Kansas Attorney General Opinion 2011-025

2011-025Kanag

Texte intégral

December 29, 2011
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 2011- 25
The Honorable Ray Merrick
Senator, 37th District
6874 West 164th Terr.
Stilwell, Kansas 66085
Re: 	Constitution 	of 	the 	United 	States—Legislative Powers—Limitations on
States; Laws Impairing the Obligation of Contracts; Annexation by Cities;
Area in a Fire District; Refund of Ad Valorem Taxes
Cities 	and 	Municipalities—Additions, 	Vacation 	and 	Lot 	Frontage—
Annexation by Cities; Area in a Fire District; Refund of Ad Valorem Taxes;
Impairment of Contracts
Synopsis: 	2011 Senate Bill 150 may violate the Contract Clause of the United States
Constitution if the application of Section 12(a) results in a substantial
impairment of a contractual obligation, and Section 12(a) is either not
justified by a significant and legitimate public purpose, or if the substantial
impairment 	of 	a 	contractual 	obligation 	caused 	by 	Section 	12(a) 	is
unreasonable in light of the significant and legitimate public purpose which
justifies the law. Cited herein: K.S.A. 19-3623f; K.S.A. 75-704.
* 	* 	*
Dear Senator Merrick:
As State Senator for the 37th district, you ask for our opinion regarding Section 12(a) of
2011 Senate Bill 150 (SB 150), which states:
If any land located within a fire district is annexed by a city and such land
remains a part of the fire district beyond the current tax year, the owner of
such land shall be entitled to a refund of all ad valorem taxes paid for fire
service, including any tax levy for bond and interest payments from either
Ray Merrick
Page 2
the city or the fire district, whichever entity levies taxes for fire service
against the land but does not provide such service.1
This section of SB 150 is intended to prevent persons annexed into a city from having to
pay taxes to both the city and the county for fire protection. 2 If the city begins providing
fire service to a newly annexed area within a fire district, then landowners in that area
are entitled to a refund of all taxes paid to the fire district, and will only pay taxes to the
city for fire service. As a result, the property base subject to taxation for the purpose of
paying fire district bonds would decrease. In your letter, you ask whether SB 150
violates the Contract Clause of the United States Constitution by retroactively impairing
the contract rights of the fire district and its bond holders.
The Contract Clause provides that no state shall pass any law impairing the obligation
of contracts. 3 This clause is intended to safeguard the contractual obligations of debtors
and 	creditors, 	which 	are 	essential 	to 	“prosperous 	trade.”4 The 	Contract 	Clause’s
limitation on state legislative power is not absolute; it must be reconciled with the state’s
right to assert the powers reserved to the states by the constitution, such as the power
of eminent domain, and the police power to protect the health and welfare of the state’s
citizens. 5
The test for determining whether a Contract Clause violation has occurred starts with a
determination 	of 	whether 	the 	state 	law 	has, 	in 	fact, 	operated 	as 	a 	“substantial
impairment” of a contractual relationship. 6 Examples of substantial impairments to
contracts include a state law that imposed retroactive compensation and pension
requirements on private employers, 7 and the repeal of a statutory covenant pledged as
a security for bonds.8
If the state law operates as a substantial impairment to a contractual relationship, the
court then considers whether the state law is justified by a significant and legitimate
public purpose. 9 Once a legitimate public purpose has been identified, the court will
determine whether the state law’s impact on the rights and responsibilities of the
contracting parties is reasonable and appropriate in light of the public purpose justifying
the state law. 10
In your letter, you express concern that a situation may exist in which a fire district
issued bonds for the acquisition or construction of fire stations prior to annexation by the
city. In this situation, bond holders may have purchased the fire district’s bonds in
1 L. 2011, Ch. 101, § 12(a).
2 Minutes, House Local Government Committee, February 8, 2011.
3 U.S. Const., Art. 1, § 10, Cl. 1.
4 Home Bldg. & Loan Assn. v. Blaisdell, 290 U.S. 398, 427-428 (1934).
5 United States Trust Co. of N.Y. v. New Jersey, 431 U.S. 1, 22-24 (1977).
6 Allied Structural Steel Co. v. Spannaus, 438 U.S. 234, 244 (1978).
7 Id.
8 431 U.S. at 29-32.
9 Energy Reserves Group, Inc. v. Kansas Power and Light Co., 459 U.S. 400, 411 (1983).
10 Id. at 412.
Ray Merrick
Page 3
reliance on K.S.A. 19-3623f(e), which guarantees that property subject to a tax levy for
a city-issued bond will remain subject to such taxes after the property is detached from
the city. 11 While K.S.A. 19-3623f(e) does not address ongoing bond obligations of
property annexed by a city, the statute plainly protects bondholders in the event of
detachment.
We were not presented with information regarding a specific bond that may be impacted
by SB 150, and our role is limited to providing opinions on questions of law. 12 As such,
we opine that if SB 150 operates to substantially impair the contractual obligations
between a bondholder and a fire district, and such impairment is not justified by a
significant and legitimate public purpose, or if SB 150’s substantial impact on such
contract 	is 	unreasonable 	in 	light 	of 	the 	significant 	and 	legitimate 	public 	purpose
justifying the law, then SB 150 would violate the Contract Clause.
Whether SB 150 violates the Contract Clause depends on the facts of a particular
circumstance. The threshold inquiry in a Contract Clause challenge is whether state law
in 	fact 	operates 	as 	a 	substantial 	impairment 	of 	a 	contractual 	relationship. 	If 	no
substantial impairment exists, then a Contract Clause violation will not be found. 13
Sincerely,
Derek Schmidt
Attorney General
Sarah Fertig
Assistant Attorney General
DS:AA:SF:ke
11 K.S.A. 19-3623f(e): “When the land annexed to such city is detached and excluded from such district
the governing body of the district shall redefine the new boundaries of the district to exclude the land so
detached. All general obligation bonds issued for the acquisition or construction of fire stations or
buildings, the acquisition of sites therefor and the purchase of fire fighting equipment by a fire district
which are issued prior to the detachment of such land shall continue as an obligation of the property
subject to taxation for the payment thereof at the time such bonds were issued.”
12 K.S.A. 75-704.
13 E.g., Faitoute Iron and Steel Co. v. City of Asbury Park, 316 U.S. 502 (1942).

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.