In re W.M. CA2/4

CourtListener 10266162Calctapp6 nov 2024

Testo completo

Filed 11/6/24 In re W.M. CA2/4
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS

California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION FOUR

In re W.M., a Person Coming B336574
Under the Juvenile Court Law.
(Los Angeles County
LOS ANGELES COUNTY Super. Ct. No. 21LJJP00396C)
DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN
AND FAMILY SERVICES,

Plaintiff and Respondent,

v.

M.M.,

Defendant and Appellant.

APPEAL from order of the Superior Court of the County of
Los Angeles, Donald A. Buddle, Jr., Judge. Conditionally
Reversed in Part and Remanded.
Janelle B. Price, under appointment by the Court of
Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, Kim Nemoy,
Assistant County Counsel, and Navid Nakhjavani, Principal
Deputy County Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.

______________________________________________

W.M. (born 2022) was declared a dependent shortly after
her birth. M.M. (mother) appeals from the order terminating her
parental rights. Mother contends the Los Angeles County
Department of Children and Family Services (DCFS) and the
juvenile court failed to comply with the inquiry and notice
provisions of the Indian Child Welfare Act (ICWA, 25 U.S.C.
§ 1900, et seq.) and related California law, the California Indian
Child Welfare Act (Cal-ICWA; Welf. & Inst. Code,1 § 224 et seq.).
The juvenile court found it had no reason to know that ICWA
applied to W.M., relying on denials of Indian2 ancestry from both
parents and three other relatives. However, DCFS did not ask
multiple known extended family members about possible Indian
ancestry. We conditionally reverse and remand.

BACKGROUND
As the parties are familiar with the facts and procedural
history of the case, we do not restate those details in full here.

1 Unless otherwise specified, subsequent statutory references are
to the Welfare and Institutions Code.
2 “[B]ecause ICWA uses the term ‘Indian,’ we do the same for
consistency, even though we recognize that other terms, such as
‘Native American’ or ‘indigenous,’ are preferred by many.” (In re
Benjamin M. (2021) 70 Cal.App.5th 735, 739, fn. 1.)

2
Below, we discuss only the facts and history as needed to resolve
the issue presented on appeal.
In a separate dependency case, the juvenile court sustained
a section 300 petition alleging that W.M.’s father, Daniel M.
(father), sexually abused W.M.’s half-sister. The day after
jurisdiction was terminated, W.M. was born, and DCFS received
a referral for W.M.
Before W.M. was removed from mother and father in
February 2022, DCFS spoke with them and several relatives. A
social worker interviewed maternal great-grandmother, maternal
step-grandmother (Kym S.), and one maternal aunt (Teresa S.)
but did not ask them about possible Indian ancestry. Parents
were asked to identify relatives with whom W.M. could be placed.
During these conversations, the parents identified paternal
grandmother (MaryAnn B.),3 her husband (Jonathan), and two
paternal aunts, one in California and another in Indiana. A
social worker spoke with paternal grandmother but did not
question her about possible Indian ancestry.
At the detention hearing in March 2022, the juvenile court
acknowledged the parents’ Parental Notifications of Indian
Status indicating they had no Indian ancestry. The juvenile
court found no reason to believe or know W.M. was an Indian
child and did not order notice to any tribe or the Bureau of Indian
Affairs.
The juvenile court sustained a section 300 petition that
alleged, among other things, father’s sexual abuse of W.M.’s half-
sister and mother’s failure to protect W.M. from father. During

3 Mother refers to MaryAnn B. as MaryAnn M. and describes her
as W.M.’s paternal grandmother. For consistency, we will refer to her
as MaryAnn B.

3
the reunification period, DCFS filed reports detailing parents’
visits. An entry dated July 28, 2022 states, “Mom also talked to
[W.M.] about the many aunts that she has. Mom named
[K]rystal, Jen, T[ ]eresa, Michelle, and other relatives.” 4
Reunification services were terminated in early 2023, and a
permanency planning review hearing was set. In January 2023,
DCFS spoke with maternal aunt Krystal D. about the possibility
of placing W.M. with her, but no questions were asked about
possible Indian heritage. In June 2023, DCFS filed “an updated
ICWA inquiry” stating that W.M.’s maternal grandmother was
interviewed, and when asked if she had Indian heritage, her
response was “‘Not that I am aware of.’”
In August 2023, DCFS prepared and filed an attorney order
that stated: “DCFS shall interview/attempt to interview all
extended family members, including but not limited to, Maternal
Great Grandmother (Virginia B.), Maternal Aunt (Teresa S.),
Paternal Aunt (Michell [sic] A.), and Paternal Uncle (Steve A.),
about whether the child is, or may be, an Indian child as required
by WIC section 224.2, subd. (b).” The order also stated that
DCFS would “document all its efforts and submit a written report
on the results of the interviews/attempts to interview all
extended family members” before the permanency planning
hearing. The juvenile court signed the order on August 17, 2023.
On August 25, 2023, DCFS filed a report with “Updated
ICWA Information.” It reported that paternal aunt (who
identified herself as Michelle V.) and spouse (who identified
himself as Steve V.) stated they were unaware of whether they or

4 Maternal aunt Krystal D. is sometimes identified in the record
as Crystal D. and Crystal D-G. For consistency, we will refer to her as
Krystal D.

4
W.M. had Indian ancestry. DCFS reported a voicemail had been
left for maternal aunt Teresa S. requesting a return call. In a
mid-September 2023 report, DCFS provided “ICWA Updates”
stating that both parents were asked for any new information
regarding Indian ancestry, and both reported they had none.
DCFS filed no other report about ICWA inquiries before the
permanency planning hearing.
At an initial permanency planning hearing, the juvenile
court did not make a finding that DCFS had interviewed all
available extended family members, but it found it did “not have
a reason to know that ICWA applies” as to mother or father. A
continued permanency planning hearing was held in April 2024,
and the juvenile court terminated parental rights.
Mother timely appealed from the order terminating her
parental rights.5

DISCUSSION
Mother contends DCFS’s inquiry was insufficient because it
did not interview all extended family members about potential
Indian ancestry. DCFS concedes its inquiry was limited to
mother, father, maternal grandmother, one paternal aunt, and
her spouse, but it argues the juvenile court’s finding that ICWA
did not apply should nevertheless be affirmed.

5 Although the notice of appeal refers to an order denying a
section 388 petition, mother has not discussed this order in her briefs,
and thus, has forfeited any claims of error. (Christoff v. Union Pacific
Railroad Co. (2005) 134 Cal.App.4th 118, 125.)

5
A. Governing Law
Congress enacted ICWA “to promote the stability and
security of Indian tribes and families by establishing minimum
standards for removal of Indian children from their families and
placement of such children ‘in foster or adoptive homes which will
reflect the unique values of Indian culture . . . .’” (In re Levi U.
(2000) 78 Cal.App.4th 191, 195, quoting 25 U.S.C. § 1902.) ICWA
recognizes that ‘“the tribe has an interest in the child which is
distinct from but on a parity with the interest of the parents.”’
[Citation.].” (Dwayne P. v. Superior Court (2002) 103 Cal.App.4th
247, 253.)
“ICWA provides as to dependency proceedings, ‘[W]here the
court knows or has reason to know that an Indian child is
involved, the party seeking . . . termination of parental rights
to . . . an Indian child shall notify the parent or Indian custodian
and the Indian child’s tribe, by registered mail with return
receipt requested, of the pending proceedings and of their right of
intervention.’” (In re Antonio R. (2022) 76 Cal.App.5th 421, 428
(Antonio R.), citing 25 U.S.C. § 1912(a).) “California law
similarly requires notice to the Indian tribe and the parent, legal
guardian, or Indian custodian if the court or the Department
‘knows or has reason to know’ the proceeding concerns an Indian
child.” (Ibid., § 224.3, subd. (a); Cal. Rules of Court, rule
5.481(c)(1).) “The notice requirement is at the heart of ICWA
because it ‘enables a tribe to determine whether the child is an
Indian child and, if so, whether to intervene in or exercise
jurisdiction over the proceeding.’ [Citation.]” (Id. at p. 429; see
25 U.S.C. § 1912(a); § 224.3, subd. (d).)
The juvenile court and DCFS “‘ha[d] an affirmative and
continuing duty to inquire whether a child for whom a petition

6
under Section 300 . . . may be or has been filed, is or may be an
Indian child.” (Antonio R., supra, 76 Cal.App.5th at p. 429,
quoting § 224.2, subd. (a).) “‘The continuing duty to inquire
whether a child is or may be an Indian child “can be divided into
three phases: the initial duty to inquire, the duty of further
inquiry, and the duty to provide formal ICWA notice.”’
[Citation.]” (Ibid.)
“‘The duty to inquire begins with initial contact (§ 224.2,
subd. (a)) and obligates the juvenile court and child protective
agencies to ask all relevant involved individuals whether the
child may be an Indian child. (§ 224.2, subds. (a)–(c)).’
[Citation.]” (Antonio R., supra, 76 Cal.App.5th at p. 429.)
Section 224.2, subdivision (b) imposes on DCFS a duty of inquiry
that includes, “‘but is not limited to, asking the child, parents,
legal guardian, Indian custodian, extended family members,
others who have an interest in the child, and the party reporting
child abuse or neglect, whether the child is, or may be, an Indian
child . . . .’” (Id. at pp. 429–430; see Cal. Rules of Court, rule
5.481(a)(1).) “Under ICWA, the term ‘extended family member’ is
‘defined by the law or custom of the Indian child’s tribe or, in the
absence of such law or custom, shall be a person who has reached
the age of eighteen and who is the Indian child’s grandparent,
aunt or uncle, brother or sister, brother-in-law or sister-in-law,
niece or nephew, first or second cousin, or stepparent.’” (Id. at
p. 430, quoting 25 U.S.C. § 1903(2); see § 224.1, subd. (c).)
A “juvenile court’s fact-specific determination that an
inquiry is adequate, proper, and duly diligent is ‘a
quintessentially discretionary function’ [citation] subject to a
deferential standard of review.” (In re Dezi C. (2024) 16 Cal.5th
1112, 1141 (Dezi C.), citing § 224.2, subd. (i)(2).) “‘On a well-

7
developed record, the court has relatively broad discretion to
determine whether the agency’s inquiry was proper, adequate,
and duly diligent on the specific facts of the case. However, the
less developed the record, the more limited that discretion
necessarily becomes.’ [Citation.]” (In re Kenneth D. (2024) 16
Cal.5th 1087, 1101–1102.) In this district, we generally review
the juvenile court’s ICWA findings for substantial evidence, and
when the material facts at issue are undisputed, we review
independently whether ICWA requirements have been satisfied.
(In re J.K. (2022) 83 Cal.App.5th 498, 504.)
“If, upon review, a juvenile court’s findings that an inquiry
was adequate and proper and ICWA does not apply are found to
be supported by sufficient evidence and record documentation as
required by California law (rule 5.481(a)(5)), there is no error and
conditional reversal would not be warranted even if the agency
did not inquire of everyone who has an interest in the child.”
(Dezi C., supra, 16 Cal.5th at p. 1141].) “On the other hand, if the
inquiry is inadequate, conditional reversal is required so the
agency can cure the error and thereby safeguard the rights of
tribes, parents, and the child.” (Ibid.)

B. Sufficiency of DCFS’s Inquiry
Mother argues that DCFS’s inquiry was deficient because it
failed to ask multiple known relatives about possible Indian
ancestry, including maternal step-grandmother, paternal
grandmother and her spouse, a maternal aunt, a second maternal
aunt and her fiancé, and two paternal aunts. We agree.
Inquiries have been held insufficient where the agency
failed to ask the dependent child’s known extended family
members about possible Indian ancestry. (See In re L.B. (2023)

8
98 Cal.App.5th 512, 519 [“[N]otwithstanding the availability of
and contact with multiple members of L.B.’s extended family,
there seems to have been no attempt to ask those relatives about
L.B.’s ancestry. For that reason, the inquiry was inadequate as a
matter of law . . . .”]; In re J.W. (2022) 81 Cal.App.5th 384, 389
[Department “did not ask Mother’s extended family members
about their Indian ancestry, despite having contact with
maternal grandmother, uncle, and aunt. This was a violation of
California law”].)
DCFS did not make ancestry inquiries of four extended
family members with whom social workers had spoken. Before
the detention hearing, social workers spoke with maternal step-
grandmother and one maternal aunt, Teresa S., but did not ask
them about possible Indian ancestry. Social workers also spoke
to paternal grandmother and a second maternal aunt, Krystal D.,
about placement of the child but did not ask them any ancestry
questions, either. DCFS does not dispute these persons were
statutory extended family members or that they were not asked
about their heritage.
DCFS asserts that W.M.’s parents, maternal grandmother,
and one paternal aunt and her spouse “reliably answered” the
question of whether there was reason to believe W.M. was an
Indian child. It further argues that having to ask additional
relatives would have been “‘absurd at best and impossible at
worst.’ [Citation.] (In re E.W. (2023) 91 Cal.App.5th 314.)”
DCFS’s position “ignores the express obligation that section
224.2, subdivision (b), imposes on [DCFS] to inquire of a child’s
extended family members—regardless of whether the parents
deny Indian ancestry.” (Antonio R., supra, 76 Cal.App.5th at
p. 431; In re S.S. (2023) 90 Cal.App.5th 694, 701 [“[E]xtended

9
family members can have tribal information the parents lack, or
have forgotten, or refuse to divulge”].) DCFS is correct that the
general statutory duty “does not require inquiry with every adult
living extended family member,” and is “not intended to obligate
county welfare departments to search for possible Indian
ancestry without regard to cost or other practical considerations.”
(In re H.B. (2023) 92 Cal.App.5th 711, 720 (H.B.).) However, in
this case, DCFS actually spoke to four relatives without inquiring
about possible Indian ancestry, and it also failed to make
inquiries other relatives who were identified during the case.6
(See In re S.S., supra, 90 Cal.App.5th at p. 703 [“[W]hen [social
workers] already are having or planning a conversation, how long
does this additional question take: ‘Might this child be an Indian
child?’”].)
As the result of DCFS’s incomplete inquiry, there is a
dearth of information about the ancestry of three of W.M.’s four
grandparents. Paternal grandmother and paternal grandfather,
though contacted or identified during the investigation, were not
asked about their ancestry. On mother’s side, no one furnished
information about the maternal grandfather’s heritage, though
DCFS could have asked two maternal aunts who were contacted
during its investigation. (Compare, H.B., supra, 92 Cal.App.5th
at p. 721 [DCFS fulfilled duty of inquiry where it “inquired about
Indian ancestry with representatives from both sides of two
generational levels of H.B.’s family” and “contacted every person

6 Although not mentioned by mother, DCFS’s reports reveal
additional relatives who were apparently not asked about possible
Indian ancestry. Father disclosed a second paternal aunt who lived in
Indiana, and mother disclosed an aunt named “Jen.” Father also
reported speaking to paternal grandfather in August 2022.

10
its interviewees identified as a likely source of information about
ancestry”].) We conclude DCFS’s inquiry was inadequate to
discharge its duty of inquiry under section 224.2.
DCFS argues that, even if its inquiry was inadequate, any
error should be considered harmless. However, we cannot
conclude DCFS’s failure to ask known extended relatives about
their Indian ancestry was harmless in light of Dezi C., supra, 16
Cal.5th 1112, which was published by our high court while this
appeal was pending. Dezi C. resolved a split of authority
regarding “whether a child welfare agency’s failure to make the
statutorily required initial inquiry under California’s heightened
ICWA requirements constitutes reversible error.” (Id. at
p. 1125.) Our high court concluded, “When a Cal-ICWA inquiry is
inadequate, it is impossible to ascertain whether the agency’s
error is prejudicial.” (Id. at p. 1136.) Our high court set out a
bright line rule under which “error resulting in an inadequate
initial Cal-ICWA inquiry requires conditional reversal with
directions for the child welfare agency to comply with the inquiry
requirement of section 224.2, document its inquiry in compliance
with rule 5.481(a)(5), and when necessary, comply with the notice
provision of section 224.3.” (Ibid.)
Because we conclude DCFS’s inquiry was insufficient, we
must conditionally reverse the order terminating parental rights.
(Dezi C., supra, 16 Cal.5th at p. 1152.) “It is only by conditionally
reversing that we can ascertain whether error in the inquiry is
prejudicial.” (Ibid.)

11
DISPOSITION
The order terminating parental rights is conditionally
reversed. We remand to the juvenile court with instructions to
DCFS and the court to comply with the inquiry, notice, and
documentation requirements of ICWA. If the court finds an
adequate further inquiry and due diligence has been conducted
and concludes ICWA does not apply (§ 224.2, subd. (i)(2)), then it
shall reinstate the order terminating parental rights.

MORI, Acting P. J.
We concur:

ZUKIN, J.

**SIGGINS, J.

** Retired Presiding Justice of the Court of Appeal, First Appellate
District, assigned by the Chief Justice pursuant to article VI, section 6
of the California Constitution.

12

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.