regulate her emotions and anger were

8
impaired as were her insight and judgment. Mother’s defensive presentation
made it difficult to assess her true psychological functioning. She was unable
or unwilling to acknowledge her role and responsibility in the removal of
Minor. Mother lacked insight about Minor’s emotional needs and appeared
unwilling or unable to place Minor’s needs ahead of her own.
The evaluator discussed the case with a cultural consultant to ensure
cultural sensitivity in the evaluation. The consultant confirmed that “church
pinches and whoopings are a real thing” in the state where Mother was
raised, but the consultant also said, “They are not the seed of abuse or not
wanting to engage.” The consultant expressed concern about Mother’s
expressed belief that Minor was conceived from a sexual assault. The
consultant stated this perception could lead to harsher words and to harsher
discipline of Minor because “empathy and attachment are not present.”
Based on the consultation, the evaluator determined Mother’s behaviors
appeared “primarily related to mental health issues and real or perceived
traumas” rather than “cultural influences.”
The evaluator recommended an intense outpatient program,
medication evaluation, and individual therapy with a therapist trained in
personality disorders who matches Mother’s cultural and ethnic background.
The evaluator also recommended continued participation in child abuse
prevention classes “to gain increased awareness and knowledge of the
symptomology of abuse, effects of abuse/neglect on children, and develop
skills to decrease potential for abuse in the future.”
In January 2024, Minor moved from PCC to a temporary placement
which she liked. However, Minor exhibited concerning behaviors such as
locking the caregivers out of their house and not getting along with other
children in the home and the neighborhood. The caregivers were willing to

9
keep Minor through the school year, but said they were not a permanent
placement option.
Maternal great-grandmother was approved for placement out of state.
The Agency recommended moving Minor to great-grandmother’s care. The
court continued the matter to address Minor’s medications and to explore
other placement options.
In February, the Agency set a special hearing to request placement of
Minor with maternal great-grandmother out of state. Mother did not agree
and requested a trial. Minor’s counsel agreed with the Agency’s
recommendation, but requested to wait to move Minor until the end of the
school year so Minor could finish some of her programs. The caregivers were
willing to keep Minor until then. Minor wanted to move out of state, but
wanted Mother to come with her.
At the scheduled six-month review hearing in April 2024, the Agency
continued to recommend placement out of the home with maternal great-
grandmother in the other state. Mother objected and requested a trial. At
this point, Minor expressed a desire to stay in California near Mother. The
guardian ad litem submitted on the Agency’s recommendation to move Minor
to maternal grandmother’s care after the school year.
F. Contested Six-month Review Hearing
After several continuances, the contested review hearing occurred on
May 13, 2024.
Minor testified that she liked visiting with Mother and being able to
hug and cuddle with her. Minor was happy that Mother attended a singing
performance in which Minor participated because Mother taught Minor to
sing. Minor wanted to stay in California to be near Mother and to continue

10
at the school Minor attended. Minor felt safe living with Mother because
visits were improving and Mother did not yell at her during visits.
Minor did not want to return to PCC because she got into fights with
other kids. She would feel safer going to her great-grandmother than
returning to PCC. She would feel comfortable going to her great-
grandmother at the end of the school year.
The social worker testified that the Agency would facilitate weekly in-
person visits with Mother if the child moved out of state, including paying for
flight and hotel expenses. Mother could visit with Minor more frequently by,
for example, visiting several times over a weekend.
As recently as March 2024, phone visits upset Minor and caused her to
dysregulate. Mother began participating in a parenting education class in
March 2024 and was receptive to its subject matter. Mother began taking the
child abuse classes at the end of April 2024, after the social worker had a
frank discussion with Mother about the need to take part in the classes.
If Minor were not placed out of state and the Agency could not locate a
resource home after the school year, Minor would return to PCC.
Mother testified on her own behalf. She asked the court to place Minor
with her. Mother did not agree with placing Minor out of state with the
maternal great-grandmother because Mother does not have a good
relationship with the maternal great-grandmother.
Mother explained she completed the psychological evaluation. She
began attending the parenting class in March 2024. As of the hearing, she
attended three child abuse classes. Mother said she learned that she is “a
good mom,” “a good person,” and she “is doing a great job.” She learned about
different parenting styles from different cultures and parenting techniques.

11
She would not mind continuing to attend the child abuse class if Minor was
returned home.
When asked on cross-examination whether she had pinched or hit
Minor with a belt, Mother responded, “We’ve all been disciplined before.” She
denied using a belt buckle or scarring Minor. She denied physically abusing
Minor or using physical force.
Mother did not participate in child abuse classes at the beginning of the
case because she had a lot going on. She also said, “I had every right to go
against it and ask for a fair trial.” She started the 52-week child abuse
course a few weeks before the contested hearing. But she said she was told
that it “does not have to be completed” before Minor could return home.
After considering the evidence presented and arguments of the parties,
the court found the return of Minor to Mother’s care would create a
substantial risk of detriment to Minor’s safety, protection, and emotional
well-being.
The court found it was not in Minor’s best interest to place her out of
state. The court ordered the Agency to continue efforts in earnest to find a
placement for Minor in San Diego and to minimize the need to return her to
PCC. Mother appealed.
DISCUSSION
Mother contends there was insufficient evidence for the court’s finding
that it would be detrimental for Minor to return to Mother’s care at the
contested six-month review hearing. We disagree.
I. General Legal Principles
After the juvenile court finds jurisdiction under section 300, it may
remove a child from a parent pursuant to section 361 at a dispositional
hearing only if it finds by clear and convincing evidence “[t]here is or would

12
be a substantial danger to the physical health, safety, protection, or physical
or emotional well-being of the minor if the minor were returned home, and
there are no reasonable means by which the minor’s physical health can be
protected without removing the minor from the minor’s parents.” (§ 361,
subd. (c)(1); see Cynthia D. v. Superior Court (1993) 5 Cal.4th 242, 248
(Cynthia D.) [“At the dispositional hearing, the standard of proof for removal
from a custodial parent is clear and convincing evidence.”].)
At the six-month review hearing, in contrast, there is a statutory
presumption that the child will be returned to parental custody “unless the
court finds, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the return of the child to
their parent or legal guardian would create a substantial risk of detriment to
the safety, protection, or physical or emotional well-being of the child.”
(§ 366.21, subd. (e)(1).) (Italics added.) The Agency bears the burden of
establishing that detriment. (Ibid; Cynthia D., supra, 5 Cal.4th at pp. 248–
249.) Proof by a preponderance standard at this stage sufficiently protects a
parent’s due process rights. (Cynthia D., at pp. 253–256.)
“In evaluating detriment, the juvenile court must consider the extent to
which the parent participated in reunification services” and “efforts or
progress the parent has made toward eliminating the conditions that led to
the child’s out-of-home placement.” (In re Yvonne W. (2008) 165 Cal.App.4th
1394, 1400 (Yvonne W.).) The juvenile court “shall consider the efforts or
progress, or both, demonstrated by the parent . . . and the extent to which
they availed themselves of services provided . . . .” (§ 366.21, subd. (e)(1).)
A juvenile court may find it is detrimental to return the child to the
parent even if the parent has complied with the reunification case plan. (See
Constance K. v. Superior Court (1998) 61 Cal.App.4th 689, 704–711
(Constance K.) [reports by mental health and medical professionals and social

13
worker supported a finding that returning the minors to mother would be
substantially detrimental even though mother had completed her program];
In re Dustin R. (1997) 54 Cal.App.4th 1131, 1143 [a court may consider
compliance with reunification plan requirements, but the court “must also
consider the parents’ progress and their capacity to meet the objectives of the
plan”]; In re Jonathan R. (1989) 211 Cal.App.3d 1214, 1221.) [“a finding that
improvements in [a] parent[’]s circumstances outweigh the failures during
reunification does not guarantee return of the child to the parents”].) The
juvenile court may consider the parent’s past conduct as well as present
circumstances (In re Troy D. (1989) 215 Cal.App.3d 889, 900), and the court is
permitted to consider a parent’s denial of the protective issues when
evaluating detriment in returning a child to parental custody (Georgeanne G.
v. Superior Court (2020) 53 Cal.App.5th 856, 865–868 (Georgeanne G.)). “It is
for the [juvenile] court to weigh [evidence of present circumstances] against
the evidence of the parents’ efforts, accomplishments, and failures during the
reunification period.” (In re Jonathan R., at p. 1221.)
“We review the juvenile court’s finding of detriment for substantial
evidence. [Citations.] Under that standard we inquire whether the evidence,
contradicted or uncontradicted, supports the court’s determination.”
(Georgeanne G., supra, 53 Cal.App.5th at pp. 864–865; see In re Mary B.
(2013) 218 Cal.App.4th 1474, 1483 (Mary B.).) “ ‘ “[W]e draw all reasonable
inferences from the evidence to support the findings and orders of the
dependency court; we review the record in the light most favorable to the
court’s determinations; and we note that issues of fact and credibility are the
province of the trial court.” [Citation.] ‘ “We do not reweigh the evidence or
exercise independent judgment, but merely determine if there are sufficient

14
facts to support the findings of the trial court.” ’ ” (In re I.J. (2013) 56 Cal.4th
766, 773.)
II. Substantial Evidence Supported the Detriment Finding
To support her primary contention that substantial evidence does not
support the trial court’s detriment finding, Mother relies upon Jennifer A. v.
Superior Court (2004) 117 Cal.App.4th 1322, 1326 where the appellate court
determined substantial evidence did not support a finding that returning
children to their mother would create a substantial risk of detriment. In that
case, the children were removed after a single instance when she left her
children alone to go to work. After removal, the mother substantially
complied with the reunification plan, learned proper parenting skills, and
accepted responsibility for the circumstances that brought her children into
the juvenile court’s custody. There was no evidence of physical or emotional
abuse and there was no evidence the mother had a mental illness that
affected her parenting skills. (Ibid.) The instant matter presents a different
situation.
The juvenile court here found by a preponderance of the evidence that
returning Minor to Mother’s care would create a substantial risk of detriment
to Minor’s safety, protection, and emotional well-being.
As the court explained, Minor was removed because the court found
Mother’s forms of discipline constituted child abuse based on both physical
evidence and statements of Minor. The court expressed concern that Mother
had not made more progress with the child abuse class in the initial review
period. The court explained this was “arguably the most important
component” of Mother’s case plan because the class is “tailored to address
what is or is not child abuse and how to prevent child abuse.” The court was
concerned both with Mother’s delay in starting the class for 10 months and

15
with the fact that Mother did not acknowledge or accept that her conduct
resulted in this dependency matter. The court believed greater participation
in the child abuse class would likely “go hand in hand with that acceptance
and with that knowledge.” The court’s findings are supported by substantial
evidence.
At the contested hearing, Mother denied she physically abused Minor.
When asked specifically about pinching or hitting Minor with a belt, Mother
responded, “We’ve all been disciplined before.” She also denied hitting Minor
with a belt buckle and leaving a visible scar.
When she was offered child abuse classes in July 2023, Mother said she
had “a lot going on” and had “every right to go against it and ask for a fair
trial.” However, the court rejected Mother’s request to strike the child abuse
class from her plan at the contested adjudication and disposition hearing in
October 2023. At that time, the court explained the class was “the most
pivotal part of her case plan” given the true finding on the allegations of child
abuse based on excessive discipline.
The psychologist who evaluated Mother also recommended, among
other things, participation in child abuse prevention classes “to gain
increased awareness and knowledge of the symptomology of abuse, effects of
abuse/neglect on children, and develop skills to decrease potential for abuse
in the future.” She recommended parent education and coaching to meet the
emotional needs of Minor, foster positive attachments, and increase Mother’s
“mediation and communication skills.” The psychologist believed measurable
progress could be made in six to 12 months of treatment if mother was
engaged in a “highly motivated manner.” The psychologist, however, thought
Mother’s lack of motivation to engage in services, pervasive mistrust, and
impaired insight and judgment made her prognosis poor.

16
Yet, Mother did not begin the child abuse class. She did not respond to
monthly requests and encouragement by the social worker to engage in the
child abuse class. She only agreed to the class in late March 2024 when the
social worker had a candid conversation about the importance of the class to
the progression of the case. She completed only three classes by the time of
the contested hearing in May 2024. At that point, it was too early to
determine if she had made progress.
Mother testified she learned from the child abuse sessions only that
there are different parenting styles and that she was a good mother doing a
“great job.” She did not believe she needed to complete the course to have
Minor returned to her care.
The court was required to consider the extent to which Mother availed
herself of the services offered to her as well as her efforts and progress in
those services. (§ 366.21, subd. (e)(1); Mary B., supra, 218 Cal.App.4th at
pp. 1483–1484.) In reviewing whether the record contains substantial
evidence that returning a minor to a parent’s custody would be detrimental,
“we must keep in mind that the purpose of the reunification plan is ‘to
overcome the problem that led to removal in the first place.’ ” (Id. at p. 1483;
Yvonne W., supra, 165 Cal.App.4th at p. 1400.) Mother’s lack of insight about
how her disciplinary conduct brought Minor into the court’s care along with
Mother’s delayed participation and minimal progress in parenting and child
abuse prevention services amply supported the court’s finding that it would
be detrimental to return Minor to Mother’s care.
Mother’s contention that her recent positive visits “proved” Minor
would be safe if returned to Mother’s care under supervision is speculative.
Although Mother participated in supervised visits and in supervised phone
visits, they did not yet establish a pattern of safe behavior with Minor. Minor

17
was initially hesitant to visit Mother in person and expressed discomfort with
Mother doing her hair during visits. There was a lapse in visits when Minor
was placed at PCC and Minor expressed disappointment that Mother failed
to see Minor then. Weekly supervised visits resumed in January 2024 when
Minor was placed in a foster home.
Minor often became dysregulated and wet the bed after phone calls
when Mother would yell at Minor or criticize her. In February, as a response,
the caregiver set time limits on phone calls. This improved Minor’s mood and
bed wetting incidents. However, even at the end of March 2024, Minor’s
teacher reported that Mother’s visits and phone calls still had a negative
impact on Minor, leaving her in emotional turmoil each week. Minor said she
liked her visits with Mother, except when Mother yelled at her.
In May 20024, a social worker observed a positive visit where Mother
and Minor played games and read books together. Mother’s parenting
education facilitator was present during the visit and Mother was working on
the parent-child interaction module. Minor testified that she enjoyed visiting
and cuddling with Mother. At the time of trial, she felt she could be safe with
Mother because visits were “improving” and Mother had not yelled at her “at
all.”
The fact that Mother recently engaged in the parenting and child abuse
classes and had positive supervised visits shortly before the contested
hearing with Minor was encouraging. But, given the history of trauma Minor
experienced from Mother’s physical and verbal abuse, it was reasonable for
the court to want to see more progress with these courses and increased
visitation before returning Minor to Mother’s care.
Mother’s contention on appeal that it would have been safe to return
Minor to her care because “there was no evidence that Mother would not

18
follow through with court orders to refrain from using physical discipline”
and because Minor “was known to report her concerns about Mother’s
discipline and yelling in the past” is hopeful speculation at this stage of the
case. We cannot interfere with the juvenile court’s order based on
speculation (In re Jose C. (2010) 188 Cal.App.4th 147, 159) or on the hope
that Mother will comply with court orders or Agency supervision (In re John
M. (2012) 212 Cal.App.4th 1117, 1127).
Mother does not have a proven track record of complying with court
orders, having only recently availed herself of services ordered at the
beginning of the case. And relying on Minor to report safety concerns would
place an unfair and undue burden on her to maintain her own safety. Minor
previously explained she could not stand up for herself because Mother would
hit her. She only felt safe because she was out of Mother’s care. The record
establishes that Mother’s continued participation in her case plan is essential
before she can realize the goal of returning Minor to her care.
Finally, Mother has not established a violation of her due process rights
by the court’s placement decision. “ ‘Although a parent’s interest in the care,
custody and companionship of a child is a liberty interest that may not be
interfered with in the absence of a compelling state interest, the welfare of a
child is a compelling state interest that a state has not only a right, but a
duty, to protect.’ ” (Constance K., supra, 61 Cal.App.4th at p. 703.) “ ‘The
dependency scheme, when viewed as a whole, provides the parent due process
and fundamental fairness while also accommodating the child’s right to
stability and permanency.’ ” (Id. at p. 704.)
The court here considered the best interests of Minor in making the
placement decision. The court rejected the Agency’s recommendation to place
Minor with the maternal grandmother in another state because it determined

19
such placement would not be in Minor’s best interest and would impede
reunification. The court was aware that changing placements was not ideal
for Minor, but acknowledged they were “in a bind” because Minor’s current
placement could not continue. The court, therefore, emphasized the need for
the Agency to continue its efforts “in earnest” to find a suitable placement
with a new foster family by the end of the school year so Minor could
transition immediately to that home rather than return to PCC. The court
was concerned about reports that Minor experienced harm from her
interactions with other children at PCC, but stated that was not reason to
send a child out of state. The court explained that both PCC and the Agency
had a duty to ensure Minor’s safety if it became necessary to place her there.
As discussed, substantial evidence supported the juvenile court’s finding that
the Agency met its burden of showing it would be detrimental to return
Minor to Mother’s care. We cannot conclude the court abused its discretion or
failed to consider the best interests of Minor in making the placement
decision.
DISPOSITION
The order is affirmed.

RUBIN, J.

WE CONCUR:

O’ROURKE, Acting P. J.

IRION, J.

20

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.