CourtListener 10045081•In re A.Q. CA2/5
Testo completo
Filed 8/15/24 In re A.Q. CA2/5
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION FIVE
In re A.Q., et al., Persons B333739
Coming Under the Juvenile (Los Angeles County
Court Law. Super. Ct. No.
20CCJP00681)
LOS ANGELES COUNTY
DEPARTMENT OF
CHILDREN AND FAMILY
SERVICES,
Plaintiff and
Respondent,
v.
D.B.,
Defendant and
Appellant.
APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of the County
of Los Angeles, Gabriella Shapiro, Judge Pro Tempore. Affirmed.
Jack A. Love, under appointment by the Court of Appeal,
for Defendant and Appellant.
Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, Kim Nemoy,
Assistant County Counsel, Aileen Wong, Senior Deputy County
Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
________________________
I. INTRODUCTION
D.B. (mother) appeals from the juvenile court’s order
denying her petition under Welfare and Institutions Code section
388.1 According to mother, the court abused its discretion by
denying the petition because her evidence in support constituted
a prima facie showing of changed circumstances and that the
requested change in order was in the best interests of her
children. We affirm.
II. FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
A. Detention, Jurisdiction, and Disposition
On January 25, 2020, the Los Angeles County Department
of Children and Family Services (Department) received a referral
on behalf of the children, A.Q. (born in 2018) and N.Q. (born in
1 All further statutory references are to the Welfare and
Institutions Code unless otherwise indicated.
2
2019). The caller reported that mother had sustained injuries
when father, during an argument, pushed her out of a car. The
police officer who interviewed mother after the incident expressed
concerns about her mental health. Mother admitted to the officer
that she had postpartum depression, oppositional defiant
disorder, and anxiety. She also admitted that she was not taking
medication. Father reported that mother’s mental health
problems had required hospitalization in the past and the police
had responded to the family home at least 10 times due to those
issues.
On January 28, 2020, mother admitted that she had a
history of domestic violence with father. She also conceded that
she had been prescribed anxiety medication, which she did not
take, and that she had been placed on a 72-hour hospital hold six
months earlier.
On January 31, 2020, the juvenile court issued a removal
order and the Department placed the children with maternal
aunt.
On February 4, 2020, the Department filed a petition under
section 300, alleging that the children were at risk of serious
physical harm. In paragraphs a-1 and b-1, the Department
alleged that mother and father had a history of engaging in
violent altercations and that their behavior endangered the
children. In paragraph b-2, the Department alleged that mother
had a history of mental problems, including anxiety, postpartum
depression, delusions, and homicidal ideation, which rendered
her incapable of caring for the children and endangered them.
And, in paragraph b-3, the Department alleged that mother had
a history of substance abuse, including methamphetamine, and
was a current user of illicit drugs and marijuana, all of which
3
rendered her incapable of caring for the children and endangered
them.
On February 5, 2020, the juvenile court detained the
children, removed them from the parents’ custody, and granted
the parents monitored visitation.
The Department filed a jurisdiction/disposition report on
March 6, 2020, relating the following facts. On February 27,
2020, mother denied having mental health issues or being
prescribed psychotropic medication. She admitted, however,
methamphetamine use “off and on” since age 18 which “at its
peak” reached three times a week. She quit using
methamphetamine when she was 22, did not attend any
treatment programs, and was a current daily user of marijuana.
Mother tested positive for marijuana on January 31, 2020, but
negative for all substances on February 28, 2020.
In a July 7, 2020, last minute information for the court, the
Department reported that mother was participating in a
parenting program and had completed six to eight sessions. She
tested negative for drugs seven times from March 17 through
June 25, 2020. But she failed to drug test on April 5 and May 4,
2020. In March 2020, mother completed an emergency domestic
violence shelter program and enrolled in outpatient treatment;
she was also participating in substance abuse groups, domestic
violence classes, parenting education, and individual counseling.
At the July 7, 2020, jurisdiction/disposition hearing, the
juvenile court sustained the section 300 petition against mother.
The court declared the children dependents of the court, ordered
them removed from parental custody, and ordered family
reunification services for mother, including a full drug/alcohol
program with aftercare services, and weekly random or on-
4
demand drug/alcohol testing. It also ordered mother to
participate in a domestic violence support group, parenting
education, mental health counseling including taking prescribed
psychotropic medication, individual counseling, and medication
management. The court granted mother monitored visitation
with the children, appointed an Evidence Code section 730
evaluator to examine her, and set the matter for a six-month
review hearing.
B. Reunification Services
At the January 5, 2021, review hearing, the juvenile court
found that mother was in compliance with her case plan, ordered
further family reunification services, allowed mother
unmonitored visitation, and set the matter for a twelve-month
review hearing.
On April 13, 2021, the juvenile court granted the
Department’s section 388 petition and ordered that mother’s
visits be monitored due to issues with her childcare during
visitation.
In a status review report filed June 17, 2021, the social
worker reported that mother tested negative for drugs and
alcohol 20 times from January 8 through May 28, 2021, with one
no show in March 2021. Mother also completed parenting and
domestic violence programs and participated in individual
therapy.
At the July 7, 2021, 12-month review hearing, the juvenile
court found that mother had made partial progress in her case
plan and ordered further reunification services for her.
5
In a report filed August 10, 2021, the social worker advised
that she had spoken with mother’s psychiatrist who informed her
that mother was diagnosed in December 2020 with an
adjustment disorder with mixed anxiety and depressed mood. In
May 2021, she was diagnosed with major depressive disorder and
depression for which she was prescribed two medications. But
mother informed the social worker that she was taking only one
medication.
On August 18, 2021, the juvenile court ordered that
mother’s visitation include one unmonitored visit each week for
two hours with each child.
By October 2021, the children had been placed with
paternal aunt.
At a December 2, 2021, progress hearing, a representative
of the Manchester Point Arena Band of Pomo Indians (the tribe)
made an appearance in juvenile court.
In a report filed on January 19, 2022, the social worker
advised that on January 1, 2022, she received an e-mail from
maternal aunt stating that, on New Year’s Eve, mother “got
belligerently drunk” and physically violent with the maternal
aunt and her friend. Mother bit maternal aunt and pulled her
hair. She also punched the aunt’s friend who was trying to calm
mother down. Maternal aunt also stated that mother had
recently been showing signs of delusional thoughts, aggression,
and paranoia. A visiting relative, who had witnessed mother’s
behavior in the past, stated that she had never seen her being
that aggressive and delusional. The police responded to the
incident. Mother initially ran away, but officers located and
arrested her.
6
On January 26, 2022, the Department filed a section 388
petition requesting that mother’s visitation be returned to
monitored status due to the incident on New Year’s Eve.
On January 28, 2022, the juvenile court held a hearing and
terminated family reunification services for mother, finding that
mother was not in substantial compliance with her court-ordered
case plan. The court also ordered mother’s visits to be monitored.
C. Section 366.26 Proceedings
In a February 15, 2022, interim review report, the social
worker reported that mother had monitored visits with the
children and that she called them every two to three days.
In a March 1, 2022, last minute information for the court,
the social worker reported that on February 28, 2022, she spoke
with mother’s therapist who advised that it had been challenging
getting in contact with mother. The last time the therapist spoke
with mother at length was in December 2021. On February 24,
2022, the parent and child interactive therapist told the social
worker that she had concerns about mother. At the last several
sessions, mother looked disheveled and she had arrived late two
times. Mother “seemed out of it” and had difficulty working with
both children.
On March 2, 2022, the juvenile court granted the
Department’s section 388 petition and ordered mother’s visitation
to take place in the Department office only.
On May 6, 2022, the juvenile court noted that the tribe
would be intervening, found that this was an ICWA2 case, and
2 Indian Child Welfare Act of 1978 (25 U.S.C. § 1901 et seq.).
7
ordered the Department to prepare a qualified expert witness
letter and work with the tribe to have the children enrolled.
In the May 20, 2022, status review report, the social worker
advised that the children remained in the care of paternal aunt.
The children were doing well in the home and had bonded with
paternal aunt and uncle. According to the social worker, paternal
aunt and uncle were interested in adopting the children.
The social worker further advised that on April 4, 2022, the
parent and child interactive therapist reported that mother had
not participated in therapy for several weeks. And, when she had
participated, she was unable to fully understand the therapist’s
explanation of parenting skills.
The social worker also reported that on April 3, 2022,
mother was arrested for vandalism. Two days later, on April 6,
2022, she was convicted of a felony assault with a deadly weapon
and sentenced to 180 days in jail with four years of probation.
Prior to mother’s incarceration, she was not visiting the children
regularly.
In a June 1, 2022, last minute information for the court, the
social worker reported that mother was released from custody on
the morning of May 28, 2022, but later that day she was arrested
for assault with a deadly weapon with possible great bodily
injury. She remained incarcerated.
At the June 1, 2022, section 366.26 hearing, the juvenile
court concluded that the permanent plan of adoption was
appropriate and continued the hearing.
In a September 14, 2022, last minute information for the
court, the social worker summarized the opinion of the qualified
expert witness as follows: In the expert’s opinion, there was clear
and convincing evidence that a causal relationship existed
8
between the conditions in the parents’ home and the likelihood
that continued custody of the children by either parent was likely
to result in serious emotional or physical damage to the children.
The expert also concurred with the Department’s
recommendation for a tribal customary adoption with paternal
aunt.
In a November 16, 2022, status review report, the social
worker advised that the children were doing well and bonded to
paternal aunt and uncle who were meeting their needs. The
social worker also advised that mother remained incarcerated
with no release date available. Paternal aunt confirmed that
mother called the children once every three days.
In a May 22, 2023, status review report, the social worker
reported that mother was released from incarceration in January
2023 and transferred to an inpatient substance abuse program.
Mother completed three months in a substance abuse
rehabilitation program and, in April 2023, she transferred to a
sober living program. She began having monitored visits with
the children every other weekend at the inpatient substance
abuse program and, when she transferred to the sober living
program, she had visits with the children at a park near the
program. Paternal aunt and uncle monitored the visits and did
not report any incidents.
In a November 15, 2023, status review report, the social
worker reported mother continued to reside in a sober living
program. She continued having monitored visits with the
children every other weekend on Sundays at a park. Paternal
aunt and uncle monitored the visits, did not report incidents, and
confirmed that mother behaved in an appropriate manner.
9
Mother told the social worker she loved the children and never
meant to hurt them; she wanted them to be safe and happy.
D. Section 388 Petition
On November 29, 2023, mother filed a section 388 petition,
requesting a change in the juvenile court’s order terminating her
reunification services and setting a section 366.26 hearing.
Mother requested the court to order further reunification
services, with liberalized visitation, or the return of custody over
the children. Mother described the changed circumstances, as
shown by her exhibits, as follows: She entered Prototypes on
April 10, 2023, and continued treatment at that facility through
the date of her petition. In that program, she participated in
treatment groups and individual substance abuse counseling, as
well as individual counseling, medication management, cognitive
behavioral therapy, and 12-step and anger management
programs. She had also received psychiatric services through
Prototypes since January 6, 2023. And, mother randomly drug
tested for the Department seven times from September 29
through November 27, 2023, with negative results. In addition to
detailing participation in services, mother asserted that she
visited consistently with the children.
Mother also alleged that the requested change in order
would be in the best interests of the children because she had
developed a protective capacity as their biological parent and she
had addressed the issues that brought this case to the juvenile
court, resulting in a reduced risk to their safety.
At the November 29, 2023, continued section 366.26
hearing, the juvenile court summarily denied mother’s section
10
388 petition, finding that mother failed to make a prima facie
showing of changed circumstances and that the change in order
would not serve the best interests of the children. The court then
continued the section 366.26 hearing to December 6, 2023.
E. Section 366.26 Hearing
At the December 6, 2023, section 366.26 hearing, following
the arguments of counsel, the juvenile court granted full faith
and credit to a tribal customary adoption order. The court noted
that the children had been in a stable placement with paternal
aunt and uncle for two years. The court also observed that, “[i]n
this particular case, the Department has worked hand-in-hand
with the [Indian tribe], and counsel, and the tribal social worker
to come up with an appropriate plan on behalf of these Indian[ ]
children and ensure continuity in their tribe and follow the
legislative intent to leave the children with family, if not with
[the] parents, and follow the exception afforded to Native
American tribes, which is to proceed to adoption without actually
terminating the parental rights of any individuals.” Pursuant to
the tribal customary adoption order, the juvenile court modified
the rights of the parents accordingly and designated the paternal
aunt and uncle as “as the holders of the children’s educational
rights and developmental decision-making rights, and also as
prospective adoptive parents . . . .”
On December 6, 2023, mother timely filed her notice of
appeal.
11
III. DISCUSSION
Mother contends the juvenile court abused its discretion by
denying her section 388 petition without an evidentiary hearing.
According to mother, the evidence attached to her petition
satisfied her prima facie burden by showing that she had been
sober and participating in a variety of services to address her
issues for the prior seven months and that additional
reunification services would be in the children’s best interests.
We disagree.
“Section 388 provides for modification of juvenile court
orders when the moving party presents new evidence or a change
of circumstances and demonstrates modification of the previous
order is in the child’s best interests. [Citations.] To obtain a
hearing on a section 388 petition, the parent must make a prima
facie showing as to both elements. [Citations.]
“The petition should be liberally construed in favor of
granting a hearing, but ‘[t]he prima facie requirement is not met
unless the facts alleged, if supported by evidence given credit at
the hearing, would sustain a favorable decision on the petition.’
[Citations.] . . . When determining whether the petition makes
the necessary showing, ‘the court may consider the entire factual
and procedural history of the case.’ [Citations.]” (In re Samuel A.
(2020) 55 Cal.App.5th 1, 6–7.)
When, as here, a section 388 petition is filed after family
reunification services have been terminated, the juvenile court’s
overriding concern is the children’s best interest. (In re
Stephanie M. (1994) 7 Cal.4th 295, 317.) The parent’s interests
in the care, custody, and companionship of the child are no longer
12
paramount; and the focus shifts to the needs of the child for
permanency and stability. (Ibid.)
“We review the summary denial of a section 388 petition for
abuse of discretion. [Citations.] . . . [W]hen the [juvenile] court’s
summary denial is based on a mistake of law on undisputed facts,
[however,] our review is de novo. [Citations.]” (In re Samuel A.,
supra, 55 Cal.App.5th at p. 7.)
The juvenile court did not abuse its discretion when it
summarily denied the section 388 petition. Mother had serious
and long-standing mental health and substance abuse issues,
which contributed to her history of domestic violence with father
and other family members. She had a history of anxiety,
postpartum depression, and delusions, and had been hospitalized,
including involuntarily, for her mental health issues. She also
had a history of not taking medication.
During the reunification period, mother participated in
services to address her mental health, substance abuse, and
domestic violence issues and was generally in compliance with
her case plan. But, in late December 2021, almost two years
after the incident that brought the family under the jurisdiction
of the juvenile court, mother, who had been showing renewed
signs of delusion, aggression, and paranoia, became intoxicated
and assaulted maternal aunt and a friend resulting in her arrest.
Three months later, in April 2022, she was arrested again for
vandalism and then convicted on the pending assault charge and
sentenced to prison. By that time, mother had not participated in
therapy for several weeks and when she had participated, she
was unable to fully understand the therapist’s explanation of
necessary parenting skills. And, when she was released from
custody on the assault charge in late May 2022, she was almost
13
immediately arrested again for assault with a deadly weapon.
She was not released from custody until January 2023 when she
again began participating in services to address her issues.
When mother’s recent seven-month participation in further
services is viewed in light of record as a whole, it does not support
her allegation of changed circumstances. By the time mother’s
reunification services were terminated on January 28, 2022, the
Department had already provided mother with 18 months of
reunification services, yet she continued to struggle with the
same issues concerning substance abuse and violence that had
plagued her for most of her life.
Moreover, even assuming mother had met her burden to
demonstrate a change in circumstance, mother did not make a
prima facie case that her requested relief would be in the
children’s best interest. By the time of the section 388 petition,
the children had been in a stable placement with paternal aunt
and uncle for over two years, and those caregivers had been
selected as the prospective adoptive parents. Mother had not
been the children’s primary caregiver since before January 2020,
that role being assumed at various times by father, maternal
aunt, and finally paternal aunt. Instead, mother’s contact with
the children during the four-year pendency of this case had been
limited to visitation, the majority of which was monitored. As the
court-appointed expert witness evaluator concluded, continued
custody of the children by either parent was likely to result in
serious emotional or physical damage to the children. Thus, it
was not unreasonable for the juvenile court to reject mother’s
assertion that further participation in reunification services
would operate to mitigate such risks in the future and conclude
that the children’s best interest would not be served by further
14
attempts at reunification and the resulting delay in
implementation of the permanent plan.
IV. DISPOSITION
The order denying the section 388 petition is affirmed.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
KIM, J.
We concur:
BAKER, Acting P. J.
MOOR, J.
15
Ti chiedi come si applica questo testo alla tua situazione?
Consulenza gratuita, senza impegno
Descrivi la tua situazione. Il nostro team ti ricontatterà via e-mail per la tua consulenza.
Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude
Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.