Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1988-169

1988-169Kanag

Texte intégral

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
A1- 01nINEY December 20, 1988
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 88- 169
Dr. Stanley C. Grant, Secretary
Department of Health and Environment
Forbes Field
Topeka, Kansas 66620-0001
Re: Public Health--Examination and Licensure of
Optometrists--Practice of Optometry; Opticians
Fitting Contact Lenses
Synopsis: Opticians may fit contact lenses pursuant to a
prescription when the fitting does not directly
relate to the aiding of any insufficiencies or
abnormal conditions of the eye after or by
examination or testing. Cited herein: K.S.A. 1987
Supp. 65-1501; 65-2887; 65-5001 et seq.
Dear Dr. Grant:
As Secretary of the Department of Health and Environment you
inquired whether opticians can lawfully fit contact lenses
pursuant to a prescription or whether this constitutes the
unlawful practice of optometry in violation of K.S.A. 1987
Supp. 65-1501 et seq., and amendments. We note for
purposes of simplifying your question that K.S.A. 65-1504b
prohibits any person from dispensing any opthalmic lenses
without a prescription.
You indicate that a technical committee of the Department of
Health and Environment is reviewing an application from the
Opticians Association of Kansas requesting the committee to
recommend the credentialing of ATTORNEYpursuant to K.S.A.
1987 Supp. 65-5001 et seq., the Kansas act on
credentialing. The committee is charged with making specific
findings predicated on the need to protect the health, safety
and welfare of the public. You would therefore like our
office to clarify the current legal status of opticians
fitting contact lenses for the purpose of making these
findings.
The practice of optometry is defined in K.S.A. 1987 Supp.
65-1501 as:
"(1) The examination of the human eye and
its adnexae and the employment of
objective or subjective means or methods
(including the administering, or
dispensing, of topical pharmaceutical
drugs) for the purpose of diagnosing the
refractive, muscular, or pathological
condition thereof;
"(2) the prescribing or adapting of
lenses (including any ophthalmic lenses
which are classified as drugs by any law
of the United States or of this state),
prisms, orthoptic exercises and visual
training therapy for the relief of any
insufficiencies or abnormal conditions of
the human eye and its adnexae; and
"(3) except as otherwise limited by this
section, the prescribing, administering or
dispensing of topical pharmaceutical drugs
for the treatment of any insufficiencies
or abnormal conditions of the human eye
and its adnexae." (Emphasis added.)
Though not dispositive of your inquiry, the Kansas Supreme
Court has addressed the question of whether an optician
fitting contact lenses in accordance with a prescription of a
physician constitutes the unlawful practice of optometry. In
State, ex rel., v. Doolin & Shaw, 209 Kan. 244 (1972)
the Court found that dispensing opticians who fabricated,
fitted, and inserted contact lenses in the eyes in accordance
with a prescription of a physician, and who required the
patient to return to the examining physician in order that the
physician determine whether or not the prescription was
properly filled and the lenses properly measured, fabricated,
and fitted, were not engaged in the practice of optometry.
The Court affirming the lower court's denial of a permanent
injunction concluded as a matter of law that the defendant's
fitting process did not include examination of the eyes for
pathological conditions or the measuring for refractive errors
nor did it constitute adapting lenses within the meaning of
the statute. In the absence of a statutory definition, the
Court judicially construed "adapting" lenses to exclude the
fitting process and to include the correction of refractive
errors caused by defects or abnormal conditions of the eye.
209 Kan. at 262.
However in 1975, subsequent to this case the Kansas
legislature provided a statutory definition of "adapt" that
does include the fitting or use of lenses, as that term is
used in establishing the practice of optometry (L. 1975, ch.
318, sec. 1). Currently in K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 65-1501a(d),
the definition states:
"adapt means the determination,
selection, fitting or use of lenses,
prisms, orthoptic exercises or visual
training therapy for the aid of any
insufficiencies or abnormal conditions of
the eyes after or by examination or
testing." (Emphasis added.)
Thus the Doolin case is not dispositive because the
legislature in effect overruled the court's decision by making
the fitting of lenses part of the practice of optometry when
the fitting is done for the aid of any insufficiencies or
abnormal conditions of the eye after or by examination or
testing. See Burch v. Kansas State Board of Examiners in
Optometry, No. 82 CV 434 (unpublished decision, Shawnee
County Dist. Ct., Twelfth Division April 7, 1982, making a
similar conclusion in an appeal from a disciplinary action
against an optometrist). See also Kansas Attorney General
Opinion letter to Dr. James Kuhlmann, December 18, 1980 (the
adaptation and fitting of contact lenses from an eyeglass
prescription by an opthalmic dispenser involves the practice
of optometry); 77 A.L.R. 3d 817 (1977) "Fitting of Contact
Lenses as Practice of Optometry".
Thus, it is clear that since the fitting of contact lenses in
certain instances involves the practice of optometry that
opticians cannot lawfully engage in such activity unless
exempted from the optometry laws. Section (a) of K.S.A.
65-1508 exempts persons licensed to practice medicine and
surgery from the optometry laws , and section (c) authorizes
optometrists' assistants to perform part of the practice of
optometry but prohibits the delegation of the final fit of
contact lenses to optometric assistants. Section (d) however
is confusing because it provides that opticians are not to be
considered optometrists' assistants within the meaning of the
section. While it is arguable that this section may exempt
opticians by allowing the delegation of optometric procedures
to them, we are hard-pressed to conclude that the legislature
intended to exempt opticians from the optometry law by
implication rather than directly as in section (a) of K.S.A.
65-1508 that states:
"Nothing in this act shall be construed to
prevent persons who are licensed to
practice medicine and surgery in this
state from performing the acts or services
authorized for optometrists under the
optometry law or from delegating the
performance of screening procedures for
visual acuities, color vision, visual
fields and intraocular pressure to
assistants."
While this opinion does not address what a physician or
surgeon can do under the terms of the exemption cited above,
K.S.A. 65-2887 prohibits doctors from assisting unlicensed
persons from practicing optometry. We also note that we
considered 1983 S.B. 245 that died in the Committee on Public
Health and Welfare. The bill attempted to amend the optometry
law to allow opticians to adapt contact lenses in all
instances.
In conclusion, the fitting of contact lenses by opticians
constitutes the practice of optometry in violation of the
optometry law, K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 65-1501 et seq. and
amendments, when the fitting is done for the aid of any
insufficiencies or abnormal conditions of the eyes after or by
examination or testing. Thus, it is our opinion that
opticians may fit contact lenses pursuant to a prescription
when the fitting does not involve the aiding of any
insufficiencies or abnormal conditions of the eyes after or by
examination or testing.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
RTS:JLM:GE:jm
Attorney General of Kansas
Guen Easley
Assistant Attorney General

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.