Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1988-130

1988-130Kanag

Texte intégral

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL September 6, 1988
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 88-130
Winston Barton
Secretary, State Department of
Social and Rehabilitation Services
Docking State Office Building
Sixth Floor
Topeka, Kansas
Re: Minors--Kansas Code for Care of Children; General
Provisions--Chronic Runaways; Placement in Secure
Facilities
Synopsis: In chronological order, the following must occur
before a court may authorize placement in a secure
facility pursuant to L. 1988, Ch. 138, §8(e): 1)
The child must have run from a court ordered or
designated placement at least twice; 2) the child
must be adjudicated as a child in need of care for
having so run; 3) the court must enter an order
directing the child to remain in a specified
placement, following the procedures set forth in L.
1988, Ch. 138, §8(a); 4) the child must violate
this order; 5) upon the filing of an application
pursuant to L. 1988, Ch. 138, §8(b), a hearing on
the violation must be held and the court must make
the determinations required in L. 1988, Ch. 138,
58(e). A subsection 8(e) court order authorizing
placement in a secure facility expires 60 days
after it is issued. The court may grant two
extensions of such authorization, up to 60 days
each, upon rehearing pursuant to K.S.A. 38-1564.
The secure placement authorized by L. 1988, Ch.
138, §8(e) may not be in an adult jail except when
a juvenile detention facility located therein, in
quarters separated by sight and sound from adult
prisoners, is used to hold the child for not more
than 24 hours, including time spent therein
pursuant to subsections 8(c) and (d). Cited
herein: K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 38-1502, K.S.A. 38-1527,
38-1528, 38-1542, 38-1543, all as amended by L.
1988, Ch. 138; K.S.A. 38-1556; 38-1563; and L.
1988, Ch. 138, §8.
Dear Secretary Barton:
As Secretary for the State Department of Social and
Rehabilitation Services, you request our opinion interpreting
1988 Senate Bill No. 557 (L. 1988, Ch. 138). Specifically,
you seek clarification of the events and procedures which must
occur before a child may be placed in a secure facility
pursuant to subsection 8(e) of the bill.
L. 1988, Ch. 138, §8 provides in part:
"(a) Valid court order. During
proceedings under this code, the court may
enter an order directing a child who is
the subject of the proceedings to remain
in a present or future placement if:
"(1) The court makes a finding that the
child has been adjudicated to be a child
in need of care pursuant to subsection
(a)(10) of K.S.A. 38-1502 and amendments
thereto;
"(2) the child and the child's guardian
ad litem are present before the court
at the time the order is entered; and
"(3) the child and the child's guardian
ad litem are given adequate and fair
warning, both orally and in writing, of
the consequences of violation of the order
and a copy of such warning is recorded in
the official file of the case.
"(b) Application. Any person may file
with the court a verified application for
a determination that a child has violated
an order entered pursuant to subsection
(a) and for an order authorizing the
holding of such child in a secure facility
as provided by this section. Such
application shall state the applicant's
belief that the child has violated a valid
court order entered pursuant to subsection
(a) and the specific facts which are
relied upon to support the belief.
"(e) Hearing on violation of order;
authorization. The court shall hold a
hearing on an application filed pursuant
to subsection (b) within 24 hours
following the child's being taken into
custody, if the child admits the
allegations of the application, or within
72 hours following the child's being taken
into custody, if secure detention of the
child is ordered pursuant to subsection
(d). Notice of the time and place of such
hearing shall be given orally or in
writing to the child's parents, any legal
custodian of the child and the child's
guardian ad litem. Upon such hearing,
the court may enter an order awarding
custody of the child to the secretary, if
the secretary does not have legal custody
of the child, and authorizing the
secretary to place the child in a secure
facility if the court determines that:
"(1) The child has been adjudicated to be
a child in need of care pursuant to
subsection (a)(10) of K.S.A. 38-1502 and
amendments thereto;
"(2) the child has violated a valid court
order entered pursuant to subsection (a);
"(3) the child has been provided at the
hearing with the right to: (A) Have the
alleged violation in writing and served
upon the child a reasonable time before
the hearing; (B) a hearing before the
court on the-issue of placement in a
secure facility; (C) an explanation of the
nature and consequences of the proceeding;
(D) a guardian ad litem pursuant to
K.S.A. 38-1505 and amendments thereto; (E)
confront and present witnesses; (F) have a
transcript or record of the proceedings;
and (G) appeal; and
"(4) there is no less restrictive
alternative appropriate to the needs of
the juvenile and the community.
"The authorization to place a child in a
secure facility pursuant to this
subsection shall expire 60 days, including
Saturdays, Sundays and legal holidays,
after it is issued. The court may grant
extensions of such authorization for two
additional periods not exceeding 60 days,
including Saturdays, Sundays and legal
holidays, upon rehearing pursuant to
K.S.A. 38-1564 and amendments thereto.
Payment by the secretary to a secure
facility for child care services provided
pursuant to this subsection shall be paid
only upon receipt by the secretary of a
copy of a valid court order."
While there are several scenarios which may result in secure
placement pursuant to subsection 8(e), we will attempt to set
forth the very least that must occur.
Before a court may authorize the secretary of social and
rehabilitation services (secretary) to place a child in a
secure facility for up to 60 days, or longer with appropriate
grants of extension, it must determine that the child violated
a valid court order entered pursuant to subsection 8(a)
(i.e. the child ran from the court ordered placement), that
the requirements of subsection 8(e)(3) were met, and that
"there is no less restrictive alternative appropriate to the
needs of the juvenile and the community." L. 1988, Ch. 138,
§8(e)(4). Subsection 8(a) sets forth the steps a court must
follow in issuing a placement order sufficient to meet the
subsection 8(e) requirements. Pursuant to subsection 8(a),
the court must, in addition to assuring the protections
specified in L. 1988, Ch. 138, §8(a)(2) and (3), make a
finding that the child has been adjudicated as a child in need
of care (CINC) pursuant to K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 38-1502(a)(10),
as amended by L. 1988, Ch. 138, 51. To adjudicate a child as
a CINC pursuant to K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 38-1502(a)(10), as
amended, the court before which the proceedings are conducted
must find that the child has run at least twice from a "court
ordered or designated placement." (Emphasis added.) L.
1988, Ch. 138, 58(a) provides that the court order authorized
by that subsection may be entered "[d]uring proceedings
under this code." Thus, we see no reason why this court order
could not be entered at the 38-1502(a)(10) adjudicatory
hearing. See K.S.A. 38-1556. At this point, the child has
demonstrated a propensity to run and need not be given one
more "free" run.
As stated previously, the court must find at the
38-1502(a)(10) adjudicatory hearing that the child has run at
least twice from a court ordered or designated placement.
Though usually this will be a run from a placement ordered by
the court pursuant to adjudication of the child (K.S.A.
38-1556 and 38-1563), a child may find himself in a court
designated placement even before any court proceedings have
been commenced. (Although there is no definition of the term
"court designated placement" in the code, we presume the
legislature contemplated a designation by administrative order
of an administrative judge for children picked up in his or
her particular district.) For example, K.S.A. 38-1527(b), as
amended by L. 1988, Ch. 138, 55, authorizes a law enforcement
officer to take a child into custody when the officer has
probable cause to believe that the child is a CINC and there
are reasonable grounds to believe inaction would result in
harm befalling the child. "Child in need of care" is defined
at K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 38-1502(a), as amended by L. 1988, Ch'.
138, 51. Neither K.S.A. 38-1527(b) nor K.S.A. 1987 Supp.
38-1502(a) require the child to have been adjudicated as a
CINC before an officer may take the child into custody. A
child taken into custody pursuant to K.S.A. 38-1527(b), as
amended, if not delivered to the custody of the child's
parents or processed under the interstate compact on
juveniles, must "forthwith be delivered to a facility or
person designated by the secretary or to a court
designated shelter facility, court services officer or other
person." K.S.A. 38-1528(a) as amended by L. 1988, Ch. 138, 56
(emphasis added). See also K.S.A. 38-1528(c). Thus, a
child who runs twice from such a placement, regardless whether
previously adjudicated as a CINC, may be adjudicated
pursuant to K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 38-1502(a)(10), as amended.
In chronological order, the following must occur before a
court may authorize placement in a secure facility pursuant to
L. 1988, Ch. 138, §8(e): 1) The child must have run from a
court ordered or designated placement at least twice; 2) the
child must be adjudicated as a CINC for having so run; 3)
the court must enter an order directing the child to remain in
a specified placement, following the procedures set forth in
L. 1988, Ch. 138, §8(a); (4) the child must violate this
order; (5) upon the filing of an application pursuant to L.
1988, Ch. 138, §8(b), a hearing on the violation must be held
and the court must make the determinations required in L.
1988, Ch. 138, §8(e). A subsection 8(e) court order
authorizing placement in a secure facility expires 60 days
after it is issued. The court may grant two extensions of
such authorization, up to 60 days each, upon rehearing
pursuant to K.S.A. 38-1564.
Finally, you question whether a secure facility may be an
adult jail. The term "secure facility" is defined at K.S.A.
1987 Supp. 38-1502(h), as amended by L. 1988, Ch. 138, §1, as:
"[A] facility which is operated or
structured so as to ensure that all
entrances and exists from the facility are
under the exclusive control of the staff
of the facility . . . or which relies on
locked rooms and buildings, fences or
physical restraint in order to control
behavior of its residents. No secure
facility, other than a juvenile detention
facility, shall be in a city or county
jail." (Emphasis added.)
This definition, together with subsection 8(e), appear to
allow placement of a child in a city or county jail if a
juvenile detention facility is located therein. However, L.
1988, Ch. 138, §8(f) places limitations on the types of
facilities used pursuant to a subsection 8(e) order:
"Nothing in [section 8] shall authorize
placement of a child in a juvenile
detention facility, except that a child
may be held in any such facility which, if
in an adult jail, is in quarters separated
by sight and sound from adult prisoners:
"(2) when ordered by a court pursuant to
subsection (e), for not more than 24 hours
following the hearing provided for by that
subsection, except that nothing in this
subsection shall allow a child to be held
in an adult jail for more than 24
hours." (Emphasis added.)
Thus, the secure placement authorized by subsection 8(e) may
not be in an adult jail except when a juvenile detention
facility separated by sight and sound from adult prisoners is
located therein, and then only for a maximum of 24 hours.
[Anytime spent in an adult jail pursuant to subsection (c) or
(d) is to be included in this maximum limit]. Further, secure
placement pursuant to subsection 8(e) may not be in any other
juvenile detention facility for more than 24 hours following a
subsection 8(e) hearing. Other sections in the code for care
of children which authorize detention of a child in a secure
facility, which may be a juvenile detention facility located
in an adult jail in quarters separated from the adult
prisoners, are K.S.A. 38-1528, 38-1542 and 38-1543, as amended
by L. 1988, Ch. 138, §§6, 7 and 10 respectively.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Julene L. Miller
Deputy Attorney General
RTS:JLM:jm

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.