Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1988-132

1988-132Kanag

Texte intégral

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL September 9, 1988
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 88- 132
The Honorable Edward F. Reilly, Jr.
State Senator, Third District
430 Delaware
Leavenworth, Kansas 66048-2733
Re: Constitution of the State of Kansas--Corporations--
Cities' Powers of Home Rule
Synopsis: Kansas cities have authority under the police power
and article 12, section 5 of the Kansas
Constitution to regulate the drilling of oil wells
within their corporate limits. In our judgment, an
ordinance which prohibits drilling within one
thousand feet of a residential building, or which
prohibits placement of a tank for storage of crude
oil within the limits of a city, is not
unreasonable or arbitrary, and does not deprive
landowners of their property without due process of
law. Cited herein: Kan. Const., Art. 12, §5.
* * *
Dear Senator Reilly:
You request our opinion concerning ordinances of the city of
Leavenworth and Lansing which regulate the drilling of oil
wells within the territorial limits of the subject cities.
Specifically, you question the validity of a provision which
prohibits drilling within one thousand feet of a residential
building, and a provision which prohibits placement of a tank
for storage of crude oil within the limits of the city.
Cities in this state have authority to regulate the drilling
of oil wells within their corporate limits pursuant to the
police power and article 12, section 5 of the Kansas
Constitution (the city home rule amendment). In Marrs v.
City of Oxford, 32 F.2d 134 (8th Cir. 1929) an ordinance
restricting the drilling and operation of gas and oil wells
within the city of Oxford was challenged. The court, in
upholding the ordinance, stated as follows:
"The police power is an attribute of
sovereignty to be exercised for the public
welfare, and it has been authoritatively
said: 'The possession and enjoyment of
all rights are subject to such reasonable
conditions as may be deemed by the
governing authority of the country
essential to the safety, health, peace,
good order and morals of the community.'
Also, 'that all contract and property
rights are held subject to' a fair
exercise of the police power. '* * * And
it is well settled that the enforcement of
uncompensated obedience to a legitimate
regulation established under the police
power is not a taking of property without
compensation, or without due process of
law, in the sense of the Fourteenth
Amendment. . . .' Necessarily these
regulations will encroach, when the power
is exercised, on private rights; but that
does not render them void. The power has
its limitations and when submitted for
judicial review it must appear that its
exercise appropriately affords protection
to the public against threatened evils.
Arbitrary and unreasonable regulations,
clearly ineffective in accomplishment of
the claimed public interest, will be
stayed; but the presumption is in favor of
a law or ordinance passed in the exercise
of the power, until the contrary is
shown." 32 F.2d at 139 (citations
omitted).
In regard to the reasonableness of regulations restricting
drilling, the court in Marrs stated as follows:
"[lit seems undenial to us that when
work of the kind under consideration is
carried on in residential or business
sections of a town or city without some
limit to the number of wells in a given
area, they will necessarily become
nuisances of a most aggravated sort to its
inhabitants and its business interests.
There will be annoyance from unsightly
structures, disquieting noises of
machinery, the immediate and constant
presence of numbers of workmen and the
persistent thought of impending danger
from explosion and conflagration because
of the highly inflammable nature of the
product. Such a situation calls for some
governmental restriction and control. The
greater the number of wells in a city
block the greater will be the annoyance
and hazard to the pubic. Indeed, it would
be hard to say that an ordinance
prohibiting the drilling and operation of
any well within the business or
residential districts of a city would be
an unreasonable and invalid exercise of
the police power." 32 F.2d at 139-140.
In accordance with the above-quoted authority, it is our
opinion that a city may prohibit oil and gas activity within
its territorial limits when reasonably related to protecting
the public health, safety, and welfare. In this regard, we
are unable to conclude that the above-referenced regulations
of the city of Leavenworth and the city of Lansing are
unreasonable or arbitrary, or that they deprive landowners of
their property without due process of law.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Terrence R. Hearshman
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:TRH:jm

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.