CourtListener 10272518•Martin v. Brazell CA1/5
Testo completo
Filed 11/12/24 Martin v. Brazell CA1/5
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication or
ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FIRST APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION FIVE
EBONEE S. MARTIN, et al.,
Plaintiffs and Appellants, A169770
v. (Solano County Super. Ct.
No. CU23-00315)
RONALD BRAZELL, et al.,
Defendants and Respondents.
Plaintiffs Ebonee S. Martin and Shronna Martin (collectively,
plaintiffs) appeal from the trial court’s order sustaining the demurrer of
defendants and respondents Ronald Brazell and Terry L. Brazell (collectively,
defendants) without leave to amend. The court held that plaintiffs’ action
was time-barred because the complaint was filed 11 days after the two-year
statute of limitations expired. We disagree. Plaintiffs timely presented their
complaint for filing but had to re-file it after the clerk rejected their first
filing on the ground that the civil case cover sheet was defective. Plaintiffs
contend that their action is not time-barred because the clerk was required to
file the complaint when they initially submitted it for filing. We agree and
reverse.
1
I. BACKGROUND
On March 7, 2023, plaintiffs submitted a complaint for negligence and
wrongful death to the superior court clerk for filing. The complaint alleged
March 11, 2021 as the date of loss. A summons and civil case cover sheet
accompanied the complaint. The clerk file-stamped the complaint as received
on March 7, 2023. On March 14, 2023, the clerk returned these documents to
plaintiffs with a notice informing them that only one box instead of two
should have been checked in a section of the civil case cover sheet. Plaintiffs
corrected the purported error and refiled the complaint on March 22, 2023.
Defendants filed a demurrer, contending that plaintiffs’ entire action
was time-barred because the complaint was filed 11 days after the applicable
two-year statute of limitations had expired on March 11, 2023. Plaintiffs
countered that it would be unfair for the trial court to find their claims
untimely because they submitted their complaint for filing before the
limitations period ran and that submission was only rejected due to a defect
in the civil case cover sheet. Plaintiffs did not, however, cite any legal
authorities in their opposition. The court agreed with defendants and
sustained the demurrer without leave to amend. Plaintiffs timely appealed.1
II. DISCUSSION
We review an order sustaining a demurrer de novo and exercise our
independent judgment as to whether the complaint states a cause of action as
a matter of law. (Moore v. Regents of University of California (1990)
1 As a preliminary matter, we remind plaintiffs that an order
sustaining a demurrer is not directly appealable; the appeal must be taken
from the subsequent judgment of dismissal. Defendants do not, however,
challenge the propriety of the appeal. We therefore deem the order
sustaining the demurrer as incorporating a judgment of dismissal in the
interests of justice. (Conley v. Roman Catholic Archbishop (2000)
85 Cal.App.4th 1126, 1130.)
2
51 Cal.3d 120, 125.) This extends “even as to matters not expressly ruled
upon by the trial court.” (Hayter Trucking, Inc. v. Shell Western E&P, Inc.
(1993) 18 Cal.App.4th 1, 13.)
As an initial matter, defendants contend that plaintiffs cannot present
any new authorities or theories for the first time on appeal. We disagree.
“An appellate court may [] consider new theories on appeal from the
sustaining of a demurrer” because “[a] demurrer is directed to the face of a
complaint [citation] and [] raises only questions of law.” (B&P Dev. Corp. v.
City of Saratoga (1986) 185 Cal.App.3d 949, 959.) Accordingly, we exercise
our discretion and consider plaintiffs’ new arguments.
As plaintiffs point out, California Rules of Court, rule 3.220,
subdivision (c) requires that a court clerk file a complaint even if it is
accompanied by a defective or incomplete civil case cover sheet. Therefore,
the clerk erred when it refused to file plaintiffs’ complaint on March 7,
2023—the date plaintiff initially submitted it for filing. The appropriate
remedy for this error is to treat the complaint as filed on March 7, 2023. (See
Rojas v. Cutsforth (1998) 67 Cal.App.4th 774, 778 (Rojas); Mito v. Temple
Recycling Center Corp. (2010) 187 Cal.App.4th 276, 281 (Mito).) Thus,
plaintiffs’ complaint is timely because it should be deemed to have been filed
before the limitations period expired on March 11, 2023.
Defendants counter that the clerk’s error presents, at most, a tolling
issue. According to defendants, that error could only have tolled the statute
of limitations for the period of time that plaintiffs were not aware of the
clerk’s rejection of their initial filing. Thus, the error only tolled the
limitations period for seven days—from March 7, the date of the initial filing
by plaintiffs, until March 14, the date that the clerk issued the notice of
returned documents. Because plaintiffs waited until March 22—eight days
3
after the clerk sent the notice—to refile their complaint, defendants argue
that plaintiffs’ refiled complaint was untimely notwithstanding the clerk’s
error.2 But as of March 7, plaintiffs had taken every action necessary to
comply with the statute of limitations. Because plaintiffs did not need to do
anything else to avoid the statute of limitations bar, tolling serves no purpose
here. This is why the case law establishes that the clerk’s error in this case—
the mistaken rejection of a complaint based on a defect in the civil cover
sheet—presents a constructive filing and not a tolling issue. (Rojas, supra,
67 Cal.App.4th at p. 778; Mito, supra, 187 Cal.App.4th at p. 281.)
Maginn v. City of Glendale (1999) 72 Cal.App.4th 1102, the lone case
cited by defendants, is inapposite. In Maginn, the plaintiffs had to file their
complaint and serve the summons on or by August 12. (Id. at p. 1105.) On
August 12, the plaintiffs filed their complaint, but the clerk erroneously
waited until the next day to issue the summons. (Ibid.) The plaintiffs then
waited two additional two days before serving the summons on August 15.
(Id. at p. 1106.) The court of appeal held that “[t]his additional delay is fatal
to plaintiffs’ case and not excusable.” (Id. at p. 1108.) In rejecting the
plaintiffs’ tolling argument, the court held that even if the service deadline
was tolled for one day due to the clerk’s delay, the plaintiffs still “missed the
deadline for service by two days.” (Ibid.) By contrast, plaintiffs did not miss
any deadline. By timely submitting their complaint for filing on March 7,
2023, they did everything they needed to do to avoid the limitations bar.
Thus, plaintiffs’ failure to timely file their complaint was due solely to the
clerk’s error. Accordingly, we deem plaintiffs’ complaint to have been
2 We note that the clerk did not issue the notice of returned documents
to plaintiffs until after the limitations period had expired, and it is not clear
when plaintiffs actually received that notice.
4
constructively filed on March 7—four days before the expiration of the
limitation period.
III. DISPOSITION
The judgment is reversed and remanded, with directions to the trial
court to overrule the demurrer and to treat the complaint as filed on March
7, 2023. Plaintiffs are awarded their costs on appeal.
CHOU, J.
We concur.
SIMONS, Acting P.J.
BURNS, J.
(A169770)
5
Ti chiedi come si applica questo testo alla tua situazione?
Consulenza gratuita, senza impegno
Descrivi la tua situazione. Il nostro team ti ricontatterà via e-mail per la tua consulenza.
Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude
Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.