CourtListener 10003469•T.R.K. v. V.V. CA2/6
Testo completo
Filed 7/15/24 T.R.K. v. V.V. CA2/6
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION SIX
T.R.K., 2d Civ. No. B326455
(Super. Ct. No. 20FL-0151)
Petitioner and Appellant, (San Luis Obispo County)
v.
V.V.,
Respondent.
T.R.K. (father) appeals from the denial of his request to
modify a visitation order concerning T.K., his minor daughter.
V.V. (mother) had opposed the modification. On appeal, father
raises a variety of contentions, including that the trial court
abused its discretion in denying the request. Because the trial
court applied the incorrect standard in evaluating father’s
request to modify visitation, we will reverse and remand.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
Father and mother have a daughter T.K., born July 2018.
After hearings in November 2020, Judge Ginger Garrett awarded
temporary sole custody of T.K. to mother, subject to father’s Zoom
and supervised in-person visits. Father did not participate in
those hearings despite being given notice.
On June 2, 2021, the court held a trial to determine child
custody, parenting time, and attorney’s fees and costs. Father
did not appear. A log of visits between September 10, 2020, and
March 16, 2021, showed that father missed or canceled over 50
visits with T.K. during that period. Father had not contacted or
visited T.K. since February 1, 2021.
A custody evaluation by Dr. Suzanne Dupée concluded
father had a significant substance abuse problem, coupled with
mental health issues and criminal behavior. Father did not
participate in the evaluation.
The court found applicable Family Code section 3044,
which created a rebuttable presumption of sole custody for
mother given father’s past instances of domestic violence against
her. In November 2017, father punched mother in the eye. In
December 2017, father put a gun to mother’s head and
interrogated her about T.K.’s paternity. He fired a handgun in
mother’s presence. The court concluded no evidence rebutted the
section 3044 presumption and awarded sole legal and physical
custody of T.K. to mother.
The court ordered no visitation “unless and until [father]
completes a psychological evaluation and files a petition for
visitation with the Court showing changed circumstances.” The
court noted father’s inconsistent presence in T.K.’s life could
cause attachment, anxiety, and mood issues. It concluded: “The
2
first step in assuming a parenting role is to provide an evaluation
by a psychologist or psychiatrist as to [father’s] current level of
mental health issues and substance abuse. The fact that [father]
may suffer from mental health issues is not a reason to deny him
visitation; his inconsistent behavior toward his daughter’s best
interest is.”
On June 17, 2021, the same day the judgment was entered,
father filed a request to modify the visitation order and a motion
for reconsideration. On July 16, 2021, he filed an amended
request, adding requests for joint legal and physical custody and
for changes to a domestic violence order.
In September 2021, the case was reassigned to Judge
Matthew Guerrero. In October 2021, father challenged Judge
Guerrero pursuant to Code of Civil Procedure sections 170.6 and
170.3. The Judicial Council assigned an independent judge to
rule on the challenge. Finding no grounds for disqualification,
she denied it in an order filed on December 13, 2021.
On December 15, 2021, the court, not finding a change in
circumstances, denied father’s request for modification of custody
and visitation.
In May 2022, father filed a request to modify the visitation
order, which he amended in August 2022. Father’s supporting
declaration stated he had completed a 90-day inpatient treatment
program. Attached was a letter from Ventura Recovery Center.
It stated father successfully completed their 90-day substance
abuse treatment program in April 2022, during which he was
randomly drug tested three to four times a week, breathalyzed
daily, and attended daily AA meetings.
On September 22, 2022, the court denied without prejudice
father’s request to modify visitation. The court advised father
3
that Judge Garrett’s June 2021 order gave him “the path to [his]
visitation.” The court indicated father needed to provide random
drug testing. The court directed father to obtain psychological
records from the treatment program he completed. The court
also suggested father approach county mental health with a copy
of the June 2021 order to obtain a psychiatric examination.
Prior to the hearing, father had provided a witness list
including the professional supervisor, Donna Phalen, and an AA
sponsor, Robert Blume. The court declined to hear testimony
from Phalen at the September 22, 2022 hearing; no one
mentioned Blume. The court scheduled a December 15, 2022
“review hearing” and told father he did not “have to bring in any
witnesses.” Findings and orders were entered on November 15,
2022.
On December 2, 2022, father filed a declaration with
exhibits, including negative drug tests, psychological records
from Ventura Recovery Center, and documentation of enrollment
with Ventura County Behavioral Health.1
At the review hearing on December 15, 2022, the court
found father had “not met the criteria . . . Judge Garrett set out
in order to make a change that would amount to a material
change.” The court stated it had “not found a significant change
in circumstances to warrant a custody change.”
A formal order filed January 18, 2023, stated father “has
not demonstrated a material change in circumstances warranting
any change to the custody orders set forth in the Judgment filed
1 To facilitate our review on the merits, we grant father’s
motion to augment the record. (Cal. Rules of Court, rule
8.155(a).)
4
June 17, 2021. His requests for modification to those orders are
denied.” Father appeals.2
DISCUSSION
Father contends that in denying his request to modify
visitation, the court applied the wrong legal standard. We agree.3
We review modification of visitation orders for abuse of
discretion. (See In re Marriage of Burgess (1996) 13 Cal.4th 25,
32.) “The precise measure is whether the trial court could have
reasonably concluded that the order in question advanced the
‘best interest’ of the child. We are required to uphold the ruling if
it is correct on any basis, regardless of whether such basis was
actually invoked.” (Ibid.) We review the trial court’s factual
findings for substantial evidence. (Johnston-Rossi v. Rossi (2023)
88 Cal.App.5th 1081, 1087.) However, “a discretionary order
based on the application of improper criteria or incorrect legal
assumptions is not an exercise of informed discretion and is
subject to reversal even though there may be substantial
evidence to support [the] order.” (F.T. v. L.J. (2011) 194
Cal.App.4th 1, 16.) The record must “affirmatively show[]” the
trial court misunderstood its discretion. (Id. at p. 26.)
2 Although the notice of appeal states father is appealing
orders entered on “11/25/23” and “1/19/23,” it appears father
refers to the orders dated November 15, 2022, and January 18,
2023. Father’s appeal is timely only as to the January 2023
order. (Cal. Rules of Court, rule 8.104(a).)
3 We decline mother’s invitation to dismiss the appeal
under the disentitlement doctrine. (See In re A.G. (2012) 204
Cal.App.4th 1390, 1399.) Father’s conduct does not warrant that
response.
5
A party seeking to modify a permanent custody order must
show “a significant change of circumstances . . . .” (Montenegro v.
Diaz (2001) 26 Cal.4th 249, 256.) This changed circumstances
rule, however, does not apply when a party seeks only a visitation
modification “not amounting to a change from joint custody to
sole custody, or vice versa.” (In re Marriage of Lucio (2008) 161
Cal.App.4th 1068, 1072.) Changes in visitation are instead
subject to the child’s best interest standard. (Id. at p. 1080.)
“When determining the best interest of the child, relevant factors
include the health, safety and welfare of the child, any history of
abuse by one parent against the child or the other parent, and
the nature and amount of contact with the parents.”
(Montenegro, at p. 255; see also Fam. Code, § 3011.)
Given that father requested only a visitation change, the
changed circumstances rule does not apply. The best interest
standard governs. The court applied the wrong standard.4 At the
hearing, the court stated: “I have not found a significant change
in circumstances to warrant a custody change.” In its formal
order, the court similarly found father “has not demonstrated a
material change in circumstances warranting any change to the
custody orders.” However, father was not seeking a custody
change. He requested modification of the visitation order to
allow supervised and Zoom visitation. In light of the court’s
express invocation of the incorrect standard, we are unable to
presume it knew and properly applied the law. (Evid. Code,
§ 664; cf. Ross v. Superior Court (1977) 19 Cal.3d 899, 913.)
We cannot conclude the error was harmless. During a long
colloquy at the September 2022 hearing, the court complimented
4 At the September 2022 hearing, mother’s counsel also
argued father needed to show changed circumstances.
6
father on his demeanor, stating: “I really want to acknowledge
the progress that I can see with you.” The court directed father
to “bring and show us” records from his substance abuse
treatment program and psychological treatment. It suggested
father “go to your County Mental Health” with copies of the prior
order to “see what they can do for you.” The court also instructed
father to “bring . . . evidence of your testing, your random [drug]
testing.”
Father substantially complied with these directives. He
submitted: (1) records of a February 2022 psychiatric evaluation,
with notes from a clinical session in April 2022; (2) documents
evidencing enrollment in a substance abuse treatment program
in October 2022, reflecting that he “is making excellent progress”;
(3) proof of several negative drug tests taken in October and
November 2022; and (4) a letter from Ventura County Behavioral
Health confirming an appointment for a psychiatric evaluation on
December 14, 2022.
At the December 2022 hearing, the court provided an
indicated ruling that father “has not met the criteria that Judge
Garrett set out in order to make a change that would amount to a
material change,” but added: “I do also recognize that [father is]
making significant progress . . . but all the boxes aren’t checked.”
After argument, the court adopted its indicated ruling, stating: “I
have not found a significant change in circumstances to warrant
a custody change,” once again adding that father “is making
valiant efforts and moving – and attempting to make positive life
changes.” Thus, there was no indication the court considered
evidence of the factors relevant to the child’s best interest.
Instead, it focused solely on whether father had complied with
the judgment.
7
On this record, we are unable to determine whether the
court would have reached the same decision had it applied the
correct standard—the best interest of the child.
Because we will remand to allow the court to reconsider
father’s request applying the best interest of the child standard,
we need not reach father’s remaining contentions. However, we
note that his claims of insufficient notice of the June 2021 trial,
judicial bias, and violations of the Americans with Disabilities
Act (ADA) are all forfeited. He failed to appeal the 2021 order
(Reyes v. Kruger (2020) 55 Cal.App.5th 58, 67), he never raised
any ADA claim regarding the September or December 2022
hearings (see In re M.S. (2009) 174 Cal.App.4th 1241, 1252), and
denial of his judicial disqualification motion required a timely
petition for writ of mandate (Code Civ. Proc., § 170.3, subd. (d)),
which he did not file.
Finally, although the 2021 order provided for “no
visitation” unless father “completes a psychological evaluation
and files a petition for visitation . . . showing changed
circumstances,” we reiterate that the standard for modification of
visitation is not changed circumstances but the child’s best
interest. On remand, the court should consider all relevant,
current circumstances—whether or not father has completed a
psychological evaluation—when determining what orders will
best serve T.K.’s interests.5 Judge Garrett’s 2021 delineation of
5 Father argued he did not have the ability to pay for
certain services, such as a psychological evaluation. If the court
still believes the evaluation is necessary to determine whether
supervised visitation would be in T.K.’s best interest, under
Family Code section 3112, subdivision (a), the trial court must
“inquire into the financial condition” of a parent and ascertain
whether he or she is “able to pay” the expense of an investigation,
8
what constitutes changed circumstances is not binding on any
future judge who considers the case. (See Anne H. v. Michael B.
(2016) 1 Cal.App.5th 488, 497 [prior judge’s “comment . . . not
binding in any manner” on future judge].)
DISPOSITION
The postjudgment order denying father’s request for
modification of the visitation order is reversed. The matter is
remanded for the court to consider the request under the best
interest of the child standard. The parties shall bear their own
costs on this appeal. (Cal. Rules of Court, rule 8.278(a)(5).)
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED.
CODY, J.
We concur:
GILBERT, P.J.
BALTODANO, J.
report, or evaluation that is being undertaken by a court-
appointed investigator or evaluator.
9
Matthew G. Guerrero, Judge
Ginger Garrett, Judge
Superior Court County of San Luis Obispo
____________________________________
T.R.K. (father), in propria persona, for Petitioner and
Appellant.
Tardiff Law Offices, Neil Tardiff for Respondent V.V.
(mother).
10
Ti chiedi come si applica questo testo alla tua situazione?
Consulenza gratuita, senza impegno
Descrivi la tua situazione. Il nostro team ti ricontatterà via e-mail per la tua consulenza.
Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude
Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.