CourtListener 10015361•Howard v. Gurevich CA2/2
Testo completo
Filed 7/26/24 Howard v. Gurevich CA2/2
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION TWO
GEROLYN HOWARD, B330490
Plaintiff and Respondent,
(Los Angeles County
v. Super. Ct. No.
22STCP03304)
YELENA GUREVICH et al.,
Defendants and Appellants.
APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of Los
Angeles County. Gail Killefer, Judge. Affirmed.
Yelena Gurevich, in pro. per., and Lauren Rode, in pro.
per., for Defendants and Appellants.
Law Offices of Soheila Azizi, Soheila Azizi and Joshua
Edmondson for Plaintiff and Respondent.
__________________________________________
An arbitrator found a law firm and two attorneys had
committed legal malpractice in representing a homeowner in a
suit against her mortgage lender for breach of a loan modification
agreement. The arbitrator awarded the homeowner $771,780.
The trial court confirmed the arbitrator’s award. The two
attorneys appealed. Because the alleged errors they cite are
neither supported by the record nor cognizable grounds for
overturning an arbitration award, we affirm.
FACTS AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
I. Facts
Howard was prompted by financial problems to have
Veritas Law Group assist her in obtaining a loan modification of
her mortgage payment to lender Seterus, Inc. Believing her loan
modification had been successful, Howard began making reduced
monthly payments to the lender. Months later, a Seterus, Inc.
representative notified Howard that if certain documents were
not received, a foreclosure sale would proceed.
Howard retained Consumer Action Law Group (CALG), a
consumer litigation firm. On June 19, 2015, on behalf of Howard,
CALG sued Seterus, Inc. for breaching a modification agreement
and proceeding with a foreclosure sale. Attorneys Lauren Rode
and Yelena Gurevich (appellants) handled Howard’s case.
On June 26, 2015, CALG received a letter from Seterus,
Inc., stating the loan modification could proceed and the
foreclosure sale would be cancelled if Howard signed and
returned the enclosed documents. Howard was never made
aware of the documents; she never signed and returned them to
the lender. Howard’s house was sold in foreclosure. Howard did
not discover the Seterus, Inc. letter until after appellants and
CALG had terminated their attorney-client relationship with her.
2
II. Procedural History
A. Demand for Arbitration
In her signed retainer agreement with CALG, Howard
agreed to binding arbitration under the rules of the American
Arbitration Association (AAA) of any disputes that could not be
resolved within a reasonable time.
Howard filed a demand for arbitration with the AAA,
alleging CALG and appellants committed legal malpractice and
breached their fiduciary duty in representing Howard against
Seterus, Inc. In response, CALG and appellants filed a
counterclaim with the AAA for unpaid legal fees.
The AAA appointed Anita Rae Shapiro to preside over the
arbitration. Arbitrator Shapiro held a preliminary management
hearing. Howard and appellants were represented by counsel.
Following discovery, the arbitration hearing was conducted for
two days. Experts for both sides and Howard testified. The
hearing was recessed until Monday, November 8, 2021.
B. Howard’s Request for the Arbitrator’s Removal
Before the hearing resumed on November 8, 2021, the AAA
e-mailed the parties that Howard had requested the replacement
of her counsel and the removal of Arbitrator Shapiro. The AAA’s
e-mail included a copy of Howard’s request. In a November 8,
2021 letter, the AAA also informed the parties that: (1) Shapiro
would “not be copied on any correspondence related to the
disclosure or the arbitrator’s continued service”; and (2) “At this
time, we request comments from [CALG and appellants]
regarding the above-referenced communication [Howard’s
request]. Comments are to be received by the [AAA] on or before
November 15, 2021. Absent a response to the contrary, we will
presume your agreement with [Howard’s] position.”
3
At the November 8, 2021 hearing, CALG and appellants
objected to Howard’s request as prejudicial. Ultimately,
Howard’s current attorney withdrew as counsel of record, and
Arbitrator Shapiro ordered Howard to represent herself and
continued the hearing to December 7, 2021, to allow Howard to
retain new counsel. Shapiro also denied Howard’s request for
removal and advised the parties and the AAA that she would not
stop serving as arbitrator.
Appellants and CALG failed to respond to the AAA’s
request by the November 15, 2021 deadline. In a November 18,
2021 letter, the AAA advised the parties that “inasmuch as
[Howard’s] objection was unopposed,” Arbitrator Shapiro was
removed as arbitrator in the matter. The AAA also indicated it
intended to appoint a new arbitrator.
Appellants and CALG repeatedly wrote to the AAA on
November 18, 2021 and thereafter, urging that Arbitrator
Shapiro be reinstated. The AAA declined, and explained that by
removing Shapiro, it was properly adhering to the AAA’s rules
and procedures for consumer arbitrations.
On December 10, 2021, appellants and CALG filed a motion
with the AAA to enforce Arbitrator Shapiro’s November 8, 2021
order. They argued Shapiro should continue to serve as
arbitrator and a third day of arbitration should be scheduled.
The AAA responded that it “does not have the authority to rule
on any motions.”
C. Appointment of a New Arbitrator and the
Arbitration Hearing
The AAA appointed George J. Kovacevich to serve as the
new arbitrator without objection. The arbitration hearing lasted
two days. Arbitrator Kovacevich considered the pleadings, briefs,
4
and evidence presented and issued a written ruling. Kovacevich
found appellants liable and CALG vicariously liable for legal
malpractice. In reaching this conclusion, Kovacevich found
Howard’s witnesses were more credible than appellants’ and
CALG’s witnesses on the “core issue” of the circumstances
surrounding the letter from Seterus, Inc. Arbitrator Kovacevich
found CALG and appellants jointly and severally liable to
Howard and awarded her $771,780 in damages, including
emotional distress damages and attorney fees. Kovacevich
denied the counterclaim for legal fees.
D. Post-arbitration Proceedings in Superior Court
Howard filed a petition to confirm the arbitration award.
Appellants filed a petition to vacate the arbitration award.
The trial court simultaneously denied appellants’ petition
to vacate and granted Howard’s petition to enforce the
arbitration award, including the award for emotional distress
damages, which was separately challenged. The court
acknowledged the scope of judicial review of an arbitration award
was limited by Code of Civil Procedure section 1286.2. The court
ruled there were no statutorily authorized grounds for vacating
the award and the arbitrator’s findings supported the award of
emotional distress damages.
The trial court granted appellants’ motion to stay
enforcement of the judgment pending appeal. Appellants timely
filed a notice of appeal.1
DISCUSSION
Appellants argue the trial court erred in denying their
motion to vacate the arbitrator’s award because (1) the AAA
1 CALG is not a party to this appeal.
5
exceeded its powers and violated its own rules by failing to give
appellants the opportunity to be heard before removing
Arbitrator Shapiro; (2) appellants were prejudiced by Arbitrator
Kovacevic’s refusal to allow them to present material evidence at
the shortened arbitration hearing; and (3) the award must be
vacated because appellants’ motion to enforce Arbitrator
Shapiro’s November 8, 2021 order is still pending. We
independently review a trial court’s denial of a motion to vacate
(Richey v. AutoNation, Inc. (2015) 60 Cal.4th 909, 918, fn. 1) and
conclude the trial court’s order denying appellants’ motion to
vacate was correct for four independent reasons.
First, the California Arbitration Act (Code Civ. Proc.,
§ 1280 et seq.) carefully delineates the grounds on which an
arbitrator’s award may be vacated. Appellants’ do not dispute
that an arbitration award may be judicially vacated under Code
of Civil Procedure section 1286.2, subdivision (a) only if it was
procured by (1) corruption, fraud, or other undue means;
(2) corruption on the part of an arbitrator; (3) prejudicial
misconduct of a neutral arbitrator; (4) action by the arbitrator in
excess of his or her power; (5) prejudicial refusal to postpone the
hearing or to hear material evidence; (6) prejudicial conduct
contrary to the California Arbitration Act on the part of the
arbitrator; or (7) failure of the arbitrator to disqualify himself or
herself when required to do so. (See Richey v. AutoNation, Inc.,
supra, 60 Cal.4th at p. 916.) We agree with the trial court that
none of these grounds for vacating the arbitration award exist
here.
Second, contrary to their claim, the AAA did not violate
AAA Consumer Arbitration rule R-19 by failing to allow
6
appellants to be heard prior to removing Arbitrator Shapiro.2
Rule R-19 provides: “(a) Any arbitrator shall be impartial and
independent and shall perform his or her duties carefully and in
good faith. The AAA may disqualify an arbitrator who shows [¶]
(1) partiality or lack of independence; [¶] (2) inability or refusal to
perform his or her duties with diligence and in good faith; or [¶]
(3) any grounds for disqualification provided by applicable law.
[¶] (b) If a party objects to the continued service of an arbitrator,
or if the AAA should so decide to raise the issue of whether the
arbitrator should continue on the case, the AAA will decide if the
arbitrator should be disqualified. After gathering the opinions of
the parties, the AAA will decide and that decision shall be final
and conclusive.”
The record shows the AAA solicited appellants to make
their objections known concerning Howard’s request. But
appellants did not respond by the deadline. Having forfeited any
objections by their own failure to act, appellants cannot now fault
2 Appellants also rely on AAA Consumer Arbitration rules
R-14 and R-23. Neither rule applies. Rule R-14 states: “(a) The
arbitrator shall have the power to rule on his or her own
jurisdiction, including any objections with respect to the
existence, scope, or validity of the arbitration agreement or to the
arbitrability of any claim or counterclaim. [¶] . . . [¶] (c) A party
must object to the jurisdiction of the arbitrator or to the
arbitrability of a claim or counterclaim no later than the filing of
the answering statement to the claim or counterclaim that gives
rise to the objection. The arbitrator may rule on such objections
as a preliminary matter or as part of the final award.” Rule R-23
gives the arbitrator the power to enforce the fair exchange of
information between the parties and to ensure orderly and
efficient proceedings.
7
the AAA. While the AAA complied with rule R-19, appellants
ignored it.
Third, to the extent appellants are contending Arbitrator
Kovacevich “exceed[ed] [his] powers” or “refus[ed] . . . to hear
evidence material to the controversy” by improperly excluding
appellants’ evidence (Code Civ. Proc., § 1286.2, subd. (a)(4)–(5)),
without a reporter’s transcript, any such evidentiary ruling
cannot be shown. Notably, appellants do not state what
“material facts” appellants were prevented from presenting or
how they were prejudiced as a result. In particular, as the
arbitrator explained, his decision turned largely on the credibility
of testimony concerning the delayed discovery of the Seterus, Inc.
letter. Appellants do not indicate what excluded evidence could
have bolstered their witnesses’ credibility. In any event, an
arbitrator does not exceed his or her powers by making an
“error[] of fact or law,” and thus does not exceed his or her powers
by making an erroneous evidentiary ruling. (Moncharsh v. Heily
& Blasé (1992) 3 Cal.4th 1, 6, 11; see Schlessinger v. Rosenfeld,
Meyer & Susman (1995) 40 Cal.App.4th 1096, 1110 [incorrect
evidentiary rulings do not exceed an arbitrator’s powers].)
Finally, appellants contend their December 10, 2021
motion is still pending before the AAA, which advised it lacked
the authority to rule on motions. In light of the decisions of
Arbitrator Kovacevich and the trial court, that motion is long
since moot.
8
DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed. Howard is entitled to recover
her costs on appeal.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED.
LUI, P. J.
We concur:
ASHMANN-GERST, J.
HOFFSTADT, J.
9
Ti chiedi come si applica questo testo alla tua situazione?
Consulenza gratuita, senza impegno
Descrivi la tua situazione. Il nostro team ti ricontatterà via e-mail per la tua consulenza.
Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude
Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.