CourtListener 10306325•Zhao v. Global Valley CA2/5
Testo completo
Filed 12/31/24 Zhao v. Global Valley CA2/5
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION FIVE
ZIDAN ZHAO et al., B327953
Plaintiffs and Appellants, (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No.
v. 21STCV37440)
GLOBAL VALLEY, LLC et al.,
Defendants and Respondents.
APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of Los
Angeles County, Barbara M. Scheper, Judge. Affirmed.
Gonzalez & Gonzalez Law, Rosendo Gonzalez, and Zachary
I. Gonzalez for Plaintiffs and Appellants.
Wright Kim Douglas, J. Andrew Douglas, and David M.
Kim; Lewis Brisbois Bisgaard & Smith and Caroline E. Chan for
Defendants and Respondents.
Plaintiffs Zidan Zhao (Zidan) and East Asia Investment
Group, Inc. (East Asia) appeal from a judgment of dismissal that
the trial court entered after sustaining a demurrer on statute of
limitations grounds to their operative complaint. We consider
whether, as plaintiffs contend, the complaint and its attachments
suffice to establish their causes of action are timely under the
“discovery rule,” which “‘postpones accrual of a cause of action
until the plaintiff discovers, or has reason to discover, the cause
of action.’” (Aryeh v. Canon Business Solutions, Inc. (2013) 55
Cal.4th 1185, 1192.)
I. BACKGROUND
A. Facts Alleged in the Complaint and the Attachments
Thereto1
In broad strokes, the operative complaint Zidan filed
against Global Valley, LLC and its manager David Kuo alleges
eleven primarily contract and fraud-related causes of action
arising out of investments in Global Valley (and in another
limited liability company named Pacific Covina, LLC) made by
Zidan’s late father Xue “Gary” Zhao (Gary). More specifically,
Global Valley purchased three parcels in San Gabriel where it
operated a Crowne Plaza hotel. In 2009, Gary collected
$2,250,000 in wire transfers from family members and others in
1
“Because this case is before us after the trial court
sustained defendant’s demurrer without leave to amend, we take
the facts as stated in the operative complaint and its attachments
to be true.” (Williams & Fickett v. County of Fresno (2017) 2
Cal.5th 1258, 1265.) We do not, however, assume the truth of
contentions, deductions, or conclusions of law. (City of Dinuba v.
County of Tulare (2007) 41 Cal.4th 859, 865.)
2
China and invested that sum in Global Valley. Gary used his
niece Weijing “Jessie” Zhao as an intermediary to make the
investment in Global Valley, and that investment was ultimately
held by East Asia, Gary’s corporation.
In April and May of 2015, according to the operative
complaint, “Gary repeatedly asked Kuo for an accounting and
explanation as to the funds and balance of the accounts in
relation to Global Valley,” but “Kuo failed to provide the
requested information and documentation.” On or about May 26,
2015, Global Valley sold the Crowne Plaza hotel for $25,000,000.
Although Kuo and members of his family were paid significant
distributions following the sale of the hotel property, neither
Gary nor Jessie “ever received any money, payment or
distribution from Global Valley.”2
The operative complaint (and some of its attachments) also
describe two lawsuits involving many of the same parties that
were litigated in 2015 and 2016. First, in October of 2015, Jessie
(Gary’s niece) sued Kuo and Global Valley for breach of fiduciary
duty and other claims contending she (as the nominal investor in
Global Valley via East Asia) was wrongfully deprived of her share
of the proceeds from the Crowne Plaza sale. Zidan “participated
and testified” in the action. Second, on February 29, 2016, an
attorney for Global Valley filed an interpleader action to
determine ownership of $750,000 in proceeds from the Crowne
Plaza hotel property sale. The interpleader action named Jessie,
East Asia, and Gary’s ex-wife Jennifer Tan (Tan) as potential
claimants, and Zidan again “participated and testified” in the
2
Gary was killed five days after the sale of the hotel
property.
3
action. In May 2016, the court in the interpleader action entered
judgment awarding the disputed hotel sale funds to Tan based on
a marital settlement agreement whereby Gary had transferred a
portion of East Asia’s interest in Global Valley to Tan.
Following entry of judgment in the interpleader action, Kuo
and Global Valley moved for summary judgment in Jessie’s
lawsuit, arguing that the interpleader judgment determined
Jessie had no interest in Global Valley. According to the
operative complaint in this case, at a December 2019 hearing, the
court granted summary judgment for Global Valley and Kuo
based on its finding that Gary (or East Asia), not Jessie, had the
ownership interest in Global Valley. The operative complaint
further asserts that it was not until this December 2019 ruling
that Zidan “learned and became aware of the factual basis to
possibly assert claims and causes of action against Kuo and
Global Valley.” Prior to that time, Zidan believed Jessie was the
one who held an ownership interest in Global Valley.3
B. Procedural History of This Lawsuit
Zidan—individually, as an officer of East Asia, and as
personal representative of his father Gary’s estate—filed the
original complaint in this action on October 12, 2021. Global
Valley and Kuo demurred to the complaint, and the trial court
sustained the demurrer with leave to amend. The court found all
of the causes of action were time-barred on the face of the
3
The complaint concedes Zidan “eventually learned that
there was apparently some disagreement, dispute or concern with
respect to Jessie’s asserted investment in Global Valley” after the
end of May 2015, but it does not specify when, precisely, Zidan
learned of this disagreement.
4
complaint because the longest applicable statute of limitations
was four years and the complaint was filed roughly six years
after the wrongs alleged. The court concluded there was no basis
to find the complaint timely under the discovery rule because
plaintiffs had not pled “specific facts showing either ‘the time and
manner of discovery,’ or [Zidan’s] ‘inability to have made earlier
discovery despite reasonable diligence.’” The court, however,
gave Zidan leave to amend to attempt to address the deficiency.
Zidan subsequently filed the operative complaint on April
15, 2022. It adds allegations, some of which we have already
discussed, intended to address the statute of limitations problem
identified by the trial court.4 The operative complaint retains the
allegations concerning the lawsuit Jessie filed in 2015 and the
interpleader action Global Valley filed in 2016.
Kuo and Global Valley demurred to the operative complaint
and argued the amended allegations did nothing to ameliorate
the previously identified statute of limitations problem with all of
4
It asserts, for instance, that prior to the December 2019
summary judgment ruling in the lawsuit filed by Jessie, Zidan
“did not know or suspect, and had no reason to know or suspect,
that (i) Gary was the one that actually contributed funds to
Global Valley, (ii) Gary was actually the holder of fifty percent
interest in Global Valley, and/or (iii) there was any impropriety
or wrongful conduct that would require the assertion of causes of
action or claims by Gary regarding Kuo’s and Global Valley’s
conduct.” The complaint also alleges that at no time prior to his
death “did Gary discuss with and/or tell, inform or disclose to
[Zidan] that there was any specific impropriety or wrongdoing by
Kuo and Global Valley.”
5
the causes of action.5 Kuo and Global Valley cited authority
holding the discovery rule is triggered when a reasonable
plaintiff would have a suspicion of wrongdoing, not full
knowledge of all facts necessary to establish a claim, and
explained the action was time-barred because such a suspicion
would have arisen long before the period provided by the longest
statute of limitations for the claims in the operative complaint.
After an unreported hearing, the trial court sustained
defendants’ demurrers without leave to amend. A minute order
issued in connection with the hearing is terse: it mentions a
“spoken tentative ruling” was given, the matter was argued, the
demurrer was sustained without leave to amend, and defendants’
“spoken request to dismiss is granted.” A signed order of
dismissal was entered that same day.
II. DISCUSSION
Our review is de novo (Hilliard v. Harbour (2017) 12
Cal.App.5th 1006, 1010), and we hold the trial court correctly
concluded this action is time-barred. Plaintiffs do not dispute
that the lawsuit, filed more than six years after the sale of the
Crowne Plaza hotel property, could be timely only if the discovery
rule applies. Relying on the operative complaint itself and its
attachments (we need not rely on materials Global Valley and
Kuo asked the trial court to judicially notice), the discovery rule
does not apply. Plaintiffs were indisputably aware of facts,
5
Kuo and Global Valley also argued issue preclusion barred
all the claims in the amended complaint, which amounted to an
attempt to relitigate issues resolved by the prior interpleader
action and Jessie’s unsuccessful lawsuit against Kuo and Global
Valley.
6
perhaps as early as April 2015 (when Gary’s requests to inspect
Global Valley’s books and records were denied) and certainly as
of February 2016 (when Global Valley filed the interpleader
action naming East Asia and others), that would have put a
reasonable person on notice of the need to “go find the facts”
rather than “wait for the facts to find [him or] her.” (Jolly v. Eli
Lilly & Co. (1988) 44 Cal.3d 1103, 1111.)
“Under the statute of limitations, a plaintiff must bring a
cause of action within the limitations period applicable thereto
after accrual of the cause of action. [Citations.]” (Norgart v.
Upjohn Co. (1999) 21 Cal.4th 383, 397.) The longest potentially
applicable statute of limitations for the causes of action asserted
in the operative complaint is four years. (Code Civ. Proc., §§ 337,
343.) At the very latest, then, plaintiffs would ordinarily have
been required to file suit in or about June 2019 (four years after
the sale of the hotel and payment of proceeds) for at least some
claim in the lawsuit to be timely. That, of course, did not happen;
this action was not filed until two years after that, in October
2021.
We reject plaintiffs’ attempt to rely on the discovery rule to
claim the relevant triggering date for statute of limitations
purposes is December 2019. Plaintiffs choose that time because
they believe “[t]he December 2019 Ruling [granting Kuo’s motion
for summary judgment in Tan’s lawsuit] was the first time that
[plaintiffs] became aware of the factual basis to possibly assert
claims and causes of action against Kuo and Global Valley.”6
6
We are not bound to accept bare contentions and
conclusions of law in the operative complaint about the relevant
date for statute of limitations purposes. (Serrano v. Priest (1971)
5 Cal.3d 584, 591; 5 Witkin, California Procedure (6th ed. 2021),
7
That, however, is not the pertinent time for discovery rule
purposes because “[i]t is not the law that accrual of a cause of
action depends upon the existence, as a matter of fact, of a
winning claim. Accrual does not wait ‘until a plaintiff is in a
position to present evidence which will (regardless of what
evidence the defense musters) establish facts which make
liability a legal certainty.’ [Citation.]” (Cypress Semiconductor
Corp. v. Superior Court (2008) 163 Cal.App.4th 575, 585; accord,
Jolly, supra, 44 Cal.3d at 1111 [“A plaintiff need not be aware of
the specific ‘facts’ necessary to establish the claim; that is a
process contemplated by pretrial discovery”].) The showing
required to invoke the discovery rule is one of diligence in
attempting to learn facts, not success in obtaining those facts,
and the statute begins to run ‘“when the plaintiff has notice or
information of circumstances to put a reasonable person on
inquiry, or has the opportunity to obtain knowledge from sources
open to his investigation.”’ (Sanchez v. South Hoover Hospital
(1976) 18 Cal.3d 93, 101.)
The operative complaint and its attachments reveal a
reasonable person, and indeed, Zidan himself, would have been
on inquiry regarding Gary’s potential claims against defendants
no later than 2016—more than four years before plaintiffs filed
this lawsuit. Plaintiffs’ operative complaint admits that shortly
before the Crowne Plaza hotel property sale closed in May 2015,
Gary repeatedly asked Kuo for an accounting and explanation as
Pleading § 927 at p. 330 [“Formal averments or general
conclusions to the effect that the facts were not discovered until a
stated date, and that the plaintiff could not have made an earlier
discovery, are useless”].)
8
to the funds and balance of Global Valley’s accounts and “it
is . . . [plaintiff’s] understanding that Kuo failed to provide the
requested information and documentation.” This refusal of
Gary’s requests, coming when they did, would have alone aroused
the requisite suspicion in our view, but there is more. The mere
filing of the interpleader action in February 2016 would put a
reasonable person on inquiry. (See generally City of Morgan Hill
v. Brown (1999) 71 Cal.App.4th 1114, 1122 [“When a person may
be subject to conflicting claims for money or property, the person
may bring an interpleader action to compel the claimants to
litigate their claims among themselves. (Code Civ. Proc., § 386,
subd. (b).) Once the person admits liability and deposits the
money with the court, he or she is discharged from liability and
freed from the obligation of participating in the litigation
between the claimants”].) East Asia was named as a potential
claimant in that suit, Zidan admits he was aware of the action
(indeed, he participated in it and testified), and the question to be
determined in that action was who was entitled to receive part of
the profits of the Crowne Plaza hotel property sale. Moreover,
beyond the mere filing of the interpleader, Zidan admits in
paragraph 94 of the operative complaint that he was specifically
“aware of Kuo’s contentions and testimony in the various cases
[i.e., Jessie’s 2015 lawsuit and the 2016 interpleader action] that
Gary was somehow the owner of the fifty percent interest in
Global Valley” but did not believe Kuo because he thought Kuo
lacked credibility. Regardless of Zidan’s views about Kuo’s
credibility, this awareness of an ostensible adversary’s position
(and a seemingly favorable one at that) would have put any
reasonable person “on inquiry” to investigate the accuracy of that
9
position.7 (See, e.g., Grisham v. Philip Morris USA, Inc. (2007) 40
Cal.4th 723, 745 [“A plaintiff whose complaint shows on its face
that his claim would be barred without the benefit of the
discovery rule must specifically plead facts to show (1) the time
and manner of discovery and (2) the inability to have made
earlier discovery despite reasonable diligence”].)
The trial court was therefore correct to sustain defendants’
demurrer. There being no argument that further leave to amend
should have been granted, we need not address that issue.
7
Confronted with these allegations in the operative
complaint itself that defeat application of the discovery rule,
plaintiffs chiefly rely on Bastian v. County of San Luis Obispo
(1988) 199 Cal.App.3d 520, a case that holds a plaintiff’s “cause of
action is preserved when, despite diligent investigation, he is
blamelessly ignorant of the cause of his injuries.” (Id. at 529.)
The circumstances here are dissimilar to those in Bastian
because plaintiffs allege no facts showing they diligently
investigated their claims.
10
DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed. Defendants are awarded costs
on appeal.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
BAKER, Acting P. J.
We concur:
MOOR, J.
KIM (D.), J.
11
Ti chiedi come si applica questo testo alla tua situazione?
Consulenza gratuita, senza impegno
Descrivi la tua situazione. Il nostro team ti ricontatterà via e-mail per la tua consulenza.
Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude
Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.