Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1988-137

1988-137Kanag

Texte intégral

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL September 16, 1988
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 88-137
The Honorable Arthur W. Douville
State Representative, Twentieth District
9600 Woodson
Overland Park, Kansas 66207-2844
Re: Intoxicating Liquors and Beverages--Certain
Prohibited Acts and Penalties--Sale on Credit
Prohibited
Synopsis: K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 41-717 prohibits the retail sale
of alcoholic liquor on credit. A system which
involves the purchaser's use of a credit card, thus
allowing the purchaser to defer payment to a later
date, is a sale on credit even though the retailer
receives payment immediately through a third
party. Cited herein: K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 16a-1-301;
41-717; K.A.R. 14-13-13 (March, 1988).
*
Dear Representative Douville:
You have requested my interpretation of K.S.A. 1987 Supp.
41-717. Specifically you would like my opinion regarding the
applicability of this statute to Retriever Payment Systems.
Retriever Payment Systems is a point of sale electronic draft
capture system which operates as follows:
1. Holders of Visa, Mastercard & American Express credit
card privileges would present their cards for payment of
merchandise at a Kansas retail liquor store.
2. The card is drawn through a special machine, and is then
connected over regular telephone lines to the processing
computer to verify the validity of the card.
3. The amount of the purchase is entered into the machine
and, if the card is valid, the transaction is immediately
completed:
a. The card is charged with the sale.
b. The amount of the sale is immediately deposited in
the retailer's account with the participant's bank.
c. A receipt is automatically printed (one copy for
the customer and one for the retailer which will be
signed by the customer).
4. The transaction is then guaranteed by Retriever Payment
Systems and the bank to the retailer.
5. The retailer is issued checks to redeposit those funds
into his local retail liquor store account. (Or the money can
be automatically wire transferred to this local account.)
K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 41-717 provides in part:
"(a) No person shall sell or furnish at
retail and no microbrewery or farm
winery shall sell to any consumer any
alcoholic liquor on credit; on a passbook;
on order on a store; in exchange for any
goods, wares or merchandise; or in payment
for any services rendered. If any person
extends credit in violation of this
subsection, the debt attempted to be
created shall not be recoverable at law."
Subsection (b) of this statute authorizes retailers to accept
the personal check of the person making the purchase.
Pursuant to its rule-making authority, K.S.A. 1987 Supp.
41-210 and K.S.A. 41-211, the Division of Alcoholic Beverage
Control has adopted the following regulation interpreting and
implementing K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 41-717:
"(p) A retailer shall not purchase or
sell any alcoholic liquor on credit. A
retailer shall not enter into any
transaction or scheme the purpose of which
is to buy or sell alcoholic liquor on
credit. The following transactions shall
be considered to be buying or selling
alcoholic liquor on credit:
"(1) Taking or giving a post-dated check;
"(3) taking a check with knowledge that
there are insufficient funds to pay the
check upon presentment;
"(6) allowing any alcoholic liquor to be
removed from the licensed premises without
receiving payment for the same; and
"(7) accepting a credit card in payment
of alcoholic liquor." K.A.R. 14-13-13,
as amended March, 1988 (emphasis added).
In 1981 this office opined that K.S.A. 41-717 would not
prohibit the sale of alcoholic liquor by a retailer in
consideration of an electronic fund transfer, whereby the
purchaser's account at a financial institution is debited in
the amount of the purchase and the retailer's account at a
financial institution is correspondingly credited by such
amount prior to delivery of the alcoholic liquor. Attorney
General Opinion No. 81-266. The system here in question
differs from the electronic fund transfer described in Opinion
No. 81-266 in that here the purchaser's bank account is not
immediately debited, but rather the amount of the purchase is
charged to the purchaser's credit card account and billed to
the purchaser at a later date. Attorney General Opinion No.
81-266 specifically stated:
"[I]n a letter opinion dated October 11,
1965, Attorney General Ken Frizzell
determined that 41-2706 is 'designed to
prohibit sales on any basis other than
cash or check,' i.e., it prohibits a
'non-cash transaction' V Op. Att'y
Gen. 376, 377 (1970). This
determination provided the basis for
Attorney General Frizzell's conclusion
that 41-2706 prohibits the use of a chit
book to purchase cereal malt beverages and
that it also prohibits a retailer from
selling cereal malt beverages in exchange
for a check understood by both parties to
be a no-funds check. Id. In both
instances, the sales would constitute
non-cash transactions involving the
extension of credit.
"We concur in this interpretation of
41-2706, and in our judgment, it is
equally applicable to 41-717, as well.
Consistent with this interpretation, you
were advised by this office in a letter of
March 10, 1980, that the use of credit
cards to purchase alcoholic liquor would
not be permissible, since such credit card
transactions would not constitute sales of
liquor for 'cash for its equivalent.'"
Though it was recognized that an electronic fund transfer
system may involve the extension of credit by the financial
institution to the purchaser of the alcoholic liquor pursuant
to a preexisting agreement between the consumer and the
financial institution for a limited line of credit to cover
situations where the consumer's account is overdrawn, this
limited extension of credit was found to be incidental, unlike
the regular extension of credit involved with the use of
credit cards.
"Such an arrangement . . . is no more
reflective of or akin to a credit
transaction from the retailer's standpoint
than is an agreement between a consumer
and the consumer's bank authorizing the
bank to cover insufficient fund checks or
maintain a certain balance in a checking
account. Moreover, an electronic fund
transfer system is not equipped to allow
the arrangement of consumer loans, either
through the financial institution or any
third party involved in the transaction.
Thus, even though the purchase of
alcoholic liquor or cereal malt beverages
by means of an electronic fund transfer
may involve a financial institution's
extension of credit to the purchaser,
unlike the proposal to use credit cards
for the purchase of such beverages, it
does not necessitate the retailer's
participation in such indebtedness."
Accordingly, in Attorney General Opinion No. 84-68, we
concluded that K.S.A. 41-717 prohibits any pattern of sale
which necessarily involves the use of credit cards. The
factual situation addressed in that opinion was similar to
Retriever Payment Systems. The retail liquor store was to
receive payment immediately, but the purchaser was to make use
of a credit card and thus credit was extended, albeit by a
third party.
K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 41-717 prohibits retail sale of alcoholic
liquor on "credit" which is defined generally as "the ability
to buy or borrow in consideration of a promise to pay within a
period . . . following delivery," Kohler, A Dictionary for
Accountants 147, (5th ed. 1975). This definition, as
well as that found at K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 16a-1-301(14) of the
Kansas Uniform Consumer Credit Code, does not specify that it
must be the seller which extends the credit. Based on the
plain language of K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 41-717, the administrative
regulation properly adopted to implement that statute, and the
above-cited opinions of this office, we must conclude that a
system such as that in question which would allow the
purchaser of alcoholic liquor to defer payment until a later
date (even though the retailer is paid immediately) violates
Kansas intoxicating liquor laws.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
JuleneL.Miller
Deputy Attorney General
RTS:JLM:jm

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.